Influence of growth rate and starvation on fluorescent in situ hybridization of Rhodopseudomonas palustris

In situ hybridization with a fluorescently labeled 16S rRNA-targeted probe was examined using Rhodopseudomonas palustris as a model organism, which had been grown at different rates and under different conditions of growth and starvation. The specific growth rate did not affect the percentage of hybridized cells in aerobically grown R. palustris cultures. However, significant changes in the percentage of hybridized cells occurred during extended periods of starvation. These changes were observed both in batch cultures grown and starved aerobically in the dark, and in cultures grown phototrophically and starved anaerobically in the dark. Aerobic growth in batch culture and subsequent starvation resulted in a complete lack of detectable hybridization after 20 days of starvation. In contrast, even after 30 days of starvation, 50% of all cells were still detectable in cultures grown aerobically at growth rates <0.06 h(-1) and then starved aerobically in the dark. The same was true for phototrophically grown cells that were starved anaerobically in the light. During starvation there was a clear, though non-linear, positive correlation between the percentage of hybridized cells and the RNA content. In contrast, no direct correlation was observed between the number of hybridized cells in a culture and the viability of this culture. Thus, in habitats with growing, non-growing, and starving bacteria, data on quantitative detection of populations based on 16S rRNA-targeted probing should be used with extreme caution as the detectability of the individual cells is strongly influenced by their physiological history and current physiological state.     

Starvation survival of Salmonella enteritidis.

Washed cells of Salmonella enteritidis harvested from a defined medium during logarithmic growth were subjected to starvation in pH 7 phosphate buffer at 37 C. Viability was measured by slide cultures and plate counts. The survival of cell suspensions equivalent to 1 to 10 mg (dry wt)/ml was influenced by cryptic growth. The rate of cryptic growth, assessed by plate counts, increased with cell density and could not be alleviated by starvation with dialysis. Dialysis of the starving culture did retard the onset of cryptic growth but did not eliminate it, indicating that the major substrates for regrowth were relatively large cellular components. In phosphate buffer, 6.7 homologous heat-killed cells allowed for the doubling of one S. enteritidis cell. Cryptic growth was not observed when cells were starved on the surface of membrane filters or in suspensions equivalent to 20 mug (dry wt)/ml (105 cells/ml). Similar half-life survival times were calculated for both these populations, but the shape of their survival curves differed significantly. These differences were attributed to stress factors encountered during cell preparation and during starvation. The half-life survival time of S. enteritidis starved at 20 mug (dry wt)/ml was 140 h in phosphate buffer, 82 h in 3,6-endomethylene-1,2,3,-6-tetrahydrophthalic acid buffer, and 77 h in tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane buffer.     

Comparative studies of two membrane fractions isolated from chemotrophically and phototrophically grown cells of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata.

Light and heavy membrane fractions have been isolated by equilibrium sucrose density centrifugation from Rhodopseudomonas capsulata 938 GCM grown aerobically in the dark (chemotrophically) and anaerobically in the light (phototrophically). The densities of the light and heavy fractions from phototrophic cells were 1.1004 to 1.1006 and 1.1478, respectively, and the densities of the light and heavy fractions from chemotrophic cells were 1.0957 to 1.0958 and 1.1315, respectively. Both fractions were active in photochemical and respiratory functions and in electron transport-coupled phosphorylation. The light membrane fraction isolated from chemotrophic cells contained the reaction center and the light-harvesting pigment-protein complex B 870, but not the variable light-harvesting complex B 800-850. A small amount of the complex B 800-850 was present in the light fraction isolated from phototrophically grown cells, but it was not energetically coupled to the photosynthetic apparatus. From inhibitor studies, difference spectroscopy, and measurement of enzyme activities it was tentatively concluded that the light membrane fraction contains only the reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide-oxidizing electron transport chain having a KCN-insensitive, low-potential cytochrome c oxidase, whereas the heavy fraction contains additionally the succinate dehydrogenase and a high-potential cytochrome b terminal oxidase sensitive to KCN. The light membrane fraction was more labile than the heavy fraction in terms of phosphorylating activity.     

Semiaerobic induction of bacteriochlorophyll synthesis in the green bacterium Chloroflexus aurantiacus.

Comparison of Chloroflexus aurantiacus J-10-fl cells by freeze-fracture electron microscopy showed that cell shape and dimensions did not depend on oxygen tension or light intensity during growth. The major morphological difference between cells cultured anaerobically in the light and aerobically in the dark was the absence of chlorosomes in aerobically grown cells. C. aurantiacus cells cultured aerobically in the dark began bacteriochlorophyll synthesis immediately when shifted to either phototrophic or semiaerobic conditions. Cells adapting to phototrophic conditions grew to the same density and synthesized as much bacteriochlorophyll as nonadapting phototrophic cultures grown at the same light intensity. Cells adapting to reduced oxygen tension (semiaerobic conditions) in the dark entered an 8- to 12-h growth lag during which the bacteriochlorophyll content increased significantly. Despite variations in the initial bacteriochlorophyll content and in the length of the growth lag, the amounts of bacteriochlorophyll a and c were constant at the end of the semiaerobic growth lag. At later times during adaptation to semiaerobic conditions, after growth resumed, variations in the ratio of bacteriochlorophyll c/bacteriochlorophyll a were observed and suggested independent regulation of the two bacteriochlorophylls.     

The effect of anaerobiosis on the induced synthesis of β-galactosidase in non-growingEscherichia coli

Depending on conditions of aeration maltose and glucose were found to exhibit different effects on the inducible synthesis of β-galactosidase in aerobically grown cells ofEscherichia coli starving for an exogenous source of nitrogen; both saccharides repressed the synthesis of the enzyme under aerobic conditions, while the above-mentioned saccharides were essential for the enzyme synthesis under anaerobic conditions. The presence of maltose in the medium resulted in the repression of the enzyme synthesis in anaerobically grown cells starving for an exogenous nitrogen source under anaerobic conditions. The synthesis of β-galactosidase-specific messenger RNA was completely blocked and the synthesis of the enzyme proper considerably inhibited in aerobically grown cells incubated anaerobically in a medium without nitrogen and carbon sources.     

Photooxidative production of carbon monoxide by phototrophic microorganisms

Net photosynthesis and CO production were measured in cell suspensions of Chlorella fusca. The rate of net photosynthesis showed saturation curves with increasing radiation intensities and CO₂-mixing ratios. Maximum rates were found at 35° C with a sharp decrease at higher temperatures. By contrast, the rate of CO production was proportional to the radiation intensity and did not show any saturation up to 1.5 kW · m^?2 white light. The CO-production rate was higher in blue than in red light and was independent of the CO₂-mixing ratio of the carrier gas within a range of 0–1000 ppmv. We found that the CO-production rate was constant within the physiological temperature range of 10–35° C, but increased considerably at higher temperatures and that CO production by the chlorophyll-deficient mutant of C. fusca was 5 times that of the wild type. In addition, we measured CO production in cell suspensions of Chromatium vinosum, Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila, which were grown either anaerobically in the light or aerobically in the dark. CO production could only be observed when the cells were incubated in the presence of oxygen and light. Under these conditions more CO was produced by aerobically grown cells than by phototrophically grown cells of R. sphaeroides and R. acidophila. The results obtained indicate that CO was produced by photosensitized oxidations and not by metabolic processes.     

Localization and environmental regulation of MCP-like proteins in Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Chemotaxis to many compounds by Rhodobacter sphaeroides requires transport and at least partial metabolism of the chemoeffector. Previous investigations using phototrophically grown cells have failed to find any homologues of the MCP chemoreceptors identified in Escherichia coli. However, using an antibody raised against the highly conserved domain of E. coli Tsr, MCP-like proteins were identified in R. sphaeroides WS8N. Analysis using Western blotting and immunogold electron microscopy showed that expression of these MCP-like proteins is environmentally regulated and that receptors are targeted to two different cellular locations: the poles of the cells and the cytoplasm. In aerobically grown cells, these proteins were shown by immunoelectron microscopy to localize predominantly to the cell poles and to an electron-dense body in the cytoplasm. Western blot analysis indicated a 17-fold reduction in protein concentration when cells were grown in the light. The number of immunogold particles was also dramatically reduced in anaerobically light-grown cells and their cellular distribution was altered. Fewer receptors localized to the cell poles and more particles randomly distributed within the cell, but the cytoplasmic cluster remained. These trends were more pronounced in cells grown anaerobically under dim light than in those grown anaerobically under bright light, suggesting that expression is controlled by redox state and either light intensity or the extent of photosynthetic membrane synthesis. Recent work on E. coli chemosensing suggests that oligomerization of receptors and chemosensory proteins is important for sensory signalling. The data presented here suggest that this oligomerization can occur with cytoplasmic receptors and also provides an explanation for the multiple copies of chemosensory proteins in R. sphaeroides.     

Activity and characterization of mixed organic compounds extracted from Rhodobacter sphaeroides as alternative materials to serum for mammalian cell growth

Photosynthetic microorganisms produce relatively large amounts of physiologically active materials which stimulate the physiological activity of other organisms. In this study, mammalian HeLa cells were cultured in different culture media which were Dulbecco's modified Eagle medium (DMEM) with newborn calf serum (NCS), and DMEM including different types of physiologically activating compounds (PACs) extracted from Rhodobacter sphaeroides grown under various culture conditions. R. sphaeroides was grown under the following five different culture conditions: anaerobically in the light, anaerobically in the dark and treated with dimethyl sulfoxide, aerobically in the dark for 48 h, in the light for 48 h, and in the light for 24 h and changed after previous culturing in the dark for 24 h. The growth of HeLa cell was measured by cell counting using a hemocytometer, and the fluorescent intensities of cellular lysosomes were measured to check the level of cellular stress caused by adding PACs. The growth of HeLa cells cultured in DMEM with PACs extracted from R. sphaeroides aerobically grown under dark conditions was enhanced compared to that of cells grown with NCS. We also found that a high concentration of pigments such as bacteriochlorophylls and carotenoids and a high concentration of arginine produced by R. sphaeroides aerobically grown in the dark were implicated in increased growth of the HeLa cells. Therefore, our results suggest that PACs extracted from R. sphaeroides aerobically cultured in dark conditions can enhance the physiological activity of mammalian cells and serve as nontoxic and bioavailable materials.     

THE FINE STRUCTURE OF RHODOSPIRILLUM RUBRUM

The fine structure of Rhodospirillum rubrum grown under a series of defined conditions has been examined in thin sections prepared by the methods of Ryter and Kellenberger. In cells grown anaerobically at different light intensities, the abundance of 500 A membrane-bounded vesicles in the cytoplasm is inversely related to light intensity, and directly related to cellular chlorophyll content. When the chlorophyll content of the cell is low, the vesicles are exclusively peripheral in location; they extend more deeply into the cytoplasm when the chlorophyll content is high. Typical vesicles also occur, though rarely, in cells grown aerobically in the dark, which have a negligible chlorophyll content. When synthesis of the photosynthetic pigment system is induced in a population of aerobically grown cells by incubation under semianaerobic conditions in the dark, the vesicles become increasingly abundant with increasing cellular chlorophyll content, and the cells eventually acquire the cytoplasmic structure that is characteristic of cells growing anaerobically at a high light intensity. Poststaining with lead hydroxide reveals that the membranes surrounding the 500 A vesicles are indistinguishable in structure from the cytoplasmic membrane, and continuous with it in some areas of the sections. The bearing of these observations on current notions concerning the organization of the bacterial photosynthetic apparatus is discussed.     

Metabolism of the phase variants of the phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Growth, bacteriochlorophyll a content, electron transport chain (ETC), and activities of the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle enzymes were studied in R and M phase variants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides cells grown anaerobically in the light and aerobically in the dark. Under all cultivation conditions tested, bacteriochlorophyll a content was 2–3 times lower in the cells of the M variant compared to the R variant, which therefore was predominant in the cultures grown in the light. In both variants, activity of all TCA cycle enzymes was higher for the cells grown in the dark under aerobic conditions. When grown aerobically in the dark, the R variant, unlike the M variant, did not contain cytochrome aa ₃, acting as cytochrome c oxidase, in its ETC. An additional point of coupling the electron transfer to the generation of the proton gradient at the cytochrome aa ₃ level provided for more efficient oxidation of organic substrates, resulting in predominance of the M variant in the cultures grown in the dark under aerobic conditions.     

Effect of aerobic growth conditions on the soluble cytochrome content of the purple phototrophic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides: induction of cytochrome c554

When grown anaerobically in the light, Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains appreciable quantities of cytochromes c2 and c', but smaller amounts of other soluble cytochromes such as cytochrome c551.5, cytochrome c554, and an oxygen-binding heme protein. When R. sphaeroides is mass cultured aerobically in the dark to stationary phase, the content of cytochrome c2 does not change appreciably, whereas cytochrome c554 is approximately 8-fold more abundant, cytochrome c' is at least 10-fold less abundant, and cytochrome c551.5 is fivefold lower than in the phototrophically grown cells. These observations confirm previous literature reports that in this organism a cytochrome c553 (or c554 in our experience) is more abundant when cells are grown aerobically. Furthermore, the aerobic cytochrome c554 is positively identified with the previously characterized minor cytochrome c554 component of anaerobic photosynthetic cells. Preliminary sequence results show that cytochrome c554 is a member of the cytochrome c' structural family, but differs from normal cytochromes c' in having a methionine sixth ligand to the heme. The levels of electron carrier proteins of low redox potential had previously been reported to be less in aerobic than in photoheterotrophic cells and we have verified that observation for the specific examples of cytochromes c' and c551.5. The oxygen binding heme protein, SHP, is not induced by aerobic growth.     

Anaerobic Growth of Purple Nonsulfur Bacteria Under Dark Conditions

Purple nonsulfur photosynthetic bacteria were cultured anaerobically in the absence of light by a modification of the Hungate technique. Growth was slow and resembled that of fastidious anaerobes; on yeast extract-peptone-agar medium, each cell produced about 16 descendants in 15 to 20 days. Growth was stimulated by addition of ethyl alcohol, acetate and H₂, or pyruvate and H₂. Cells grown in the presence of pyruvate and H₂ produced acetate and CO₂; each cell produced approximately 10 descendants in 24 hr under anaerobic, dark conditions. Spectrophotometric evidence obtained from cells which were the product of five generations suggests no difference between the bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoids synthesized by cells grown anaerobically under dark or light conditions. Likewise, the ultrastructure of the photosynthetic apparatus in cells grown anaerobically in the dark and in the light appears similar.     

Dark metabolism of acetate in Rhodospirillum rubrum cells, grown under photoheterotropic conditions

The mechanism of the dark assimilation of acetate in the photoheterotrophically grown nonsulfur bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum was studied. Both in the light and in the dark, acetate assimilation in Rsp. rubrum cells, which lack the glyoxylate pathway, was accompanied by the excretion of glyoxylate into the growth medium. The assimilation of propionate was accompanied by the excretion of pyruvate. Acetate assimilation was found to be stimulated by bicarbonate, pyruvate, the C4-dicarboxylic acids of the Krebs cycle, and glyoxylate, but not by propionate. These data implied that the citramalate (CM) cycle in Rsp. rubrum cells grown aerobically in the dark can function as an anaplerotic pathway. This supposition was confirmed by respiration measurements. The respiration of cells oxidizing acetate depended on the presence of CO2 in the medium. The fact that the intermediates of the CM cycle (citramalate and mesaconate) markedly inhibited acetate assimilation but had almost no effect on cell respiration indicative that citramalate and mesaconate are intermediates of the acetate assimilation pathway. The inhibition of acetate assimilation and cell respiration by itaconate was due to its inhibitory effect on propionyl-CoA carboxylase, an enzyme of the CM cycle. The addition of 5 mM itaconate to extracts of Rsp. rubrum cells inhibited the activity of this enzyme by 85%. The data obtained suggest that the CM cycle continues to function in Rsp. rubrum cells that have been grown anaerobically in the light and then transferred to the dark and incubated aerobically.     

Control of nitrogenase in chemostat cultures of Rhodobacter capsulatus grown on ammonium at different illuminations

Rhodobacter capsulatus strain 37b4 was grown phototrophically in chemostat cultures with 2 mM of ammonium chloride and 30 mM of malate at a constant dilution rate of 0.075 h^-1. When illumination was raised from 3000 to 30000 lx, steady state biomass levels as well as malate uptake increased linearly with increasing illumination. Yet, in no case external ammonium could be detected in the culture fluid. Specific nitrogenase activity increased by a factor of ten between 3000 and 15000 lx and approached constancy above 15 000 lx. When samples were anaerobically withdrawn from the chemostat and subsequently grown in batch cultures under saturating light conditions, biomass increased to a constant level, independently of the illumination used in the previous chemostat culture. In fact, the specific nitrogen contents of cells were 0.195 and 0.154 (g of N per g of protein) with chemostat cultures adapted to 3000 and 30000 lx, respectively. With the former cultures, specific nitrogen contents decreased to 0.142 g of nitrogen per g of cell protein upon incubation in a batch system. This suggests the existence of free nitrogen compounds in cells of chemostat cultures, the concentrations of which decrease while protein levels increase with increasing energy supply. Intracellular amino acid pools revealed slightly elevated levels of major amino acids in low-light cultures as compared to high-light cultures. On the basis of intracellular levels of ammonium, however, no significant differences could be detected. Since, in addition, malate consumption increased linearly with increasing illumination, it is proposed that light controls nitrogenase in Rhodobacter capsulatus via the C/N ratio, as represented by malate and ammonium consumption, rather than directly.     

Adenylate energy charge in Saccharomyces cerevisiae during starvation.

Bakers' yeast cells, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, if grown aerobically on ethanol or if grown aerobically on glucose and allowed to pass into stationary phase, with utilization of accumulated ethanol, maintain a normal value (0.8 to 0.9) of the adenylate energy charge during prolonged starvation. In contrast, cells grown anaerobically on glucose and cells in the early stages of aerobic growth on glucose exhibit a rapid decrease of energy charge if transferred to medium lacking on energy source. These results suggest that functional mitochondria or enzymes of balance of adenine nucleotides during starvation. Yeast cells remain viable at energy charge values below 0.1, in marked contrast to results previously obtained with Escherichia coli. In other respects, the engery charge responses of yeast to starvation and refeeding are generally similar to those previously reported for E. coli.     

Light Enhances Survival of Dinoroseobacter shibae during Long-Term Starvation

Aerobic anoxygenic phototrophs (AAPs) as being photoheterotrophs require organic substrates for growth and use light as a supplementary energy source under oxic conditions. We hypothesized that AAPs benefit from light particularly under carbon and electron donor limitation. The effect of light was determined in long-term starvation experiments with Dinoroseobacter shibae DFL 12^T in both complex marine broth and defined minimal medium with succinate as the sole carbon source. The cells were starved over six months under three conditions: continuous darkness (DD), continuous light (LL), and light/dark cycle (LD, 12 h/12 h, 12 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹). LD starvation at low light intensity resulted in 10-fold higher total cell and viable counts, and higher bacteriochlorophyll a and polyhydroxyalkanoate contents. This coincided with better physiological fitness as determined by respiration rates, proton translocation and ATP concentrations. In contrast, LD starvation at high light intensity (>22 µmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹, LD conditions) resulted in decreasing cell survival rates but increasing carotenoid concentrations, indicating a photo-protective response. Cells grown in complex medium survived longer starvation (more than 20 weeks) than those grown in minimal medium. Our experiments show that D. shibae benefits from the light and dark cycle, particularly during starvation.     

Long-term nutrient starvation of continuously cultured (glucose-limited) Selenomonas ruminantium.

Selenomonas ruminantium, a strictly anaerobic ruminal bacterium, was grown at various dilution rates (D = 0.05, 0.25, and 0.35 h-1) under glucose-limited continuous culture conditions. Suspensions of washed cells prepared anaerobically in mineral buffer were subjected to nutrient starvation (24 to 36 h; 39 degrees C; N2 atmosphere). Regardless of growth rate, viability declined logarithmically, and within about 2.5 h, about 50% of the populations were nonviable. After 24 h of starvation, the numbers of viable cells appeared to be inversely related to growth rate, the highest levels occurring with the slowest grown population. Cell dry weight, carbohydrate, protein, ribonucleic acid (RNA), and deoxyribonucleic acid declined logarithmically during starvation, and the decline rates of each were generally greater with cells grown at higher D values. Both cellular carbohydrate and RNA declined substantially during the first 12 h of starvation. Most of the cellular RNA that disappeared was found in the suspending buffer as low-molecular-weight, orcinol-positive materials. During growth, S. ruminantium made a variety of fermentation acids from glucose, but during starvation, acetate was the only acid made from catabolism of cellular material. Addition of glucose or vitamins to starving cell suspensions did not decrease loss of viability, whereas a starvation in the spent culture medium resulted in a slight decrease in the rate of viability loss. Overall, the data indicate that S. ruminantium strain D has very little survival capacity under the conditions tested compared with other bacterial species that have been studied.     

Role of Clp protease subunits in degradation of carbon starvation proteins in Escherichia coli.

When deprived of a carbon source, Escherichia coli induces the synthesis of a group of carbon starvation proteins. The degradation of proteins labeled during starvation was found to be an energy-dependent process which was inhibited by the addition of KCN and accelerated when cells were resupplied with a carbon source. The degradation of the starvation proteins did not require the ATP-dependent Lon protease or the energy-independent proteases protease I, protease IV, OmpT, and DegP. During starvation, mutants lacking either the ClpA or ClpP subunit of the ATP-dependent Clp protease showed a partial reduction in the degradation of starvation proteins. Strains lacking ClpP failed to increase degradation of starvation proteins when glucose was added to starving cells. The clpP mutants showed a competitive disadvantage compared with wild-type cells when exposed to repeated cycles of carbon starvation and growth. Surprisingly, the glucose-stimulated, ClpP-dependent degradation of starvation proteins did not require either the ClpA or ClpB protein. The patterns of synthesis of starvation proteins were similar in clpP+ and clpP cells. The clpP mutants had reduced rates of degradation of certain starvation proteins in the membrane fraction when a carbon source was resupplied to the starved cells.     

The effects of exopolymers on cell morphology and culturability of Leuconostoc mesenteroides during starvation

Biofilm formation by bacterial cells can be used to modify the subsurface permeability for the purpose of microbial enhanced oil recovery, bio-barrier formation, and in situ bioremediation. Once injected into the subsurface, the bacteria undergo starvation due to a decrease in nutrient supply and diffusion limitations in biofilms. To help understand the starvation response of bacteria in biofilms, the relationship between exopolymer formation and cell culturability was examined in a batch culture. The average cell diameter was observed to decrease from 0.8 μm to 0.35 μm 3 days after starvation began. Cell chain fragmentation was also observed during starvation. Cells that underwent starvation in the presence of insoluble exopolymers showed a slower rate of decrease in cell diameter and in cell chain length than cells without insoluble exopolymers. The rate of decrease in the average cell diameter and cell chain length were determined using a first order decay model. Cells starved in the presence of exopolymers showed greater culturability than cells starved without exopolymers. After 200 days starvation, 2.5 × 10⁻³% cells were culturable, but no increase in cell number was observed. During starvation, the exopolymer concentration remained constant, an indication that the exopolymer was not consumed by the starving bacteria as an alternative carbon or energy source. Received: 8 April 1999 / Received revision: 16 July 1999 / Accepted: 6 August 1999