Base editing in crops: current advances,limitations and future implications

Targeted mutagenesis via genome‐editing technologies holds great promise in developing improved crop varieties to meet future demands. Point mutations or single nucleotide polymorphisms often determine important agronomic traits of crops. Genome‐editing‐based single‐base changes could generate elite trait variants in crop plants which help in accelerating crop improvement. Among the genome‐editing technologies, base editing has emerged as a novel and efficient genome‐editing approach which enables direct and irreversible conversion of one target base into another in a programmable manner. A base editor is a fusion of catalytically inactive CRISPR–Cas9 domain (Cas9 variants) and cytosine or adenosine deaminase domain that introduces desired point mutations in the target region enabling precise editing of genomes. In the present review, we have summarized the development of different base‐editing platforms. Then, we have focussed on the current advances and the potential applications of this precise technology in crop improvement. The review also sheds light on the limitations associated with this technology. Finally, the future perspectives of this emerging technology towards crop improvement have been highlighted.     

Plant genome editing: ever more precise and wide reaching

Genome-editing technologies consisting of targeted mutagenesis and gene targeting enable us to modify genes of interest rapidly and precisely. The discovery in 2012 of CRISPR/Cas9 systems and their development as sequence-specific nucleases has brought about a paradigm shift in biology. Initially, CRISPR/Cas9 was applied in targeted mutagenesis to knock out a target gene. Thereafter, advances in genome-editing technologies using CRISPR/Cas9 developed rapidly, with base editing systems for transition substitution using a combination of Cas9 nickase and either cytidine or adenosine deaminase being reported in 2016 and 2017, respectively, and later in 2021 bringing reports of transversion substitution using Cas9 nickase, cytidine deaminase and uracil DNA glycosylase. Moreover, technologies for gene targeting and prime editing systems using DNA or RNA as donors have also been developed in recent years. Besides these precise genome-editing strategies, reports of successful chromosome engineering using CRISPR/Cas9 have been published recently. The application of genome editing to crop breeding has advanced in parallel with the development of these technologies. Genome-editing enzymes can be introduced into plant cells, and there are now many examples of crop breeding using genome-editing technologies. At present, it is no exaggeration to say that we are now in a position to be able to modify a gene precisely and rearrange genomes and chromosomes in a predicted way. In this review, we introduce and discuss recent highlights in the field of precise gene editing, chromosome engineering and genome engineering technology in plants.     

碱基编辑系统研究最新进展及应用

CRISPR系统能够在基因组DNA中完成精准编辑,但依赖于细胞内的同源重组(Homology directed recombination,HDR)修复途径,且效率极低.基于CRISPR/Cas9系统开发的碱基编辑技术(Base editing)通过将失去切割活性的核酸酶与不同碱基脱氨基酶融合,构建了两套碱基编辑系统(...     

The CRISPR/Cas9 revolution continues: From base editing to prime editing in plant science

The ability to precisely inactivate or modify genes in model organisms helps us understand the mysteries of life. Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats(CRISPR)/CRISPR-associated protein 9(Cas9), a revolutionary technology that could generate targeted mutants, has facilitated notable advances in plant science. Genome editing with CRISPR/Cas9 has gained great popularity and enabled several technical breakthroughs. Herein, we briefly introduce the CRISPR/Cas9, with a focus on the latest breakthroughs in precise genome editing(e.g., base editing and prime editing), and we summarize various platforms that developed to increase the editing efficiency, expand the targeting scope, and improve the specificity of base editing in plants. In addition, we emphasize the recent applications of these technologies to plants. Finally, we predict that CRISPR/Cas9 and CRISPR/Cas9-based genome editing will continue to revolutionize plant science and provide technical support for sustainable agricultural development.     

基于CRISPR/Cas系统的DNA碱基编辑技术及其在生物医学和农业中的应用

近年来,基于成簇的规律间隔短回文重复序列及其相关系统(Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPR-associated protein,CRISPR/Cas)的基因编辑技术飞速发展,该系统可以利用同源定向重组(Homology directed repair,HDR)来完成其介导的精准编辑,但效率极低,限制了其在农业和生物医学等领域上的推广应用。基于CRISPR/Cas系统的DNA碱基编辑技术作为一种新兴的基因组编辑技术,能在不产生双链断裂的情况下实现碱基的定向突变,相对于CRISPR/Cas介导的HDR编辑具有更高的编辑效率和特异性。目前,已开发出了可将C碱基突变为T碱基的胞嘧啶碱基编辑器(Cytidine base editors,CBE),将A碱基突变为G碱基的腺嘌呤碱基编辑器(Adenine base editors,ABE),以及可实现碱基任意变换和小片段精准插入和缺失的Prime编辑器(Prime editors,PE)。另外,能实现C到G颠换的糖基化酶碱基编辑器(Glycosylase base editors,GBE)以及能同时编辑A和C两种底物的双碱基编辑器也已被开发出来。文中主要综述了几种DNA碱基编辑器的开发历程、研究进展及各自优点和局限性;介绍了DNA碱基编辑技术在生物医学以及农业中的成功应用案例,以期为DNA碱基编辑器的进一步优化和选择应用提供借鉴。     

植物基因组编辑新工具——引导编辑技术

基于CRISPR/Cas9系统的引导编辑(prime editing,PE)技术作为一种新兴的基因组编辑技术,能在不产生双链断裂的情况下实现所有12种单碱基替换和小片段DNA的缺失或插入.引导编辑技术已经在多种植物中成功应用并将在植物精准育种中发挥重要作用.虽然植物引导编辑(plant prime editing,PP...     

Optimized prime editing efficiently generates heritable mutations in maize

Low efficiency is the main obstacle to using prime editing in maize(Zea mays). Recently, prime-editing efficiency was greatly improved in mammalian cells and rice(Oryza sativa) plants by engineering primeediting guide RNAs(pegRNAs), optimizing the prime editor(PE) protein, and manipulating cellular determinants of prime editing. In this study, we tested PEs optimized via these three strategies in maize. We demonstrated that the ePE5max system, composed of PEmax, epegRNAs(pegRNA-evopreQ. 1), nick...     

Small-molecule inhibitors of histone deacetylase improve CRISPR-based adenine base editing

CRISPR-based base editors (BEs) are widely used to induce nucleotide substitutions in living cells and organisms without causing the damaging DNA double-strand breaks and DNA donor templates. Cytosine BEs that induce C:G to T:A conversion and adenine BEs that induce A:T to G:C conversion have been developed. Various attempts have been made to increase the efficiency of both BEs; however, their activities need to be improved for further applications. Here, we describe a fluorescent reporter-based drug screening platform to identify novel chemicals with the goal of improving adenine base editing efficiency. The reporter system revealed that histone deacetylase inhibitors, particularly romidepsin, enhanced base editing efficiencies by up to 4.9-fold by increasing the expression levels of proteins and target accessibility. The results support the use of romidepsin as a viable option to improve base editing efficiency in biomedical research and therapeutic genome engineering.     

Simplified adenine base editors improve adenine base editing efficiency in rice

Adenine base editors (ABEs) have been exploited to introduce targeted adenine (A) to guanine (G) base conversions in various plant genomes, including rice, wheat and Arabidopsis. However, the ABEs reported thus far are all quite inefficient at many target sites in rice, which hampers their applications in plant genome engineering and crop breeding. Here, we show that unlike in the mammalian system, a simplified base editor ABE‐P1S (Adenine Base Editor‐Plant version 1 Simplified) containing the ecTadA*7.10‐nSpCas9 (D10A) fusion has much higher editing efficiency in rice compared to the widely used ABE‐P1 consisting of the ecTadA‐ecTadA*7.10‐nSpCas9 (D10A) fusion. We found that the protein expression level of ABE‐P1S is higher than that of ABE‐P1 in rice calli and protoplasts, which may explain the higher editing efficiency of ABE‐P1S in different rice varieties. Moreover, we demonstrate that the ecTadA*7.10‐nCas9 fusion can be used to improve the editing efficiency of other ABEs containing SaCas9 or the engineered SaKKH‐Cas9 variant. These more efficient ABEs will help advance trait improvements in rice and other crops.     

Prime editing: advances and therapeutic applications

Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats-associated protein 9 (CRISPR–Cas)-mediated genome editing has revolutionized biomedical research and will likely change the therapeutic and diagnostic landscape. However, CRISPR–Cas9, which edits DNA by activating DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair pathways, is not always sufficient for gene therapy applications where precise mutation repair is required. Prime editing, the latest revolution in genome-editing technologies, can achieve any possible base substitution, insertion, or deletion without the requirement for DSBs. However, prime editing is still in its infancy, and further development is needed to improve editing efficiency and delivery strategies for therapeutic applications. We summarize latest developments in the optimization of prime editor (PE) variants with improved editing efficiency and precision. Moreover, we highlight some potential therapeutic applications.     

CRISPR-Cas系统在植物基因组编辑中的研究进展

基因组定点编辑技术是研究基因功能和生物体改造的重要工具。CRISPR-Cas(Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats and CRISPR-associated proteins)系统是近年来发展的一种新型基因组编辑技术,该技术通过一段向导RNA和配套的核酸酶就可对特定的基因组序列进行定点编辑,具有简单高效、应用广泛的特点,受到了生物学家的广泛关注。本文着重介绍CRISPR-Cas系统在植物中的研究进展,包括CRISPR-Cas9系统在植物中的应用与完善、扩大基因组编辑范围的研究、Cas9切口酶和失活酶的拓展、特异性单碱基突变编辑系统的研究、无外源DNA污染的植物基因编辑技术的发展以及基因组编辑技术在作物育种上的应用等方面。同时也提出了还需解决的问题,并展望了基因组编辑系统在作物育种中的应用前景,为开展这一领域的研究工作提供参考。     

Current and future editing reagent delivery systems for plant genome editing

Many genome editing tools have been developed and new ones are anticipated; some have been extensively applied in plant genetics, biotechnology and breeding, especially the CRISPR/Cas9 system. These technologies have opened up a new era for crop improvement due to their precise editing of user-specified sequences related to agronomic traits. In this review, we will focus on an update of recent developments in the methodologies of editing reagent delivery, and consider the pros and cons of current delivery systems. Finally, we will reflect on possible future directions.     

植物CRISPR基因组编辑技术的新进展

在过去的4年中,CRISPR/Cas9基因组编辑技术成为生命科学领域的革命性工具,为植物学基础研究和农作物遗传改良提供了高效、快速而又廉价的遗传操作工具。利用CRISPR/Cas9系统可以实现精准的knock-out和knock-in等遗传操作,也可用于靶向激活或抑制基因的表达。在CRISPR/Cas9被广泛地用于基因组编辑的同时,它的编辑能力、效率和精确度也在不断地改进和完善,特别是CRISPR/Cpf1系统的发掘和单碱基编辑技术的创建,使CRISPR系统正逐步成为一个理想的遗传工程技术平台。此外,利用CRISPR/Cas9技术改良的农作物品种也已经涌现,这必将推动精准基因组编辑技术在农作物遗传改良中的应用和发展。     

Applications and potential of genome editing in crop improvement

Genome-editing tools provide advanced biotechnological techniques that enable the precise and efficient targeted modification of an organism’s genome. Genome-editing systems have been utilized in a wide variety of plant species to characterize gene functions and improve agricultural traits. We describe the current applications of genome editing in plants, focusing on its potential for crop improvement in terms of adaptation, resilience, and end-use. In addition, we review novel breakthroughs that are extending the potential of genome-edited crops and the possibilities of their commercialization. Future prospects for integrating this revolutionary technology with conventional and new-age crop breeding strategies are also discussed.     

Trait discovery and editing in tomato

Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum), which is used for both processing and fresh markets, is a major crop species that is the top ranked vegetable produced over the world. Tomato is also a model species for research in genetics, fruit development and disease resistance. Genetic resources available in public repositories comprise the 12 wild related species and thousands of landraces, modern cultivars and mutants. In addition, high quality genome sequences are available for cultivated tomato and for several wild relatives, hundreds of accessions have been sequenced, and databases gathering sequence data together with genetic and phenotypic data are accessible to the tomato community. Major breeding goals are productivity, resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses, and fruit sensorial and nutritional quality. New traits, including resistance to various biotic and abiotic stresses and root architecture, are increasingly being studied. Several major mutations and quantitative trait loci (QTLs) underlying traits of interest in tomato have been uncovered to date and, thanks to new populations and advances in sequencing technologies, the pace of trait discovery has considerably accelerated. In recent years, clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)/Cas9 gene editing (GE) already proved its remarkable efficiency in tomato for engineering favorable alleles and for creating new genetic diversity by gene disruption, gene replacement, and precise base editing. Here, we provide insight into the major tomato traits and underlying causal genetic variations discovered so far and review the existing genetic resources and most recent strategies for trait discovery in tomato. Furthermore, we explore the opportunities offered by CRISPR/Cas9 and their exploitation for trait editing in tomato.     

Engineering plant virus resistance: from RNA silencing to genome editing strategies

Viral diseases severely affect crop yield and quality, thereby threatening global food security. Genetic improvement of plant virus resistance is essential for sustainable agriculture. In the last decades, several modern technologies were applied in plant antiviral engineering. Here we summarized breakthroughs of the two major antiviral strategies, RNA silencing and genome editing. RNA silencing strategy has been used in antiviral breeding for more than thirty years, and many crops engineered to stably express small RNAs targeting various viruses have been approved for commercial release. Genome editing technology has emerged in the past decade, especially CRISPR/Cas, which provides new methods for genetic improvement of plant virus resistance and accelerates resistance breeding. Finally, we discuss the potential of these technologies for breeding crops, and the challenges and solutions they may face in the future.