Functional analysis of human T cell subsets defined by monoclonal antibodies. III. Regulation of helper factor production by T cell subsets

In the present report we extended our previous studies demonstrating that obligatory T-T interactions are important in regulating human immune responses in vitro. Functionally distinct human T cell subsets were isolated by complement-mediated lysis using the monoclonal antibodies OKT4 and OKT8. Evidence was obtained that during allogeneic interactions, OKT4+, but not OKT8+, responder T cells are required to generate helper factor(s) capable of polyclonally activating human B cells independent of additional T cell help. Importantly, the alloantigen-induced helper factor(s) production and/or release was found to be suppressed by addition of graded numbers of radiosensitive OKT8+ cells. On the other hand, no evidence was obtained that supernatant derived from alloactivated OKT8+ cells could counterbalance the helper activity generated in the presence of supernatant from alloactivated OKT4+ cells. Furthermore, OKT8+ cells, known to suppress PWM-driven B cell differentiation in the presence of OKT4+ cells, do not suppress B cell differentiation induced by preformed helper factor even in the presence of OKT4+ cells. These data further underscore the importance of functional T-T interactions in immunoregulation in vitro and support the idea that the target of suppression of B cell differentiation, induced either by alloantigen-triggered helper factor or PWM, are OKT4+ cells and not B cells themselves.     

A kinetic model of CD4+ lymphocytes with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).

This report describes a kinetic model of in vitro cytopathology involving interactions of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) with CD4+ helper T lymphocytes. The model uses nonlinearly coupled, ordinary differential equations to simulate the dynamics of infected and uninfected cells and free virions. It is assumed that resting cells are more readily infected than activated cells, but once infected, only activated cells produce more virus. Resting cells can be activated by some appropriate stimulus (e.g. phytohemagglutinin, soluble antigen). The model predicts that the initial inoculum of virus is taken up by resting cells and without stimulation the system comes to a steady state of two populations, namely infected and uninfected cells. Stimulation of this system produces two additional populations, namely infected and uninfected activated cells which, along with the previous populations, exhibit cyclic behavior of growth, viral expression/release, and death. Additional stimuli enhance or diminish the cyclic behavior depending upon their occurrence in time. These simulations suggest a similar dynamics in human HIV infection and may explain a major factor responsible for the widely varying depletion rate of (CD4+) helper T cells in AIDS patients.     

Reaginic antibody formation in the mouse. X. Possible role of suppressor T cells in transient IgE antibody responses.

The kinetics of IgE antibody response to alum-absorbed dinitrophenyl derivatives of ovalbumin (DNP-OA) was dependent on the dose of immunogen. A persistent IgE antibody response was obtained when high responder BDF1 mice were immunized with a minimum (0.05 microgram) dose. An increase of the immunogen to 10 microgram depressed IgE antibody responses but enhanced IgG antibody responses of both hapten and carrier specificities. Determination of T helper cell activity and B memory cells after immunization with different doses of antigen indicated that minimum immunogen was favorable for developing helper activity, whereas 1 to 10 microgram immunogen were more favorable than a 0.05-microgram dose for developing both IgE and IgG B memory cells. Nevertheless, neither helper T cells nor B memory cells in the spleen explains a transient IgE antibody response to a high (10 microgram) dose of DNP-OA. Evidence was obtained that immunization with 10 microgram OA induced generation of antigen-specific suppressor T cells, which were not detectable after immunization with 0.05 microgram OA. Transfer of suppressor T cells to DNP-OA-primed mice depressed both anti-hapten and anti-carrier IgE antibody responses. The results suggested strongly that suppressor T cells are involved in a transient IgE antibody response to a high-dose immunogen.     

Maintenance of hyporesponsiveness to antigen by a distinct subclass of T lymphocytes.

Immunization with increasing doses of SRBC, in excess of 10(8), results in a progressive decline in the anti-SRBC PFC response. This hyporesponsive state is antigen specific and is reflected in a decrease of both T helper and B antibody-forming activity. We asked whether the apparent defect of T helper activity reflected a) an absence of alphaSRBC helper T cell activity, or b) the presence of SRBC-specific suppressor T cells within the hyporesponsive population. Our results indicate that at least a portion of hyporesponsiveness noted after antigen exposure to large doses of antigen can be ascribed to specific suppressor T cell activation. Fractionation of the suppressive T cell population using Ly antiserum showed that specific suppressive activity was mediated by a subclass of T cells (Ly2+), distinct from that committed to express helper function (Ly1).     

Idiotypic networks incorporating T-B cell co-operation. The conditions for percolation

Previous work was concerned with symmetric immune networks of idiotypic interactions amongst B cell clones. The behaviour of these networks was contrary to expectations. This was caused by an extensive percolation of idiotypic signals. Idiotypic activation was thus expected to affect almost all (greater than 10(7] B cell clones. We here analyse whether the incorporation of helper T cells (Th) into these B cell models could cause a reduction in the percolation. Empirical work on idiotypic interactions between Th and B cells however, would suggest that two different idiotypic Th models should be developed: (1) a Th which recognises native B cell idiotypes, i.e. a non-MHC-restricted "ThId" model, and (2) a "classical" MHC-restricted helper T cell model. In the ThId model, the Th-B cell interaction is symmetric. A 2-D model of a Th and a B cell clone that interact idiotypically with each other accounts for various equilibria (i.e. one virgin and two immune states). Introduction of antigen does indeed lead to a state switch from the virgin to the immune state; such a system is thus able to "remember" its exposure to antigen. Idiotypic signals do however, percolate in ThId models via these "B-Th-B-Th" pathways: proliferating Th and B cell clones that interact idiotypically, will always activate each other reciprocally. In the MHC-restricted Th model, Th-B interactions are asymmetric. Because the B cell idiotypes are processed and subsequently presented by MHC molecules, the Th receptor and the native B cell receptor are not expected to be complementary. Thus the Th and the B cells are unable to activate each other reciprocally, and a 2-D Th-B cell model cannot account for idiotypic memory. In contrast to the ThId model, idiotypic activation cannot percolate via "B-Th-B-Th" interactions. Due to the assymmetry idiotypic activation stops at the first Th level. A Th clone cannot activate a subsequent B cell clone: if the B cells recognise the Th cells, they see idiotype but get no help; if the Th cells see the B cells, the B cells are helped but see no idiotype. The percolation along "B-B-B" pathways in these two models is next analysed. Two B cells clones, each helped by one Th clone, are connected by a symmetric idiotypic interaction. It turns out that in both models the second (i.e. anti-idiotypic) B cells (B2) never proliferate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

T-T interactions in the induction of antigen-specific human suppressor T lymphocytes in vitro.

We intended to investigate whether the suppression of antigen-induced antibody responses in vitro in man by T suppressor cells required contact of T suppressor cells with target cells or whether this effect was mediated by factors released by T suppressor cells. To this end supernatants of antigen-induced T suppressor cells were tested (by a plaque forming cell assay) for their capacity to suppress antibody responses of autologous and allogeneic human peripheral blood lymphocytes. We have shown that supernatants of antigen-specific T suppressor cells, designated as TsF24: a) can suppress an antibody response of autologous but not allogeneic lymphocytes to the inducing antigen; b) are antigen-specific in their effect; and 3) are produced by radiosensitive T cells. Furthermore, the target of the factor is a radiosensitive T cell. These findings taken together indicate that, in the generation of T-effector suppressor cells in man, T-T interactions occur, and in addition, that cellfree factors may be involved in these interactions.     

Immunologic unresponsiveness after gastric administration of human gamma-globulin: antigen requirements and cellular parameters

Gastric administration of human gamma-globulin (HGG) into adult A/J mice leads to the establishment of an antigen-specific unresponsive state to subsequent parenteral challenge with HGG. An unresponsive state is induced in both helper T and B lymphocyte populations. Unresponsiveness in helper T cells is of longer duration than in B cells, lasting at least 9 wk after intragastric intubation. Adoptive cell transfer of spleen cells from gastrically inoculated mice into healthy irradiated, syngeneic recipients revealed that the unresponsive state is stable upon cell transfer and that suppressor cells are present in the spleens of gastrically tolerized mice. The establishment of HGG-specific unresponsiveness is dependent upon both the dose and the form of the antigen adminstered. Soluble and deaggregated HGG are both more efficient than is heat-aggregated HGG in inducing unresponsiveness gastrically. The administered HGG is rapidly eliminated from the animal and only a small fraction reaches the circulation as immunoreactive protein. Although the cellular parameters of the systemic unresponsiveness induced by intragastric intubation with HGG appear similar to the parameters of parenterally induced unresponsiveness, the precise mechanisms by which gastric unresponsive states are established remain to be resolved.     

Functional properties of a lymphocyte subpopulation responding to low suboptimal doses of concanavalin A

Incubation of human peripheral blood lymphocytes with concanavalin A (Con A), in a low suboptimal dose (0.5 microgram/ml), results in formation of the cells that inhibit proliferation of autologous cells in cultures activated with optimal but not with suboptimal dose of the mitogen. Nevertheless, 50 micrograms/ml Con A-activated cells efficiently suppress proliferation everywhere. Cell preincubation during 18 h before Con A activation leads to a reduction of lymphocyte responses to the mitogen in cultures reactivated with 5 micrograms/ml Con A in a mixture with autologous lymphocytes, containing no mitogen. Activation of T-T helper cells providing suppressor T cells differentiation seems to take place in the presence of a low suboptimal dose of Con A. Besides, 0.5 microgram/ml Con A prevents the preincubation-induced elimination of some lymphocytes responding to an optimal dose of Con A and autologous lymphocytes.     

A cascade of T-T interactions, mediated by the linked recognition of antigen, in the induction of T cells able to help delayed-type hypersensitivity responses

Previous work has shown that specific helper T cells are required for the primary induction of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH). Conditions are defined here under which the primary induction by antigen of precursor helper T cells only occurs in the presence of specific, irradiated effector T cells, demonstrating that the induction of helper T cells requires T-T cooperation. The interaction between precursor and effector helper T cells is mediated by the recognition of epitopes that must be physically linked to one another. In more detail, hapten-Ficoll conjugates and xenogeneic red blood cells induce medium-density but not low-density cultures of unprimed murine spleen cells to express antigen-specific DTH. Low-density cultures do not support the induction of DTH unless they are supplemented with specific irradiated helper T cells. These helper T cells are themselves induced when antigen is added to medium-density but not low-density cultures. Precursor helper T cells in low-density cultures are only induced by antigen in the presence of additional specific irradiated T cells. Further experiments were directed at analyzing the nature of this T-T interaction. Irradiated hapten-primed T cells help the induction of precursor helper T cells specific for burro red blood cells (BRBC) in the presence of haptenated BRBC and chicken red blood cells (CRBC), but do not help in the presence of haptenated CRBC and BRBC. These experiments demonstrate that the interaction between precursor and effector T cells is mediated by the linked recognition of antigen. These findings show that the induction of precursor cells for both DTH reactivity, and those T cells able to help in the induction of DTH, require specific helper T cells. It is further shown that the induction of T cells able to help in the induction of helper precursor cells takes place in medium-density but not low-density cultures. In order words, antigen, when added to medium-density cultures of normal spleen cells, induces T cells able to mediate DTH, and T cells able to help in the induction of these helper T cells, whereas antigen induces none of these T cells when added to low-density cultures unless appropriate specific helper T cells are added.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Generation of low-dose paralysis in the absence of the ability to secrete antibody.

(CBA/N female x BALB/c male)F1 male mice carry an X-linked defect, originating from CBA/N mice, which renders them unable to generate an antibody response to SSS-III. Histocompatible (BALB/c female x CBA/N male) reciprocal F1 male hybrids do not carry the X-linked defect and therefore generate a readily detectable PFC response to SSS-III, which can be adoptively transferred into nonresponding reciprocal F1 male mice. In the present work, we show that this adoptive response could be inhibited in recipient (CBA/N female x BALB/c male)F1 male nonresponding mice in which low dose paralysis had been induced. Evidence is presented which indicates that such suppression is of host rather than donor cell origin. The capacity to develop low-dose paralysis, a phenomenon that is antigen specific and has been attributed to the action of suppressor T cells, indicates that nonresponding (CBA/N female x BALB/c male) F1 males (and presumably the CBA/N progenitor strain) have the ability to recognize this antigen. Furthermore, since these animals fail to make a serum antibody response to SSS-III, the signal that activates suppressor T cells cannot be circulating antibody or antigen-antibody complexes. These findings are most consistent with the view that low-dose paralysis of the response to SSS-III is not dependent on antibody-mediated feedback inhibition; rather, it is an active process mediated by suppressor T cells.     

Analysis of two distinct B cell activation pathways mediated by a monoclonal T helper cell. II. T helper cell secretion of interleukin 4 selectively inhibits antigen-specific B cell activation by cognate, but not noncognate, interactions with T cells

A single monoclonal T helper (Th) clone can activate B cells in two distinct pathways; a cognate pathway requiring a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T-B cell interaction, and a noncognate pathway not requiring an MHC-restricted T-B cell interaction. The present study was undertaken to investigate whether Th cells mediating a given immune response provide further regulatory function to B cells other than helper function. It was demonstrated that conditions of high antigen concentration which activate a noncognate B cell activation pathway simultaneously inhibit IgG responses. The inhibition is shown to be mediated by the T cell factor interleukin 4, produced by activated cloned Th cells. The inhibitory effect of this factor is directed to B cells and is MHC-unrestricted, antigen-nonspecific, and IgG class-specific. In addition to being susceptible to the effects of augmenting cells and suppressor cells, cloned Th cell populations can therefore themselves function as regulatory cells to inhibit IgG responses when stimulated with high dose of specific antigen. These results indicate that Th cells function to regulate B cells both positively and negatively, depending upon the activation conditions.     

Immature T lymphocytes in human neonatal blood

Thirty-two cord blood samples taken after caesarean section or vaginal delivery and concurrent venous blood samples obtained from normal adult controls were evaluated using monoclonal antibodies. The percentage of circulating pan-T-cell+ lymphocytes was significantly lower in cord blood (46%) compared with adult controls (72%). In the cord cells, 22% showed reactivity with the common thymocyte antigen compared with less than 1% in adult controls. The helper:suppressor ratio was lower in cord blood (1.71) compared with 1.98 for adult blood. These figures reflect a unique population (12%) of immature T cells in cord blood that coexpress helper and suppressor phenotypes. These features are not found in adult blood. These double-labeling studies characterized a previously undescribed blood T-cell phenotype which correlates negatively with gestational age (R = -0.93). These studies reveal the presence of an immature population of T cells in normal human neonatal blood that exhibit the phenotype characteristic of normal developing thymocytes.     

A partial characterization of suppressor cells in the spleens of mice conditioned with fractionated total lymphoid irradiation (TLI)

Total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) is a highly effective modality for inducing immunosuppression and transplantation tolerance. The cellular basis for this immunosuppression is not clear, although T cells have been implicated. To study further the effect of TLI on the immune system, we have examined the B cells and suppressor cells in the spleens from TLI-conditioned mice. Our results indicate that after TLI, the spleen is rapidly repopulated with many large, immature cells. The probable source of these cells is the shielded bone marrow (BM). The B cells from TLI-conditioned mice are transiently immature and hyporesponsive in vitro to a T-independent antigen. Spleen cells from TLI-conditioned mice nonspecifically suppress the in vitro T-independent anti-TNP response of normal B cells. The suppressor cells lack both B and T cell markers and adhere to Sephadex G-10. The suppressor cells in spleens from TLI-treated mice bear a number of similarities to those present in normal BM. When normal BM cells were analyzed by indirect immunofluorescence for the presence of the Mac-1 antigen, two populations of suppressor cells could be identified: one was Mac-1+ and the other was Mac-1-. These data are consistent with the possibility that a subpopulation of the suppressor cells found in normal BM and in the spleens from TLI-conditioned mice are immature cells of the monocytic/granulocytic lineage.     

Differential responsiveness of immature- and mature-stage murine B cells to anti-IgM reflects both FcR-dependent and -independent mechanisms.

Mature and immature B cells differ in their responses to antigen receptor crosslinking. Whereas mature B cells enter cell cycle in response to such stimulation, immature B cells exhibit proliferative unresponsiveness and undergo induced tolerance following surface immunoglobulin (sIg) engagement. Previous studies evaluating antigen receptor-mediated negative signaling have utilized intact goat anti-immunoglobulin (anti-Ig) antibodies as polyclonal ligands based upon observations that the Fc portion of these reagents does not interact with and mediate negative signaling through the FcR on mature B cells. Thus, the negative effects of goat anti-Ig on immature B cells have been attributed solely to signals mediated via their antigen receptors. In the studies reported here we show that the activation unresponsiveness inherent to immature B cells is FcR independent. However, we also show that immature B cells are sensitive to FcR-mediated inhibition and that these effects can be mediated by intact goat antibodies at concentrations that promote positive activation signals in mature B cells. Our results demonstrate that inhibition of immature B cell LPS responses by anti-Ig antibodies, used in previous studies as an in vitro model for B cell tolerance induction, is an FcR-mediated phenomenon. We show that developmentally associated anti-Ig-mediated inhibition of LPS requires the use of intact antibodies, and that this inhibition can be blocked by the anti-FcR monoclonal antibody 2.4G2. Flow cytometric analysis of FcR-positive B cells indicates that both mature and immature B cells express equivalent levels of FcR gamma. Therefore, the sensitivity of immature, but not mature, cells to intact goat anti-mu antibodies suggests that either FcRs or their associated inhibitory pathways change during B cell development.     

T cell tolerization in vitro: modulation of helper and suppressor cell activities

This paper analyzes the conditions for in vitro tolerization of purified whole T cell populations and the consequences on helper and suppressor T cell functions. Highly purified splenic T cells from adult DBA/2 mice were incubated in vitro for 24 hr with high doses of trinitrophenyl coupled to human gamma-globulins (TNP-HGG). A profound inhibition of the TNP-specific helper function of these T lymphocytes was observed in a cooperative culture with normal purified splenic B cells and TNP-SRBC as antigen. This state of specific unresponsiveness was maintained after trypsin treatment of the cells, at the end of the 24-hr incubation with the tolerogen. We checked that this procedure removed the vast majority of F23.1 T cell receptor determinants from the cells. This result indicates that T cell receptors for antigen were not merely blocked by the tolerogen. In addition, B cells preincubated with tolerized T cells for 24 hr remained as responsive to TNP as B cells mixed with normal T cells in similar conditions. This demonstrates that the decreased response is not the result of secondary B cell tolerization. In addition, anti-Ia monoclonal antibodies were shown to block the induction of tolerance. We also showed that tolerized T cells significantly decreased the anti-TNP response of normal T and B cells in vitro, whereas the anti-SRBC response in the same cultures was unaffected. When tolerized T cells were separated into Lyt-2- and Lyt-2+ cells, it was found that tolerized Lyt-2- cells had lost about 75% of their helper activity and that Lyt-2+ cells suppressed 70% of the response of a normal T and B cell culture. Thus, in vitro induction of T cell tolerance results in a specific T cell unresponsiveness which is due to both helper T cell inactivation and induction of specific suppressor T cells.     

Feedback mechanisms between T helper cells and macrophages in the determination of the immune response

The interactions between macrophages and T helper (Th) cells are a complex interplay of positive and negative signals. Some of the mathematical models of interactions between T helpers have indeed taken the influence of macrophages into account. In this work the macrophage is not considered as an extrinsic agent, that is duly directed by the T cells to be cytotoxic, nor is there consideration of T helper cell populations that are dominantly regulated by extrinsic properties of antigens per se, or by certain classes of presenting cells that preferentially select certain classes of lymphocytes or bias their commitment. Rather, a simplified model of feedback loops between Th cells and macrophages is formulated and analyzed. It is suggested how the mutual influence between Th and macrophages can determine the cytokine secretion pattern of these populations. The model provides a feedback scenario to account for experimental findings concerning reversal in the dominance of a specific cytokine profile in the course of some infections. A possible scenario accounting for the difference between the stability of Th1 and Th2 cytokine pattern is put forward. The model suggests explanations for the variability in the outcome of the immune response according to different body compartments. A rationale is presented that accounts for paradoxical findings indicating that Th1 cytokines are sometimes responsible for the downregulation of a Th1 dominated response.     

Differences in the regulation of humoral responses between mice infected with Trypanosoma cruzi and mice administered T. cruzi-induced suppressor substance

In the present study, the effects of Trypanosoma cruzi and the T. cruzi-induced serum suppressor substance (SSS) on antibody responses were compared. Although infection with T. cruzi led to an alteration in T cell helper activity and a reduced specific B cell precursor frequency, SSS did not have a similar effect on either of these cell populations. The characteristics of the altered T cell helper activity was further investigated, and it was found that helper activity appeared earlier in infected mice than in normal or SSS-suppressed mice, and less antigen was required for optimal elicitation of T helper cells in infected mice. The potency of T cell helper activity also was shown to differ, and in the order T. cruzi-infected 6E normal 6E SSS-suppressed mice. It was found that spleen cells from T. cruzi-infected mice elaborated more potent specific helper factors than spleen cells from normal or SSS-suppressed mice, but did not produce a detectable nonspecific helper factor in vitro. Finally, the addition of B cells from low-dose primed, T. cruzi-infected mice to cultures of normal spleen cells resulted in subnormal responses to the priming antigen (sheep erythrocytes) but not to another unrelated antigen (trinitrophenyl-haptenated Brucella abortus), whereas similarly sensitized B cells from normal or SSS-suppressed mice caused no such effect.     

T cell regulation of B cell activation. An antigen-mediated tripartite interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and B cells is required for suppression

To determine the requirements underlying the antigen specificity observed in T cell-mediated immune response suppression, cloned major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T suppressor (Ts) cells specific for keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and cloned MHC-restricted T helper (Th) cells specific for fowl gamma-globulin (FGG) were employed to study the regulation of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific B cell responses. Neither antigen bridging between Ts cells and Th cells (FGG=KLH) nor bridging between Ts cells and B cells (TNP-KLH) was sufficient to allow suppression; a mixture of FGG=KLH and TNP-KLH was also insufficient for suppression. In contrast, suppression was induced by KLH-specific Ts cells only when suppressor determinants (KLH), helper determinants (FGG), and B cell determinants (TNP) were covalently linked on the same molecule (TMP-FGG)=(TNP-KLH) or TNP-(FGG=KLH)). These findings imply that a tripartite antigen-mediated interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and responding B cells is necessary for the mediation of this antigen-specific suppression.     

The actin cytoskeleton coordinates the signal transduction and antigen processing functions of the B cell antigen receptor

The B cell antigen receptor （BCR） is the sensor on the B cell surface that surveys foreign molecules （antigen） in our bodies and activates B cells to generate antibody responses upon encountering cognate antigen. The binding of antigen to the BCR induces signaling cascades in the cytoplasm, which provides the first signal for B cell activation. Subsequently, BCRs internalize and target bound antigen to endosomes, where antigen is processed into T cell recognizable forms. T helper cells generate the second activation signal upon binding to antigen presented by B cells. The optimal activation of B cells requires both signals, thereby depending on the coordination of BCR signaling and antigen transport functions. Antigen binding to the BCR also induces rapid remodeling of the cortical actin network of B cells. While being initiated and controlled by BCR signaling, recent studies reveal that this actin remodeling is critical for both the signaling and antigen processing functions of the BCR, indicating a role for actin in coordinating these two pathways. Here we will review previous and recent studies on actin reorganization during BCR activation and BCR- mediated antigen processing, and discuss how actin remodeling translates BCR signaling into rapid antigen uptake and processing while providing positive and negative feedback to BCR signaling.