Ribosomal RNAs in translation termination: facts and hypotheses

It is now well established that ribosomal RNAs (rRNAs) play an active role in every aspect of translation. This review focuses on recent evidence for the involvement of rRNAs from both subunits of the ribosome in translation termination. This evidence comprises data obtained with rRNA mutants both in vivo and in vitro. In particular, mutations in specific regions of rRNAs caused readthrough of nonsense codons in vivo. Consistent with their in vivo characteristics, the mutations decreased the productive association of the ribosome with release factor 2 (RF2) and the efficiency of catalysis of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis in the presence of RF2 in realistic in vitro termination systems. It is now evident that genetic selections for termination-defective mutants in vivo and their characterization in realistic in vitro termination assays will rapidly advance our understanding of the mechanism of termination.     

Mutations in conserved regions of ribosomal RNAs decrease the productive association of peptide-chain release factors with the ribosome during translation termination

Early studies provided evidence that peptide-chain release factors (RFs) bind to both ribosomal subunits and trigger translation termination. Although many ribosomal proteins have been implicated in termination, very few data present direct biochemical evidence for the involvement of rRNA. Particularly absent is direct evidence for a role of a large subunit rRNA in RF binding. Previously we demonstrated in vitro that mutations in Escherichia coli rRNAs, known to cause nonsense codon readthrough in vivo, reduce the efficiency of RF2-driven catalysis of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. This reduction was consistent with the idea that in vivo defective termination at the mutant ribosomes contributes to the readthrough. Nevertheless, other explanations were also possible, because still missing was essential biochemical evidence for that idea, namely, decrease in productive association of RFs with the mutant ribosomes. Here we present such evidence using a new realistic in vitro termination assay. This study directly supports in vivo involvement in termination of conserved rRNA regions that also participate in other translational events. Furthermore, this study provides the first strong evidence for involvement of large subunit rRNA in RF binding, indicating that the same rRNA region interacts with factors that determine both elongation and termination of translation.     

Structural aspects of translation termination on the ribosome

Translation of genetic information encoded in messenger RNAs into polypeptide sequences is carried out by ribosomes in all organisms. When a full protein is synthesized, a stop codon positioned in the ribosomal A site signals termination of translation and protein release. Translation termination depends on class I release factors. Recently, atomic-resolution crystal structures were determined for bacterial 70S ribosome termination complexes bound with release factors RF1 or RF2. In combination with recent biochemical studies, the structures resolve long-standing questions about translation termination. They bring insights into the mechanisms of recognition of all three stop codons, peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis, and coordination of stop-codon recognition with peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. In this review, the structural aspects of these mechanisms are discussed.     

Inhibition of peptide chain termination by antibodies specific for ribosomal proteins

The effects of antibodies specific for the Escherichia coli 30 S and 50 S ribosomal proteins have been determined for in vitro peptide chain termination and two partial reactions, the codon-directed binding of E. coli release factor to the ribosome and peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis with RF². Antibodies to ribosomal proteins L7 and L12 inhibit the initial binding of RF to the ribosome, and as a result, the subsequent peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. The kinetics of ribosomal inactivation for in vitro termination by anti-L7/L12 indicate that Fab fragments bind to three ribosome sites, and suggest that each of three copies of L7/L12 is involved in the binding of RF to the ribosome. When 70 S ribosome substrates are pretreated with anti-L11 and anti-L16 RF-dependent peptidyl-tRNA, hydrolysis is partially inhibited but the interaction of RF with the ribosome is not affected. The inactivation of in vitro termination by a mixture of anti-L11 and anti-L16 is not co-operative. Pretreatment of the 30 S ribosomal subunit (but not 70 S ribosomal substrate) with antibodies to the 30 S proteins, S9 and S11, results in strong inhibition of codon-directed hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA. While these antibodies inhibit ribosome subunit association, a requirement for peptide chain termination, and thereby may inhibit the in vitro termination reactions indirectly, the codon-directed binding of RF is markedly more affected than peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis by anti-S9 and anti-S11. Antibody to S2 and anti-S3 exhibit a similar but less marked differential effect on the partial reactions of in vitro termination under the same conditions. When dissociated ribosomes are pretreated with anti-L11, in vitro termination is completely inhibited and both codon-directed binding of RF and peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis are affected. L11 may, therefore, be at or near the interface between the ribosome subunits and like S9 and S11 not completely accessible to antibody in 70 S ribosomes. Pretreatment of dissociated ribosomes with antibodies to a number of other ribosomal proteins (L2, L4, L6, L14, L15, L17, L18, L20, L23, L26, L27) results in partial inhibition of all termination reactions although these antibodies have no effect on termination when incubated with 70 S ribosome substrates. The antibodies probably affect in vitro termination indirectly as a result of either preventing correct ribosome subunit association, or preventing correct positioning of the fMet-tRNA at the ribosome P site.     

Functional sites of interaction between release factor RF1 and the ribosome

Translational release factors decipher stop codons in mRNA and activate hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA in the ribosome during translation termination. The mechanisms of these fundamental processes are unknown. Here we have mapped the interaction of bacterial release factor RF1 with the ribosome by directed hydroxyl radical probing. These experiments identified conserved domains of RF1 that interact with the decoding site of the 30S ribosomal subunit and the peptidyl transferase site of the 50S ribosomal subunit. RF1 interacts with a binding pocket formed between the ribosomal subunits that is also the interaction surface of elongation factor EF-G and aminoacyl-tRNA bound to the A site. These results provide a basis for understanding the mechanism of stop codon recognition coupled to hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA, mediated by a protein release factor.     

Release factor RF-3 GTPase activity acts in disassembly of the ribosome termination complex.

RF3 was initially characterized as a factor that stimulates translational termination in an in vitro assay. The factor has a GTP binding site and shows sequence similarity to elongation factors EF-Tu and EF-G. Paradoxically, addition of GTP abolishes RF3 stimulation in the classical termination assay, using stop triplets. We here show GTP hydrolysis, which is only dependent on the simultaneous presence of RF3 and ribosomes. Applying a new termination assay, which uses a minimessenger RNA instead of separate triplets, we show that GTP in the presence of RF3 stimulates termination at rate-limiting concentrations of RF1. We show that RF3 can substitute for EF-G in RRF-dependent ribosome recycling reactions in vitro. This activity is GTP-dependent. In addition, excess RF3 and RRF in the presence of GTP caused release of nonhydrolyzed fmet-tRNA. This supports previous genetic experiments, showing that RF3 might be involved in ribosomal drop off of peptidyl-tRNA. In contrast to GTP involvement of the above reactions, stimulation of termination with RF2 by RF3 was independent of the presence of GTP. This is consistent with previous studies, indicating that RF3 enhances the affinity of RF2 for the termination complex without GTP hydrolysis. Based on our results, we propose a model of how RF3 might function in translational termination and ribosome recycling.     

A posttermination ribosomal complex is the guanine nucleotide exchange factor for peptide release factor RF3

The mechanism by which peptide release factor RF3 recycles RF1 and RF2 has been clarified and incorporated in a complete scheme for translation termination. Free RF3 is in vivo stably bound to GDP, and ribosomes in complex with RF1 or RF2 act as guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEF). Hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA by RF1 or RF2 allows GTP binding to RF3 on the ribosome. This induces an RF3 conformation with high affinity for ribosomes and leads to rapid dissociation of RF1 or RF2. Dissociation of RF3 from the ribosome requires GTP hydrolysis. Our data suggest that RF3 and its eukaryotic counterpart, eRF3, have mechanistic principles in common.     

Methylation of bacterial release factors RF1 and RF2 is required for normal translation termination in vivo

Bacterial release factors RF1 and RF2 are methylated on the Gln residue of a universally conserved tripeptide motif GGQ, which interacts with the peptidyl transferase center of the large ribosomal subunit, triggering hydrolysis of the ester bond in peptidyl-tRNA and releasing the newly synthesized polypeptide from the ribosome. In vitro experiments have shown that the activity of RF2 is stimulated by Gln methylation. The viability of Escherichia coli K12 strains depends on the integrity of the release factor methyltransferase PrmC, because K12 strains are partially deficient in RF2 activity due to the presence of a Thr residue at position 246 instead of Ala. Here, we study in vivo RF1 and RF2 activity at termination codons in competition with programmed frameshifting and the effect of the Ala-246 --> Thr mutation. PrmC inactivation reduces the specific termination activity of RF1 and RF2(Ala-246) by approximately 3- to 4-fold. The mutation Ala-246 --> Thr in RF2 reduces the termination activity in cells approximately 5-fold. After correction for the decrease in level of RF2 due to the autocontrol of RF2 synthesis, the mutation Ala-246 --> Thr reduced RF2 termination activity by approximately 10-fold at UGA codons and UAA codons. PrmC inactivation had no effect on cell growth in rich media but reduced growth considerably on poor carbon sources. This suggests that the expression of some genes needed for optimal growth under such conditions can become growth limiting as a result of inefficient translation termination.     

Modification of Escherichia coli ribosomes: in vitro termination is less dependent on histidine residues at the peptidyl transferase centre when ribosomes lack protein L11

Chemical modification of ribosomes with the histidine specific reagents, 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (FDNB) and diethylpyrocarbonate (DEP), result in a loss of activities in vitro of codon-dependent termination and peptide bond formation. The binding of release factor (RF) to the ribosome is unaffected but the hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA is inhibited. On reversal of the modification activity can be restored. Partial protection is provided by chloramphenicol indicating that one or more of the affected residues is at the peptidyl transferase centre. Codon-dependent termination on ribosomes lacking L11, which have a greater affinity for RF-2, is significantly less affected by the modification than on control ribosomes. Peptide bond formation is affected similarly on L11 lacking and normal ribosomes.     

Distinct Roles for Release Factor 1 and Release Factor 2 in Translational Quality Control

In bacteria, stop codons are recognized by two similar class 1 release factors, release factor 1 (RF1) and release factor 2 (RF2). Normally, during termination, the class 2 release factor 3 (RF3), a GTPase, functions downstream of peptide release where it accelerates the dissociation of RF1/RF2 prior to ribosome recycling. In addition to their canonical function in termination, both classes of release factor are also involved in a post peptidyl transfer quality control (post PT QC) mechanism where the termination factors recognize mismatched (i.e. error-containing) ribosome complexes and promote premature termination. Here, using a well defined in vitro system, we explored the role of release factors in canonical termination and post PT QC. As reported previously, during canonical termination, RF1 and RF2 recognize stop codons in a similar manner, and RF3 accelerates their rate of dissociation. During post PT QC, only RF2 (and not RF1) effectively binds to mismatched ribosome complexes; and whereas the addition of RF3 to RF2 increased its rate of release on mismatched complexes, the addition of RF3 to RF1 inhibited its rate of release but increased the rate of peptidyl-tRNA dissociation. Our data strongly suggest that RF2, in addition to its primary role in peptide release, functions as the principle factor for post PT QC.     

Translation termination in eukaryotes: polypeptide release factor eRF1 is composed of functionally and structurally distinct domains

Class-1 polypeptide chain release factors (RFs) trigger hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA at the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center mediated by one of the three termination codons. In eukaryotes, apart from catalyzing the translation termination reaction, eRF1 binds to and activates another factor, eRF3, which is a ribosome-dependent and eRF1-dependent GTPase. Because peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis and GTP hydrolysis could be uncoupled in vitro, we suggest that the two main functions of eRF1 are associated with different domains of the eRF1 protein. We show here by deletion analysis that human eRF1 is composed of two physically separated and functionally distinct domains. The "core" domain is fully competent in ribosome binding and termination-codon-dependent peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis, and encompasses the N-terminal and middle parts of the polypeptide chain. The C-terminal one-third of eRF1 binds to eRF3 in vivo in the absence of the core domain, but both domains are required to activate eRF3 GTPase in the ribosome. The calculated isoelectric points of the core and C domains are 9.74 and 4.23, respectively. This highly uneven charge distribution between the two domains implies that electrostatic interdomain interaction may affect the eRF1 binding to the ribosome and eRF3, its activity in the termination reaction and activation of eRF3 GTPase. The positively charged core of eRF1 may interact with negatively charged rRNA and peptidyl-tRNA phosphate backbones at the ribosomal eRF1 binding site and exhibit RNA-binding ability. The structural and functional dissimilarity of the core and eRF3-binding domains implies that evolutionarily eRF1 originated as a product of gene fusion.     

Non-standard genetic codes and translation termination

Genetic code is not universal. Various non-standard versions of the code were found in mitochondrial, prokaryotic and eukaryotic genomes. Stop codons are used to signal the ribosome stop translation of the coding sequence and prone to reassignment to sense codons. Class-1 termination factors recognize stop codons and promote hydrolysis of the peptidyl-tRNA in ribosome (RF1, RF2 in prokaryotes and eRF1 in eukaryotes). The class-1 factor termination specificity is changed in non-standart codes organisms. Pyrrolysine and selenocysteine use dissimilar decoding strategies. The various non-standart code origin hypotheses are described. It was proposed that specificity alteration of the class-1 release factor was a starting point for stop codon reassignment.     

Release factor RF3 in E.coli accelerates the dissociation of release factors RF1 and RF2 from the ribosome in a GTP-dependent manner.

Ribosomes complexed with synthetic mRNA and peptidyl-tRNA, ready for peptide release, were purified by gel filtration and used to study the function of release factor RF3 and guanine nucleotides in the termination of protein synthesis. The peptide-releasing activity of RF1 and RF2 in limiting concentrations was stimulated by the addition of RF3 and GTP, stimulated, though to a lesser extent, by RF3 and a non-hydrolysable GTP analogue, and inhibited by RF3 and GDP or RF3 without guanine nucleotide. With short incubation times allowing only a single catalytic cycle of RF1 or RF2, peptide release activity was independent of RF3 and guanine nucleotide. RF3 hydrolysis of GTP to GDP + P(i) was dependent only on ribosomes and not on RF1 or RF2. RF3 affected neither the rate of association of RF1 and RF2 with the ribosome nor the catalytic rate of peptide release. A model is proposed which explains how RF3 recycles RF1 and RF2 by displacing the factors from the ribosome after the release of peptide.     

The importance of the Escherichia coli ribosomal protein L16 for the reconstitution of the peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis activity of peptide chain termination

The incubation of the 50 S ribosomal subunit of Escherichia coli with 1.5 M LiCl yields 1.5c core particles inactive in the peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis activity of in vitro termination. The omission of L16 alone from reconstitutions of the proteins into the core results in inactive ribosomes. The single omission of a number of other proteins, in particular L7/L12, L10, L25, L27, and L15, gives ribosomes with intermediate activity. L16 alone is unable to restore significant activity to 1.5c cores, but together L16 and the above "stimulating" proteins produce particles as active as those reconstituted with the full complement of proteins. The ribosomal proteins important for the expression of peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis and peptidyl transferase activities are very similar. However, ribosomes lacking both L11 and L16, but not L16 alone, surprisingly can catalyze codon- and release factor 2-dependent peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. The addition of L16 dramatically increases the activity. L16 is, therefore, important but not essential for the expression of the release factor 2-dependent peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis.     

Structure of a human translation termination complex

In contrast to bacteria that have two release factors, RF1 and RF2, eukaryotes only possess one unrelated release factor eRF1, which recognizes all three stop codons of the mRNA and hydrolyses the peptidyl-tRNA bond. While the molecular basis for bacterial termination has been elucidated, high-resolution structures of eukaryotic termination complexes have been lacking. Here we present a 3.8 Å structure of a human translation termination complex with eRF1 decoding a UAA(A) stop codon. The complex was formed using the human cytomegalovirus (hCMV) stalling peptide, which perturbs the peptidyltransferase center (PTC) to silence the hydrolysis activity of eRF1. Moreover, unlike sense codons or bacterial stop codons, the UAA stop codon adopts a U-turn-like conformation within a pocket formed by eRF1 and the ribosome. Inducing the U-turn conformation for stop codon recognition rationalizes how decoding by eRF1 includes monitoring geometry in order to discriminate against sense codons.     

Mapping functionally important motifs SPF and GGQ of the decoding release factor RF2 to the Escherichia coli ribosome by hydroxyl radical footprinting. Implications for macromolecular mimicry and structural changes in RF2

The function of the decoding release factor (RF) in translation termination is to couple cognate recognition of the stop codon in the mRNA with hydrolysis of the completed polypeptide from its covalently linked tRNA. For this to occur, the RF must interact with specific A-site components of the active centers within both the small and large ribosomal subunits. In this work, we have used directed hydroxyl radical footprinting to map the ribosomal binding site of the Escherichia coli class I release factor RF2, during translation termination. In the presence of the cognate UGA stop codon, residues flanking the universally conserved (250)GGQ(252) motif of RF2 were each shown to footprint to the large ribosomal subunit, specifically to conserved elements of the peptidyltransferase and GTPase-associated centers. In contrast, residues that flank the putative "peptide anticodon" of RF2, (205)SPF(207), were shown to make a footprint in the small ribosomal subunit at positions within well characterized 16 S rRNA motifs in the vicinity of the decoding center. Within the recently solved crystal structure of E. coli RF2, the GGQ and SPF motifs are separated by 23 A only, a distance that is incompatible with the observed cleavage sites that are up to 100 A apart. Our data suggest that RF2 may undergo gross conformational changes upon ribosome binding, the implications of which are discussed in terms of the mechanism of RF-mediated termination.     

Translation termination and its regulation in eukaryotes: recent insights provided by studies in yeast

In protein synthesis, the arrival of one or other of the three stop codons in the ribosomal A-site triggers the binding of a release factor (RF) to the ribosome and subsequent polypeptide chain release. In eukaryotes, the RF is composed of two proteins, eRF1 and eRF3. eRF1 is responsible for the hydrolysis of the peptidyl-tRNA, while eRF3 provides a GTP-dependent function, although its precise role remains to be defined. Recent findings on translation termination and its regulation from studies in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae are reviewed and the potential role of eRF3 is discussed.     

Interaction between a mutant release factor one and P-site peptidyl-tRNA is influenced by the identity of the two bases downstream of the stop codon UAG.

Termination efficiency of a mutant form of RF (release facor) 1, as compared to the wild-type enzyme, is influenced by the P-site peptidyl-tRNA if the termination signal is UAGA. This effect is weaker at the stronger termination signal UAGU. Similarly, low efficiency of the mutant RF1, together with certain peptidyl-tRNAs, can be increased by changing the second base of the 3'-flanking codon from C to G. The data suggest that the mutant RF1 interacts with the P-site peptidyl-tRNA in conjunction with the context at the 3'-side of the termination codon.     

Recognition of the amber UAG stop codon by release factor RF1

We report the crystal structure of a termination complex containing release factor RF1 bound to the 70S ribosome in response to an amber (UAG) codon at 3.6‐Å resolution. The amber codon is recognized in the 30S subunit‐decoding centre directly by conserved elements of domain 2 of RF1, including T186 of the PVT motif. Together with earlier structures, the mechanisms of recognition of all three stop codons by release factors RF1 and RF2 can now be described. Our structure confirms that the backbone amide of Q230 of the universally conserved GGQ motif is positioned to contribute directly to the catalysis of the peptidyl‐tRNA hydrolysis reaction through stabilization of the leaving group and/or transition state. We also observe synthetic‐negative interactions between mutations in the switch loop of RF1 and in helix 69 of 23S rRNA, revealing that these structural features interact functionally in the termination process. These findings are consistent with our proposal that structural rearrangements of RF1 and RF2 are critical to accurate translation termination.