Animal-vegetal asymmetries influence the earliest steps in retina fate commitment in Xenopus.

An individual retina descends from a restricted and invariant group of nine animal blastomeres at the 32-cell stage. We tested which molecular signaling pathways are responsible for the competence of animal blastomeres to contribute to the retina. Inactivation of activin/Vg1 or fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signaling by expression of dominant-negative receptors does not prevent an animal blastomere from contributing to the retina. However, increasing bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) signaling in the retina-producing blastomeres significantly reduces their contribution. Conversely, reducing BMP signaling by expression of a dominant-negative BMP receptor or Noggin allows other animal blastomeres to contribute to the retina. Thus, the initial step in the retinal lineage is regulated by position within the BMP/Noggin field of epidermal versus neural induction. Vegetal tier blastomeres, in contrast, cannot contribute to the retina even when given access to the appropriate position and signaling fields by transplantation to the dorsal animal pole. We tested whether expression of molecules within the mesoderm inducing (activin, FGF), mesoderm-modifying (Wnt), or neural-inducing (BMP, Noggin) pathways impart a retinal fate on vegetal cell descendants. None of these, several of which induce secondary head structures, caused vegetal cells to contribute to retina. This was true even if the injected blastomeres were transplanted to the dorsal animal pole. Two pathways that specifically induce head tissues also were investigated. The simultaneous blockade of Wnt and BMP signaling, which results in the formation of a complete secondary axis with head and eyes, did not cause the vegetal clone to give rise to retina. However, Cerberus, a secreted protein that also induces an ectopic head with eyes, redirected vegetal progeny into the retina. These experiments indicate that vegetal blastomere incompetence to express a retinal fate is not due to a lack of components of known signaling pathways, but relies on a specific pathway of head induction.     

Two-step induction of primitive erythrocytes in Xenopus laevis embryos: signals from the vegetal endoderm and the overlying ectoderm

Primitive blood cells differentiate from the ventral mesoderm blood islands in Xenopus embryos. In order to determine the tissue interactions that propagate blood formation in early embryogenesis, we used embryos that had the ventral cytoplasm removed. These embryos gastrulated normally, formed a mesodermal layer and lacked axial structures, but displayed a marked enhancement of alpha-globin expression. Early ventral markers, such as msx-1, vent-1 and vent-2 were highly expressed at the gastrula stage, while a dorsal marker, goosecoid, was diminished. Several lines of experimental evidence demonstrate the critical role of animal pole-derived ectoderm in blood cell formation: 1) Mesoderm derived from dorsal blastomeres injected with beta-galactosidase mRNA (as a lineage tracer) expressed alpha-globin when interfaced with an animal pole-derived ectodermal layer; 2) Embryos in which the animal pole tissue had been removed by dissection at the blastula stage failed to express alpha-globin; 3) Exogastrulated embryos that lacked an interaction between the mesodermal and ectodermal layers failed to form blood cells, while muscle cells were observed in these embryos. Using dominant-negative forms of the BMP-4 and ALK-4 receptors, we showed that activin and BMP-4 signaling is necessary for blood cell differentiation in ventral marginal zone explants, while FGF signaling is not essential. In ventralized embryos, inactivation of the BMP-4 signal within a localized area of the ectoderm led to suppression of globin expression in the adjacent mesoderm layer, but inactivation of the activin signal did not have this effect. These observations suggest that mesodermal cells, derived from a default pathway that is induced by the activin signal, need an additional BMP-4-dependent factor from the overlying ectoderm for further differentiation into a blood cell lineage.     

Responses of embryonic Xenopus cells to activin and FGF are separated by multiple dose thresholds and correspond to distinct axes of the mesoderm.

The potent mesoderm-inducing factors activin and FGF are present as maternally synthesized proteins in embryos of X. laevis. We show that activin can act on explanted blastomeres to induce at least five different cell states ranging from posterolateral mesoderm to dorsoanterior organizer mesoderm. Each state is induced in a narrow dose range bounded by sharp thresholds. By contrast, FGF induces only posterolateral markers and does so over relatively broad dose ranges. FGF can modulate the actions of activin, potentiating them and broadening the threshold-bounded dose windows. Our results indicate that orthogonal gradients of activin and FGF would be sufficient to specify the main elements of the body plan.     

Changes in states of commitment of single animal pole blastomeres of Xenopus laevis

The experiments described in this paper were designed to compare the normal fates of animal pole blastomeres of Xenopus laevis with their state of commitment. Single animal pole blastomeres were labeled with a lineage marker and transplanted into the blastocoels of host embryos of different stages. The distribution of labeled daughter cells in the tadpole reflects the state of commitment of the parent cell at the time of transplantation. It is known that cells from the animal pole of the early blastula normally contribute predominantly to ectoderm with a small, but significant, contribution to the mesoderm. We show that on transplantation to the blastocoels of late blastula host embryos these blastomeres are pluripotent, contributing to all three germ layers. At later stages the normal fate of these cells becomes restricted solely to ectoderm and concomitantly the proportion of pluripotent cells is reduced, although the results depend upon the stage of the host embryo. Blastomeres from late blastula donors transplanted to mid gastrulae contribute solely to ectoderm in 34% of cases; however, in earlier hosts, when the vegetal hemisphere cells have "mesoderm inducing" or "vegetalizing" activity, late blastula animal pole blastomeres contribute to mesoderm and endoderm rather than ectoderm. Thus during the blastula stage animal pole cells pass from pluripotency to a labile state of commitment to ectoderm.     

Inhibition of FGF signaling converts dorsal mesoderm to ventral mesoderm in early Xenopus embryos

In early vertebrate development, mesoderm induction is a crucial event regulated by several factors including the activin, BMP and FGF signaling pathways. While the requirement of FGF in Nodal/activin-induced mesoderm formation has been reported, the fate of the tissue modulated by these signals is not fully understood. Here, we examined the fate of tissues when exogenous activin was added and FGF signaling was inhibited in animal cap explants of Xenopus embryos. Activin-induced dorsal mesoderm was converted to ventral mesoderm by inhibition of FGF signaling. We also found that inhibiting FGF signaling in the dorsal marginal zone, in vegetal-animal cap conjugates or in the presence of the activin signaling component Smad2, converted dorsal mesoderm to ventral mesoderm. The expression and promoter activities of a BMP responsive molecule, PV.1 and a Spemann organizer, noggin, were investigated while FGF signaling was inhibited. PV.1 expression increased, while noggin decreased. In addition, inhibiting BMP-4 signaling abolished ventral mesoderm formation induced by exogenous activin and FGF inhibition. Taken together, these results suggest that the formation of dorso-ventral mesoderm in early Xenopus embryos is regulated by a combination of FGF, activin and BMP signaling.     

Comparison of induction during development between Xenopus tropicalis and Xenopus laevis

Several in vitro systems exist for the induction of animal caps using growth factors such as activin. In this paper, we compared the competence of activin-treated animal cap cells dissected from the late blastulae of Xenopus tropicalis and Xenopus laevis. The resultant tissue explants from both species differentiated into mesodermal and endodermal tissues in a dose-dependent manner. In addition, RT-PCR analysis revealed that organizer and mesoderm markers were expressed in a similar temporal and dose-dependent manner in tissues from both organisms. These results indicate that animal cap cells from Xenopus tropicalis have the same competence in response to activin as those from Xenopus laevis.     

The Xenopus eomesodermin promoter and its concentration-dependent response to activin

Eomesodermin is an essential early gene in Xenopus mesoderm formation and shows a morphogen-like response to activin. Here we define the regions of the Eomesodermin promoter required for mesodermal expression and for concentration-dependent response to activin. We find an activin response element (ARE) located between -5.6 and -5.0 kb which contains two critical FAST2 binding sites. The ARE alone is necessary and sufficient for concentration-dependent response to activin. A 5.6 kb promoter recapitulates Eomes expression in normal mesoderm cells. A repressor element extinguishes Eomes expression in the endoderm. We relate our results to mesoderm patterning in early Xenopus development and to a mechanism of morphogen gradient response.     

Brain induction in ascidian embryos is dependent on juxtaposition of FGF9/16/20-producing and -receiving cells

Coordinated regulation of inductive events, both spatially and temporally, during animal development ensures that tissues are induced at their specific positions within the embryo. The ascidian brain is induced in cells at the anterior edge of the animal hemisphere by fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signals secreted from vegetal cells. To clarify how this process is spatially regulated, we first identified the sources of the FGF signal by examining the expression of brain markers Hr-Otx and Hr-ETR-1 in embryos in which FGF signaling is locally inhibited by injecting individual blastomeres with morpholino oligonucleotide against Hr-FGF9/16/20, which encodes an endogenous brain inducer. The blastomeres identified as the inducing sources are A5.1 and A5.2 at the 16-cell stage and A6.2 and A6.4 at the 24-cell stage, which are juxtaposed with brain precursors at the anterior periphery of the embryo at the respective stages. We also showed that all the cells of the animal hemisphere are capable of expressing Hr-Otx in response to the FGF signal. These results suggest that the position of inducers, rather than competence, plays an important role in determining which animal cells are induced to become brain tissues during ascidian embryogenesis. This situation in brain induction contrasts with that in mesoderm induction, where the positions at which the notochord and mesenchyme are induced are determined mainly by intrinsic competence factors that are inherited by signal-receiving cells.     

Regulation of C-cadherin function during activin induced morphogenesis of Xenopus animal caps

Treatment of Xenopus animal pole tissue with activin results in the induction of mesodermal cell types and a dramatic elongation of the tissue. The morphogenetic movements involved in the elongation appear similar to those in normal gastrulation, which is driven by cell rearrangement and cell intercalations. We have used this system to explore the potential regulation of cell-cell adhesion and cadherin function during morphogenesis. Quantitative blastomere aggregation assays revealed that activin induction reduced the calcium-dependent adhesion between blastomeres. Activin-induced blastomeres formed smaller aggregates, and a greater proportion of the population remained as single cells compared to uninduced blastomeres. The aggregation was mediated by C-cadherin because C-cadherin was present in the blastomeres during the aggregation assay, and monoclonal antibodies against C-cadherin inhibited the calcium-dependent aggregation of blastomeres. E-cadherin was not detectable until after the completion of the assay and, therefore, does not explain the adhesive differences between induced and uninduced blastomeres. L cells stably expressing C- cadherin (LC cells) were used to demonstrate that C-cadherin activity was specifically altered after activin induction. Blastomeres induced with activin bound fewer LC cells than uninduced blastomers. L cells not expressing C-cadherin did not adhere to blastomeres. The changes in C-cadherin-mediated adhesion occurred without detectable changes in the steady-state levels of C-cadherin or the amount of C-cadherin present on the surface of the cell. Immunoprecipitation of C-cadherin and its associated catenins revealed that the ratio of C-cadherin and the catenins was not altered by activin induction. These results demonstrate that activin decreases the adhesive function of existing C- cadherin molecules on the surface of blastomeres and suggest that decreased cadherin mediated cell-cell adhesion is associated with increased morphogenetic movement.     

Regulated expression of the retinoblastoma gene product by fibroblast growth factor but not by activin during mesoderm induction in Xenopus

 The retinoblastoma (RB) gene is a tumor suppressor gene that plays an important role in cell cycle arrest and in the terminal differentiation of skeletal myoblasts. Differentiation into muscle occurs in Xenopus embryo explants during mesoderm induction by fibroblast growth factor (FGF) or activin A. We examined expression of the RB gene product (pRB) during mesoderm induction in vivo and in vitro. We show that hypo- and hyper-phosphorylated forms of pRB are present during early development and that expression of both forms increases significantly during the blastula stage, concomitant with mesoderm induction. Further investigation revealed that pRB is enriched in the presumptive mesoderm of the blastula stage embryo. In animal cap explants induced by Xenopus bFGF (XbFGF), pRB expression levels increased approximately tenfold while no increase was observed in explants induced by activin. However, when explants were induced by XbFGF in the presence of sodium orthovanadate, a compound previously shown to synergize with FGF to produce more dorsal ”activin-like” inductions than FGF alone, only a slight increase in pRB expression was observed. Furthermore, upregulation of pRB during mesoderm induction in vitro displayed an inverse correlation with expression of XFKH1, a marker for notochord. These results suggest that pRB may be important for patterning along the dorsoventral axis. Received: 22 February 1996 / Accepted: 20 September 1996     

Nuclear exclusion of Smad2 is a mechanism leading to loss of competence

Controlling the duration of a signalling process in development by loss of competence is important because too strong an induction can change cell fate. To understand some of the mechanisms that underlie loss of competence, we have analysed the transduction of transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) signalling during mesoderm formation, which is thought to be induced by TGF-beta-like signalling, in embryos of the frog Xenopus laevis. Here we show that gastrula ectoderm has the ability to express mesodermal marker genes in response to the TGF-beta signalling molecule activin for many hours, but then loses this ability within 1 h for all mesodermal genes tested. This loss of mesodermal competence correlates with the inability of Smad2, the principal intracellular signal transducer of activin, to accumulate in the nucleus. Mutating three phosphorylation sites within Smad2 abrogates the temporal restriction of Smad2 to accumulate in the nucleus. Overexpression of this mutant form of Smad2 can prolong the competence of endogenous mesodermal genes to respond to activin signalling. Thus, restricting the subcellular localization of an intracellular signal transducer constitutes a mechanism that leads to loss of mesodermal competence. This mechanism operates within less than an hour, and is therefore well suited to control an orderly sequence of inductions.     

Mesodermal and axial determinants contribute to mesoderm regionalization in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bufo arenarum</Emphasis> embryos

The existence of mesodermal determinants in the equator of Bufo arenarum embryos has been previously demonstrated. In this work, their role in dorso-ventral regionalization of mesoderm was studied by transferring the determinants to animal blastomeres. The transfer was performed by cleavage reorientation and cytoplasmic microinjection. Forced inclination during early cleavage caused deviation of the third cleavage plane and annexation of equatorial cytoplasm into animal quartets. Animal blastomeres from embryos oriented with the dorsal side up, incorporated ventro-equatorial cytoplasm and formed blood cells, mesenchyme, and coelomic epithelium. In contrast, animal blastomeres from embryos oriented with the ventral side up, acquired dorso-equatorial cytoplasm and developed notochord, somites, mesenchyme, coelomic epithelium and nervous tissue. In order to investigate if this dorso-ventral differentiation pattern responds to an interaction of mesodermal and axial factors, isolated 8-cell-stage animal quartets were microinjected with subcortical cytoplasm from: (a) the ventro-equatorial region of synchronous embryos; (b) the vegetal pole of uncleaved eggs; (c) a combination of both cytoplasms. As expected, the implanted ventro-equatorial cytoplasm promoted ventral mesoderm differentiation. Conversely, the joint transfer of ventro-equatorial cytoplasm and vegetal pole cytoplasm behaved as the dorso-equatorial cytoplasm, promoting dorso-lateral mesoderm and neural formation. Thus, mesoderm regionalization in B. arenarum embryos seems to be caused by a concurrent action of both mesodermal and axial determinants.     

Induction of tooth and eye by transplantation of activin A-treated, undifferentiated presumptive ectodermal Xenopus cells into the abdomen

Activin A can induce the Xenopus presumptive ectoderm (animal cap) to form different types of mesoderm and endoderm at different concentrations and the animal cap treated with activin can function as an organizer during early development. The dissociated Xenopus animal cap cells treated with activin form an aggregate and it develops into various tissues in vitro. In this study, to induce jaw cartilage from undifferentiated cells effectively, we developed a culture method to manipulate body patterning in vitro, using activin A and dissociated animal cap cells. An aggregate consisting only of activin A-treated dissociated cells developed into endodermal tissues. However, when activin A-treated cells were mixed with untreated cells at a ratio of 1:5, the aggregate developed cartilage with the maxillofacial regional marker genes, goosecoid, Xenopus Distal-less 4 and X-Hoxa2. When this aggregate was transplanted into the abdominal region of host embryos, maxillofacial structures containing cartilage and eye developed. We raised these embryos to adulthood and found that tooth germ had developed in the transplanted tissue. Here, we show the induction of jaw cartilage, tooth germ and eye structures from animal caps using activin A in the aggregation culture method. This differentiation system will help to promote a better understanding of the regulating mechanisms of body patterning and tooth induction in vertebrates.     

Regional specification within the mesoderm of early embryos of Xenopus laevis

We have further analysed the roles of mesoderm induction and dorsalization in the formation of a regionally specified mesoderm in early embryos of Xenopus laevis. First, we have examined the regional specificity of mesoderm induction by isolating single blastomeres from the vegetalmost tier of the 32-cell embryo and combining each with a lineage-labelled (FDA) animal blastomere tier. Whereas dorsovegetal (D1) blastomeres induce 'dorsal-type' mesoderm (notochord and muscle), laterovegetal and ventrovegetal blastomeres (D2-4) induce either 'intermediate-type' (muscle, mesothelium, mesenchyme and blood) or 'ventral-type' (mesothelium, mesenchyme and blood) mesoderm. No significant difference in inductive specificity between blastomeres D2, 3 and 4 could be detected. We also show that laterovegetal and ventrovegetal blastomeres from early cleavage stages can have a dorsal inductive potency partially activated by operative procedures, resulting in the induction of intermediate-type mesoderm. Second, we have determined the state of specification of ventral blastomeres by isolating and culturing them in vitro between the 4-cell stage and the early gastrula stage. The majority of isolates from the ventral half of the embryo gave extreme ventral types of differentiation at all stages tested. Although a minority of cases formed intermediate-type and dorsal-type mesoderms we believe these to result from either errors in our assessment of the prospective DV axis or from an enhancement, provoked by microsurgery, of some dorsal inductive specificity. The results of induction and isolation experiments suggest that only two states of specification exist in the mesoderm of the pregastrula embryo, a dorsal type and a ventral type. Finally we have made a comprehensive series of combinations between different regions of the marginal zone using FDA to distinguish the components. We show that, in combination with dorsal-type mesoderm, ventral-type mesoderm becomes dorsalized to the level of intermediate-type mesoderm. Dorsal-type mesoderm is not ventralized in these combinations. Dorsalizing activity is confined to a restricted sector of the dorsal marginal zone, it is wider than the prospective notochord and seems to be graded from a high point at the dorsal midline. The results of these experiments strengthen the case for the three-signal model proposed previously, i.e. dorsal and ventral mesoderm inductions followed by dorsalization, as the simplest explanation capable of accounting for regional specification within the mesoderm of early Xenopus embryos.     

Duration of competence and inducing capacity of blastomeres in notochord induction during ascidian embryogenesis

Notochord cells in ascidian embryos are formed by the inducing action of cells of presumptive endoderm, as well as neighboring presumptive notochord, at the 32-cell stage. Studies of the timing of induction using recombinations of isolated blastomeres have suggested that notochord induction must be initiated before the decompaction of blastomeres at the 32-cell stage and is completed by the 64-cell stage. However, it is not yet clear how the duration of notochord induction is strictly limited. In the present paper, the aim was to determine in detail when the presumptive notochord blastomeres lost their competence to respond, and when the presumptive endoderm blastomeres produced inducing signals for the notochord. Presumptive notochord blastomeres and presumptive endoderm blastomeres were isolated from early 32-cell embryos, and were heterochronously recombined at various stages ranging from the early 32-cell stage to the 64-cell stage. Presumptive notochord blastomeres could respond to inductive signals at the early 32-cell stage, and started to lose their responsiveness at the decompaction stage. By contrast, the presumptive endoderm blastomeres persisted in their inducing capacity even at the 64-cell stage. These observations suggest that the loss of competence in presumptive notochord blastomeres limits the duration of notochord induction in intact ascidian embryos.     

Dorsal and ventral cells of cleavage-stage Xenopus embryos show the same ability to induce notochord and somite formation

Cells in the dorsal marginal zone of the amphibian embryo acquire the potential for mesoderm formation during the first few hours following fertilization. An examination of those early cell interactions may therefore provide insight on the mechanisms important for organization of axial structures. The formation of mesoderm (notochord, somites, and pronephros) was studied by combining blastomeres from the animal pole region of Xenopus embryos (32- to 512-cell stages) with blastomeres from different regions of the vegetal hemisphere. The frequency of notochord and somite development was similar in combinations made with dorsal or ventral blastomeres, or with both. Our results show that during early cleavage stages the ventral half of the vegetal hemisphere has the potential to organize axial structures, a property previously believed to be limited to the dorsal region.     

Pre-MBT patterning of early gene regulation in Xenopus: the role of the cortical rotation and mesoderm induction

Patterning events that occur before the mid-blastula transition (MBT) and that organize the spatial pattern of gene expression in the animal hemisphere have been analyzed in Xenopus embryos. We present evidence that genes that play a role in dorsoventral specification display different modes of activation. Using early blastomere explants (16–128-cell stage) cultured until gastrula stages, we demonstrate by RT-PCR analysis that the expression of goosecoid (gsc), wnt-8 and brachyury (bra) is dependent on mesoderm induction. In contrast, nodal-related 3 (nr3) and siamois (sia) are expressed in a manner that is independent of mesoderm induction, however their spatially correct activation does require cortical rotation. The pattern of sia and nr3 expression reveals that the animal half of the 16-cell embryo is already distinctly polarized along the dorsoventral axis as a result of rearrangement of the egg structure during cortical rotation. Similar to the antagonistic activity between the ventral and the dorsal mesoderm, the ventral animal blastomeres can attenuate the expression of nr3 and sia in dorsal animal blastomeres. Our data suggest that no Nieuwkoop center activity at the blastula stage is required for the activation of nr3 and sia in vivo.     

Lnx-2b restricts gsc expression to the dorsal mesoderm by limiting Nodal and Bozozok activity

Coordinated Nodal-related signals and Bozozok (Boz) activity are critical for the initial specification of dorsal mesoderm and anterior neuroectoderm during zebrafish embryogenesis. Overexpression of Boz expands gsc expression into the ventro-lateral marginal blastomeres where Nodal signaling is active, but is insufficient to induce ectopic gsc expression in the animal region. We found that overexpression of Boz together with depletion of Lnx-2b (previously named Lnx-like, Lnx-l), but not each manipulation alone, causes robust gsc expression in all blastomeres. Furthermore, nodal-related signals are required for gsc expression in embryos with elevated Boz activity. Through targeted injection into single cells at the 128-cell stage we illustrate the role of maternally deposited Lnx-2b to restrict the expansion of gsc expression into the presumptive ectodermal region. This report provides a novel mechanism for limiting dorsal organizer specification to a defined region of the early zebrafish embryo.