The conformational and property space of acetylcholine bound to muscarinic receptors: an entropy component accounts for the subtype selectivity of acetylcholine

The conformational behavior of receptor-bound acetylcholine (ACh) was investigated by molecular dynamics simulations. Based on the great similarity among muscarinic receptors, the study was focused on the human M(1), M(2), and M(5) receptors as previously modeled by us. The results showed that receptor-bound ACh was not frozen in a single preferred conformation but preserved an unexpected fraction of its conformational space. However, there were marked differences between the three receptors since the ligand was mostly trans in the M(1) receptor, equally distributed among trans and gauche conformers in M(2), and exclusively gauche in the M(5); the greater flexibility of M(2)-bound ACh was paralleled by the greater flexibility of the occupied M(2) binding site. By contrast, the property space of receptor-bound ACh, and particularly its virtual (computed, conformation-dependent) lipophilicity, was restricted to relatively narrow ranges optimal for successful interaction. Experimental binding investigations to the individual human M(1), M(2), and M(5) muscarinic receptors showed ACh to have a 10-fold higher affinity for the M(2) compared to the M(1) and M(5) receptors. This selectivity was not confirmed by the calculated binding scores, a fact postulated to be caused by the absence of an entropy component in such binding scores. Indeed, the Shannon entropy of all geometric and physicochemical properties monitored were markedly higher in M(2)-bound ACh compared to M(1)-bound and M(5)-bound ACh. This finding suggests that the selectivity profile of acetylcholine for the M(2) receptor is largely entropy-driven, a fact that might explain the intrinsic difficulty to design subtype-selective muscarinic agonists.     

Affinity profiles of various muscarinic antagonists for cloned human muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (mAChR) subtypes and mAChRs in rat heart and submandibular gland.

A family of five subtypes of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors (mAChR) has been identified based on their molecular structures and second signal transduction pathways. In the present study, we examined the antagonist binding profiles of 9 muscarinic antagonists (atropine, 4-DAMP, pirenzepine, oxybutynin, tiquizium, timepidium, propiverine, darifenacin and zamifenacin) for human muscarinic acetylcholine receptor subtypes (m1, m2, m3, m4 and m5) produced by using a baculovirus infection system in Sf9 insect cells, and rat tissue membrane preparations (heart and submandibular gland). In a scopolamine methyl chloride [N-methyl-3H]- ([3H]NMS) binding assay, pirenzepine and timepidium displayed the highest affinities for the m1 and m2 subtypes, respectively, and both zamifenacin and darifenacin had the highest affinities for the m3 subtype, although the selectivities among the five subtypes were less than 10-fold. Propiverine showed a slightly higher affinity for the m5 subtype, whereas none of the drugs used in this study was uniquely selective for the m4 subtype. The binding affinities of muscarinic antagonists for rat heart and submandibular gland strong correlated with those for human cloned m2 and m3 subtypes, respectively. These data suggest that [3H]NMS binding studies using rat heart and submandibular gland might be useful methods which predict the affinities of test drugs for human muscarinic M2 and M3 receptor subtypes.     

Characterization of Muscarinic Receptors: Type M2 (Subtype B) on Neuro-2A Neuroblastoma Cells

Abstract

The binding of the nonselective muscarinic antagonist, [³H]N-methylscopolamine (NMS) to a mouse neuroblastoma cell line (Neuro-2A) and its coupling to the inhibition of adenylate cyclase were characterized. Specific [³H]NMS binding to membrane preparations was rapid, saturable, and of high affinity. Saturation experiments revealed a single class of binding sites for the radioligand. Competition experiments with the muscarinic drugs pirenzepine, AF DX 116, dicyclomine and atropine revealed that the muscarinic receptors present on these cells are predominantly of a single class, subtype B (M2). In addition, agonist binding demonstrated existence of a GTP-sensitive high affinity binding state of the receptors. Coupling of these muscarinic receptors to the adenylate cyclase system was investigated using the muscarinic agonist carbachol which was able to inhibit the prostaglandin (PGE₁)-stimulated activation of adenylate cyclase. The agonist carbachol did not stimulate the formation of IP₃ above basal levels, which indicated that the receptors are not coupled to phosphatidylinositol metabolism. In conclusion, we show that possessing predominantly one subtype of muscarinic receptor, the Neuro-2A cells provide a useful model for the investigation of the heterogeneity of muscarinic receptors and the relationship of subtype to the coupling of different effectors.     

Differential effects of paraoxon on the M3 muscarinic receptor and its effector system in rat submaxillary gland cells

The effects of the organophosphorus anticholinesterase paraoxon on the binding of radioactive ligands to the M₃ subtype of the muscarinic receptor and receptor-coupled synthesis of second messengers in intact rat submaxillary gland (SMG) cells were investigated. The binding of [³H]quinuclidinyl benzilate ([³H]QNB) was most sensitive to atropine and the M₃-specific antagonist 4-DAMP followed by pirenzepine and least sensitive to the cardioselective M₂ antagonist AFDX116. This, and the binding characteristics of [³H]4-DAMP, confirmed that the muscarinic receptors in this preparation are of the M₃ subtype. Activation of these muscarinic receptors by carbamylcholine (CBC) produced both stimulation of phosphoinositide (PI) hydrolysis and inhibition of cAMP synthesis, suggesting that this receptor subtype couples to both effector systems. Paraoxon (100 μM) reduced B_max of [³H]4-DAMP binding from 27 ± 4 to 13 ± 3 fmol/mg protein with nonsignificant change in affinity, suggesting noncompetitive inhibition of binding by paraoxon. Like the agonist CBC, paraoxon inhibited the forskolininduced cAMP formation in SMG cells with an EC₅₀ of 200 nM, but paraoxon was > 500 fold more potent than CBC. However, while the inhibition by CBC was counteracted by 2 μM atropine, that by paraoxon was unaffected by up to 100 μM atropine. It suggested that this effect of paraoxon was not via binding to the muscarinic receptor. Paraoxon did not affect β-adrenoreceptor function in the preparation, since it did not affect the 10 μM isoproterenol-induced cAMP synthesis, which was inhibited totally by 10 μM propranolol and partially by CBC. Paraoxon had a small but significant effect on CBC-stimulated PI metabolism in the SMG cells. It is suggested that paraoxon binds to two different sites in these SMG cells. One is an allosteric site on the M₃ muscarinic receptor which affects ligand binding and may modulate receptor function. The other site may be on the G_i proteinadenylyl cyclase system, and produces CBC-like action, that is, inhibition of the forskolin-stimulated [³H]cAMP synthesis, and is unaffected by atropine inhibition of the muscarinic receptor. This adds to the complexity of paraoxon actions on muscarinic receptors and their effector systems.     

Pharmacologic characterization of muscarinic receptors of insect brains.

Muscarinic receptors in brain membranes from honey bees, houseflies, and the American cockroach were identified by their specific binding of the non-selective muscarinic receptor antagonist [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate ([3H]QNB) and the displacement of this binding by agonists as well as subtype-selective antagonists, using filtration assays. The binding parameters, obtained from Scatchard analysis, indicated that insect muscarinic receptors, like those of mammalian brains, had high affinities for [3H]QNB (KD = 0.47 nM in honey bees, 0.17 nM in houseflies and 0.13 nM in the cockroach). However, the receptor concentration was low (108, 64.7, and 108 fmol/mg protein for the three species, respectively). The association and dissociation rates of [3H]QNB binding to honey bee brain membranes, sensitivity of [3H]QNB binding to muscarinic agonists, and high affinity for atropine were also features generally similar to muscarinic receptors of mammalian brains. In order to further characterize the three insect brain muscarinic receptors, the displacement of [3H]QNB binding by subtype-selective antagonists was studied. The rank order of potency of pirenzepine (PZ), the M1 selective antagonist, 11-[2-[dimethylamino)-methyl)1-piperidinyl)acetyl)-5,11- dihydro-6H-pyrido(2,3-b)-(1,4)-benzodiazepin-6 one (AF-DX 116), the M2-selective antagonist, and 4-DAMP (4-diphenylacetoxy-N-methylpiperidine methiodide) the M3-selective antagonist, was also the same as that of mammalian brains, i.e., 4-DAMP greater than PZ greater than AF-DX 116. The three insect brain receptors had 27-50-fold lower affinity for PZ (Ki 484-900 nM) than did the mammalian brain receptor (Ki 16 nM), but similar to that reported for the muscarinic receptor subtype cloned from Drosophila. Also, the affinity of insect receptors for 4-DAMP (Ki 18.9-56.6 nM) was much lower than that of the M3 receptor, which predominates in rat submaxillary gland (Ki of 0.37 nM on [3H]QNB binding). These drug specificities of muscarinic receptors of brains from three insect species suggest that insect brains may be predominantly of a unique subtype that is close to, though significantly different from, the mammalian M3 subtype.     

In vivo demonstration of M3 muscarinic receptor subtype selectivity of darifenacin in mice

A novel muscarinic receptor antagonist, darifenacin, inhibited specific binding of [N-methyl-(3)H]scopolamine ([(3)H]NMS) in the mouse bladder, submaxillary gland and heart in a concentration-dependent manner. The inhibitory effect was most potent in the submaxillary gland, followed by the bladder and heart. In addition, darifenacin inhibited specific [(3)H]NMS binding in the membranes of CHO-K1 cell lines expressing muscarinic M(2) and M(3) receptor subtypes, and the potency was significantly (22-fold) greater at the M(3) than at the M(2) subtype. At 0.5 to 12 h after oral administration of darifenacin, a significant increase in K(d) values for specific [(3)H]NMS binding was seen in the bladder, submaxillary gland and lung of mice, compared with control values. Also, there was a sustained decrease in the B(max) values in the submaxillary gland. These data suggest that muscarinic receptor binding of oral darifenacin is rapid in onset and of a long duration. On the other hand, oral darifenacin exerted only temporary or little binding of muscarinic receptors in the heart and colon. Pilocarpine-induced salivary secretion in mice was continuously suppressed by oral darifenacin. The time-course of suppression coincided well with that for the muscarinic receptor binding in the submaxillary gland. The antagonistic effect of darifenacin against the dose-response curves for pilocarpine appeared to be insurmountable. In conclusion, the present study has shown that oral darifenacin may exert a pronounced and long-lasting binding of muscarinic receptors in tissues expressing the M(3) subtype.     

Effects of D-Tubocurarine on Rat Cardiac Muscarinic Receptors: A Comparison with Gallamine

Abstract

Gallamine and d-tubocurarine inhibited (³H)N-methylscopolamine ((³H)NMS) binding to rat cardiac muscarinic receptors with I₅₀ values of 0.7 μM and 22 μM, respectively. They decreased the association and dissociation rates of the two ligands (³H)NMS and (³H)Oxotremorine M ((³H)Oxo-M).

Gallamine interaction with muscarinic receptors was markedly inhibited by (³H)NMS and (³H)Oxo-M binding to the receptors. We were unable to demonstrate (³H)NMS or (³H)Oxo-M binding to the muscarinic receptor-gallamine complex.

By contrast, d-tubocurarine interaction with rat cardiac muscarinic receptors was facilitated by (³H)Oxo-M binding and only slightly inhibited by (³H)NMS binding to muscarinic binding sites. Furthermore, (³H)NMS and (³H)Oxo-M bound to the receptor-d-tubocurarine complex, indicating that the latter drug interacted with an allosteric site on cardiac muscarinic receptors but did not recognize the muscarinic binding site (at concentrations below 1 mM).     

The existence of a second allosteric site on the M1 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor and its implications for drug design

Fully flexible docking of KT5720, an allosteric modulator of the muscarinic receptors, was performed on a dynamic model of the M(1) muscarinic acetylcholine receptor. The results confirmed the existence of a second allosteric site, located on the intracellular face of the receptor. These results would be beneficial for the design of modulators of this receptor to be used as an effective alternative against the Alzheimer's disease.     

Sialic acid is selectively involved in the interaction of agonists with M2 muscarinic acetylcholine receptors

Neuraminidase and slight acid hydrolysis were used to investigate the role of sialic acid residues in the binding of muscarinic agonists and antagonists to membranes from tissues rich in M1 and M2 receptors. Membranes were pretreated with neuraminidase at pH 5 and the binding parameters were determined from competitive experiments with (3H)-quinuclidinylbenzylate. The removal of sialic acid residues reduced the affinity of muscarinic agonists for cerebellum, heart and lung membranes (M2), in contrast to striatum (M1). The affinity of antagonists was not affected. Thus, sialic acid is selectively involved in the interaction of agonists with M2 muscarinic receptors.     

Differential alterations in muscarinic receptor subtypes in Alzheimer's disease: implications for cholinergic-based therapies

Molecular subtypes of muscarinic receptors (m1-m5) are novel targets for cholinergic replacement therapies in Alzheimer's disease (AD). However, knowledge concerning the relative distribution, abundance and functional status of these receptors in human brain and AD is incomplete. Recent data from our laboratory have demonstrated a defect in the ability of the M1 receptor subtype to form a high affinity agonist-receptor-G protein complex in AD frontal cortex. This defect is manifested by decreased M1 receptor-stimulated GTPgammaS binding and GTPase activity and by a loss in receptor-stimulated phospholipase C activity. Normal levels of G proteins suggest that the aberrant receptor-G protein interaction may result from an altered form of the m1 receptor in AD. The combined use of radioligand binding and receptor-domain specific antibodies has permitted the re-examination of the status of muscarinic receptor subtypes in the human brain. In AD, normal levels of m1 receptor [3H]-pirenzepine binding contrasted with diminished m1 immunoreactivity, further suggesting that there is an altered form of the m1 receptor in the disease. Reduced m2 immunoreactivity was consistent with decreased numbers of m2 binding sites. Increased levels of m4 receptors were observed in both binding and immunoreactivity measurements. These findings suggest one possible explanation for the relative ineffectiveness of cholinergic replacement therapies used to date and suggest potential new directions for development of effective therapeutic strategies for AD.     

The effect of absolute configuration on activity,subtype selectivity (M3/M2) of 3α-acyloxy-6β-acetoxyltropane derivatives as muscarinic M3 receptor antagonists

Both enantiomers of 3α-acyloxy-6β-acetoxyltropane derivatives 1–4 were prepared respectively and underwent functional studies and radioreceptor binding assays. 6S Enantiomers showed obvious muscarinic M3, M2 antagonistic activity, while the 6R ones elicited little muscarinic activity by functional studies. Besides, the affinity of 6S enantiomers to muscarinic M3 receptors of rat submandibulary gland, M2 receptors of rat left atria was much larger than that of corresponding 6R enantiomers. All these pharmalogical results indicated 6S configuration was favorable for 3α-acyloxy-6β-acetoxyltropane derivatives to bind with muscarinic M3 or M2 receptors and elicited antagonistic activity. Furthermore, the muscarinic M3 activity and subtype selectivity (M3/M2) of 6S enantiomers could be improved by increasing the electron density of carbonyl oxygen or introducing methylene group between the carbonyl and phenyl ring in C-3α position. Understanding the effect of absolute configuration on activity, subtype selectivity (M3/M2) of 3α-acyloxy-6β-acetoxyltropane derivatives will provide the clues for designing muscarinic M3 antagonists with high activity and low side effects or toxicity.     

Sodium Nitroprusside Induces Internalization of Muscarinic Receptors Stably Expressed in Chinese Hamster Ovary Cell Lines

Abstract: We have characterized the internalization of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors induced by the nitric oxide (NO)-generating compound sodium nitroprusside. When Chinese hamster ovary cells, stably transfected with the human m4 muscarinic receptor subtype, were incubated for 1 h in the presence of 700 µ M sodium nitroprusside, the number of receptors measured in intact cells with the hydrophilic ligand N -[³H]methylscopolamine was reduced by 30%. The effect was dose dependent, beginning with a concentration of sodium nitroprusside as low as 45 µ M . Removal of sodium nitroprusside from the incubation medium did not result in a recovery of the binding sites. The phenomenon was temperature dependent and was blocked by the muscarinic antagonist atropine. No receptor diminution was detected when the number of binding sites was evaluated with the lipophilic antagonist [³H]quinuclidinyl benzilate. This indicates that sodium nitroprusside induces a redistribution of the muscarinic receptors between the plasma membrane and an internal compartment of the cell. Receptor loss was readily reversed by treatment with the sulfhydryl reducing agent diethyldithiocarbamate. Our data provide evidence that muscarinic receptors are internalized by sodium nitroprusside through the oxidation of sulfhydryl groups; they also suggest that NO could play a role in muscarinic receptor desensitization.     

Muscarinic receptor subtypes in bovine adrenal medulla

Catecholamine secretion in the bovine adrenal medulla is evoked largely by nicotinic receptor activation. However, bovine adrenal medulla also contain muscarinic receptors that mediate several cell responses. To understand the physiological role of muscarinic receptors in the bovine adrenal medulla it is important to identify the pharmacological subtypes present in this tissue. For this, we analyzed the abilities of differnt selective muscarinic antagonists in displacing the binding of the non-selective antagonist [3H] quinuclidinyl benzylate to an enriched plasma membrane fraction prepared from bovine adrenal medulla. All the selective antagonists bind at least two bindings sites with different affinities. The binding profile of the sites with high proportion is similar to the M2 subtype and those present in low proportion have a M1 profile. However, some variation in the proportion of the sites for the different ligands suggest the presence of the third pharmacological subtype (M3). We conclude that the sites in high proportion (60–80%) correspond to M2 muscarinic subtypes, and the rest is constitute by M1 plus M3 subtypes. The presence of multiplicity of subtypes in the adrenal medulla membranes suggests a diversity of functions of muscarinic receptors in the adrenal gland.Abbreviations [3H]QNB [3H]quinuclidinyl benzylate - HHSiD hexahydro-siladifenidol-hydrochloride - AF-DX 116 11-[[2-(diethylamino)methyl]]-1-piperidinyl]-5,11-dihydro-6H-pyrido[2,3,-b][1,4]benzodiazepin-6-one - 4-DAMP 4-diphenylacetoxy-N-methyl piperidine methobromide     

The muscarinic receptor subtype in mouse pancreatic B-cells

Isolated mouse islets were used to identify the muscarinic receptor subtype present in pancreatic B-cells. We thus compared the inhibitory potencies of atropine (non-specific), of pirenzepine (specific for M1 receptors) and of compound AF-DX 116 (specific for cardiac M2 receptors) on acetylcholine-induced insulin release, 86Rb+ efflux and 45Ca2+ efflux. The three antagonists inhibited all effects of acetylcholine, but EC50 values were markedly different: atropine = 1.5-5 nM, pirenzepine = 0.6-1.7 microM and AF-DX 116 = 1.7-11 microM. The results did not suggest that the various effects of ACh could result from the activation of different subtypes of receptors. It is concluded that muscarinic receptors of pancreatic B-cells belong to an M2 subtype distinct from the cardiac M2 receptors.     

Molecular and pharmacological characterization of muscarinic receptors in retinal pigment epithelium: role in light-adaptive pigment movements

Muscarinic receptors are the predominant cholinergic receptors in the central and peripheral nervous systems. Recently, activation of muscarinic receptors was found to elicit pigment granule dispersion in retinal pigment epithelium isolated from bluegill fish. Pigment granule movement in retinal pigment epithelium is a light-adaptive mechanism in fish. In the present study, we used pharmacological and molecular approaches to identify the muscarinic receptor subtype and the intracellular signaling pathway involved in the pigment granule dispersion in retinal pigment epithelium. Of the muscarinic receptor subtype-specific antagonists used, only antagonists specific for M1 and M3 muscarinic receptors were found to block carbamyl choline (carbachol)-induced pigment granule dispersion. A phospholipase C inhibitor also blocked carbachol-induced pigment granule dispersion, and a similar result was obtained when retinal pigment epithelium was incubated with an inositol trisphosphate receptor inhibitor. We isolated M2 and M5 receptor genes from bluegill and studied their expression. Only M5 was found to be expressed in retinal pigment epithelium. Taken together, pharmacological and molecular evidence suggest that activation of an odd subtype of muscarinic receptor, possibly M5, on fish retinal pigment epithelium induces pigment granule dispersion.     

High affinity quinuclidinyl benzilate binding to rat parotid membranes requires muscarinic receptor. G protein interactions

The binding of the non-selective muscarinic antagonist [3H]quinuclidinyl benzilate (QNB) to rat parotid membranes was characterized. Under equilibrium conditions, [3H]QNB bound to a homogenous population of muscarinic receptors (Kd, 118 +/- 19 pM; Bmax, 572 +/- 42 fmol/mg membrane protein, n = 12). The addition of G protein activators AlF4- or guanosine-5'-O-(3-thiotriphosphate) (GTP gamma S) + Mg2+ increased the Kd by 77 +/- 7% (n = 4, P less than 0.05) and 83 +/- 27% (n = 7, P less than 0.05), respectively, without a change in the Bmax or homogeneity of the binding site. GTP gamma S added without exogenous Mg2+ did not affect [3H]QNB binding. Thus, optimal QNB binding requires a muscarinic receptor/G protein interaction.     

Muscarinic Binding of Pial Vessels and Arachnoid Membrane

Abstract: The muscarinic sites in arachnoid and pial vessels were compared by analysis of the binding of quinuclidinyl benzilate (QNB) to membrane preparations. Saturation analysis indicated that the process was saturable, high affinity, and related to protein concentration in both structures. Although the affinities in the two structures [ K _D= 0.039 (arachnoid) and 0.097 n M (pial vessels)] were similar, the arachnoid had ∼ 10-fold more binding sites ( B _max= 2,100 fmol/mg of protein) than the pial vessels ( B _max= 250 fmol/ mg of protein). This difference was found in both bovine and porcine fractions. Pharmacological analysis of [³H]-QNB displacement by muscarinic and nonmuscarinic ligands gave the typical pattern of muscarinic receptors in both structures. Inhibition of binding to pial vessels by the M, antagonist pirenzepine revealed only one low-affinity site ( K _i= 7.8 × 10⁻⁷ M ), whereas, the arachnoid had a small proportion (21%) of high-affinity sites ( K _i= 2.2 × 10⁻⁹ M ) associated with low-affinity sites ( K _i= 5.50 × 10⁻⁷ M ). It is concluded that muscarinic-mediated effects that do not involve the M, subtype are induced in bovine pial vessels by a relatively low concentration of binding sites. The high content of muscarinic binding sites and their diversity in the arachnoid suggest a functional role for muscarinic cholinergic receptors in this structure.     

M1胆碱受体选择性别构激动剂的虚拟筛选和体外活性研究

目的:M1毒蕈碱型乙酰胆碱受体(M1受体)在改善学习和记忆等高级认知功能障碍中起重要作用,本文利用计算机辅助药物设计和高表达各M受体亚型的CHO细胞(Chinese hamster ovary cell,中国仓鼠卵巢细胞),以期筛选获得新型M1受体选择性别构激动剂。方法:通过计算机辅助药物设计方法,对已知具有M1受体选择性作用别构激动剂与M1受体的晶体结构进行对接,确定活性对接口袋,据此进行化合物库虚拟筛选;利用高表达各M受体亚型的CHO细胞,对化合物进行体外活性检测。结果:虚拟筛选得到184个化合物,其中,体外实验显示化合物AJ-292和AG-205-6对M1受体有明显的激动效果,而对M3、M5受体则无影响。结论:综合利用虚拟筛选、结构分析以及特异性活性分析,筛选出具有M1受体高选择性激动作用的化合物AJ-292和AG-205-6,为设计开发新型的M1选择性别构激动剂奠定了基础。