Perspectives on holoprosencephaly: Part I. Epidemiology, genetics, and syndromology

This paper provides an updated, comprehensive, critical review of the epidemiology, genetics, and syndromic aspects of holoprosencephaly and is divided into four parts. In the first part, epidemiologic aspects are discussed under the following headings: prevalence, temporal trends, socioeconomic status, exposure to environmental teratogens, maternal and paternal ages, pregnancy histories, and birth weights. The second part analyzes the facial phenotypes because the genetic and syndromic aspects of holoprosencephaly cannot be understood without knowledge of facial variability and its meaning. Topics discussed include cyclopia, ethmocephaly, cebocephaly, median cleft lip, and less severe facial dysmorphism. The third section, on genetics, analyzes associated anomalies, chromosomal and non-chromosomal holoprosencephaly, family studies, twin studies, genetics of nonsyndromic holoprosencephaly, and recurrence risks. The final section on syndromology summarizes 48 conditions in which some degree of holoprosencephaly may be a feature.     

Selected clinical research involving the central nervous system

This paper updates three clinical research projects involving the central nervous system. Discussions of conditions with encephalocele include several associations: encephalocele/craniostenosis, transsphenoidal encephalocele/hypothalamic-pituitary dysfunction, encephalocele/oculo-auriculo-vertebral spectrum, and encephalocele/frontonasal dysplasia. The relationship between oculo-auriculo-vetebral spectrum with encephalocele and frontonasal dysplasia with epibulbar dermoids and ear tags is also discussed and an explanation for encephalocele formation in the Apert syndrome is provided. Studies of the central nervous system in Apert syndrome indicate that distortion ventriculomegaly is common, but progressive hydrocephalus occurs infrequently. A recurrent pattern of abnormalities was discerned consisting of megalencephaly, gyral abnormalities, and defects of the corpus callosum and limbic structures. Five neuropathologic studies lend further support to this pattern of CNS anomalies in the Apert syndrome. In a study of holoprosencephaly, eight principles governing associated facial dysmorphism were derived. Each diagnostic category was shown to have its own frequency and range of holoprosencephalic faces. Some categories, such as del(13q), have narrow ranges; others, such as trisomy 13 syndrome, have broad ranges. However, no broad diagnostic range is known to include agnathia-holoprosencephaly and other severe forms of facial dysmorphism without agnathia. Absent maxillary incisors and a single maxillary central incisor are extremely common in holoprosencephaly with severe facial dysmorphism and may occur on occasion as a striking microform of holoprosencephaly, most commonly in the autosomal dominant form.     

Teratogenic effect of AY 9944 in rats: importance of the day of administration and maternal plasma cholesterol level

An inhibitor of cholesterol synthesis, AY 9944 (trans-1,4-bis(2-chlorobenzylaminomethyl) cyclohexane dihydrochloride) is teratogenic. A single dose of AY 9944 (50 mg/kg or 75 mg/kg) given to Wistar pregnant rats on the second, fourth, sixth, seventh, or eighth day of gestation induced malformations such as holoprosencephaly. They were often limited to isolated pituitary agenesis. The highest percentage of holoprosencephalic fetuses was found when AY 9944 was given on the fourth day of gestation. Whatever the dose and the day of administration, the lower the maternal plasma cholesterol level, the more frequent were holoprosencephalic fetuses. Therefore, it is suggested that the decrease in maternal plasma cholesterol level is at least one of the factors provoking holoprosencephaly.     

Holoprosencephaly: clinical, anatomic, and molecular dimensions

Holoprosencephaly is addressed under the following headings: alobar, semilobar, and lobar holoprosencephaly; arrhinencephaly; agenesis of the corpus callosum; pituitary abnormalities; hindbrain abnormalities; syntelencephaly; aprosencephaly/atelencephaly; neural tube defects; facial anomalies; median cleft lip; minor facial anomalies; single maxillary central incisor; holoprosencephaly-like phenotype; epidemiology; genetic causes of holoprosencephaly; teratogenic causes of holoprosencephaly; SHH mutations; ZIC2 mutations; SIX3 mutations; TGIF mutations; PTCH mutations; GLI2 mutations; FAST1 mutations; TDGF1 mutations; and DHCR7 mutations.     

Neural crest anomaly syndromes in children with spina bifida.

A hereditary contribution to the etiology of neural tube defects (NTDs) has been suggested by clinical studies and animal models. To evaluate the hypothesis that common genes are important for both neural tube defects and neural crest anomalies, we examined children with developmental abnormalities of the spinal cord for anomalies of neural crest-derived structures. Neural crest anomalies, particularly auditory and pigmentary disorders, were identified and classified according to inheritance and type of anomaly. Of the 515 children screened, 44 (8.5%) had neural crest anomalies, 20 (3.9%) of which were apparently familial. Another 19 (3.7%) families had neural crest anomalies in two or more close relations, but the NTD subject was unaffected. Sixteen (3.1%) children with NTDs had a recognizable syndrome, including nine (1.7%) with a subtype of the Waardenburg syndromes. The coincidence of familial neural crest anomaly syndromes in subjects with spina bifida implies that defects in genes underlying neural crest development may contribute to the etiology of neural tube defects in a fraction of cases. The rate of anomalies and familial syndromes of neural crest-derived structures must be assessed in an adequate control sample to evaluate whether or not these abnormalities constitute risk factors for NTDs.     

Anatomical observations of holoprosencephaly in swine

In a study of swine congenital anomalies, nine newborn piglets with varying degrees of optic hypotelorism including cyclopia were collected. Nasal and maxillary development were abnormal in all animals regardless of the degree of eye fusion. All animals except one had intact upper lips and hard palates that carried two or three small extopic teeth. The "snout" was only a medial wedge-shaped rudiment projecting from the upper lip. It was distally covered by a typical snout-like glabrous epithelium and carried small vibrissae. Six animals also had a tubular proboscis dorsal to the eye. The distal tip of the proboscis was covered by glabrous epithelium. External nares and nasal passageways, albeit blind-ended, were prominent in the proboscis. The nasofrontal bones projected into the base of the proboscis. Seven piglets were hairless except for fine vibrissae and some eyebrow hairs. All animals had some degree of ear abnormalities, e.g., malposition and absence of external auditory meatus. In all animals the brain was malformed. This abnormality varied from complete absence of the forebrain to an alobar structure with gyri. The remainder of the body of each animal was normal. Developmental anomalies of the nose and eye generally reflect malformations of the forebrain, although the etiology of these defects is unclear. The cyclopia associated with the medial proboscis suggests that both the telencephalon and diencephalon are dysplastic. The presence of glabrous epithelium in two regions on the face suggests that studies of the development of the midline face in the swine will help to elucidate the etiology of the holoprosencephalic series. In this way the pig may prove to be an excellent modeling system for human holoprosencephaly.     

Craniofacial anomalies: from development to molecular pathogenesis

Advances in developmental biology combined with progress in human genetics are helping us decipher how the craniofacial region develops and how the consequences of misdirected development result in malformation. This review describes the molecular etiology of a number of craniofacial developmental anomalies. The more common craniofacial anomalies cleft lip and palate and craniosynostosis, as well as cleidocranial dysplasia, hemifacial microsomia, holoprosencephaly, enlarged parietal foramina, Treacher Collins syndrome and cherubism are discussed.     

Agnathia malformation complex associated with a cystic distention of the oral cavity and hydranencepahly

A fetus with a severe variant of the agnathia malformation complex (AMC) was delivered following prenatal diagnostic evaluation with ultrasonography. The constellation of anomalies that accompanied the agnathia included holoprosencephaly, hydranencephaly, situs inversus, and polysplenia. Recently, several authors have reported the association between the agnathia, holoprosencephaly, and situs inversus. We present evidence which suggests that, when hydranencephaly is also present, this may represent the most severe variant of the AMC. Our case is presented, the literature is reviewed, and a hypothesis regarding the embryopathologic mechanism is discussed.     

On the association profound nerve deafness, semilobar holoprosencephaly, and minor midline developmental anomalies

A two-year-old boy with the combination of profound nerve deafness and semilobar holoprosencephaly associated with minor midline developmental anomalies is reported. In a review of the literature we could not find other examples of this possible syndromic association.     

FGFR2 exon IIIa and IIIc mutations in Crouzon, Jackson-Weiss, and Pfeiffer syndromes: evidence for missense changes, insertions, and a deletion due to alternative RNA splicing.

Fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 (FGFR2) mutations have been associated with the craniosynostotic conditions Crouzon, Jackson-Weiss, and Pfeiffer syndromes. Previously, mutations were described in the exons IIIa and IIIc, which form the extracellular, third immunoglobulin-like domain (IgIII) and adjacent linker regions, both of which are normally involved in ligand binding. For all three conditions, mutations were found in exon IIIc. Only in Crouzon syndrome were mutations identified in exon IIIa. In this study, 39 cases with one of these three conditions were screened for exon IIIa or IIIc mutations. Eleven mutations are reported in 17 unrelated cases. Mutations in exon IIIa are identified for not only Crouzon but also Jackson-Weiss and Pfeiffer syndromes. Four mutations in either exon IIIa or exon IIIc reported only in Crouzon syndrome are present also in one of the other two syndromes. Two insertions, one in exon IIIa in a Crouzon syndrome patient and the other in exon IIIc in a Pfeiffer syndrome patient, were observed. The latter mutation has the same alternative RNA splicing effect as a reported synonymous mutation for Crouzon syndrome. A missense mutation was detected in one Pfeiffer syndrome family in which two members had craniosynostosis without limb anomalies. The inter- and intrafamilial variability in expression of FGFR2 mutations suggests that these three syndromes, presumed to be clinically distinct, are instead representative of a spectrum of related craniosynostotic and digital disorders.     

The Ubiquitin E3 Ligase NOSIP Modulates Protein Phosphatase 2A Activity in Craniofacial Development

Holoprosencephaly is a common developmental disorder in humans characterised by incomplete brain hemisphere separation and midface anomalies. The etiology of holoprosencephaly is heterogeneous with environmental and genetic causes, but for a majority of holoprosencephaly cases the genes associated with the pathogenesis could not be identified so far. Here we report the generation of knockout mice for the ubiquitin E3 ligase NOSIP. The loss of NOSIP in mice causes holoprosencephaly and facial anomalies including cleft lip/palate, cyclopia and facial midline clefting. By a mass spectrometry based protein interaction screen we identified NOSIP as a novel interaction partner of protein phosphatase PP2A. NOSIP mediates the monoubiquitination of the PP2A catalytic subunit and the loss of NOSIP results in an increase in PP2A activity in craniofacial tissue in NOSIP knockout mice. We conclude, that NOSIP is a critical modulator of brain and craniofacial development in mice and a candidate gene for holoprosencephaly in humans.     

RASopathien

The RASopathies comprise Noonan syndrome, related disorders (CFC, Costello and LEOPARD syndromes) as well as neurofibromatosis type 1 and similar diseases (Legius and NF1-Noonan syndromes). The common pathogenetic mechanism is a constitutional dysregulation of the RAS-MAPK signaling pathway resulting in typical patterns of congenital and developmental anomalies with very variable expression. Typical clinical manifestations include cardiac anomalies, growth retardation, craniofacial dysmorphism and developmental delay. There is also an increased risk of tumor development depending on the specific entity and the genotype. Knowledge of the molecular basis has significantly contributed to our understanding of clinical overlaps and differences among these diseases. Genetic diagnostics are widely available. Current treatment options for RAS-MAPK pathway disorders are symptomatic. Interdisciplinary management and a lifelong follow-up are basic elements of the therapeutic concept.     

Holoprosencephaly in a fetal macaque (Macaca nemestrina) following weekly exposure to ethanol

Previous studies in rodents have indicated that the facial changes of fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) closely resemble those of a mild form of holoprosencephaly. In order to examine this relationship in non-human primates, we evaluated a 133-day gestation macaque (Macaca nemestrina) with holoprosencephaly, median cleft lip and palate, and encephalocele. The mother had been given ethanol once per week (1.8 g/kg body weight) from weeks 2 to 19 postconception. Diagnosis of holoprosencephaly was made following ultrasound evaluation for polyhydramnios and delivery of the female fetus by caesarean section. Another fetus of identical age was delivered by caesarean section for use as a control. Both fetuses were studied by anthropometric, gross, radiographic, and histologic techniques. In the fetus exposed to alcohol, no extracranial anomalies were identified and the karyotype was normal. The brain was micrencephalic, with absent olfactory bulbs, tracts, optic nerves and chiasma, fused frontal lobes, and a single, dilated lateral ventricle; a parietooccipital encephalocele consisted of thin, dysplastic cortex bordering the ventricle; the cerebellum was dysplastic and superiorly displaced. Within the craniofacial complex, anophthalmia was bilateral; premaxillary components were absent, palatal shelves separate, the maxillae closeset, and the ethmoid bone small and deformed. Most of these defects are similar to those encountered in humans with holoprosencephaly and support the hypothesis of shared etiologic and pathogenetic relations between the facial anomalies of fetal alcohol syndrome and holoprosencephaly.     

Interpretation of isolated agenesis of the pituitary.

Cholesterol synthesis inhibitors administered to rats caused more or less complete forms of the holoprosencephalic syndrome, consisting of severe abnormalities of the brain, sense organs and pituitary. The absence of the pituitary was also observed in fetuses without externally visible cephalic abnormalities. These observations suggest that the isolated absence of the pituitary is the lesser form of the holoprosencephalic syndrome. This interpretation is also valid for cases of isolated absence of the pituitary observed in humans.     

The community of human malformation syndromes that shares ectodermal dysplasia and deformities of the hands and feet.

Syndromes of human congenital malformation may be classified be recognizing communities of syndromes that share multiple phenotypic similarities involving their principal diagnostic features. A community of syndromes that shares various expressions of ectodermal dysplasia and various deformities of the hands and feet is proposed; these syndromes are divisible into two classes according to the presence or absence of anomalies in the nasal or labial regions of the face. The dysmorphogenetic validity of the division is supported by the fact that the syndromes without nasal or labial anomalies have a high frequency of sensorineural deafness as one expression of ectodermal dysplasia whereas those without such anomalies do not. The usefulness of such a syndromal community as a base for evolving a taxonomic scheme of dysmorphogenetic relatedness amongst different syndromes is illustrated.     

Microcephaly in familial holoprosencephaly

The holoprosencephaly sequence (HS) is characterized by abnormalities in forebrain cleavage and midface development. Familial holoprosencephaly has been reported in several families and there appears to be variable expression of the disorder in those who inherit the gene. Previous investigators have suggested hypotelorism and/or missing central incisors as mild manifestations of autosomal dominant HS. We evaluated a large kindred with three individuals with severe brain anomalies and 12 individuals with minor manifestations of the disorder. The most consistent sign in those mildly affected was microcephaly. We suggest that head circumference is an important part of the evaluation of the relatives of a patient with holoprosencephaly.     

Atelencephalic microcephaly: craniofacial anatomy and morphologic comparisons with holoprosencephaly and anencephaly

This is the first detailed report of the craniofacial anatomy of atelencephaly. Comparisons were made with a control specimen and others with holoprosencephaly, anencephaly, and anencephaly with holoprosencephalic facial features. In the atelencephalic fetus, severe microcephaly, flattened calvaria, and partial synostosis of the metopic suture were apparent. The cranial fossae were much smaller than usual; lesser wings of the sphenoid were folded into a rounded basal mass. Facial features were pronounced, and orbits were hyperteloric, lowset, and rounded. Ethmoidal cartilages, nasal bones, and maxillary structures were distorted and elongated. The secondary palate was displaced inferiorly and cleft. Because major components of the craniofacial complex were generally present, although misshapen, changes in the atelencephalic skull seem to be deformations rather than malformations. Differences in the cranial morphology of associated disorders--holoprosencephaly and anencephaly--can be construed as aberrations of separate developmental fields. Relationships between atelencephaly and these fields are unclear.     

Syndrome of renal, genital and feet malformations.

We report a 2 months old girl affected by renal hypoplasia, genital abnormalities, syndactyly and a pattern of minor anomalies. Although the pattern of malformations overlaps the Townwes-Brock syndrome and that reported by Green et al in 1996, differential diagnosis was made with other several syndromes including acral and renal anomalies.