Approaches to Minimize Variation of Transgene Expression in Plants

Genetic transformation of plants has become a widely used technology that serves multiple purposes in plant biology research. However, considerable variation of transgene expression is often observed within populations of transgenic plants transformed with the same transgene construct. This inter-transformant variation of transgene expression hampers proper evaluation of transgenes and might be most undesirable when high-throughput transgene screening is intended. The general plant transformation strategy today is to generate a sufficiently high number of transgenic plants to find some transformants with the desired level of expression. To reduce cost, labor and interpretational flaws, multiple efforts are being directed toward achieving stable expression of transgenes with an expected level of expression. Various factors are thought to contribute to transgene expression variation including the transgene copy number, RNA silencing, transgene insertion site and the employment of certain regulatory sequences to drive transgene expression. This review provides an update on current methodologies to minimize inter-individual variation of transgene expression in nuclear transformed plants.     

The influence of matrix attachment regions on transgene expression in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis thaliana</Emphasis> wild type and gene silencing mutants

Many studies in both animal and plant systems have shown that matrix attachment regions (MARs) can increase the expression of flanking transgenes. However, our previous studies revealed no effect of the chicken lysozyme MARs (chiMARs) on transgene expression in the first generation transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana plants transformed with a β-glucuronidase gene (uidA) unless gene silencing mutants were used as genetic background for transformation. In the present study, we investigated why chiMARs do not influence transgene expression in transgenic wild-type Arabidopsis plants. We first studied the effect of chiMARs on transgene expression in the progeny of primary transformants harboring chiMAR-flanked T-DNAs. Our data indicate that chiMARs do not affect transgene expression in consecutive generations of wild-type A. thaliana plants. Next, we examined whether these observed results in A. thaliana transformants are influenced by the applied transformation method. The results from in vitro transformed A. thaliana plants are in accordance with those from in planta transformed A. thaliana plants and again reveal no influence of chiMARs on transgene expression in A. thaliana wild-type transformants. The effect of chiMARs on transgene expression is also examined in in vitro transformed Nicotiana tabacum plants, but as for A. thaliana, the transgene expression in tobacco transformants is not altered by the presence of chiMARs. Taken together, our results show that the applied method or the plant species used for transformation does not influence whether and how chiMARs have an effect on transgene expression. Finally, we studied the effect of MARs (tabMARs) of plant origin (tobacco) on the transgene expression in A. thaliana wild-type plants and suppressed gene silencing (sgs2) mutants. Our results clearly show that similar to chiMARs, the tobacco-derived MARs do not enhance transgene expression in a wild-type background but can be used to enhance transgene expression in a mutant impaired in gene silencing. Electronic supplementary material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at and is accessible for authorized users. Miguel F.C. De Bolle, Katleen M.J. Butaye Contributed equally to this work     

Transformation of Plants with Multiple Cassettes Generates Simple Transgene Integration Patterns and High Expression Levels

We transformed rice (Oryza sativa L.) simultaneously with five minimal cassettes, each containing a promoter, coding region and polyadenylation site but no vector backbone. We found that multi-transgene cotransformation was achieved with high efficiency using multiple cassettes, with all transgenic plants we generated containing at least two transgenes and 16% containing all five. About 75% of the plants had simple transgene integration patterns with a predominance of single-copy insertions. The expression levels for all transgenes, and the overall coexpression frequencies, were much higher than previously reported in whole plasmid transformants. Four of five lines analyzed for transgene expression stability in subsequent generations showed stable and high expression levels over generations. A simple model is proposed, which accounts for differences in the molecular make-up and the expression profile of transgenic plants generated using whole plasmid or minimal cassettes. We conclude that gene transfer using minimal cassettes is an efficient and rapid method for the production of transgenic plants containing and stably expressing several different transgenes. Our results facilitate effective manipulation of multi-gene pathways in plants in a single transformation step.     

Local and differential control of vegetative storage protein expression in response to herbivore damage in Arabidopsis thaliana

Vegetative storage proteins (VSPs) are thought to fulfil important nutritional roles during plant development and stress adaptation. Plant responses to mechanical wounding and herbivore damage include an activation of VSP expression. It was recently suggested that vsp is part of the systemic response of Arabidopsis to wounding. To test this proposal, we monitored the spatial regulation of vsp mRNAs and VSP proteins. Arabidopsis contains two vsp genes and real-time quantitative PCR allowed us to characterize their differential expression. The ratio of vsp1 to vsp2 mRNA abundance increased when plants were challenged with diamondback moth larvae or Egyptian cotton worms, but not when they were mechanically wounded. We observed a dramatic increase of vsp1 and vsp2 mRNA as well as VSP protein levels in leaves that experienced herbivore damage. By contrast, there was a relatively minor increase of vsp mRNA and VSP protein levels in undamaged leaves of infested plants. These results clearly demonstrate that VSPs are part of the local plant response to herbivore attack. To obtain additional information on vsp regulation, we analysed a fusion of a soybean vspB promoter fragment to the β-glucuronidase gene in transgenic Arabidopsis plants. The vspB promoter responded to both jasmonate and herbivore treatments, suggesting that similar signals regulate its expression in both plant species.     

Efficient Down-Regulation of the Major Vegetative Storage Protein Genes in Transgenic Soybean Does Not Compromise Plant Productivity

Soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) contains two related and abundant proteins, VSP alpha and VSP beta, that have been called vegetative storage proteins (VSP) based on their pattern of accumulation, degradation, tissue localization, and other characteristics. To determine whether these proteins play a critical role in sequestering N and other nutrients during early plant development, a VspA antisense gene construct was used to create transgenic plants in which VSP expression was suppressed in leaves, flowers, and seed pods. Total VSP was reduced at least 50-fold due to a 100-fold reduction in VSP alpha and a 10-fold reduction in VSP beta. Transgenic lines were grown in replicated yield trials in the field in Nebraska during the summer of 1999 and seed harvested from the lines was analyzed for yield, protein, oil, and amino acid composition. No significant difference (alpha = 0.05) was found between down-regulated lines and controls for any of the traits tested. Young leaves of antisense plants grown in the greenhouse contained around 3% less soluble leaf protein than controls at the time of flowering. However, total leaf N did not vary. Withdrawing N from plants during seed fill did not alter final seed protein content of antisense lines compared with controls. These results indicate that the VSPs play little if any direct role in overall plant productivity under typical growth conditions. The lack of VSPs in antisense plants might be partially compensated for by increases in other proteins and/or non-protein N. The results also suggest that the VSPs could be genetically engineered or replaced without deleterious effects.     

转基因植物中T-DNA整合的分子特征及表达

植物中不同转基因方法转化外源基因的T-DNA整合特征既具有共性,又具有特性,使得转基因的遗传在各独立转化体间呈现多样性,另外多种遗传因子和限制因素使受体植物中外源基因的表达存在下降,甚至出现基因沉默等复杂现象。本文主要对农杆菌介导及裸露DNA直接转化转基因植物中T-DNA的分子特征和转基因表达的影响因子进行了介绍和概述。转化体中转基因的遗传稳定性和表达主要取决于转基因在植物基因组中的整合位置、拷贝数及组成结构。因而,通过对具有表达水平各异的转化体进行深入的遗传分析和分子生物学研究以及转化体之间进行的比较研究,将对转基因技术自身的完善、定点整合以及更有效的利用转基因技术都具有十分重要的意义。     

A comparison of transgenic barley lines produced by particle bombardment and Agrobacterium-mediated techniques

Two barley transformation systems, Agrobacterium-mediated and particle bombardment, were compared in terms of transformation efficiency, transgene copy number, expression, inheritance and physical structure of the transgenic loci using fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH). The efficiency of Agrobacterium-mediated transformation was double that obtained with particle bombardment. While 100% of the Agrobacterium-derived lines integrated between one and three copies of the transgene, 60% of the transgenic lines derived by particle bombardment integrated more than eight copies of the transgene. In most of the Agrobacterium-derived lines, the integrated T-DNA was stable and inherited as a simple Mendelian trait. Transgene silencing was frequently observed in the T₁ populations of the bombardment-derived lines. The FISH technique was able to reveal additional details of the transgene integration site. For the efficient production of transgenic barley plants, with stable transgene expression and reduced silencing, the Agrobacterium-mediated method appears to offer significant advantages over particle bombardment.     

Transgene behaviour across two generations in a large random population of transgenic rice plants produced by particle bombardment

The relationship between transgene copy number, rearrangement levels, inheritance patterns, expression levels, transgene stability and plant fertility was analysed in a random population of 95 independently transformed rice plant lines. This analysis has been conducted for both the selectable marker gene ( aphIV) and the unselected reporter gene ( gusA), in the presence or absence of flanking Matrix Attachment Regions (MARs) in order to develop a better understanding of transgene behaviour in a population of transgenic rice plants created by particle bombardment. In the first generation (T(0)), all the independently transformed plant lines contained and expressed the aphIV gene conferring resistance to hygromycin, but only 87% of the lines were co-transformed with the unselected gusA marker gene. Both transgenes seemed to be expressed independently. Most lines exhibited complex transgene rearrangements as well as an intact transgene expression unit for both aphIV and gusA transgenes. Transgene copy number was proportional to the quantity of DNA used during bombardment. In T(0) plants, high gusA copy number significantly decreased GUS expression levels but there was no correlation between expression level and transgene copy number across the entire population of lines. Four main factors impaired transgene expression in primary transgenic plants (T(0)) and their progeny (T(1)): (1) absence of transgene expression in T(0) plants (41% of lines), (2) sterility of T(0) plants (28% of lines), (3) non-transmission of intact transgenes to some or all progenies (at least 14% of lines), and (4) silencing of transgene expression in progeny plants (10% of lines). Transgene stability was significantly related to differences in transgene structure and expression levels. The presence of Rb7 MARs flanking the gusA expression unit had no effect on plant fertility or non-transmission of transgenes, but provided copy number-dependent expression of the transgene and improved expression levels and stability over two generations. Overall, only 7% of the plant lines without MARs and 17% of the lines with MARs initially generated, exhibited stable transgene expression over two generations.     

植物转基因沉默及控制

植物基因工程的目的就是获取外源基因能够按照设计要求正常表达和稳定遗传的转基因植物。近几年来,广泛报道了转基因植物中存在转基因沉默现象。主要阐述了两种转基因沉默的机理即转录水平的基因沉默和转录后水平的基因沉默,各种机理都涉及DNA DNA,DNA RNA,RNA RNA的相互作用。同时,还讨论一些控制转基因沉默现象的策略,特别是MAR在转基因植物中具有增强基因表达和减少株间差异的作用。     

Transformation strategies for stable expression of complex hetero‐multimeric proteins like secretory immunoglobulin A in plants

Plant expression systems have proven to be exceptional in producing high‐value complex polymeric proteins such as secretory IgAs (SIgAs). However, polymeric protein production requires the expression of multiple genes, which can be transformed as single or multiple T‐DNA units to generate stable transgenic plant lines. Here, we evaluated four strategies to stably transform multiple genes and to obtain high expression of all components. Using the in‐seed expression of a simplified secretory IgA (sSIgA) as a reference molecule, we conclude that it is better to spread the genes over two T‐DNAs than to contain them in a single T‐DNA, because of the presence of homologous recombination events and gene silencing. These T‐DNAs can be cotransformed to obtain transgenic plants in one transformation step. However, if time permits, more transformants with high production levels of the polymeric protein can be obtained either by sequential transformation or by in‐parallel transformation followed by crossing of transformants independently selected for excellent expression of the genes in each T‐DNA.     

Variation in GUS activity in vegetatively propagated Hevea brasiliensis transgenic plants

Hevea brasiliensis transgenic plants are regenerated from transgenic callus lines by somatic embryogenesis. Somatic embryogenesis is not yet available for commercial propagation of Hevea clones, which requires conventional grafting of buds on rootstock seedlings (budding). The stability of transgene expression in budded plants is therefore necessary for further development of genetic engineering in rubber trees. Transgene expression was assessed by fluorimetric beta-glucuronidase (GUS) activity in fully developed leaves of in vitro plants from transgenic lines and their sub-lines obtained by budding. A large variation in GUS activity was found in self-rooted in vitro plants of five transgenic lines, and the absence of activity in one line suggested transgene silencing. Beyond confirming transmissibility of the reporter gene by budding and long-term expression, a quantification of GUS activity revealed that greater variability existed in budded plants compared to self-rooted mother in vitro plants for three transgenic lines. Although somatic embryogenesis provided more stable GUS activity, budding remained an efficient way of propagating transgenic plants but transgene expression in budded plants should be verified for functional analysis and further development.     

Irregular patterns of transgene silencing in allohexaploid oat

An irregular pattern of transgene silencing was revealed in expression and inheritance studies conducted over multiple generations following transgene introduction by microprojectile bombardment of allohexaploid cultivated oat (Avena sativa L.). Expression of two transgenes, bar and uidA, delivered on the same plasmid was investigated in 23 transgenic oat lines. Twenty-one transgenic lines, each derived from an independently selected transformed tissue culture, showed expression of both bar and uidA while two lines expressed only bar. The relationship of the transgenic phenotypes to the presence of the transgenes in the study was determined using (1) phenotypic scoring combined with Southern blot analyses of progeny, (2) coexpression of the two transgenic phenotypes since the two transgenes always cosegregated, and (3) reactivation of a transgenic phenotype in self-pollinated progenies of transgenic plants that did not exhibit a transgenic phenotype. Transgene silencing was observed in 19 of the 23 transgenic lines and resulted in distorted segregation of transgenic phenotypes in 10 lines. Silencing and inheritance distortions were irregular and unpredictable. They were often reversible in a subsequent generation of self-pollinated progeny and abnormally segregating progenies were as likely to trace back to parents that exhibited normal segregation in a previous generation as to parents showing segregation distortions. Possible causes of the irregular patterns of transgene silencing are discussed.