Tris-borate is a poor counterion for RNA: a cautionary tale for RNA folding studies

Native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis is a powerful approach for visualizing RNA folding states and folding intermediates. Tris-borate has a high-buffering capacity and is therefore widely used in electrophoresis-based investigations of RNA structure and folding. However, the effectiveness of Tris-borate as a counterion for RNA has not been systematically investigated. In a recirculated Hepes/KCl buffer, the catalytic core of the bI5 group I intron RNA undergoes a conformational collapse characterized by a bulk transition midpoint, or Mg_1/2, of ~3 mM, consistent with extensive independent biochemical experiments. In contrast, in Tris-borate, RNA collapse has a much smaller apparent Mg_1/2, equal to 0.1 mM, because in this buffer the RNA undergoes a different, large amplitude, folding transition at low Mg²⁺ concentrations. Analysis of structural neighbors using a short-lived, RNA-tethered, photocrosslinker indicates that the global RNA structure eventually converges in the two buffer systems, as the divalent ion concentration approaches ~1 mM Mg²⁺. The weak capacity of Tris-borate to stabilize RNA folding may reflect relatively unfavorable interactions between the bulky Tris-borate ion and RNA or partial coordination of RNA functional groups by borate. Under some conditions, Tris-borate is a poor counterion for RNA and its use merits careful evaluation in RNA folding studies.     

Structural Rearrangements Linked to Global Folding Pathways of the Azoarcus Group I Ribozyme

Stable RNAs must fold into specific three-dimensional structures to be biologically active, yet many RNAs form metastable structures that compete with the native state. Our previous time-resolved footprinting experiments showed that Azoarcus group I ribozyme forms its tertiary structure rapidly (τ < 30 ms) without becoming significantly trapped in kinetic intermediates. Here, we use stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy to probe the global folding kinetics of a ribozyme containing 2-aminopurine in the loop of P9. The modified ribozyme was catalytically active and exhibited two equilibrium folding transitions centered at 0.3 and 1.6 mM Mg²⁺, consistent with previous results. Stopped-flow fluorescence revealed four kinetic folding transitions with observed rate constants of 100, 34, 1, and 0.1 s^− 1 at 37 °C. From comparison with time-resolved Fe(II)-ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid footprinting of the modified ribozyme under the same conditions, these folding transitions were assigned to formation of the I_C intermediate, tertiary folding and docking of the nicked P9 tetraloop, reorganization of the P3 pseudoknot, and refolding of nonnative conformers, respectively. The footprinting results show that 50-60% of the modified ribozyme folds in less than 30 ms, while the rest of the RNA population undergoes slow structural rearrangements that control the global folding rate. The results show how small perturbations to the structure of the RNA, such as a nick in P9, populate kinetic folding intermediates that are not observed in the natural ribozyme.     

Importance in catalysis of a magnesium ion with very low affinity for a hammerhead ribozyme

Available evidence suggests that Mg²⁺ ions are involved in reactions catalyzed by hammerhead ribozymes. However, the activity in the presence of exclusively monovalent ions led us to question whether divalent metal ions really function as catalysts when they are present. We investigated ribozyme activity in the presence of high levels of Mg²⁺ ions and the effects of Li⁺ ions in promoting ribozyme activity. We found that catalytic activity increased linearly with increasing concentrations of Mg²⁺ ions and did not reach a plateau value even at 1 M Mg²⁺ ions. Furthermore, this dependence on Mg²⁺ ions was observed in the presence of a high concentration of Li⁺ ions. These results indicate that the Mg²⁺ ion is a very effective cofactor but that the affinity of the ribozyme for a specific Mg²⁺ ion is very low. Moreover, cleavage by the ribozyme in the presence of both Li⁺ and Mg²⁺ ions was more effective than expected, suggesting the existence of a new reaction pathway—a cooperative pathway—in the presence of these multiple ions, and the possibility that a Mg²⁺ ion with weak affinity for the ribozyme is likely to function in structural support and/or act as a catalyst.     

Imino proton NMR analysis of HDV ribozymes: nested double pseudoknot structure and Mg2+ ion-binding site close to the catalytic core in solution

Minimized trans-acting HDV ribozyme systems consisting of three (Rz-3) and two (Rz-2) RNA strands were prepared and their folding conformations were analyzed by NMR spectroscopy. The guanosine residues in one of the enzyme components of Rz-3 were labeled with ¹³C and ¹⁵N. Imino proton signals were assigned by analysis of NOESY and HSQC spectra. The results are consistent with the nested double pseudoknot model, which contains novel base pairs (P1.1), as observed in the crystal structure of a genomic HDV ribozyme. The NOE connectivities suggest an additional G:G pair at the bottom of P1.1 and at the top of P4. The effects of temperature and Mg²⁺ ions on base pairs for Rz-3 were examined. The temperature variation experiment on Rz-3 showed that P3 is the most stable and that P1.1 is as stable as P1 and P2. The imino proton signals of the G:U pair at the bottom of P1 and the top of P1.1, which are close to the cleavage site, showed the largest changes upon Mg²⁺ titration of Rz-3. The results suggest that the catalytic Mg²⁺ ion binds to the pocket formed by P1 and L3.     

NMR studies of the structure and Mg2+ binding properties of a conserved RNA motif of EMCV picornavirus IRES element

The structure and Mg²⁺ binding properties of a conserved 75mer RNA motif of the internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element of encephalomyocarditis virus picornavirus have been investigated by ¹H-NMR and UV melting experiments. The assignment of the imino proton resonances with characteristic chemical shift dispersion for canonical and non-canonical base pairs confirmed the predicted secondary structure of the 75mer and its fragments. Addition of Mg²⁺ resulted in a dramatic increase in apparent melting temperature, with the 75mer RNA registering the biggest increase, from 63 to 80°C, thus providing evidence for enhanced stability arising from Mg²⁺ binding. Similarly, addition of Mg²⁺ induced selective changes to the chemical shifts of the imino protons of a GCGA tetraloop in the 75mer, that is essential for IRES activity, thereby highlighting a possible structural role for Mg²⁺ in the folding of the 75mer. Significantly, the same protons show retarded exchange to water solvent, even at elevated temperature, which suggest that Mg²⁺ induces a conformational rearrangement of the 75mer. Thus, we propose that Mg²⁺ serves two important roles: (i) enhancing thermodynamic stability of the 75mer RNA (and its submotifs) via non-specific interactions with the phosphate backbone and (ii) promoting the folding of the 75mer RNA by binding to the GCGA tetraloop.     

The RNA-binding domain of ribosomal protein L11 recognizes an rRNA tertiary structure stabilized by both thiostrepton and magnesium ion

Antibiotics that inhibit ribosomal function may do so by one of several mechanisms, including the induction of incorrect RNA folding or prevention of protein and/or RNA conformational transitions. Thiostrepton, which binds to the ‘GTPase center’ of the large subunit, has been postulated to prevent conformational changes in either the L11 protein or rRNA to which it binds. Scintillation proximity assays designed to look at the binding of the L11 C-terminal RNA-binding domain to a 23S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) fragment, as well as the ability of thiostrepton to induce that binding, were used to demonstrate the role of Mg²⁺, L11 and thiostrepton in the formation and maintenance of the rRNA fragment tertiary structure. Experiments using these assays with both an Escherichia coli rRNA fragment and a thermostable variant of that RNA show that Mg²⁺, L11 and thiostrepton all induce the RNA to fold to an essentially identical tertiary structure.     

Quantitative studies of Mn(2+)-promoted specific and non-specific cleavages of a large RNA: Mn(2+)-GAAA ribozymes and the evolution of small ribozymes

Manganese (Mn²⁺) promotes specific cleavage at two major (I and III) and four minor (II, IV, V and VI) sites, in addition to slow non-specific cleavage, in a 659-nucleotide RNA containing the Cr.LSU group I intron. The specific cleavages occurred between G and AAA sequences and thus can be considered Mn²⁺-GAAA ribozymes. We have estimated rates of specific and non-specific cleavages under different conditions. Comparisons of the rates of major-specific and background cleavages gave a maximal specificity of approximately 900 for GAAA cleavage. Both specific and non-specific cleavages showed hyperbolic kinetics and there was no evidence of cooperativity with Mn²⁺ concentration. Interestingly, at site III, Mg²⁺ alone promoted weak, but the same specific cleavage as Mn²⁺. When added with Mn²⁺, Mg²⁺ had a synergistic effect on cleavage at site III, but inhibited cleavage at the other sites. Mn²⁺ cleavage at site III also exhibited lower values of K (Mn²⁺ requirement), pH-dependency and activation energy than did cleavage at the other sites. In contrast, the pH-dependency and activation energy for cleavage at site I was similar to non-specific cleavage. These results increase our understanding of the Mn²⁺-GAAA ribozyme. The implications for evolution of small ribozymes are also discussed.     

Catalytic cleavage of cis- and trans-acting antigenomic delta ribozymes in the presence of various divalent metal ions

Catalytic activity of four structural variants of the antigenomic delta ribozyme, two cis- and two trans-acting, has been compared in the presence of selected divalent metal ions that effectively support catalysis. The ribozymes differ in regions that are not directly involved in formation of the ribozyme active site: the region immediately preceding the catalytic cleavage site, the P4 stem and a stretch of the viral RNA sequence extending the minimal ribozyme sequence at its 3′-terminus. The variants show high cleavage activity in the presence of Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺ and Mn²⁺, lower with Co²⁺ and Sr²⁺ and some variants are also active with Cd²⁺ and Zn²⁺ ions. In the presence of a particular metal ion the ribozymes cleave, however with different initial rates, according to pseudo-first or higher order kinetics and to different final cleavage extents. On the other hand, relatively small differences are observed in the reactions induced by various metal ions. The cleavage of trans-acting ribozymes induced by Mg²⁺ is partially inhibited in the presence of Na⁺, spermidine and some other divalent metal ions. The inert Co(NH₃)₆³⁺ complex is unable to support catalysis, as reported earlier for the genomic ribozyme. The results are discussed in terms of the influence of structural elements peripheral to the ribozyme active site on its cleavage rate and efficiency as well as the role of metal ions in the cleavage mechanism. Some implications concerning further studies and possible applications of delta ribozymes are also considered.     

Modelling ion binding to AA platform motifs in RNA: a continuum solvent study including conformational adaptation

Binding of monovalent and divalent cations to two adenine–adenine platform structures from the Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme has been studied using continuum solvent models based on the generalised Born and the finite-difference Poisson–Boltzmann approaches. The adenine–adenine platform RNA motif forms an experimentally characterised monovalent ion binding site important for ribozyme folding and function. Qualitative agreement between calculated and experimental ion placements and binding selectivity was obtained. The inclusion of solvation effects turned out to be important to obtain low energy structures and ion binding placements in agreement with the experiment. The calculations indicate that differences in solvation of the isolated ions contribute to the calculated ion binding preference. However, Coulomb attraction and van der Waals interactions due to ion size differences and RNA conformational adaptation also influence the calculated ion binding affinity. The calculated alkali ion binding selectivity for both platforms followed the order K⁺ > Na⁺ > Rb⁺ > Cs⁺ > Li⁺ (Eisenman series VI) in the case of allowing RNA conformational relaxation during docking. With rigid RNA an Eisenman series V was obtained (K⁺ > Rb⁺ > Na⁺ > Cs⁺ > Li⁺). Systematic energy minimisation docking simulations starting from several hundred initial placements of potassium ions on the surface of platform containing RNA fragments identified a coordination geometry in agreement with the experiment as the lowest energy binding site. The approach could be helpful to identify putative ion binding sites in nucleic acid structures determined at low resolution or with experimental methods that do not allow identification of ion binding sites.     

Folding of the group I intron ribozyme from the 26S rRNA gene of Candida albicans

Preincubation of the group I intron Ca.LSU from Candida albicans at 37°C in the absence of divalent cations results in partial folding of this intron. This is indicated by increased resistance to T1 ribonuclease cleavage of many G residues in most local helices, including P4-P6, as well as the non-local helix P7, where the G binding site is located. These changes correlate with increased gel mobility and activation of catalysis by precursor RNA containing this intron after preincubation. The presence of divalent cations or spermidine during preincubation results in formation of the predicted helices, as indicated by protection of additional G residues. However, addition of these cations during preincubation of the precursor RNA alters its gel mobility and eliminates the preincubation activation of precursor RNA seen in the absence of cations. These results suggest that, in the presence of divalent cations or spermidine, Ca.LSU folds into a more ordered, stable but misfolded conformation that is less able to convert into the catalytically active form than the ribozyme preincubated without cations. These results indicate that, like the group I intron of Tetrahymena, multiple folding pathways exist for Ca.LSU. However, it appears that the role cations play in the multiple folding pathways leading to the catalytically active form may differ between folding of these two group I introns.     

Outersphere and innersphere coordinated metal ions in an aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase ribozyme

Metal ions are essential cofactors for various ribozymes. Here we dissect the roles of metal ions in an aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase-like ribozyme (ARS ribozyme), which was evolved in vitro. This ribozyme can charge phenylalanine on tRNA in cis, where it is covalently attached to the 5′-end of tRNA (i.e. a form of precursor tRNA), as well as in trans, where it can act as a catalyst. The presence of magnesium ion is essential for this ribozyme to exhibit full catalytic activity. Metal-dependent kinetics, as well as structural mappings using Tb³⁺ in competition with Mg²⁺ or Co(NH₃)₆³⁺, identified two potential metal-binding sites which are embedded near the tRNA-binding site. The high affinity metal-binding site can be filled with either Mg²⁺ or Co(NH₃)₆³⁺ and thus the activity relies on a metal ion that is fully coordinated with water or ammonium ions. This site also overlaps with the amino acid-binding site, suggesting that the metal ion plays a role in constituting the catalytic core. The weak metal-binding site is occupied only by a metal ion(s) that can form innersphere contacts with ligands in the ribozyme and, hence, Mg²⁺ can enhance ribozyme activity, but Co(NH₃)₆³⁺ cannot. The experiments described in this work establish the roles of metal ions that have distinct coordination properties in the ARS ribozyme.     

A further investigation and reappraisal of the thio effect in the cleavage reaction catalyzed by a hammerhead ribozyme

We synthesized three types of 11mer substrate, namely the natural substrate S11O and the thiosubstituted substrates S11SpS and S11RpS, in which the respective pro-Sp and pro-Rp oxygen atoms were replaced by sulfur, and subjected them to detailed kinetic analysis in the cleavage reaction catalyzed by a hammerhead ribozyme. In agreement with previous findings, in the presence of Mg²⁺ or Ca²⁺ ions the rate of ribozyme-catalyzed cleavage of S11SpS was as high as that of S11O, whereas the corresponding rate for S11RpS was nearly four orders of magnitude lower than that for either S11O or S11SpS. However, the rate of the ribozyme-catalyzed reaction with each of the three substrates was enhanced by Cd²⁺ ions. Such results have generally been taken as evidence that supports the direct interaction of the sulfur atom at the Rp position of the cleavage site with the added Cd²⁺ ion. However, our present analysis demonstrates that (i) the added Cd²⁺ ion binds at the P9 site; (ii) the bound Cd²⁺ ion at the P9 site replaces two Mg²⁺ or two Ca²⁺ ions, an observation that suggests a different mode of interaction with the added Cd²⁺ ion; and, most importantly and in contrast to the conclusion reached by other investigators, (iii) the Cd²⁺ ion does not interact with the sulfur atom at the Rp position of the scissile phosphate either in the ground state or in the transition state.     

In vitro selection and characterization of a highly efficient Zn(II)-dependent RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme

A group of highly efficient Zn(II)-dependent RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes has been obtained through in vitro selection. They share a common motif with the ‘8–17’ deoxyribozyme isolated under different conditions, including different design of the random pool and metal ion cofactor. We found that this commonly selected motif can efficiently cleave both RNA and DNA/RNA chimeric substrates. It can cleave any substrate containing rNG (where rN is any ribonucleotide base and G can be either ribo- or deoxyribo-G). The pH profile and reaction products of this deoxyribozyme are similar to those reported for hammerhead ribozyme. This deoxyribozyme has higher activity in the presence of transition metal ions compared to alkaline earth metal ions. At saturating concentrations of Zn²⁺, the cleavage rate is 1.35 min^–1 at pH 6.0; based on pH profile this rate is estimated to be at least ~30 times faster at pH 7.5, where most assays of Mg²⁺-dependent DNA and RNA enzymes are carried out. This work represents a comprehensive characterization of a nucleic acid-based endonuclease that prefers transition metal ions to alkaline earth metal ions. The results demonstrate that nucleic acid enzymes are capable of binding transition metal ions such as Zn²⁺ with high affinity, and the resulting enzymes are more efficient at RNA cleavage than most Mg²⁺-dependent nucleic acid enzymes under similar conditions.     

Requirement for canonical base pairing in the short pseudoknot structure of genomic hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

The tertiary structure of the 3′-cleaved product of the genomic hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme was solved by X-ray crystallographic analysis. In this structure, three single-stranded regions (SSrA, -B and -C) interact intricately with one another via hydrogen bonds between nucleotide bases, phosphate oxygens and 2′-OHs to form a nested double pseudoknot structure. Among these interactions, two Watson–Crick (W–C) base pairs, 726G–710C and 727G–709C, that form between SSrA and SSrC (P1.1) seem to be especially important for compact folding. To characterize the importance of these base pairs, ribozymes were subjected to in vitro selection from a pool of RNA molecules randomly substituted at positions 709, 710, 726 and 727. The results establish the importance of the two W–C base pairs for activity, although some mutants are active with one G–C base pair. In addition, the kinetic parameters were analyzed in all 16 combinations with two canonical base pairs. Comparison of variant ribozymes with the wild-type ribozyme reveals that the difference in reaction rates for these variants (ΔΔG^‡) is not simply accounted for by the differences in the stability of P1.1 (ΔΔG⁰₃₇). The role played by Mg²⁺ ions in formation of the P1.1 structure is also discussed.     

Investigation of Mg2+- and temperature-dependent folding of the hairpin ribozyme by photo-crosslinking: effects of photo-crosslinker tether length and chemistry

We have used photo-crosslinking to investigate the structure and dynamics of four-way junction hairpin ribozyme constructs. Four phenylazide photo-crosslinkers were coupled to 2′-NH₂-modified U+2 in the substrate and irradiated at different Mg²⁺ concentrations and temperatures. Consistent with the role of divalent metal ions in hairpin ribozyme folding, we observed more interdomain crosslinks in the presence of Mg²⁺ than in its absence. In general, we observed intradomain crosslinks to nucleotides 2–11 and interdomain crosslinks to the U1A binding loop. Crosslinks to A26 and G36 in domain B were also observed when crosslinking was carried out at −78°C. In contrast to crosslinking results at higher temperatures (0, 25 and 37°C), similar crosslinks were obtained in the presence and absence of Mg²⁺ at −78°C, suggesting Mg²⁺ stabilizes a low-energy hairpin ribozyme conformation. We also evaluated the effects of photo-crosslinker structure and mechanism on crosslinks. First, most crosslinks were to unpaired nucleotides. Second, shorter and longer photo-crosslinkers formed crosslinks to intradomain locations nearer to and farther from photo-crosslinker modification, respectively. Finally, fluorine substitutions on the phenylazide ring did not change the locations of crosslinks, but rather decreased crosslinking efficiency. These findings have implications for the use of phenylazide photo-crosslinkers in structural studies of RNA.     

Hinge stiffness is a barrier to RNA folding

Cation-mediated RNA folding from extended to compact, biologically active conformations relies on a temporal balance of forces. The Mg^2 +-mediated folding of the Tetrahymena thermophila ribozyme is characterized by rapid nonspecific collapse followed by tertiary-contact-induced compaction. This article focuses on an autonomously folding portion of the Tetrahymena ribozyme, its P4-P6 domain, in order to probe one facet of the rapid collapse: chain flexibility. The time evolution of P4-P6 folding was followed by global and local measures as a function of Mg^2 + concentration. While all concentrations of Mg^2 + studied are sufficient to screen the charge on the helices, the rates of compaction and tertiary contact formation diverge as the concentration of Mg^2 + increases; collapse is greatly accelerated by Mg^2 +, while tertiary contact formation is not. These studies highlight the importance of chain stiffness to RNA folding; at 10 mM Mg^2 +, a stiff hinge limits the rate of P4-P6 folding. At higher magnesium concentrations, the rate-limiting step shifts from hinge bending to tertiary contact formation.     

A recurrent magnesium-binding motif provides a framework for the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center

The ribosome is an ancient macromolecular machine responsible for the synthesis of all proteins in all living organisms. Here we demonstrate that the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center (PTC) is supported by a framework of magnesium microclusters (Mg²⁺-μc's). Common features of Mg²⁺-μc's include two paired Mg²⁺ ions that are chelated by a common bridging phosphate group in the form Mg_(a)²⁺–(O1P-P-O2P)–Mg_(b)²⁺. This bridging phosphate is part of a 10-membered chelation ring in the form Mg_(a)²⁺–(OP-P-O5′-C5′-C4′-C3′-O3′-P-OP)–Mg_(a)²⁺. The two phosphate groups of this 10-membered ring are contributed by adjacent residues along the RNA backbone. Both Mg²⁺ ions are octahedrally coordinated, but are substantially dehydrated by interactions with additional RNA phosphate groups. The Mg²⁺-μc's in the LSU (large subunit) appear to be highly conserved over evolution, since they are unchanged in bacteria (Thermus thermophilus, PDB entry 2J01) and archaea (Haloarcula marismortui, PDB entry 1JJ2). The 2D elements of the 23S rRNA that are linked by Mg²⁺-μc's are conserved between the rRNAs of bacteria, archaea and eukarya and in mitochondrial rRNA, and in a proposed minimal 23S-rRNA. We observe Mg²⁺-μc's in other rRNAs including the bacterial 16S rRNA, and the P4–P6 domain of the tetrahymena Group I intron ribozyme. It appears that Mg²⁺-μc's are a primeval motif, with pivotal roles in RNA folding, function and evolution.     

Requirement of a Relatively High Threshold Level of Mg2+ for Cell Growth of a Rhizoplane Bacterium, Sphingomonas yanoikuyae EC-S001

Mg²⁺ is one of the essential elements for bacterial cell growth. The presence of the magnesium cation (Mg²⁺) in various concentrations often affects cell growth restoration in plant-associating bacteria. This study attempted to determine whether Mg²⁺ levels in Sphingomonas yanoikuyae EC-S001 affected cell growth restoration in the host plant and what the threshold level is. S. yanoikuyae EC-S001, isolated from the rhizoplane of spinach seedlings grown from surface-sterilized seeds under aseptic conditions, displayed uniform dispersion and attachment throughout the rhizoplane and phylloplane of the host seedlings. S. yanoikuyae EC-S001 did not grow in potato-dextrose broth medium but grew well in an aqueous extract of spinach leaves. Chemical investigation of the growth factor in the spinach leaf extract led to identification of the active principle as the magnesium cation. A concentration of ca. 0.10 mM Mg²⁺ or more allowed S. yanoikuyae EC-S001 to grow in potato-dextrose broth medium. Some saprophytic and/or diazotrophic bacteria used in our experiment were found to have diverse threshold levels for their Mg²⁺ requirements. For example, Burkholderia cepacia EC-K014, originally isolated from the rhizoplane of a Melastoma sp., could grow even in Mg²⁺-free Hoagland's no. 2 medium with saccharose and glutamine (HSG medium) and requires a trace level of Mg²⁺ for its growth. In contrast, S. yanoikuyae EC-S001, together with Bacillus subtilis IFO12113, showed the most drastic restoring responses to subsequent addition of 0.98 mM Mg²⁺ to Mg²⁺-free HSG medium. Our studies concluded that Mg²⁺ is more than just the essential trace element needed for cell growth restoration in S. yanoikuyae EC-S001 and that certain nonculturable bacteria may require a higher concentration of Mg²⁺ or another specific essential element for their growth.