Bacillus subtilis SecA ATPase exists as an antiparallel dimer in solution

SecA ATPase promotes the biogenesis of membrane and secretory proteins into and across the cytoplasmic membrane of Eubacteria. SecA binds to translocon component SecYE and substrate proteins and undergoes ATP-dependent conformational cycles that are coupled to the stepwise translocation of proteins. Our recent crystal structure of B. subtilis SecA [Hunt, J. F., Weinkauf, S., Henry, L., Fak, J. J., McNicholas, P., Oliver, D. B., and Deisenhofer, J. (2002) Science 297, 2018-2026] showed two different dimer interactions in the lattice which both buried significant solvent-accessible surface area in their interface and could potentially be responsible for formation of the physiological dimer in solution. In this paper, we utilize fluorescence resonance energy transfer methodology with genetically engineered SecA proteins containing unique pairs of tryptophan and fluorophore-labeled cysteine residues to determine the oligomeric structure of SecA protein in solution. Our results show that of the two dimers interactions observed in the crystal structure, SecA forms an antiparallel dimer in solution that maximizes the buried solvent-accessible surface area and intermolecular contacts. At the submicromolar protein concentrations used in the fluorescence experiments, we saw no evidence for the formation of higher-order oligomers of SecA based on either the alternative dimer or the 3(1) helical fiber observed in the crystal lattice. Our studies are consistent with previous ones demonstrating the existence of a dimerization determinant within the C-domain of SecA as well as those documenting the interaction of N- and C-domains of SecA. Our results also provide a valuable starting point for a determination of whether the subunit status of SecA changes during the protein translocation as well as studies designed to elucidate the conformational dynamics of this multidomain protein during its translocation cycle.     

Role of a conserved glutamate residue in the Escherichia coli SecA ATPase mechanism

Escherichia coli SecA uses ATP to drive the transport of proteins across cell membranes. Glutamate 210 in the "DEVD" Walker B motif of the SecA ATP-binding site has been proposed as the catalytic base for ATP hydrolysis (Hunt, J. F., Weinkauf, S., Henry, L., Fak, J. J., McNicholas, P., Oliver, D. B., and Deisenhofer, J. (2002) Science 297, 2018-2026). Consistent with this hypothesis, we find that mutation of glutamate 210 to aspartate results in a 90-fold reduction of the ATP hydrolysis rate compared with wild type SecA, 0.3 s(-1) versus 27 s(-1), respectively. SecA-E210D also releases ADP at a slower rate compared with wild type SecA, suggesting that in addition to serving as the catalytic base, glutamate 210 might aid turnover as well. Our results contradict an earlier report that proposed aspartate 133 as the catalytic base (Sato, K., Mori, H., Yoshida, M., and Mizushima, S. (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 17439-17444). Re-evaluation of the SecA-D133N mutant used in that study confirms its loss of ATPase and membrane translocation activities, but surprisingly, the analogous SecA-D133A mutant retains full activity, revealing that this residue does not play a key role in catalysis.     

Arginine 357 of SecY is needed for SecA-dependent initiation of preprotein translocation

The Escherichia coli SecYEG complex forms a transmembrane channel for both protein export and membrane protein insertion. Secretory proteins and large periplasmic domains of membrane proteins require for translocation in addition the SecA ATPase. The conserved arginine 357 of SecY is essential for a yet unidentified step in the SecA catalytic cycle. To further dissect its role, we have analysed the requirement for R357 in membrane protein insertion. Although R357 substitutions abolish post-translational translocation, they allow the translocation of periplasmic domains targeted co-translationally by an N-terminal transmembrane segment. We propose that R357 is essential for the initiation of SecA-dependent translocation only.     

Electrophysiological studies in Xenopus oocytes for the opening of Escherichia coli SecA-dependent protein-conducting channels

Protein translocation in Escherichia coli requires protein-conducting channels in cytoplasmic membranes to allow precursor peptides to pass through with adenosine triphosphate (ATP) hydrolysis. Here, we report a novel, sensitive method that detects the opening of the SecA-dependent protein-conducting channels at the nanogram level. E. coli inverted membrane vesicles were injected into Xenopus oocytes, and ionic currents were recorded using the two-electrode voltage clamp. Currents were observed only in the presence of E. coli SecA in conjunction with E. coli membranes. Observed currents showed outward rectification in the presence of KCl as permeable ions and were significantly enhanced by coinjection with the precursor protein proOmpA or active LamB signal peptide. Channel activity was blockable with sodium azide or adenylyl 5'-(beta,gamma-methylene)-diphosphonate, a nonhydrolyzable ATP analogue, both of which are known to inhibit SecA protein activity. Endogenous oocyte precursor proteins also stimulated ion current activity and can be inhibited by puromycin. In the presence of puromycin, exogenous proOmpA or LamB signal peptides continued to enhance ionic currents. Thus, the requirement of signal peptides and ATP hydrolysis for the SecA-dependent currents resembles biochemical protein translocation assay with E. coli membrane vesicles, indicating that the Xenopus oocyte system provides a sensitive assay to study the role of Sec and precursor proteins in the formation of protein-conducting channels using electrophysiological methods.     

Lipid and signal peptide-induced conformational changes within the C-domain of Escherichia coli SecA protein

SecA ATPase is an essential component of the Sec-dependent protein translocation machinery. Upon interaction with the plasma membrane containing SecYE, preprotein, and ATP, SecA undergoes cycles of membrane insertion and retraction resulting in the translocation of segments of the preprotein to the trans side of the membrane. To study the structural basis of SecA function, we employed fluorescence spectroscopy along with collisional quenchers with a set of SecA proteins containing single tryptophan substitutions. Our data show that among the seven naturally occurring tryptophan residues of Escherichia coli SecA, only the three tryptophan residues contained within the C-domain contributed significantly to the fluorescence signal, and they occupied distinct local environments in solution: Trp723 and Trp775 were found to be relatively solvent accessible and inaccessible, respectively, while Trp701 displayed an intermediate level of solvent exposure. Exposure to increased temperature or interaction with model membranes or signal peptide elicited a similar conformational response from SecA based upon the fluorescence signals of the SecA-W775F and SecA-W723F mutant proteins. Specifically, Trp775 became more solvent exposed, while Trp723 became less solvent accessible under these conditions, indicating similarities in the overall conformational change of the C-domain promoted by temperature or translocation ligands. Only Trp701 did not respond in parallel to the different conditions, since its solvent accessibility changed only in the presence of signal peptide. These results provide the first detailed structural information about the C-domain of SecA and its response to translocation ligands, and they provide insight into the conformational changes within SecA that drive protein translocation.     

Two distinct ATP-binding domains are needed to promote protein export by Escherichia coli SecA ATPase

Six putative ATP-binding motifs of SecA protein were altered by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis to try to define the ATP-binding regions of this multifunctional protein. The effects of the mutations were analysed by genetic and biochemical assays. The results show that SecA contains two essential ATP-binding domains. One domain is responsible for high-affinity ATP binding and contains motifs AO and BO, located at amino acid residues 102-109 and 198-210, respectively. A second domain is responsible for low-affinity ATP binding and contains motifs A3 and a predicted B motif located at amino acid residues 503-511 and 631-653, respectively. The ATP-binding properties of both domains were essential for SecA-dependent translocation ATPase and in vitro protein translocation activities. The significance of these findings for the mechanism of SecA-dependent protein translocation is discussed.     

Precursor protein translocation by the Escherichia coli translocase is directed by the protonmotive force.

The SecY/E protein of Escherichia coli was coreconstituted with the proton pump bacteriorhodopsin and cytochrome c oxidase yielding proteoliposomes capable of sustaining a protonmotive force (delta p) of defined polarity and composition. Proteoliposomes support the ATP- and SecA-dependent translocation of proOmpA which is stimulated by a delta p, inside acid and positive. delta p of opposite polarity, inside alkaline and negative, suppresses translocation while SecA-mediated ATP hydrolysis continues unabated. delta psi and delta pH are equally effective in promoting or inhibiting translocation. Membrane-spanning translocation intermediates move backwards in the presence of a reversed delta p. These results support a model [Schiebel, E., Driessen, A.J.M., Hartl, F.-U. and Wickner, W. (1991) Cell, 64, 927-939] in which the delta p defines the direction of translocation after ATP hydrolysis has released proOmpA from its association with SecA. The polarity effect of the delta p challenges models involving delta p-dependent membrane destabilization and provides further evidence for a role of the delta p as driving force in precursor protein translocation.     

Membrane topology inversion of SecG detected by labeling with a membrane-impermeable sulfhydryl reagent that causes a close association of SecG with SecA

SecG stimulates protein translocation in Escherichia coli by facilitating the membrane insertion-deinsertion cycle of SecA. SecG was previously shown to undergo membrane topology inversion, since SecA-dependent protein translocation renders the membrane-protected region of SecG sensitive to external proteases. To examine this topology inversion in more detail without protease-treatment, SecG derivatives with a single cysteine residue at various positions were labeled in the presence and absence of protein translocation with a membrane impermeable SH reagent, 4-acetamido-4'-maleimidylstilbene-2-2'-disulfonic acid (AMS). Treatment of spheroplasts with AMS revealed that a cysteine residue in the cytoplasmic region of SecG could be labeled from the periplasm side only in the presence of protein translocation, whereas a cytoplasmic protein, elongation factor, Tu, remained unlabeled. Treatment of inverted membrane vesicles with AMS also revealed that cysteine residues in the periplasmic region were labeled from the cytoplasmic side of membranes only when protein translocation was in progress. This labeling required ATP, SecA and a precursor protein, and became more efficient as the position of the cysteine residue became closer to the C-terminus. Crosslinking analyses revealed that the interaction between SecG and SecA in membranes markedly increases when SecA and SecG undergo membrane-insertion and topology inversion, respectively. Thus, the two most dynamic components of the translocation machinery were found for the first time to interact with each other when both undergo conformational changes.     

Preprotein transfer to the Escherichia coli translocase requires the co-operative binding of SecB and the signal sequence to SecA

In Escherichia coli , precursor proteins are targeted to the membrane-bound translocase by the cytosolic chaperone SecB. SecB binds to the extreme carboxy-terminus of the SecA ATPase translocase subunit, and this interaction is promoted by preproteins. The mutant SecB proteins, L75Q and E77K, which interfere with preprotein translocation in vivo , are unable to stimulate in vitro translocation. Both mutants bind proOmpA but fail to support the SecA-dependent membrane binding of proOmpA because of a marked reduction in their binding affinities for SecA. The stimulatory effect of preproteins on the interaction between SecB and SecA exclusively involves the signal sequence domain of the preprotein, as it can be mimicked by a synthetic signal peptide and is not observed with a mutant preprotein (Δ8proOmpA) bearing a non-functional signal sequence. Δ8proOmpA is not translocated across wild-type membranes, but the translocation defect is suppressed in inner membrane vesicles derived from a prlA4 strain. SecB reduces the translocation of Δ8proOmpA into these vesicles and almost completely prevents translocation when, in addition, the SecB binding site on SecA is removed. These data demonstrate that efficient targeting of preproteins by SecB requires both a functional signal sequence and a SecB binding domain on SecA. It is concluded that the SecB–SecA interaction is needed to dissociate the mature preprotein domain from SecB and that binding of the signal sequence domain to SecA is required to ensure efficient transfer of the preprotein to the translocase.     

SecA protein: autoregulated ATPase catalysing preprotein insertion and translocation across the Escherichia coli inner membrane

Recent insight into the biochemical mechanism of protein translocation in Escherichia coli indicates that SecA ATPase is required both for the initial binding of preproteins to the inner membrane as well as subsequent translocation across this structure. SecA appears to promote these events by direct recognition of the preprotein or preprotein-SecB complex, binding to inner-membrane anionic phospholipids, insertion into the membrane biiayer and association with the preprotein translocator, SecY/SecE. ATP binding appears to control the affinity of SecA for the various components of the system and ATP hydrolysis promotes cycling between its different biochemical states. As a component likely to catalyse a rate-determining step in protein secretion, SecA synthesis is co-ordinated with the activity of the protein export pathway. This form of negative reguiation appears to rely on SecA protein binding to its mRNA and repressing translation if conditions of rapid protein secretion prevail within the cell. A precise biochemical scheme for SecA-dependent catalysis of protein export and the details of secA regulation appear to be close at hand. The evolutionary conservation of SecA protein among eubacteria as well as the general requirement for translocation ATPases in other protein secretion systems argues for a mechanistic commonality of all prokaryotic protein export pathways.     

In vivo studies of the role of SecA during protein export in Escherichia coli.

SecA is found in Escherichia coli both tightly associated with the cytoplasmic membrane where it functions as a translocation ATPase during protein export and free in the cytosol (R. J. Cabelli, K. M. Dolan, L. Qian, and D. B. Oliver, J. Biol. Chem. 266:24420-24427, 1991; D. B. Oliver and J. Beckwith, Cell 30:311-319, 1982; W. Wickner, A. J. M. Driessen, and F.-U. Hartl, Annu. Rev. Biochem. 60:101-124, 1991). Here we show that SecA can be immunoprecipitated from the cytosol in complex with both fully elongated and nascent species of the precursor of maltose-binding protein, an exported, periplasmic protein. In addition, under conditions in which the distribution of SecA between the cytosolic and membrane-bound states changes from that normally observed, the distribution of precursor maltose-binding protein changes in parallel. These results support the idea that cytosolic SecA plays a role in export. With the aim of determining the roles of the multiple binding sites for ATP on SecA, we compared the export defect in a culture of E. coli expressing a temperature-sensitive allele of secA with the defect in a culture treated with sodium azide. The results indicate that the mutational change and treatment with sodium azide inhibit export by affecting different steps in the cycle of ATP binding and hydrolysis by SecA.     

Escherichia coli SecA helicase activity is not required in vivo for efficient protein translocation or autogenous regulation

SecA is an essential ATP-driven motor protein that binds to preproteins and the translocon to promote protein translocation across the eubacterial plasma membrane. Escherichia coli SecA contains seven conserved motifs characteristic of superfamily II of DNA and RNA helicases, and it has been shown previously to possess RNA helicase activity. SecA has also been shown to be an autogenous repressor that binds to its translation initiation region on secM-secA mRNA, thereby blocking and dissociating 30 S ribosomal subunits. Here we show that SecA is an ATP-dependent helicase that unwinds a mimic of the repressor helix of secM-secA mRNA. Mutational analysis of the seven conserved helicase motifs in SecA allowed us to identify mutants that uncouple SecA-dependent protein translocation activity from its helicase activity. Helicase-defective secA mutants displayed normal protein translocation activity and autogenous repression of secA in vivo. Our studies indicate that SecA helicase activity is nonessential and does not appear to be necessary for efficient protein secretion and secA autoregulation.     

A molecular switch in SecA protein couples ATP hydrolysis to protein translocation

SecA, the dimeric ATPase subunit of bacterial protein translocase, catalyses translocation during ATP-driven membrane cycling at SecYEG. We now show that the SecA protomer comprises two structural modules: the ATPase N-domain, containing the nucleotide binding sites NBD1 and NBD2, and the regulatory C-domain. The C-domain binds to the N-domain in each protomer and to the C-domain of another protomer to form SecA dimers. NBD1 is sufficient for single rounds of SecA ATP hydrolysis. Multiple ATP turnovers at NBD1 require both the NBD2 site acting in cis and a conserved C-domain sequence operating in trans. This intramolecular regulator of ATP hydrolysis (IRA) mediates N-/C-domain binding and acts as a molecular switch: it suppresses ATP hydrolysis in cytoplasmic SecA while it releases hydrolysis in SecY-bound SecA during translocation. We propose that the IRA switch couples ATP binding and hydrolysis to SecA membrane insertion/deinsertion and substrate translocation by controlling nucleotide-regulated relative motions between the N-domain and the C-domain. The IRA switch is a novel essential component of the protein translocation catalytic pathway.     

A dual function for SecA in the assembly of single spanning membrane proteins in Escherichia coli

The assembly of bacterial membrane proteins with large periplasmic loops is an intrinsically complex process because the SecY translocon has to coordinate the signal recognition particle-dependent targeting and integration of transmembrane domains with the SecA-dependent translocation of the periplasmic loop. The current model suggests that the ATP hydrolysis by SecA is required only if periplasmic loops larger than 30 amino acids have to be translocated. In agreement with this model, our data demonstrate that the signal recognition particle- and SecA-dependent multiple spanning membrane protein YidC becomes SecA-independent if the large periplasmic loop connecting transmembrane domains 1 and 2 is reduced to less than 30 amino acids. Strikingly, however, we were unable to render single spanning membrane proteins SecA-independent by reducing the length of their periplasmic loops. For these proteins, the complete assembly was always SecA-dependent even if the periplasmic loop was reduced to 13 amino acids. If, however, the 13-amino acid-long periplasmic loop was fused to a downstream transmembrane domain, SecA was no longer required for complete translocation. Although these data support the current model on the SecA dependence of multiple spanning membrane proteins, they indicate a novel function of SecA for the assembly of single spanning membrane proteins. This could suggest that single and multiple spanning membrane proteins are processed differently by the bacterial SecY translocon.     

Topology inversion of SecG is essential for cytosolic SecA-dependent stimulation of protein translocation

SecG, a subunit of the protein translocon, undergoes a cycle of topology inversion. To further examine the role of this topology inversion, we analyzed the activity of membrane vesicles carrying a SecG-PhoA fusion protein (SecG-PhoA inverted membrane vesicles (IMVs)). In the absence of externally added SecA, SecG-PhoA IMVs were as active in protein translocation as SecG(+) IMVs per SecA. Consistent with this observation, insertion of membrane-bound SecA into SecG-PhoA IMVs was normally observed. On the other hand, externally added SecA did not affect the activity of SecG-PhoA IMVs, but it caused >10-fold stimulation of the translocation activity of SecG(+) IMVs, indicating that the topology inversion of SecG, which cannot occur in SecG-PhoA IMVs, is essential for cytosolic SecA-dependent stimulation of protein translocation. SecG-PhoA IMVs generated a 46-kDa fragment of SecA upon trypsin treatment. The accumulation of this membrane-inserted SecA in the SecG-PhoA IMVs was responsible for the loss of the soluble SecA-dependent stimulation. Moreover, fixation of the inverted SecG topology was found to be dependent on soluble SecA. The dual functions of SecG in protein translocation will be discussed.     

Global co-ordination of protein translocation by the SecA IRA1 switch

SecA, the dimeric ATPase subunit of protein translocase, contains a DEAD helicase catalytic core that binds to a regulatory C-terminal domain. We now demonstrate that IRA1, a conserved helix-loop-helix structure in the C-domain, controls C-domain conformation through direct interdomain contacts. C-domain conformational changes are transmitted to the DEAD motor and alter its conformation. These interactions establish DEAD motor/C-domain conformational cross-talk that requires a functional IRA1. IRA1-controlled binding/release cycles of the C-domain to the DEAD motor couple this cross-talk to protein translocation chemistries, i.e. DEAD motor affinities for ligands (nucleotides, preprotein signal peptides, and SecYEG, the integral membrane component of translocase) and ATP turnover. IRA1-mediated global co-ordination of SecA catalysis is essential for protein translocation.     

Distinct membrane binding properties of N- and C-terminal domains of Escherichia coli SecA ATPase

SecA is a motor protein that drives protein translocation at the Escherichia coli translocon. SecA membrane binding has been shown to occur with high affinity at SecYE and low affinity at anionic phospholipids. To dissect SecA-membrane interaction with reference to SecA structure, the membrane binding properties of N- and C-terminal SecA domains, denoted SecA-N664 and SecA-619C, respectively, were characterized. Remarkably, only SecA-N664 bound to the membrane with high affinity, whereas SecA-619C bound with low affinity in a nonsaturable manner through partitioning with phospholipids. Moreover, SecA-N664 and SecA-619C associated with each other to reconstitute wild type binding affinity. Corroborative results were also obtained from membrane binding competition and subcellular fractionation studies along with binding studies to membranes prepared from strains overproducing SecYE protein. Together, these findings indicate that the specific interaction of SecA with SecYE occurs through its N-terminal domain and that the C-terminal domain, although important in SecA membrane cycling at a later stage of translocation, appears to initially assist SecA membrane binding by interaction with phospholipids. These results provide the first evidence for distinct membrane binding characteristics of the two SecA primary domains and their importance for optimal binding activity, and they are significant for understanding SecA dynamics at the translocon.     

Binding,activation and dissociation of the dimeric SecA ATPase at the dimeric SecYEG translocase

The bacterial preprotein translocase is comprised of a membrane-embedded oligomeric SecYEG structure and a cytosolic dimeric SecA ATPase. The associations within SecYEG oligomers and SecA dimers, as well as between these two domains are dynamic and reversible. Here, it is shown that a covalently linked SecYEG dimer forms a functional translocase and a high affinity binding site for monomeric and dimeric SecA in solution. The interaction between these two domains stimulates the SecA ATPase, and nucleotides modulate the affinity and ratio of SecA monomers and dimers bound to the linked SecYEG complex. During the translocation reaction, the SecA monomer remains in stable association with a SecYEG protomer and the translocating preprotein. The nucleotides and translocation-dependent changes of SecA-SecYEG associations and the SecA dimeric state may reflect important facets of the preprotein translocation reaction.     

In vivo membrane topology of Escherichia coli SecA ATPase reveals extensive periplasmic exposure of multiple functionally important domains clustering on one face of SecA

The Sec-dependent protein translocation pathway promotes the transport of proteins into or across the bacterial plasma membrane. SecA ATPase has been shown to be a nanomotor that associates with its protein cargo as well as the SecYEG channel complex and to undergo ATP-driven cycles of membrane insertion and retraction that promote stepwise protein translocation. Previous studies have shown that both the 65-kDa N-domain and 30-kDa C-domain of SecA appear to undergo such membrane cycling. In the present study we performed in vivo sulfhydryl labeling of an extensive collection of monocysteine secA mutants under topologically specific conditions to identify regions of SecA that are accessible to the trans side of the membrane in its membrane-integrated state. Our results show that distinct regions of five of six SecA domains were labeled under these conditions, and such labeling clusters to a single face of the SecA structure. Our results demarcate an extensive face of SecA that interacts with SecYEG and is in fluid contact with the protein-conducting channel. The observed domain-specific labeling patterns should also provide important constraints on model building efforts in this dynamic system.     

The catalytic cycle of the escherichia coli SecA ATPase comprises two distinct preprotein translocation events.

SecA is the ATP-dependent force generator in the Escherichia coli precursor protein translocation cascade, and is bound at the membrane surface to the integral membrane domain of the preprotein translocase. Preproteins are thought to be translocated in a stepwise manner by nucleotide-dependent cycles of SecA membrane insertion and de-insertion, or as large polypeptide segments by the protonmotive force (Deltap) in the absence of SecA. To determine the step size of a complete ATP- and SecA-dependent catalytic cycle, translocation intermediates of the preprotein proOmpA were generated at limiting SecA translocation ATPase activity. Distinct intermediates were formed, spaced by intervals of approximately 5 kDa. Inhibition of the SecA ATPase by azide trapped SecA in a membrane-inserted state and shifted the step size to 2-2.5 kDa. The latter corresponds to the translocation elicited by binding of non-hydrolysable ATP analogues to SecA, or by the re-binding of partially translocated polypeptide chains by SecA. Therefore, a complete catalytic cycle of the preprotein translocase permits the stepwise translocation of 5 kDa polypeptide segments by two consecutive events, i.e. approximately 2.5 kDa upon binding of the polypeptide by SecA, and another 2.5 kDa upon binding of ATP to SecA.