A new multiparameter flow cytometer: optical and electrical cell analysis in combination with video microscopy in flow

BACKGROUND: Flow cytometers, which are commercially available, do not necessarily meet all demands of actual biomedical research. This is the case for the investigation of mechanisms involved in cell volume regulation, which requires electrical volume measurement and ratiometric multichannel fluorescence analysis for the simultaneous assessment of different physiologic parameters (intracellular pH and the intracellular concentration of calcium ions, etc). METHODS AND RESULTS: We describe the construction of a new nonsorting flow cytometer designed for the simultaneous acquisition of seven parameters including fluorescence signals, forward and perpendicular light scatter, cell volume according to the electrical Coulter principle, and flow cytometric imaging. The instrument is equipped with three different light sources. A tunable argon-ion laser generates efficient excitation of the most standard fluorescent probes in the visible spectral range, and an arc lamp provides the means for ultraviolet excitation at low cost. Because of the spatial filtering by the excitation and detection optics, two independent sets of dual fluorescence measurements can be performed, a prerequisite for flexible ratiometric fluorescence analysis. A flow video microscope integrated into the optical system optionally generates either brightfield or phase images of selected flowing particles. Only particles whose individual datasets meet predefined gating conditions are imaged in real time. To avoid smear effects, the motion of the object to be imaged (speed approximately 8 m/s) is frozen on the target of a CCD camera by flash illumination. For this purpose, a high radiance gas discharge lamp with 25-mJ electric pulse energy provides an illumination time of 18 ns (full width half maximum). Test results obtained from latex spheres and cells are shown. CONCLUSIONS: Test results indicate that our instrument can perform Coulter measurements in combination with flexible optical analysis. Moreover, integration of an adapted video microscope into a flow cytometer is an approach to overcome the gap between flow and image cytometry.     

Utility of light scatter in the morphological analysis of sperm.

We were able to differentiate the morphologically diverse sperm nuclei of four animal species by using an Ortho flow cytometer to detect the forward light scatter from a red (helium-neon) laser. Cytograms depicting the axial light loss and forward red scatter signals revealed unique, but reproducible, sigmoid distributions that reflected not only interspecies differences in shape and size, but variations in particle refractive index and orientation within the flow cell at the time of analysis. Consequently, we were able to use regional gating of the light scatter cytogram to minimize the influence of orientation on the resolution of the fluorescence signal. We also observed that sperm enlarging as a result of chemically induced decondensation exhibit over time a biphasic shift (increase, then decrease) in light scatter at a species-dependent rate. These results suggest that, without any special adaptations to the flow cytometer, light-scatter parameters can be used to discriminate morphologically different sperm, to enhance the resolution of fluorescence measurements that may otherwise be confounded by variability in radial orientation, and to detect alterations in the rate of a biochemical/biophysical process such as decondensation.     

Fluorescence as an alternative to light-scatter gating strategies to identify frozen–thawed cells with flow cytometry

Flow cytometry is a key instrument in biological studies, used to identify and analyze cells in suspension. The identification of cells from debris is commonly based on light scatter properties as it has been shown that there is a relationship between forward scattered light and cell volume and this has become common practice in flow cytometry. Cryobiological conditions induce changes in cells that alter their light scatter properties. Cells with membrane damage from freeze–thaw stress produce lower forward scatter signals and may fall below standard forward scatter thresholds. In contrast to light scatter properties that cannot identify damaged cells from debris, fluorescent dyes used in membrane integrity and mitochondrial polarization assays are capable of labeling and discriminating all cells in suspension. Under cryobiological conditions, isolating cell populations is more effectively accomplished by gating on fluorescence rather than light scatter properties. This study shows the limitations of using forward scatter thresholds in flow cytometry to identify and gate cells after exposure to a freeze–thaw protocol and demonstrates the use of fluorescence as an alternative means of identifying and analyzing cells.     

Determination of the Biomasses of Small Bacteria at Low Concentrations in a Mixture of Species with Forward Light Scatter Measurements by Flow Cytometry

The forward light scatter intensity of bacteria analyzed by flow cytometry varied with their dry mass, in accordance with theory. A standard curve was formulated with Rayleigh-Gans theory to accommodate cell shape and alignment. It was calibrated with an extinction-culture isolate of the small marine organism Cycloclasticus oligotrophus, for which dry weight was determined by CHN analysis and ¹⁴C-acetate incorporation. Increased light scatter intensity due to formaldehyde accumulation in preserved cells was included in the standard curve. When differences in the refractive indices of culture media and interspecies differences in the effects of preservation were taken into account, there was agreement between cell mass obtained by flow cytometry for various bacterial species and cell mass computed from Coulter Counter volume and buoyant density. This agreement validated the standard curve and supported the assumption that cells were aligned in the flow stream. Several subpopulations were resolved in a mixture of three species analyzed according to forward light scatter and DNA-bound DAPI (4′,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) fluorescence intensity. The total biomass of the mixture was 340 μg/liter. The lowest value for mean dry mass, 0.027 ± 0.008 pg/cell, was for the subpopulation of C. oligotrophus containing cells with a single chromosome. Calculations from measurements of dry mass, Coulter Counter volume, and buoyant density revealed that the dry weight of the isolate was 14 to 18% of its wet weight, compared to 30% for Escherichia coli. The method is suitable for cells with 0.005 to about 1.2 pg of dry weight at concentrations of as low as 10³ cells/ml and offers a unique capability for determining biomass distributions in mixed bacterial populations.     

Laser flow cytometric light scatter and fluorescence pulse width and pulse rise-time sizing of mammalian cells.

In laser flow cytometry, an increasingly popular technique of analytical cytology, quantitative measurements of interest include cell and nuclear diameters. Electronic circuitry for a new cell sizing technique has been developed which measured the time that signal pulses from either fluorescence or light scatter sensors exceed a preset constant fraction of the peak signal amplitude (pulse width) or the time that it takes a signal to rise between constant fractions of the peak signal amplitude on the rising side of the pulse (pulse rise-time). These pulse width or pulse rise-time measurements were related to cell or nuclear diameters and were used in combination to determine nuclear size to cell size ratios. This method of sizing was found to be independent of fluorescent or light-absorbing stain intensity, linearly related to cell or nuclear diameter, and capable of resolving small diameter differences.     

Discriminating between damaged and intact cells in fixed flow cytometric samples

A vital, nucleic acid stain (LDS-751) was used to discriminate intact from damaged cells in a flow cytometer even after the samples had been fixed with paraformaldehyde. Three major cell populations with different fluorescence properties with LDS-751 were found in the fixed samples. Cells not staining or only dimly staining with LDS-751 were identified as erythrocytes and platelets, respectively. Cells staining with intermediate amounts of LDS-751 were found to be intact cells, while cells intensively stained were identified as damaged cells. Confirmation of the identity of the populations was obtained by light microscopic examination of the sorted populations and by correlating the fluorescent signals of FDA and LDS-751 in nonfixed cell preparations. Agglutinated cells could also be identified by the increased fluorescent signal in the LDS-751 channel as compared with single cells. The spectral properties of this dye permit excitation at 488 nm with emission in the far red portion of the spectrum. This allowed two-color immunofluorescence to be combined with the intact/damaged cell discrimination on fixed samples. Therefore, intact single cells could be distinguished during flow cytometric analysis, increasing the accuracy of the immunofluorescence measurements. The visualization of the multidimensional data was facilitated using color to discriminate cell populations depicted in multiple perspectives.     

Growth of Azotobacter vinelandii with correlation of Coulter cell size, flow cytometric parameters, and ultrastructure

When Azotobacter vinelandii is grown under nitrogen-fixing conditions, the mean cell volume fluctuates from 2.7 to 6.6 microns 3 as determined using a Coulter counter. When NH4Cl is supplied as nitrogen source, the mean cell volume fluctuates from 4.6 to 7.4 microns3. Parallel experiments using flow cytometric measurements show similar characteristic fluctuations in the narrow forward angle light scattering signal and also in cellular protein content as determined using fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) fluorescence. Fluctuations in the perpendicular light scatter signal during batch growth are similar for both sets of growth conditions. Changes in cell morphology and ultrastructure are also similar for both sets of growth conditions, as demonstrated by electron microscopic examination. We conclude that narrow forward angle light scatter is a close correlate of cell size, whereas right angle scatter is an indicator of morphological variations other than size.     

Method to improve the sensitivity of flow cytometric membrane potential measurements in mouse spinal cord cells.

We have developed a technique to improve the sensitivity of relative membrane potential measurements in mouse spinal cord cells using the fluorescent, anionic, voltage sensitive dye, DiBa-C4(3) (Oxonol) and flow cytometry. In order to attribute cellular fluorescence primarily to membrane potential, signal variability due to cell size and shape was reduced by dividing the log fluorescence signal from each cell by either its log forward angle light scatter or log side scatter signals. The use of these ratios in place of log oxonol fluorescence reduced the coefficient of variation of the distributions while leaving the changes in mean fluorescence largely unaffected. Kolmogorov-Smirnov analysis of pre- vs. postkainate stimulation (an excitatory amino acid) showed improved sensitivity of the assay with the use of this ratio technique.     

Effects of mismatched refractive indices in aquatic flow cytometry.

BACKGROUND: Forward-angle light scatter, as measured by flow cytometry, can be used to estimate the size spectra of cell assemblages from natural waters. The refractive index of water samples from aquatic environments can differ because of a variety of factors such as dissolved organic content, aldehyde preservative, sample salinity, and temperature. In flow cytometric analyses, mismatch between the refractive indices of the sheath fluid and the sample causes distortion of the forward-angle light scatter signal. We measured the effect of this mismatch on cell size measurements. METHODS: We examined the error by measuring the scatter signal of a variety of particle types and sizes and changing the sheath-to-sample salinity ratio. The effects were characterized for standard microspheres, cultured phytoplankton cells of different sizes, and natural populations from an estuarine river. RESULTS: We found that the distorted scatter signals resulted in an increase in the apparent size of small cells (1--2 microm) by a factor of 4.5 times. Cells in the size range of 3--5 microm were less affected by the salinity differences, and cells larger than 5 microm were not affected. Chlorophyll and phycoerythrin fluorescences and 90 degrees light scatter signals were not changed by sheath and sample salinity differences. CONCLUSIONS: Care must be taken to ensure that the sheath and sample refractive index are matched when using forward light scatter to measure cell size spectra, especially in estuarine studies, where salinity can vary greatly. Of the factors considered that can change the sample refractive index, salinity gradients in an estuary cause the largest index mismatch and, consequently, the largest error in scatter.     

Activation markers and cell proliferation as indicators of toxicity: A flow cytometric approach

Cell proliferation is an attractive endpoint inin vitro toxicity assays, since nearly any kind of damage in a cell may result in altered cell proliferation. In toxicological applications, liquid scintillation counting, measuring radioactivity from tritiated thymidine, has been the traditional way to estimate cell proliferation. An alternative approach is the measurement of BrdU incorporation by flow cytometry. Before the actual DNA synthesis starts, several proteins are expressed on the cell surface, as well as intracellularly. Among the markers on the cell surface CD69, CD25, and CD71 are sequentially expressed on human lymphocytes after a mitogenic stimulation. The aim of this study was to evaluate information obtained by analysis of expression of activation markers on cell surfaces in lymphocyte subsets and to compare it with data from cell proliferation studies performed by liquid scintillation counting and BrdU flow cytometry. The experiments were performed with phytohemagglutinin-stimulated human lymphocytes exposed to ochratoxin A and cyclosporin A. While ochratoxin A-treated cultures showed a steep inhibition with increasing concentration, the cyclosporin A treatment gave an inhibition curve with a less steep slope. Activation marker studies showed that the effect of treatment with both of the toxins was more pronounced on the late markers CD25 and CD71, while CD69 had the advantage that significant effects could be detected as early as 6 h after ochratoxin A treatment. Cyclosporin A treatment induced only minor alterations in CD69 expression. Certain differences in expression of activation markers between CD4⁺ and CD8⁺ subsets were found both in ochratoxin A- and cyclosporin A-treated cultures. A stimulating effect was found in cell cultures exposed to the lowest concentration of ochratoxin A on CD69 and CD25 expression. Signs of an increase in frequencies of proliferating cells measured with the BrdU flow cytometry method were also seen. This increase could not be detected with liquid scintillation counting. No other differences between the liquid scintillation counting and BrdU flow cytometry measurements of proliferation were obtained. We conclude that studies of activation marker expression by the flow cytometric approach used in this report are useful complements to traditional measurements of cell proliferation as they yield subsetspecific information about cellular processes which precede proliferation of lymphocytes.Abbreviations A pulse area - BrdU bromodeoxyuridine - CD cluster of differentiation - FBS fetal bovine serum - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - FL fluorescence - FSC forward light scatter - H pulse height - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - PI propidium iodide - R-PE R-phycoerythrin - RPMI Roswell Park Memorial Institute - SEM standard error of the mean - SSC orthogonal light scatter - W pulse width     

An adapter for defined sample volumes makes it possible to count absolute particle numbers in flow cytometry.

A device is described which makes it possible to count absolute particle (cell) numbers per volume by flow cytometry. It can easily by adapted to several types of flow cytometers, especially to the Coulter EPICS V and EPICS 750 series. A volume adapter has been installed in place of the normal sample handling system without any further modifications of the instrument or the data acquisition program. The adapter consists of a special pipette with two opto-electronic detectors for the beginning and end of the measuring period. These switch on/off a shutter for the illuminating laser beam so that acquisition of the data is controlled indirectly. Sample volumes of 50 microliters were measured at flow rates up to 10(3) particles/s. Calibration beads as well as blood cells were enumerated according to FALS (forward angle light scatter), to SSC (90 degrees light scatter), and to fluorescence parameters. The results were compared to the evaluation made on a Coulter counter or in a Neubauer chamber of a light microscope. Using a concentration of 1 x 10(5)-5 x 10(5) particles/ml, the absolute numbers of particles were determined with a high reproducibility and an estimated error rate of 2-5%.     

Flow microfluorometric and light-scatter measurement of nuclear and cytoplasmic size in mammalian cells.

A technique for rapid measurement of nuclear and cytoplasmic size relationships in mammalian cell populations has been developed. Based on fluorescence staining of either the nucleus alone or in combination with the cytoplasm using two-color fluorescence methods, this technique permits the simultaneous determination of nuclear and cytoplasmic diameters from fluorescence and light-scatter measurements. Cells stained in liquid suspension pass through a flow chamber at a constant velocity, intersecting a laser beam which excites cell fluorescence and causes light scatter. Depending upon which analysis procedure is used, optical sensors measure nuclear fluorescence and light scatter (whole cell size) or two-color nuclear and cytoplasmic fluorescence from individual cells crossing the laser beam. The time durations of signals generated by the nucleus and cytoplasm are converted electronically into signals proportional to the respective diameters and are displayed as frequency distribution hitograms. Illustrative examples of measurements on uniform microspheres, cultured mammalian cells and human exfoliated gynecologic cells are presented.     

Flow cytometric enumeration of absolute lymphocyte number in peripheral blood using two parameters of light scatter

A method was developed to measure the absolute lymphocyte count (ALC) of whole blood using the Spectrum III automated flow cytometer. Ninety-nine samples of human peripheral blood were analysed on the Spectrum and the Coulter Counter S Plus II, to allow for comparison of the two machines. Regression analysis was used to test the extent of agreement between the sets of measurements on the two machines. The results demonstrated that the slope of the regression line was not significantly different from one, indicating a high level of correlation between Spectrum and Coulter ALC's. However, the mean difference between Coulter and Spectrum ALC's was not equal to zero, with the Spectrum giving counts approximately 10% lower than those of the Coulter machine. This is attributed to the different ways by which the two machines define a lymphocyte, the Spectrum III by two parameters of light scatter and the Coulter S Plus II by the single parameter of cell volume.     

Discrimination of eukaryotic phytoplankton cell types from light scatter and autofluorescence properties measured by flow cytometry

Flow cytometric methods for recognizing several groups of eukaryotic marine phytoplankton were tested using 26 laboratory cultures. Each culture was divided into three aliquots, and these samples were analyzed for 1) Coulter volume; 2) light scatter (magnitude and polarization properties of forward scattered light and magnitude of right-angle scattered light) and autofluorescence emission (phycoerythrin and chlorophyll); and 3) autofluorescence excitation (by 488 nm and 515 nm light). Three kinds of cells could be easily distinguished from others in the culture collection: 1) The two cryptophytes and the rhodophyte had high phycoerythrin/chlorophyll ratios; 2) the two coccolithophores depolarized forward scattered light; and 3) the two pennate diatoms scattered only a relatively small amount of light in the forward direction compared with that at right angles. Mean chlorophyll fluorescence excited by blue light relative to that excited by green light was highest in the four chlorophytes, but there was overlap between some of these and some other kinds of cells. Unresolved cell types included centric diatoms, dinoflagellates, and naked coccolithophores. Forward light scatter and Coulter volume were closely related (except for the pennate diatoms) over a range of about 0.01 to 30 pL (equivalent spherical diameter about 3 to 40 microns), according to a logarithmic function.     

Correlated analysis of cellular DNA, membrane antigens and light scatter of human lymphoid cells

Flow cytometric correlated analysis of membrane antigens, DNA, and light scatter was performed on human lymphoid cells using fluorescein (FITC)-conjugated antibodies to label B- and T-cell antigens and propidium iodide (PI) to stain DNA after ethanol fixation and RNase treatment. A FACS II flow cytometer was modified to obtain digitized measurements of two color fluorescence and light scatter emissions, simultaneously. Software was written to allow single parameter analysis or correlated analysis of any two of the three parameters acquired. Ethanol fixation preserved FITC surface labeling for at least 15 weeks, but produced marked changes in light scatter. No changes in FITC distributions were observed after RNase treatment and PI staining, and the presence of FITC labeling did not affect DNA distributions. Within heterogeneous cell populations, the DNA distribution of cell subpopulations identified by a membrane antigen was clearly demonstrated.     

Flow cytometric measurements of fluorescence energy transfer using single laser excitation

Flow cytometric energy transfer (FCET) measurements between labeled specific sites of cell surface elements (Sz?llosi et al., Cytometry, 5:210-216, 1984) have been extended in a simplified form using a flow cytometer equipped with single excitation beam. This versatile and easily applicable method has several advantages over any nonflow cytometric (i.e., spectrofluorimetric) energy transfer measurements on cell surfaces: The labeled ligands can be applied in excess, without washing, thereby enabling the investigation of relatively labile receptor-ligand complexes. Contributions of signals from cell debris, from cell aggregates, or from nonviable cells can be avoided by gating the data collection on the light scatter signal. The heterogeneity of the cell population with respect to the proximity of the labeled binding sites can be studied. In the cases of homologous ligands or of ligands binding to the same molecule but at different epitopes, the determination of fluorescence resonance energy transfer efficiency values can be carried out on a cell-by-cell basis, offering data on intramolecular conformational changes. This modified FCET method enabled us to demonstrate the uniform density of glycoproteins, specific for Con A binding, in the plasma membrane of normal and Gross virus leukemic mouse cells of different sizes. The utility of this procedure has also been demonstrated by using the mean fluorescence intensities of the distribution curves in the calculation of the fluorescence energy transfer efficiency.     

Discrimination of myogenic and nonmyogenic cells from embryonic skeletal muscle by 90 degrees light scattering

A myogenic cell suspension was isolated from the breast muscles of 10-day-old chicken embryos by trypsin digestion. The cell preparation was subjected to Percoll density centrifugation to reduce the number of fibroblast-like cells present. The Percoll-isolated, predominantly myogenic cell population was then fractionated by flow cytometry using 90 degrees light scattering as the parameter for sorting. Cells exhibiting lower scatter, with a peak of 45 units, produced cultures containing myotubes and gave rise only to myogenic clones. Cells exhibiting higher scatter (120-200 units) produced nonmyogenic cultures and gave rise to nonmyogenic clones. Cells with intermediate light scatter were also detected. The latter produced both myogenic and nonmyogenic clones. The differences in light scatter presumably reflect higher cytoplasmic complexity of the nonmyogenic cells compared with the myogenic cells. Moreover, the differences in light scattering properties of the different cell types offer a means for the isolation of pure populations of myogenic cells directly from the intact muscle.     

Flow Cytometric Analysis of Electronic Nuclear Volume and DNA Content in Normal Mouse Tissues

Light scatter is used in flow cytometry for identification of cells based on their size and/or granularity. However, forward light scatter is not an accurate measure of cell size. The measurement of Electronic Volume (EV) by Coulter principle is more accurate. However, EV cannot be measured on most of the commercially available flow cytometers. We have described the development and applications of a flow cytometer that can simultaneously measure Electronic Nuclear Volume (ENV) and DNA content. In the present study we have used a commercially available NPE QuantaTm for measuring EV and DNA content of different normal mice tissues.Fresh/frozen or formalin fixed-paraffin embedded tissues from mice were processed for isolation of nuclei, which were then analyzed for EV versus DNA content. By using these two parameters, distinct sub-populations were identified in liver, thymus, small intestine and bone marrow. Dual parametric analysis of EV versus DNA content can be a valuable technique for identification of sub-populations in heterogeneous cell mixtures such as those of complex tissues like bone marrow, intestine and tumors. The methods established are rapid and can provide valuable data for identification and characterization of sub-populations for cell cycle analysis by flow cytometry.     

Flow cytometric analysis of electronic nuclear volume and DNA content in normal mouse tissues

Light scatter is used in flow cytometry for identification of cells based on their size and/or granularity. However, forward light scatter is not an accurate measure of cell size. The measurement of Electronic Volume (EV) by Coulter principle is more accurate. However, EV cannot be measured on most of the commercially available flow cytometers. We have described the development and applications of a flow cytometer that can simultaneously measure Electronic Nuclear Volume (ENV) and DNA content. In the present study we have used a commercially available NPE Quanta for measuring EV and DNA content of different normal mice tissues. Fresh/frozen or formalin fixed-paraffin embedded tissues from mice were processed for isolation of nuclei, which were then analyzed for EV versus DNA content. By using these two parameters, distinct sub-populations were identified in liver, thymus, small intestine and bone marrow. Dual parametric analysis of EV versus DNA content can be a valuable technique for identification of sub-populations in heterogeneous cell mixtures such as those of complex tissues like bone marrow, intestine and tumors. The methods established are rapid and can provide valuable data for identification and characterization of sub-populations for cell cycle analysis by flow cytometry.