Structure of lipid bilayers

The quantitative experimental uncertainty in the structure of fully hydrated, biologically relevant, fluid (L(alpha)) phase lipid bilayers has been too large to provide a firm base for applications or for comparison with simulations. Many structural methods are reviewed including modern liquid crystallography of lipid bilayers that deals with the fully developed undulation fluctuations that occur in the L(alpha) phase. These fluctuations degrade the higher order diffraction data in a way that, if unrecognized, leads to erroneous conclusions regarding bilayer structure. Diffraction measurements at high instrumental resolution provide a measure of these fluctuations. In addition to providing better structural determination, this opens a new window on interactions between bilayers, so the experimental determination of interbilayer interaction parameters is reviewed briefly. We introduce a new structural correction based on fluctuations that has not been included in any previous studies. Updated measurements, such as for the area compressibility modulus, are used to provide adjustments to many of the literature values of structural quantities. Since the gel (L(beta)') phase is valuable as a stepping stone for obtaining fluid phase results, a brief review is given of the lower temperature phases. The uncertainty in structural results for lipid bilayers is being reduced and best current values are provided for bilayers of five lipids.     

Softening of lipid bilayers

The softening of wet lipid bilayer membranes during their gel-to-fluid first-order phase transition is studied by computer simulation of a family of two-dimensional microscopic interaction models. The models include a variable number, q, of lipid chain conformational states, where 2q10. Results are presented as functions of q and temperature for a number of bulk properties, such as internal energy, specific heat, and lateral compressibility. A quantitative account is given of the statistics of the lipid clusters which are found to form in the neighborhood of the transition. The occurrence of these clusters is related to the softening and the strong thermal density fluctuations which dominate the specific heat and the lateral compressibility for the high-q models. The cluster distributions and the fluctuations behave in a manner reminiscent of critical phenomena and percolation. The findings of long-lived metastable states and extremely slow relaxational behavior in the transition region are shown to be caused by the presence of intermediate lipid chain conformational states which kinetically stabilize the cluster distribution and the effective phase coexistence. This has as its macroscopic consequence that the first-order transition apperas as a continuous transition, as invariably observed in all experiments on uncharged lecithin bilayer membranes. The results also suggest an explanation of the non-horizontal isotherms of lipid monolayers. Possible implications of lipid bilayer softening and enhanced passive permeability for the functioning of biological membranes are discussed.Abbreviations PC phosphatidvlcholine - DMPC dimyristoyl PC - DPPC dipalmitoyl PC - ac alternating current - DSC differential scanning calorimetry - T _m lipid gel-to-fluid phase transition temperature - TEMPO 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine-N-oxyl Supported by the Danish Natural Science Research Council and A/S De Danske Spritfabrikkers JubilæumslegatSupported in part by the NSERC of Canada and Le FCAC du Quebec     

Structure of fully hydrated fluid phase lipid bilayers with monounsaturated chains

Quantitative structures are obtained at 30 degrees C for the fully hydrated fluid phases of palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine (POPC), with a double bond on the sn-2 hydrocarbon chain, and for dierucoylphosphatidylcholine (di22:1PC), with a double bond on each hydrocarbon chain. The form factors F(qz) for both lipids are obtained using a combination of three methods. (1) Volumetric measurements provide F(0). (2) X-ray scattering from extruded unilamellar vesicles provides /F(qz)/ for low q(z). (3) Diffuse X-ray scattering from oriented stacks of bilayers provides /F(qz)/ for high q(z). Also, data using method (2) are added to our recent data for dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) using methods (1) and (3); the new DOPC data agree very well with the recent data and with (4) our older data obtained using a liquid crystallographic X-ray method. We used hybrid electron density models to obtain structural results from these form factors. The result for area per lipid (A) for DOPC 72.4 +/- 0.5 A(2) agrees well with our earlier publications, and we find A = 69.3 +/- 0.5 A2 for di22:1PC and A = 68.3 +/- 1.5 A2 for POPC. We obtain the values for five different average thicknesses: hydrophobic, steric, head-head, phosphate-phosphate and Luzzati. Comparison of the results for these three lipids and for our recent dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) determination provides quantitative measures of the effect of unsaturation on bilayer structure. Our results suggest that lipids with one monounsaturated chain have quantitative bilayer structures closer to lipids with two monounsaturated chains than to lipids with two completely saturated chains.     

Functional tethered lipid bilayers

Our strategy to provide the structural basis for the build-up of functional tethered membranes focuses on three approaches: the first one is based on the pre-organization of a monomolecular layer of a lipopolymer at the water/air interface which is then transferred to a solid support. Prior to deposition, the substrate is coated with a layer of benzophenone-derivatized silane molecules that allow for a stable covalent attachment by photo-cross-linking of some of the monomer units of the lipopolymer to the support. An alternative concept realizes a layer-by-layer deposition of the various structural elements: (1) the attachment layer with the reactive sites for the chemical stabilization; (2) a polymer 'cushion' prepared by adsorption and simultaneous or subsequent partial covalent binding to the reactive sites; and (3) a lipid monolayer transferred from the water/air interface, that contains a certain amount of lipids with reactive headgroups which, upon binding to the polymer tether, act as anchor lipids stabilizing the whole monolayer/cushion-composite. And finally, we build peptide-supported monolayers by first (self-) assembling amino acid sequences of various lengths via a SH-group near their N-terminus onto Au substances and use then their COO(-)-terminus to chemically attach phosphatidyl-ethanolamine lipids to form a stable monolayer of lipid-peptide conjugates. All the individual preparation steps and the various resulting (multi-) layers are characterized by surface plasmon spectroscopy, X-ray and neutron-reflectometry, contact angle measurements, IR spectroscopy, fluorescence microscopy, scanning probe microscopies, as well as, electrochemical techniques. For all tethering systems, the final membranes' architecture is obtained by fusing lipid vesicles onto the lipid monolayer. Proteins can be incorporated by either fusing vesicles that are loaded with the respective receptors, pores, or ion pumps via a reconstitution procedure, or via a transfer directly from a micellar solution to the pre-formed lipid bilayer at the solid support by a dialysis step. Two structural/dynamical features of tethered membranes which are considered to be of particular functional relevance, i.e. the degree of water uptake and, hence, the degree of swelling of the polymer support, as well as the lateral mobility of the lipid molecules in the membrane, are tested by surface plasmon optics and by measurements of the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP), respectively. The results confirm that the presented preparation protocols yield fluid bilayers that mimic certain relevant properties of biological membranes. The functional characterization of tethered membranes, which is briefly summarized, is based on various electrochemical techniques, in particular, impedance spectroscopy, cyclic voltammetry, and chronoamperometric studies. The results obtained for reconstituted H(+)-ATPase from chloroplasts and E. coli and for cytochrome oxidase (with and without cytochrome c) confirm the incorporation of the proteins in an active form, thus, opening opportunities for novel sensor formats or offering a completely new model membrane system.     

Structure stability of lytic peptides during their interactions with lipid bilayers.

In this work, molecular dynamics simulations were used to examine the consequences of a variety of analogs of cecropin A on lipid bilayers. Analog sequences were constructed by replacing either the N- or C-terminal helix with the other helix in native or reverse sequence order, by making palindromic peptides based on both the N- and C-terminal helices, and by deleting the hinge region. The structure of the peptides was monitored throughout the simulation. The hinge region appeared not to assist in maintaining helical structure but help in motion flexibility. In general, the N-terminal helix of peptides was less stable than the C-terminal one during the interaction with anionic lipid bilayers. Sequences with hydrophobic helices tended to regain helical structure after an initial loss while sequences with amphipathic helices were less able to do this. The results suggests that hydrophobic design peptides have a high structural stability in an anionic membrane and are the candidates for experimental investigation.     

Proton permeation of lipid bilayers

Proton permeation of the lipid bilayer barrier has two unique features. First, permeability coefficients measured at neutral pH ranges are six to seven orders of magnitude greater than expected from knowledge of other monovalent cations. Second, proton conductance across planar lipid bilayers varies at most by a factor of 10 when pH is varied from near 1 to near 11. Two mechanisms have been proposed to account for this anomalous behavior: proton conductance related to contaminants of lipid bilayers, and proton translocation along transient hydrogen-bonded chains (tHBC) of associated water molecules in the membrane. The weight of evidence suggests that trace contaminants may contribute to proton conductance across planar lipid membranes at certain pH ranges, but cannot account for the anomalous proton flux in liposome systems.Two new results will be reported here which were designed to test the tHBC model. These include measurements of relative proton/potassium permeability in the gramicidin channel, and plots of proton flux against the magnitude of pH gradients. (1) The relative permeabilities of protons and potassium through the gramicidin channel, which contains a single strand of hydrogenbonded water molecules, were found to differ by at least four orders of magnitude when measured at neutral pH ranges. This result demonstrates that a hydrogen-bonded chain of water molecules can provide substantial discrimination between protons and other cations. It was also possible to calculate that if approximately 7% of bilayer water was present in a transient configuration similar to that of the gramicidin channel, it could account for the measured proton flux. (2) The plot of proton conductance against pH gradient across liposome membranes was superlinear, a result that is consistent with one of three alternative tHBC models for proton conductance described by Nagle elsewhere in this volume.     

Structure of polymerizable lipid bilayers: water profile of a diacetylenic lipid bilayer using elastic neutron scattering

Elastic neutron scattering experiments have been used to study the hydration of multibilayers of 1,2-bis(10,12-tricosadiynoyl)-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DC8,9PC). Previously published FTIR spectroscopic data had suggested, based on shifts in the carbonyl (C = O) stretch frequencies, that the phosphocholine headgroup in these polymerizable lipid bilayers was much less hydrated than that of saturated phosphatidylcholines. Our results demonstrate that the DC8,9PC headgroup is at least as well hydrated as that of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC), a saturated lipid, under the same conditions.     

Cholestryl-phosphoryl-choline in lipid bilayers.

Cholesteryl-phosphoryl-choline (CPC), a hybrid between cholesterol and lecithin, is incorporated into sonicated liposomes and erythrocyte membranes similarly to cholesterol. The effect of CPC on lipid microviscosity and degree of order is smaller, but not significantly than that of cholesterol. It is proposed that CPC may be employed as an efficient modulator of lipid dynamics.     

Surface potential determination in planar lipid bilayers: a simplification of the conductance-ratio method

One of the methods available for the measurement of surface potentials of planar lipid bilayers uses the conductance ratio between a charged and a neutral bilayer doped with ionophores to calculate the surface potential of the charged bilayer. We have devised a simplification of that method which does not require the use of an electrically neutral bilayer as control. The conductance of the charged bilayer is measured before and after the addition of divalent cations (Ba(2+)) to the bathing solution. Ba(2+) ions screen fixed surface charges, decreasing the surface potential. If the membrane is negatively charged the screening has the effect of decreasing the membrane conductance to cations. The resulting conductance ratio is used to calculate the surface potential change, which is fed into an iterative computer program. The program generates pairs of surface potential values and calculates the surface charge density for the two conditions. Since the surface charge density remains constant during this procedure, there is only one pair of surface potentials that satisfies the condition of constant charge density. Applying this method to experimental data from McLaughlin et al. [McLaughlin, S.G.A., Szabo, G. and Eisenman, G., Divalent ions and the surface potential of charged phospholipid membranes, J. Gen. Physiol., 58 (1971) 667-687.] we have found very similar results. We have also successfully used this method to determine the effect of palmitic acid on the surface potential of asolectin membranes.     

Surface potential determination in planar lipid bilayers: A simplification of the conductance-ratio method

One of the methods available for the measurement of surface potentials of planar lipid bilayers uses the conductance ratio between a charged and a neutral bilayer doped with ionophores to calculate the surface potential of the charged bilayer. We have devised a simplification of that method which does not require the use of an electrically neutral bilayer as control. The conductance of the charged bilayer is measured before and after the addition of divalent cations (Ba²⁺) to the bathing solution. Ba²⁺ ions screen fixed surface charges, decreasing the surface potential. If the membrane is negatively charged the screening has the effect of decreasing the membrane conductance to cations. The resulting conductance ratio is used to calculate the surface potential change, which is fed into an iterative computer program. The program generates pairs of surface potential values and calculates the surface charge density for the two conditions. Since the surface charge density remains constant during this procedure, there is only one pair of surface potentials that satisfies the condition of constant charge density.Applying this method to experimental data from McLaughlin et al. [McLaughlin, S.G.A., Szabo, G. and Eisenman, G., Divalent ions and the surface potential of charged phospholipid membranes, J. Gen. Physiol., 58 (1971) 667–687.] we have found very similar results. We have also successfully used this method to determine the effect of palmitic acid on the surface potential of asolectin membranes.     

Binding of glucagon to lipid bilayers

At physiological pH and temperature, glucagon binds to liposomes composed of egg phosphatidylcholine and cholesterol (2:1 mol/mol) in a highly specific manner. The chemical reactivities of the functional groups were determined over the concentration range of 1.0 X 10(-6)-3.0 X 10(-8) M by the method of competitive labelling with 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene as the labelling reagent. At concentrations above 3 X 10(-7) M, the amino terminal histidine and the two tyrosine residues showed a marked decrease in reactivity in the presence of liposomes, but the reactivity of the Lys-12 N epsilon-amino group was unaltered. At lower concentrations the Lys-12 reactivity also decreased markedly, owing to a change in the environment of this group. These results indicated that two different forms of glucagon existed over the concentration range studied. Both in the absence and presence of liposomes the Lys-12 N epsilon-amino groups showed a transition in reactivity at 1.8 X 10(-7) M. In the presence of liposomes the other functional groups also showed a transition in reactivity at 2 X 10(-7) M but the change was much smaller. The pattern of reactivities were consistent with the X-ray crystallographic structure of the type 2 glucagon trimer being the predominant species at 10(-6) M, with free monomeric glucagon occurring at 3 X 10(-8) M. A trimerization constant of 4 X 10(13) M-2 at pH 7.5 and 37 degrees C was determined.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Interactions of hexachlorocyclohexanes with lipid bilayers

Quenching of the fluorescence of a hydrophobic analogue of tryptophan incorporated into lipid bilayers has been used to measure partition coefficients for lindane and the α- and δ-isomers of hexachlorocyclohexane. Partition coefficients between water and lipid are comparable to those between water and octanol and exhibit a negative temperature coefficient. Binding to the lipid phase is limited by saturation of the aqueous phase rather than of the lipid phase. The binding of lindane has no detectable effect on membrane fluidity as measured by fluorescence polarisation of diphenylhexatriene, or on the permeability properties of the membrane, as measured by the leak of carboxyfluorescein.     

Affinity of polyphenols for lipid bilayers

Interaction of tea catechins with lipid bilayers has been investigated with liposome systems. Epicatechin gallate had the highest affinity for lipid bilayers, followed by epigallocatechin gallate, epicatechin, and epigallocatechin. Epicatechin gallate and epigallocatechin gallate in the surface of lipid bilayer perturbed the membrane structure.     

Experimental determination and computational interpretation of biophysical properties of lipid bilayers enriched by cholesteryl hemisuccinate

Cholesteryl hemisuccinate (CHS) is one of the cholesterol-mimicking detergents not observed in nature. It is, however, widely used in protein crystallography, in biochemical studies of proteins, and in pharmacology. Here, we performed an extensive experimental and theoretical study on the behavior of CHS in lipid membranes rich in unsaturated phospholipids. We found that the deprotonated form of CHS (that is the predominant form under physiological conditions) does not mimic cholesterol very well. The protonated form of CHS does better in this regard, but also its ability to mimic the physical effects of cholesterol on lipid membranes is limited. Overall, although ordering and condensing effects characteristic to cholesterol are present in systems containing any form of CHS, their strength is appreciably weaker compared to cholesterol. Based on the considerable amount of experimental and atomistic simulation data, we conclude that these differences originate from the fact that the ester group of CHS does not anchor it in an optimal position at the water–membrane interface. The implications of these findings for considerations of protein–cholesterol interactions are briefly discussed.     

Helix-helix interactions in lipid bilayers.

Using a continuum model, we calculated the electrostatic interaction free energy between two alpha-helices in three environments: the aqueous phase, a low dielectric alkane phase, and a simple representation of a lipid bilayer. As was found in previous work, helix-helix interactions in the aqueous phase are quite weak, because of solvent screening, and slightly repulsive, because of desolvation effects that accompany helix assembly. In contrast, the interactions can be quite strong in a hypothetical alkane phase because desolvation effects are essentially nonexistent and because helix-helix interactions are not well screened. In this type of environment, the antiparallel helix orientation is strongly favored over the parallel orientation. In previous work we found that the free energy penalty associated with burying helix termini in a bilayer is quite high, which is why the termini tend to protrude into the solvent. Under these conditions the electrostatic interaction is strongly screened by solvent; indeed, it is sufficient for the termini to protrude a few angstroms from the two surfaces of the bilayer for their interaction to diminish almost completely. The effect is consistent with the classical model of the helix dipole in which the dipole moment is represented by point charges located at either terminus. Our results suggest, in agreement with previous models, that there is no significant nonspecific driving force for helix aggregation and, hence, that membrane protein folding must be driven by specific interactions such as close packing and salt-bridge and hydrogen bond formation.     

Hydrocarbon chain dynamics in lipid bilayers

A model is proposed for hydrocarbon chain dynamics in lipid bilayers. In the upper and middle parts of the chain all motion occurs by concerted rotations around at least two carbon carbon bonds at a time, preserving a structural with kinks (that is gauche^±trans gauche^? conformations) as the only deviations from the all-trans chain. At the end, independent rotations around carboncarbon bonds play a larger and larger part. This gives a reasonable interpretation of deuterium NMR data.     

Diffusion in lipid bilayers containing barriers

In epithelial cells, a barrier or tight junction restricts the diffusion of lipid probes from the apical to the basolateral side of the outer membrane bilayer. This phenomenon is studied theoretically with the diffusion equation on planar and spherical surfaces. Two models for the tight junction are considered: a penetrable barrier embedded in a monolayer and an impenetrable obstacle in the outer membrane of a bilayer than must be bypassed by flip-flopping between inner and outer membranes. The rate of passing from one side of the cell to the other is calculated for each of these models under steady state conditions. The results are compared with recent fluorescent photobleaching recovery experiments. The theoretical interpretation indicates that it would be difficult to distinguish experimentally between the flip-flop case and the barrier crossing case. Assuming a flip-flop model, large differences in the magnitude of the flip-flop rates of probes are necessary to explain the experimental results as suggested by Dragsten et al. (Dragsten, P. R., R. Blumenthal, and J. S. Handler, 1981, Nature [Lond.], 294:718--722).