Molecular Studies on Entry Exclusion in Escherichia coli Minicells

Minicells produced by abnormal cell division in a strain of Escherichia coli (K-12) have been employed here to investigate the phenomenon of "entry exclusion." When purified minicells from strains containing F' or R factors, or both, are mated with radioactive thymidine-labeled Hfr or R(+) donors, the recipient minicells can be conveniently separated from normal-sized donors following mating, and the products of conjugation can be analyzed in the absence of donors and of further growth of the recipients. Transmissible plasmids or episomes are transferred less efficiently to purified minicells derived from strains carrying similar or related elements than to strains without them. Measurement of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) degradation and determination of weight-average molecular weights following transfer indicate that degradation of transferred DNA or transfer of smaller pieces cannot account for the comparative reduction in transfer to entry-excluding recipients. Therefore, we conclude that entry exclusion operates to prevent the physical entry of DNA into recipients expressing the exclusion phenotype. The R-produced repressor (product of the drd(+) gene), which represses fertility (i.e., ability to act as donor), reduces exclusion mediated by R or F factor, or both, in matings between strains carrying homologous elements. Furthermore, the data suggest that the presence of the F pilus or F-like R pilus on recipient cells ensures maximum expression of the exclusion phenotype but is not essential for its expression. In contrast to previous suggestions, we found no evidence for a reduction of entry exclusion attributable to the DNA temperature-sensitive chromosomal mutation dnaB(TS).     

Influence of lipopolysaccharide and protein in the cell envelope on recipient capacity in conjugation of Salmonella typhimurium.

In crosses of Salmonella typhimurium FfinP301 lac+ to F- strains of S. typhimurium in broth, recipient strains which were rough mutants affected in the outer core region of the lipopolysaccharide gave an average of 1.4 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell and over 50% of the donor and recipient cells in mating aggregates, whereas smooth recipient strains gave 0.08 Lac+ transconjugants and few cells in mating aggregates. Strains with mutations affecting the inner core of the lipopolysaccharide were usually poor recipients. When cells were mated on Millipore membrane filters, both smooth and rough strains gave ca. 1.0 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell. Plasmids in Inc groups FI, FII, M, J, and I beta gave more transconjugants with rough than smooth strains, but there were no difference in crosses with plasmids in Inc groups T, L, P, N, and W. Strains with mutations in the ompA gene (deficient in Omp Ap = 33K = II* = conjugation protein) yielded only 0.02 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell and few cells in mating aggregates. There was no indication of a deficiency of Omp Ap in smooth strains compared with rough strains. Reduced fertility of smooth recipients may occur because the O side chains of the lipopolysaccharide shield the recipient and reduce the frequency of stabilization of mating aggregates. However, gradient-of-transmission experiments indicated that once these mating aggregates are stabilized, they are equally stable in both smooth and rough recipients. Fertility was high in crosses of S. typhimurium Flac+ to Escherichia coli K-12 F- (0.75 Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell; over 50% of the cells in mating aggregates). In crosses of E. coli K-12 Flac+ to S. typhimurium smooth F-, ca. 10(-5) Lac+ transconjugants per donor cell were obtained; in crosses to rough recipient strains, fertility was increased 14-fold, and when the recipient was defective in the SA and LT host restriction systems, fertility was increased in additional 100-fold. Thus, both the lipopolysaccharide and the protein in the cell envelope of S. typhimurium were shown to be important in the recipient function in F-mediated conjugation.     

Physical Properties and Mechanism of Transfer of R Factors in Escherichia coli

The physical properties of F-like and I-like R factors have been compared with those of the wild-type F factor in Escherichia coli K-12 unmated cells and after transfer to recipient cells by conjugation. The F-like R factor R538-1drd was found to have a molecular weight of 49 x 10(6), whereas the molecular weight of the I-like R factor R64drd11 was 76 x 10(6). The wild-type F factor, F1, had a molecular weight of 62 x 10(6). When conjugation experiments are performed by using donor strains carrying these derepressed F-like or I-like R factors, the transferred deoxyribonucleic acid can be isolated as a covalently closed circle from the recipient cells. This circular deoxyribonucleic acid was characterized by making use of the observation that the complementary strands of these R factors can be separated in a CsCl-poly (U, G) equilibrium gradient. The results of the strand-separation experiments show that only one of the complementary strands of the R factor is transferred from the donor to the recipient. With both the F-like and I-like R factors, this strand is the heavier strand in CsCl-poly (U, G). These results indicate that even though F-like and I-like R factors differ greatly in many properties (phage specificity, size, compatability, etc.), they are transferred by a similar mechanism.     

Studies on superinfection immunity among transmissible plasmids in Escherichia coli

Superinfection immunity was studied by a method which permits the specific labeling of plasmid DNA following its entry into a recipient cell during conjugation. By measuring the incorporation of [³H]thymine during matings between a donor strain of Escherichia coli K12 carrying the R factor, Rl, and various recipients, we found that the presence in the recipient of a plasmid closely related to R1 (F or R factor 222), or isogenic to it (resistance transfer factor, from Rl), resulted in a reduction of 80 to 90% in the rate of [³H]thymine incorporation, relative to a mating with a plasmid-negative (F ^?) recipient. The DNA present in these recipients after 60 minutes of mating was further examined by neutral sucrose gradient eentrifugation. The DNA in the F⁺ and F ^? recipients sedimented similarly, in two major peaks at 50 S (relaxed circles) and 75 S (supercoiled circles). However, the DNA in the RTF recipient sedimented at rates intermediate between 50 S and 75 S. Pulse-chase experiments revealed that the DNA species seen after 60 minutes of an R1 × RTF mating are normal replicative intermediates which have disappeared by 60 minutes in the R1 × F^? or R1 × F⁺ matings.These data support genetic evidence suggesting that superinfection immunity is due to two distinct effects—entry exclusion and plasmid incompatibility. Thus, F (related to R1 but genetically compatible with it), as well as the incompatible plasmids, 222 and the RTF of R1 itself, when present in the recipient, greatly reduce the total synthesis of newly introduced R1 DNA in the recipient. We interpret this effect as entry exclusion. Incompatibility, manifested by RTF, but not F, further reduces the efficiency of conjugation by slowing the rate at which a newly acquired plasmid is replicated.     

Exclusion in IncI-type Escherichia coli conjugations: the stage of conjugation at which exclusion operates

The stage at which exclusion operates in matings between donors belonging to the I-type incompatibility group (IncI) was investigated. Mating between Escherichia coli cells harbouring the I-type plasmid R144 and E. coli cells harbouring the R144-derived recombinant plasmid pRAH308, which causes a hundredfold exclusion, was performed on a membrane filter to test whether mating aggregate formation was disturbed. Besides, level and kinetics of the formation of mating aggregates in mixtures of R144⁺ donor cells and recipient cells carrying plasmid pRAH308 (exclusion-proficient) was compared with the aggregate formation in mixtures of the donor cells and exclusion-deficient recipient cells. Results from these experiments revealed that the exclusion by pRAH308 does not operate at the level of aggregate formation, but acts at the stage of DNA transfer. The exclusion phenomenon by the recombinant plasmid pRAH308 appeared to be representative for exclusion caused by plasmid R144, since essentially identical results were obtained if plasmid R144 was used as exclusion-determining factor.     

Conjugal transfer in Lactococcus lactis of a 68-kilobase-pair chromosomal fragment containing the structural gene for the peptide bacteriocin nisin.

Nisin-producing transconjugants were generated by mating nisin-producing strains of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis with derivatives of L. lactis subsp. lactis LM0230. The sucrose-utilizing ability and reduced bacteriophage sensitivity were also transferred with the nisin-producing character. Pulsed-field gel electrophoretic analysis of genomic DNA from donor, recipient, and nisin-producing transconjugants indicated that 68 kbp of DNA was transferred from the chromosome of the donor into the chromosome of the recipient in the conjugation process. The location of the transferred nisin structural gene spaN in the transconjugant HID500 was not stable, and cultures of strain HID500 were a mixture of different genotypes in which spaN was located at different positions in the chromosome on different SmaI fragments. ApaI, BglI, BssHII, NciI, SalI, and SmaI digests of genomic DNA were used to map the location of spaN in a donor (DL11) and a nisin-producing transconjugant (HID504).     

Conjugal transfer in Lactococcus lactis of a 68-kilobase-pair chromosomal fragment containing the structural gene for the peptide bacteriocin nisin.

Nisin-producing transconjugants were generated by mating nisin-producing strains of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis with derivatives of L. lactis subsp. lactis LM0230. The sucrose-utilizing ability and reduced bacteriophage sensitivity were also transferred with the nisin-producing character. Pulsed-field gel electrophoretic analysis of genomic DNA from donor, recipient, and nisin-producing transconjugants indicated that 68 kbp of DNA was transferred from the chromosome of the donor into the chromosome of the recipient in the conjugation process. The location of the transferred nisin structural gene spaN in the transconjugant HID500 was not stable, and cultures of strain HID500 were a mixture of different genotypes in which spaN was located at different positions in the chromosome on different SmaI fragments. ApaI, BglI, BssHII, NciI, SalI, and SmaI digests of genomic DNA were used to map the location of spaN in a donor (DL11) and a nisin-producing transconjugant (HID504).     

Retrotransfer in Escherichia coli conjugation: bidirectional exchange or de novo mating?

DNA can be transferred among eubacteria and to plants and fungi by related, plasmid-mediated processes collectively referred to as bacterial conjugation. Conjugation occurs between cells in contact with one another and results in the unidirectional delivery of DNA from a bacterial donor to a recipient. Recent experiments that have reexamined the directionality of DNA flow during conjugation have come to different conclusions, some suggesting that genetic material also flows from recipient cells into the donor and that this process, termed retrotransfer, is likewise directed by donor-encoded functions. Given that bacteria are perhaps united with all living creatures by conjugation, the possibility of gene flow into donor bacteria during conjugation raises interesting evolutionary and biocontainment issues. Here we report that plasmid transmission from bacterial recipients to donors is not a donor-mediated event. Movement of genetic material from recipients to donors was inhibited by streptomycin, which does not inhibit the conjugative donor, indicating that retrotransfer requires gene expression in recipients. Furthermore, retrotransfer was reduced in matings mediated by plasmids that encode strong entry exclusion, to a similar degree as matings between two donors. Therefore we suggest that retrotransfer is in fact newly initiated conjugation between transconjugants and donors.     

Gene 19 of plasmid R1 is required for both efficient conjugative DNA transfer and bacteriophage R17 infection.

F-like plasmids require a number of genes for conjugation, including tra operon genes and genes traM and traJ, which lie outside the tra operon. We now establish that a gene in the "leading region," gene 19, provides an important function during conjugation and RNA phage infection. Mutational inactivation of gene 19 on plasmid R1-16 by introduction of two nonpolar stop codons results in a 10-fold decrease in the conjugation frequency. Furthermore, infection studies with the male-specific bacteriophage R17 revealed that the phage is not able to form clear plaques in Escherichia coli cells carrying an R1-16 plasmid with the defective copy of gene 19. The total number of cells infected by phage R17 is reduced by a factor of 10. Both the conjugation- and infection-attenuated phenotypes caused by the defective gene 19 can be complemented in trans by introducing gene 19 alleles encoding the wild-type protein. Restoration of the normal phenotypes is also possible by introduction of the pilT gene encoded by the unrelated IncI plasmid R64. Our functional studies and similarities of protein 19 to proteins encoded by other DNA transfer systems, as well as the presence of a conserved motif in all of these proteins (indicative for a putative muramidase activity) suggest that protein 19 of plasmid R1 facilitates the passage of DNA during conjugation and entry of RNA during phage infection.     

Ammonia Inhibition of Plasmid pRmeGR4a Conjugal Transfer between Rhizobium meliloti Strains

We have examined nutritional factors influencing conjugal transfer of the two nonsymbiotic large plasmids, pRmeGR4a and pRmeGR4b, of Rhizobium meliloti GR4. To monitor transfer, each plasmid was tagged with a different antibiotic resistance marker. Transfer of plasmid pRmeGR4b was dependent upon the presence of plasmid pRmeGR4a on the same donor cell. Transconjugants for pRmeGR4b were obtained at frequencies 5-to 10-fold higher than transconjugants carrying both plasmids, indicating that mobilization of pRmeGR4b by pRmeGR4a probably occurred in trans. Conjugal transfer of the tagged plasmids between R. meliloti strains was tested on minimal medium supplemented with single amino acids, nitrate, or ammonium as the single nitrogen source. A higher number of transconjugants was obtained when glutamate was the only nitrogen source, whereas conjugation was virtually undetectable on ammonium. No relationship was found between donor or recipient growth rate and plasmid transfer rate on a given nitrogen source. Furthermore, in media containing both glutamate and ammonium as nitrogen sources, transfer was reduced almost 100-fold compared with that in media containing glutamate alone. Inhibition was readily detected at 2.5 mM or higher concentrations of either ammonium chloride or ammonium sulfate and appeared to be specific for exogenously supplied ammonium. Inhibition of conjugal transfer between R. meliloti strains by ammonium was only observed for rhizobial plasmids, not for a heterologous plasmid such as RP4. Apparently, ammonium did not affect the plasmid-encoded transfer machinery, as it had no influence on rhizobial plasmid transfer from R. meliloti to Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The effect of ammonium seemed to take place on R. meliloti recipient cells, thereby reducing the efficiency of plasmid conjugation, probably by affecting mating pair formation or stabilization.     

Role of the cell surface in bacterial mating: requirement for intact mucopeptide in donors for the expression of surface exclusion in R+ strains of Escherichia coli.

Two derivatives of the F-like R factor R1drd19 carrying mutually exclusive resistance determinants were used to study the role of the mucopeptide in the expression of conjugal functions. The use of metabolically active penicillin spheroplasts in R+ times R- matings had no effect on the ability of the cells to donate or accept a plasmid. However, in R+ times R+ matings it was found that surface exclusion was totally abolished if the donor, but not the recipient, was a spheroplast. This result implies that the traS gene, expressed by the excluding plasmid, is dependent for its action on an intact mucopeptide layer in the donor cell, and that this interaction is independent of the transfer ability of the excluding plasmid.     

Plasmid associated with diplococcin production in Streptococcus.

The ability to produce diplococcin (Dip+) was transferred by conjugation from Streptococcus cremoris 346 to two plasmid-free S. cremoris recipients at a high frequency (10(-1) per donor). Dip+ transconjugants from each mating gained a 54-megadalton plasmid. Spontaneous loss of this plasmid restored the Dip- phenotype.     

Plasmid associated with diplococcin production in Streptococcus

The ability to produce diplococcin (Dip+) was transferred by conjugation from Streptococcus cremoris 346 to two plasmid-free S. cremoris recipients at a high frequency (10(-1) per donor). Dip+ transconjugants from each mating gained a 54-megadalton plasmid. Spontaneous loss of this plasmid restored the Dip- phenotype.     

A microcosm for measuring survival and conjugation of genetically engineered bacteria in rhizosphere environments

A microcosm is described to evaluate and measure bacterial conjugation in the rhizosphere of barley and radish with strains ofPseudomonas cepacia. The purpose was to describe a standard method useful for evaluating the propensity of genetically engineered microorganisms (GEMs) to transfer DNA to recipient bacteria. Results demonstrated the formation of transconjugants from the rhizosphere of each plant 24 h after inoculation. Transconjugant populations peaked at 1.8 × 10² colony forming units (CFU)/g root and associated soil in barley and 2.0×10² CFU/g root and associated soil in radish; they then declined over the next five days of the experiment. No significant differences were found in the survival of transconjugant populations monitored from the two plant species. The microcosm was also used to document the formation of false positive transconjugants, which resulted from donor and recipientP. cepacia mating on the surface of selective agar plates instead of in microcosms. Transconjugants resulting from such plate mating occurred in substantial numbers during the first 5 days of the experiment but declined to undetectable numbers by day 7. The use of nalidixic acid was investigated to determine the magnitude of plate mating. The number of transconjugants detected from radish rhizosphere was reduced by two orders of magnitude by including nalidixic acid in the plating medium; this indicated that 99% of the transconjugants were a result of plate mating.     

Biotic and abiotic factors affecting plasmid transfer in Escherichia coli strains.

The influence of biotic and abiotic factors on plasmid transfer between Escherichia coli strains in terms of the variation in the number of transconjugants formed and the variation in transfer frequency was investigated. The density of parent cells affected the number of transconjugants, reaching a maximum when the cell density was on the order of 10(8) CFU ml-1. As the donor-to-recipient ratios varied from 10(-4) to 10(4), the number of transconjugants varied significantly (P less than 0.001), reaching a maximum with donor-to-recipient ratios between 1 and 10. The concentration of total organic carbon in the mating medium affects both the number of transconjugants and the transfer frequency, being significantly higher (P less than 0.001) when the total organic carbon concentration was higher than 1,139 mg of C liter-1. However, the transconjugants were detected even with less than 1 mg of C liter-1. Linear regression of log10 transconjugants versus mating temperature showed a highly significant regression line (P less than 0.001). Neither the transfer frequency nor the transconjugant number varied significantly in the range of pHs assayed. We can conclude that plasmid transfer by conjugation can take place within a wide range of conditions, even in such adverse conditions as the absence of nutrients and low temperatures.     

Biotic and abiotic factors affecting plasmid transfer in Escherichia coli strains.

The influence of biotic and abiotic factors on plasmid transfer between Escherichia coli strains in terms of the variation in the number of transconjugants formed and the variation in transfer frequency was investigated. The density of parent cells affected the number of transconjugants, reaching a maximum when the cell density was on the order of 10(8) CFU ml-1. As the donor-to-recipient ratios varied from 10(-4) to 10(4), the number of transconjugants varied significantly (P less than 0.001), reaching a maximum with donor-to-recipient ratios between 1 and 10. The concentration of total organic carbon in the mating medium affects both the number of transconjugants and the transfer frequency, being significantly higher (P less than 0.001) when the total organic carbon concentration was higher than 1,139 mg of C liter-1. However, the transconjugants were detected even with less than 1 mg of C liter-1. Linear regression of log10 transconjugants versus mating temperature showed a highly significant regression line (P less than 0.001). Neither the transfer frequency nor the transconjugant number varied significantly in the range of pHs assayed. We can conclude that plasmid transfer by conjugation can take place within a wide range of conditions, even in such adverse conditions as the absence of nutrients and low temperatures.     

Recombinant plasmid associated cell aggregation and high-frequency conjugation of Streptococcus lactis ML3

Lactose-positive (Lac+) transconjugants resulting from matings between Streptococcus lactic ML3 and S. lactis LM2301 possess a single plasmid of approximately 60 megadaltons (Mdal) which is nearly twice the size of the lactose plasmid of the donor. The majority of these Lac+ transconjugants aggregated in broth and were able to transfer lactose-fermenting ability at a frequency higher than 10(-1) per donor on milk agar plates or in broth. Lac+ transconjugants which did not clump conjugated at a much lower frequency. Lactose-negative derivatives of Lac+ clumping transconjugants did not aggregate in broth and were missing the 60-Mdal plasmid. The ability to aggregates in broth was very unstable. Strains could lose the ability to clump but retain lactose-fermenting ability. The majority of these Lac+ nonclumping derivatives of clumping transconjugants contained a plasmid of approximately 33 Mdal, the size of the lactose plasmid of the original donor ML3. These strains transferred lactose-fermenting ability at a frequency of approximately 10(-6) per donor, resulting in both Lac+ clumping transconjugants which contained a 60-Mdal plasmid and Lac+ nonclumping transconjugants which possessed a 33-Mdal plasmid. Our results suggest that the genes responsible for cell aggregation and high-frequency conjugation are on the segment of deoxyribonucleic acid which recombined with the 33-Mdal lactose plasmid in S. lactis ML3.     

Determination of plasmid transfer frequency in soil: Consequences of bacterial mating on selective agar media

The possible occurrence of bacterial matings on transconjugant-selective plates used in experiments aimed at assessing conjugal transfer in soil was investigated. Matings on transconjugant-selective plates (with rifampicin, streptomycin, tetracycline, and kanamycin) between donor and recipient cells were shown to occur depending on the number of parent cells. Temperature also influenced conjugation frequencies on agar plates, since a lower temperature resulted in a decreased number of transconjugants. The use of nalidixic acid instead of streptomycin in conjunction with rifampicin for donor counter selection inhibited conjugation on selective plates. Conjugation in soil was analyzed by plating on selective media with nalidixic acid or streptomycin. The results indicated that conjugation in bentonite- or nutrient-amended soil was readily detected; however, part of the transconjugants could be assigned to be the result of matings on the selective plates. Conjugation was also stimulated in the presence of plant roots. Colony hybridization experiments confirmed the presence of plasmid RP4 in the transconjugants.     

Transfer of Tn925 and plasmids between Bacillus subtilis and alkaliphilic Bacillus firmus OF4 during Tn925-mediated conjugation.

Conjugative transposon Tn925 was transferred to alkaliphilic Bacillus firmus OF4 during mating experiments, as monitored by the acquisition of tetracycline resistance at pH 7.5 and confirmed by Southern analysis of chromosomal DNA from transconjugants. Tetracycline resistance could not be demonstrated at pH 10.5, but transconjugants retained resistance upon growth at pH 7.5 after having grown for several generations at pH 10. When the Bacillus subtilis donor strain contained plasmids, either pUB110 or pTV1, in addition to Tn925, transfer of the plasmid to the alkaliphile occurred during conjugation, either together with or independently of the transfer of the transposon. The plasmids were stable in B. firmus OF4, expressing their resistance markers for kanamycin or chloramphenicol at pH 7.5 after growth of the transformants at high pH. Transconjugant B. firmus OF4, which carried Tn925, could serve as the donor in mating experiments with B. subtilis lacking the transposon. These studies establish a basis for initiation of genetic studies in this alkaliphilic Bacillus species, including the introduction of cloned genes and the use of transposon-mediated insertional mutagenesis.     

Determination of conjugation rates on solid surfaces

A cytometric method for the estimation of end-point conjugation rates is developed and adapted to surface conjugation. This method improves the through-put of conjugation assays based on replica-plating and results in less noisy experimental data. Although conjugation on solid surfaces deviates from ideal conditions in which cells are continuously mixed, results show that, within the limits of high initial population densities and short mating times, end-point estimates of the conjugation rates are robust measurements. They are independent of the donor/recipient ratios and, to some extent, of the sampling time. Remixing the mating population in the course of a conjugation experiment results in a boost in the frequency of transconjugants.