The pro region N-terminal domain provides specific interactions required for catalysis of alpha-lytic protease folding

The extracellular bacterial protease, alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP), is synthesized with a large, two-domain pro region (Pro) that catalyzes the folding of the protease to its native conformation. In the absence of its Pro folding catalyst, alphaLP encounters a very large folding barrier (DeltaG = 30 kcal mol(-1)) that effectively prevents the protease from folding (t(1/2) of folding = 1800 years). Although homology data, mutational studies, and structural analysis of the Pro.alphaLP complex suggested that the Pro C-terminal domain (Pro C-domain) serves as the minimum "foldase" unit responsible for folding catalysis, we find that the Pro N-terminal domain (Pro N-domain) is absolutely required for alphaLP folding. Detailed kinetic analysis of Pro N-domain point mutants and a complete N-domain deletion reveal that the Pro N-domain both provides direct interactions with alphaLP that stabilize the folding transition state and confers stability to the Pro C-domain. The Pro N- and C-domains make conflicting demands upon native alphaLP binding that are alleviated in the optimized interface of the folding transition state complex. From these studies, it appears that the extremely high alphaLP folding barrier necessitates the presence of both the Pro domains; however, alphaLP homologues with less demanding folding barriers may not require both domains, thus possibly explaining the wide variation in the pro region size of related pro-proteases.     

The folding landscape of an alpha-lytic protease variant reveals the role of a conserved beta-hairpin in the development of kinetic stability

Most secreted bacterial proteases, including alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP), are synthesized with covalently attached pro regions necessary for their folding. The alphaLP folding landscape revealed that its pro region, a potent folding catalyst, is required to circumvent an extremely large folding free energy of activation that appears to be a consequence of its unique unfolding transition. Remarkably, the alphaLP native state is thermodynamically unstable; a large unfolding free energy barrier is solely responsible for the persistence of its native state. Although alphaLP folding is well characterized, the structural origins of its remarkable folding mechanism remain unclear. A conserved beta-hairpin in the C-terminal domain was identified as a structural element whose formation and positioning may contribute to the large folding free energy barrier. In this article, we characterize the folding of an alphaLP variant with a more favorable beta-hairpin turn conformation (alphaLP(beta-turn)). Indeed, alphaLP(beta-turn) pro region-catalyzed folding is faster than that for alphaLP. However, instead of accelerating spontaneous folding, alphaLP(beta-turn) actually unfolds more slowly than alphaLP. Our data support a model where the beta-hairpin is formed early, but its packing with a loop in the N-terminal domain happens late in the folding reaction. This tight packing at the domain interface enhances the kinetic stability of alphaLP(beta-turn), to nearly the same degree as the change between alphaLP and a faster folding homolog. However, alphaLP(beta-turn) has impaired proteolytic activity that negates the beneficial folding properties of this variant. This study demonstrates the evolutionary limitations imposed by the simultaneous optimization of folding and functional properties.     

Interdependent folding of the N- and C-terminal domains defines the cooperative folding of alpha-lytic protease

Alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) serves as an important model in achieving a quantitative and physical understanding of protein folding reactions. Synthesized as a pro-protease, alphaLP belongs to an interesting class of proteins that require pro regions to facilitate their proper folding. alphaLP's pro region (Pro) acts as a potent folding catalyst for the protease, accelerating alphaLP folding to its native conformation nearly 10(10)-fold. Structural and mutational studies suggested that Pro's considerable foldase activity is directed toward structuring the alphaLP C-terminal domain (CalphaLP), a seemingly folding-impaired domain, which is believed to contribute significantly to the high-energy folding and unfolding transition states of alphaLP. Pro-mediated nucleation of alphaLP folding within CalphaLP was hypothesized to subsequently enable the alphaLP N-terminal domain (NalphaLP) to dock and fold, completing the formation of native protease. In this paper, we find that ternary folding reactions of Pro and noncovalent NalphaLP and CalphaLP domains are unaffected by the order in which the components are added or by the relative concentrations of the alphaLP domains, indicating that neither discrete CalphaLP structuring nor docking of the two alphaLP domains is involved in the folding transition state. Instead, the rate-limiting step of these folding reactions appears to be a slow and concerted rearrangement of the NalphaLP and CalphaLP domains to form active protease. This cooperative and interdependent folding of both protease domains defines the large alphaLP folding barrier and is an apparent extension of the highly cooperative alphaLP unfolding transition that imparts the protease with remarkable kinetic stability and functional longevity.     

alpha-lytic protease precursor: characterization of a structured folding intermediate

The bacterial alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) is synthesized as a precursor containing a large N-terminal pro region (Pro) transiently required for correct folding of the protease [Silen, J. L., and Agard, D. A. (1989) Nature 341, 462-464]. Upon folding, the precursor is autocatalyticly cleaved to yield a tight-binding inhibitory complex of the pro region and the fully folded protease (Pro/alphaLP). An in vitro purification and refolding protocol has been developed for production of the disulfide-bonded precursor. A combination of spectroscopic approaches have been used to compare the structure and stability of the precursor with either the Pro/alphaLP complex or isolated Pro. The precursor and complex have significant similarities in secondary structure but some differences in tertiary structure, as well as a dramatic difference in stability. Correlations with isolated Pro suggest that the pro region part of the precursor is fully folded and acts to stabilize and structure the alphaLP region. Precursor folding is shown to be biphasic with the fast phase matching the rate of pro region folding. Further, the rate-limiting step in oxidative folding is formation of the disulfide bonds and autocatalytic processing occurs rapidly thereafter. These studies suggests a model in which the pro region folds first and catalyzes folding of the protease domain, forming the active site and finally causing autocatalytic cleavage of the bond separating pro region and protease. This last processing step is critical as it allows the protease N-terminus to rearrange, providing the majority of net stabilization of the product Pro/alphaLP complex.     

The role of pro regions in protein folding

In vivo, many proteases are synthesized as larger precursors. During the maturation process, the catalytically active protease domain is released from the larger polypeptide or pro-enzyme by one or more proteolytic processing steps. In several well studied cases, amino-terminal pro regions have been shown to play a fundamental role in the folding of the associated protease domains. The mechanism by which pro regions facilitate folding appears to be significantly different from that used by the molecular chaperones. Recent results suggest that the pro region assisted folding mechanism may be used by a wide variety of proteases, and perhaps even by non-proteases.     

Correct folding of alpha-lytic protease is required for its extracellular secretion from Escherichia coli

alpha-Lytic protease is a bacterial serine protease of the trypsin family that is synthesized as a 39-kD preproenzyme (Silen, J. L., C. N. McGrath, K. R. Smith, and D. A. Agard. 1988. Gene (Amst.). 69: 237-244). The 198-amino acid mature protease is secreted into the culture medium by the native host, Lysobacter enzymogenes (Whitaker, D. R. 1970. Methods Enzymol. 19:599-613). Expression experiments in Escherichia coli revealed that the 166-amino acid pro region is transiently required either in cis (Silen, J. L., D. Frank, A. Fujishige, R. Bone, and D. A. Agard. 1989. J. Bacteriol. 171:1320-1325) or in trans (Silen, J. L., and D. A. Agard. 1989. Nature (Lond.). 341:462-464) for the proper folding and extracellular accumulation of the enzyme. The maturation process is temperature sensitive in E. coli; unprocessed precursor accumulates in the cells at temperatures above 30 degrees C (Silen, J. L., D. Frank, A. Fujishige, R. Bone, and D. A. Agard. 1989. J. Bacteriol. 171:1320-1325). Here we show that full-length precursor produced at nonpermissive temperatures is tightly associated with the E. coli outer membrane. The active site mutant Ser 195----Ala (SA195), which is incapable of self-processing, also accumulates as a precursor in the outer membrane, even when expressed at permissive temperatures. When the protease domain is expressed in the absence of the pro region, the misfolded, inactive protease also cofractionates with the outer membrane. However, when the folding requirement for either wild-type or mutant protease domains is provided by expressing the pro region in trans, both are efficiently secreted into the extracellular medium. Attempts to separate folding and secretion functions by extensive deletion mutagenesis within the pro region were unsuccessful. Taken together, these results suggest that only properly folded and processed forms of alpha-lytic protease are efficiently transported to the medium.     

The folding landscape of Streptomyces griseus protease B reveals the energetic costs and benefits associated with evolving kinetic stability

Like most extracellular bacterial proteases, Streptomyces griseus protease B (SGPB) and alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) are synthesized with covalently attached pro regions necessary for their folding. In this article, we characterize the folding free energy landscape of SGPB and compare it to the folding landscapes of alphaLP and trypsin, a mammalian homolog that folds independently of its zymogen peptide. In contrast to the thermodynamically stable native state of trypsin, SGPB and alphaLP fold to native states that are thermodynamically marginally stable or unstable, respectively. Instead, their apparent stability arises kinetically, from unfolding free energy barriers that are both large and highly cooperative. The unique unfolding transitions of SGPB and alphaLP extend their functional lifetimes under highly degradatory conditions beyond that seen for trypsin; however, the penalty for evolving kinetic stability is remarkably large in that each factor of 2.4-8 in protease resistance is accompanied by a cost of ~10(5) in the spontaneous folding rate and ~5-9 kcal/mole in thermodynamic stability. These penalties have been overcome by the coevolution of increasingly effective pro regions to facilitate folding. Despite these costs, kinetic stability appears to be a potent mechanism for developing native-state properties that maximize protease longevity.     

Two energetically disparate folding pathways of alpha-lytic protease share a single transition state

The Lysobacter enzymogenes alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) is synthesized with a 166 amino acid pro region (Pro) that catalyzes the folding of the 198 amino acid protease into its native conformation. An extraordinary feature of this system is the very high energy barrier (DeltaG = 30 kcal mol-1) that effectively prevents alphaLP from folding in the absence of Pro (t1/2 = 1800 years). A pair of mutations has been isolated in the protease that completely suppresses the catalytic defect incurred in Pro by truncation of its last three amino acids. These mutations also accelerate the folding of alphaLP in the absence of Pro by 400-fold. An energetic analysis of the two folding reactions indicates that the mutations stabilize the transition states of both the catalyzed and uncatalyzed folding reactions by 3 kcal mol-1. This finding points to a single transition state for these two distinct and energetically disparate folding pathways, and raises the possibility that all alphaLP folding pathways share the same transition state.     

Analysis of prepro-alpha-lytic protease expression in Escherichia coli reveals that the pro region is required for activity.

The alpha-lytic protease of Lysobacter enzymogenes was successfully expressed in Escherichia coli by fusing the promoter and signal sequence of the E. coli phoA gene to the proenzyme portion of the alpha-lytic protease gene. Following induction, active enzyme was found both within cells and in the extracellular medium, where it slowly accumulated to high levels. Use of a similar gene fusion to express the protease domain alone produced inactive enzyme, indicating that the large amino-terminal pro region is necessary for activity. The implications for protein folding are discussed. Furthermore, inactivation of the protease by mutation of the catalytic serine residue resulted in the production of a higher-molecular-weight form of the alpha-lytic protease, suggesting that the enzyme is self-processing in E. coli.     

Comprehensive analysis of protein folding activation thermodynamics reveals a universal behavior violated by kinetically stable proteases

Alpha-lytic protease (alpha LP) and Streptomyces griseus protease B (SGPB) are two extracellular serine proteases whose folding is absolutely dependent on the existence of their companion pro regions. Moreover, the native states of these proteins are, at best, marginally stable, with the apparent stability resulting from being kinetically trapped in the native state by large barriers to unfolding. Here, in an effort to understand the physical properties that distinguish kinetically and thermodynamically stable proteins, we study the temperature-dependences of the folding and unfolding kinetics of alpha LP and SGPB without their pro regions, and compare their behavior to a comprehensive set of other proteins. For the folding activation thermodynamics, we find some remarkable universal behaviors in the thermodynamically stable proteins that are violated dramatically by alpha LP. Despite significant variations in deltaC(P,F)++, the maximal folding speed occurs within the narrow biological temperature range for all proteins, except for alpha LP, with its maximal folding speed shifted lower by 200 K. This implies evolutionary pressures on folding speed for typical proteins, but not for alpha LP. In addition, the folding free energy barrier in the biological temperature range for most proteins is predominantly enthalpic, but purely entropic for alpha LP. The unfolding of alpha LP and SGPB is distinguished by three properties: a remarkably large deltaC(P,U)++, a very high deltaG(U)++, and a maximum deltaG(u)++ at the optimal growth temperature for the organism. While other proteins display each of these traits to some approximation, the simultaneous optimization of all three occurs only in the kinetically stable proteins, and appears to be required to maximize their unfolding cooperativity, by suppressing local unfolding events, and slowing the rate of global unfolding. Together, these properties extend the lifetime of these enzymes in the highly proteolytic extracellular environment. Attaining such functional properties seems possible only through the gross perturbation of the folding thermodynamics, which in turn has required the co-evolution of pro regions as folding catalysts.     

A conserved aromatic residue in the autochaperone domain of the autotransporter Hbp is critical for initiation of outer membrane translocation

Autotransporters are bacterial virulence factors that share a common mechanism by which they are transported to the cell surface. They consist of an N-terminal passenger domain and a C-terminal β-barrel, which has been implicated in translocation of the passenger across the outer membrane (OM). The mechanism of passenger translocation and folding is still unclear but involves a conserved region at the C terminus of the passenger domain, the so-called autochaperone domain. This domain functions in the stepwise translocation process and in the folding of the passenger domain after translocation. In the autotransporter hemoglobin protease (Hbp), the autochaperone domain consists of the last rung of the β-helix and a capping domain. To examine the role of this region, we have mutated several conserved aromatic residues that are oriented toward the core of the β-helix. We found that non-conservative mutations affected secretion with Trp(1015) in the cap region as the most critical residue. Substitution at this position yielded a DegP-sensitive intermediate that is located at the periplasmic side of the OM. Further analysis revealed that Trp(1015) is most likely required for initiation of processive folding of the β-helix at the cell surface, which drives sequential translocation of the Hbp passenger across the OM.     

Independent intramolecular mediators of folding, activity, and inhibition for the Plasmodium falciparum cysteine protease falcipain-2

The Plasmodium falciparum cysteine protease falcipain-2 is a trophozoite hemoglobinase and potential antimalarial drug target. Unlike other studied papain family proteases, falcipain-2 does not require its prodomain for folding to active enzyme. Rather, folding is mediated by an amino-terminal extension of the mature protease. As in related enzymes, the prodomain is a potent inhibitor of falcipain-2. We now report further functional evaluation of the domains of falcipain-2 and related plasmodial proteases. The minimum requirement for folding of falcipain-2 and four related plasmodial cysteine proteases was inclusion of a 14-15-residue amino-terminal folding domain, beginning with a conserved Tyr. Chimeras of the falcipain-2 catalytic domain with extensions from six other plasmodial proteases folded normally and had kinetic parameters (k(cat)/K(m) 124,000-195,000 M(-1) s(-1)) similar to those of recombinant falcipain-2 (k(cat)/K(m) 120,000 M(-1) s(-1)), indicating that the folding domain is functionally conserved across the falcipain-2 subfamily. Correct folding also occurred when the catalytic domain was refolded with a separate prodomain-folding domain construct but not with an isolated folding domain peptide. Thus, the prodomain mediated interaction between the other two domains when they were not covalently bound. The prodomain-catalytic domain interaction was independent of the active site, because it was blocked by free inactive catalytic domain but not by the active site-binding peptide leupeptin. The folded catalytic domain retained activity after purification from the prodomain-folding domain construct (k(cat)/K(m) 168,000 M(-1) s(-1)), indicating that the folding domain is not required for activity once folding has been achieved. Activity was lost after nonreducing gelatin SDS-PAGE but not native gelatin PAGE, indicating that correct disulfide bonds are insufficient to direct appropriate folding. Our results identify unique features of the falcipain-2 subfamily with independent mediation of activity, folding, and inhibition.     

Disabling the folding catalyst is the last critical step in alpha-lytic protease folding

Alpha-Lytic protease (alphaLP) is an extracellular bacterial pro-protease marked by extraordinary conformational rigidity and a highly cooperative barrier to unfolding. Although these properties successfully limit its proteolytic destruction, thereby extending the functional lifetime of the protease, they come at the expense of foldability (t(1/2) = 1800 yr) and thermodynamic stability (native alphaLP is less stable than the unfolded species). Efficient folding has required the coevolution of a large N-terminal pro region (Pro) that rapidly catalyzes alphaLP folding (t(1/2) = 23 sec) and shifts the thermodynamic equilibrium in favor of folded protease through tight native-state binding. Release of active alphaLP from this stabilizing, but strongly inhibitory, complex requires the proteolytic destruction of Pro. alphaLP is capable of initiating Pro degradation via cleavage of a flexible loop within the Pro C-terminal domain. This single cleavage event abolishes Pro catalysis while maintaining strong native-state binding. Thus, the loop acts as an Achilles' heel by which the Pro foldase machinery can be safely dismantled, preventing Pro-catalyzed unfolding, without compromising alphaLP native-state stability. Once the loop is cleaved, Pro is rapidly degraded, releasing active alphaLP.     

Mutational and inhibitive analysis of SARS coronavirus 3C-like protease by fluorescence resonance energy transfer-based assays

The 3C-like protease (3CL(pro)) of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV) plays key roles in viral replication and is an attractive target for anti-SARS drug discovery. In this report, a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based method was developed to assess the proteolytic activity of SARS-CoV 3CL(pro). Two internally quenched fluorogenic peptides, 1NC and 2NC, corresponding to the N-terminal and the C-terminal autocleavage sites of SARS-CoV 3CL(pro), respectively, were used as substrates. SARS-CoV 3CL(pro) seemed to work more efficiently on 1NC than on 2NC in trans-cleavage assay. Mutational analysis demonstrated that the His41 residue, the N-terminal 7 amino acids, and the domain III of SARS-CoV 3CL(pro) were important for the enzymatic activity. Antibodies recognizing domain III could significantly inhibit the enzymatic activity of SARS-CoV 3CL(pro). The effects of class-specific protease inhibitors on the trans-cleavage activity revealed that this enzyme worked more like a serine protease rather than the papain protease.     

Activation of the proteinase B precursor of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae by autocatalysis and by an internal sequence.

Proteinase B (PrB) is a subtilisin-like serine protease found in the vacuole of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It is first made as a large precursor that consists of a putative signal sequence, a 260-amino acid pro region, the serine protease domain, and two small COOH-terminal post regions (Moehle, C. M., Dixon, C. K., and Jones, E. W. (1989) J. Cell Biol. 108, 309-324). This precursor is glycosylated and proteolytically processed at least three times before mature enzyme is formed. To determine whether an intact PrB catalytic site is required for proteolytic processing of the precursor, point mutations were generated at the codons for the active site serine or aspartate residues by site-directed mutagenesis. The effect of these mutations on PrB processing suggests that the large pro region may be cleaved by an intramolecular, autocatalytic mechanism. The properties of a prb1 mutant that accumulates a 37-kDa precursor in addition to mature sized mutant PrB antigen suggests that the final proteolytic cleavage step is also autocatalytic. A prb1 deletion that lacks codons for the large pro region was made to test whether this part of the precursor is required for formation of mature PrB. Analysis of this mutant revealed two functions for this region: it prevents N-linked glycosylation of the serine protease domain and it allows the PrB precursor to be processed by proteinase A. The pro region can fulfill this latter function if added as a separate molecule, so long as glycosylation of the catalytic domain is prevented by other means.     

On the unfolding of alpha-lytic protease and the role of the pro region

Molecular dynamics simulations of alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) alone and complexed with its pro region (PRO) are performed to understand the origin of its high unfolding (and folding) barrier when it is alone and how the pro region lowers this barrier. At room temperature, alphaLP exhibits lower dynamic fluctuations than alpha-chymotrypsin. Simulation of PRO alone led to reorientation of its N terminal helix and collapse to a more compact state. A model for the uncleaved proenzyme was built and found to be stable in the time scale of the simulations. Energetic analysis suggests that the origin of strain in the uncleaved proenzyme compared with the cleaved complex is in the intramolecular backbone electrostatic interactions of the cleaved strand. In high temperature simulations, the interaction of the long beta hairpin of the enzyme with the C terminal beta sheet of PRO is among the most stable in the complex and a likely "nucleation site" for folding. In the course of unfolding, the C terminal tail of PRO is sometimes observed to intervene between the long hairpin and the aspartate loop of the enzyme, perhaps thereby lowering the energy barrier for separation of the two hairpins. Tighter interactions at the interface between the enzyme and its pro region are also occasionally observed, providing an additional mechanism for unfolding catalysis. Simulations of a mutant enzyme where the buried ion pair residues R102 and D142 were replaced by W and L, respectively, did not display any distinguishable behavior compared with the wild type.     

A conserved region within the Bordetella pertussis autotransporter BrkA is necessary for folding of its passenger domain

Autotransporter secretion represents a unique mechanism that Gram-negative bacteria employ to deliver proteins to their cell surface. BrkA is a Bordetella pertussis autotransporter protein that mediates serum resistance and contributes to adherence of the bacterium to host cells. BrkA is a 103 kDa protein that is cleaved to form a 73 kDa alpha-domain and a 30 kDa beta domain. The alpha domain, also referred to as the passenger domain, is responsible for the effector functions of the protein, whereas the beta domain serves as a transporter. In an effort to characterize BrkA secretion, we have shown that BrkA has a 42 amino acid signal peptide for transit across the cytoplasmic membrane, and a translocation unit made up of a short linker region fused to the beta-domain to ferry the passenger domain to the bacterial surface through a channel formed by the beta-domain. In this report, we provide genetic, biochemical and structural evidence demonstrating that a region within the BrkA passenger (Glu601-Ala692) is necessary for folding the passenger. This region is not required for surface display in the outer membrane protease OmpT-deficient Escherichia coli strain UT5600. However, a BrkA mutant protein bearing a deletion in this region is susceptible to digestion when expressed in E. coli strains expressing OmpT suggesting that the region is required to maintain a stable structure. The instability of the deletion mutant can be rescued by surface expressing Glu601-Ala692in trans suggesting that this region is acting as an intramolecular chaperone to effect folding of the passenger concurrent with or following translocation across the outer membrane.     

Mesophile versus thermophile: insights into the structural mechanisms of kinetic stability

Obtaining detailed knowledge of folding intermediate and transition state (TS) structures is critical for understanding protein folding mechanisms. Comparisons between proteins adapted to survive extreme temperatures with their mesophilic homologs are likely to provide valuable information on the interactions relevant to the unfolding transition. For kinetically stable proteins such as alpha-lytic protease (alphaLP) and its family members, their large free energy barrier to unfolding is central to their biological function. To gain new insights into the mechanisms that underlie kinetic stability, we have determined the structure and high temperature unfolding kinetics of a thermophilic homolog, Thermobifida fusca protease A (TFPA). These studies led to the identification of a specific structural element bridging the N and C-terminal domains of the protease (the "domain bridge") proposed to be associated with the enhanced high temperature kinetic stability in TFPA. Mutagenesis experiments exchanging the TFPA domain bridge into alphaLP validate this hypothesis and illustrate key structural details that contribute to TFPA's increased kinetic thermostability. These results lead to an updated model for the unfolding transition state structure for this important class of proteases in which domain bridge undocking and unfolding occurs at or before the TS. The domain bridge appears to be a structural element that can modulate the degree of kinetic stability of the different members of this class of proteases.