Systemic Acquired Resistance Induced in Tobacco Plants by Localized Virus Infection Does Not Operate Against Challenging Viruses That Infect Systemically

Localized infections produced by tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) or tomato mosaic virus (ToMV) in White Burley tobacco induced a systemic acquired resistance in upper, uninoculated leaves. This resistance was effective against challenge infection by TNV or ToMV but not by potato virus Y, necrotic strain (PVYⁿ), tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) or tobacco rattle virus (TRV), viruses giving systemic infections. Systemic acquired resistance against TNV or ToMV was expressed as a reduction in lesion size but not in viral antigen content of the resulting necrotic local lesions. The acquisition of resistance was concurrent with an increased capacity of the resistant leaves to convert 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid into ethylene. Systemic acquired resistance was ineffective to contrast or minimize in whatever way the systemic challenge infection produced by PVY^N, TMV or TRV. Severity of symptoms and virus multiplication did not differ in resistant leaves from controls. This result does not allow any optimistic promise on possible application of the systemic acquired resistance against severe viral diseases of crops.     

Effects of Salicylate on Systemic Invasion of Tobacco Plants by Various Viruses

Salicylate watered onto soil in which White Burley tobacco plants were grown represents a reversible stress characterized by stomatal closure, slight slackening of plant growth and low chlorophyll loss. Salicylate affected viral pathogenesis in opposite ways. It had no effect against local and systemic infections by potato virus X (PVX), potato virus Y⁰ (PVY⁰) or tobacco mosaic virus (TMV), whereas it completely prevented systemic infection by alfalfa mosaic virus (AIMV) or tobacco, rattle virus (TRV) in a high proportion of treated plants. When infection moved from leaves inoculated with AIMV or TRV, the tendency to limit systemic spread was shown by the restriction of systemic infection to very limited areas erratically distributed in some uninoculated leaves. The salicylate-induced restriction of AIMV or TRV infectivity to inoculated leaves did not appear due to inhibition of virus multiplication because the inoculation of potentially resistant leaves of salicylate-reated plants resulted in virus antigen accumulation comparable to that of untreated controls. Salicylate may therefore inhibit some long distance virus transport function. Salicylate appears able to evoke true hypersensitivity only against systemic viruses able to induce local necrotic lesions, probably by activating some genetic information for resistance that is normally not expressed.     

Pathogen-activated induced resistance of cucumber: response of arthropod herbivores to systemically protected leaves

Summary Restricted (non-systemic) inoculation of cucurbits, green bean, tobacco, and other plants with certain viruses, bacteria, or fungi has been shown to induce persistent, systemic resistance to a wide range of diseases caused by diverse pathogens. The non-specificity of this response has fueled speculation that it may also affect plant suitability for arthropod herbivores, and there is limited evidence, mainly from work with tobacco, which suggests that this may indeed occur. Young cucumber plants were immunized by restricted infection of a lower leaf with tobacco necrosis virus (TNV), and upper leaves were later challenged with anthracnose fungus, Colletotrichum lagenarium, to confirm induction of systemic resistance to a different pathogen. The response of arthropod herbivores was simultaneously measured on non-infected, systemically protected leaves of the same plants. As has been reported before, immunization with TNV gave a high degree of protection from C. lagenarium, reducing the number of lesions and the area of fungal necrosis by 65–93%. However, there was no systemic effect on population growth of twospotted spider mites, Tetranychus urticae Koch, on upper leaves, nor did restricted TNV infection of leaf tissue on one side of the mid-vein systemically affect mite performance on the opposite, virus-free side of the leaf. Similarly, there were no effects on growth rate, pupal weight, or survival when fall armyworm larvae were reared on systemically protected leaves from induced plants. In free-choice tests, greenhouse whiteflies oviposited indiscriminately on induced and control plants. Feeding preference of fall armyworms was variable, but striped cucumber beetles consistently fed more on induced than on control plants. There was no increase in levels of cucurbitacins, however, in systemically-protected foliage of induced plants. These findings indicate that pathogen-activated induced resistance of cucumber is unlikely to provide significant protection from herbivory. The mechanisms and specificity of induced resistance in cucurbits apparently differ in response to induction by pathogens or herbivores.     

Induction of Systemic Resistance to Tobacco Powdery Mildew by Tobacco Mosaic Virus, Tobacco Necrosis Virus or Ethephon

Local infections of either TMV or TNV in tobacco plants cv. Havana 425 (hypersensitive to TMV) proved effective in inducing systemic resistance to subsequent inoculation with the powdery mildew fungus Erysiphe cichoracearum DC. The proportion of leaf surface invaded by this pathogen and the amount of conidia it produced were both significantly lower in virus inoculated plants than in non-inoculated controls. However, the decrease in sporulation rate was less regularly observed than the reduction in leaf area infected. TMV was more effective than TNV in protecting tobacco plants from powdery mildew. E. cichoracearum is thus added to the list of challenge pathogens to which TMV or TNV are known to induce resistance in the host plants. Necrotic lesions caused to the leaves by local treatment with Ethephon (an ethylene-releasing compound) also conferred to tobacco some degree of systemic resistance to the same fungal pathogen, more frequently visible as a reduction of leaf area invaded. The protection due to the Ethephon lesions was in present experiments less marked than that of TMV. No effects against subsequent powdery mildew infection were obtained when point freeze necrotic lesions were provoked on the plants.     

Tobacco plants epigenetically suppressed in phenylalanine ammonia-lyase expression do not develop systemic acquired resistance in response to infection by tobacco mosaic virus

The response of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Xanthinc) plants, epigenetically suppressed for phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (PAL) activity, was studied following infection by tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). These plants contain a bean PAL2 transgene in the sense orientation, and have reduced endogenous tobacco PAL mRNA and suppressed production of phenylpropanoid products. Lesions induced by TMV infection of PAL-suppressed plants are markedly different in appearance from those induced on control plants that have lost the bean transgene through segregation, with a reduced deposition of phenofics. However, they develop at the same rate as on control tobacco, and pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins are induced normally upon primary infection. The levels of free salicylic acid (SA) produced in primary inoculated leaves of PAL-suppressed plants are approximately fourfold lower than in control plants after 84 h, and a similar reduction is observed in systemic leaves. PR proteins are not induced in systemic leaves of PAL-suppressed plants, and secondary infection with TMV does not result in the restriction of lesion size and number seen in control plants undergoing systemic acquired resistance (SAR). In grafting experiments between wild-type and PAL-suppressed tobacco, the SAR response can be transmitted from a PAL-suppressed root-stock, but SAR is not observed if the scion is PAL-suppressed. This indicates that, even if SA is the systemic signal for establishment of SAR, the amount of pre-existing phenylpropanoid compounds in systemic leaves, or the ability to synthesize further phenylpropanoids in response to the systemic signal, may be important for the establishment of SAR. Treatment of PAL-suppressed plants with dichloro-isonicotinic acid (INA) induces PR protein expression and SAR against subsequent TMV infection. However, treatment with SA, while inducing PR proteins, only partially restores SAR, further suggesting that de novo synthesis of SA, and/or the presence or synthesis of other phenylpropanoids, is required for expression of resistance in systemic leaves.     

Virus Infection of Forest Trees by Mechanical Transmission

Abstract Back transmission trials on young forest plants with isolates of purified viruses from the same tree species were performed using different inoculation techniques. Spruce seedlings and willow plants were successfully infected with tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) by the conventional method of mechanical inoculation of virus suspension mixed with celite as abrasive. Cherry leaf roll virus (CLRV) was transmitted to birches only after adding poly-L-orithine (PLO) to the inoculum. The same method was successful with brome mosaic virus (BMV) on beech seedlings. PLO also improved the rate of infection on TNV in willows. In only one case, was CLRV transmitted conventionally to a white ash seedling. The infection of white ash was increased when frozen powders, of infected ash leaves were directly rubbed onto leaves. BMV could not be transmitted to beech seedlings by carborundum pressure-inoculation. Stem slashing-inoculation of BMV and CLRV was successful with CLRV in one beech out of 60 seedlings.     

Pathogen-associated molecular pattern recognition rather than development of tissue necrosis contributes to bacterial induction of systemic acquired resistance in Arabidopsis

Systemic acquired resistance (SAR) is usually described as a phenomenon whereby localized inoculation with a necrotizing pathogen renders a plant more resistant to subsequent pathogen infection. Here we show that Pseudomonas syringae strains for which Arabidopsis thaliana represents a non-host plant systemically elevate resistance although the underlying interactions neither trigger a hypersensitive response nor cause necrotic disease symptoms. A similar enhancement of systemic resistance was observed when elicitor-active preparations of two typical bacterial pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs), flagellin and lipopolysaccharides (LPS), were applied in a localized manner. Several lines of evidence indicate that the observed systemic resistance responses are identical to SAR. Localized applications of non-adapted bacteria, flagellin or LPS elevate levels of the SAR regulatory metabolite salicylic acid (SA) and pathogenesis-related (PR) gene expression not only in treated but also in distant leaves. All treatments also systemically increase expression of the SAR marker gene FLAVIN-DEPENDENT MONOOXYGENASE 1. Further, a whole set of SAR-deficient Arabidopsis lines, including mutants in SA biosynthesis and signalling, are impaired in establishing the systemic resistance response triggered by non-host bacteria or PAMPs. We also show that the magnitude of defence reactions such as SA accumulation, PR gene expression or camalexin accumulation induced at sites of virulent or avirulent P. syringae inoculation but not the extent of tissue necrosis during these interactions determines the extent of SAR in distant leaves. Our data indicate that PAMPs significantly contribute to SAR initiation in Arabidopsis and that tissue necroses at inoculation sites are dispensable for SAR activation.     

Transport of Salicylic Acid in Tobacco Necrosis Virus-Infected Cucumber Plants

The transport of salicylic acid (SA) was studied in cucumber (Cucumis sativus L.) using 14C-labeled benzoic acid that was injected in the cotyledons at the time of inoculation. Primary inoculation with tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) on the cotyledons led to an induction of systemic resistance of the first primary leaf above the cotyledon against Colletotrichum lagenarium as early as 3 d after inoculation. [14C]SA was detected in the phloem or in the first leaf 2 d after TNV inoculation, whereas [14C]benzoic acid was not detected in the phloem during the first 3 d after TNV inoculation of the cotyledons, indicating phloem transport of [14C]SA from cotyledon. In leaf 1, the specific activity of [14C]SA decreased between 1.7 and 8.6 times compared with the cotyledons, indicating that, in addition to transport, leaf 1 also produced more SA. The amount of SA transported after TNV infection of the cotyledon was 9 to 160 times higher than in uninfected control plants. Thus, SA can be transported to leaf 1 before the development of systemic acquired resistance, and SA accumulation in leaf 1 results both from transport from the cotyledon and from synthesis in leaf 1.     

Induction of resistance in Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv. Lima against some soil-borne fungal pathogens by pre-inoculation with tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) reacting hypersensitivity

Abstract

Tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) was tested to induce systemic acquired resistance (SAR) in Phaseolus vulgaris cv. Lima against three important soil-borne fungal pathogens viz: Rhizoctonia solani, Macrophomina phaseolina and Fusarium oxysporum. Application of TNV as a local infection of seven-day old primary leaves of Phaseolus vulgaris cv. Lima resulted in reduction of the mean disease rating of root-rot and damping-off caused by the tested fungal pathogens. The pre-inoculated plants with TNV showed a significant enhancement in their content of photosynthetic pigments (chlorophyll a, b and carotenoids) compared to those inoculated with fungal pathogens only. The percentage of cell membrane stability and ion leakage of viral-treated plants were significantly increased confirming the healthy cytological status of the treated plants. Results demonstrated that inoculation of the primary leaves of beans with TNV before infection with the fungal pathogens leads to changes in protein patterns and showed differences compared with control and caused the appearance of at least one new protein band compared with only fungal-infected plants. Also, an increase in peroxidase activity emerged in the thickness of the isozymic pattern in addition to the synthesis of new bands which was observed as a result of TNV application before infection with the three fungal pathogens. Induction of the synthesis of a new protein and increasing peroxidase activity in the inoculated plants enhanced the defense system against the target pathogen. The results greatly supported the successful application of TNV in the induction of systemic acquired resistance in P. vulgaris cv. Lima against the fungal pathogens.     

PeaT1-induced systemic acquired resistance in tobacco follows salicylic acid-dependent pathway

Systemic acquired resistance (SAR) is an inducible defense mechanism which plays a central role in protecting plants from pathogen attack. A new elicitor, PeaT1 from Alternaria tenuissima, was expressed in Escherichia coil and characterized with systemic acquired resistance to tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). PeaT1-treated plants exhibited enhanced systemic resistance with a significant reduction in number and size of TMV lesions on wild tobacco leaves as compared with control. The quantitative analysis of TMV CP gene expression with real-time quantitative PCR showed there was reduction in TMV virus concentration after PeaT1 treatment. Similarly, peroxidase (POD) activity and lignin increased significantly after PeaT1 treatment. The real-time quantitative PCR revealed that PeaT1 also induced the systemic accumulation of pathogenesis-related gene, PR-1a and PR-1b which are the markers of systemic acquired resistance (SAR), NPR1 gene for salicylic acid (SA) signal transduction pathway and PAL gene for SA synthesis. The accumulation of SA and the failure in development of similar level of resistance as in wild type tobacco plants in PeaT1 treated nahG transgenic tobacco plants indicated that PeaT1-induced resistance depended on SA accumulation. The present work suggested that the molecular mechanism of PeaT1 inducing disease resistance in tobacco was likely through the systemic acquired resistance pathway mediated by salicylic acid and the NPR1 gene.     

Acquired Resistance in Hypersensitive Tobacco Operates by Limiting Cell-to-Cell Spread of Virus Infection without Affecting Virus Multiplication

Localized and systemic acquired resistance against tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) or tobacco necrosis virus was induced when local lesions were produced in leaves of Xanthi-nc tobacco by mechanical inoculation with TMV. Both types of resistance were characterized by reduction in the size of lesions produced by the challenging viruses, whereas accumulation of viral antigen in lesions was slightly increased. These results, confirming previous findings relative to other hypersensitive plant virus combinations, do not support the view that an inhibitor of virus replication operates in the resistant tissues, but indicate that both types of resistance operate only against cell-to-cell spread of virus.     

Local and systemic spread of tobacco mosaic virus in transgenic tobacco.

Expression of a chimeric gene encoding the coat protein (CP) of tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) in transgenic tobacco plants confers resistance to infection by TMV. We investigated the spread of TMV within the inoculated leaf and throughout the plant following inoculation. Plants that expressed the CP gene [CP(+)] and those that did not [CP(-)] accumulated equivalent amounts of virus in the inoculated leaves after inoculation with TMV-RNA, but the CP(+) plants showed a delay in the development of systemic symptoms and reduced virus accumulation in the upper leaves. Tissue printing experiments demonstrated that if TMV infection became systemic, spread of virus occurred in the CP(+) plants essentially as it occurred in the CP(-) plants although at a reduced rate. Through a series of grafting experiments, we showed that stem tissue with a leaf attached taken from CP(+) plants prevented the systemic spread of virus. Stem tissue without a leaf had no effect on TMV spread. All of these findings indicate that protection against systemic spread in CP(+) plants is caused by one or more mechanisms that, in correlation with the protection against initial infection upon inoculation, result in a phenotype of resistance to TMV.     

Ultrastructural studies of plasmodesmatal and vascular translocation of tobacco rattle virus (TRV) in tobacco and potato

The studies focus on an ultrastructural analysis of the phenomenon of intercellular and systemic (vascular) transport of tobacco rattle virus (TRV) in tissues of the infected plants. TRV is a dangerous pathogen of cultivated and ornamental plants due to its wide range of plant hosts and continuous transmission by vectors—ectoparasitic nematodes. Two weeks after infection with the PSG strain of TRV, tobacco plants of the Samsun variety and potato plants of the Glada variety responded with spot surface necroses on inoculated leaf blades. Four weeks after the infection a typical systemic response was observed on tobacco and potato leaves, necroses on stems and lesions referred to as corky ringspot. Ultrastructural analysis revealed the presence of two types of TRV virions: capsidated and non-capsidated forms in tobacco and potato tissues. In the protoplast area, viral particles either occurred in a dispersed form or they formed organised inclusions of virions. We demonstrated for the first time the presence of non-capsidated-type TRV in the vicinity of and inside plasmodesmata. Capsidated particles of TRV were observed in intercellular spaces of the tissues of aboveground and underground organs. Expanded apoplast area was noted at the cell wall, with numerous dispersed non-capsidated-type TRV particles. These phenomena suggest active intercellular transport. Our ultrastructure studies showed for the first time that xylem can be a possible route of TRV systemic transport. We demonstrated that both capsidated and non-capsidated virions, of varied length, participate in long-distance transport. TRV virions were more often documented in xylem (tracheary elements and parenchyma) than in phloem. Non-capsidated TRV particles were observed inside tracheary elements in a dispersed form and in regular arrangements in potato and tobacco xylem. The presence of TRV virions inside the bordered pits was demonstrated in aboveground organs and in the root of the tested plants. We documented that both forms of TRV virions can be transported systemically via tracheary elements of xylem.     

Peroxidase Activity and Isoperoxidase Pattern in Tobacco Leaves Infected with Tobacco Necrosis Virus and Other Viruses Inducing Necrotic and Non-Necrotic Alterations

The level of peroxidase activity was greatly enhanced in tobacco leaves infected by tobacco necrosis virus (TNV) and other viruses which induce necrotic symptoms (TMV, ToMV and PVY^N). The intensity was related to the age of the leaves infected: absent or neglible in mature leaves and very pronounced in young growing infected leaves. On the contrary, changes in peroxidase activity were negligible when the infection was provoked by viruses which do not produce necrotic reactions (TMV and PVY^O). Analysis of the peroxidase isoenzymes, pattern in tobacco leaves infected by TNV and other necrosis-inducing viruses revealed in all cases, a slight increase in anionic (pl 3.5–3.7) and a considerable increase in moderately anionic isoenzymes particularly the pl 4.6 isoenzyme which in TNV and PVY^N-infected leaves reached levels up to 21 and 72 times the healthy control values. A considerable increase in the cationic (pl9.3–8.8) isoenzymes and the appearance of one moderately cationic isoenzyme (pl 8.2) was also detected. In leaf extracts from-virus-infected tobacco leaves with nonnecrotic response, no, or negligible alterations on the isoenzyme pattern were detected. However, infection by a fungal parasite (Erisyphe cichoracearum), which established a fully compatible, non-necrotic, interaction with tobacco leaves, like the necrosis-inducing viruses, changed the isoperoxidase pattern. The data suggest the necrotic alterations and associated changes in the peroxidase activity and isoperoxidase pattern in virus-infected leaves are not clearly related.     

A new multigene family inducible by tobacco mosaic virus or salicylic acid in tobacco.

A previously undescribed cDNA family was isolated from tobacco challenged with tobacco mosaic virus (TMV). A cDNA library was constructed with mRNA from upper leaves of Xanthi nc tobacco plants that had been inoculated with TMV on the lower leaves 11 days previously. The library was screened differentially with radiolabeled cDNA synthesized with mRNA from upper, uninoculated leaves of either TMV-inoculated or mock-inoculated tobacco plants. The new cDNA family, designated SAR8.2, had at least five expressed members, one or more of which were inducible by TMV inoculation and by salicylic acid treatment. The cDNAs encoded small, highly basic proteins containing N-terminal hydrophobic signal peptides and highly conserved cysteine-rich C-terminal domains. One of the SAR8.2 family members contained a direct repeat of the C-terminal domain in tandem. Hybridization of SAR8.2 cDNA to tobacco genomic DNAs indicated a gene family of 10-12 members.     

Transiently expressed short hairpin RNA targeting 126 kDa protein of tobacco mosaic virus interferes with virus infection

RNA-interference (RNAi) silences gene expression by'guiding mRNA degradation in asequence-specific fashion.Small interfering RNA (siRNA),an intermediate of the RNAi pathway,has beenshown to be very effective in inhibiting virus infection in mammalian cells and cultured plant cells.Here,wereport that Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transient expression of short hairpin RNA (shRNA) couldinhibit tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA accumulation by targeting the gene encoding the replication-asso-ciated 126 kDa protein in intact plant tissue.Our results indicate that transiently expressed shRNA efficientlyinterfered with TMV infection.The interference observed is sequence-specific,and time-and site-dependent.Transiently expressed shRNA corresponding to the TMV 126 kDa protein gene did not inhibit cucumbermosaic virus (CMV),an unrelated tobamovirus.In order to interfere with TMV accumulation in tobaccoleaves,it is essential for the shRNA constructs to be infiltrated into the same leaves as TMV inoculation.Ourresults support the view that RNAi opens the door for novel therapeutic procedures against virus diseases.We propose that a combination of the RNAi technique and Agrobacterium-mediated transient expressioncould be employed as a potent antiviral treatment in plants.     

Is Salicylic Acid a Translocated Signal of Systemic Acquired Resistance in Tobacco?

Salicylic acid (SA) is a likely endogenous signal in the development of systemic acquired resistance (SAR) in some dicotyledonous plants. In tobacco mosaic virus (TMV)-resistant Xanthi-nc tobacco, SA levels increase systemically following the inoculation of a single leaf with TMV. To determine the extent to which systemic increases in SA result from SA export from the inoculated leaf, SA produced in TMV-inoculated or healthy leaves was noninvasively labeled with 18O2. Spatial and temporal distribution of 18O-SA indicated that most of the SA detected in the healthy tissues was synthesized in the inoculated leaf. No significant increase in the activity of benzoic acid 2-hydroxylase, the last enzyme involved in SA biosynthesis, was detected in upper uninoculated leaves, although the basal level of enzyme activity was relatively high. No increases in SA level, pathogenesis-related PR-1 gene expression, or TMV resistance in the upper uninoculated leaf were observed if the TMV-inoculated leaf was detached up to 60 hr after inoculation. Apart from the inoculated tissues, the highest increase in SA was observed in the leaf located directly above the inoculated leaf. The systemic SA increase observed during SAR may be explained by phloem transport of SA from the inoculation sites.     

Systemic Infection of Tobacco by Pepper Veinal Mottle Potyvirus (PVMV) Depends on the Presence of Potato Virus Y (PVY)

In single inoculations, both PVY and PVMV replicated in inoculated leaves of Nicotiana tabacum cv. ‘Xanthi nc’ plants, but only PVY infected the tobacco plants systemically, whereas PVMV caused localized infection. A mixed infection by the PVY-To72 and PVMV-type strains was experimentally realized in ‘Xanthi nc’ plants. In the presence of PVY, PVMV migrated systemically into the upper leaves of the tobacco plant, as was proved by back inoculation. It would appear that in tobacco, PVY acts as a “helper” virus, providing PVMV with the necessary component factor for migration. In extracts from the co–infected leaves. Immune Electron Microscopy (IEM) revealed phenotypic mixed particles which contained a mixture of coat proteins of PVY and PVMV. The role of the structural and functional interactions between the two viruses, which enable PVMV to migrate systemically in tobacco plants, is discussed.     

Characterization of tobacco plants expressing a bacterial salicylate hydroxylase gene

Transgenic tobacco plants that express the bacterial nahG gene encoding salicylate hydroxylase have been shown to accumulate very little salicylic acid and to be defective in their ability to induce systemic acquired resistance (SAR). In recent experiments using transgenic NahG tobacco and Arabidopsis plants, we have also demonstrated that salicylic acid plays a central role in both disease susceptibility and genetic resistance. In this paper, we further characterize tobacco plants that express the salicylate hydroxylase enzyme. We show that tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) inoculation of NahG tobacco leaves induces the accumulation of the nahG mRNA in the pathogen infected leaves, presumably due to enhanced stabilization of the bacterial mRNA. SAR-associated genes are expressed in the TMV-infected leaves, but this is localized to the area surrounding necrotic lesions. Localized acquired resistance (LAR) is not induced in the TMV-inoculated NahG plants suggesting that LAR, like SAR, is dependent on SA accumulation. When SA is applied to nahG-expressing leave's SAR gene expression does not result. We have confirmed earlier reports that the salicylate hydroxylase enzyme has a narrow substrate specificity and we find that catechol, the breakdown product of salicylic acid, neither induces acquired resistance nor prevents the SA-dependent induction of the SAR genes.