Synonymous Codon Usage, Accuracy of Translation, and Gene Length in Caenorhabditis elegans

In many unicellular organisms, invertebrates, and plants, synonymous codon usage biases result from a coadaptation between codon usage and tRNAs abundance to optimize the efficiency of protein synthesis. However, it remains unclear whether natural selection acts at the level of the speed or the accuracy of mRNAs translation. Here we show that codon usage can improve the fidelity of protein synthesis in multicellular species. As predicted by the model of selection for translational accuracy, we find that the frequency of codons optimal for translation is significantly higher at codons encoding for conserved amino acids than at codons encoding for nonconserved amino acids in 548 genes compared between Caenorhabditis elegans and Homo sapiens. Although this model predicts that codon bias correlates positively with gene length, a negative correlation between codon bias and gene length has been observed in eukaryotes. This suggests that selection for fidelity of protein synthesis is not the main factor responsible for codon biases. The relationship between codon bias and gene length remains unexplained. Exploring the differences in gene expression process in eukaryotes and prokaryotes should provide new insights to understand this key question of codon usage. Received: 18 June 2000 / Accepted: 10 November 2000     

The Nonrandom Location of Synonymous Codons Suggests That Reading Frame-Independent Forces Have Patterned Codon Preferences

Biased codon usage is common in eukaryotic and prokaryotic genes. Evidence from Escherichia, Saccharomyces, and Drosophila indicates that it favors translational efficiency and accuracy. However, to date no functional advantages have been identified in the codon–anticodon interactions involving the most frequently used (preferred) codons. Here we present evidence that forces not related to the individual codon–anticodon interaction may be involved in determining which synonymous codons are preferred or avoided. We show that the ``off-frame' trinucleotide motif preferences inferrable from Drosophila coding regions are often in the same direction as Drosophila's ``in-frame' codon preferences, i.e., its codon usage. The off-frame preferences were inferred from the nonrandomness of the location of confamilial synonymous codons along coding regions—a pattern often described as a context dependence of nucleotide choice at synonymous positions or as codon-pair bias. We relied on randomizations of the location of confamilial codons that do not alter, and cannot be influenced by, the encoded amino acid sequences, codon usage, or base composition of the genes examined. The statistically significant congruency of in-frame and off-frame trinucleotide preferences suggests that the same kind of reading-frame-independent force(s) may also influence synonymous codon choice. These forces may have produced biases in codon usage that then led to the evolution of the translational advantages of these motifs as preferred codons. Under this scenario, tRNA pool size differences between preferred and nonpreferred codons initially were evolved to track the default overrepresentation of codons with preferred motifs. The motif preference hypothesis can explain the structuring of codon preferences and the similarities in the codon usages of distantly related organisms. Received: 10 November 1998 / Accepted: 23 February 1999     

Synonymous Codon Choices in the Extremely GC-Poor Genome of Plasmodium falciparum: Compositional Constraints and Translational Selection

We have analyzed the patterns of synonymous codon preferences of the nuclear genes of Plasmodium falciparum, a unicellular parasite characterized by an extremely GC-poor genome. When all genes are considered, codon usage is strongly biased toward A and T in third codon positions, as expected, but multivariate statistical analysis detects a major trend among genes. At one end genes display codon choices determined mainly by the extreme genome composition of this parasite, and very probably their expression level is low. At the other end a few genes exhibit an increased relative usage of a particular subset of codons, many of which are C-ending. Since the majority of these few genes is putatively highly expressed, we postulate that the increased C-ending codons are translationally optimal. In conclusion, while codon usage of the majority of P. falciparum genes is determined mainly by compositional constraints, a small number of genes exhibit translational selection. Received: 10 November 1998 / Accepted: 28 January 1999     

Dissecting the contributions of GC content and codon usage to gene expression in the model alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The efficiency of gene expression in all organisms depends on the nucleotide composition of the coding region. GC content and codon usage are the two key sequence features known to influence gene expression, but the underlying molecular mechanisms are not entirely clear. Here we have determined the relative contributions of GC content and codon usage to the efficiency of nuclear gene expression in the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. By comparing gene variants that encode an identical amino acid sequence but differ in their GC content and/or codon usage, we show that codon usage is the key factor determining translational efficiency and, surprisingly, also mRNA stability. By contrast, unfavorable GC content affects gene expression at the level of the chromatin structure by triggering heterochromatinization. We further show that mutant algal strains that permit high‐level transgene expression are less susceptible to epigenetic transgene suppression and do not establish a repressive chromatin structure at the transgenic locus. Our data disentangle the relationship between GC content and codon usage, and suggest simple strategies to overcome the transgene expression problem in Chlamydomonas.     

Codon Usage in Plastid Genes Is Correlated with Context, Position Within the Gene, and Amino Acid Content

Highly expressed plastid genes display codon adaptation, which is defined as a bias toward a set of codons which are complementary to abundant tRNAs. This type of adaptation is similar to what is observed in highly expressed Escherichia coli genes and is probably the result of selection to increase translation efficiency. In the current work, the codon adaptation of plastid genes is studied with regard to three specific features that have been observed in E. coli and which may influence translation efficiency. These features are (1) a relatively low codon adaptation at the 5′ end of highly expressed genes, (2) an influence of neighboring codons on codon usage at a particular site (codon context), and (3) a correlation between the level of codon adaptation of a gene and its amino acid content. All three features are found in plastid genes. First, highly expressed plastid genes have a noticeable decrease in codon adaptation over the first 10–20 codons. Second, for the twofold degenerate NNY codon groups, highly expressed genes have an overall bias toward the NNC codon, but this is not observed when the 3′ neighboring base is a G. At these sites highly expressed genes are biased toward NNT instead of NNC. Third, plastid genes that have higher codon adaptations also tend to have an increased usage of amino acids with a high G + C content at the first two codon positions and GNN codons in particular. The correlation between codon adaptation and amino acid content exists separately for both cytosolic and membrane proteins and is not related to any obvious functional property. It is suggested that at certain sites selection discriminates between nonsynonymous codons based on translational, not functional, differences, with the result that the amino acid sequence of highly expressed proteins is partially influenced by selection for increased translation efficiency. Received: 21 July 1999 / Accepted: 5 November 1999     

Heterogeneity in Codon Usage in the Flatworm Schistosoma mansoni

Synonymous codon choices vary considerably among Schistosoma mansoni genes. Principal components analysis detects a single major trend among genes, which highly correlates with GC content in third codon positions and exons, but does not discriminate among putatively highly and lowly expressed genes. The effective number of codons used in each gene, and its distribution when plotted against GC₃, suggests that codon usage is shaped mainly by mutational biases. The GC content of exons, GC₃, 5′, 3′, and flanking (5′+ 3′+ introns) regions are all correlated among them, suggesting that variations in GC content may exist among different regions of the S. mansoni genome. We propose that this genome structure might be among the most important factors shaping codon usage in this species, although the action of selection on certain sequences cannot be excluded. Received: 10 March 1997 / Accepted: 27 June 1997     

葡萄基因组密码子使用偏好模式研究

根据完整基因组序列,运用多元统计分析和对应分析的方法,探讨了葡萄全基因组序列密码子的使用模式和影响密码子使用的各种可能因素。结果显示:葡萄密码子偏好性主要受到碱基差异(r=0.925)和自然选择(r=0.193)共同作用的影响,突变压力占了主导因素,自然选择的作用较小。同时基因长度和蛋白质疏水性也对密码子的偏好性有所影响。确定了葡萄的20个最优密码子。     

Adaptive basis of codon usage in the haploid moss Physcomitrella patens

Patterns of codon usage bias were studied in the moss model species Physcomitrella patens. A total of 92 nuclear, protein coding genes were employed, and estimated levels of gene expression were tested for association with two measures of codon usage bias and other variables hypothesized to be associated with gene expression. Codon bias was found to be positively associated both with estimated levels of gene expression and GC content in the coding parts of studied genes. However, GC content in noncoding parts, that is, introns and 5' and 3' untranslated regions (UTRs), was not associated with estimated levels of gene expression. It is argued that codon bias is not shaped by mutational bias, but rather by weak natural selection for translational efficiency in P. patens. The possible role of life history characteristics in shaping patterns of codon usage in this species is discussed.     

Synonymous and Nonsynonymous Substitution Rates in Diatoms: A Comparison Between Chloroplast and Nuclear Genes

Rates of synonymous and nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions and codon usage bias (ENC) were estimated for a number of nuclear and chloroplast genes in a sample of centric and pennate diatoms. The results suggest that DNA evolution has taken place, on an average, at a slower rate in the chloroplast genes than in the nuclear genes: a rate variation pattern similar to that observed in land plants. Synonymous substitution rates in the chloroplast genes show a negative association with the degree of codon usage bias, suggesting that genes with a higher degree of codon usage bias have evolved at a slower rate. While this relationship has been shown in both prokaryotes and multicellular eukaryotes, it has not been demonstrated before in diatoms. Received: 3 June 1998 / Accepted: 11 August 1998     

Comparison and Evolutionary Analysis of the Glycosomal Glyceraldehyde-3-Phosphate Dehydrogenase from Different Kinetoplastida

In this work, we present the sequences and a comparison of the glycosomal GAPDHs from a number of Kinetoplastida. The complete gene sequences have been determined for some species (Crithidia fasciculata, Herpetomonas samuelpessoai, Leptomonas seymouri, and Phytomonas sp), whereas for other species (Trypanosoma brucei gambiense, Trypanosoma congolense, Trypanosoma vivax, and Leishmania major), only partial sequences have been obtained by PCR amplification. The structure of all available glycosomal GAPDH genes was analyzed in detail. Considerable variations were observed in both their nucleotide composition and their codon usage. The GC content varies between 64.4% in L. seymouri and 49.5% in the previously sequenced GAPDH gene from Trypanoplasma borreli. A highly biased codon usage was found in C. fasciculata, with only 34 triplets used, whereas in T. borreli 57 codons were employed. No obvious correlation could be observed between the codon usage and either the nucleotide composition or the level of gene expression. The glycosomal GAPDH is a very well-conserved enzyme. The maximal overall difference observed in the amino acid sequences is only 25%. Specific insertions and extensions are retained in all sequences. The residues involved in catalysis, substrate, and inorganic phosphate binding are fully conserved, whereas some variability is observed in the cofactor-binding pocket. The implications of these data for the design of new trypanocidal drugs targeted against GAPDH are discussed. All available gene and amino acid sequences of glycosomal GAPDHs were used for a phylogenetic analysis. The division of the Kinetoplastida into two suborders, Bodonina and Trypanosomatina, was well supported. Within the letter group, the Trypanosoma species appeared to be monophyletic, whereas the other trypanosomatids form a second clade. Received: 23 February 1998/Accepted: 26 March 1998     

Intron Length and Codon Usage

The correlation was shown between the length of introns and the codon usage of the coding sequences of the corresponding genes, which in some cases can be related to the level of gene expression. The link is positive in the unicellular organisms, i.e., genes with the longer introns show the higher bias of codon usage. It is most pronounced in baker's yeast, where it is definitely related to the level of gene expression—genes with the higher level of expression have the longer introns. The correlation is inverted in multicellular organisms as compared to unicellular ones. Some organisms, however, do not show the link. The presence or absence of the link does not seem to be related to the GC percent of the coding sequences. Received: 7 December 1999 / Accepted: 10 May 2000     

The Evolution of Codon Preferences in Drosophila: A Maximum-Likelihood Approach to Parameter Estimation and Hypothesis Testing

Synonymous codon usage in related species may differ as a result of variation in mutation biases, differences in the overall strength and efficiency of selection, and shifts in codon preference—the selective hierarchy of codons within and between amino acids. We have developed a maximum-likelihood method to employ explicit population genetic models to analyze the evolution of parameters determining codon usage. The method is applied to twofold degenerate amino acids in 50 orthologous genes from D. melanogaster and D. virilis. We find that D. virilis has significantly reduced selection on codon usage for all amino acids, but the data are incompatible with a simple model in which there is a single difference in the long-term N _e, or overall strength of selection, between the two species, indicating shifts in codon preference. The strength of selection acting on codon usage in D. melanogaster is estimated to be |N _e s|≈ 0.4 for most CT-ending twofold degenerate amino acids, but 1.7 times greater for cysteine and 1.4 times greater for AG-ending codons. In D. virilis, the strength of selection acting on codon usage for most amino acids is only half that acting in D. melanogaster but is considerably greater than half for cysteine, perhaps indicating the dual selection pressures of translational efficiency and accuracy. Selection coefficients in orthologues are highly correlated (ρ= 0.46), but a number of genes deviate significantly from this relationship. Received: 20 December 1998 / Accepted: 17 February 1999     

How Mitochondria Redefine the Code

Annotated, complete DNA sequences are available for 213 mitochondrial genomes from 132 species. These provide an extensive sample of evolutionary adjustment of codon usage and meaning spanning the history of this organelle. Because most known coding changes are mitochondrial, such data bear on the general mechanism of codon reassignment. Coding changes have been attributed variously to loss of codons due to changes in directional mutation affecting the genome GC content (Osawa and Jukes 1988), to pressure to reduce the number of mitochondrial tRNAs to minimize the genome size (Anderson and Kurland 1991), and to the existence of transitional coding mechanisms in which translation is ambiguous (Schultz and Yarus 1994a). We find that a succession of such steps explains existing reassignments well. In particular, (1) Genomic variation in the prevalence of a codon's third-position nucleotide predicts relative mitochondrial codon usage well, though GC content does not. This is because A and T, and G and C, are uncorrelated in mitochondrial genomes. (2) Codons predicted to reach zero usage (disappear) do so more often than expected by chance, and codons that do disappear are disproportionately likely to be reassigned. However, codons predicted to disappear are not significantly more likely to be reassigned. Therefore, low codon frequencies can be related to codon reassignment, but appear to be neither necessary nor sufficient for reassignment. (3) Changes in the genetic code are not more likely to accompany smaller numbers of tRNA genes and are not more frequent in smaller genomes. Thus, mitochondrial codons are not reassigned during demonstrable selection for decreased genome size. Instead, the data suggest that both codon disappearance and codon reassignment depend on at least one other event. This mitochondrial event (leading to reassignment) occurs more frequently when a codon has disappeared, and produces only a small subset of possible reassignments. We suggest that coding ambiguity, the extension of a tRNA's decoding capacity beyond its original set of codons, is the second event. Ambiguity can act alone but often acts in concert with codon disappearance, which promotes codon reassignment. Received: 26 October 2000 / Accepted: 19 January 2001     

Analysis of synonymous codon usage in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Zea mays</Emphasis>

It is important and meaningful to understand the codon usage pattern and the factors that shape codon usage of maize. In this study, trends in synonymous codon usage in maize have been firstly examined through the multivariate statistical analysis on 7402 cDNA sequences. The results showed that the genes positions on the primary axis were strongly negatively correlated with GC3s, GC content of individual gene and gene expression level assessed by the codon adaptation index (CAI) values, which indicated that nucleotide composition and gene expression level were the main factors in shaping the codon usage of maize, and the variation in codon usage among genes may be due to mutational bias at the DNA level and natural selection acting at the level of mRNA translation. At the same time, CDS length and the hydrophobicity of each protein were, respectively, significantly correlated with the genes locations on the primary axis, GC3s and CAI values. We infer that genes length and the hydrophobicity of the encoded protein may play minor role in shaping codon usage bias. Additional 28 codons ending with a G or C base have been defined as “optimal codons”, which may provide useful information for maize gene-transformation and gene prediction.     

Selection on the codon bias of chloroplast and cyanelle genes in different plant and algal lineages

In the plant chloroplast genome the codon usage of the highly expressed psbA gene is unique and is adapted to the tRNA population, probably due to selection for translation efficiency. In this study the role of selection on codon usage in each of the fully sequenced chloroplast genomes, in addition to Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, is investigated by measuring adaptation to this pattern of codon usage. A method is developed which tests selection on each gene individually by constructing sequences with the same amino acid composition as the gene and randomly assigning codons based on the nucleotide composition of noncoding regions of that genome. The codon bias of the actual gene is then compared to a distribution of random sequences. The data indicate that within the algae selection is strong in Cyanophora paradoxa, affecting a majority of genes, of intermediate intensity in Odontella sinensis, and weaker in Porphyra purpurea and Euglena gracilis. In the plants, selection is found to be quite weak in Pinus thunbergii and the angiosperms but there is evidence that an intermediate level of selection exists in the liverwort Marchantia polymorpha. The role of selection is then further investigated in two comparative studies. It is shown that average relative codon bias is correlated with expression level and that, despite saturation levels of substitution, there is a strong correlation among the algae genomes in the degree of codon bias of homologous genes. All of these data indicate that selection for translation efficiency plays a significant role in determining the codon bias of chloroplast genes but that it acts with different intensities in different lineages. In general it is stronger in the algae than the higher plants, but within the algae Euglena is found to have several unusual features which are noted. The factors that might be responsible for this variation in intensity among the various genomes are discussed. Received: 6 June 1997 / Accepted: 24 July 1997     

Codon usage-mediated inhibition of HIV-1 gag expression in mammalian cells occurs independently of translation

Codon usage is considered one of the critical factors that limit the expression rate of heterologous genes. Impaired translation efficiency, specifically insufficient amount of corresponding tRNAs and changed startcodon context, are believed to account for the low translation initiation and elongation rates during the protein biosynthesis in unicellular organisms. Translational efficiency is probably not the primary factor influencing codon usage diversity in mammalian cells. However, the other possible mechanisms preventing expression of genes with low-usage such as mRNA stability, processing and nucleocytoplasmic transport, are not adequately explored. In our work, we addressed the question of whether codon usage differences affect exclusively translational efficiency of mammalian gene products. We demonstrated that the CMV-induced expression of gag-reporter in human H1299 cell line was influenced by the nucleotide composition of the mRNA, and the limitation of gag expression appeared to be inversely related to the level of codon optimization. However, cytoplasmic expression of the gag-reporter driven by vaccinia virus/T7 RNA polymerase hybrid system rescued its expression independently of HIV-1 gag mRNA nucleotide content. We concluded that impaired HIV-1 gag expression may be caused by translation-independent mechanisms, which probably play a major role in codon usage-mediated defects in heterologous gene expression in mammalian cells.     

Evolutionary Lability of Context-Dependent Codon Bias in Bacteria

In bacteria, synonymous codon usage can be considerably affected by base composition at neighboring sites. Such context-dependent biases may be caused by either selection against specific nucleotide motifs or context-dependent mutation biases. Here we consider the evolutionary conservation of context-dependent codon bias across 11 completely sequenced bacterial genomes. In particular, we focus on two contextual biases previously identified in Escherichia coli; the avoidance of out-of-frame stop codons and AGG motifs. By identifying homologues of E. coli genes, we also investigate the effect of gene expression level in Haemophilus influenzae and Mycoplasma genitalium. We find that while context-dependent codon biases are widespread in bacteria, few are conserved across all species considered. Avoidance of out-of-frame stop codons does not apply to all stop codons or amino acids in E. coli, does not hold for different species, does not increase with gene expression level, and is not relaxed in Mycoplasma spp., in which the canonical stop codon, TGA, is recognized as tryptophan. Avoidance of AGG motifs shows some evolutionary conservation and increases with gene expression level in E. coli, suggestive of the action of selection, but the cause of the bias differs between species. These results demonstrate that strong context-dependent forces, both selective and mutational, operate on synonymous codon usage but that these differ considerably between genomes. Received: 6 May 1999 / Accepted: 29 October 1999     

Base Composition Skews, Replication Orientation, and Gene Orientation in 12 Prokaryote Genomes

Variation in GC content, GC skew and AT skew along genomic regions was examined at third codon positions in completely sequenced prokaryotes. Eight out of nine eubacteria studied show GC and AT skews that change sign at the origin of replication. The leading strand in DNA replication is G-T rich at codon position 3 in six eubacteria, but C-T rich in two Mycoplasma species. In M. genitalium the AT and GC skews are symmetrical around the origin and terminus of replication, whereas its GC content variation has been shown to have a centre of symmetry elsewhere in the genome. Borrelia burgdorferi and Treponema pallidum show extraordinary extents of base composition skew correlated with direction of DNA replication. Base composition skews measured at third codon positions probably reflect mutational biases, whereas those measured over all bases in a sequence (or at codon positions 1 and 2) can be strongly affected by protein considerations due to the tendency in some bacteria for genes to be transcribed in the same direction that they are replicated. Consequently in some species the direction of skew for total genomic DNA is opposite to that for codon position 3. Received: 2 February 1998 / Accepted: 15 June 1998