Retinoic acid respecifies limb bud cells in vitro.

Retinoic acid (RA) is known to have dramatic effects on limb pattern formation and has been shown to exert its effects on limbs by converting anterior limb bud cells into cells with posterior positional properties. In this study we find that dissociated posterior limb bud cells from chick and mouse embryos cultured at high density (micromass cultures) are able to stimulate the formation of supernumerary digits when grafted into developing wing buds and that the positional identity of both chick and mouse limb bud cells can be maintained for finite periods of time in vitro. Furthermore, using this assay system we have tested whether anterior cells from mouse and chick limb buds can be converted into cells with posterior identity by exposure to RA in vitro. We find that anterior limb bud cells acquire posterior properties after culture in the presence of RA.     

Mouse limb bud cells respond to retinoic acid in vitro with reduced growth.

Retinoic acid (RA) has dramatic effects on the pattern of developing and regenerating vertebrate limbs. These effects are considered to result from RA-induced changes in the positional identity of limb cells, and involve the formation of extra structures. Whether the growth required to form the supernumerary parts of the pattern is a primary effect of RA treatment or a secondary effect that follows after a change in positional identity is not at present known. In this paper we have investigated the effects of RA treatment on the growth of cells from anterior and posterior halves of mouse limb buds in vitro. We observed that under our culture conditions, limb bud cells treated with 1 nM to 1 microM RA (0.3 ng/ml to 300 ng/ml) continue to grow but do so at a significantly slower rate than control cultures. There is a maximum inhibition of growth (50% of controls) between 10 nM and 100 nM RA, which corresponds to the measured range of concentrations of RA in vivo. Our observation of a significant decrease in growth rate over a wide range of RA concentrations is consistent with comparable reports of growth inhibition for a large number of other cell types in vitro as well as with the observation that exogenous RA inhibits blastemal growth in amphibians during the period of exposure to RA. We propose that the effects of RA on growth, either enhancement in vivo or reduction in vitro, can be seen as consequences of the ability of RA to alter positional identity.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Differential cell affinity and sorting of anterior and posterior cells during outgrowth of recombinant avian limb buds

To examine the role of position-specific differences in cell-cell affinity, recombinant limb buds composed of dissociated and reaggregated cells derived from anterior (A) and posterior (P) limb bud fragments were analyzed. Dissociated anterior and/or posterior cells were differentially labeled, and their behavior was analyzed during recombinant limb bud outgrowth. We find that anterior and posterior cells sort out from one another to form alternating anterior and posterior stripes of cells that extend distally along the proximal-distal axis. These alternating stripes are prominent across the A/P axis in whole-mount preparations of recombinant limb buds after 48 h of outgrowth when the presumptive autopod is dorsal-ventrally flattened and digit rudiments are not evident. After 96 h, when digital and interdigital regions are clearly defined, we find evidence that A/P stripes do not follow obvious anatomical boundaries. The formation of A/P stripes is not inhibited by grafts of ZPA tissue, suggesting that polarizing activity does not influence cell-cell affinity early in limb outgrowth. In vitro studies provide evidence that cell sorting is not dependent on the limb bud ectoderm or the AER; however, cells sort out without organizing into stripes. Gene expression studies using anterior-specific (Alx-4) and posterior-specific (Shh, Bmp-2, and Hoxd-13) marker genes failed to reveal expression domains that corresponded to stripe formation. Control recombinant limb buds composed of anterior, central, or posterior mesenchyme formed digits in a position-specific manner. A/P recombinant limb buds that develop to later stages form digits that are characteristic of central recombinant limbs. These data provide the first definitive evidence of A/P cell sorting during limb outgrowth in vivo and suggest that differential cell affinities play a role in modulating cell behavior during distal outgrowth.     

Intercalation and the cellular origin of supernumerary limbs in Xenopus

The hypothesis that a specialized polarizing zone controls the pattern of the anterior-posterior axis during limb development in Xenopus has been tested by analysing the cellular contribution to supernumerary limbs. Supernumerary limbs were generated by grafting hindlimb buds contralaterally between X. borealis and X. laevis to appose anterior and posterior limb tissues. Cells derived from these two species of Xenopus are readily identified by staining with quinacrine. The analysis of cellular contribution showed that supernumerary limbs consist of approximately half anterior-derived (57%) and half posterior-derived (43%) cells. These data are not consistent with the polarizing zone theory but are consistent with the hypothesis that both supernumerary limbs and normally developing limbs arise from intercalary interactions between limb bud cells with different positional values.     

Stimulation of embryonic mouse limb bud mesenchymal cell growth by peptide growth factors

The possible role of peptide growth factors in mammalian intrauterine cell growth has been investigated using primary cultures of undifferentiated mesenchymal cells from 11-day mouse embryo limb buds. When grown as monolayer cultures, proliferation is greatly favored by high cell densities. In medium containing 0.2% serum, purified epidermal growth factor (EGF), fibroblast growth factor (FGF), multiplication stimulating activity (MSA), insulin, and somatomedin-C (Sm-C) do not increase cell growth, but a 30-40,000 molecular weight component of mouse fetal liver conditioned medium is stimulatory. On the other hand, when limb bud cells are grown as high density or micromass cultures, a method which better approximates in vivo growth conditions, all of the purified growth factors tested stimulate cell growth significantly. These growth factors have additive effects when used in combination, the best stimulation being observed with liver medium (10% v/v), EGF (10 ng/ml), FGF (200 ng/ml), and either insulin (1 microgram/ml) or Sm-C (20 ng/ml). We conclude that the response of limb bud cells to growth stimulation is influenced by the manner in which the cells are cultured and that at least four different growth factors are required for optimal in vitro proliferation. One of these, the active component of liver medium, appears to be a previously uncharacterized growth factor.     

Compatible limb patterning mechanisms in urodeles and anurans

We have experimentally tested the similarity of limb pattern-forming mechanisms in urodeles and anurans. To determine whether the mechanisms of limb outgrowth are equivalent, we compared the results of two kinds of reciprocal limb bud grafts between Xenopus and axolotls: contralateral grafts to confront anterior and posterior positions of graft and host, and ipsilateral grafts to align equivalent circumferential positions. Axolotl limb buds grafted to Xenopus hosts are immunologically rejected at a relatively early stage. Prior to rejection, however, experimental (but not control) grafts form supernumerary digits. Xenopus limb buds grafted to axolotl hosts are not rejected within the time frame of the experiment and therefore can be used to test the ability of frog cells to elicit responses from axolotl tissue that are similar to those that are elicited by axolotl tissue itself. When Xenopus buds were grafted to axolotl limb stumps so as to align circumferential positions, the majority of limbs did not form any supernumerary digits. However, in experimental grafts, where anterior and posterior of host and graft were misaligned, supernumerary digits formed at positional discontinuities. These results suggest that Xenopus/axolotl cell interactions result in responses that are similar to axolotl/axolotl cell interactions. Furthermore, axolotl and Xenopus cells can cooperate to build recognizable skeletal elements, despite large differences in cell size and growth rate between the two species. We infer from these results that urodeles and anurans share the same limb pattern-forming mechanisms, including compatible positional signals that allow appropriate localized cellular interactions between the two species. Our results suggest an approach for understanding homology of the tetrapod limb based on experimental cellular interactions.     

Behavior of cells in artificially made cell aggregates and tissue fragments after grafting to developing hind limb buds in Xenopus laevis

During vertebrate limb development, the limb bud grows along the proximo-distal (P-D) direction, with the cells changing their adhesiveness. To know whether the position-related differences in cell adhesiveness are actually utilized by morphogenesis to constitute limb structures, we grafted cell aggregates made of dissociated cells derived from different positions and stages of developing hind limb buds into developing hind limb buds and observed the behavior of the cells. Cell aggregates made of dissociated mesenchymal cells from two different origins were implanted in different positions and stages of limb buds or grafted on limb stumps made by cutting. The two grafted cell populations in the aggregate always sorted out from each other, but their patterning of sorting-out was quite different according to the transplanted regions. In summary, cells in the aggregate that have closer positional identity to the transplanted site were always situated at the boundary between host and donor cells. The pattern of sorting-out seemed to be determined by the relative adhesiveness of surrounding cells to the constituent cells of the aggregates. We also transplanted fragments dissected out from different regions along the P-D axis into st. 50 limb buds. The descendants of grafted cells moved distally to the region corresponding to their positional identity and participated in the formation of more distal structures from that point. These results suggest that the difference in cell adhesiveness may probably play a role in arranging cells along the P-D axis of a developing limb bud.     

Temporal pattern of posterior positional identity in mouse limb buds

This study describes the temporal pattern of posterior positional identity in mouse limb bud cells. To do this wedges of tissue from the posterior edge of mouse limb buds at various stages (limb stages: Wanek et al., 1989b. J. Exp. Zool. 249, 41-49) were grafted to the anterior edge of a host chick embryo wing bud. Grafts of mouse posterior cells are able to induce the formation of supernumerary digits every time when they are taken from buds from stage 3 through stage 6. At stage 7, the frequency declines and by stage 8 the chick cells no longer respond. The results indicate a change in tissue properties at stage 7, which progresses by stage 8 to the point at which posterior positional identity is no longer detectable by this assay. These temporal changes in this aspect of limb pattern formation can be used as an additional criterion to guide the identification of genes involved in the specification of posterior positional identity.     

Fibroblast Growth Factor 4 Directs Gap Junction Expression in the Mesenchyme of the Vertebrate Limb Bud

Pattern in the developing limb depends on signaling by polarizing region mesenchyme cells, which are located at the posterior margin of the bud tip. Here we address the underlying cellular mechanisms. We show in the intact bud that connexin 43 (Cx43) and Cx32 gap junctions are at higher density between distal posterior mesenchyme cells at the tip of the bud than between either distal anterior or proximal mesenchyme cells. These gradients disappear when the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) is removed. Fibroblast growth factor 4 (FGF4) produced by posterior AER cells controls signaling by polarizing cells. We find that FGF4 doubles gap junction density and substantially improves functional coupling between cultured posterior mesenchyme cells. FGF4 has no effect on cultured anterior mesenchyme, suggesting that any effects of FGF4 on responding anterior mesenchyme cells are not mediated by a change in gap junction density or functional communication through gap junctions. In condensing mesenchyme cells, connexin expression is not affected by FGF4. We show that posterior mesenchyme cells maintained in FGF4 under conditions that increase functional coupling maintain polarizing activity at in vivo levels. Without FGF4, polarizing activity is reduced and the signaling mechanism changes. We conclude that FGF4 regulation of cell–cell communication and polarizing signaling are intimately connected.     

A gradient of gap junctional communication along the anterior-posterior axis of the developing chick limb bud.

A modification of the scrape-loading/dye transfer technique was used to study gap junctional communication along the anterior-posterior (A-P) axis of embryonic chick wing buds at an early stage of development (stage 20/21) when positional values along the A-P axis are being specified. Extensive intercellular transfer of the gap junction-permeable dye, lucifer yellow, from scrape-loaded mesenchymal cells to contiguous cells occurs in the posterior mesenchymal tissue of the wing bud adjacent to the zone of polarizing activity, which is thought to be the source of a diffusible morphogen that specifies A-P positional identity according to its local concentration. Considerably less transfer of lucifer yellow dye occurs in scrape-loaded mesenchymal tissue in the middle of the limb bud compared to posterior mesenchymal tissue, and little or no transfer of lucifer yellow is observed in the mesenchymal tissue in the anterior portion of the limb bud. No intercellular transfer of the gap junction-impermeable dye, rhodamine dextran, occurs in any region of the limb bud. These results indicate that there is a gradient of gap junctional communication along the A-P axis of the developing chick wing bud. This gradient of gap junctional communication along the A-P axis might generate a graded distribution of a relatively low molecular weight intracellular regulatory molecule involved in specifying A-P positional identities.     

Preservation of the ability of dissociated quail wing bud mesoderm to elicit a position-related differentiative response

Previous studies showed that grafting wedges of fresh or cultured anterior quail wing mesoderm into posterior slits in chick wing buds resulted in the formation of supernumerary cartilage in a high percentage of cases. When anterior quail mesoderm, which had been dissociated into single cells and pelleted by centrifugation, was grafted into posterior slits of host chick wing buds, supernumerary rods or nodules of cartilage formed in 74.3% of the cases. Few supernumerary skeletal structures formed following control operations in which pelleted dissociated anterior or posterior mesoderm was grafted into homologous locations in host chick wing buds. When pelleted, dissociated anterior mesoderm was cultured in vitro for 1 or 2 days prior to being implanted in posterior locations, the incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation increased to 95.5% and 93.8%, respectively. The incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation following control orthotopic grafts of cultured mesoderm was 11.8% for 1-day and 31% for 2-day cultured anterior mesoderm; for 1- and 2-day cultured posterior mesoderm, the incidence of supernumerary cartilage formation was 20% and 41.7%, respectively. Longer-term culture resulted in a substantial decrease in the percentage of supernumerary cartilage after anterior to posterior grafts and an increase in the incidence of supernumerary cartilage from control grafts. The results demonstrate that quail anterior wing bud mesodermal cells do not need to maintain constant contact with one another in order to retain the ability to form or stimulate the formation of supernumerary cartilage after being grafted into a posterior location in a host wing bud. This ability is retained when the pelleted dissociated mesoderm is cultured in vitro outside the limb field for at least 1 to 2 days.     

Posterior apical ectodermal ridge removal in the chick wing bud triggers a series of events resulting in defective anterior pattern formation

The ability of the anterior apical ectodermal ridge to promote outgrowth in the chick wing bud when disconnected from posterior apical ridge was examined by rotating the posterior portion of the stage-19/20 to stage-21 wing bud around its anteroposterior axis. This permitted contact between the anterior and posterior mesoderm, without removing wing bud tissue. In a small but significant number of cases (10/54), anterior structures (digit 2) formed spatially isolated from posterior structures (digits 3 and 4). Thus, continuity with posterior ridge is not a prerequisite for anterior-ridge function in the wing bud. Nevertheless, posterior-ridge removal does result in anterior limb truncation. To investigate events leading to anterior truncation, we examined cell death patterns in the wing bud following posterior-ridge removal. We observed an abnormal area of necrosis along the posterior border of the wing bud at 6-12 h following posterior-ridge removal. This was followed by necrosis in the distal, anterior mesoderm at 48 h postoperatively and subsequent anterior truncation. Clearly, healthy posterior limb bud mesoderm is needed for anterior limb bud survival and development. We propose that anterior truncation is the direct result of anterior mesodermal cell death and that this may not be related to positional specification of anterior cells. In our view, cell death of anterior mesoderm, after posterior mesoderm removal, should not be used as evidence for a role in position specification by the polarizing zone during the limb bud stages of development. We suggest that the posterior mesoderm that maintains the anterior mesoderm need not be restricted to the mapped polarizing zone, but is more extensively distributed in the limb bud.     

Interplay between activator-inhibitor coupling and cell-matrix adhesion in a cellular automaton model for chondrogenic patterning

We present a stochastic cellular automaton model for the behavior of limb bud precartilage mesenchymal cells undergoing chondrogenic patterning. This "agent-oriented" model represents cells by points on a lattice that obey rules motivated by experimental findings. The "cells" follow these rules as autonomous agents, interacting with other cells and with the microenvironments cell activities produce. The rules include random cell motion, production and lateral deposition of a substrate adhesion molecule (SAM, corresponding to fibronectin), production and release of a diffusible growth factor ("activator," corresponding to TGF-beta) that stimulates production of the SAM, and another diffusible factor ("inhibitor") that suppresses the activity of the activator. We implemented the cellular automaton on a two-dimensional (2D) square lattice to emulate the quasi-2D micromass culture extensively used to study patterning in avian limb bud precartilage cells. We identified parameters that produce nodular patterns that resemble, in size and distribution, cell condensations in leg-cell cultures, thus establishing a correspondence between in vitro and in silico results. We then studied the in vitro and in silico micromass cultures experimentally. We altered the standard in vitro micromass culture by diluting the initial cell density, transiently exposing it to exogenous activator, suppressing the inhibitor, and constitutively activating fibronectin production. We altered the standard in silico micromass culture in each case by changing the corresponding parameter. In vitro and in silico experiments agreed well. We also used the model to test hypotheses for differences in the in vitro patterns of cells derived from chick embryo forelimb and hindlimb. We discuss the applicability of this model to limb development in vivo and to other organ development.     

A gradient of responsiveness to the growth-promoting activity of ZPA (zone of polarizing activity) in the chick limb bud

Limb bud mesoderm of stage 22-23 embryos was dissected into four pieces along the anteroposterior axis and dissociated cells of each region were separately cultured under various conditions. When the cells were cultured in medium containing 0.1% fetal calf serum (serum-poor medium) only a slight increase in cell number occurred in the cultures of all four regions. However, when the cells were cultured in medium containing 10% FCS, only cells of two central regions proliferated rapidly, and no growth promotion was observed in cells in the most anterior and posterior regions. Using the serum-poor medium, we examined the growth-promoting effects of cocultured limb bud fragments and of some growth factors on the cells of four regions. Anterior, distal, and proximal fragments promoted cell proliferation and their promotive effect on the cells of each region was equal. On the other hand, posterior fragments (containing ZPA) showed stronger promotive effects on preaxial cells than on postaxial cells. For comparison with the growth-promotive effect of the posterior fragment, fibroblast growth factor (FGF), epidermal growth factor (EGF), insulin, and retinoic acid were tested in cell culture. FGF showed position-dependent growth promotion, while EGF and insulin promoted growth in the cells of all four regions to a similar degree. Retinoic acid showed no effect on cell growth at low concentrations, and was rather toxic at high concentrations. These results suggest that the cells of the posterior region secrete an FGF-like growth factor(s), which controls normal limb development and experimental duplicate formation.     

Organization of positional information in the axolotl limb

We have used the phenomenon of position-dependent growth stimulation, brought about by the confrontation of cells with dissimilar positional values, to reveal the organization of positional information in the center of the upper and lower arms of axolotls. When either humerus or radius was transplanted into either dorsal or posterior positions, extra growth leading to the formation of supernumerary digits occurred following amputation through the graft. However, transplants of humerus or radius into anterior or ventral positions did not lead to the formation of any additional digits. The ulna by contrast was capable of stimulating supernumerary digit formation when transplanted into anterior, posterior, dorsal, or ventral positions. We interpret these results to indicate that the humerus and radius are surrounded by symmetrically arranged anterior and ventral positional values, whereas the ulna is surrounded by a complete asymmetrical set of angular positional values. We use our proposed arrangement for the positional information in the limb center to explain a number of previous experimental findings. In addition, we provide an explanation, in terms of the underlying positional information, for the structural and developmental relationships between the different skeletal elements of the vertebrate limb, and in particular for the anatomical pattern known as Gregory's pyramid.     

Involvement of Frzb-1 in mesenchymal condensation and cartilage differentiation in the chick limb bud

In developing limb bud, mesenchymal cells form cellular aggregates called "mesenchymal condensations". These condensations show the prepattern of skeletal elements of the limb prior to cartilage differentiation. Roles of various signaling molecules in chondrogenesis in the limb bud have been reported. One group of signaling factors includes the Wnt proteins, which have been shown to have an inhibitory effect on chondrogenesis in the limb bud. Therefore, regulation of Wnt activity may be important in regulating cartilage differentiation. Here we show that Frzb-1, which encodes a secreted frizzled-related protein that can bind to Wnt proteins and can antagonize the activity of some Wnts, is expressed in the developing limb bud. At early stages of limb development, Frzb-1 is expressed in the ventral core mesenchyme of the limb bud, and later Frzb-1 expression becomes restricted to the central core region where mesenchymal condensations occur. At these stages, a chondrogenic marker gene, aggrecan, is not yet expressed. As limb development proceeds, expression of Frzb-1 is detected in cartilage primordial cells, although ultimately Frzb-1 expression is down-regulated. Similar results were obtained in the recombinant limb bud, which was constructed from dissociated and re-aggregated mesenchymal cells and an ectodermal jacket with the apical ectodermal ridge. In addition, Frzb-1 expression preceded aggrecan expression in micromass cultures. These results suggest that Frzb-1 has a role in condensation formation and cartilage differentiation by regulating Wnt activity in the limb bud.     

SF/HGF is a mediator between limb patterning and muscle development.

Scatter factor/hepatocyte growth factor (SF/HGF) is known to be involved in the detachment of myogenic precursor cells from the lateral dermomyotomes and their subsequent migration into the newly formed limb buds. As yet, however, nothing has been known about the role of the persistent expression of SF/HGF in the limb bud mesenchyme during later stages of limb bud development. To test for a potential role of SF/HGF in early limb muscle patterning, we examined the regulation of SF/HGF expression in the limb bud as well as the influence of SF/HGF on direction control of myogenic precursor cells in limb bud mesenchyme. We demonstrate that SF/HGF expression is controlled by signals involved in limb bud patterning. In the absence of an apical ectodermal ridge (AER), no expression of SF/HGF in the limb bud is observed. However, FGF-2 application can rescue SF/HGF expression. Excision of the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) results in ectopic and enhanced SF/HGF expression in the posterior limb bud mesenchyme. We could identify BMP-2 as a potential inhibitor of SF/HGF expression in the posterior limb bud mesenchyme. We further demonstrate that ZPA excision results in a shift of Pax-3-positive cells towards the posterior limb bud mesenchyme, indicating a role of the ZPA in positioning of the premuscle masses. Moreover, we present evidence that, in the limb bud mesenchyme, SF/HGF increases the motility of myogenic precursor cells and has a role in maintaining their undifferentiated state during migration. We present a model for a crucial role of SF/HGF during migration and early patterning of muscle precursor cells in the vertebrate limb.