Step changes in end-tidal CO2: methods and implications.

A dynamic end-tidal forcing technique for producing step changes in end-tidal CO2 with end-tidal O2 held constant independent of the ventilation response or the mixed venous return is introduced for characterizing the human ventilation response to end-tidal CO2 step changes for both normoxic (PAO2 = 125 Torr) and hypoxic (PAO2 = 60 Torr) conditions. The ventilation response approaches a steady state within 5 min. In normoxia, the on-transient is faster than the off-transient, presumably reflecting the action of cerebral blood flow. The hypoxic step response is faster than the normoxic response presumably reflecting the increased contribution from the carotid body. The delay in the ventilation response after the change in end-tidal CO2 is less in hypoxia than in normoxia and reflects the action of a transport delay and that of a virtual delay. These delays are interpreted with respect to the high-frequency phase shift data for the same subject, generated using sinusoidal end-tidal forcing. The methods of others for experiments utilizing step changes in inspired CO2 are considered with respect to our methods.     

Respiration during recovery from exercise: effects of trapping and release of femoral blood flow

To investigate the contribution of vascular and metabolic stimuli to the sustained hyperpnea after exercise, the respiratory effects of obstructing and then releasing the femoral blood flow were recorded in 15 normal volunteers during recovery from steady-state cycle exercise (80 W). Obstruction was achieved using cuffs around the upper thighs, inflated for the first 2 min of recovery to a pressure of 200 mmHg. Cuff inflation significantly reduced ventilation during recovery compared with control (P less than 0.001); the subsequent release of pressure was accompanied by an increase in ventilation (averaging 3.2 l/min), which began on the first breath after release. This preceded a rise in end-tidal CO2 (maximum 8.3 Torr increase), which first became significant on the fourth breath after release and led to a further rise in ventilation. The first-breath increase in ventilation after cuff release persisted, although slightly attenuated (averaging 2.5 l/min), in additional experiments with inspired O2 fraction of 1.0. The pattern of ventilatory response was also similar when the experiments were performed with 5% CO2 in air as the inspirate. The immediate rise in ventilation on cuff release, together with the persistent response on 100% O2, suggests that the vascular changes resulting from cuff release exert an influence on ventilation independent of the effects of released metabolites on the known chemoreceptors. The persistence of the response on 5% CO2 indicates that CO2-sensitive lung afferents do not have a major role in these responses.     

Analysis of factors that influence rates of carbon monoxide uptake, distribution, and washout from blood and extravascular tissues using a multicompartment model.

To better understand factors that influence carbon monoxide (CO) washout rates, we utilized a multicompartment mathematical model to predict rates of CO uptake, distribution in vascular and extravascular (muscle vs. other soft tissue) compartments, and washout over a range of exposure and washout conditions with varied subject-specific parameters. We fitted this model to experimental data from 15 human subjects, for whom subject-specific parameters were known, multiple washout carboxyhemoglobin (COHb) levels were available, and CO exposure conditions were identical, to investigate the contributions of exposure conditions and individual variability to CO washout from blood. We found that CO washout from venous blood was biphasic and that postexposure times at which COHb samples were obtained significantly influenced the calculated CO half times (P < 0.0001). The first, more rapid, phase of CO washout from the blood reflected the loss of CO to the expired air and to a slow uptake by the muscle compartment, whereas the second, slower washout phase was attributable to CO flow from the muscle compartment back to the blood and removal from blood via the expired air. When the model was used to predict the effects of varying exposure conditions for these subjects, the CO exposure duration, concentration, peak COHb levels, and subject-specific parameters each influenced washout half times. Blood volume divided by ventilation correlated better with half-time predictions than did cardiac output, muscle mass, or ventilation, but it explained only approximately 50% of half-time variability. Thus exposure conditions, COHb sampling times, and individual parameters should be considered when estimating CO washout rates for poisoning victims.     

Computer simulation of experiments in responses to intravenous and inhaled CO2

A simulation of ventilatory responses to infused and inhaled CO2 at controlled cardiac output and high and low levels of neural excitation mimics comparable experiments in animals. The model suggests that at low levels of endogenous and exogenous CO2 load the alert quiescent animal will show hyperpnea to both test states associated with hypercapnia. The nonalert quiescent animal simulated will show an isocapnic response to endogenous load and hypercapnic response to exogenous load. The explanation of this behavior lies in the model formulation, which allows the neural signal from metabolically active sources to drive the proportional component of the controller below an operating level established by its set point. By this reasoning the excited but metabolically inactive animal should be paradoxically less sensitive to small changes in CO2, whether exogenous or endogenous, than the quiescent animal. The model demonstrates further that a neural "exercise" signal in proportion to venous return better simulates observations in which CO2 load and venous return are dissociated than one in which the neural signal is computed from metabolism. The use of delta V/delta P slopes as estimates of sensitivity go awry in experiment and simulation when blood flow, CO2 level, and neural excitatory state are dissociated. This is particularly true when the organism is operating at and below the hypothesized set point.     

A mathematical model of CO2 effect on cardiovascular regulation

The effect of changes in arterial CO2 tension on the cardiovascular system is analyzed by means of a mathematical model. The model is an extension of a previous one that already incorporated the main reflex and local mechanisms triggered by O2 changes. The new aspects covered by the model are the O2-CO2 interaction at the peripheral chemoreceptors, the effect of local CO2 changes on peripheral resistances, the direct central neural system (CNS) response to CO2, and the control of central chemoreceptors on ventilation and tidal volume. A statistical comparison between model simulation results and various experimental data has been performed. This comparison suggests that the model is able to simulate the acute cardiovascular response to changes in blood gas content in a variety of conditions (normoxic hypercapnia, hypercapnia during artificial ventilation, hypocapnic hypoxia, and hypercapnic hypoxia). The model ascribes the observed responses to the complex superimposition of many mechanisms simultaneously working (baroreflex, peripheral chemoreflex, CNS response, lung-stretch receptors, local gas tension effect), which may be differently activated depending on the specific stimulus under study. However, although some experiments can be reproduced using a single basal set of parameters, reproduction of other experiments requires a different combination of the mechanism strengths (particularly, a different strength of the local CO2 mechanism on peripheral resistances and of the CNS response to CO2). Starting from these results, some assumptions to explain the striking differences reported in the literature are presented. The model may represent a valid support for the interpretation of physiological data on acute cardiovascular regulation and may favor the synthesis of contradictory results into a single theoretical setting.     

Effect of ventilation on pulmonary blood volume of the fetal lamb.

Blood volume changes in the fetal lung following the onset of ventilation were studied by isotopic measurement of red blood cell and plasma volume in rapidly frozen lungs of ten near term fetal lambs. Total pulmonary blood volumes of fetal lambs ventilated with 3% O2 and 7% CO2 in nitrogen (so that blood gas levels were little changed from fetal values), or with air, were compared with measurements in unventilated lambs. Regional correlations of blood volume and blood flow (measured with isotope-labeled microemboli) within the lungs were also examined. Total pulmonary blood volume averaged 5.6 ml/kg body weight in unventilated fetal lambs and was approximately 43% greated in fetal lambs after 5-20 min of air ventilation, but not significantly different in lambs ventilated with 3% O2 and 7% CO2 in nitrogen. Thus it is ventilation with air, rather than the introduction of gas into the alveoli, which enlarges the fetal pulmonary vascular bed. Regional pulmonary blood volume and blood flow were correlated, though poorly, in air-ventilated lungs, but not in lungs ventilated with 3% O2 and 7% CO2 in nitrogen; this suggests that a common factor may operate to increase both blood flow and blood volume in the fetal lung following the introduction of air.     

Extracorporeal CO2-removal: pulmonary and extracorporeal equilibria in dogs and sheep

Extracorporeal CO2-removal promises to be an efficient alternative to the conservative treatment of advanced lung diseases. Extracorporeal CO2-removal is achieved in a veno-venous bypass in combination with low frequency ventilation. Positive clinical results in the treatment of adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) are encouraging. In order to prove the applicability of this method to different kinds of respiratory insufficiency, physiological studies using animal models are necessary. We report here on experiments with dogs and sheep undergoing a veno-venous bypass employing a CO2-eliminator. The experimental results are compared with theoretical values which predict the important relationships between blood flow rate of the extracorporeal circulation (ECC), the CO2-elimination capacity of the CO2-eliminator and the low ventilation rate (down to apnea for 5 h) of the natural lung. It was shown that the blood gas data as well as acid base status could be maintained within physiological ranges.     

Cardiac receptors evoke ventilatory response with increased venous PCO2 at constant arterial PCO2

The effects of elevated venous PCO2 and denervation of the cardiac ventricles on ventilation were studied in 20 anesthetized open-chest unidirectionally ventilated White Leghorn cockerels. Venous PCO2 was increased by insufflating the gut with high CO2 while recording changes in the amplitude of the sternal movements. Arterial blood gases were held constant by unidirectionally ventilating the lungs with gas flows approximately five times the animal's resting minute volume. Insufflating the gut with 90% N2-10% O2 did not change the level of ventilation, whereas with 90% CO2-10% O2 the amplitude of sternal movement increased 500% above that with no gut gas flow. Exchange of N2 for the CO2 was followed by a rapid reduction of ventilatory movements to control levels. Arterial blood gases remained constant during gut gas insufflation, whereas mixed venous PCO2 increased and mixed venous pH decreased when high CO2 was given to the gut. Cutting the middle cardiac nerves, which primarily innervate the ventricles of the heart, reduced the ventilatory response to CO2 gut insufflation by 67%. Sympathetic denervation of the thoracic viscera did not change the responses. It appears that, in the chicken, increasing the mixed venous PCO2 while holding the arterial blood gases constant alters ventilation by an afferent system located in the venous circulation or in the right ventricle which is sensitive to changes in PCO2.     

Measurement and analysis of gas exchange during exercise using a programmable calculator

Although exercise testing is useful in the diagnosis and management of cardiovascular and pulmonary diseases, a rapid comprehensive method for measurement of ventilation and gas exchange has been limited to expensive complex computer-based systems. We devised a relatively inexpensive, technically simple, and clinically oriented exercise system built around a desktop calculator. This system automatically collects and analyzes data on a breath-by-breath basis. Our calculator system overcomes the potential inaccuracies of gas exchange measurement due to water vapor dilution and mismatching of expired flow and gas concentrations. We found no difference between the calculator-derived minute ventilation, CO2 production, O2 consumption, and respiratory exchange ratio and the values determined from simultaneous mixed expired gas collections in 30 constant-work-rate exercise studies. Both tabular and graphic displays of minute ventilation, CO2 production, O2 consumption, respiratory exchange ratio, heart rate, end-tidal O2 tension, end-tidal CO2 tension, and arterial blood gas value are included for aid in the interpretation of clinical exercise tests.     

Pulmonary circulation in different gaseous media

The ultrasonic method was used in acute experiments on cats with an open (under artificial lung ventilation) and closed chest to explore lung circulation in a changed gaseous medium. Moderate hypoxia (10% O2) and hypercapnia (5, 10% CO2) induce a 10-15% decrease in the lung blood flow in the inferolobular pulmonary artery in the presence of unchanged or slightly elevated minute volume of the heart. The higher hypoxia (5% O2) provokes inconclusive changes in the lung blood flow: biphasic response or increase. It is assumed that considerable elevation of blood pressure in the common pulmonary artery in all the cases points to vasoconstriction that occurs under the effect of hypoxia and hypercapnia.     

Respiratory adaptation to chronic hypercapnia in newborn rats

We asked 1) whether newborn rats respond to chronic hypercapnia with a persistent increase in ventilation and 2) whether changes in lung mass were accompanying the respiratory adaptation to chronic hypercapnia, as previously observed during neonatal chronic hypoxia. Five litters of rats were kept in 7% CO2 (with 21% O2) from day 1 to 7 after birth (CO2exp) and compared with six litters of control rats growing in normocapnia-normoxia (C). Body weight was similar between the two groups. Ventilation, measured by flow plethysmography, increased in CO2exp from day 2 and remained steadily elevated, and at day 7 it almost doubled (174%) the C value because of the large increase in tidal volume and mean inspiratory flow (192 and 189%, respectively) with no changes in respiratory frequency. Two days after return to normocapnia, ventilation was still 33% higher than in C; at this time, acute exposure to hypercapnia increased ventilation relatively less in the CO2exp than in C because of a lower increase in tidal volume. Neither the lung weight-to-body weight nor the heart weight-to-body weight ratios increased in CO2exp. We conclude that 1) chronic hypercapnia in newborn rats induces a steady increase in ventilation, which persists at least 2 days after return to normocapnia with a reduction in the acute response to CO2, and 2) hyperventilation per se is not the cause of the increased lung mass observed during chronic neonatal hypoxia.     

Ventilatory responses to intravenous and airway CO2 administration in anesthetized dogs

The ventilatory responses to steady-state venous CO2 loading (iv CO2) and CO2 inhalation have been observed in chloralose-urethan-anesthetized dogs. Intravenous CO2 was administered by increasing the CO2 fraction of gas ventilating a membrane gas exchanger in an arteriovenous bypass; blood flow rate was fixed at 30 ml/min. During the study, we identified a time-dependent hyperventilation in all 14 experimentally treated dogs and in 4 additional sham-treated dogs. When we tested 8 of these animals with a protocol having small progressive increments in iv CO2 loading rate, we observed a response approaching isocapnia during iv CO2 and a large hypocapnia when we returned to control conditions. The use of a randomized protocol in 6 animals demonstrated the necessity of accounting for this systematic base-line shift, because before doing so the response depended more on the passage of time than on the nature of the CO2 load. After this analytical adjustment was made, there was no significant difference between the respiratory controller gains (delta nu E/delta Paco2) for inhaled and iv CO2.     

Ventilatory responses to increased blood flow and decreased lung volume in awake dogs

The effect of decreased lung volume on ventilatory responses to arteriovenous fistula-induced increased cardiac output was studied in four chronic awake dogs. Lung volume decreases were imposed by application of continuous negative-pressure breathing of -10 cmH2O to the trachea. The animals were surgically prepared with chronic tracheostomy, indwelling carotid artery catheter, and bilateral arteriovenous femoral shunts. Control arteriovenous blood flow was 0.5 l/min, and test flow level was 2.0 l/min. Arterial blood CO2 tension (PaCO2) was continuously monitored using an indwelling Teflon membrane mass spectrometer catheter, and inhaled CO2 was given to maintain isocapnia throughout. Increased fistula flow alone led to a mean 52% increase in cardiac output (CO), whereas mean systemic arterial blood pressure (Psa) fell 4% (P less than 0.01). Negative-pressure breathing alone raised Psa by 3% (P less than 0.005) without a significant change in CO. Expired minute ventilation (VE) increased by 27% (P less than 0.005) from control in both of these conditions separately. Combined increased flow and negative pressure led to a 50% increase in CO and 56% increase in VE (P less than 0.0025) without any significant change in Psa. Effects of decreased lung volume and increased CO appeared to be additive with respect to ventilation and to occur under conditions of constant PaCO2 and Psa. Because both decreased lung volume and increased CO occur during normal exercise, these results suggest that mechanisms other than chemical regulation may play an important role in the control of breathing and contribute new insights into the isocapnic exercise hyperpnea phenomenon.     

Estimation of amount of stationary pulmonary blood from carbon monoxide uptake measurements

A mathematical model of CO uptake from a single alveolus is modified to include stationary pulmonary blood arising from a pulmonary vascular obstruction. From this model an estimator model is developed that produces simultaneous estimations of the diffusing capacity of the lung for CO and the fraction of the pulmonary capillary blood that is stationary. The estimator model was tested using simulated data from uniform and non-uniform simulators and found to be only mildly sensitive to noise and incorrect values for the pulmonary capillary blood volume. Both the estimator model and breath-to-breath changes in the diffusing capacity of the lung for CO (exhaled) were found to be greatly affected by inhomogeneity of diffusing capacity and ventilation. At times both returned false positive results that limit their use as a screening test for stationary pulmonary blood. Although changes in CO uptake may at times indicate the presence of stationary pulmonary blood, the confounding effects of inhomogeneity of ventilation and diffusing capacity make the use of such changes impractical under most circumstances.     

Almitrine bismesylate and the central and peripheral ventilatory response to CO2

Effects of almitrine bismesylate on the peripheral and central chemoreflex to a CO2 challenge during normoxia were studied in nine alpha-chloralose-urethan anesthetized cats. With the dynamic end-tidal CO2 forcing technique the ventilatory response after a square-wave change in end-tidal PCO2 (PETCO2) was partitioned into a central and a peripheral part using a two-compartment model. With almitrine administered intravenously (0.6 mg/kg followed by a maintenance dose of 0.4 mg.kg-1 X h-1) the CO2 sensitivity of the peripheral chemoreflex increased on the average from 0.315 to 0.564 l.min-1 X kPa-1 (P less than 0.001, 6 cats, 73 runs), whereas the CO2 sensitivity of the central chemoreflex remained the same (P = 0.87). The extrapolated PETCO2 at zero ventilation (apneic threshold) of the (total) steady-state response curve decreased on the average from 3.50 to 2.36 kPa (P less than 0.001). With the artificial brain stem perfusion technique it was confirmed that almitrine did not affect ventilation by administering it to the blood perfusing the brain stem. We conclude that almitrine bismesylate during normoxia enhances the CO2 sensitivity of the peripheral chemoreflex loop and decreases the apneic threshold due to an action located outside the brain stem.     

Role of VCO2 in control of breathing of awake exercising dogs

Steady-state ventilatory responses to CO2 inhalation, intravenous CO2 loading (loading), and intravenous CO2 unloading (unloading) were measured in chronic awake dogs while they exercised on an air-conditioned treadmill at 3 mph and 0% grade. End-tidal PO2 was maintained at control levels by manipulation of inspired gas. Responses obtained in three dogs demonstrated that the response to CO2 loading [average increase in CO2 output (Vco2) of 216 ml/min or 35%] was a hypercapnic hyperpnea in every instance. Also, the response to CO2 unloading [average decrease in Vco2 of 90 ml/min or 15% decrease] was a hypocapnic hypopnea in every case. Also, the analysis of the data by directional statistics indicates that there was no difference in the slopes of the responses (change in expiratory ventilation divided by change in arterial Pco2) for loading, unloading, and inhalation. These results indicate that the increased CO2 flow to the lung that occurs in exercise does not provide a direct signal to the respiratory controller that accounts for the exercise hyperpnea. Therefore, other mechanisms must be important in the regulation of ventilation during exercise.     

Intrapulmonary Co2 receptors and ventilatory response to lung Co2 loading

The possible role of intrapulmonary CO2 receptors (IPC) in arterial CO2 partial pressure (PaCO2) homeostasis was investigated by comparing the arterial blood gas and ventilatory responses to CO2 loading via the inspired gas and via the venous blood. Adult male Pekin ducks were decerebrated 1 wk prior to an experiment. Venous CO2 loading was accomplished with a venovenous extracorporeal blood circuit that included a silicone-membrane blood oxygenator. The protocol randomized four states: control (no loading), venous CO2 loading, inspired CO2 loading, and venous CO2 unloading. Intravenous and inspired loading both resulted in hypercapnic hyperpnea. Comparison of the ventilatory sensitivity (delta VE/delta PaCO2) showed no significant difference between the two loading regimes. Likewise, venous CO2 unloading led to a significant hypocapnic hypopnea. Sensitivity to changes in PaCO2 could explain the response of ventilation under these conditions. The ventilatory pattern, however, was differentially sensitive to the route of CO2 loading; inspired CO2 resulted in slower deeper breathing than venous loading. It is concluded that IPC play a minor role in adjusting ventilation to match changes in pulmonary CO2 flux but rather are involved in pattern determination.     

Cardiopulmonary control during exercise in the duck

To determine the importance of nonhumoral drives to exercise hyperpnea in birds, we exercised adult White Pekin ducks on a treadmill (3 degrees incline) at 1.44 km X h-1 for 15 min during unidirectional artificial ventilation. Intrapulmonary gas concentrations and arterial blood gases could be regulated with this ventilation procedure while allowing ventilatory effort to be measured during both rest and exercise. Ducks were ventilated with gases containing either 4.0 or 5.0% CO2 in 19% O2 (balance N2) at a flow rate of 12 l X min-1. At that flow rate, arterial CO2 partial pressure (PaCO2) could be maintained within +/- 2 Torr of resting values throughout exercise. Arterial O2 partial pressure did not change significantly with exercise. Heart rate, mean arterial blood pressure, and mean right ventricular pressure increased significantly during exercise. On the average, minute ventilation (used as an indicator of the output from the central nervous system) increased approximately 400% over resting levels because of an increase in both tidal volume and respiratory frequency. CO2-sensitivity curves were obtained for each bird during rest. If the CO2 sensitivity remained unchanged during exercise, then the observed 1.5 Torr increase in PaCO2 during exercise would account for only about 6% of the total increase in ventilation over resting levels. During exercise, arterial [H+] increased approximately 4 nmol X l-1; this increase could account for about 18% of the total rise in ventilation. We conclude that only a minor component of the exercise hyperpnea in birds can be accounted for by a humoral mechanism; other factors, possibly from muscle afferents, appear responsible for most of the hyperpnea observed in the running duck.     

Rate of rise of intrapulmonary CO2 drives breathing frequency in garter snakes.

Garter snakes increase ventilation in response to elevated venous PCO2 without a concomitant rise in arterial PCO2 (Furilla et al. Respir. Physiol. 83: 47-60, 1991). Elevating venous PCO2 will increase the PCO2 gradient between pulmonary arterial blood and intrapulmonary gas during inspiration, leading to a greater rate of rise of intrapulmonary CO2 after inspiration. Because the lung contains CO2-sensitive receptors, I assessed the effect of the rate of rise of intrapulmonary CO2 on ventilation in unidirectionally ventilated snakes. CO2 concentration was altered using a digital gas mixer connected to a personal computer. Breathing frequency was highly correlated with the rate of rise intrapulmonary CO2 but only slightly affected by peak intrapulmonary CO2. On the other hand, tidal volume was more closely related to peak intrapulmonary CO2 than to the rate of rise of CO2. Bilateral pulmonary or cervical vagotomy nearly eliminated the ventilatory response associated with altered CO2 rise times but had little influence on the tidal volume response to the rate of rise of CO2. The mechanism whereby breathing frequency is controlled by the rate of rise of intrapulmonary CO2 is likely to originate with intrapulmonary chemoreceptors and may be important in the control of breathing during exercise.     

Ventilatory response of intact cats to carbon monoxide hypoxia

Adult intact conscious or anesthetized cats have been exposed to either hypoxia or low concentrations of CO in air. In addition, the ventilatory response to CO2 was studied in air, hypoxic hypoxia, and CO hypoxia. The results show that 1) in conscious cats, low concentrations of CO (0.15%) induce a slight decrease in ventilation and higher concentrations of CO (0.20%) induce first a small decrease in ventilation and then a characteristic tachypnea similar to the hypoxic tachypnea described in carotid-denervated cats; 2) in anesthetized cats, CO hypoxia induces only mild changes in ventilation; and 3) the ventilatory response to CO2 is increased in CO hypoxia in both conscious and anesthetized animals but differs from the increase observed during hypoxia. It is concluded that the initial decrease in ventilation may be caused by some brain stem depression of the respiratory centers with CO hypoxia, whereas the tachypnea originates probably at some suprapontine level. Conversely, the possible central acidosis may account for the potentiation of the ventilatory response to CO2 observed in either conscious or anesthetized animals.