The novel Cladosporium fulvum lysin motif effector Ecp6 is a virulence factor with orthologues in other fungal species

During tomato leaf colonization, the biotrophic fungus Cladosporium fulvum secretes several effector proteins into the apoplast. Eight effectors have previously been characterized and show no significant homology to each other or to other fungal genes. To discover novel C. fulvum effectors that might play a role in virulence, we utilized two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE) to visualize proteins secreted during C. fulvum –tomato interactions. Three novel C. fulvum proteins were identified: CfPhiA, Ecp6 and Ecp7. CfPhiA shows homology to proteins found on fungal sporogenous cells called phialides. Ecp6 contains lysin motifs (LysM domains) that are recognized as carbohydrate-binding modules. Ecp7 encodes a small, cysteine-rich protein with no homology to known proteins. Heterologous expression of Ecp6 significantly increased the virulence of the vascular pathogen Fusarium oxysporum on tomato. Furthermore, by RNA interference (RNAi)-mediated gene silencing we demonstrate that Ecp6 is instrumental for C. fulvum virulence on tomato. Hardly any allelic variation was observed in the Ecp6 coding region of a worldwide collection of C. fulvum strains. Although none of the C. fulvum effectors identified so far have obvious orthologues in other organisms, conserved Ecp6 orthologues were identified in various fungal species. Homology-based modelling suggests that the LysM domains of C. fulvum Ecp6 may be involved in chitin binding.     

Evidence that γ-aminobutyric acid is a major nitrogen source during Cladosporium fulvum infection of tomato

The growth of the biotrophic pathogen Cladosporium fulvum within the tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) leaf is restricted to the intercellular space. Previous studies from this laboratory have demonstrated that gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) accumulates to millimolar concentrations in the apoplast during a compatible interaction. We decided to further investigate the role of GABA during infection. A gene encoding a required enzyme for GABA metabolism, GABA transaminase (Gat1), was cloned and sequenced from C. fulvum. The predicted protein sequence of Gat1 had high homology to other fungal GABA transaminases, particularly from Aspergillus nidulans. In vitro expression experiments revealed Gat1 to be strongly expressed during fungal growth on both GABA and glutamate whereas nearly no expression was evident during nitrogen starvation conditions. Expression of Gat1 was also apparent during infection, suggesting for the first time that C. fulvum actively metabolises GABA during infection. This indicates that the fungus may be utilising the GABA in the apoplast as a nutrient source. Further analysis revealed that the expression of tomato glutamate decarboxylase, the enzyme responsible for GABA synthesis, appeared appreciably higher during a compatible interaction than in the incompatible interaction. These findings imply that the infecting fungus may alter the physiology of the tomato leaf with the result that a source of nitrogen is supplied.     

An effector-targeted protease contributes to defense against Phytophthora infestans and is under diversifying selection in natural hosts

Since the leaf apoplast is a primary habitat for many plant pathogens, apoplastic proteins are potent, ancient targets for apoplastic effectors secreted by plant pathogens. So far, however, only a few apoplastic effector targets have been identified and characterized. Here, we discovered that the papain-like cysteine protease C14 is a new common target of EPIC1 and EPIC2B, two apoplastic, cystatin-like proteins secreted by the potato (Solanum tuberosum) late blight pathogen Phytophthora infestans. C14 is a secreted protease of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) and potato typified by a carboxyl-terminal granulin domain. The EPIC-C14 interaction occurs at a wide pH range and is stronger than the previously described interactions of EPICs with tomato defense proteases PIP1 and RCR3. The selectivity of the EPICs is also different when compared with the AVR2 effector of the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum, which targets PIP1 and RCR3, and only at apoplastic pH. Importantly, silencing of C14 increased susceptibility to P. infestans, demonstrating that this protease plays a role in pathogen defense. Although C14 is under conservative selection in tomato, it is under diversifying selection in wild potato species (Solanum demissum, Solanum verrucosum, and Solanum stoliniferum) that are the natural hosts of P. infestans. These data reveal a novel effector target in the apoplast that contributes to immunity and is under diversifying selection, but only in the natural host of the pathogen.     

The nitrogen content of the tomato leaf apoplast increases during infection by Cladosporium fulvum

To address the problem of the nutritional requirements of phyto-pathogenic fungi growing in planta, the environment for the intercellular biotrophic pathogen, Cladosporium fulvum Cooke, of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.) was analysed. Using a novel technique for infiltrating the intercellular space, we measured the concentrations of 21 amino acids, nitrate and ammonia in the apoplast of the tomato leaf during infection. The concentrations of most amino acids, and total nitrogen content, increased during infection. The levels of nearly all amino acids remained relatively unchanged during an incompatible interaction. All protein amino acids were detected during infection, except cysteine and tryptophan. Most amino acids were present at a concentration between 0.1-0.7 mM. The non-protein amino acid gamma-aminobutyric acid was detected at the highest concentration (up to 2.5 mM) during the compatible interaction. Preliminary investigations on the source of the amino acids revealed that protease activity within the apoplast increased during infection and that infection induced the expression of the pathogenicity-related extracellular serine protease P69B. The nitrogen status of the infecting fungus and sources for the additional amino acids are discussed.     

Endoplasmic reticulum-quality control chaperones facilitate the biogenesis of Cf receptor-like proteins involved in pathogen resistance of tomato

Cf proteins are receptor-like proteins (RLPs) that mediate resistance of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) to the foliar pathogen Cladosporium fulvum. These transmembrane immune receptors, which carry extracellular leucine-rich repeats that are subjected to posttranslational glycosylation, perceive effectors of the pathogen and trigger a defense response that results in plant resistance. To identify proteins required for the functionality of these RLPs, we performed immunopurification of a functional Cf-4-enhanced green fluorescent protein fusion protein transiently expressed in Nicotiana benthamiana, followed by mass spectrometry. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) heat shock protein70 binding proteins (BiPs) and lectin-type calreticulins (CRTs), which are chaperones involved in ER-quality control, were copurifying with Cf-4-enhanced green fluorescent protein. The tomato and N. benthamiana genomes encode four BiP homologs and silencing experiments revealed that these BiPs are important for overall plant viability. For the three tomato CRTs, virus-induced gene silencing targeting the plant-specific CRT3a gene resulted in a significantly compromised Cf-4-mediated defense response and loss of full resistance to C. fulvum. We show that upon knockdown of CRT3a the Cf-4 protein accumulated, but the pool of Cf-4 protein carrying complex-type N-linked glycans was largely reduced. Together, our study on proteins required for Cf function reveals an important role for the CRT ER chaperone CRT3a in the biogenesis and functionality of this type of RLP involved in plant defense.     

Specific HR-associated recognition of secreted proteins from Cladosporium fulvum occurs in both host and non-host plants

The resistance of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) to the pathogenic fungus Cladosporium fulvum complies with the gene-for-gene concept. Host resistance is based on specific recognition of extracellular fungal proteins, resulting in a hypersensitive response (HR). Five proteins secreted by C. fulvum were purified and the encoding cDNA clone was obtained from two novel ones among them. Various tomato breeding lines and accessions of Lycopersicon pimpinellifolium were tested for their recognitional specificity by injection of the purified proteins or potato virus X-based expression of the cDNA. We found that HR-associated recognition of one or more of these proteins, in addition to recognition of the race-specific elicitors AVR4 and AVR9 of C. fulvum, occurs among Lycopersicon species. Studies on the inheritance of this recognition confirmed that single dominant genes are involved. Furthermore, one of the extracellular proteins of C. fulvum is specifically recognized by Nicotiana paniculata, which is not a host for C. fulvum. These results indicate that plants have a highly effective surveillance system for the presence of 'foreign' proteins, which, together with the high mutation rate of pathogens, can explain the complex gene-for-gene relationships frequently observed in pathosystems.     

Cladosporium fulvum Avr4 protects fungal cell walls against hydrolysis by plant chitinases accumulating during infection

Resistance against the leaf mold fungus Cladosporium fulvum is mediated by the tomato Cf proteins which belong to the class of receptor-like proteins and indirectly recognize extracellular avirulence proteins (Avrs) of the fungus. Apart from triggering disease resistance, Avrs are believed to play a role in pathogenicity or virulence of C. fulvum. Here, we report on the avirulence protein Avr4, which is a chitin-binding lectin containing an invertebrate chitin-binding domain (CBM14). This domain is found in many eukaryotes, but has not yet been described in fungal or plant genomes. We found that interaction of Avr4 with chitin is specific, because it does not interact with other cell wall polysaccharides. Avr4 binds to chitin oligomers with a minimal length of three N-acetyl glucosamine residues. In vitro, Avr4 protects chitin against hydrolysis by plant chitinases. Avr4 also binds to chitin in cell walls of the fungi Trichoderma viride and Fusarium solani f. sp. phaseoli and protects these fungi against normally deleterious concentrations of plant chitinases. In situ fluorescence studies showed that Avr4 also binds to cell walls of C. fulvum during infection of tomato, where it most likely protects the fungus against tomato chitinases, suggesting that Avr4 is a counter-defensive virulence factor.     

Expression of the Avirulence gene Avr9 of the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum is regulated by the global nitrogen response factor NRF1

Here we describe the role of the Cladosporium fulvum nitrogen response factor 1 (Nrf1) gene in regulation of the expression of avirulence gene Avr9 and virulence on tomato. The Nrf1 gene, which was isolated by a polymerase chain reaction-based strategy, is predicted to encode a protein of 918 amino acid residues. The protein contains a putative zinc finger DNA-binding domain that shares 98% amino acid identity with the zinc finger of the major nitrogen regulatory proteins AREA and NIT2 of Aspergillus nidulans and Neurospora crassa, respectively. Functional equivalence of Nrf1 to areA was demonstrated by complementation of an A. nidulans areA loss-of-function mutant with Nrf1. Nrf1-deficient transformants of C. fulvum obtained by homologous recombination were unable to utilize nitrate and nitrite as a nitrogen source. In contrast to what was observed in the C. fulvum wild-type, the Avr9 gene was no longer induced under nitrogen-starvation conditions in Nrf1-deficient strains. On susceptible tomato plants, the Nrf1-deficient strains were as virulent as wild-type strains of C. fulvum, although the expression of the Avr9 gene was strongly reduced. In addition, Nrf1-deficient strains were still avirulent on tomato plants containing the functional Cf-9 resistance gene, indicating that in planta, apparently sufficient quantities of stable AVR9 elicitor are produced. Our results suggest that the NRF1 protein is a major regulator of the Avr9 gene.     

Nitrogen limitation induces expression of the avirulence gene avr9 in the tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum

The avirulence gene avr9 of the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum encodes a race-specific peptide elicitor that induces the hypersensitive response in tomato plants carrying the complementary resistance gene Cf9. The avr9 gene is not expressed under optimal growth conditions in vitro, but is highly expressed when the fungus grows inside the tomato leaf. In this paper we present evidence for the induction of avr9 gene expression in C. fulvum grown in vitro under conditions of nitrogen limitation. Only growth medium with very low amounts of nitrogen (nitrate, ammonium, glutamate or glutamine) induced the expression of avr9. Limitation of other macronutrients or the addition of plant factors did not induce the expression of avr9. The induced expression of avr9 is possibly mediated by a positive-acting nitrogen regulatory protein, homologous to the Neurospora crassa NIT2 protein, which induces the expression of many genes under conditions of nitrogen limitation. The avr9 promoter contains several putative NIT2 binding sites. The expression of avr9 during the infection process was explored cytologically using transformants of C. fulvum carrying an avr9 promoter-β-glucuronidase reporter gene fusion. The possibility that expression of avr9 in C. fulvum growing in planta is caused by nitrogen limitation in the apoplast of the tomato leaf is discussed.     

The chitin-binding Cladosporium fulvum effector protein Avr4 is a virulence factor

The biotrophic fungal pathogen Cladosporium fulvum (syn. Passalora fulva) is the causal agent of tomato leaf mold. The Avr4 protein belongs to a set of effectors that is secreted by C. fulvum during infection and is thought to play a role in pathogen virulence. Previous studies have shown that Avr4 binds to chitin present in fungal cell walls and that, through this binding, Avr4 can protect these cell walls against hydrolysis by plant chitinases. In this study, we demonstrate that Avr4 expression in Arabidopsis results in increased virulence of several fungal pathogens with exposed chitin in their cell walls, whereas the virulence of a bacterium and an oomycete remained unaltered. Heterologous expression of Avr4 in tomato increased the virulence of Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici. Through tomato GeneChip analyses, we demonstrate that Avr4 expression in tomato results in the induced expression of only a few genes. Finally, we demonstrate that silencing of the Avr4 gene in C. fulvum decreases its virulence on tomato. This is the first report on the intrinsic function of a fungal avirulence protein that has a counter-defensive activity required for full virulence of the pathogen.     

The Cf-4 and Cf-9 resistance genes against Cladosporium fulvum are conserved in wild tomato species

The Cf-4 and Cf-9 genes originate from the wild tomato species Lycopersicon hirsutum and L. pimpinellifolium and confer resistance to strains of the leaf mold fungus Cladosporium fulvum that secrete the Avr4 and Avr9 elicitor proteins, respectively. Homologs of Cf-4 and Cf-9 (Hcr9s) are located in several clusters and evolve mainly through sequence exchange between homologs. To study the evolution of Cf genes, we set out to identify functional Hcr9s that mediate recognition of Avr4 and Avr9 (designated Hcr9-Avr4s and Hcr9-Avr9s) in all wild tomato species. Plants responsive to the Avr4 and Avr9 elicitor proteins were identified throughout the genus Lycopersicon. Open reading frames of Hcr9s from Avr4- and Avr9-responsive tomato plants were polymerase chain reaction-amplified. Several Hcr9s that mediate Avr4 or Avr9 recognition were identified in diverged tomato species by agroinfiltration assays. These Hcr9-Avr4s and Hcr9-Avr9s are highly identical to Cf-4 and Cf-9, respectively. Therefore, we conclude that both Cf-4 and Cf-9 predate Lycopersicon speciation. These results further suggest that C. fulvum is an ancient pathogen of the genus Lycopersicon, in which Cf-4 and Cf-9 have been maintained by selection pressure imposed by C. fulvum.     

Nitrogen limitation induces expression of the avirulence gene avr9 in the tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum

The avirulence gene avr9 of the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum encodes a race-specific peptide elicitor that induces the hypersensitive response in tomato plants carrying the complementary resistance gene Cf9. The avr9 gene is not expressed under optimal growth conditions in vitro, but is highly expressed when the fungus grows inside the tomato leaf. In this paper we present evidence for the induction of avr9 gene expression in C. fulvum grown in vitro under conditions of nitrogen limitation. Only growth medium with very low amounts of nitrogen (nitrate, ammonium, glutamate or glutamine) induced the expression of avr9. Limitation of other macronutrients or the addition of plant factors did not induce the expression of avr9. The induced expression of avr9 is possibly mediated by a positive-acting nitrogen regulatory protein, homologous to the Neurospora crassa NIT2 protein, which induces the expression of many genes under conditions of nitrogen limitation. The avr9 promoter contains several putative NIT2 binding sites. The expression of avr9 during the infection process was explored cytologically using transformants of C. fulvum carrying an avr9 promoter--glucuronidase reporter gene fusion. The possibility that expression of avr9 in C. fulvum growing in planta is caused by nitrogen limitation in the apoplast of the tomato leaf is discussed.     

A protease activity-depleted environment for heterologous proteins migrating towards the leaf cell apoplast

Recombinant proteins face major constraints along the plant cell secretory pathway, including proteolytic processing compromising their structural integrity. Here, we demonstrate the potential of protease inhibitors as in situ stabilizing agents for recombinant proteins migrating towards the leaf apoplast. Genomic data for Arabidopsis, rice and Nicotiana spp. were assessed to determine the relative incidence of protease families in the cell secretory pathway. Transient expression assays with the model platform Nicotiana benthamiana were then performed to test the efficiency of protease inhibitors in stabilizing proteins targeted to the apoplast. Current genomic data suggest the occurrence of proteases from several families along the secretory pathway, including A1 and A22 Asp proteases; C1A and C13 Cys proteases; and S1, S8 and S10 Ser proteases. In vitro protease assays confirmed the presence of various proteases in N. benthamiana leaves, notably pointing to the deposition of A1‐ and S1‐type activities preferentially in the apoplast. Accordingly, transient expression and secretion of the A1/S1 protease inhibitor, tomato cathepsin D inhibitor (SlCDI), negatively altered A1 and S1 protease activities in this cell compartment, while increasing the leaf apoplast protein content by ～45% and improving the accumulation of a murine diagnostic antibody, C5‐1, co‐secreted in the apoplast. SlCYS9, an inhibitor of C1A and C13 Cys proteases, had no impact on the apoplast proteases and protein content, but stabilized C5‐1 in planta, presumably upstream in the secretory pathway. These data confirm, overall, the potential of protease inhibitors for the in situ protection of recombinant proteins along the plant cell secretory pathway.     

The phytopathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 has three high-affinity iron-scavenging systems functional under iron limitation conditions but dispensable for pathogenesis

High-affinity iron scavenging through the use of siderophores is a well-established virulence determinant in mammalian pathogenesis. However, few examples have been reported for plant pathogens. Here, we use a genetic approach to investigate the role of siderophores in Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 (DC3000) virulence in tomato. DC3000, an agronomically important pathogen, has two known siderophores for high-affinity iron scavenging, yersiniabactin and pyoverdin, and we uncover a third siderophore, citrate, required for growth when iron is limiting. Though growth of a DC3000 triple mutant unable to either synthesize or import these siderophores is severely restricted in iron-limited culture, it is fully pathogenic. One explanation for this phenotype is that the DC3000 triple mutant is able to directly pirate plant iron compounds such as heme/hemin or iron-nicotianamine, and our data indicate that DC3000 can import iron-nicotianamine with high affinity. However, an alternative explanation, supported by data from others, is that the pathogenic environment of DC3000 (i.e., leaf apoplast) is not iron limited but is iron replete, with available iron of >1 μM. Growth of the triple mutant in culture is restored to wild-type levels by supplementation with a variety of iron chelates at >1 μM, including iron(III) dicitrate, a dominant chelate of the leaf apoplast. This suggests that lower-affinity iron import would be sufficient for DC3000 iron nutrition in planta and is in sharp contrast to the high-affinity iron-scavenging mechanisms required in mammalian pathogenesis.     

A role for BELLRINGER in cell wall development is supported by loss-of-function phenotypes

Studies reported unintended pleiotropic effects for a number of pesticidal proteins ectopically expressed in transgenic crops, but the nature and significance of such effects in planta remain poorly understood. Here we assessed the effects of corn cystatin II (CCII), a potent inhibitor of C1A cysteine (Cys) proteases considered for insect and pathogen control, on the leaf proteome and pathogen resistance status of potato lines constitutively expressing this protein. The leaf proteome of lines accumulating CCII at different levels was resolved by 2-dimensional gel electrophoresis and compared with the leaf proteome of a control (parental) line. Out of ca. 700 proteins monitored on 2-D gels, 23 were significantly up- or downregulated in CCII-expressing leaves, including 14 proteins detected de novo or up-regulated by more than five-fold compared to the control. Most up-regulated proteins were abiotic or biotic stress-responsive proteins, including different secretory peroxidases, wound inducible protease inhibitors and pathogenesis-related proteins. Accordingly, infection of leaf tissues by the fungal necrotroph Botryris cinerea was prevented in CCII-expressing plants, despite a null impact of CCII on growth of this pathogen and the absence of extracellular Cys protease targets for the inhibitor. These data point to the onset of pleiotropic effects altering the leaf proteome in transgenic plants expressing recombinant protease inhibitors. They also show the potential of these proteins as ectopic modulators of stress responses in planta, useful to engineer biotic or abiotic stress tolerance in crop plants of economic significance.     

The AVR9 race-specific elicitor of Cladosporium fulvum is processed by endogenous and plant proteases.

The avirulence gene avr9 of the fungal tomato pathogen Cladosporium fulvum encodes a race-specific peptide elicitor that induces a hypersensitive response in tomato plants carrying the complementary resistance gene Cf9. The avr9 gene is highly expressed when C. fulvum is growing in the plant and the elicitor accumulates in infected leaves as a 28-amino acid (aa) peptide. In C. fulvum grown in vitro, the peptide elicitor is not produced in detectable amounts. To produce significant amounts of the AVR9 elicitor in vitro, the coding and termination sequences of the avr9 gene were fused to the constitutive gpd-promoter (glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate dehydrogenase) of Aspergillus nidulans. Transformants of C. fulvum were obtained that highly expressed the avr9 gene in vitro and produced active AVR9 peptide elicitors. These peptides were partially sequenced from the N terminus and appeared to consist of 32, 33, and 34 aa's, respectively, and are the precursors of the mature 28-aa AVR9 peptide. We demonstrated that plant factors process the 34-aa peptide into the mature 28-aa peptide. We present a model for the processing of AVR9 involving cleavage of a signal peptide during excretion and further maturation by fungal and plant proteases into the stable 28-aa peptide elicitor.