Mammalian in vivo assays for aneuploidy in female germ cells

This paper presents an evaluation of and offers recommendations for assays to detect chemically induced aneuploidy in mammalian female germ cells. 72 papers on female germ cell aneuploidy, published from 1970 to 1984, were reviewed. 28 papers were selected for critical evaluation; the other 44 papers were rejected according to pre-established criteria. Salient points emerging from the information reviewed allow an assessment of the current status of mammalian female germ cell tests for aneuploidy. The majority of data have been obtained by analyzing metaphase II mouse oocyte chromosomes following superovulation. Various classes of chemicals were administered usually around the time of ovulation. Dose-response relationships have not been obtained for the majority of chemicals evaluated. The method of data reporting and analysis usually was not conducive to comparisons among different studies. Few of the 16 chemicals studied can be regarded as negative for their ability to induce aneuploidy, whereas an even smaller number should be considered as positive. Certainly, a need exists to identify the chemicals and the dosages that could increase the incidence of aneuploidy in mammalian female germ cells. Obtaining such data definitely is feasible in cytogenetic laboratories. However, the mammalian female germ cell aneuploid assay should not be perceived as a rapid, inexpensive, routine procedure. The assay is capable of detecting aneuploidy following anaphase I when metaphase II oocytes are studied and following anaphases I and II when first-cleavage zygotes are studied.     

Mechanisms and chemical induction of aneuploidy in rodent germ cells

The objective of this review is to suggest that the advances being made in our understanding of the molecular events surrounding chromosome segregation in non-mammalian and somatic cell models be considered when designing experiments for studying aneuploidy in mammalian germ cells. Accurate chromosome segregation requires the temporal control and unique interactions among a vast array of proteins and cellular organelles. Abnormal function and temporal disarray among these, and others to be identified, biochemical reactions and cellular organelles have the potential for predisposing cells to aneuploidy. Although numerous studies have demonstrated that certain chemicals (mainly those that alter microtubule function) can induce aneuploidy in mammalian germ cells, it seems relevant to point out that such data can be influenced by gender, meiotic stage, and time of cell-fixation post-treatment. Additionally, a consensus has not been reached regarding which of several germ cell aneuploidy assays most accurately reflects the human condition. More recent studies have shown that certain kinase, phosphatase, proteasome, and topoisomerase inhibitors can also induce aneuploidy in rodent germ cells. We suggest that molecular approaches be prudently incorporated into mammalian germ cell aneuploidy research in order to eventually understand the causes and mechanisms of human aneuploidy. Such an enormous undertaking would benefit from collaboration among scientists representing several disciplines.     

Current status of aneuploidy testing in Drosophila

Based on the literature on file at EMIC, 181 papers contained material on aneuploidy testing. Initial screening rejected papers providing no data, no negative control and/or poorly designed genetic schemes; 67 papers representing tests of 76 compounds were reported on. Statistical classifications were established as follows: (+)=a statistically significant difference at the 5% level between the treated and control frequencies; (-)=no significant difference at the 5% level when the number of offspring tested was sufficient to have identified an increase of 0.2% over the control with a power of 75%; I=inconclusive= (a) no significant difference at the 5% level but the number of offspring tested was below that necessary to detect an increase of 0.2% with a power of 75%; (b) the nature of apparent complete loss is undetermined; or (c) the nature of the germ cells sampled is not determined. Of the 76 compounds analyzed, calls were made on 34 compounds. 17/34 compounds were positive for chromosome gain (11/34 for chromosome gain and chromosome loss, 6/34 for chromosome gain only). 17/34 compounds were negative for chromosome gain (11/34 for chromosome gain and chromosome loss and 6 for chromosome gain only). Are any fo the compounds found to induce aneuploidy specific for aneuploid induction? 7 or the compounds positive for chromosome gain were positive in one or more tests assaying for other genetic endpoints, and no reliable data exists regarding results in other tests for the remaining 10 compounds; accordingly, the answer to the question awaits further work.     

Chemically-induced aneuploidy in mammalian oocytes

The ability of certain chemicals to elevate the frequency of aneuploidy above spontaneous levels in mammalian experimental models prompts the concern that a similar situation might exist in humans. Validation of experimental models for aneuploidy studies is in progress since there is much to be learned about the causes and mechanisms of chemically-induced aneuploidy. Several biological variables have been shown to influence the results from aneuploidy assays. In this review, we examine these variables as they relate to female germ cell aneuploid assays. Also, we have found that the aneuploidy results obtained from different cell types, sexes, and experimental models cannot necessarily be expected to agree due to certain anatomic and physiologic differences and the end points measured.     

Radiation- and chemically-induced chromosome aberrations in mouse oocytes: a comparison with effects in males.

Data from studies on radiation- and chemically-induced chromosome aberrations in mouse oocytes have been summarized. An attempt has been made to assess the relative sensitivity to mutagenic agents of female and male germ cells through comparison of observations from mutation studies of female and male mice. No unequivocal evidence of a mutagenic effect limited to a single sex could be found in the cytogenetic data, although differences in relative germ cell sensitivity could be inferred for ionizing radiation and some chemicals. However, the pattern of inter-sex variations was not consistent: for example, irradiation of dictyate oocytes yielded a lower rate of heritable chromosome translocations than the same dose to spermatogonia; in contrast, some chemicals, such as mitomycin C, yielded a larger incidence of chromosome anomalies after treatment of dictyate oocytes than spermatogonia. Overall, the limitations in quality and quantity of cytogenetic data, and the uncertainties associated with comparing information obtained in disparate assays, place severe constraints on the use of observations on induced chromosome aberrations to assess the relative sensitivities of female and male germ cells to environmental mutagens.     

The influence of the Robertsonian translocation Rb(X.2)2Ad on anaphase I non-disjunction in male laboratory mice

A Robertsonian translocation in the mouse between the X chromosome and chromosome 2 is described. The male and female carriers of the Rb(X.2)2Ad were fertile. A homozygous/hemizygous line was maintained. The influence of the X-autosomal Robertsonian translocation on anaphase I non-disjunction in male mice was studied by chromosome counts in cells at metaphase II of meiosis and by assessment of aneuploid progeny. The results conclusively show that the inclusion of Rb2Ad in the male genome induces non-disjunction at the first meoitic division. In second metaphase cells the frequency of sex-chromosomal aneuploidy was 10.8%, and secondary spermatocytes containing two or no sex chromosome were equally frequent. The Rb2Ad males sired 3.9% sex-chromosome aneuploid progeny. The difference in aneuploidy frequencies in the germ cells and among the progeny suggests that the viability of XO and XXY individuals is reduced. The pairing configurations of chromosomes 2, Rb2Ad and Y were studied during meiotic prophase by light and electron microscopy. Trivalent pairing was seen in all well spread nuclei. Complete pairing of the acrocentric autosome 2 with the corresponding segment of the Rb2Ad chromosome was only seen in 3.2% of the cells analysed in the electron microscope. The pairing between the X and Y chromosome in the Rb2Ad males corresponded to that in males with normal karyotype. Reasons for sex-chromosomal non-disjunction despite the normal pairing pattern between the sex chromosomes may be seen in the terminal chiasma location coupled with the asynchronous separation of the sex chromosomes and the autosomes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Chemically induced aneuploidy in mammalian cells in culture

Our objectives were to assess whether there exist useful aneuploidy tests in vitro, to identify chemicals that showed potential for mitotic aneuploidy induction, and to recommend some features of suitable protocols for such testing. From over 100 papers we selected 24 for review. The acceptable studies examined hyperdiploidy at metaphase, had concurrent negative controls with low background rates of hyperdiploidy, used a fixation time sufficient for cells to complete more than one cell cycle after treatment and had multiple dose levels with at least 100 cells scored per point. We judged that 12 compounds were positive, 7 inconclusive, and 4 negative with the reservation that 2 of the 4 compounds had not been tested up to toxic doses. Many of the positive compounds are also known to cause structural chromosome aberrations. We separately reviewed qualitative reports of 'C-mitotic' effects, anaphase lagging, multipolar mitoses, or altered DNA content, since these effects may sometimes by associated with aneuploidy induction. No well-validated in vitro aneuploidy assay exists, and much research is required to develop tests, perhaps using chromosome counts, DNA content, or effects on cell organelles necessary for mitosis. In test protocol development we should carefully consider choice of cell sample size, use of in vitro metabolic activation systems, and selection of doses, especially with regard to the problem of whether cytotoxic concentrations should be used.     

Effect of methylmethane sulfonate-sensitive mutations on nondisjunction and loss of sex chromosomes in Drosophila males

The MMS-sensitive mutants mus(1) 120M1 and mus(1) 121M1 of Drosophila melanogaster were investigated regarding their effects on spontaneous and X-ray induced (2000 R) aneuploidy in male germ cells, during different stages of spermatogenesis. In matings of males carrying mus mutation and a doubly marked Y-chromosome (BsYy+) with repair proficient y f females, the frequencies of partial loss, nondisjunctions and especially complete loss were significantly higher than in the control. Apparently, MMS-sensitive mutants deal with meiotic processes and maintenance of chromosome structural stability both in females and in males, in somatic and germ cells.     

Systems and results of tests for chemical induction of mitotic malsegregation and aneuploidy in Aspergillus nidulans

In Aspergillus several types of test systems have been developed for detection of chemicals which induce aneuploidy and/or malsegregation of chromosomes. Results from 23 papers were reviewed in which numerical data for 42 chemicals had been reported. The test systems fall into two groups. One group includes all purely genetic tests that detect euploid mitotic segregants from heterozygous diploids and identify these either as products of malsegregation of chromosomes or as products of crossing-over (13 papers, several reviewed in detail previously; K?fer et al. (1982) and Scott et al. (1982)). The other group includes tests that treat haploid or diploid strains and detect aneuploids as unstable abnormally growing segregants which can be identified as specific disomics or trisomics by their characteristic phenotypes. In addition, such tests characterize abnormal segregants from heterozygous diploids by correlating phenotypes with patterns of genetic segregation in spontaneous euploid sectors. This analysis makes it possible to distinguish between induced primary aneuploidy of whole chromosomes and partial tri- or monosomy resulting from chromosome breakage and secondary spontaneous malsegregation (10 papers). Based on results of both types of tests, it is postulated that chemicals which cause increases of euploid malsegregants, but not of crossovers, normally induce aneuploids as primary products (as shown for 7 of the 14 cases). These include compounds which damage spindles or membranes (especially the well-known haploidizing agents) and generally are effective only when growing cells are exposed. (8 chemicals that may belong in this category could not be classified for certain, because information was insufficient.) On the other hand, chemicals which cause increases of all types of euploid segregants (11 cases), mostly induce drastic mutations and aberrations as primary effects and cause spontaneous malsegregation or crossing-over only as secondary events (as demonstrated for radiation-induced abnormals). In addition, a few chemicals were negative, because they increased only crossing-over or showed no increased segregation at all at concentrations which reduced survival or growth rate (9 cases). Recommendations are made for standardization of methods and protocols. New tester strains and specific procedures are outlined which should be useful for conclusive tests of chemicals that may induce aneuploidy.     

CENP-B is not critical for meiotic chromosome segregation in male mice.

Centromere protein B (CENP-B) is a constitutive protein that binds to a highly conserved 17bp motif located at most mammalian centromeres. To determine whether disruption of this gene affects chromosome segregation in male germ cells, we evaluated the frequencies of disomic and diploid sperm in CENP-B heterozygous and homozygous null mice using the mouse epididymal sperm aneuploidy (m-ESA) assay, a multicolor FISH method with probes for chromosomes X, Y and 8. The specificity and sensitivity of the m-ESA assay was demonstrated using Robertsonian (2.8) translocation heterozygotes as positive controls for sperm aneuploidy. Our results show that the frequencies of disomic and diploid sperm did not differ significantly between CENP-B heterozygous and homozygous null mice (P> or = 0.5) or from 129/Swiss isogenic mice (P> or = 0.5) and B6C3F1 mice (P> or = 0.2). These findings indicate that CENP-B does not have an essential role during chromosome segregation in male meiosis.     

Aneuploidy in mammalian somatic cells in vivo

Aneuploidy is an important potential source of human disease and of reproductive failure. Nevertheless, the ability of chemical agents to induce aneuploidy has been investigated only sporadically in intact (whole-animal) mammalian systems. A search of the available literature from the EMCT Aneuploidy File (for years 1970-1983) provided 112 papers that dealt with aneuploidy in mammalian somatic cells in vivo. 59 of these papers did not meet minimal criteria for analysis and were rejected from subsequent review. Of the remaining 53 papers that dealt with aneuploidy induction by chemical agents in mammalian somatic cells in vivo, only 3 (6%) contained data that were considered to be supported conclusively by adequate study designs, execution, and reporting. These 3 papers dealt with 2 chemicals, one of which, mercury, was negative for aneuploidy induction in humans, and the other, pyrimethamine, was positive in an experimental rodent study. The majority of papers (94%) were considered inconclusive for a variety of reasons. The most common reasons for calling a study inconclusive were (a) combining data on hyperploidy with those on hypoploidy and/or polyploidy, (b) an inadequate or unspecified number of animals and/or cells per animal scored per treatment group, and (c) poor data presentation such that animal-to-animal variability could not be assessed. Suggestions for protocol development are made, and the future directions of research into aneuploidy induction are discussed.     

Griseofulvin-induced aneuploidy and meiotic delay in male mouse germ cells: detected by using conventional cytogenetics and three-color FISH.

Griseofulvin (GF) was tested in male mouse germ cells for the induction of meiotic delay and aneuploidy. Starved mice were orally treated with 500, 1000 and 2000 mg/kg of GF in corn oil and testes were sampled 22 h later for meiotic delay analysis and chromosome counting in spermatocytes at the second meiotic metaphase (MMII). A dose-related increase in meiotic delay by dose-dependently arresting spermatocytes in first meiotic metaphase (MMI) or/and prolonging interkinesis was observed. Hyperhaploid MMII cells were not significantly increased. Sperm were sampled from the Caudae epididymes 22 days after GF-treatment of the males for three-color fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH). The frequencies of diploidies were 0.01-0.02% in sperm of the solvent control animals and increased dose-dependently to 0.03%, 0.068% and 0.091%, respectively, for 500, 1000 and 2000 mg/kg of GF. The frequencies of disomic sperm were increased significantly above the controls in all GF-treated groups but showed no dose response. The data for individual classes of disomic sperm indicated that MII was more sensitive than MI to GF-induced non-disjunction in male mice. A comparison of the present data from male mice and literature data from female mice suggests that mouse oocytes are more sensitive than mouse spermatocytes to GF-induced meiotic delay and aneuploidy.     

Human sperm aneuploidy after exposure to pesticides

This study examined the effect of paternal environmental exposure to pesticides on the frequency of aneuploidy in human sperm. To determine if the chromosome number in germ cells was altered by paternal exposure, multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis was utilized to measure aneuploidy frequencies in the sperm of 40 men (20 exposed, 20 controls). Samples were coded for "blind analysis" to eliminate scorer bias. Aneuploidy and diploidy frequencies were assessed for chromosomes 13, 21, X, and Y. A minimum of 10,000 sperm was scored per donor per chromosome probe with a total of 809,935 sperm scored. Hybridization efficiency was 99%. There were no significant differences in aneuploidy or diploidy frequencies between exposed and control groups, suggesting that the pesticides did not increase the risk of numerical chromosomal abnormalities in these men.     

CENP-B is not critical for meiotic chromosome segregation in male mice

Centromere protein B (CENP-B) is a constitutive protein that binds to a highly conserved 17 bp motif located at most mammalian centromeres. To determine whether disruption of this gene affects chromosome segregation in male germ cells, we evaluated the frequencies of disomic and diploid sperm in CENP-B heterozygous and homozygous null mice using the mouse epididymal sperm aneuploidy (m-ESA) assay, a multicolor FISH method with probes for chromosomes X, Y and 8. The specificity and sensitivity of the m-ESA assay was demonstrated using Robertsonian (2.8) translocation heterozygotes as positive controls for sperm aneuploidy. Our results show that the frequencies of disomic and diploid sperm did not differ significantly between CENP-B heterozygous and homozygous null mice (P≥0.5) or from 129/Swiss isogenic mice (P≥0.5) and B6C3F1 mice (P≥0.2). These findings indicate that CENP-B does not have an essential role during chromosome segregation in male meiosis.     

Aging and diethylstilbestrol-induced aneuploidy in male germ cells: a transgenic mouse model

The incidence of aneuploidy in male germ cells was evaluated by analyzing extra marker chromosome(s) signal(s) in round and/or hook spermatids of transgenic mice. Two types of transgenic mice were used as models. The inserted foreign DNA (λ-gt10LacZ shuttle vector and/or pSVc-myc plasmid) was located at the middle of the long arms of chromosome 2 (λ DNA) and/or chromosome 8 (c-myc). The number of marker chromosomes present could easily be detected after fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) in testicular cells. The frequency of spontaneous aneuploidy of chromosome 2 was similar in round spermatids of lambda and λ-myc mice. Differential involvement of chromosomes 2 and 8 was observed in both round and hook spermatids. The frequency of spontaneous aneuploidy in round spermatids was higher than that in hook spermatids. The frequency of aneuploidy of marker chromosomes was significantly higher in older mice (2 years old) than in younger ones. Diethylstilbestrol (DES)-induced aneuploidy was dose dependent, and was not influenced by the stage at which germ cells were treated with DES. These results demonstrate the usefulness of a transgenic mouse model for the study of aneuploidy in germ cells. Received: 5 August 1998 / Accepted: 27 August 1998     

In vitro and in vivo extrapolations of genotoxin exposures: consideration of factors which influence dose-response thresholds

The concept of a threshold of activity of a genotoxic agent is primarily based upon considerations of protective mechanisms and multiple cellular targets, which require inactivation before a toxic response is produced. In this paper, we have considered and evaluated the influences of compound metabolism, DNA lesion formation, mutation induction and sequence content, aneuploidy induction and the influence of repair enzymes upon genetic endpoints produced by both DNA reactive chemicals and by those chemicals which modify non-DNA cellular targets. Thresholds of activity have been evaluated by critical analysis of the published literature and original data analysing both the role of sequence context upon point mutation induction and DNA repair mechanisms upon the sensitivity of cultured cells to the induction of aneuploidy. In the case of DNA reactive chemicals, the presence of a threshold of chemical activity will be dependent upon cellular activities such as those of the Phase II enzymes reducing the activity of chemicals before lesion formation takes place and/or those of the DNA repair enzymes which reduce the proportion of DNA lesions which are processed into DNA sequence changes. Under such conditions, a given exposure of a DNA reactive chemical does not produce a linear or semi-linear increase in DNA lesions or in mutation frequency. However, even when these protective mechanisms are overwhelmed by the high exposures of genotoxic chemicals the biological effects of a genotoxin may be influenced by the sequence context of the gene under consideration. Here, we demonstrate that point mutations are detected at relatively higher frequencies in the non-coding introns compared with the coding exons. Many of the base changes detected in the exons do not produce amino acid changes in the proteins coded for by the genes being monitored for mutation induction. Both sequence context and the types of base changes induced may provide a "buffering" effect reducing the biological consequences of mutation induction. Spindle damaging chemicals, such as colcemid and vinblastine, induce aneuploidy by modifying the numbers of spindle fibres which regulate the segregation of chromosomes during mitosis and meiosis. The redundancy of spindle fibres in the dividing mammalian cell leads to the prediction that only chemical exposures which damage most, if not all, of the fibres will lead to the induction of polyploidy and/or aneuploidy. Such predicted thresholds of chemical activity can be observed when both chromosome loss and non-disjunction are measured in wild type cultures. However, we observed a substantial increase in sensitivity to aneugenic chemicals when measurements were made in primary cell cultures derived from xerodoma pigmentosum and trichothiodystrophy patients. Further studies are necessary to evaluate the consequences of the genetic background of tester strains upon the nature of the dose-response curve of aneugenic chemicals.     

A monochromosomal hybrid cell assay for evaluating the genotoxicity of environmental chemicals

The development and utilization of a monochromosomal hybrid cell assay for detecting aneuploidy and chromosomal aberrations are described. The monochromosomal hybrid cell lines were produced by a two-step process involving transfer of a marker bacterial gene to a human chromosome and then by integration of that human chromosome into a mouse complement of chromosomes through microcell fusion. For chemically induced aneuploidy, the segregation of a single human chromosome among mouse chromosomes is used as a cytogenetic marker. The genetic assay for aneuploidy is based on the ability of the cells to grow in a medium that selects for the loss of the human chromosome. The assay for clastogenicity is based on survival of the cells after treatment with the chemicals in medium that selects for retention of the human chromosome but loss of its segment containing diphtheria toxin locus. The assays greatly simplify the detection of chromosomal aberrations induced by environmental factors at low-dose levels.     

Aneuploid epididymal sperm detected in chromosomally normal and Robertsonian translocation-bearing mice using a new three-chromosome FISH method

We present a new method to detect epididymal sperm aneuploidy (ESA) in mice using simultaneous fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with DNA probes specific for mouse chromosomes X, Y and 8. The method was applied to Robertsonian (Rb) translocation (8.14) heterozygotes and homozygotes as well as the chromosomally normal B6C3F1. The sex ratios of sperm did not differ from the expected 1∶1 and the hybridization efficiencies were ≈99.7% for over 60 000 sperm analyzed. Mice heterozygous for Rb (8.14) produced about tenfold higher rates of sperm with chromosome 8 hyperhaploidy than did Rb (8.14) homozygotes or chromosomally normal mice, while frequencies of sperm with hyperhaploidies for chromosomes X and Y were unaffected in all three lines of mice. Hyperhaploid frequencies obtained with the ESA method were consistent with those of the previous testicular FISH method and were validated by published data obtained by conventional cytogenetic analyses (meiotic metaphase II and first cleavage). Thus, the mouse three-chromosome ESA assay together with the previously developed aneuploidy assay for human sperm constitute a promising pair of interspecific biomarkers for comparative studies of the genetic and physiologic mechanisms of the induction and persistence of aneuploidy in male germ cells. Edited by: T. Hassold     

Assessment of the potential germ cell mutagenicity of industrial and plant protection chemicals as part of an integrated study of genotoxicity in vitro and in vivo

An approach is described that enables the germ cell mutagenicity of chemicals to be assessed as part of an integrated assessment of genotoxic potential. It is recommended, first, that the genotoxicity of a chemical be defined by appropriate studies in vitro. This should involve use of the Salmonella mutation assay and an assay for the induction of chromosomal aberrations, but supplementary assays may be indicated in specific instances. If negative results are obtained from these 2 tests there is no need for the conduct of additional tests. Agents considered to be genotoxic in vitro should then be assessed for genotoxicity to rodents. This will usually involve the conduct of a bone marrow cytogenetic assay, and in the case of negative results, a genotoxicity test in an independent tissue. Agents found to be non-genotoxic in vivo are regarded as having no potential for germ cell mutagenicity. Agents found to be genotoxic in vivo may either be assumed to have potential as germ cell mutagens, or their status in this respect may be defined by appropriate germ cell mutagenicity studies. The basis of the approach, which is supported by the available experimental data, is that germ cell mutagens will be evident as somatic cell genotoxins in vivo, and that these will be detected as genotoxins in vitro given appropriate experimentation. The conduct of appropriate and adequate studies is suggested to be of more value than the conduct of a rigid set of prescribed tests.     

Monitoring meiosis in gametogenesis

Meiotic recombination is essential to hold homologous chromosomes together so that they can separate accurately in the formation of gametes, thus preventing fetal loss due to aneuploidy. How do germ cells know when they have finished genetic recombination and that it is time to enter the meiotic division phase, and what are the elements that signal the onset of the division phase? During spermatogenesis there is no arrest at the end of meiotic prophase (as there is in oogenesis) and signals for progress into the meiotic division phase may be closely related to events of chromosome pairing and recombination. Methods for culture of male germ cells have been used to show that spermatocytes become competent for some aspects of the division phase by the early pachytene stage, long before they would normally enter division. Evidence suggests that establishment of homologous chromosome pairing is one aspect of acquiring competence. Activation of the cell cycle regulator MPF also appears to be important, and there is a requirement for activity of topoisomerase II in order for spermatocytes to exit prophase and enter the meiotic division phase. Understanding how these molecular entities tie into monitoring the completion of recombination and meiotic progress will be instructive about important gametic safeguards preventing aberrant chromosome segregation and resultant aneuploidy.