Shotgun proteome analysis utilising mixed mode (reversed phase‐anion exchange chromatography) in conjunction with reversed phase liquid chromatography mass spectrometry analysis

The 2‐D peptide separations employing mixed mode reversed phase anion exchange (MM (RP‐AX)) HPLC in the first dimension in conjunction with RP chromatography in the second dimension were developed and utilised for shotgun proteome analysis. Compared with strong cation exchange (SCX) typically employed for shotgun proteomic analysis, peptide separations using MM (RP‐AX) revealed improved separation efficiency and increased peptide distribution across the elution gradient. In addition, improved sample handling, with no significant reduction in the orthogonality of the peptide separations was observed. The shotgun proteomic analysis of a mammalian nuclear cell lysate revealed additional proteome coverage (2818 versus 1125 unique peptides and 602 versus 238 proteins) using the MM (RP‐AX) compared with the traditional SCX hyphenated to RP‐LC‐MS/MS. The MM analysis resulted in approximately 90% of the unique peptides identified present in only one fraction, with a heterogeneous peptide distribution across all fractions. No clustering of the predominant peptide charge states was observed during the gradient elution. The application of MM (RP‐AX) for 2‐D LC proteomic studies was also extended in the analysis of iTRAQ‐labelled HeLa and cyanobacterial proteomes using nano‐flow chromatography interfaced to the MS/MS. We demonstrate MM (RP‐AX) HPLC as an alternative approach for shotgun proteomic studies that offers significant advantages over traditional SCX peptide separations.     

Increased proteome coverage by combining PAGE and peptide isoelectric focusing: Comparative study of gel‐based separation approaches

The in‐depth analysis of complex proteome samples requires fractionation of the sample into subsamples prior to LC‐MS/MS in shotgun proteomics experiments. We have established a 3D workflow for shotgun proteomics that relies on protein separation by 1D PAGE, gel fractionation, trypsin digestion, and peptide separation by in‐gel IEF, prior to RP‐HPLC‐MS/MS. Our results show that applying peptide IEF can significantly increase the number of proteins identified from PAGE subfractionation. This method delivers deeper proteome coverage and provides a large degree of flexibility in experimentally approaching highly complex mixtures by still relying on protein separation according to molecular weight in the first dimension.     

Comparative analysis of OFFGel,strong cation exchange with pH gradient,and RP at high pH for first‐dimensional separation of peptides from a membrane‐enriched protein fraction

The analysis and quantitation of membrane proteins have proved challenging for proteomics. Although several approaches have been introduced to complement gel‐based analysis of intact proteins, the literature is rather limited in comparing major emerging approaches. Peptide fractionation using IEF (OFFGel), strong cation exchange HPLC using a pH gradient (SCX‐pG), and RP HPLC at high pH, have been shown to increase peptide and protein identification over classic MudPIT approaches. This article compares these three approaches for first‐dimensional separation of peptides using a detergent phase (Triton X‐114) enriched membrane fraction from mouse cortical brain tissue. Results indicate that RP at high pH (pH 10) was superior for the identification of more peptides and proteins in comparison to the OFFGel or the SCX‐pG approaches. In addition, gene ontology analysis (GOMiner) revealed that RP at high pH (pH 10) successfully identified an increased number of proteins with “membrane” ontology, further confirming its suitability for membrane protein analysis, in comparison to SCX‐pG and OFFGel techniques.     

High pH reversed‐phase chromatography as a superior fractionation scheme compared to off‐gel isoelectric focusing for complex proteome analysis

MS/MS is the technology of choice for analyzing complex protein mixtures. However, due to the intrinsic complexity and dynamic range present in higher eukaryotic proteomes, prefractionation is an important step to maximize the number of proteins identified. Off‐gel IEF (OG‐IEF) and high pH RP (Hp‐RP) column chromatography have both been successfully utilized as a first‐dimension peptide separation technique in shotgun proteomic experiments. Here, a direct comparison of the two methodologies was performed on ex vivo peripheral blood mononuclear cell lysate. In 12‐fraction replicate analysis, Hp‐RP resulted in more peptides and proteins identified than OG‐IEF fractionation. Distributions of peptide pIs and hydropathy did not reveal any appreciable bias in either technique. Resolution, defined here as the ability to limit a specific peptide to one particular fraction, was significantly better for Hp‐RP. This leads to a more uniform distribution of total and unique peptides for Hp‐RP across all fractions collected. These results suggest that fractionation by Hp‐RP over OG‐IEF is the better choice for typical complex proteome analysis.     

The 4‐pyridylmethyl ester as a protecting group for glutamic and aspartic acids: ‘flipping’ peptide charge states for characterization by positive ion mode ESI‐MS

Use of the 4‐pyridylmethyl ester group for side‐chain protection of glutamic acid residues in solid‐phase peptide synthesis enables switching of the charge state of a peptide from negative to positive, thus making detection by positive ion mode ESI‐MS possible. The pyridylmethyl ester moiety is readily removed from peptides in high yield by hydrogenation. Combining the 4‐pyridylmethyl ester protecting group with benzyl ester protection reduces the number of the former needed to produce a net positive charge and allows for purification by RP HPLC. This protecting group is useful in the synthesis of highly acidic peptide sequences, which are often beset by problems with purification by standard RP HPLC and characterization by ESI‐MS. Copyright © 2014 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Optimal selection of 2D reversed-phase–reversed-phase HPLC separation techniques in bottom-up proteomics

Evaluation of: Stephanowitz H, Lange S, Lang D et al. Improved two-dimensional reversed phase–reversed phase LC-MS/MS approach for identification of peptide–protein interactions. J. Proteome Res. 11(2), 1175–1183 (2011).

Recent developments in bottom-up proteomics have supplanted the use of gel-based approaches in favor of multidimensional chromatographic separations of peptide mixtures followed by mass spectrometry analysis. This trend is driven by the desire to eliminate labor-intensive in-gel digestion procedures and increase proteome coverage through better recovery of proteolytic fragments. Introduction of reversed-phase–reversed-phase 2D separation techniques is one of the major improvements that have made this possible. In this article, we review recent developments in 2D HPLC and highlight variations in reversed-phase HPLC separation selectivity that allow for superior peak capacity in peptide fractionation.     

Computational analysis of unassigned high‐quality MS/MS spectra in proteomic data sets

In a typical shotgun proteomics experiment, a significant number of high‐quality MS/MS spectra remain “unassigned.” The main focus of this work is to improve our understanding of various sources of unassigned high‐quality spectra. To achieve this, we designed an iterative computational approach for more efficient interrogation of MS/MS data. The method involves multiple stages of database searching with different search parameters, spectral library searching, blind searching for modified peptides, and genomic database searching. The method is applied to a large publicly available shotgun proteomic data set.     

SWATH‐ID: An instrument method which combines identification and quantification in a single analysis

Data‐independent acquisition (DIA) approaches, such as SWATH^®‐MS, are showing great potential to reliably quantify significant numbers of peptides and proteins in an unbiased manner. These developments have enhanced interest in developing a single DIA method that integrates qualitative and quantitative analysis, eliminating the need of a prebuilt library of peptide spectra, which are created through data‐dependent acquisition methods or from public repositories. Here, we introduce a new DIA approach, referred to as “SWATH‐ID,” which was developed to allow peptide identification as well as quantitation. The SWATH‐ID method is composed of small Q1 windows, achieving better selectivity and thus significantly improving high‐confidence peptide extractions from data files. Furthermore, the SWATH‐ID approach transmits precursor ions without fragmentation as well as their fragments within the same SWATH acquisition period. This provides a single scan that includes all precursor ions within the isolation window as well as a record of all of their fragment ions, substantially negating the need for a survey scan. In this way all precursors present in a small Q1 window are associated with their fragment ions, improving the identification specificity and providing a more comprehensive and in‐depth view of protein and peptide species in complex samples.     

Enantiomeric separation of type I and type II pyrethroid insecticides with different chiral stationary phases by reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography

The enantiomeric separation of type I (bifenthrin, BF) and type II (lambda‐cyhalothrin, LCT) pyrethroid insecticides on Lux Cellulose‐1, Lux Cellulose‐3, and Chiralpak IC chiral columns was investigated by reversed‐phase high‐performance liquid chromatography. Methanol/water or acetonitrile/water was used as mobile phase at a flow rate of 0.8 mL/min. The effects of chiral stationary phase, mobile phase composition, column temperature, and thermodynamic parameters on enantiomer separation were carefully studied. Bifenthrin got a partial separation on Lux Cellulose‐1 column and baseline separation on Lux Cellulose‐3 column, while LCT enantiomers could be completely separated on both Lux Cellulose‐1 and Lux Cellulose‐3 columns. Chiralpak IC provided no separation ability for both BF and LCT. Retention factor (k) and selectivity factor (α) decreased with the column temperature increasing from 10°C to 40°C for both BF and LCT enantiomers. Thermodynamic parameters including ?H and ?S were also calculated, and the maximum R_s were not always obtained at lowest temperature. Furthermore, the quantitative analysis methods for BF and LCT enantiomers in soil and water were also established. Such results provide a new approach for pyrethroid separation under reversed‐phase condition and contribute to environmental risk assessment of pyrethroids at enantiomer level.     

A label‐free internal standard method for the differential analysis of bioactive lupin proteins using nano HPLC‐Chip coupled with Ion Trap mass spectrometry

Quantitative proteomics based on MS is useful for pointing out the differences in some food proteomes relevant to human nutrition. Stable isotope label‐free (SIF) techniques are suitable for comparing an unlimited number of samples by the use of relatively simple experimental workflows. We have developed an internal standard label‐free method based on the intensities of peptide precursor ions from MS/MS spectra, collected in data dependent runs, for the simultaneous qualitative characterization and relative quantification of storage proteins of Lupinus albus seeds in protein extracts of four lupin cultivars (cv Adam, Arés, Lucky, Multitalia). The use of an innovative microfluidic system, the HPLC‐Chip, coupled with a classical IT mass spectrometer, has allowed a complete qualitative characterization of all proteins. In particular, the homology search mode has permitted to identify single amino acid substitutions in the sequences of vicilins (β‐conglutin precursor and vicilin‐like protein). The MS/MS sequencing of substituted peptides confirms the high heterogeneity of vicilins according to the peculiar characteristics of the vicilin‐encoding gene family. Two suitable bioinformatics parameters were optimized for the differential analyses of the main bioactive proteins: the “normalized protein average of common reproducible peptides” (N‐ACRP) for γ‐conglutin, which is a homogeneous protein, and the “normalized protein mean peptide spectral intensity” (N‐MEAN) for the highly heterogenous class of the vicilins.     

Proteome analysis of Escherichia coli using high-performance liquid chromatography and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

The basic problem of complexity poses a significant challenge for proteomic studies. To date two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) followed by enzymatic in-gel digestion of the peptides, and subsequent identification by mass spectrometry (MS) is the most commonly used method to analyze complex protein mixtures. However, 2-DE is a slow and labor-intensive technique, which is not able to resolve all proteins of a proteome. To overcome these limitations gel-free approaches are developed based on high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS). The high resolution and excellent mass accuracy of FT-ICR MS provides a basis for simultaneous analysis of numerous compounds. In the present study, a small protein subfraction of an Escherichia coli cell lysate was prepared by size-exclusion chromatography and proteins were analyzed using C4 reversed phase (RP)-HPLC for pre-separation followed by C18 RP nanoHPLC/nanoESI FT-ICR MS for analysis of the peptide mixtures after tryptic digestion of the protein fractions. We identified 231 proteins and thus demonstrated that a combination of two RP separation steps - one on the protein and one on the peptide level - in combination with high-resolution FT-ICR MS has the potential to become a powerful method for global proteomics studies.     

Bottom‐up proteome analysis of E. coli using capillary zone electrophoresis‐tandem mass spectrometry with an electrokinetic sheath‐flow electrospray interface

The Escherichia coli proteome was digested with trypsin and fractionated using SPE on a C18 SPE column. Seven fractions were collected and analyzed by CZE‐ESI‐MS/MS. The separation was performed in a 60‐cm‐long linear polyacrylamide‐coated capillary with a 0.1% v/v formic acid separation buffer. An electrokinetic sheath‐flow electrospray interface was used to couple the separation capillary with an Orbitrap‐Velos operating in higher‐energy collisional dissociation mode. Each CZE‐ESI‐MS/MS run lasted 50 min and total MS time was 350 min. A total of 23 706 peptide spectra matches, 4902 peptide IDs, and 871 protein group IDs were generated using MASCOT with false discovery rate less than 1% on the peptide level. The total mass spectrometer analysis time was less than 6 h, the sample identification rate (145 proteins/h) was more than two times higher than previous studies of the E. coli proteome, and the amount of sample consumed (<1 μg) was roughly fourfold less than previous studies. These results demonstrate that CZE is a useful tool for the bottom‐up analysis of prokaryote proteomes.     

Rapid selection of peptide containing fractions in off‐line 2‐D HPLC in shotgun proteome analysis by screening with MALDI TOF MS

A simple and fast screening method for the selection of fractions of first dimension separation to be analyzed in second dimension‐MS/MS experiments in offline multidimensional liquid chromatographic separation schemes for shotgun proteome analysis was developed. The method is based on the measurement of total peptide content of the first dimension fractions by MALDI MS and was established using a tryptic digest of a bacterial proteome. The results of the screening process were in good agreement with those obtained in a detailed proteome analysis performed by RP×ion‐pair RP‐MALDI TOF/TOF MS analysis. The method supports a straightforward planning of experiments, also enabling a reduction of overall measurement time in shotgun proteome analysis.     

Alignment and statistical difference analysis of complex peptide data sets generated by multidimensional LC-MS

A method for high-resolution proteomics analyses of complex protein mixtures is presented using multidimensional HPLC coupled to MS (MDLC-MS). The method was applied to identify proteins that are differentially expressed during fruit ripening of tomato. Protein extracts from red and green tomato fruits were digested by trypsin. The resulting highly complex peptide mixtures were separated by strong cation exchange chromatography (SCX), and subsequently analyzed by RP nano-LC coupled to quadrupole-TOF MS. For detailed quantitative comparison, triplicate RP-LC-MS runs were performed for each SCX fraction. The resulting data sets were analyzed using MetAlign software for noise and data reduction, multiple alignment and statistical variance analysis. For each RP-LC-MS chromatogram, up to 7000 mass components were detected. Peak intensity data were compared by multivariate and statistical analysis. This revealed a clear separation between the green and red tomato samples, and a clear separation of the different SCX fractions. MS/MS spectra were collected using the data-dependent acquisition mode from a selected set of differentially detected peptide masses, enabling the identification of proteins that were differentially expressed during ripening of tomato fruits. Our approach is a highly sensitive method to analyze proteins in complex mixtures without the need of isotope labeling.     

Performance of five different electrospray ionisation sources in conjunction with rapid monolithic column liquid chromatography and fast MS/MS scanning

The performances of five different ESI sources coupled to a polystyrene–divinylbenzene monolithic column were compared in a series of LC‐ESI‐MS/MS analyses of Escherichia coli outer membrane proteins. The sources selected for comparison included two different modifications of the standard electrospray source, a commercial low‐flow sprayer, a stainless steel nanospray needle and a coated glass Picotip. Respective performances were judged on sensitivity and the number and reproducibility of significant protein identifications obtained through the analysis of multiple identical samples. Data quality varied between that of a ground silica capillary, with 160 total protein identifications, the lowest number of high quality peptide hits obtained (3012), and generally peaks of lower intensity; and a stainless steel nanospray needle, which resulted in increased precursor ion abundance, the highest‐quality peptide fragmentation spectra (5414) and greatest number of total protein identifications (259) exhibiting the highest MASCOT scores (average increase in score of 27.5% per identified protein). The data presented show that, despite increased variability in comparative ion intensity, the stainless steel nanospray needle provides the highest overall sensitivity. However, the resulting data were less reproducible in terms of proteins identified in complex mixtures – arguably due to an increased number of high intensity precursor ion candidates.     

Retention time prediction using the model of liquid chromatography of biomacromolecules at critical conditions in LC‐MS phosphopeptide analysis

LC combined with MS/MS analysis of complex mixtures of protein digests is a reliable and sensitive method for characterization of protein phosphorylation. Peptide retention times (RTs) measured during an LC‐MS/MS run depend on both the peptide sequence and the location of modified amino acids. These RTs can be predicted using the LC of biomacromolecules at critical conditions model (BioLCCC). Comparing the observed RTs to those obtained from the BioLCCC model can provide additional validation of MS/MS‐based peptide identifications to reduce the false discovery rate and to improve the reliability of phosphoproteome profiling. In this study, energies of interaction between phosphorylated residues and the surface of RP separation media for both “classic” alkyl C18 and polar‐embedded C18 stationary phases were experimentally determined and included in the BioLCCC model extended for phosphopeptide analysis. The RTs for phosphorylated peptides and their nonphosphorylated analogs were predicted using the extended BioLCCC model and compared with their experimental RTs. The extended model was evaluated using literary data and a complex phosphoproteome data set distributed through the Association of Biomolecular Resource Facilities Proteome Informatics Research Group 2010 study. The reported results demonstrate the capability of the extended BioLCCC model to predict RTs which may lead to improved sensitivity and reliability of LC‐MS/MS‐based phosphoproteome profiling.     

Multiplexed two-dimensional liquid chromatography for MALDI and nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry in proteomics

We developed a multiplexed two-dimensional separation system based on reversed phase (RP)--strong cation exchange (SCX) chromatography as a front-end device for matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) or nanoelectrospray ionization (nanoESI) mass spectrometry. Tryptic peptide mixtures were fractionated on a reversed-phase HPLC column, and each fraction was loaded onto multiplexed SCX microcolumns. Because this second chromatography was carried out in parallel, the analysis time is independent of the fraction number in the first RP-HPLC separation. The resultant samples were desalted/concentrated and eluted onto a MALDI plate with matrix-containing elution solutions in parallel, or eluted with optimized solutions for nanoESI and loaded onto nanoESI sprayers by an automated instrument. The soluble portion of HCT116 lysate was digested and fractionated using a 48-plexed chromatography system. Approximately 1000 unique peaks were detected in MALDI-MS with 3000 MS/MS spectra, while 724 peptides with ultrahigh peptide mass accuracy (sub-ppm error) were identified in nanoESI-FTICR mass spectrometry with five integrated selected ion monitoring scans. Since MS measurement with this off-line LC-LC approach is not restricted by continuous LC elution, it is expected to be useful especially in cases where repeated analysis with different scan modes or long-term data acquisition is required.     

Software for analysing ion mobility mass spectrometry data to improve peptide identification

The development of ion mobility (IM) MS instruments has the capability to provide an added dimension to peptide analysis pipelines in proteomics, but, as yet, there are few software tools available for analysing such data. IM can be used to provide additional separation of parent ions or product ions following fragmentation. In this work, we have created a set of software tools that are capable of converting three dimensional IM data generated from analysis of fragment ions into a variety of formats used in proteomics. We demonstrate that IM can be used to calculate the charge state of a fragment ion, demonstrating the potential to improve peptide identification by excluding non-informative ions from a database search. We also provide preliminary evidence of structural differences between b and y ions for certain peptide sequences but not others. All software tools and data sets are made available in the public domain at http://code.google.com/p/ion-mobility-ms-tools/.     

On-line capillary column immobilised metal affinity chromatography/electrospray ionisation mass spectrometry for the selective analysis of histidine-containing peptides

Capillary column immobilised metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) has been combined on-line with electrospray ionisation/quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry for the fractionation of histidine-containing peptides. IMAC beads (Poros 20MC, 20 microm) containing imidodiacetate chelating groups on a cross-linked poly(styrene-divinylbenzene) support were packed into a fused silica column (250 microm i.d.), which was interfaced to the electrospray ion source of the spectrometer. A Cu(II) activated column was used to isolate histidine-containing peptides from tryptic and other peptide mixtures with an average breakthrough of 9.1%, to reduce the complexity of the mass spectral analysis. The analysis cycle time was reduced to less than 15 min, at an optimum flow rate of 7.5 microL/min, without sacrificing peptide selectivity. Direct coupling of capillary IMAC with MS allows on-line separation, using MS compatible loading and elution buffers, and detection in a high-throughput fashion when compared to off-line strategies.     

Automation of nanoflow liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry for proteome analysis by using a strong cation exchange trap column

An approach was developed to automate sample introduction for nanoflow LC-MS/MS (microLC-MS/MS) analysis using a strong cation exchange (SCX) trap column. The system consisted of a 100 microm id x 2 cm SCX trap column and a 75 microm id x 12 cm C18 RP analytical column. During the sample loading step, the flow passing through the SCX trap column was directed to waste for loading a large volume of sample at high flow rate. Then the peptides bound on the SCX trap column were eluted onto the RP analytical column by a high salt buffer followed by RP chromatographic separation of the peptides at nanoliter flow rate. It was observed that higher performance of separation could be achieved with the system using SCX trap column than with the system using C18 trap column. The high proteomic coverage using this approach was demonstrated in the analysis of tryptic digest of BSA and yeast cell lysate. In addition, this system was also applied to two-dimensional separation of tryptic digest of human hepatocellular carcinoma cell line SMMC-7721 for large scale proteome analysis. This system was fully automated and required minimum changes on current microLC-MS/MS system. This system represented a promising platform for routine proteome analysis.