Application of Balanced Scorecard in the Evaluation of a Complex Health System Intervention: 12 Months Post Intervention Findings from the BHOMA Intervention: A Cluster Randomised Trial in Zambia

Introduction

In many low income countries, the delivery of quality health services is hampered by health system-wide barriers which are often interlinked, however empirical evidence on how to assess the level and scope of these barriers is scarce. A balanced scorecard is a tool that allows for wider analysis of domains that are deemed important in achieving the overall vision of the health system. We present the quantitative results of the 12 months follow-up study applying the balanced scorecard approach in the BHOMA intervention with the aim of demonstrating the utility of the balanced scorecard in evaluating multiple building blocks in a trial setting.

Methods

The BHOMA is a cluster randomised trial that aims to strengthen the health system in three rural districts in Zambia. The intervention aims to improve clinical care quality by implementing practical tools that establish clear clinical care standards through intensive clinic implementations. This paper reports the findings of the follow-up health facility survey that was conducted after 12 months of intervention implementation. Comparisons were made between those facilities in the intervention and control sites. STATA version 12 was used for analysis.

Results

The study found significant mean differences between intervention(I) and control (C) sites in the following domains: Training domain (Mean I:C; 87.5.vs 61.1, mean difference 23.3, p = 0.031), adult clinical observation domain (mean I:C; 73.3 vs.58.0, mean difference 10.9, p = 0.02 ) and health information domain (mean I:C; 63.6 vs.56.1, mean difference 6.8, p = 0.01. There was no gender differences in adult service satisfaction. Governance and motivation scores did not differ between control and intervention sites.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates the utility of the balanced scorecard in assessing multiple elements of the health system. Using system wide approaches and triangulating data collection methods seems to be key to successful evaluation of such complex health intervention.

Trial number

ClinicalTrials.gov {"type":"clinical-trial","attrs":{"text":"NCT01942278","term_id":"NCT01942278"}}NCT01942278     

Intervention against the Maillard reaction in vivo

The field of Maillard/glycation reactions in vivo has grown enormously during the past 20 years, going from 25 to 500 publications per year. It is now well recognized that many of the “advanced” products form oxidatively or anaerobically and can have deleterious effects on macromolecular and biological function. The feasibility of developing pharmacological agents with beneficial in vivo properties, based on in vitro inhibition of glycation, has been surprisingly successful. This Editorial sets the stage for a series of articles by experts in the field, who have made key contributions to our understanding of the Maillard reaction in vivo.     

学业自我妨碍的干预策略

为使学业自我妨碍者获得学业进步,学校教育必须消除和改变自我妨碍策略发生的线索,避免学生过多使用自我妨碍的动机策略来保护其自尊水平。文章对学业自我妨碍的概念、影响因素、作用结果和干预策略进行了综述,旨在为学校教育提供科学信息,使自我妨碍的学生走出学业困境,提高其学业水平。     

衰老的分子机制与干预研究的最新进展

随着全球老龄化时代的到来,衰老和衰老相关疾病带来的健康问题日益突出。如何最大限度地维持老龄人口健康、干预衰老相关疾病并延缓衰老的发生对于医疗系统、科研机构乃至整个社会都是巨大的挑战。目前,对于衰老的分子机制研究已经有长足的进步,对于衰老进程的生物学和遗传学机制已有突破性的认识,对于衰老相关疾病的发病机制也有了深刻的理解。但这些研究成果还远远达不到能够延缓人类衰老并遏制衰老相关疾病的发生的要求。该文将从衰老的分子机制和干预手段这两个方面入手,综述衰老的理论研究和实际应用中的主要成果和最新进展。     

A Cluster-Randomized Controlled Intervention Study to Assess the Effect of a Contact Intervention in Reducing Leprosy-Related Stigma in Indonesia

Background

Can deliberate interaction between the public and persons affected by leprosy reduce stigmatization? The study described in this paper hypothesises that it can and assesses the effectiveness of a ‘contact intervention’.

Methods/Principal Findings

This cluster-randomized controlled intervention study is part of the Stigma Assessment and Reduction of Impact (SARI) project conducted in Cirebon District, Indonesia. Testimonies, participatory videos and comics given or made by people affected by leprosy were used as methods to facilitate a dialogue during so-called ‘contact events’. A mix of seven quantitative and qualitative methods, including two scales to assess aspects of stigma named the SDS and EMIC-CSS, were used to establish a baseline regarding stigma and knowledge of leprosy, monitor the implementation and assess the impact of the contact events. The study sample were community members selected using different sampling methods. The baseline shows a lack of knowledge about leprosy, a high level of stigma and contrasting examples of support. In total, 91 contact events were organised in 62 villages, directly reaching 4,443 community members (mean 49 per event). The interview data showed that knowledge about leprosy increased and that negative attitudes reduced. The adjusted mean total score of the EMIC-CSS reduced by 4.95 points among respondents who had attended a contact event (n = 58; p <0.001, effect size = 0.75) compared to the score at baseline (n = 213); for the SDS this was 3.56 (p <0.001, effect size = 0.81). About 75% of those attending a contact event said they shared the information with others (median 10 persons).

Conclusions/Significance

The contact intervention was effective in increasing knowledge and improving public attitudes regarding leprosy. It is relatively easy to replicate elsewhere and does not require expensive technology. More research is needed to improve scalability. The effectiveness of a contact intervention to reduce stigma against other neglected tropical diseases and conditions should be evaluated.     

围产儿出生缺陷分析及干预措施

摘要目的：掌握围产儿出生缺陷的发生情况,探讨引起围产儿出生缺陷的相关因素,为制订及完善出生缺陷预防对策及干预措施提供科学依据。方法：按照全国出生缺陷监测中心制定的监测方案,对2010年10月1日～2011年9月30日在湘潭市县级及以上医疗保健机构住院分娩的围生儿出生缺陷监测资料进行分析。结果：5年出生缺陷的平均发生率为93．30／万,出生缺陷的发生率无明显趋势（x2=0．114,P=0．736）乡村的出生缺陷发生率明显高于城镇（X2=24．638,P〈O．001）,男性围产儿的出生缺陷发生率显著高于女性（XZ=6．693,P=0．010）,出生缺陷的发生率与季节无关（x2=3．852,P=0．278）,出生缺陷的围产儿死亡率大大高于非出生缺陷）L（X2=2904．583,P〈0．001）,先天性心脏病、肢体畸形（并指／趾、多指／趾、肢体短缩、马蹄内翻足）、唇裂及唇腭裂是高发的出生缺陷。结论：减少出生缺陷的发生是一项长期工程,需要采取综合措施,从各个环节入手,以预防为主,加强优生优育健康教育,落实婚前及围产期保健,推行新生儿疾病筛查,可有效降低出生缺陷的发病率,提高出生人口素质。     

心理干预对难治性抑郁症患者康复治疗的影响

目的：探讨心理干预对难治性抑郁症（TRD）患者康复治疗效果的影响。方法：对2011年1月-2013年2月在我院就诊的136例（脱落7例,实际完成129例）TRD患者的临床资料行回顾性分析,根据实施心理干预与否分组,比较两组治疗前后HAMD、CGI、NOSIE、GQOLI-74等量表评分,并记录不良反应。结果：因疗程不足,观察组（原68例）脱落2例,实际完成66例;对照组（原68例）脱落5例,实际完成63例,共129例。两组患者的各指标无明显差异（P〉0．05）。与对照组相比,观察组患者在治疗8周后的HAMD和cGI减分率明显升高;NOSIE积极因子和消极因子分数明显下降;心理健康、躯体健康、物质生活、社会功能评分明显升高（P〈0．05）。两组不良反应主要以体重增加、锥体外系副反应、口干、便秘、头晕与头痛等为主,均未影响治疗。结论：对于TRD康复治疗,辅行心理干预,有助于增强药物治疗效果,改善患者预后,值得深究推广。     

Monitoring Intervention Coverage in the Context of Universal Health Coverage

Monitoring universal health coverage (UHC) focuses on information on health intervention coverage and financial protection. This paper addresses monitoring intervention coverage, related to the full spectrum of UHC, including health promotion and disease prevention, treatment, rehabilitation, and palliation. A comprehensive core set of indicators most relevant to the country situation should be monitored on a regular basis as part of health progress and systems performance assessment for all countries. UHC monitoring should be embedded in a broad results framework for the country health system, but focus on indicators related to the coverage of interventions that most directly reflect the results of UHC investments and strategies in each country. A set of tracer coverage indicators can be selected, divided into two groups—promotion/prevention, and treatment/care—as illustrated in this paper. Disaggregation of the indicators by the main equity stratifiers is critical to monitor progress in all population groups. Targets need to be set in accordance with baselines, historical rate of progress, and measurement considerations. Critical measurement gaps also exist, especially for treatment indicators, covering issues such as mental health, injuries, chronic conditions, surgical interventions, rehabilitation, and palliation. Consequently, further research and proxy indicators need to be used in the interim. Ideally, indicators should include a quality of intervention dimension. For some interventions, use of a single indicator is feasible, such as management of hypertension; but in many areas additional indicators are needed to capture quality of service provision. The monitoring of UHC has significant implications for health information systems. Major data gaps will need to be filled. At a minimum, countries will need to administer regular household health surveys with biological and clinical data collection. Countries will also need to improve the production of reliable, comprehensive, and timely health facility data. Please see later in the article for the Editors'' Summary

Summary Points

• Monitoring universal health coverage (UHC) should be integral to overall tracking of health progress and performance, which requires regular assessment of health system inputs (finances, health workforce, and medicines), outputs (service provision), coverage of interventions, and health impacts, as well as the social determinants of health.
• Within this overall context, we propose that UHC monitoring focus on financial protection and intervention coverage indicators, with a strong equity focus. This paper focuses on intervention coverage.
• Progress towards UHC should be tracked using tracer intervention coverage indicators selected on the basis of objective considerations and designed to keep the numbers of indicators small and manageable while covering a range of health interventions to capture the essence of the UHC goal.
• Since UHC is about progressive realization and countries differ in epidemiology, health systems, socioeconomic development, and people''s expectations, the indicator sets will not be the same everywhere.
• Coverage indicators should cover promotion and prevention, as well as treatment, rehabilitation, and palliation. While there are several suitable indicators for the first two, there are major gaps for coverage indicators of treatment, as population need for treatment is difficult to measure.
• A small set of well-established international intervention tracer coverage indicators can be identified for monitoring UHC. Where no good indicators are currently available, proxy indicators and equity analysis of service utilization can provide some insights.
• Special attention needs to be paid to quality of services, either through the tracer indicator itself (referred to as effective coverage) or through additional indicators on quality of services or health impact of the intervention.
• Targets should be set in accordance with baseline, historical rate of progress, and measurement considerations.
• The main data sources of intervention coverage indicators are household surveys and health facility reports. Investments in both are needed to improve the ability of countries to monitor progress towards UHC.
• It is essential to find effective ways of communicating progress towards UHC in ways that are meaningful to the general public and that capture the attention of policy makers.

This paper is part of the PLOS Universal Health Coverage Collection.

     

围手术期护理干预对腹腔镜胆囊切除术疗效的影响

目的探讨围手术期实施护理干预措施,对腹腔镜胆囊切除术疗效的影响。方法腹腔镜胆囊切除术患者100例根据护理方法的不同随机分为护理干预和对照组各50例。对照组进行常规护理,护理干预在对照组的基础上采取一系列的术前、术中及术后的围手术期护理干预措施。观察比较两组腹腔镜胆囊切除术的疗效及并发症情况。结果护理干预组的手术时间、术中出血量及术后排气时间、术后住院时间均明显短于对照组（P〈0.05）。且护理干预组术后发生切口感染、出血以及胆漏、放射痛、肠粘连的发生率明显低于对照组（P〈0.05）。结论通过采取系列的围手术期护理干预措施,可以积极预防并发症的发生,缩短手术时间及住院时间,提高治疗效果。