Pollen-based biome reconstructions for the past 450 000 yr from the Funza-2 core,Colombia: comparisons with model-based vegetation reconstructions

The 586-m Funza-2 sequence from the high plain of Bogotá, Colombia has provided one of the longest pollen-based vegetation reconstructions in the world. Affinity scores to seven biomes are compared to the record of CO₂ fluctuation from the Vostok ice core for the period spanning from approximately 25 000 to 450 000 yr before present (BP). Results are compared to output from the BIOME-3 vegetation model run under different environmental scenarios at regional and local scales. The model is run with temperature and precipitation reductions, relative to the present values, of up to −10°C and −700 mm yr⁻¹ respectively. For this particular investigation we are interested in the role of CO₂ as a forcer of vegetation change; we run the model with concentrations of atmospheric CO₂ ([CO₂]_atm.) within the range of 170 to 340 ppmV. During glacial periods, the cool grass/shrubland biome is highly dominant, less so during interglacial periods when the cool evergreen and cool mixed forest biomes become co-dominant. In addition to this climate-driven altitudinal oscillation of the vegetation, there is also a signal that indicates longer term evolution of the vegetation. The cool grass/shrubland and cool evergreen and cool mixed forest biomes become co-dominant for the first time over the 450 000-yr record at approximately 170 000 yr BP, become completely anti-phase (during a period of extreme low [CO₂]_atm.) and then become co-dominant from approximately 120 000 yr BP until the core top, just prior to the last glacial maximum. The model results for the Funza area indicate that changes in [CO₂]_atm., temperature and precipitation are inter-linked by the vegetation response. A shift of 5.5°C is required to lower the cool grass/shrubland biome to altitudes about the Funza catchment where the Andean forest biome dominant. At low [CO₂]_atm. concentrations, particularly below 180 ppmV, the composition of the high latitudinal tropical vegetation about the Funza catchment changed. It is suggested that this low [CO₂]_atm., combined with a period when the climate was characterised by extreme cooling and drying, caused a readjustment of the tropical high altitudinal vegetation zonation and the formation of plant communities that are presently recorded.     

Climate and CO2 controls on global vegetation distribution at the last glacial maximum: analysis based on palaeovegetation data, biome modelling and palaeoclimate simulations

The global vegetation response to climate and atmospheric CO₂ changes between the last glacial maximum and recent times is examined using an equilibrium vegetation model (BIOME4), driven by output from 17 climate simulations from the Palaeoclimate Modelling Intercomparison Project. Features common to all of the simulations include expansion of treeless vegetation in high northern latitudes; southward displacement and fragmentation of boreal and temperate forests; and expansion of drought‐tolerant biomes in the tropics. These features are broadly consistent with pollen‐based reconstructions of vegetation distribution at the last glacial maximum. Glacial vegetation in high latitudes reflects cold and dry conditions due to the low CO₂ concentration and the presence of large continental ice sheets. The extent of drought‐tolerant vegetation in tropical and subtropical latitudes reflects a generally drier low‐latitude climate. Comparisons of the observations with BIOME4 simulations, with and without consideration of the direct physiological effect of CO₂ concentration on C₃ photosynthesis, suggest an important additional role of low CO₂ concentration in restricting the extent of forests, especially in the tropics. Global forest cover was overestimated by all models when climate change alone was used to drive BIOME4, and estimated more accurately when physiological effects of CO₂ concentration were included. This result suggests that both CO₂ effects and climate effects were important in determining glacial‐interglacial changes in vegetation. More realistic simulations of glacial vegetation and climate will need to take into account the feedback effects of these structural and physiological changes on the climate.     

The influence of vegetation activity on the Dole effect and its implications for changes in biospheric productivity in the mid-Holocene

The Dole effect is defined as the difference between the oxygen isotope composition of atmospheric oxygen and seawater (currently 23.5 parts per thousand) and reflects the balance between processes and fractionations associated with O₂ consumption and production by the terrestrial and marine biospheres. Isotopic records from ice cores and ocean sediments provide a means of assessing variations in the Dole effect during the late Quaternary but the biogeochemical interpretation of these changes is limited because we are currently unable to account adequately for vegetation effects on the global isotopic balance of atmospheric O₂. Here, I show that the previously unquantified influence of canopy transpiration on the isotopic composition of atmospheric water vapour now closes the mass balance budget for the isotopes of atmospheric O₂ under the current climate. Using this new finding, the effects of vegetation on the Dole effect have been assessed at the global scale for the mid-Holocene (6000 years ago). The results indicate that the small reduction in the Dole effect in the mid-Holocene represented a fall in the ratio of terrestrial to marine gross primary production from 1.8 to 1.0. Improved understanding of the environmental and physiological processes controlling the oxygen isotopic composition of plants and their feedback on the isotopes of atmospheric O₂ offers considerable promise in quantitatively accounting for the changes in biospheric productivity associated with the Dole effect over glacial–interglacial cycles. In addition, such work should provide an as yet unexploited basis for testing the results of climate models against the oxygen isotope composition of Quaternary plant fossils.     

The variation of upper ocean structure and paleoproductivity in the Kuroshio source region during the last 200 kyr

A core from the source region of the Kuroshio warm current (east of the Luzon Island) was analyzed using several proxies in order to study the variability of the Western Pacific Warm Pool (WPWP) during the last two glacial–interglacial cycles. Primary productivity (PP) variations were deduced from variations in the coccolith flora. Primary productivity was higher during glacial periods (the end of Marine Isotope Stage [MIS] 3, some periods in MIS 2 and 6), and decreased during interglacial periods (MIS 7, MIS 5e and probably MIS 5c–5d), with the lowest PP in MIS 5e. Variations in the δ¹³C difference in benthic and bulk carbonate, thus in the vertical gradient of δ¹³C in dissolved inorganic carbon (Δδ¹³C_{C. wuellerstorfi–N. dutertrei} and Δδ¹³C_{C. wuellerstorfi–coccolith}) coincided with the PP changes, showing that export productivity was low during interglacial periods (MIS 7, MIS 5e and Holocene) and high during glacial periods (MIS 6, probably MIS 5c–5d, late MIS 4 and late MIS 3). Comparison of foraminiferal carbonate dissolution indicators and PP changes reveals that nannofossil assemblage in core Ph05-5 is not sensitive to carbonate dissolution intensity. The depth of the thermocline (DOT) was estimated from planktonic forminiferal assemblages, and was relatively greater during interglacial periods (MIS 7, MIS 5e, probably MIS 5c and Holocene) than during glacials (middle MIS 6, probably MIS 5b and 5d, some periods in MIS 4, MIS 3 and MIS 2). Good coherence between the paleoproductivity records and the DOT suggests that the DOT changes could be the primary control factor in changes of paleoproductivity, and the glacial high productivity in the Kuroshio source region could be associated with a global increase of nutrient concentration in the intermediate waters that upwelled into the photic zone. The low CO₂ values derived for intervals of high productivity and a relatively shallow DOT suggest that the changes in biological productivity and DOT in the equatorial Pacific could have modified atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. High Sea Surface Temperatures (SSTs) during the warm MIS 5e in combination with intensified monsoonal rain fall could have resulted in a more intense stratification of the upper waters, resulting in low nutrient supply to the surface waters and a resulting decrease in productivity.     

Photosynthetic acclimation and resource use by the C3 and C4 subspecies of Alloteropsis semialata in low CO2 atmospheres

During the past 25 Myr, partial pressures of atmospheric CO₂ (C_a) imposed a greater limitation on C₃ than C₄ photosynthesis. This could have important downstream consequences for plant nitrogen economy and biomass allocation. Here, we report the first phylogenetically controlled comparison of the integrated effects of subambient C_a on photosynthesis, growth and nitrogen allocation patterns, comparing the C₃ and C₄ subspecies of Alloteropsis semialata. Plant size decreased more in the C₃ than C₄ subspecies at low C_a, but nitrogen pool sizes were unchanged, and nitrogen concentrations increased across all plant partitions. The C_3, but not C₄ subspecies, preferentially allocated biomass to leaves and increased specific leaf area at low C_a. In the C₃ subspecies, increased leaf nitrogen was linked to photosynthetic acclimation at the interglacial C_a, mediated via higher photosynthetic capacity combined with greater stomatal conductance. Glacial C_a further increased the biochemical acclimation and nitrogen concentrations in the C₃ subspecies, but these were insufficient to maintain photosynthetic rates. In contrast, the C₄ subspecies maintained photosynthetic rates, nitrogen‐ and water‐use efficiencies and plant biomass at interglacial and glacial C_a with minimal physiological adjustment. At low C_a, the C₄ carbon‐concentrating mechanism therefore offered a significant advantage over the C₃ type for carbon acquisition at the whole‐plant scale, apparently mediated via nitrogen economy and water loss. A limiting nutrient supply damped the biomass responses to C_a and increased the C₄ advantage across all C_a treatments. Findings highlight the importance of considering leaf responses in the context of the whole plant, and show that carbon limitation may be offset at the expense of greater plant demand for soil resources such as nitrogen and water. Results show that the combined effects of low CO₂ and resource limitation benefit C₄ plants over C₃ plants in glacial–interglacial environments, but that this advantage is lessened under anthropogenic conditions.     

C4 photosynthesis, atmospheric CO2, and climate

The objectives of this synthesis are (1) to review the factors that influence the ecological, geographical, and palaeoecological distributions of plants possessing C₄ photosynthesis and (2) to propose a hypothesis/model to explain both the distribution of C₄ plants with respect to temperature and CO₂ and why C₄ photosynthesis is relatively uncommon in dicotyledonous plants (hereafter dicots), especially in comparison with its widespread distribution in monocotyledonous species (hereafter monocots). Our goal is to stimulate discussion of the factors controlling distributions of C₄ plants today, historically, and under future elevated CO₂ environments. Understanding the distributions of C₃/C₄ plants impacts not only primary productivity, but also the distribution, evolution, and migration of both invertebrates and vertebrates that graze on these plants. Sixteen separate studies all indicate that the current distributions of C₄ monocots are tightly correlated with temperature: elevated temperatures during the growing season favor C₄ monocots. In contrast, the seven studies on C₄ dicot distributions suggest that a different environmental parameter, such as aridity (combination of temperature and evaporative potential), more closely describes their distributions. Differences in the temperature dependence of the quantum yield for CO₂ uptake (light-use efficiency) of C₃ and C₄ species relate well to observed plant distributions and light-use efficiency is the only mechanism that has been proposed to explain distributional differences in C₃/C₄ monocots. Modeling of C₃ and C₄ light-use efficiencies under different combinations of atmospheric CO₂ and temperature predicts that C₄-dominated ecosystems should not have expanded until atmospheric CO₂ concentrations reached the lower levels that are thought to have existed beginning near the end of the Miocene. At that time, palaeocarbonate and fossil data indicate a simultaneous, global expansion of C₄-dominated grasslands. The C₄ monocots generally have a higher quantum yield than C₄ dicots and it is proposed that leaf venation patterns play a role in increasing the light-use efficiency of most C₄ monocots. The reduced quantum yield of most C₄ dicots is consistent with their rarity, and it is suggested that C₄ dicots may not have been selected until CO₂ concentrations reached their lowest levels during glacial maxima in the Quaternary. Given the intrinsic light-use efficiency advantage of C₄ monocots, C₄ dicots may have been limited in their distributions to the warmest ecosystems, saline ecosystems, and/or to highly disturbed ecosystems. All C₄ plants have a significant advantage over C₃ plants under low atmospheric CO₂ conditions and are predicted to have expanded significantly on a global scale during full-glacial periods, especially in tropical regions. Bog and lake sediment cores as well as pedogenic carbonates support the hypothesis that C₄ ecosystems were more extensive during the last glacial maximum and then decreased in abundance following deglaciation as atmospheric CO₂ levels increased. Received: 12 February 1997 / Accepted: 20 June 1997     

High frequency palaeoceanographic changes during the past 140?000 yr recorded by the organic matter in sediments of the Iberian Margin

Biogenic records of the marine palaeoproductivity (carbonates, organic carbon, and C₃₇ alkenones) and the molecular stratigraphy of past sea surface temperatures (SSTs; U₃₇^K′) were studied at high resolution in two cores of the Iberian Margin. The comparison of these records indicates that the oceanographic conditions switched abruptly during the past 160 kyr between three kinds of regimes. A first regime with high (17-22°C) SST and low productivity typifies the interglacial periods, marine isotopic stages (MIS) 5 and 1. Several periods during MIS 6, 2, and the terminations II and I are characterised by about 4-5°C colder SST and a higher organic matter accumulation, both of which define the second regime. This anticorrelation between SST and marine productivity suggests that these variations are related to the intensity of the coastal upwelling. By contrast with this upwelling behaviour, extremely low biological productivity and very cold SST (6-12°C) occurred during short phases of glacial MIS 6, 4, and 2, and as abrupt events (≈1 kyr or less) during MIS 3. The three oceanographic regimes are consistent with micropalaeontological changes in the same cores based on foraminifera and diatoms.The general trend of these hydrologic changes follows the long-term glacial/interglacial cycle, but the millennium scale variability is clearly related to Heinrich events and Dansgaard-Oeschger cycles. Strengthening of the upwelling corresponds probably to an intensification of the subtropical atmospheric circulation over the North Atlantic which was influenced by the presence of continental ice sheets. However, extreme glacial conditions due to massive discharges of icebergs interrupted the upwelling. Interestingly, both terminations II and I coincided with strong but transient intensification of the upwelling.     

13C discrimination by fossil leaves during the late-glacial climate oscillation 12-10 ka BP: measurements and physiological controls

The late-glacial climatic oscillation, 12-10 ka BP, is characterised in ice core oxygen isotope profiles by a rapid and abrupt return to glacial climate. Recent work has shown that associated with this cooling was a drop in atmospheric CO₂ concentration of ca. 50 ppm. In this paper, the impact of these environmental changes on ¹³C discrimination is reported, based on measurements made on a continuous sequence of fossil Salix herbacea leaves from a single site. The plant responses were interpreted using an integrated model of stomatal conductance, CO₂ assimilation and intercellular CO₂ concentration, influenced by external environmental factors. According to the model, temperature exerts a marked influence on ¹³C discrimination by leaves and the pattern of ¹³C changes recorded by the fossil leaves is consistent with other palaeotemperature curves for 12-10 ka BP, particularly the deuterium isotope record from Alaskan Salix woods, which generally reflects ocean temperatures. The gas exchange model correctly accounts for these changes and so permits the reconstruction of ancient rates of leaf CO₂ uptake and loss of water vapour in response to the abrupt late-glacial changes in global climate and CO₂. The approach provides the required physiological underpinning for extracting quantitative estimates of past temperatures and for contributing an ecophysiological explanation for changes in ¹³C discrimination in the fossil record.     

Oceanic sinks for atmospheric CO2

There is approximately 50 times more inorganic carbon in the global ocean than in the atmosphere. On time scales of decades to millions of years, the interaction between these two geophysical fluids determines atmospheric CO₂ levels. During glacial periods, for example, the ocean serves as the major sink for atmospheric CO₂, while during glacial–interglacial transitions, it is a source of CO₂ to the atmosphere. The mechanisms responsible for determining the sign of the net exchange of CO₂ between the ocean and the atmosphere remain unresolved. There is evidence that during glacial periods, phytoplankton primary productivity increased, leading to an enhanced sedimentation of particulate organic carbon into the ocean interior. The stimulation of primary production in glacial episodes can be correlated with increased inputs of nutrients limiting productivity, especially aeolian iron. Iron directly enhances primary production in high nutrient (nitrate and phosphate) regions of the ocean, of which the Southern Ocean is the most important. This trace element can also enhance nitrogen fixation, and thereby indirectly stimulate primary production throughout the low nutrient regions of the central ocean basins. While the export flux of organic carbon to the ocean interior was enhanced during glacial periods, this process does not fully account for the sequestration of atmospheric CO₂. Heterotrophic oxidation of the newly formed organic carbon, forming weak acids, would have hydrolyzed CaCO₃ in the sediments, increasing thereby oceanic alkalinity which, in turn, would have promoted the drawdown of atmospheric CO₂. This latter mechanism is consistent with the stable carbon isotope pattern derived from air trapped in ice cores. The oceans have also played a major role as a sink for up to 30% of the anthropogenic CO₂ produced during the industrial revolution. In large part this is due to CO₂ solution in the surface ocean; however, some, poorly quantified fraction is a result of increased new production due to anthropogenic inputs of combined N, P and Fe. Based on ‘circulation as usual’, models predict that future anthropogenic CO₂ inputs to the atmosphere will, in part, continue to be sequestered in the ocean. Human intervention (large-scale Fe fertilization; direct CO₂ burial in the deep ocean) could increase carbon sequestration in the oceans, but could also result in unpredicted environmental perturbations. Changes in the oceanic thermohaline circulation as a result of global climate change would greatly alter the predictions of C sequestration that are possible on a ‘circulation as usual’ basis.     

Winter-spring precipitation as the principal control on predominance of C3 plants in Central Asia over the past 1.77 Myr: Evidence from δC of loess organic matter in Tajikistan

Although changes in atmospheric CO₂ levels are thought to be the major factor driving long-term C₃/C₄ vegetation evolution, recent studies tend to emphasize the effect of regional climate conditions on C₃/C₄ variations. The middle latitudes (30-45°), in which C₃/C₄ plants are highly sensitive to environmental changes, provide an optimal basis for the investigation of the relative impacts of climate and pCO₂ on shifts in C₃/C₄ cover. In order to assess the factors controlling these shifts as well as the complex interactions between environmental factors, the carbon isotopic composition of bulk organic matter from the Chashmanigar loess section (southern Tajikistan) was measured for the past 1.77 Myr. In general, the δ¹³C record shows mostly negative values throughout the sequence, almost all δ¹³C values falling between − 23‰ and − 26‰, indicating a predominance of C₃ plants in Central Asia over this time period, despite the presence of numerous glacial-interglacial cycles. From 0.85 Myr to the present, the δ¹³C values become increasingly positive, reflecting a growing C₄ signal. However, this C₄ component is not detectable prior to 0.25 Myr, after which minor peaks are evident at ∼ 228, ∼ 171 and ∼ 18 kyr. The δ¹³C record from Chashmanigar indicates that winter-spring precipitation, i.e., Mediterranean climatic conditions, have characterized Central Asia throughout the past 1.77 Myr, leading to the predominance of C₃ vegetation. In the context of glacial-interglacial-scale changes in atmospheric CO₂, therefore, it is climate rather than pCO₂ that controls C₃/C₄ variations in Asia’s middle latitudes. The gradual increase in the C₄ component since 0.85 Myr, especially the notable peaks after 0.25 Myr, may have been caused by an increase in summer precipitation due to an enhanced southward shift of the climate zones.     

Physiological and Growth Responses of C3 and C4 Plants to Reduced Temperature When Grown at Low CO2 of the Last Ice Age

During the last Ice age, CO2 concentration ([CO2]) was 180-200 μmol/mol compared with the modern value of 380 μmol/mol,and global temperatures were ～8 ℃ cooler. Relatively little is known about the responses of C3 and C4 species to longterm exposure to glacial conditions. Here Abutilon theophrasti Medik. (C3) and Amaranthus retroflexus L. (C4) were grown at 200 μmol/mol CO2 with current (30/24 ℃) and glacial (22/16 ℃) temperatures for 22 d. Overall, the C4 species exhibited a large growth advantage over the C3 species at low [CO2]. However, this advantage was reduced at low temperature, where the C4 species produced 5× the total mass of the C3 species versus 14× at the high temperature.This difference was due to a reduction In C4 growth at low temperature, since the C3 species exhibited similar growth between temperatures. Physiological differences between temperatures were not detected for either species, although photorespirationlnet photosynthesis was reduced in the C3 species grown at low temperature, suggesting evidence of improved carbon balance at this treatment. This system suggests that C4 species had a growth advantage over C3 species during low [CO2] of the last ice age, although concurrent reductions in temperatures may have reduced this advantage.     

Yield responses of wild C3 and C4 crop progenitors to subambient CO2: a test for the role of CO2 limitation in the origin of agriculture

Limitation of plant productivity by the low partial pressure of atmospheric CO₂ (C_a) experienced during the last glacial period is hypothesized to have been an important constraint on the origins of agriculture. In support of this hypothesis, previous work has shown that glacial C_a limits vegetative growth in the wild progenitors of both C₃ and C₄ founder crops. Here, we present data showing that glacial C_a also reduces grain yield in both crop types. We grew four wild progenitors of C₃ (einkorn wheat and barley) and C₄ crops (foxtail and broomcorn millets) at glacial and postglacial C_a, measuring grain yield and the morphological and physiological components contributing to these yield changes. The C₃ species showed a significant increase in unthreshed grain yield of ~50% with the glacial to postglacial increase in C_a, which matched the stimulation of photosynthesis, suggesting that increases in photosynthesis are directly translated into yield at subambient levels of C_a. Increased yield was controlled by a higher rate of tillering, leading to a larger number of tillers bearing fertile spikes, and increases in seed number and size. The C₄ species showed smaller, but significant, increases in grain yield of 10–15%, arising from larger seed numbers and sizes. Photosynthesis was enhanced by C_a in only one C₄ species and the effect diminished during development, suggesting that an indirect mechanism mediated by plant water relations could also be playing a role in the yield increase. Interestingly, the C₄ species at glacial C_a showed some evidence that photosynthetic capacity was upregulated to enhance carbon capture. Development under glacial C_a also impacted negatively on the subsequent germination and viability of seeds. These results suggest that the grain production of both C₃ and C₄ crop progenitors was limited by the atmospheric conditions of the last glacial period, with important implications for the origins of agriculture.     

Elevated CO2 affects porewater chemistry in a brackish marsh

As atmospheric CO₂ concentrations continue to rise and impact plant communities, concomitant shifts in belowground microbial processes are likely, but poorly understood. We measured monthly porewater concentrations of sulfate, sulfide, methane (CH₄), dissolved inorganic carbon and dissolved organic carbon over a 5-year period in a brackish marsh. Samples were collected using porewater wells (i.e., sippers) in a Schoenoplectus americanus-dominated (C₃ sedge) community, a Spartina patens-dominated (C₄ grass) community and a mixed (C₃ and C₄) community within the marsh. Plant communities were exposed to ambient and elevated (ambient + 340 ppm) CO₂ levels for 15 years prior to porewater sampling, and the treatments continued over the course of our sampling. Sulfate reduction was stimulated by elevated CO₂ in the C₃-dominated community, but not in the C₄-dominated community. Elevated CO₂ also resulted in higher porewater concentrations of CH₄ and dissolved organic carbon in the C₃-dominated system, though inhibition of CH₄ production by sulfate reduction appears to temper the porewater CH₄ response. These patterns mirror the typical divergent responses of C₃ and C₄ plants to elevated CO₂ seen in this ecosystem. Porewater concentrations of nitrogen (as ammonium) and phosphorus did not decrease despite increased plant biomass in the C₃-dominated community, suggesting nutrients do not strongly limit the sustained vegetation response to elevated CO₂. Overall, our data demonstrate that elevated CO₂ drives changes in porewater chemistry and suggest that increased plant productivity likely stimulates microbial decomposition through increases in dissolved organic carbon availability.     

Simulated effects of low atmospheric CO2 on structure and composition of North American vegetation at the Last Glacial Maximum

1. Physiological experiments have indicated that the lower CO₂ levels of the last glaciation (200 μmol mol^?1) probably reduced plant water-use efficiency (WUE) and that they combined with increased aridity and colder temperatures to alter vegetation structure and composition at the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM). 2. The effects of low CO₂ on vegetation structure were investigated using BIOME3 simulations of leaf area index (LAI), and a two-by-two factorial experimental design (modern/LGM CO₂, modern/LGM climate).3. Using BIOME3, and a combination of lowered CO₂ and simulated LGM climate (from the NCAR-CCM1 model), results in the introduction of additional xeric vegetation types between open woodland and closed-canopy forest along a latitudinal gradient in eastern North America.4. The simulated LAI of LGM vegetation was 25–60% lower in many regions of central and eastern United States relative to modern climate, indicating that glacial vegetation was much more open than today.5. Comparison of factorial simulations show that low atmospheric CO₂ has the potential to alter vegetation structure (LAI) to a greater extent than LGM climate.6. If the magnitude of LAI reductions simulated for glacial North America were global, then low atmospheric CO₂ may have promoted atmospheric warming and increased aridity, through alteration of rates of water and heat exchange with the atmosphere.     

Controlling for anthropogenically induced atmospheric variation in stable carbon isotope studies

Increased use of stable isotope analysis to examine food-web dynamics, migration, transfer of nutrients, and behavior will likely result in expansion of stable isotope studies investigating human-induced global changes. Recent elevation of atmospheric CO₂ concentration, related primarily to fossil fuel combustion, has reduced atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C (¹³C/¹²C), and this change in isotopic baseline has, in turn, reduced plant and animal tissue δ¹³C of terrestrial and aquatic organisms. Such depletion in CO₂ δ¹³C and its effects on tissue δ¹³C may introduce bias into δ¹³C investigations, and if this variation is not controlled, may confound interpretation of results obtained from tissue samples collected over a temporal span. To control for this source of variation, we used a high-precision record of atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C from ice cores and direct atmospheric measurements to model modern change in CO₂ δ¹³C. From this model, we estimated a correction factor that controls for atmospheric change; this correction reduces bias associated with changes in atmospheric isotopic baseline and facilitates comparison of tissue δ¹³C collected over multiple years. To exemplify the importance of accounting for atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C depletion, we applied the correction to a dataset of collagen δ¹³C obtained from mountain lion (Puma concolor) bone samples collected in California between 1893 and 1995. Before correction, in three of four ecoregions collagen δ¹³C decreased significantly concurrent with depletion of atmospheric CO₂ δ¹³C (n ≥ 32, P ≤ 0.01). Application of the correction to collagen δ¹³C data removed trends from regions demonstrating significant declines, and measurement error associated with the correction did not add substantial variation to adjusted estimates. Controlling for long-term atmospheric variation and correcting tissue samples for changes in isotopic baseline facilitate analysis of samples that span a large temporal range.     

Effects of RuBisCO and CO2 concentration on cyanobacterial growth and carbon isotope fractionation

Carbon isotope biosignatures preserved in the Precambrian geologic record are primarily interpreted to reflect ancient cyanobacterial carbon fixation catalyzed by Form I RuBisCO enzymes. The average range of isotopic biosignatures generally follows that produced by extant cyanobacteria. However, this observation is difficult to reconcile with several environmental (e.g., temperature, pH, and CO₂ concentrations), molecular, and physiological factors that likely would have differed during the Precambrian and can produce fractionation variability in contemporary organisms that meets or exceeds that observed in the geologic record. To test a specific range of genetic and environmental factors that may impact ancient carbon isotope biosignatures, we engineered a mutant strain of the model cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942 that overexpresses RuBisCO across varying atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. We hypothesized that changes in RuBisCO expression would impact the net rates of intracellular CO₂ fixation versus CO₂ supply, and thus whole-cell carbon isotope discrimination. In particular, we investigated the impacts of RuBisCO overexpression under changing CO₂ concentrations on both carbon isotope biosignatures and cyanobacterial physiology, including cell growth and oxygen evolution rates. We found that an increased pool of active RuBisCO does not significantly affect the ¹³C/¹²C isotopic discrimination (ε_p) at all tested CO₂ concentrations, yielding ε_p of ≈ 23‰ for both wild-type and mutant strains at elevated CO₂. We therefore suggest that expected variation in cyanobacterial RuBisCO expression patterns should not confound carbon isotope biosignature interpretation. A deeper understanding of environmental, evolutionary, and intracellular factors that impact cyanobacterial physiology and isotope discrimination is crucial for reconciling microbially driven carbon biosignatures with those preserved in the geologic record.     

Increasing CO2 and plant-plant interactions: effects on natural vegetation

Plant species and functional groups of species show marked differences in photosynthesis and growth in relation to rising atmospheric CO₂ concentrations through the range of the 30 % increase of the recent past and the 100 % increase since the last glaciation. A large shift was found in the compositional mix of 26 species of C₃'s and 17 species of C₄'s grown from a native soil seed bank in a competitive mode along a CO₂ gradient that approximated the CO₂ increase of the past 150 years and before. The biomass of C₃'s increased from near zero to 50 % of the total while that of the C₄'s was reduced 25 % as CO₂ levels approached current ambient. The proposition that acclimation to rising CO₂ will largely negate the fertilization effect of higher CO₂ levels on C₃'s is not supported. No signs of photosynthetic acclimation were evident forAvena sativa, Prosopis glandulosa, andSchizachyrium scoparium plants grown in subambient CO₂. The effects of changing CO₂ levels on vegetation since the last glaciation are thought to have been at least as great, if not greater, than those which should be expected for a doubling of current CO₂ levels. Atmospheric CO₂ concentrations below 200 ppm are thought to have been instrumental in the rise of the C₄ grasslands of North America and other extensive C₄ grasslands and savannas of the world. Dramatic invasion of these areas by woody C₃ species are accompanying the historical increase in atmospheric CO₂ concentration now in progress.     

C3 plants enhance rates of photosynthesis by reassimilating photorespired and respired CO2

Photosynthetic carbon gain in plants using the C₃ photosynthetic pathway is substantially inhibited by photorespiration in warm environments, particularly in atmospheres with low CO₂ concentrations. Unlike C₄ plants, C₃ plants are thought to lack any mechanism to compensate for the loss of photosynthetic productivity caused by photorespiration. Here, for the first time, we demonstrate that the C₃ plants rice and wheat employ a specific mechanism to trap and reassimilate photorespired CO₂. A continuous layer of chloroplasts covering the portion of the mesophyll cell periphery that is exposed to the intercellular air space creates a diffusion barrier for CO₂ exiting the cell. This facilitates the capture and reassimilation of photorespired CO₂ in the chloroplast stroma. In both species, 24–38% of photorespired and respired CO₂ were reassimilated within the cell, thereby boosting photosynthesis by 8–11% at ambient atmospheric CO₂ concentration and 17–33% at a CO₂ concentration of 200 µmol mol^?1. Widespread use of this mechanism in tropical and subtropical C₃ plants could explain why the diversity of the world's C₃ flora, and dominance of terrestrial net primary productivity, was maintained during the Pleistocene, when atmospheric CO₂ concentrations fell below 200 µmol mol^?1.     

Effects of climate and atmospheric CO2 partial pressure on the global distribution of C4 grasses: present, past, and future

C₄ photosynthetic physiologies exhibit fundamentally different responses to temperature and atmospheric CO₂ partial pressures (pCO₂) compared to the evolutionarily more primitive C₃ type. All else being equal, C₄ plants tend to be favored over C₃ plants in warm humid climates and, conversely, C₃ plants tend to be favored over C₄ plants in cool climates. Empirical observations supported by a photosynthesis model predict the existence of a climatological crossover temperature above which C₄ species have a carbon gain advantage and below which C₃ species are favored. Model calculations and analysis of current plant distribution suggest that this pCO₂-dependent crossover temperature is approximated by a mean temperature of 22°C for the warmest month at the current pCO₂ (35 Pa). In addition to favorable temperatures, C₄ plants require sufficient precipitation during the warm growing season. C₄ plants which are predominantly graminoids of short stature can be competitively excluded by trees (nearly all C₃ plants) – regardless of the photosynthetic superiority of the C₄ pathway – in regions otherwise favorable for C₄. To construct global maps of the distribution of C₄ grasses for current, past and future climate scenarios, we make use of climatological data sets which provide estimates of the mean monthly temperature to classify the globe into areas which should favor C₄ photosynthesis during at least 1 month of the year. This area is further screened by excluding areas where precipitation is <25 mm per month during the warm season and by selecting areas classified as grasslands (i.e., excluding areas dominated by woody vegetation) according to a global vegetation map. Using this approach, grasslands of the world are designated as C₃, C₄, and mixed under current climate and pCO₂. Published floristic studies were used to test the accuracy of these predictions in many regions of the world, and agreement with observations was generally good. We then make use of this protocol to examine changes in the global abundance of C₄ grasses in the past and the future using plausible estimates for the climates and pCO₂. When pCO₂ is lowered to pre-industrial levels, C₄ grasses expanded their range into large areas now classified as C₃ grasslands, especially in North America and Eurasia. During the last glacial maximum (∼18 ka BP) when the climate was cooler and pCO₂ was about 20 Pa, our analysis predicts substantial expansion of C₄ vegetation – particularly in Asia, despite cooler temperatures. Continued use of fossil fuels is expected to result in double the current pCO₂ by sometime in the next century, with some associated climate warming. Our analysis predicts a substantial reduction in the area of C₄ grasses under these conditions. These reductions from the past and into the future are based on greater stimulation of C₃ photosynthetic efficiency by higher pCO₂ than inhibition by higher temperatures. The predictions are testable through large-scale controlled growth studies and analysis of stable isotopes and other data from regions where large changes are predicted to have occurred. Received: 3 July 1997 / Accepted: 3 December 1997     

Elevation‐induced climate change as a dominant factor causing the late Miocene C4 plant expansion in the Himalayan foreland

During the late Miocene, a dramatic global expansion of C₄ plant distribution occurred with broad spatial and temporal variations. Although the event is well documented, whether subsequent expansions were caused by a decreased atmospheric CO₂ concentration or climate change is a contentious issue. In this study, we used an improved inverse vegetation modeling approach that accounts for the physiological responses of C₃ and C₄ plants to quantitatively reconstruct the paleoclimate in the Siwalik of Nepal based on pollen and carbon isotope data. We also studied the sensitivity of the C₃ and C₄ plants to changes in the climate and the atmospheric CO₂ concentration. We suggest that the expansion of the C₄ plant distribution during the late Miocene may have been primarily triggered by regional aridification and temperature increases. The expansion was unlikely caused by reduced CO₂ levels alone. Our findings suggest that this abrupt ecological shift mainly resulted from climate changes related to the decreased elevation of the Himalayan foreland.