Continuous, real-time monitoring of the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) in animal cell bioreactors

A new method for real-time monitoring of the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) in bioreactors, based on dissolved oxygen (DO) measurement at two points, has been developed and tested extensively. The method has several distinct advantages over known techniques.It enables the continuous and undisturbed monitoring of OUR, which is conventionally impossible without gas analyzers. The technique does not require knowledge of k(L)a. It provides smooth, robust, and reliable signal. The monitoring scheme is applicable to both microbial and mammalian cell bioprocesses of laboratory or industrial scale. The method was successfully used in the cultivation of NSO-derived murine myeloma cell line producing monoclonal antibody. It was found that while the OUR increased with the cell density, the specific OUR decreased to approximately one-half at cell concentrations of 16 x 10(6) cells/mL, indicating gradual reduction of cell respiration activity. Apart from the laboratory scale cultivation, the method was applied to industrial scale perfusion culture, as well as to processes using other cell lines. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

杂交瘤细胞培养中摄氧速率(OUR)的在线检测及其与细胞生长及代谢的关系

在批式及灌流培养条件下研究了杂交瘤细胞在无血清培养基中的生长、代谢情况与氧消耗的关系。应用动力学方法在线进行OUR的检测,同时离线取样检测其他参数。结果发现OUR与谷氨酰胺的消耗、抗体的生成及活细胞密度间有明显的相关关系,进一步的分析还发现在对数生长期,OUR与活细胞密度间具有良好的线性关系,qOUR(0.103±0.028)×10^-12mol/cell/h,可以通过它来进行细胞密度的在线检测。并通过以ΔOUR=0时刻作为灌流调整点进行连续灌流培养的初步实验验证了OUR作为培养过程反馈控制参数的可能性。     

On line estimation of oxygen uptake rate for insect cells growing in a modified spinner flask

The simple design of traditional spinner flasks makes the on-line estimation of cellular metabolism impossible. An on-line estimation system has been developed and used for the monitoring of oxygen uptake rate (OUR) for insect cells growing in a modified spinner flask. Neglect of oxygen desorption from culture media is a common source of error in OUR measurements for Sf21 cells. Therefore, an algorithm was developed to compensate for the affect of such desorption process on the determination of OUR. A modified spinner flask was successfully used as a low-volume bioreactor for insect cell cultivation and the OUR measurement developed here is both convenient and reliable.     

On-line gas analysis in animal cell cultivation: II. Methods for oxygen uptake rate estimation and its application to controlled feeding of glutamine

Different methods for oxygen uptake rate (OUR) determinations in animal cell cultivation were investigated using a high quality mass spectrometer. Dynamic measurements have considerable disadvantages because of disturbances of the growing cells by the necessary variations of dissolved oxygen concentration. Only infrequent discrete measurements are possible using this method. Stationary liquid phase balance yielded better results with much higher frequency. Gas phase balancing has the advantage of not requiring dissolved oxygen measurement and knowledge of K(L)a, both of them are easily biased. It was found that simple gas phase balancing is either very inaccurate (error larger than expected signal) or very slow, with gas phase residence times of several hours. Therefore, a new method of aeration was designed. Oxygen and CO(2) transfer are mainly achieved via sparging. The gas released to the headspace is diluted with a roughly 100-fold stream of an inert gas (helium). Through this dilution, gas ratios are not changed for O(2), CO(2), Ar, and N(2). The measurement of lower concentrations (parts per million and below) is easy using mass spectrometry with a secondary electron multiplier. With this new method an excellent accuracy and sufficient speed of analysis were obtained. All these on-line methods for OUR measurement were tested during the cultivation of animal cells. The new method allowed better study of the kinetics of animal cell cultures as was shown with a hybridoma cell line (HFN 7.1, ATCC CRL 1606) producing monoclonal antibodies against human fibronectin. With the aid of these methods it was possible to find a correlation between a rapid decrease in oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and glutamine concentration. The sudden decrease in OUR can be attributed to glutamine depletion. This provided a basis for the controlled addition of glutamine to reduce the formation of ammonia produced by hydrolysis. This control method based on OUR measurement resulted in increased cell concentration and threefold higher product concentration. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

A sensitive measurement of oxygen uptake rate using a optochemical sensor

Summary The measurement of the specific oxygen uptake rate (OUR) of slow growing organisms using a small sample size is often hampered by the consumption of oxygen by the electrode used. Using a optochemical sensor we measured the OUR of carrot embryos with approximately 1000 cell clusters and of hybridoma with approximately 10⁶ cells. An OUR as low as 0.02 mol/h can be accurately measured.     

On-line gas analysis in animal cell cultivation: I. Control of dissolved oxygen and pH

To monitor gas reaction rates in animal cell culture at constant dissolved oxygen concentration (DO) and constant pH it was necessary to develop improved control methods. Decoupling of both controllrs was obtained by manipulation of molar fractions of oxygen and carbon dioxide in the gas phase. Two pairs of DO and pH controllers were designed and tested both in simulation and exprimental runs. The first controller pair was developed for headspace aeration only, whereas the second controller pair was designed for bubble aeration using a microsparger and flushing the headspace with helium. pH was controlled by a conventional discrete PID controller in its velocity form. For DO control two linear state space feedback controllers with parameter adaptation were established. In these controllers the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) was considered as a disturbance and was not included in the mathematical model. The feedback gain adaptation was based on the difference between the actual molar fraction of oxygen at time step n and the initial molar fraction. This difference is related to OUR and was used to increase or decrease the state feedback controller gain (k and k(1), respectively) in a slow manner. With these controllers it was possible to get an excellent online estimate of OUR. In the case of bubble aeration a simple gas phase mass balance was sufficient, whereas during the headspace aeration a liquid phase balance was required. It has been shown that determination of OUR using gas balance requires a significantly better controller performance compared to just keeping DO and pH within reasonable limits. (c) 1995 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

High density culture of mammalian cells with dynamic perfusion based on on-line oxygen uptake rate measurements

In a continuous culture with cell retention the perfusion rate must be adjusted dynamically to meet the cellular demand. An automated mechanism of adjusting the perfusion rate based on real-time measurement of the metabolic load of the bioreactor is important in achieving a high cell concentration and maintaining high viability. We employed oxygen uptake rate (OUR) measurement as an on-line metabolic indicator of the physiological state of the cells in the bioreactor and adjusted the perfusion rate accordingly. Using an internal hollow fiber microfiltration system for total cell retention, a cell concentration of almost 10⁸ cells/mL was achieved. Although some aggregates were formed during the cultivation, the viability remained high as examined with confocal microscopy after fluorescent vital staining. The results demonstrate that on-line OUR measurement facilitates automated dynamic perfusion and allows a high cell concentration to be achieved.     

应用动力学方法在线检测Vero细胞培养过程中的摄氧率

流加和灌注培养已被广泛应用于动物细胞培养 ,以获得高活性、高密度的细胞和高的产物得率。在这些培养过程中 ,一般通过离线检测关键参数 (如细胞密度、营养和代谢产物的浓度 )来人为调整灌注速率和补料策略 ,但是 ,当细胞密度较高时 ,由于细胞代谢旺盛使得培养的微环境变化很快 ,这就需要更加频繁快速地调整操作条件 ,从而导致因频繁取样和离线分析所带来的污染危险及大量人力、物力的浪费。这在大规模细胞培养过程中是不可取的。因此 ,要建立大规模、高效动物细胞培养过程 ,有必要研究和探索在线检测技术 ,以实时掌握细胞培养过程所处的状…     

Determination of in vivo oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide evolution rates from off-gas measurements under highly dynamic conditions

In vivo kinetics of Saccharomyces cerevisiae are studied, in a time window of 150 s, by analyzing the response of O(2) and CO(2) in the fermentor off-gas after perturbation of chemostat cultures by metabolite pulses. Here, a new mathematical method is presented for the estimation of the in vivo oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and carbon dioxide evolution rate (CER) directly from the off-gas data in such perturbation experiments. The mathematical construction allows effective elimination of delay and distortion in the off-gas measurement signal under highly dynamic conditions. A black box model for the fermentor off-gas system is first obtained by system identification, followed by the construction of an optimal linear filter, based on the identified off-gas model. The method is applied to glucose and ethanol pulses performed on chemostat cultures of S. cerevisiae. The estimated OUR is shown to be consistent with the independent dissolved oxygen measurement. The estimated in vivo OUR and CER provide valuable insights into the complex dynamic behavior of yeast and are essential for the establishment and validation of in vivo kinetic models of primary metabolism.     

Generalised additive modelling approach to the fermentation process of glutamate

In this work, generalised additive models (GAMs) were used for the first time to model the fermentation of glutamate (Glu). It was found that three fermentation parameters fermentation time (T), dissolved oxygen (DO) and oxygen uptake rate (OUR) could capture 97% variance of the production of Glu during the fermentation process through a GAM model calibrated using online data from 15 fermentation experiments. This model was applied to investigate the individual and combined effects of T, DO and OUR on the production of Glu. The conditions to optimize the fermentation process were proposed based on the simulation study from this model. Results suggested that the production of Glu can reach a high level by controlling concentration levels of DO and OUR to the proposed optimization conditions during the fermentation process. The GAM approach therefore provides an alternative way to model and optimize the fermentation process of Glu.     

On-line monitoring of respiration in recombinant-baculovirus infected and uninfected insect cell bioreactor cultures

Respiration rates in Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf-9) cell bioreactor cultures were successfully measured on-line using two methods: The O(2) uptake rate (OUR) was determined using gas phase pO(2) values imposed by a dissolved oxygen controller and the CO(2) evolution rate (CER) was measured using an infrared detector. The measurement methods were accurate, reliable, and relatively inexpensive. The CER was routinely determined in bioreactor cultures used for the production of several recombinant proteins. Simple linear relationships between viable cell densities and both OUR and CER in exponentially growing cultures were used to predict viable cell density. Respiration measurements were also used to follow the progress of baculoviral infections in Sf-9 cultures. Infection led to increases in volumetric and per-cell respiration rates. The relationships between respiration and several other culture parameters, including viable cell density, cell protein, cell volume, glucose consumption, lactate production, viral titer, and recombinant beta-galactosidase accumulation, were examined. The extent of the increase in CER following infection and the time postinfection at which maximum CER was attained were negatively correlated with the multiplicity of infection (MOI) at multiplicities below the level required to infect all the cells in a culture. Delays in the respiration peak related to the MOI employed were correlated with delays in the peak in recombinant protein accumulation. DO levels in the range 5-100% did not exert any major effects on viable cell densities, CER, or product titer in cultures infected with a baculovirus expressing recombinant beta-galactosidase. (c) 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Determination of external and internal mass transfer limitation in nitrifying microbial aggregates

In this article we present a study of the effects of external and internal mass transfer limitation of oxygen in a nitrifying system. The oxygen uptake rates (OUR) were measured on both a macro-scale with a respirometric reactor using off-gas analysis (Titrimetric and Off-Gas Analysis (TOGA) sensor) and on a micro-scale with microsensors. These two methods provide independent, accurate measurements of the reaction rates and concentration profiles around and in the granules. The TOGA sensor and microsensor measurements showed a significant external mass transfer effect at low dissolved oxygen (DO) concentrations in the bulk liquid while it was insignificant at higher DO concentrations. The oxygen distribution with anaerobic or anoxic conditions in the center clearly shows major mass transfer limitation in the aggregate interior. The large drop in DO concentration of 22-80% between the bulk liquid and aggregate surface demonstrates that the external mass transfer resistance is also highly important. The maximum OUR even for floccular biomass was only attained at much higher DO concentrations (approximately 8 mg/L) than typically used in such systems. For granules, the DO required for maximal activity was estimated to be >20 mg/L, clearly indicating the effects of the major external and internal mass transfer limitations on the overall biomass activity. Smaller aggregates had a larger volumetric OUR indicating that the granules may have a lower activity in the interior part of the aggregate.     

A lab-built respirometer for plant and animal cell culture

A very simple off-line respirometer was developed to measure oxygen consumption rates of low respiring and shear-sensitive cell suspensions. The respirometer is composed of a 10 mL glass syringe in which the plunger was substituted with a polarographic dissolved oxygen probe. Mechanical agitation is provided by means of a magnetic stirring bar inside the measuring chamber and a stir plate placed below the respirometer. Abiotic oxygen fluxes occurring in the measurement chamber such as oxygen diffusion and probe oxygen consumption were investigated. The apparent oxygen uptake rate was then corrected for abiotic oxygen fluxes, leading to accurate measurements of respiration rates ranging from 0.5 to 25.0 mM x h(-1). Additionally, the effect of the stirring bar shape and of the test length on the integrity of plant (Eschschzoltzia californica) and animal (NS0) cells was evaluated. Animal cells showed a higher resistance to mechanical stirring inside the respirometer compared to plant cells (0% of broken cells and 78.1% respectively for a polygonal stirring bar and a 15 min test). For plant cells, cell damage inside the measurement chamber was reduced by optimizing the stirring bar shape and reducing the test length to 5 min or less. This very simple design was shown to provide reliable and low-cost quantification of the oxygen uptake rate of plant and animal cells and can be use even for more demanding measurements such as oxygen affinity studies.     

Relationship between oxygen uptake rate and time of infection of Sf9 insect cells infected with a recombinant baculovirus

Oxygen uptake rates (OUR) of Sf9 insect cells propagated in a serum-free medium (SF900II, Gibco) and of cells infected with a recombinant AcNPV were investigated before and after infection in a laboratory-scale bioreactor. The volumetric OURs of uninfected and exponentially growing cells were found to be proportional to the cell density. For infected cultures, the specific OUR of cells increased immediately after addition of virus and a maximum of 1.3 times the value of uninfected cells was noted for all the cultures between 8 to 30 hours post infection, which coincides with the period at which most viral replication and the majority of DNA synthesis takes place. It was observed that the rate of rise in the specific OUR decreased as the cell density at the time of infection increased, which meant that the later the infection, the later the maximum sOUR was observed. We therefore suggest that OUR measurement can be used to reflect the efficiency of a batch infection. Carbohydrate and amino acid consumption rates from an infected run were analysed in an effort to identify substrate(s) that may be used at increased rates to fuel the rise in oxygen demand observed early in the infection cycle. No observable rise in the consumption rates of glucose or glutamine, which are the major energy sources for animal cells, were seen after infection but an increase in the consumption rates of some amino acids suggests that infected Sf9 cells may utilise amino acids at an enhanced rate for energy post infection.     

On-line estimation of viable biomass of a microaerobic culture using exit gas analysis

Summary A method is proposed to estimate the concentration of metabolically active cells of a microaerobic culture on-line from the measurement of oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and respiratory quotient (RQ). With the cultivation ofEnterobacter aerogenes in a fedbatch mode the estimated active cell concentration agrees well with the viable cell concentration determined by microscopic count and agar plate incubation.     

Multi-rate nonlinear state and parameter estimation in a bioreactor

This paper concerns real-time, multi-rate, nonlinear state and parameter estimation in a pilot-scale biochemical reactor in which cultivation of mouse-mouse hybridoma cells takes place. A multi-rate estimator is designed and implemented to estimate specific growth rate and concentrations of viable cells, total cells, glucose, glutamine, and monoclonal antibodies (MAb) in the reactor. These are estimated from frequent measurement (inferred values) of oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and infrequent and delayed measurements of the concentrations of viable cells, total cells, glucose, glutamine, and MAb. The infrequent measurements are available every 2 to 17 h with a time delay of 0.08 to 2.00 h, and OUR is inferred from dissolved oxygen concentration measurements that are available very 0.17 h. For each of the process variables, its infrequent measurement data and the profile of its estimate are presented to show the performance of the multi-rate estimator.     

Computer-aided on-line monitoring of physiological variables in suspended cell cultures of Perilla frutescens in a bioreactor

A computer-aided on-line real-time monitoring system for plant cell bioprocesses was established and applied to the cultivation of Perilla frutescens plant cells in a bioreactor. This system calculated several informative process variables which were useful for the identification of the physiological states of the plant cells during cultivation. Some variables, such as the respiratory quotient (RQ), pH, and specific carbon dioxide evolution rate (SCER), could be used for the identification of the growing phase of cell cultures. The results also suggest that the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) and the specific OUR (SOUR) may depend on the accumulation of anthocyanin (a secondary metabolite) in P. frutescens cell cultures.     

A new method for on-line measurement of the volumetric oxygen uptake rate in membrane aerated animal cell cultures

Oxygen is a key substrate in animal cell metabolism and its consumption is thus a parameter of great interest for bioprocess monitoring and control. A system for measuring it based on an oxygen balance on the liquid phase was developed. The use of a gas-permeable membrane offered the possibility to provide the required quantity of oxygen into the culture, while avoiding problems of foaming or shear stress generally linked to sparging. This aeration system allowed moreover to keep a known and constant k(L)a value through cultures up to 400 h. Oxygen uptake rate (OUR) was measured on-line with a very good accuracy of +/-5%, and the specific OUR for a CHO cell line was determined during batch (growth phase) and continuous culture as, respectively, equal to 2. 85x10(-13) and 2.54x10(-13) mol O(2) cell(-1) h(-1). It was also shown that OUR continuous monitoring gives actually more information about the metabolic state of the culture than the cell concentration itself, especially during transition phases like the end of the growth phase in a batch culture.     

Noninvasive measurement of dissolved oxygen in shake flasks

Shake flasks are ubiquitous in cell culture and fermentation. However, conventional devices for measuring oxygen concentrations are impractical in these systems. Thus, there is no definitive information on the oxygen supply of growing cells. Here we report the noninvasive, nonintrusive monitoring of dissolved oxygen (DO) in shake flasks using a low-cost optical sensor. The oxygen-sensitive element is a thin, luminescent patch affixed to the inside bottom of the flask. The sensitivity and accuracy of this device is maximal up to 60% DO, within the range that is critical to cell culture applications. By measuring actual oxygen levels every 1 or 5 min throughout the course of yeast and E. coli fermentations, we found that a modest increase in shaker speed and a decrease in culture volume slowed the onset of oxygen limitation and reduced its duration. This is the first time that in situ oxygen limitation is reported in shake flasks. The same data is unattainable with a Clark type electrode because the presence of the intrusive probe itself changes the actual conditions. Available fiber optic oxygen sensors require cumbersome external connections and recalibration when autoclaved.     

Cell cycle- and growth phase-dependent variations in size distribution, antibody productivity, and oxygen demand in hybridoma cultures

Simultaneous determination of cell size and DNA content of hybridomas (HB-32) revealed a direct correlation between average cell volume and progression through the cell cycle. Pseudocontinuous experiments showed that G(1) cells, as estimated from cell size measurements, secreted monoclonal antibody at rates higher than those of cells in other stages of interphase and mitosis. Similarly, fed-batch and batch experiments suggested that specific oxygen uptake rate (qO(2)) is also a function of cell cycle, being minimum for cells in G(0) and G(1) phase. In batch cultures, HB-32 showed a rapid decrease in oxygen uptake rate (OUR) just prior to reaching maximum cell concentration. The OUR steadily increased from 0.01-0.05 to 0.5-0.7 mmol O(2)/L h as the cells went from the lag to the midexponential phase. The qO(2) increased from 0.3 x 10(-10)-0.9 x 10(-10) mmol O(2)/cell h at inoculation to 3.3 x 10(-10)-3.7 x 10(-10) mmol O(2)/cell h during the early exponential phase where it remained relatively constant. Several hours before maximum cell concentration was reached, OUR and qO(2) rapidly decreased to levels below those observed at inoculation. The time at which the shift in OUR and qO(2) occurred and the onset of decrease in the average cell size corresponded to the time of glutamine depletion. Based on monitoring OUR on-line in batch cultures, glutamine was supplemented, resulting in increased cell concentration, extension of culture viability, and increased MAb concentration.