Genetic divergence of chars of the genus Salvelinus from Kronotsky Lake (Kamchatka Peninsula)

Chars from the genus Salvelinus, inhabiting lakes and lake-river systems, belong to morphologically and ecologically different forms whose taxonomic status is under dispute. In the present work, we have examined genetic variation and divergence in various chars from the Kronotsky lake basin: the lacustrine chars (white, nose, and long-head) and Dolly Varden char Salvelinus malma. The study was conducted using analysis of allozyme and microsatellite loci, myogens, RAPD, and restriction analysis of two mtDNA segments. The estimates of heterozygoisty at allozyme and microsatellite loci were similar to the corresponding parameters in populations of northern Dolly Varden and Arctic char. Heterozygote deficit was recorded in both samples of individual forms, and in the combined sample of all chars from Kronotsky Lake. For both markers, appreciable genetic differentiation among the samples of different char forms was found, which was comparable to that among the spatially isolated populations of northern Dolly Varden. This result indicates reproductive isolation among the char forms examined. However, this isolation is not complete, because no fixed differences between the forms by any of the genetic systems analyzed was found. The genetic differentiation among different forms of lacustrine chars, which corresponds to the interpopulation rather than interspecies level, is thought to be explained by their comparatively recent divergence.     

Genetic Divergence of Chars of the Genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus</Emphasis> from Kronotsky Lake (Kamchatka Peninsula)

Chars of the genus Salvelinus, inhabiting lakes and lake-river systems, comprise morphological and ecological forms whose taxonomic status is under dispute. In the present work, we have examined genetic variation and divergence in various chars from the Kronotsky lake basin: the lacustrine chars (white, nose, and longhead) and riverine Dolly Varden Salvelinus malma. The study was conducted using analysis of allozyme and microsatellite loci, myogens, RAPD, and restriction analysis of two mtDNA segments. The estimates of heterozygosity at allozyme and microsatellite loci were similar to the corresponding parameters in populations of northern Dolly Varden and Arctic char. Heterozygote deficit was recorded in both samples of separate forms, and in the total sample of all chars from Kronotsky Lake. For allozyme and microsatellite loci, appreciable genetic differentiation among the samples of different char forms was found, which was comparable to that among the spatially isolated populations of northern Dolly Varden. This result indicates reproductive isolation among the char forms examined. However, this isolation is not complete, because no fixed differences between the forms by any of the genetic systems analyzed were found. The genetic differentiation among different forms of lacustrine chars, which corresponds to the interpopulation rather than interspecific level, is thought to be explained by their comparatively recent divergence.__________Translated from Genetika, Vol. 41, No. 8, 2005, pp. 1096–1107.Original Russian Text Copyright © 2005 by Salmenkova, Omel’chenko, Radchenko, Gordeeva, Rubtsova, Romanov.     

On the origin of charrs of the genus Salvelinus of the Kronotskoe Lake and their relationships with other charr populations of the Kamchatka peninsula

To reveal genetic differentiation and origin of sympatric Lake Kronotskoe charr morphs, we sequenced a fragment of control region (558-bp) and Cytochrome B gene (1015-bp) (combined length 1573-bp) in 232 specimens from the lake and, as an outgroup, 57 specimens from the Kronotskaya River below water-falls (anadromous malma) and 77 specimens from other large water bodies from the Kamchatka. A total of 52 nucleotide positions were polymorphic, and these defined 67 haplotypes. Our data does not allow to estimate genetic differentiation among different lake-dwelling morphs, but strongly supports the monophyletic origin of all morphs within the lake. To estimate genetic differentiation and population structure, an extensive study of microsatellite variation has to be conducted.     

Karyotype and relationships of the endemic char Salvelinus krogiusae from Dal'nee Lake (Kamchatka)

Resident (lacustrine) chars, inhabiting many lakes of Kamchatka, Chukotka, and continental coast of the Sea of Okhotsk, are of particular interest for understanding the mechanisms of speciation and evolution of Salvelinus chars. Since one of these, the char from Dal'nee Lake (Paratunka River basin, southeastern Kamchatka), is substantially different from lacustrine-riverine and anadromous chars from the Paratunka River basin in several morphological traits, hemoglobin spectrum, ecology, and reproduction, it is considered an isolated species Salvelinus krogiusae. The karyotype of the resident char from Dal'nee Lake was shown to be variable in most individuals, containing 76 to 80 chromosomes in different cells, with NF = 98. This suggests that the variability of the chromosome number in this char form is explained by Robertsonian translocations. In females and males, cells with respectively 2n = 78 and 2n = 77 prevailed. Heteromorphic sex chromosomes were not found in the karyotype of this char species. Nucleolar-organizing regions (NORs) were mostly detected in the telomeric regions of short arms of large submetacentric chromosomes. These features of the Krogius char karyotype demonstrate that this species is isolated from other Kamchatka chars, being similar to Taranetz char S. taranetzi from Chukotka Peninsula, which is in good agreement with morphological data.     

Karyotype and Relationships of the Endemic Char <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus krogiusae</Emphasis> from Dal'nee Lake (Kamchatka)

Resident (lacustrine) chars, inhabiting many lakes of Kamchatka, Chukotka, and continental coast of the Sea of Okhotsk, are of particular interest for understanding the mechanisms of speciation and evolution of Salvelinus chars. Since one of these, the char from Dal'nee Lake (Paratunka River basin, southeastern Kamchatka), is substantially different from lacustrine-riverine and anadromous chars from the Paratunka River basin in several morphological traits, hemoglobin spectrum, ecology, and reproduction, it is considered an isolated species Salvelinus krogiusae. The karyotype of the resident char from Dal'nee Lake was shown to be variable in most individuals, containing 76 to 80 chromosomes in different cells, with NF = 98. This suggests that the variability of the chromosome number in this char form is explained by Robertsonian translocations. In females and males, cells with respectively 2n = 78 and 2n = 77 prevailed. Heteromorphic sex chromosomes were not found in the karyotype of this char species. Nucleolar-organizing regions (NORs) were mostly detected in the telomeric regions of short arms of large submetacentric chromosomes. These features of the Krogius char karyotype demonstrate that this species is isolated from other Kamchatka chars, being similar to Taranetz char S. taranetzi from Chukotka Peninsula, which is in good agreement with morphological data.     

Specific features of ecology of chars of the genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus</Emphasis> (Salmonidae) from the basin of Lake Kronotskoe (Kamchatka) according to parasitological data

A parasitological study was performed of chars of the genus Salvelinus inhabiting Lake Kronotskoe (Kamchatka Peninsula)—S. malma, S. albus, S. schmidtii, and S. kronocius, as well as of juvenile Salvelinus spp. Twenty-three species of parasites, including six species new for the lake, Hennequya zschokkei, Protteocephalus longicollis, Diphyllobothrium dendriticum, Crepidostomum sp., Echinorhynchus salmonis, and Paracanthobdella livanowi, were found. With consideration of published data, in chars of this water body, 28 species of parasites were recorded, including seven species (N. cf. pungitius, B. luciopercae, Crepidostomum sp., Cr. fausti, Cr. cf. cooperi, Eubothrium crassium, and Proteocephalus sp.), whose presence or species identification in the lake ecosystem need confirmation. Two species (N. rutili and Diphyllobothrium sp.) are removed from the list. Parasites common for all species of chars were revealed. They include Myxobolus arcticus, E. salvelini, D. ditretum, Crepidostotum sp., Cr. farionis, Cr. metoecus, Cystidicola farionis, Cucullanus truttae, Philonema oncorhynchi, and Salmincola carpionis. Cluster analysis of the fauna of parasites of different species of chars demonstrated considerable differences in infestation, which indicates differences between them in preference for food items and occupied biotopes and thereby supports the ecological differentiation of chars in the basin of Lake Kronotskoe. S. albus and S. kronocius are most similar in parasitofauna, which is determined by their predation; S. malma as a benthophage is infected by the same species of parasites, but considerably less intensively. Extremely high indices of population numbers of some parasite species are considered as a manifestation of the Krebs cycle in parasites under the conditions of an isolated lake.     

Genetic structure of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus</Emphasis> genus chars from reservoirs of the Kuril Islands

Genetic resemblance of chars Salvelinus alpinus krasheninnikovi (Salvelinus malma krasheninnikovi) of 35 samples collected in five Kuril Islands--Shumshu, Paramushir, Onekotan, Iturup, and Kunashir--has been studied by the PCR-RAPD method. In the limits of each island, both resident isolates and anadromous forms give strictly supported clusters distinct from samples from the other islands. The samples from five islands form three superclusters: the first from Kunashir and Iturup Islands, the second from Paramushir and Onekotan Islands, and the third from Shumshu Island. The possible reasons for genetic similarity of resident and anadromous forms of Dolly Varden chars inhabiting reservoirs of a definite island are considered (the founder effect, homing, limited migration).     

Genetic divergence of mitochondrial DNA in white char <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus albus</Emphasis> and northern Dolly Varden char <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus malma malma</Emphasis>

Comparative analysis of mitochondrial DNA variation was performed in white char Salvelinus albus Glubokovsky and in its putative ancestor species, northern Dolly Varden char Salvelinus malma malma Walbaum. Highly statistically significant differentiation of S. albus and S. m. malma in the areas of sympatric (Kamchatka River basin) and allopatric (Kronotskoe Lake and Kronotskaya River) residence was demonstrated. The mtDNA divergence between S. albus and S. m. malma did not exceed the range of intraspecific variation in the populations of northern Dolly Varden char. At the same time, clusterization pattern of the Salvelinus chars provides hypothesis on the common origin of two allopatric populations of white char. Genealogical analysis of haplotypes indicates that S. albus and S. m. malma currently demonstrate incomplete divergence of mitochondrial lineages. The low nucleotide divergence estimates between S. albus and S. m. malma reflect the short time period since the beginning of the divergence of ancestral lineages. These estimates are determined by ancestral polymorphism and haplotype exchange between the diverged phylogenetic groups as a result of introgressive hybridization.     

Genetic divergence of populations of the white char <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus Albus</Emphasis>, northern and southern forms of malma <Emphasis Type="Italic">S. malma</Emphasis> (Salmonidae), by microsatellite loci of DNA

A very small but statistically significant genetic differentiation by allele frequencies (in the Kamchatka basin F _ST = 0.016 and in Kronotskoe Lake F _ST = 0.063) is revealed between sympatric populations of the northern malma Salvelinus malma malma and of the white char S. albus by analysis of nine microsatellite loci. Factor analysis and clusterization of individual multilocal genotypes in the sum sample of sympatric S. malma malma and S. albus also demonstrate their extremely weak genetic differentiation. Divergence between geographically isolated (allopatric) populations of each of these chars exceeds by two-three times the interspecies differentiation in the zones of sympatry. Samples from allopatric populations clusterize by the geographic principle but not by the taxonomic principle. Such a situation may be explained by the absence of reproductive isolation and presence of hybridization between sympatric S. malma malma and S. albus with the simultaneous existence of some limitations of genetic exchange related to the ecological specialization of these chars. Analysis of microsatellite loci revealed highly significant genetic differences between the northern and southern forms of malma S. malma krascheninnikovi by many times exceeding genetic differences between S. malma malma and S. albus. The obtained data do not confirm the independent species status of S. albus but support the opinion of the species level of differences between the northern and southern forms of malma.     

Genetic divergence of sympatric charrs of the genus Salvelinus from Nachikinskoe Lake (Kamchatka)

We studied genetic differentiation of two charr species, Dolly Varden Salvelinus malma malma Walbaum and resident lacustrine charr Salvelinus sp., which sympatrically inhabit Nachikinskoe Lake (the Bol'shaya River basin) in southwestern Kamchatka Peninsula. Using restriction analysis (RFLP), three mitochondrial DNA fragments (ND1/ND2, ND5/ND6, and Cytb/D loop) amplified in polymerase chain reaction (PCR) were compared. The divergence of the mtDNA sequences between Salvelinus sp. and S. malma malma was 2.8%; Salvelinus sp. and S. taranetzi, 0.36%; Salvelinus sp. and S. krogiusae, 0.21%; Salvelinus sp. and S. alpinus, 3.0%. These results point to reproductive isolation of charrs in Nachikinskoe Lake and support the earlier suggestion on a close relationship between Salvelinus sp., S. taranetzi, and S. krogiusae.     

Variability of microsatellite DNA and genetic differentiation of populations in the resident form of Dolly Varden Salvelinus malma krascheninnikovi from Sakhalin

Variability in 11 microsatellite loci is followed for nine populations of the resident southern form of Dolly Varden Salvelinus malma krascheninnikovi from Sakhalin. In all studied populations, the level of genetic differentiation is significant with global values of F _st and R _st 0.182 and 0.329, respectively. On the NJ tree, two clusters are separated significantly: the former is represented by the populations from southwestern Sakhalin (the Novoselka River basin), and the latter includes all populations from southern and eastern Sakhalin. Abrupt size variations (bottleneck events) are suggested for several studied populations, and 50% reductions of allelic richness and average heterozygosity are observed in two lacustrine populations of the Novoselka River basin in comparison to the riverine populations of this basin. The results suggest an occurrence of a comparatively recent gene flow between the populations of resident Dolly Varden from Sakhalin and absence of reproductive isolation between the anadromous and resident forms. The degradation of the majority of Dolly Varden populations can be expected in the near future, and conservation projects should be developed.     

Morphological and ecological differentiation of sympatric whitefish species of the genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Coregonus</Emphasis> from Lake Taymyr

Results of the morphological analysis of ecology and feeding of two sympatric forms of whitefishes (lacustrine and lacustrine–riverine) inhabiting Lake Taymyr (the Taymyr Peninsula) are presented in the article. It is revealed that these forms do not differ in the number of gill rakers on the first branchial arch and in the number of perforated scales in the lateral line, but they do differ in plastic characters, spawning periods, and area. At the age of 2–3 years they become separate in regards to feeding type. It is assumed that both forms of whitefishes inhabited Lake Taymyr simultaneously with the filling of the lake basin. Apparently the taxonomic status of the sympatric whitefishes from Lake Taymyr is broader than the term “ecological form.”     

Basic description and some notes on the evolution of seven sympatric morphs of Dolly Varden Salvelinus malma from the Lake Kronotskoe Basin

The study examines the basic morphological and ecological features of Dolly Varden from Lake Kronotskoe (Russia, Kamchatka). Seven valid morphs different in head proportions, feeding, timing, and place of spawning have been determined in this ecosystem. The basic morphometric characteristics clearly separate Lake Kronotskoe morphs from each other, as well as from its potential ancestor (Dolly Varden). According to CVA analysis, the most notable morphological characteristics determining the mouth position are the length of a lower jaw and rostrum. Furthermore, five of seven morphs inhabit different depth zones of the lake and feed on different food resources. Our data suggest that reproductive isolation may be maintained by temporal/spatial isolation for two morphs with lacustrine spawning, and by spatial isolation only for the rest of the morphs with riverine spawning. The sympatric diversity of the Lake Kronotskoe charrs is exceptionally wide, and there are no other examples for seven sympatric morphs of genus Salvelinus to coexist within a single ecosystem. This study puts forward a three‐step hypothetical model of charr divergence in Lake Kronotskoe as a potential ground for future studies.     

Change in nucleotide sequence of mitochondrial DNA from cytochrome b gene in chars of Salvelinus genus

Nucleotide sequences of two (405- and 1050-bp) regions of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) cytochrome c gene were established in chars of the genus Salvelinus from Russian Far East and Siberia. Based on the divergence and phylogenetic analysis of nucleotide sequences of the mtDNA cytochrome c gene, S. laecomaenis was shown to carry the most ancient mitochondrial lineage, which is close to the ancestral one. The archaic mtDNA of S. levanidovi occupied an isolated position on the phylogenetic trees. The mtDNA lineage of the southern S. malma was close to the S. alpinus-S. malma complex group. Within the S. alpinus-S. malma complex, three groups of mtDNA types having particular geographic distributions were distinguished. The Kolyma-Chukotka group includes lake S. taranetzi, S. boganidae and S. elgyticus from Chukotka, lake chars from Kolyma. The Okhotsk group is represented by northern S. malma, lake chars from northern Sea of Okhotsk, and anadromous S. taranetzi. The Siberian group is close to the Okhotsk one and consists of Taimyr and Baikal region chars as well as Arctic char from Finland. The divergence of char mitochondrial lineages was dated to the Pliocene-Pleistocene.     

Karyotype and divergence of stream Dolly Varden from the Southern Sakhalin

The karyotype of stream Dolly Varden inhabiting a tributary of the Belaya River (the basin of Naiba River, southern Sakhalin) was determined (2n = 82 and NF = 98 + 2). According to the main characteristics (chromosome number and arm number, the presence of a pair of marker submeta-subtelocentric chromosomes with nucleolus organizer regions (NORs), one pair of large acrocentric chromosomes, and one pair of subtelocentric chromosomes), this karyotype is identical to the karyotype of anadromous southern Dolly Varden from Salvelinus malma krasheninnikovi of Primorye and Japan. However, in most stream Dolly Varden individuals, additional active nucleolus organizer regions (NORs) located in telomeric and paracentric regions of two to three pairs of acrocentric chromosomes were revealed. It is suggested that the stream and anadromous southern forms of Dolly Varden are evolutionarily related NORs that are silent in the anadromous souther form are active in the stream form. Possible causes of these differences in NOR activity are discussed.     

Karyological Differentiation of Northern Dolly Varden and Sympatric Chars of the Genus <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salvelinus</Emphasis> in Northeastern Russia

In many cases the taxonomic status of sympatric chars (with exception of white-spotted char Salvelinus leucomaenis) is not clear and is actively debated. We karyotyped three pairs of sympatric chars inhabiting the Russian Far East-northern Dolly Varden, S. malma malma, and Lavanidov's char, S. levanidovi, from the Yama River (northern coast of the Sea of Okhotsk, Magadan Region), northern Dolly Varden and Taranetz's char, S. taranetzi, from Lake Achchen (east Chukotka), and northern Dolly Varden and white char, S. albus, from the Kamchatka River (Kamchatka Peninsula). Three of them had similar chromosome numbers. But all chars studied had an individual and discrete set of karyotypic characters, which enabled reliable identification each of them by chromosome number, chromosome arm number, and number and location of active nuclear organizer regions.     

Ecology of Slaty-Backed Gull (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Larus schistisagus</Emphasis>) Breeding on Kronotskoe Lake,Kamchatka Peninsula

The slaty-backed gull population of Kronotskoe Lake has not been subjected to anthropogenic impact for many decades. The number and distribution of the breeding colonies of the slaty-backed gulls on the islands of this largest freshwater reservoir of the Kamchatka Peninsula are presented. Data on the breeding phenology, the seasonal dynamics of the food composition of breeding gulls, the foraging distance, and breeding success are considered. These data are compared to the results obtained earlier for Kuril’skoe Lake. Both gull populations are unique in that they are the only freshwater colonies within the distribution range of this marine species. The breeding success of the slaty-backed gulls on Kronotskoe Lake suffers from predation, both intra- and interspecific, in the latter case from brown bears and sea eagles. The hatching period and the fledging time of chicks in this population are both shifted to the end of summer, when gulls have the most abundant food available within the lake area, which increases successful survival of the fledglings. Despite considerable differences between the ecosystems of Kronotskoe Lake and Kuril’skoe Lake, there are several common features in the diets of the gull populations living on the lakes: (1) Despite the fact that gulls perform foraging flights to the sea coast, they only take fish and almost never collect marine invertebrates there. (2) Nearly half of all food items are taken within a 40-km distance from the colony. (3) During the growth period of chicks, gulls from both lakes rely on salmonids (anadromous in Kuril’skoe Lake, resident in Kronotskoe Lake) that they hunt in the lakes near their colonies.     

Changes in the pattern of feeding of kokanee <Emphasis Type="Italic">Oncorhynchus nerka</Emphasis> from Lake Tolmachevskoe during the formation of its population

Analysis of the feeding of kokanee Oncorhynchus nerka from Lake Tolmachevskoe, which was relocated here from Lake Kronotskoe more than 20 years ago, was studied. Lake Kronotskoe is inhabited by two forms of kokanee that differ in the pattern of feeding (plankton-eaters and benthos-eaters) and some morphological characters. According to the number of rakers at the first gill arch, kokanee from Tolmachevskoe Lake corresponds to plankton-eaters from Kronotskoe Lake; however, in the target water body, only single fish and only in the autumn period feed on plankton. The bulk of feeding is comprised of larger organisms: in summer of insect imagines and in autumn of benthos. Feeding of large and small fish in different areas of the lake from July to September is characterized. The change in the lake ecosystem related to the construction of Tolmachevskaya Hydraulic Power Plant and the formation of the reservoir apparently affected the pattern of fish feeding from 2003 to 2007, the number of prey in stomachs and the stomach fullness index considerably decreased, and the proportion in the food bolus of nonfood items, mainly plant remains, drastically increased.     

On brook chars of the southern Kuril Islands and a possible mechanism of formation of dwarf forms of Dolly Varden trout Salvelinus malma curilus

The specific morphological and biological features of dwarf chars Salvelinus malma curilus from three isolated populations of the southern Kuril Islands Kunashir and Iturup were studied. It was shown that brook dwarfs, in comparison with the migratory form of Salvelinus malma curilus, are characterized by a smaller diameter of spawned eggs (which corresponds to smaller yolk reserves and shorter embryos at hatching), retarded growth and morphogenesis of early juveniles, a mosaic pattern of paedomorphic and peramorphic morphological transformations, and a short lifespan. The population and age variability of the relative sizes and shape of otoliths was revealed. Dwarf populations are typically characterized by considerable morphological differences between males and females corresponding to those in migratory fish. The strategy of dwarfism is assumed to be built into the genome of the migratory ecotype of S. malma curilus.     

Phenetic relationships and probable ways of morphological diversification of the African large barbs (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Barbus intermedius</Emphasis> complex) in Lake Tana (Ethiopia)

29 quantitative and 18 qualitative skull characters were studied in the African large barbs (Barbus intermedius complex) from Lake Tana (Ethiopia). Based on results of principle components analysis phenetic relationships of 12 morphotypes were assessed. External features diagnostic of the morphotypes were found in individuals substantially different in the skull characters. The obtained data along with the data on morphological diversity of large barbs from Ethiopia beyond the Lake Tana basin suggest origination of the Lake Tana complex of forms from a complex of forms that existed in the upper reaches of the Blue Nile before the lake came into being, and the extant morphotypes of the Lake Tana barbs originated from three or four forms that composed the ancestral riverine local complex.