In situ observation of elementary growth processes of protein crystals by advanced optical microscopy

To start systematically investigating the quality improvement of protein crystals, the elementary growth processes of protein crystals must be first clarified comprehensively. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has made a tremendous contribution toward elucidating the elementary growth processes of protein crystals and has confirmed that protein crystals grow layer by layer utilizing kinks on steps, as in the case of inorganic and low-molecular-weight compound crystals. However, the scanning of the AFM cantilever greatly disturbs the concentration distribution and solution flow in the vicinity of growing protein crystals. AFM also cannot visualize the dynamic behavior of mobile solute and impurity molecules on protein crystal surfaces. To compensate for these disadvantages of AFM, in situ observation by two types of advanced optical microscopy has been recently performed. To observe the elementary steps of protein crystals noninvasively, laser confocal microscopy combined with differential interference contrast microscopy (LCM-DIM) was developed. To visualize individual mobile protein molecules, total internal reflection fluorescent (TIRF) microscopy, which is widely used in the field of biological physics, was applied to the visualization of protein crystal surfaces. In this review, recent progress in the noninvasive in situ observation of elementary steps and individual mobile protein molecules on protein crystal surfaces is outlined.     

Repair of impurity-poisoned protein crystal surfaces

The surface morphology of Bence-Jones protein (BJP) crystals was investigated during growth and dissolution by using in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM). It was shown that over a wide supersaturation range, impurities adsorb on the crystalline surface and ultimately form an impurity adsorption layer that prevents further growth of the crystal. At low undersaturations, this impurity adsorption layer prevents dissolution. At greater undersaturation, dissolution takes place around large particles incorporated into the crystal, leading to etch pits with impurity-free bottoms. On restoration of supersaturation conditions, two-dimensional nucleation takes place on the impurity-free bottoms of these etch pits. After new growth layers fill in the etch pits, they cover the impurity-poisoned top layer of the crystal face. This leads to the resumption of its growth. Formation of an impurity-adsorption layer can explain the termination of growth of macromolecular crystals that has been widely noted. Growth-dissolution-growth cycles could be used to produce larger crystals that otherwise would have stopped growing because of impurity poisoning.     

Visualization of RNA crystal growth by atomic force microscopy.

The crystallization of transfer RNA (tRNA) was investigated using atomic force microscopy (AFM) over the temperature range from 4 to 16 degrees C, and this produced the first in situ AFM images of developing nucleic acid crystals. The growth of the (110) face of hexagonal yeast tRNAPhe crystals was observed to occur at steps on vicinal hillocks generated by multiple screw dislocation sources in the temperature range of 13.5-16 degrees C. Two-dimensional nucleation begins to dominate at 13.5 degrees C, with the appearance of three-dimensional nuclei at 12 degrees C. The changes in growth mechanisms are correlated with variations in supersaturation which is higher in the low temperature range. Growth of tRNA crystals was characterized by a strong anisotropy in the tangential step movement and transformation of growth modes on single crystals were directly observed by AFM over the narrow temperature range utilized. Finally, lattice resolution images of the molecular structure of surface layers were recorded. The implications of the strong temperature dependence of tRNAPhe crystal growth are discussed in view of improving and better controlling crystallization of nucleic acids.     

Growth and disorder of macromolecular crystals: insights from atomic force microscopy and X-ray diffraction studies

The growth processes and defect structures of protein and virus crystals have been studied in situ by atomic force microscopy (AFM), X-ray diffraction topography, and high-resolution reciprocal space scanning. Molecular mechanisms of macromolecular crystallization were visualized and fundamental kinetic and thermodynamic parameters, which govern the crystallization process of a number of macromolecular crystals, have been determined. High-resolution AFM imaging of crystal surfaces provides information on the packing of macromolecules within the unit cell and on the structure of large macromolecular assemblies. X-ray diffraction techniques provide a bulk probe with poorer spatial resolution but excellent sensitivity to mosaicity and strain. Defect structures and disorder created in macromolecular crystals during growth, seeding, and post-growth treatments including flash cooling were characterized and their impacts on the diffraction properties of macromolecular crystals have been analyzed. The diverse and dramatic effects of impurities on growth and defect formation have also been studied. Practical implications of these fundamental insights into the improvement of macromolecular crystallization protocols are discussed.     

Quantitative characterization of biomolecular assemblies and interactions using atomic force microscopy

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been applied in many biological investigations in the past 15 years. This review focuses on the application of AFM for quantitatively characterizing the structural and thermodynamic properties of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid complexes. AFM can be used to determine the stoichiometries and association constants of multiprotein assemblies and to quantify changes in conformations of proteins and protein-nucleic acid complexes. In addition, AFM in solution permits the observation of the dynamic properties of biomolecular complexes and the measurement of intermolecular forces between biomolecules. Recent advances in cryogenic AFM, AFM on two-dimensional crystals, carbon nanotube probes, solution imaging, high-speed AFM, and manipulation capabilities enhance these applications by improving AFM resolution and the dynamic and operative capabilities of the AFM. These developments make AFM a powerful tool for investigating the biomolecular assemblies and interactions that govern gene regulation.     

Crystallization, stability, and enzymatic degradation of poly(L-lactide) thin film

Poly(L-lactide) (PLLA) thin film with 100 nm thickness was crystallized at 160 degreesC for 20 min from the melt obtained at 220 degreesC. Hexagonal crystals with three types of growth (derivative growth lamellae, overgrowth multistacked lamellae, and undergrowth multistacked lamellae) were simultaneously observed by atomic force microscopy (AFM). These phenomena are due to the differences of the formative points of secondary crystal nuclei against the basal lamella. Enzymatic degradation of PLLA thin film revealed two types of amorphous regions. These regions were identified as the free amorphous region around the crystals and the restricted amorphous region between the crystal and glass substrate. In situ observation of thermal behavior of lamellar crystals was performed to understand the correlation between the chain folding and stability of the crystal by using temperature-controlled AFM. The morphology of the sectors with [100] growth plane had changed to a comblike morphology despite the fact that the [110] growth plane remained unchanged, suggesting that the stability of the chain folding and the chain-packing state affected the thermal behavior.     

Atomic force microscopy of three-dimensional membrane protein crystals. Ca-ATPase of sarcoplasmic reticulum.

We have observed three-dimensional crystals of the calcium pump from sarcoplasmic reticulum by atomic force microscopy (AFM). From AFM images of dried crystals, both on graphite and mica, we measured steps in the crystal thickness, corresponding to the unit cell spacing normal to the substrate. It is known from transmission electron microscopy that crystal periodicity in the plane of the substrate is destroyed by drying, and it was therefore not surprising that we were unable to observe this periodicity by AFM. Thus, we were motivated to use the AFM on hydrated crystals. In this case, crystal adsorption appeared to be a limiting factor, and our studies indicate that adsorption is controlled by the composition of the medium and by the physical-chemical properties of the substrate. We used scanning electron microscopy to determine the conditions yielding the highest adsorption of crystals, and, under these conditions, we have obtained AFM images of hydrated crystals with a resolution similar to that observed with dried samples (i.e., relatively poor). In the same preparations, we have observed lipid bilayers with a significantly better resolution, indicating that the poor quality of crystal images was not due to instrumental limitations. Rather, we attribute poor images to the intrinsic flexibility of these multilamellar crystals, which apparently allow movement of one layer relative to another in response to shear forces from the AFM tip. We therefore suggest some general guidelines for future studies of membrane proteins with AFM.     

Nucleation and growth of calcite on native versus pyrolyzed oyster shell folia

The thin sheets of calcite, termed folia, that make up much of the shell of an oyster are covered by a layer of discrete globules that has been proposed to consist of agglomerations of protein and mineral. Foliar fragments, treated at 475 degrees C for 36 h to remove organic matter, were imaged by atomic force microscopy (AFM) as crystals grew on the foliar surfaces in artificial seawater at calcite supersaturations up to 52-fold. Crystals were also viewed later by scanning electron microscopy. After pyrolysis, the foliar globules persisted only as fragile remnants that were quickly washed away during AFM imaging, revealing an underlying morphology on the foliar laths of a tightly packed continuum of nanometer-scale protrusions. At intermediate supersaturations, crystal formation was seen immediately almost everywhere on these surfaces, each crystal having the same distinctive shape and orientation, even at the outset with crystals as small as a few nanometers. In contrast, nucleation did not occur readily on non-pyrolyzed foliar surfaces, and the crystals that did grow, although slowly at intermediate supersaturations, had irregular shapes. Possible crystallographic features of foliar laths are considered on the basis of the morphology of ectopic crystals and the atomic patterns of various surfaces. A model for foliar lath formation is presented that includes cycles of pulsed secretion of shell protein, removal of the protein from the mineralizing solution upon binding to mineral, and mineral growth at relatively high supersaturation over a time frame of about 1 h for each turn of the cycle.     

In situ observation of crystal growth for poly[(S)-lactide] by temperature-controlled atomic force microscopy

The crystallization behavior and crystalline morphologies of poly[(S)-lactide] (P[(S)-LA]) in thin films crystallized isothermally at over 160 degrees C were characterized by transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The dendritic crystal and hexagonal crystal were formed in thin film with thicknesses below 30 nm or over 50 nm, respectively. The crystal structures of dendritic and hexagonal crystals were identical, suggesting that the crystalline morphology of P[(S)-LA] is strongly dependent upon the film thickness. In situ observation of the crystal growth in the P[(S)-LA] thin film at 165 degrees C from the melt was carried out by using temperature-controlled AFM equipped with a heating stage. The initial stage of crystallization and development of lamellae were successfully observed during isothermal crystallization at 165 degrees C. The first forming crystal showed the edge-on orientation, and grew to S-shaped edge-on lamellae. Dendritic flat-on crystals were developed from the S-shaped edge-on lamellae. The growth rates of flat-on and edge-on lamellae were almost identical.     

Enzymatic degradation processes of lamellar crystals in thin films for poly[(R)-3-hydroxybutyric acid] and its copolymers revealed by real-time atomic force microscopy

Enzymatic degradation processes of flat-on lamellar crystals in melt-crystallized thin films of poly[(R)-3-hydroxybutyric acid] (P(3HB)) and its copolymers were characterized by real-time atomic force microscopy (AFM) in a phosphate buffer solution containing PHB depolymerase from Ralstonia pickettii T1. Fiberlike crystals with regular intervals were generated along the crystallographic a axis at the end of lamellar crystals during the enzymatic degradation. The morphologies and sizes of the fiberlike crystals were markedly dependent on the compositions of comonomer units in the polyesters. Length, width, interval, and thickness of the fiberlike crystals after the enzymatic degradation for 2 h were measured by AFM, and the dimensions were related to the solid-state structures of P(3HB) and its copolymers. The width and thickness decreased at the tip of fiberlike crystals, indicating that the enzymatic degradation of crystals takes place not only along the a axis but also along the b and c axes. These results from AFM measurement were compared with the data on crystal size by wide-angle X-ray diffraction, and on lamellar thickness and long period by small-angle X-ray scattering. In addition, the enzymatic erosion rate of flat-on lamellar crystals along the a axis was measured from real-time AFM height images. A schematic glacier model for the enzymatic degradation of flat-on lamellar crystals of P(3HB) by PHB depolymerase has been proposed on the basis of the AFM observations.     

Incorporation of microcrystals by growing protein and virus crystals

In the course of time-lapse video and atomic force microscopy (AFM) investigations of macromolecular crystal growth, we frequently observed the sedimentation of microcrystals and three-dimensional nuclei onto the surfaces of much larger, growing protein or virus crystals. This was followed by the direct incorporation over time of the smaller crystals into the bulk of the larger crystals. In some cases, clear indications were present that upon absorption of the small crystal onto the surface of the larger, there was proper alignment of the respective lattices, and consolidation proceeded without observable defect formation, i.e., the two lattices knitted together without discontinuity. In the case of at least one virus crystal, cubic satellite tobacco mosaic virus (STMV), addition of three-dimensional nuclei and subsequent expansion provided the principal growth mechanism at high supersaturation. This process has not been reported for growth from solution of conventional crystals. In numerous other instances, the lattices of the small and larger crystals were obviously misaligned, and incorporation occurred with the formation of some defect. This phenomenon of small crystals physically embedded in larger crystals could only degrade the overall diffraction and materials properties of macromolecular crystals.     

Atomic force microscopy of crystalline insulins: the influence of sequence variation on crystallization and interfacial structure.

The self-association of proteins is influenced by amino acid sequence, molecular conformation, and the presence of molecular additives. In the presence of phenolic additives, LysB28ProB29 insulin, in which the C-terminal prolyl and lysyl residues of wild-type human insulin have been inverted, can be crystallized into forms resembling those of wild-type insulins in which the protein exists as zinc-complexed hexamers organized into well-defined layers. We describe herein tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (TMAFM) studies of single crystals of rhombohedral (R3) LysB28ProB29 that reveal the influence of sequence variation on hexamer-hexamer association at the surface of actively growing crystals. Molecular scale lattice images of these crystals were acquired in situ under growth conditions, enabling simultaneous identification of the rhombohedral LysB28ProB29 crystal form, its orientation, and its dynamic growth characteristics. The ability to obtain crystallographic parameters on multiple crystal faces with TMAFM confirmed that bovine and porcine insulins grown under these conditions crystallized into the same space group as LysB28ProB29 (R3), enabling direct comparison of crystal growth behavior and the influence of sequence variation. Real-time TMAFM revealed hexamer vacancies on the (001) terraces of LysB28ProB29, and more rounded dislocation noses and larger terrace widths for actively growing screw dislocations compared to wild-type bovine and porcine insulin crystals under identical conditions. This behavior is consistent with weaker interhexamer attachment energies for LysB28ProB29 at active growth sites. Comparison of the single crystal x-ray structures of wild-type insulins and LysB28ProB29 suggests that differences in protein conformation at the hexamer-hexamer interface and accompanying changes in interhexamer bonding are responsible for this behavior. These studies demonstrate that subtle changes in molecular conformation due to a single sequence inversion in a region critical for insulin self-association can have a significant effect on the crystallization of proteins.     

Kinetics of degradation of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayers as a result of vipoxin phospholipase A2 activity: an atomic force microscopy (AFM) approach

In this paper we used AFM as an analytical tool to visualize the degradation of a phospholipid bilayer undergoing hydrolysis of the vipoxin's PLA(2). We obtained time series images during the degradation process of supported 1, 2-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) bilayers and evaluated the occurrence and the growth rate of the bilayer defects. The special resolution of the AFM images allowed us to measure the area and the perimeter length of these defects and to draw conclusions about the kinetics of the enzyme reaction. Moreover, we also report for some unique characteristics discovered during the vipoxin's PLA(2) action. Experimentally for the first time, we observed the appearance and the growth of three-dimensional (3D), crystal-like structures within the formed defects of the degraded bilayer. In an effort to explain their nature, we applied bearing image analysis to estimate the volume of these crystals and we found that their growth rate follows a similar kinetic pattern as the degradation rate of the supported bilayer.     

Structural and morphological characterization of ultralente insulin crystals by atomic force microscopy: evidence of hydrophobically driven assembly.

Although x-ray crystal structures exist for many forms of insulin, the hormone involved in glucose metabolism and used in the treatment of diabetes, x-ray structural characterization of therapeutically important long-acting crystalline ultralente insulin forms has been elusive because of small crystal size and poor diffraction characteristics. We describe tapping-mode atomic force microscopy (TMAFM) studies, performed directly in crystallization liquor, of ultralente crystals prepared from bovine, human, and porcine insulins. Lattice images obtained from direct imaging of crystal planes are consistent with R3 space group symmetry for each insulin type, but the morphology of the human and porcine crystals observed by AFM differs substantially from that of the bovine insulin crystals. Human and porcine ultralente crystals exhibited large, molecularly flat (001) faces consisting of hexagonal arrays of close packed hexamers. In contrast, bovine ultralente crystals predominantly exhibited faces with cylindrical features assignable to close-packed stacks of insulin hexamers laying in-plane, consistent with the packing motif of the (010) and (011) planes. This behavior is attributed to a twofold increase in the hydrophobic character of the upper and lower surfaces of the donut-shaped insulin hexamer in bovine insulin compared to its human and porcine counterparts that results from minor sequence differences between these insulins. The increased hydrophobicity of these surfaces can promote hexamer-hexamer stacking in precrystalline aggregates or enhance attachment of single hexamers along the c axis at the crystal surface during crystal growth. Both events lead to enhanced growth of ¿hk0¿ planes instead of (001). The insulin hexamers on the (010) and (110) faces are exposed "edge-on" to the aqueous medium, such that solvent access to the center of the hexamer and to solvent channels is reduced compared to the (001) surface, consistent with the slower dissolution and reputed unique basal activity of bovine ultralente insulin. These observations demonstrate that subtle variations in amino acid sequence can dramatically affect the interfacial structure of crystalline proteins.     

Growth of Protein 2-D Crystals on Supported Planar Lipid Bilayers Imagedin Situby AFM

Theories of crystallization, both in 3-D and 2-D, are still very limited, mainly due to the scarcity of experimental approaches providing pertinent data on elementary phenomena. We present here a novel experimental approach for following, in real time andin situ, the process of 2-D crystallization of proteins on solid supports. Using annexin V as a model of a protein binding by affinity to a lipid matrix, we show that 2-D crystals of proteins can be formed on supported planar lipid bilayers (SPBs). Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) enables the process of 2-D crystal growth to be visualized. The submolecular organization of the crystals was characterized at a resolution of ≈ 2 nanometers, and defects, hitherto not observed in protein crystals, were resolved. These results have potential applications in basic and applied sciences.     

Streptavidin 2D Crystal Substrates for Visualizing Biomolecular Processes by Atomic Force Microscopy

Flat substrate surfaces are a key to successful imaging of biological macromolecules by atomic force microscopy (AFM). Although usable substrate surfaces have been prepared for still imaging of immobilized molecules, surfaces that are more suitable have recently been required for dynamic imaging to accompany the progress of the scan speed of AFM. In fact, the state-of-the-art high-speed AFM has achieved temporal resolution of 30 ms, a capacity allowing us to trace molecular processes played by biological macromolecules. Here, we characterize three types of streptavidin two-dimensional crystals as substrates, concerning their qualities of surface roughness, uniformity, stability, and resistance to nonspecific protein adsorption. These crystal surfaces are commonly resistant to nonspecific protein adsorption, but exhibit differences in other properties to some extent. These differences must be taken into consideration, but these crystal surfaces are still useful for dynamic AFM imaging, as demonstrated by observation of calcium-induced changes in calmodulin, GroES binding to GroEL, and actin polymerization on the surfaces.     

Annealing and melting behavior of poly(l-lactic acid) single crystals as revealed by in situ atomic force microscopy

In situ annealing and melting of folded-chain single crystals of poly(l-lactic acid) (PLLA) was examined by temperature-controlled atomic force microscopy (AFM). Prominent changes in the crystal appearance during annealing could be followed in real time by the AFM at temperatures above the original crystallization temperature. Thickening of the crystal edges could be occasionally observed, and this indicates that the crystal edges are less perfect than the central, well-ordered regions. At higher annealing temperatures, melting of the unthickened part started. The melting of the unthickened region progressed from the boundaries of the thickened portion normal to the growth face, rather than to the folding surfaces. In addition, it is suggested that melting also initiates at defective or distorted sites in the crystal as revealed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and AFM.     

In situ measurement of cell stiffness of Arabidopsis roots growing on a glass micropillar support by atomic force microscopy

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) can measure the mechanical properties of plant tissue at the cellular level, but for in situ observations, the sample must be held in place on a rigid support and it is difficult to obtain accurate data for living plants without inhibiting their growth. To investigate the dynamics of root cell stiffness during seedling growth, we circumvented these problems by using an array of glass micropillars as a support to hold an Arabidopsis thaliana root for AFM measurements without inhibiting root growth. The root elongated in the gaps between the pillars and was supported by the pillars. The AFM cantilever could contact the root for repeated measurements over the course of root growth. The elasticity of the root epidermal cells was used as an index of the stiffness. By contrast, we were not able to reliably observe roots on a smooth glass substrate because it was difficult to retain contact between the root and the cantilever without the support of the pillars. Using adhesive to fix the root on the smooth glass plane overcame this issue, but prevented root growth. The glass micropillar support allowed reproducible measurement of the spatial and temporal changes in root cell elasticity, making it possible to perform detailed AFM observations of the dynamics of root cell stiffness.     

A complementary microscopy analysis of Sticholysin II crystals on lipid films: Atomic force and transmission electron characterizations

A new crystal form of the cytotoxin Sticholysin II (StnII) formed on lipid monolayers of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) has been characterized by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and by tapping mode atomic force microscopy (AFM) under nearly physiological conditions. Both approaches show the existence of single- and double-layered 2D crystals possessing hexagonal symmetry and unit cell dimensions of a = b =10 nm and gamma = 120 degrees. However, single-layered StnII crystals could only be analysed by TEM and double-layered crystals by AFM. Considering the previously known atomic structure of native StnII and that of a tetrameric assembly, a model is proposed for this new crystal form in which StnII conserves its monomeric state upon interaction with the lipid monolayer. These results are in agreement with the existence of the so called M2 state of the actinoporins.     

Surface processes in the crystallization of turnip yellow mosaic virus visualized by atomic force microscopy.

In situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to investigate surface evolution during the growth of single crystals of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV). Growth of the (101) face of TYMV crystals proceeded by two-dimensional nucleation. The molecular structure of the step edges and adsorption of individual virus particles and their aggregates on the crystalline surface were recorded. The surfaces of individual virions within crystals were visualized and seen to be quite distinctive with the hexameric and pentameric capsomers of the T = 3 capsids being clearly resolved. This, so far as we are aware, is the first direct visualization of the capsomere structure of a virus by AFM. In the course of recording the in situ development of the crystals, a profound restructuring of the surface arrangement was observed. This transformation was highly cooperative in nature, but the transitions were unambiguous and readily explicable in terms of an organized loss of classes of virus particles from specific lattice positions. In some cases areas of a single crystal surface were recorded in which were captured successive phases of the transition. We believe this provides the first visual record of a cooperative restructuring of the surface of a supramolecular crystal.