Identification of de novo deletions at the NF1 gene: no preferential paternal origin and phenotypic analysis of patients

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is a common autosomal dominant disorder. To date, a relatively small number of NF1 mutations have been characterized, thus precluding genotype-phenotype correlations. By genotyping 75 NF1 families, we have detected six hemizygous patients (two of whom are members of the same family). The five presumed deletions were confirmed by two quantitative methods of analysis of NF1 copy number: Southern hybridization with cDNA probes and a single-strand conformation polymorphism analysis that discriminates between the NF1 gene and the pseudogene sequences. The five deletions remove most of the NF1 gene, at least 225 kb, from exon 9 to the 3′ end of the coding sequence. The origin of de novo mutations in the NF1 gene has been reported to be mainly paternal but we have determined that four of the de novo deletions involved the maternal chromosome and one the paternal chromosome. The six patients with deletions exhibited precocious, multiple clinical features of the disease. The incidence of tumor complications, particularly plexiform neurofibromas and intracranial tumors, among this group of patients is higher than the observed incidence in our NF1 population, suggesting that NF1 haploinsufficiency may cause a more severe phenotype with regard to tumor development. In contrast to other reports that associated large deletions with mildly dysmorphic facies, mental retardation and a large number of cutaneous neurofibromas, only one out of our six patients presented this phenotype. Received: 15 August 1996 / Revised: 10 December 1996     

Confirmation of a double-hit model for the NF1 gene in benign neurofibromas.

Neurofibroma is a benign tumor that arises from small or large nerves. This neoplastic lesion is a common feature of neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), one of the most common autosomal dominant disorders. The NF1 gene codes for a protein called "neurofibromin." It possesses a region that shares a high homology with the family of GTPase-activating proteins, which are negative regulators of RAS function and thereby control cell growth and differentiation. The evidence points to the NF1 gene being a tumor-suppressor gene. NF1 patients also have an increased incidence of certain malignant tumors that are believed to follow the "two hit" hypothesis, with one allele constitutionally inactivated and the other somatically mutated. Recently, somatic loss of heterozygosity (LOH) has been described for neurofibromas, and mutations in both copies of the NF1 gene have been reported for a dermal neurofibroma. The aim of our study was the analysis of the NF1 locus in benign neurofibromas in NF1 patients. We performed LOH analysis on 60 neurofibromas belonging to 17 patients, 9 of them with family history of the disease and 8 of them sporadic. We have analyzed five intragenic NF1 markers and six extragenic markers, and we have found LOH in 25% of the neurofibromas (corresponding to 53% of the patients). In addition, we found that in the neurofibromas of patients from familial cases the deletions occurred in the allele that is not transmitted with the disease, indicating that both copies of the NF1 gene were inactivated in these tumors. Therefore, the recent reports mentioned above, together with our findings, strongly support the double inactivation of the NF1 gene in benign neurofibromas.     

Mutational and functional analysis of the neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) gene

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is one of the most common autosomal dominant disorders. It is caused by mutations in the NF1 gene which comprises 60 exons and is located on chromosome 17q. The NF1 gene product, neurofibromin, displays partial homology to GTPase-activating protein (GAP). The GAP-related domain (GRD), encoded by exons 20–27a, is the only region of neurofibromin to which a biological function has been ascribed. A total of 320 unrelated NF1 patients were screened for mutations in the GRD-encoding region of the NF1 gene. Sixteen different lesions in the NF1 GRD region were identified in a total of 20 patients. Of these lesions, 14 are novel and together comprise three missense, two nonsense and three splice site mutations plus six deletions of between 1 and 4 bp. The effect of one of the missense mutations (R1391S) was studied by in vitro expression of a site-directed mutant and GAP activity assay. The mutant protein, R1391S, was found to be some 300-fold less active than wild-type NF1 GRD. The mutations reported in this study therefore provide further material for the functional analysis of neurofibromin as well as an insight into the mutational spectrum of the NF1 GRD. Received: 13 July 1996 / Revised: 6 August 1996     

Regulating heart development: the role of Nf1

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is one of the most common human genetic disorders and is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. The gene responsible for this disorder, NF1, encodes neurofibromin, which can function to down-regulate ras activity. Mutations that inactivate NF7 result in elevated levels of ras signaling and increased cell proliferation in some tissues. NF7 functions as a tumor suppressor gene; patients inherit one mutated copy and are believed to acquire a "second hit" in tissues that go on to form benign or malignant tumors. NF7 is expressed widely, yet certain tissues are more susceptible to growth dysregulation in NF1 patients. Cardiovascular defects also contribute to NF1, though the cause remains unclear. In a recent study, we used tissue-specific gene inactivation in mice to study the role of neurofibromin in heart development. A further understanding of neurofibromin function will help to elucidate the pathophysiology of NF1 and will also lead to a better understanding of cell cycle regulation and ras pathways in specific cell types. Finally, we comment on how similar genetic strategies can be used in mice to study the role of additional signaling pathways involved in heart development.     

Regulating Heart Development: The Role of Nf1

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is one of the most common human genetic disorders and is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. The gene responsible for this disorder, NF1, encodes neurofibromin, which can function to down-regulate ras activity. Mutations that inactivate NF1 result in elevated levels of ras signaling and increased cell proliferation in some tissues. NF1 functions as a tumor suppressor gene; patients inherit one mutated copy and are believed to acquire a “second hit” in tissues that go on to form benign or malignant tumors.^1,2 NF1 is expressed widely, yet certain tissues are more susceptible to growth dysregulation in NF1 patients. Cardiovascular defects also contribute to NF1, though the cause remains unclear. In a recent study, we used tissue-specific gene inactivation in mice to study the role of neurofibromin in heart development. A further understanding of neurofibromin function will help to elucidate the pathophysiology of NF1 and will also lead to a better understanding of cell cycle regulation and ras pathways in specific cell types. Finally, we comment on how similar genetic strategies can be used in mice to study the role of additional signaling pathways involved in heart development.     

Deletion and amplification of the HGPRT locus in Chinese hamster cells.

Somatic cell selective techniques and hybridization analyses with a cloned cDNA probe were used to isolate and identify Chinese hamster cell lines in which the X-linked gene for hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HGPRT) has been altered. Two of 19 HGPRT-deficient mutants selected were found to have major DNA deletions affecting the HGPRT locus. Cytogenetic studies revealed that the X chromosome of each deletion mutant had undergone a translocation event, whereas those from the remaining 17 mutants were normal. Phenotypic revertants of the thermosensitive HGPRT mutant RJK526 were isolated, and amplification of the mutant allele was shown to be the predominant mechanism of reversion. Comparisons of restriction enzyme fragments of DNA from deletion versus amplification strains identified two regions of the Chinese hamster genome that contained homology to the cDNA probe. One was shown to be much larger than the 1,600-nucleotide mRNA for HGPRT and to be comprised of linked fragments that contained the functional HGPRT gene. The second was neither transcribed nor tightly linked to the functional gene. These initial studies of HGPRT alterations at the level of DNA thus identified molecular mechanisms of phenotypic variation.     

Evidence for non-homologous end joining and non-allelic homologous recombination in atypical NF1 microdeletions

NF1 microdeletion syndrome is caused by haploinsufficiency of the NF1 gene and of gene(s) located in adjacent flanking regions. Most of the NF1 deletions originate by non-allelic homologous recombination between repeated sequences (REP-P and -M) mapped to 17q11.2, while the remaining deletions show unusual breakpoints. We performed high-resolution FISH analysis of 18 NF1 microdeleted patients with the aims of mapping non-recurrent deletion breakpoints and verifying the presence of additional recombination-prone architectural motifs. This approach allowed us to obtain the sequence of the first junction fragment of an atypical deletion. By conventional FISH, we identified 16 patients with REP-mediated common deletions, and two patients carrying atypical deletions of 1.3 Mb and 3 Mb. Following fibre-FISH, we identified breakpoint regions of 100 kb, which led to the generation of several locus-specific probes restricting the atypical deletion endpoint intervals to a few kilobases. Sequence analysis provided evidence of small blocks of REPs, clustered around the 1.3-Mb deletion breakpoints, probably involved in intrachromatid non-allelic homologous recombination (NAHR), while isolation and sequencing of the 3-Mb deletion junction fragment indicated that a non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) mechanism is implicated.M. Venturin and C. Gervasini contributed equally to the study     

Neurofibromin can inhibit Ras-dependent growth by a mechanism independent of its GTPase-accelerating function.

The NF1 gene, which is altered in patients with type 1 neurofibromatosis, has been postulated to function as a tumor suppressor gene. The NF1 protein product neurofibromin stimulates the intrinsic GTPase activity of active GTP-bound Ras, thereby inactivating it. Consistent with a tumor suppressor function, we have found that the introduction of NF1 in melanoma cell lines that are deficient in neurofibromin inhibited their growth and induced their differentiation. In addition, overexpression of neurofibromin in NIH 3T3 cells was growth inhibitory but did not alter the level of GTP.Ras in the cells. Transformation by v-ras, whose protein product is resistant to GTPase stimulation by neurofibromin, was inhibited in a cell line overexpressing neurofibromin, while transformation by v-raf was not altered. The results demonstrate that NF1 is a tumor suppressor gene that can inhibit Ras-dependent growth by a regulatory mechanism that is independent of neurofibromin's ability to stimulate Ras GTPase.     

Detection of spinal muscular atrophy carriers by nested polymerase chain reaction of single sperm cells

Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive disorder with a carrier frequency of approximately 1 in 40. Approximately 95% of patients have homozygous deletions of exon 7 and/or 8 of the SMN1 gene. Carrier testing for SMA is relatively complex and requires quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR) of genomic DNA to determine SMN1 copy number. The purpose of this study was to assess the feasibility of carrier testing for SMA in males, by nested PCR analysis of SMN1 deletions in single sperm cells. A nested PCR method was developed to amplify SMN1 exon 7 in single cells. Restriction enzyme digestion with DraI was used to differentiate between the highly homologous SMN1 and SMN2 genes. Single sperm cells from five known SMA carriers and six noncarriers were analyzed. Among the five carriers, a total of 132 single sperm cells were analyzed and SMN1 exon 7 deletion was detected in 68 cells (51.5%). In contrast, among the six noncarriers, a total of 136 single sperm cells were analyzed. Of these, an apparent SMN1 exon 7 deletion was detected in four sperm cells. This was interpreted as an allele dropout (ADO) rate of 2.9%. We conclude that nested PCR of SMN1 exon 7 is an accurate and reproducible method for detection of SMA male carriers with a SMN1 deletion.     

A common set of at least 11 functional genes is lost in the majority of NF1 patients with gross deletions

Large deletions of the NF1 locus occur in 5 to 10% of patients with neurofibromatosis and are commonly associated with specific additional abnormalities characterized by mental retardation, dysmorphic features, and intellectual impairment. To characterize the extent of codeleted genes we constructed a long-range physical BAC/PAC map around the NF1 locus between D17S117 and D17S57 and determined the deletion boundaries in seven unrelated patients. Surprisingly, the proximal and distal breakpoints in five of seven patients fall at almost identical positions, resulting in the loss of at least 11 functional genes. Five of six patients investigated showed a de novo deletion on the maternally derived chromosome. Since D17S117 and D17S57 were previously reported as the outer limits for the great majority of NF1 deletions, we suggest that most NF1 patients with deletion of the entire NF1 gene are hemizygous for the same set of at least 10 additional genes, including SHGC-37343, SHGC-2390, SHGC-34232, OMG, EVI2B, EVI2A, WI-9521, WI-6742, SHGC-34334, and KIAA0160, and thus present with a relatively uniform clinical phenotype.     

Construction and characterization of deletions with defined end points in Drosophila using P elements in trans

We used P-element transposase-mediated "male recombination" between two P elements in trans to create genetic deletions that removed a number of loci, including the gene encoding the neuropeptide crustacean cardioactive peptide (CCAP). Two classes of recombinant chromosomes were produced. Approximately one-quarter were viable when homozygous or hemizygous, whereas the remaining lines caused homozygous and hemizygous lethality. Preliminary analyses using PCR and CCAP immunohistochemistry suggested that, whereas the DNA of the viable lines was largely intact, most lethal lines contained chromosomal deletions that were roughly bounded by the insertion sites of the two P elements used. Southern blot analyses of select lethal lines showed that the DNA flanking the deletion was indeed grossly intact whereas the intervening DNA could not be detected. Sequencing across the deletion in three of these lethal lines identified a single line bearing intact genomic DNA on either side of the deletion separated by 30 bp of P-element DNA. The method described here suggests a simple procedure for creating deletions with defined end points. Importantly, it can use preexisting P-element insertion strains and does not rely on the use of transposable elements that are engineered to cause specific DNA rearrangements.     

Copy number variations due to large genomic deletion in X-linked chronic granulomatous disease

Mutations in genes for any of the six subunits of NADPH oxidase cause chronic granulomatous disease (CGD), but almost 2/3 of CGD cases are caused by mutations in the X-linked CYBB gene, also known as NAD (P) H oxidase 2. Approximately 260 patients with CGD have been reported in Japan, of whom 92 were shown to have mutations of the CYBB gene and 16 to have chromosomal deletions. However, there has been very little detailed analysis of the range of the deletion or close understanding of the disease based on this. We therefore analyzed genomic rearrangements in X-linked CGD using array comparative genomic hybridization analysis, revealing the extent and the types of the deletion genes. The subjects were five Japanese X-linked CGD patients estimated to have large base deletions of 1 kb or more in the CYBB gene (four male patients, one female patient) and the mothers of four of those patients. The five Japanese patients were found to range from a patient exhibiting deletions only of the CYBB gene to a female patient exhibiting an extensive DNA deletion and the DMD and CGD phenotype manifested. Of the other three patients, two exhibited CYBB, XK, and DYNLT3 gene deletions. The remaining patient exhibited both a deletion encompassing DNA subsequent to the CYBB region following intron 2 and the DYNLT3 gene and a complex copy number variation involving the insertion of an inverted duplication of a region from the centromere side of DYNLT3 into the deleted region.     

Extensively high load of internal tumors determined by whole body MRI scanning in a patient with neurofibromatosis type 1 and a non-LCR-mediated 2-Mb deletion in 17q11.2

Deletions in 17q11.2 affecting the NF1 gene and surrounding regions occur in 5% of patients with NF1. The two major types of NF1 deletions encompass 1.4-Mb and 1.2-Mb, respectively, and have breakpoints in the NF1 low-copy repeats or in the JJAZ gene and its pseudogene. Deletions larger than 1.4-Mb are rare, and only seven cases have been reported so far. Here, we describe a 26-year-old NF1 patient with an atypical NF1 deletion of 2-Mb. In contrast to the 1.4-Mb deletions, which preferentially occur by interchromosomal recombination during maternal meiosis, the deletion described here occurred intrachromosomally on the paternal chromosome. The centromeric deletion breakpoint lies in an L1-element located 1.3-Mb proximal to the NF1 gene. The telomeric deletion boundary is located in a single copy segment between an AT-rich segment and an AluSx-element in intron 15 of the JJAZ1 gene. Structural analysis implies that non-B DNA conformations at the breakpoints destabilized the duplex DNA and caused double-strand breaks. Although the breakpoints of this 2-Mb deletion are not recurrent, it is conspicuous that one breakpoint is located in the JJAZ1 gene. Paralogous recombination between the JJAZ1 gene and its pseudogene causes the recurrent 1.2 Mb deletions. The genomic architecture of the NF1 gene region, influenced by paralogous sequences such as the JJAZ1 gene and its pseudogene, seems also to stimulate the occurrence of non-recurrent deletions mediated by non-homologous end joining. Patient 442 described here suffers from a very high burden of subdermal neurofibromas. Magnetic resonance imaging of the whole body revealed numerous internal tumors, mainly plexiform neurofibromas and spinal tumors. This demonstrates the value of whole-body MRI scanning in determining the total tumor load, which is an important aspect in genotype/phenotype correlations with regard to large NF1 deletions.     

Type 2 NF1 deletions are highly unusual by virtue of the absence of nonallelic homologous recombination hotspots and an apparent preference for female mitotic recombination

Approximately 5% of patients with neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) exhibit gross deletions that encompass the NF1 gene and its flanking regions. The breakpoints of the common 1.4-Mb (type 1) deletions are located within low-copy repeats (NF1-REPs) and cluster within a 3.4-kb hotspot of nonallelic homologous recombination (NAHR). Here, we present the first comprehensive breakpoint analysis of type 2 deletions, which are a second type of recurring NF1 gene deletion. Type 2 deletions span 1.2 Mb and are characterized by breakpoints located within the SUZ12 gene and its pseudogene, which closely flank the NF1-REPs. Breakpoint analysis of 13 independent type 2 deletions did not reveal any obvious hotspots of NAHR. However, an overrepresentation of polypyrimidine/polypurine tracts and triplex-forming sequences was noted in the breakpoint regions that could have facilitated NAHR. Intriguingly, all 13 type 2 deletions identified so far are characterized by somatic mosaicism, which indicates a positional preference for mitotic NAHR within the NF1 gene region. Indeed, whereas interchromosomal meiotic NAHR occurs between the NF1-REPs giving rise to type 1 deletions, NAHR during mitosis appears to occur intrachromosomally between the SUZ12 gene and its pseudogene, thereby generating type 2 deletions. Such a clear distinction between the preferred sites of mitotic versus meiotic NAHR is unprecedented in any other genomic disorder induced by the local genomic architecture. Additionally, 12 of the 13 mosaic type 2 deletions were found in females. The marked female preponderance among mosaic type 2 deletions contrasts with the equal sex distribution noted for type 1 and/or atypical NF1 deletions. Although an influence of chromatin structure was strongly suspected, no sex-specific differences in the methylation pattern exhibited by the SUZ12 gene were apparent that could explain the higher rate of mitotic recombination in females.     

Fine structure DNA mapping studies of the chromosomal region harboring the genetic defect in neurofibromatosis type 1

To better map the location of the von Recklinghausen neurofibromatosis (NF1) gene, we have characterized a somatic cell hybrid designated 7AE-11. This microcell-mediated, chromosome-transfer construct harbors a centromeric segment and a neo-marked segment from the distal long arm of human chromosome 17. We have identified 269 cosmid clones with human sequences from a 7AE-11 library and, using a panel of somatic cell hybrids with a total of six chromosome 17q breakpoints, have mapped 240 of these clones on chromosome 17q. The panel included a hybrid (NF13) carrying a der(22) chromosome that was isolated from an NF1 patient with a balanced translocation, t(17;22) (q11.2;q11.2). Fifty-three of the cosmids map into a region spanning the NF13 breakpoint, as defined by the two closest flanking breakpoints (17q11.2 and 17q11.2-q12). RFLP clones from a subset of these cosmids have been mapped by linkage analysis in normal reference families, to localize the NF1 gene more precisely and to enhance the potential for genetic diagnosis of this disorder. The cosmids in the NF1 region will be an important resource for testing DNA blots of large-fragment restriction-enzyme digests from NF1 patient cell lines, to detect rearrangements in patients' DNA and to identify the 17;22 NF1 translocation breakpoint.     

An absence of cutaneous neurofibromas associated with a 3-bp inframe deletion in exon 17 of the NF1 gene (c.2970-2972 delAAT): evidence of a clinically significant NF1 genotype-phenotype correlation

Neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) is characterized by cafe-au-lait spots, skinfold freckling, and cutaneous neurofibromas. No obvious relationships between small mutations (<20 bp) of the NF1 gene and a specific phenotype have previously been demonstrated, which suggests that interaction with either unlinked modifying genes and/or the normal NF1 allele may be involved in the development of the particular clinical features associated with NF1. We identified 21 unrelated probands with NF1 (14 familial and 7 sporadic cases) who were all found to have the same c.2970-2972 delAAT (p.990delM) mutation but no cutaneous neurofibromas or clinically obvious plexiform neurofibromas. Molecular analysis identified the same 3-bp inframe deletion (c.2970-2972 delAAT) in exon 17 of the NF1 gene in all affected subjects. The Delta AAT mutation is predicted to result in the loss of one of two adjacent methionines (codon 991 or 992) ( Delta Met991), in conjunction with silent ACA-->ACG change of codon 990. These two methionine residues are located in a highly conserved region of neurofibromin and are expected, therefore, to have a functional role in the protein. Our data represent results from the first study to correlate a specific small mutation of the NF1 gene to the expression of a particular clinical phenotype. The biological mechanism that relates this specific mutation to the suppression of cutaneous neurofibroma development is unknown.