The influence of mechanical loading on osseointegration: an animal study

Osseointegration of implant provides a stable support for the prosthesis under functional loads. The timing of loading is a critical parameter that can govern the success of the osseointegration of implant. However, it is not clear whether the early loading can affect the success of osseointegration, or whether the no-loading healing period can be shortened. This paper presents an animal study conducted to investigate how external loads influence the osseointegration at the initial stage of healing. Titanium implants were inserted into the goat tibia laterally, and different axial loadings were applied to the implants in 4 weeks after surgery. After the 2 weeks period of early loading, animals were sacrificed and the tibia bones with the implants were cut off from the bodies. Then mechanical test was employed to find out the differences in the pull-out force, and shear strength at the bone-implant interface between the non-loaded and the loaded implants. The implant-bone interfaces were analyzed by histomorphometric method, SEM (scanning electron micrograph) and EDS (energy density spectrum). The results indicated that the bone-implant interface did not well integrate 4 weeks after surgery, and the fibrous tissue could be found at the interfaces of the specimens without loadings. While the results of loaded specimens with 10 N axial force showed that that parts of the interface were well integrated, indicating that the early mild loading may play a positive role in the process of the osseointegration. The results support that a certain range of external loading would influence the process of osseointegration, and appropriate mechanical loading can be applied to shorten the osseointegration period after surgery. Supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 30370376, 10529202 and 10672015).     

A finite element analysis of the vibration behaviour of a cementless hip system

An early diagnosis of aseptic loosening of a total hip replacement (THR) by plain radiography, scintigraphy or arthography has been shown to be less reliable than using a vibration technique. However, it has been suggested that it may be possible to distinguish between a secure and a loose prosthesis using a vibration technique. In fact, vibration analysis methods have been successfully used to assess dental implant stability, to monitor fracture healing and to measure bone mechanical properties. Several studies have combined the vibration technique with the finite element (FE) method in order to better understand the events involved in the experimental technique. In the present study, the main goal is to simulate the change in the resonance frequency during the osseointegration process of a cementless THR (Zweymüller). The FE method was used and a numerical modal analysis was conducted to obtain the natural frequencies and mode shapes under vibration. The effects were studied of different bone and stem material properties, and different contact conditions at the bone–implant interface. The results were in agreement with previous experimental and computational observations, and differences among the different cases studied were detected. As the osseointegration process at the bone–implant interface evolved, the resonance frequency values of the femur–prosthesis system also increased. In summary, vibration analysis combined with the FE method was able to detect different boundary conditions at the bone–implant interface in cases of both osseointegration and loosening.     

Modeling the debonding process of osseointegrated implants due to coupled adhesion and friction

Cementless implants have become widely used for total hip replacement surgery. The long-term stability of these implants is achieved by bone growing around and into the rough surface of the implant, a process called osseointegration. However, debonding of the bone–implant interface can still occur due to aseptic implant loosening and insufficient osseointegration, which may have dramatic consequences. The aim of this work is to describe a new 3D finite element frictional contact formulation for the debonding of partially osseointegrated implants. The contact model is based on a modified Coulomb friction law by Immel et al. (2020), that takes into account the tangential debonding of the bone-implant interface. This model is extended in the direction normal to the bone-implant interface by considering a cohesive zone model, to account for adhesion phenomena in the normal direction and for adhesive friction of partially bonded interfaces. The model is applied to simulate the debonding of an acetabular cup implant. The influence of partial osseointegration and adhesive effects on the long-term stability of the implant is assessed. The influence of different patient- and implant-specific parameters such as the friction coefficient \(\mu _\text {b}\), the trabecular Young’s modulus \(E_\text {b}\), and the interference fit \(I\!F\) is also analyzed, in order to determine the optimal stability for different configurations. Furthermore, this work provides guidelines for future experimental and computational studies that are necessary for further parameter calibration.

     

Stress transfer properties of different commercial dental implants: a finite element study

Dental implantology has high success rates, and a suitable estimation of how stresses are transferred to the surrounding bone sheds insight into the correct design of implant features. In this study, we estimate stress transfer properties of four commercial implants (GMI, Lifecore, Intri and Avinent) that differ significantly in macroscopic geometry. Detailed three-dimensional finite element models were adopted to analyse the behaviour of the bone-implant system depending on the geometry of the implant (two different diameters) and the bone-implant interface condition. Occlusal static forces were applied and their effects on the bone, implant and bone-implant interface were evaluated. Large diameters avoided overload-induced bone resorption. Higher stresses were obtained with a debonded bone-implant interface. Relative micromotions at the bone-implant interface were within the limits required to achieve a good osseointegration. We anticipate that the methodology proposed may be a useful tool for a quantitative and qualitative comparison between different commercial dental implants.     

Simulation of impact test for determining "health" of percutaneous bone anchored implants

There is an ongoing requirement for a clinically relevant, noninvasive technique to monitor the integrity of percutaneous implants used for dental restorations, bone-anchored hearing aids, and to retain extra-oral prostheses (ear, eye, nose, etc). Because of the limitations of conventional diagnostic techniques (CT, MRI), mechanical techniques that measure the dynamic response of the implant-abutment system are being developed. This paper documents a finite element analysis that simulates a transient response to mechanical impact testing using contact elements. The detailed model allows for a specific interface between the implant and bone and characterizes potential clinical situations including loss of bone margin height, loss of osseointegration, and development of a soft connective tissue layer at the bone-implant interface. The results also show that the expected difference in interface stiffness between soft connective tissue and osseointegrated bone will cause easily measurable changes in the response of the implant/abutment system. With respect to the loss of bone margin height, changes in the order of 0.2 mm should be detectable, suggesting that this technique is at least as sensitive as radiography. A partial loss of osseointegration, while not being as readily evident as a bone margin loss, would still be detectable for losses as small as 0.5 mm.     

Use of micro-CT-based finite element analysis to accurately quantify peri-implant bone strains: a validation in rat tibiae

Although research has been addressed at investigating the effect of specific loading regimes on bone response around the implant, a precise quantitative understanding of the local mechanical response close to the implant site is still lacking. This study was aimed at validating micro-CT-based finite element (μFE) models to assess tissue strains after implant placement in a rat tibia. Small implants were inserted at the medio-proximal site of 8 rat tibiae. The limbs were subjected to axial compression loading; strain close to the implant was measured by means of strain gauges. Specimen-specific μFE models were created and analyzed. For each specimen, 4 different models were created corresponding to different representations of the bone–implant interface: bone and implant were assumed fully osseointegrated (A); a low stiffness interface zone was assumed with thickness of 40 μm (B), 80 μm (C), and 160 μm (D). In all cases, measured and computational strains correlated highly (R ² = 0.95, 0.92, 0.93, and 0.95 in A, B, C, and D, respectively). The averaged calculated strains were 1.69, 1.34, and 1.15 times higher than the measured strains for A, B, and C, respectively, and lower than the experimental strains for D (factor = 0.91). In conclusion, we demonstrated that specimen-specific FE analyses provide accurate estimates of peri-implant bone strains in the rat tibia loading model. Further investigations of the bone-implant interface are needed to quantify implant osseointegration.     

A bone preservation protocol that enables evaluation of osseointegration of implants with micro- and nanotextured surfaces

Development of surface treatments has enabled secure attachment of dental implants in less than 1 month. Consequently, it is necessary to characterize accurately the osseointegration of the implant surface in the region of the bone-implant contact (BIC). We developed a method for sample preparation that preserves both bone and BIC to permit analysis of the contact interface. We prepared eight nanotextured implants and implanted them in rabbit tibias. After healing for 30 days, outcomes were analyzed using both our bone preservation protocol and routine decalcification followed by preparation of histological sections stained by hematoxylin and eosin (H & E). Pull-out tests for implant osseointegration were performed after healing. Non-implanted samples of rabbit mandible were used as a control for assessing organic and mineralized bone characteristics and bone structure. Our bone preservation protocol enabled evaluation of many of the same bone characteristics as histological sections stained with H & E. Our protocol enables analysis of implant samples, implant surfaces and osseointegration without risk of BIC damage.     

Micromotion-induced peri-prosthetic fluid flow around a cementless femoral stem

Micromotion-induced interstitial fluid flow at the bone-implant interface has been proposed to play an important role in aseptic loosening of cementless implants. High fluid velocities are thought to promote aseptic loosening through activation of osteoclasts, shear stress induced control of mesenchymal stem cells differentiation, or transport of molecules. In this study, our objectives were to characterize and quantify micromotion-induced fluid flow around a cementless femoral stem using finite element modeling. With a 2D model of the bone-implant interface and full-factorial design, we first evaluated the relative influence of material properties, and bone-implant micromotion and gap on fluid velocity. Transverse sections around a femoral stem were built from computed tomography images, while boundary conditions were obtained from experimental measurements on the same femur. In a second step, a 3D model was built from the same data-set to estimate the shear stress experienced by cells hosted in the peri-implant tissues. The full-factorial design analysis showed that local micromotion had the most influence on peak fluid velocity at the interface. Remarkable variations in fluid velocity were observed in the macrostructures at the surface of the implant in the 2D transverse sections of the stem. The 3D model predicted peak fluid velocities extending up to 2.2 mm/s in the granulation tissue and to 3.9 mm/s in the trabecular bone. Peak shear stresses on the cells hosted in these tissues ranged from 0.1 to 12.5 Pa. These results offer insight into mechanical stimuli encountered at the bone-implant interface.     

Biomaterial osseointegration enhancement with biophysical stimulation

Despite the ongoing improvement in implant characteristics, bone intrinsic potential for regeneration may be stimulated with adjuvant therapies to standard surgical procedures, as it is important to achieve the best possible implant osseointegration into the adjacent bone and to ensure therefore long-term implant stability. For this purpose various pharmacological, biological or biophysical modalities have been developed, such as bone grafting materials, pharmacological agents, growth factors and bone morphogenetic proteins. Biophysical stimulation of osseointegration includes two non-invasive and safe methods that have been initially developed to enhance fracture healing: pulsed electromagnetic fields (PEMFs) and lowintensity ultrasounds (LIPUS), for which most studies confirm their beneficial effects. The present paper is an overview of bone-implant osseointegration and the current trends on its enhancement, focusing mainly on the two methods of biophysical stimulation.     

Mechanisms of reduced implant stability in osteoporotic bone

The determining factors for the fixation of uncemented screws in bone are the bone-implant interface and the peri-implant bone. The goal of this work was to explore the role of the peri-implant bone architecture on the mechanics of the bone-implant system. In particular, the specific aims of the study were to investigate: (i) the impact of the different architectural parameters, (ii) the effects of disorder, and (iii) the deformations in the peri-implant region. A three-dimensional beam lattice model to describe trabecular bone was developed. Various microstructural features of the lattice were varied in a systematic way. Implant pull-out tests were simulated, and the stiffness and strength of the bone-implant system were computed. The results indicated that the strongest decrease in pull-out strength was obtained by trabecular thinning, whereas pull-out stiffness was mostly affected by trabecular removal. These findings could be explained by investigating the peri-implant deformation field. For small implant displacements, a large amount of trabeculae in the peri-implant region were involved in the load transfer from implant to bone. Therefore, trabecular removal in this region had a strong negative effect on pull-out stiffness. Conversely, at higher displacements, deformations mainly localized in the trabeculae in contact with the implant; hence, thinning those trabeculae produced the strongest decrease in the strength of the system. Although idealized, the current approach is helpful for a mechanical understanding of the role played by peri-implant bone.     

Influence of custom-made implant designs on the biomechanical performance for the case of immediate post-extraction placement in the maxillary esthetic zone: a finite element analysis

Due to the increasing adoption of immediate implantation strategies and the rapid development of the computer aided design/computer aided manufacturing technology, a therapeutic concept based on patient-specific implant dentistry has recently been reintroduced by many researchers. However, little information is available on the designs of custom-made dental implant systems, especially their biomechanical behavior. The influence of the custom-made implant designs on the biomechanical performance for both an immediate and a delayed loading protocol in the maxillary esthetic zone was evaluated by means of the finite element (FE) method. FE models of three dental implants were considered: a state of the art cylindrical implant and two custom-made implants designed by reverse engineering technology, namely a root-analogue implant and a root-analogue threaded implant. The von Mises stress distributions and micro-motions around the bone-implant interfaces were calculated using ANSYS software. In a comparison of the three implant designs for both loading protocols, a favorable biomechanical performance was observed for the use of root-analogue threaded implant which approximated the geometry of natural anterior tooth and maintained the original long-axis. The results indicated that bone-implant interfacial micro-motion was reduced and a favorable stress distribution after osseointegration was achieved.     

Primary stability of an anatomical cementless hip stem: a statistical analysis

The primary stability that the surgeon can achieve during surgery is a determinant of the clinical success of cementless implants. Thus, estimating what level of primary stability can be obtained with a new design is an important aspect of pre-clinical evaluation. The primary stability of a cementless hip stem is not only affected by the implant design, but also by other factors such as the mechanical quality of the host bone, the presence of gaps around the bone-implant interface, the body weight of the patient, and the size of the implant. Even the most extensive experimental study can only explore a small sub-set of all possible combinations found in vivo. To overcome this limitation, we propose a combination of experimental and numerical methods. The primary stability of a cementless anatomical stem is assessed in vitro. A finite element model is developed to accurately replicate the same experiment. The model is then parameterised over the various factors that affect the primary stability, and used in a Monte Carlo scheme to assess the primary stability over a simulated population. In this study, the method was used to investigate the mechanical stability of an anatomical cementless stem over more than 1000 simulated cases. Twenty cases were found macroscopically unstable, due to a combination of unfavourable conditions. The rest of the Monte Carlo sample showed on average a peak micromotion under stair climbing loading of 206 +/- 159 microm. The proposed method can be used to evaluate new designs in conditions more representative of the variability in clinical practice.     

Bone remodelling around a cementless glenoid component

Post-operative change in the mechanical loading of bone may trigger its (mechanically induced) adaptation and hamper the mechanical stability of prostheses. This is especially important in cementless components, where the final fixation is achieved by the bone itself. The aim of this study is, first, to gain insight into the bone remodelling process around a cementless glenoid component, and second, to compare the possible bone adaptation when the implant is assumed to be fully bonded (best case scenario) or completely loose (worst case scenario). 3D finite element models of a scapula with and without a cementless glenoid component were created. 3D geometry of the scapula, material properties, and several physiological loading conditions were acquired from or estimated for a specific cadaver. Update of the bone density after implantation was done according to a node-based bone remodelling scheme. Strain energy density for different loading conditions was evaluated, weighted according to their frequencies in activities of daily life and used as a mechanical stimulus for bone adaptation. The average bone density in the glenoid increased after implantation. However, local bone resorption was significant in some regions next to the bone-implant interface, regardless of the interface condition (bonded or loose). The amount of bone resorption was determined by the condition imposed to the interface, being slightly larger when the interface was loose. An ideal screw, e.g. in which material fatigue was not considered, was enough to keep the interface micromotions small and constant during the entire bone adaptation simulation.     

Development and experimental validation of a finite element model of total ankle replacement

Total ankle replacement remains a less satisfactory solution compared to other joint replacements. The goal of this study was to develop and validate a finite element model of total ankle replacement, for future testing of hypotheses related to clinical issues. To validate the finite element model, an experimental setup was specifically developed and applied on 8 cadaveric tibias. A non-cemented press fit tibial component of a mobile bearing prosthesis was inserted into the tibias. Two extreme anterior and posterior positions of the mobile bearing insert were considered, as well as a centered one. An axial force of 2 kN was applied for each insert position. Strains were measured on the bone surface using digital image correlation. Tibias were CT scanned before implantation, after implantation, and after mechanical tests and removal of the prosthesis. The finite element model replicated the experimental setup. The first CT was used to build the geometry and evaluate the mechanical properties of the tibias. The second CT was used to set the implant position. The third CT was used to assess the bone-implant interface conditions. The coefficient of determination (R-squared) between the measured and predicted strains was 0.91. Predicted bone strains were maximal around the implant keel, especially at the anterior and posterior ends. The finite element model presented here is validated for future tests using more physiological loading conditions.     

Effect of micromechanical stimulations on osteoblasts: development of a device simulating the mechanical situation at the bone-implant interface

Many experimental models have been developed to investigate the effects of mechanical stimulation of cells, but none of the existing devices can simulate micromotions at the cellular-mechanical interface with varying amplitudes and loads. Osteoblasts are sensitive to mechanical stimuli, so to study the bone-implant interface it would be important to quantify their reaction in a situation mimicking the mechanical situation arising at that interface. In this study, we present the development of a new device allowing the application of micromotions and load on cells in vitro. The new device allowed the cells to be stimulated with sinusoidal motions of amplitudes comprised between +/- 5 and +/- 50 microm, frequencies between 0.5 and 2 Hz, and loads between 50 and 1000 Pa. The device, with a total length of 20 cm, was designed to work in an incubator at 37 degrees C and 100% humidity. Expression of various bone important genes was monitored by real-time RT-PCR. Micromotions and load were shown to affect the behavior of osteoblasts by down-regulating the expression of genes necessary for the creation of organic extracellular matrix (collagen type I) as well as for genes involved in the mineralization process (osteocalcin, osteonectin). The developed device could then be used to simulate different mechanical situations at the bone-implant interface.     

Biomechanical analysis of the shear behaviour adjacent to an axially loaded implant

Good mechanical fixation of an implant to the surrounding bone is important for its longevity, and is influenced by both biological and mechanical factors. This study parametrically evaluates the mechanics of the interface with a computationally efficient analytic structural model of the shear stress field and global shear stiffness of an axially loaded implant. The utility of the analytic model was first established by validating its assumptions with a case-specific finite element model. We then used the analytic model for a sensitivity analysis of the relationship between the pattern of tissue growth and shear properties of the interface for our previously reported loaded in vivo experimental micromotion device. The bone located directly at the implant surface was found to be the most effective site for increasing interface stiffness. This suggests that the implant surface is the most desirable site for bone growth, yet is also the most mechanically challenging environment due to its maximal shear stresses. Thus, these findings support the further investigation of osteo-conductive coatings and other biological stimuli to overcome the challenging mechanics, and to promote bone growth directly at the implant surface. The model also demonstrated that the mechanical contribution to the global implant shear stiffness of a commonly observed isolated sclerotic bone rim is very limited. The results of this sensitivity analysis agree with experimental studies with the micromotion device, and with clinical studies reporting good results with osteo-conductive coatings.     

A histological and biomechanical study of bone stress and bone remodeling around immediately loaded implants

Immediate loading(IL)increases the risk of marginal bone loss.The present study investigated the biomechanical response of peri-implant bone in rabbits after IL,aiming at optimizing load management.Ninety-six implants were installed bilaterally into femurs of 48 rabbits.Test implants on the left side created the maximal initial stress of 6.9 and 13.4 MPa in peri-implant bone and unloaded implants on the contralateral side were controls.Bone morphology and bone-implant interface strength were measured with histological examination and push-out testing during a 12-week observation period.Additionally,the animal data were incorporated into finite element(FE)models to calculate the bone stress distribution at different levels of osseointegration.Results showed that the stress was concentrated in the bone margin and the bone stress gradually decreased as osseointegration proceeded.A stress of about 2.0 MPa in peri-implant bone had a positive effect on new bone formation,osseointegration and bone-implant interface strength.Bone loss was observed in some specimens with stress exceeding 4.0 MPa.Data indicate that IL significantly increases bone stress during the early postoperative period,but the load-bearing capacity of peri-implant bone increases rapidly with an increase of bone-implant contact.Favorable bone responses may be continually promoted when the stress in peri-implant bone is maintained at a definite level.Accordingly,the progressive loading mode is recommended for IL implants.     

A finite element comparison between the mechanical behaviour of rigid and resilient oral implants with respect to immediate loading

In this paper, a qualitative comparison between two types of dental implants with respect to their behaviour under immediate loading is presented. This analysis has been carried out using the finite element method. Since micromotions (and not the load) are responsible of the appearance of a fibrous interface avoiding osseointegration, the relative displacement between the bone surface and the implant has been the main variable analyzed at different loading states and for the two implant types here considered. The implants analyzed differ in their mechanical behavior: rigid or resilient. Their main difference lies in the joining between the different pieces that make up the dental system. While in the rigid implant all the pieces are screwed, in the resilient implant a relative displacement between the pieces is allowed, with the additional introduction of a silicone gasket that acts like the periodontal ligament. Both implants were considered with a similar geometry and under two different loading scenarios, one equivalent to the force of chewing applied to a molar and another which corresponds to a premolar. For the resilient implant, a hyperelastic behaviour for the silicone and contact conditions between the different mobile parts of the implant are considered. The displacements of the emerging-body in both designs are also compared with the values obtained by several authors. However, the results show that both implants fulfill the constraint of the immediate loading protocol. The micromotions of the resilient implant are lower to those of the rigid one, favouring therefore a good osseointegration process while keeping the stresses in the implant under admissible maximum values.     

On the mechanical stability of porous coated press fit titanium implants: a finite element study of a pushout test

Pushout tests can be used to estimate the shear strength of the bone implant interface. Numerous such experimental studies have been published in the literature. Despite this researchers are still some way off with respect to the development of accurate numerical models to simulate implant stability. In the present work a specific experimental pushout study from the literature was simulated using two different bones implant interface models. The implant was a porous coated Ti-6Al-4V retrieved 4 weeks postoperatively from a dog model. The purpose was to find out which of the interface models could replicate the experimental results using physically meaningful input parameters. The results showed that a model based on partial bone ingrowth (ingrowth stability) is superior to an interface model based on friction and prestressing due to press fit (initial stability). Even though the present study is limited to a single experimental setup, the authors suggest that the presented methodology can be used to investigate implant stability from other experimental pushout models. This would eventually enhance the much needed understanding of the mechanical response of the bone implant interface and help to quantify how implant stability evolves with time.     

Bone ingrowth into a porous coated implant predicted by a mechano-regulatory tissue differentiation algorithm

Bone ingrowth into a porous surface is one of the primary methods for fixation of orthopaedic implants. Improved understanding of bone formation and fixation of these devices should improve their performance and longevity. In this study predictions of bone ingrowth into an implant porous coating were investigated using mechano-reculatory models. The mechano-regulatory tissue differentiation algorithm proposed by Lacroix et al., and a modified version that enforces a tissue differentiation pathway by transitioning from differentiation to bone adaptation were investigated. The modified algorithm resulted in nearly the same behavior as the original algorithm when applied to a fracture-healing model. The algorithms were further compared using micromechanical finite element model of a beaded porous scaffold. Predictions of bone and fibrous tissue formation were compared between the two algorithms and to clinically observed phenomena. Under loading conditions corresponding to a press-fit hip stem, the modified algorithm predicted bone ingrowth into approximately 25% of the pore space, which is similar to that reported in experimental studies, while the original algorithm was unstable. When micromotion at the bone-implant interface was simulated, 20 mum of transverse displacement resulted in soft tissue formation at the bone-implant interface and minimal bone ingrowth. In contrast, 10 and 5 mum of micromotion resulted in bone filling 40% of the pore space and a stable interface, again consistent with clinical and experimental observations.