Comprehensive analysis of kinase inhibitor selectivity

We tested the interaction of 72 kinase inhibitors with 442 kinases covering >80% of the human catalytic protein kinome. Our data show that, as a class, type II inhibitors are more selective than type I inhibitors, but that there are important exceptions to this trend. The data further illustrate that selective inhibitors have been developed against the majority of kinases targeted by the compounds tested. Analysis of the interaction patterns reveals a class of 'group-selective' inhibitors broadly active against a single subfamily of kinases, but selective outside that subfamily. The data set suggests compounds to use as tools to study kinases for which no dedicated inhibitors exist. It also provides a foundation for further exploring kinase inhibitor biology and toxicity, as well as for studying the structural basis of the observed interaction patterns. Our findings will help to realize the direct enabling potential of genomics for drug development and basic research about cellular signaling.     

Exploring sequence-structure relationships in the tyrosine kinome space: functional classification of the binding specificity mechanisms for cancer therapeutics

MOTIVATION: Evolutionary and structural conservation patterns shared by more than 500 of identified protein kinases have led to complex sequence-structure relationships of cross-reactivity for kinase inhibitors. Understanding the molecular basis of binding specificity for protein kinases family, which is the central problem in discovery of cancer therapeutics, remains challenging as the inhibitor selectivity is not readily interpreted from chemical proteomics studies, neither it is easily discernable directly from sequence or structure information. We present an integrated view of sequence-structure-binding relationships in the tyrosine kinome space in which evolutionary analysis of the kinases binding sites is combined with computational proteomics profiling of the inhibitor-protein interactions. This approach provides a functional classification of the binding specificity mechanisms for cancer agents targeting protein tyrosine kinases. RESULTS: The proposed functional classification of the kinase binding specificities explores mechanisms in which structural plasticity of the tyrosine kinases and sequence variation of the binding-site residues are linked with conformational preferences of the inhibitors in achieving effective drug binding. The molecular basis of binding specificity for tyrosine kinases may be largely driven by conformational adaptability of the inhibitors to an ensemble of structurally different conformational states of the enzyme, rather than being determined by their phylogenetic proximity in the kinome space or differences in the interactions with the variable binding-site residues. This approach provides a fruitful functional linkage between structural bioinformatics analysis and disease by unraveling the molecular basis of kinase selectivity for the prominent kinase drugs (Imatinib, Dasatinib and Erlotinib) which is consistent with structural and proteomics experiments.     

Novel and selective spiroindoline-based inhibitors of Sky kinase

We report the discovery of a novel series of spiroindoline-based inhibitors of Sky kinase that bind in the ATP-binding site and exhibit high levels of kinome selectivity through filling the Ala571-subpocket. These inhibitors exhibit moderate oral bioavailability in the rat due to low absorption across the gut wall.     

Identification and SAR of a new series of thieno[3,2-d]pyrimidines as Tpl2 kinase inhibitors

We report here the synthesis and SAR of a new series of thieno[3,2-d]pyrimidines as potent Tpl2 kinase inhibitors. The proposed binding mode suggests the potential flipped binding mode depending on the substitution. Biacore studies show evidence of binding of these molecules to the protein kinase. The kinome inhibition profile of these molecules suggests good selectivity.     

Analysis of water patterns in protein kinase binding sites

Deregulation of protein kinases is associated with numerous diseases, making them important targets for drug discovery. The majority of drugs target the catalytic site of these proteins, but due to the high level of similarity within the ATP binding sites of protein kinases, it is often difficult to achieve the required pharmacological selectivity. In this study, we describe the identification and subsequent analysis of water patterns in the ATP binding sites of 171 protein kinase structures, comprising 19 different kinases from various branches of the kinome, and demonstrate that structurally similar binding sites often have significantly different water patterns. We show that the observed variations in water patterns of different, but structurally similar kinases can be exploited in the structure-based design of potent and selective kinase inhibitors.     

Synthesis and profiling of a 3-aminopyridin-2-one-based kinase targeted fragment library: Identification of 3-amino-5-(pyridin-4-yl)pyridin-2(1H)-one scaffold for monopolar spindle 1 (MPS1) and Aurora kinases inhibition

Screening a 3-aminopyridin-2-one based fragment library against a 26-kinase panel representative of the human kinome identified 3-amino-5-(1-methyl-1H-pyrazol-4-yl)pyridin-2(1H)-one (2) and 3-amino-5-(pyridin-4-yl)pyridin-2(1H)-one (3) as ligand efficient inhibitors of the mitotic kinase Monopolar Spindle 1 (MPS1) and the Aurora kinase family. These kinases are well recognised as attractive targets for therapeutic intervention for treating cancer. Elucidation of the binding mode of these fragments and their analogues has been carried out by X-ray crystallography. Structural studies have identified key interactions with a conserved lysine residue and have highlighted potential regions of MPS1 which could be targeted to improve activity and selectivity.     

Discovery of 3-(4-sulfamoylnaphthyl)pyrazolo[1,5-a]pyrimidines as potent and selective ALK2 inhibitors

The pyrazolo[1,5-a]pyrimidine LDN-193189 is a potent inhibitor of activin receptor-like kinase 2 (ALK2) but is nonselective for highly homologous ALK3 and shows only modest kinome selectivity. Herein, we describe the discovery of a novel series of potent and selective ALK2 inhibitors by replacing the quinolinyl with a 4-(sulfamoyl)naphthyl, yielding ALK2 inhibitors that exhibit not only excellent discrimination versus ALK3 but also high kinome selectivity. In addition, the optimized compound 23 demonstrates good ADME and in vivo pharmacokinetic properties.     

Imprint of evolutionary conservation and protein structure variation on the binding function of protein tyrosine kinases

MOTIVATION: According to the models of divergent molecular evolution, the evolvability of new protein function may depend on the induction of new phenotypic traits by a small number of mutations of the binding site residues. Evolutionary relationships between protein kinases are often employed to infer inhibitor binding profiles from sequence analysis. However, protein kinases binding profiles may display inhibitor selectivity within a given kinase subfamily, while exhibiting cross-activity between kinases that are phylogenetically remote from the prime target. The emerging insights into kinase function and evolution combined with a rapidly growing number of publically available crystal structures of protein kinases complexes have motivated structural bioinformatics analysis of sequence-structure relationships in determining the binding function of protein tyrosine kinases. RESULTS: In silico profiling of Imatinib mesylate and PD-173955 kinase inhibitors with protein tyrosine kinases is conducted on kinome scale by using evolutionary analysis and fingerprinting inhibitor-protein interactions with the panel of all publically available protein tyrosine kinases crystal structures. We have found that sequence plasticity of the binding site residues alone may not be sufficient to enable protein tyrosine kinases to readily evolve novel binding activities with inhibitors. While evolutionary signal derived solely from the tyrosine kinase sequence conservation can not be readily translated into the ligand binding phenotype, the proposed structural bioinformatics analysis can discriminate a functionally relevant kinase binding signal from a simple phylogenetic relationship. The results of this work reveal that protein conformational diversity is intimately linked with sequence plasticity of the binding site residues in achieving functional adaptability of protein kinases towards specific drug binding. This study offers a plausible molecular rationale to the experimental binding profiles of the studied kinase inhibitors and provides a theoretical basis for constructing functionally relevant kinase binding trees.     

Inhibition of Tpl2 kinase and TNFalpha production with quinoline-3-carbonitriles for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

The synthesis and structure-activity studies of a series of quinoline-3-carbonitriles as inhibitors of Tpl2 kinase are described. Potent inhibitors of Tpl2 kinase with selectivity against a panel of selected kinases in enzymatic assays and specificity in cell-based phosphorylation assays in LPS-treated human monocytes were identified. Selected inhibitors with moderate activity in human whole blood assay effectively inhibited LPS/D-Gal induced TNFalpha release when administered intraperitoneally in mice.     

Strategic use of conformational bias and structure based design to identify potent JAK3 inhibitors with improved selectivity against the JAK family and the kinome

Using a structure based design approach we have identified a series of indazole substituted pyrrolopyrazines, which are potent inhibitors of JAK3. Intramolecular electronic repulsion was used as a strategy to induce a strong conformational bias within the ligand. Compounds bearing this conformation participated in a favorable hydrophobic interaction with a cysteine residue in the JAK3 binding pocket, which imparted high selectivity versus the kinome and improved selectivity within the JAK family.     

What general conclusions can we draw from kinase profiling data sets?

Understanding general selectivity trends across the kinome has implications ranging from target selection, compound prioritization, toxicity and patient tailoring. Several recent publications have described the characterization of kinase inhibitors via large assay panels, offering a range of generalizations that influenced kinase inhibitor research trends. Since a subset of profiled inhibitors overlap across reports, we evaluated the concordance of activity results for the same compound–kinase pairs across four data sources generated from different kinase biochemical assay technologies. Overall, 77% of all results are within 3 fold or qualitatively in agreement across sources. However, the agreement for active compounds is only 37%, indicating that different profiling panels are in better agreement to determine a compound's lack of activity rather than degree of activity. Low concordance is also found when comparing the promiscuity of kinase targets evaluated from different sources, and the pharmacological similarity of kinases. In contrast, the overall promiscuity of kinase inhibitors was consistent across sources. We highlight the difficulty of drawing general conclusions from such data by showing that no significant selectivity difference distinguishes type I vs. type II inhibitors, and limited kinase space similarity that is consistent across different sources. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Inhibitors of Protein Kinases (2012).     

Utilizing comprehensive and mini-kinome panels to optimize the selectivity of quinoline inhibitors for cyclin G associated kinase (GAK)

We demonstrate an innovative approach for optimization of kinase inhibitor potency and selectivity utilising kinase mini-panels and kinome-wide panels. We present a focused case study on development of a selective inhibitor of cyclin G associated kinase (GAK) using the quin(az)oline inhibitor chemotype. These results exemplify a versatile, efficient approach to drive kinome selectivity during inhibitor development programs.     

Structure–activity relationship of novel DAPK inhibitors identified by structure-based virtual screening

Death-associated protein kinase (DAPK) is a serine/threonine protein kinase implicated in diverse programmed cell death pathways. DAPK is a promising target protein for the treatment of ischemic diseases. We identified novel potent and selective DAPK inhibitors efficiently by structure-based virtual screening, then further developed the hit compounds. In this paper, we describe the development of the hit compounds and the structure–activity relationship studies of the DAPK inhibitors in detail, including calculation of the solvated interaction energy (SIE), and verification of selectivity using a kinase panel.     

Identification of pyrimidine derivatives as hSMG-1 inhibitors

hSMG-1 kinase plays a dual role in a highly conserved RNA surveillance pathway termed nonsense-mediated RNA decay (NMD) and in cellular genotoxic stress response. Since deregulation of cellular responses to stress contributes to tumor growth and resistance to chemotherapy, hSMG-1 is a potential target for cancer treatment. From our screening efforts, we have identified pyrimidine derivatives as hSMG-1 kinase inhibitors. We report structure-based optimization of this pan-kinase scaffold to improve its biochemical profile and overall kinome selectivity, including mTOR and CDK, to generate the first reported selective hSMG-1 tool compound.     

Discovery of a broad spectrum antiproliferative agent with selectivity for DDR1 kinase: cell line-based assay,kinase panel,molecular docking,and toxicity studies

Herein, we report compound KST9046, a new agent possessing quinazoline-urea scaffold. Preliminary biological evaluation done by the National Cancer Institute (NCI), USA, showed a great inhibitory effect of KST9046 over the 60 cell-line tumor panel. Accordingly, it was selected for a dose-response assay; a broad spectrum antiproliferative activity with GI₅₀ ranging from 1.3 to 3.9?µM was exerted. To explore a potential kinase inhibitory effect, KST9046 was applied at a single dose of 10?µM against a kinase panel of 347 different enzymes representing >50% of the predicted human protein kinome. Interestingly, selective inhibition of 76% was observed on DDR1 kinase. Further, KST9046 showed an IC₅₀ value of 4.38?µM for DDR1. A molecular docking model presented KST9046 as a potential type III inhibitor for DDR1 kinase with an allosteric mode of interaction, which may offer an explanation for its selectivity. As further investigation, CYP450 assay was carried out for KST9046, it showed a promising toxicity profile against four different isoforms. Based on these findings, KST9046 can be further evaluated as a promising safe new hit for the development of broad spectrum anticancer agents with a selectivity for DDR1 kinase.     

SAR studies around a series of triazolopyridines as potent and selective PI3Kγ inhibitors

Herein we describe the SAR of a novel series of 6-aryl-2-amino-triazolopyridines as potent and selective PI3Kγ inhibitors. The 6-aryl-triazolopyridine core was identified by chemoproteomic screening of a kinase focused library. Rapid chemical expansion around a bi-functional core identified the key features required for PI3Kγ activity and selectivity. The series was optimized to afford 43 (CZC19945), a potent PI3Kγ inhibitor with high oral bioavailability and selectivity over PI3Kα and PI3Kδ. Modification to the core afforded 53 (CZC24832) which showed increased selectivity over the entire kinome in particular over PI3Kβ.     

The sea urchin kinome: a first look

This paper reports a preliminary in silico analysis of the sea urchin kinome. The predicted protein kinases in the sea urchin genome were identified, annotated and classified, according to both function and kinase domain taxonomy. The results show that the sea urchin kinome, consisting of 353 protein kinases, is closer to the Drosophila kinome (239) than the human kinome (518) with respect to total kinase number. However, the diversity of sea urchin kinases is surprisingly similar to humans, since the urchin kinome is missing only 4 of 186 human subfamilies, while Drosophila lacks 24. Thus, the sea urchin kinome combines the simplicity of a non-duplicated genome with the diversity of function and signaling previously considered to be vertebrate-specific. More than half of the sea urchin kinases are involved with signal transduction, and approximately 88% of the signaling kinases are expressed in the developing embryo. These results support the strength of this nonchordate deuterostome as a pivotal developmental and evolutionary model organism.     

Discovery of 5-substituent-N-arylbenzamide derivatives as potent,selective and orally bioavailable LRRK2 inhibitors

Leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2) has been suggested as a potential therapeutic target for Parkinson’s disease. Herein we report the discovery of 5-substituent-N-arylbenzamide derivatives as novel LRRK2 inhibitors. Extensive SAR study led to the discovery of compounds 8e, which demonstrated potent LRRK2 inhibition activity, high selectivity across the kinome, good brain exposure, and high oral bioavailability.