Viscoelastic and rheological properties of concentrated solutions of proteoglycan subunit and proteoglycan aggregate

The oscillatory and steady shear rheological properties of concentrated solutions of proteoglycan subunit (PGS) and aggregate (PGA) from bovine articular cartilage have been studied using a Rheometrics fluids spectrometer. At comparable concentrations in the physiological range tan delta increases from 0.5 to 1.0 for PGA as the oscillation frequency (omega) increases from 10(-1) to 10(2) rads/s, compared to a decrease from 40 to 5 for PGS. Thus PGA solutions exhibit predominantly elastic response whereas those of PGS exhibit primarily viscous behavior. PGA solutions show pronounced shear-thinning behavior at all shear rates (gamma) in the range 10(-2) less than gamma (s-1) less than 10(2), whereas PGS solutions exhibit predominantly Newtonian flow. For PGA, the small-strain complex viscosity eta* (omega) is substantially smaller than the steady-flow viscosity eta(gamma) at comparable values of omega and gamma. These observations indicate that the presence of proteoglycan aggregates leads to formation of a transient or weak-gel network. Since aggregation leads to a large increase in molecular hydrodynamic volume and hence in the relaxation times for macromolecular rotation, it appears that role of aggregate formation is to shift the linear viscoelastic response from the terminal viscous flow into the plateau elastomeric regime of relaxational behavior. Normal or pathological changes that produce a decrease in aggregation will result in a loss of elastomeric behavior of the proteoglycan matrix.     

The influence of link protein stabilization on the viscometric properties of proteoglycan aggregate solutions

The dynamic, steady-shear and transient shear flow properties of precisely prepared link-stable (s0 136, 66% aggregate) and link-free (s0 93, 59% aggregate) proteoglycan aggregate solutions at concentrations ranging from 10 to 50 mg/ml were determined using a cone-on-plate viscometer in a mechanical spectrometer. All proteoglycan solutions tested possessed: (1) linear viscoelastic properties - as measured by the dynamic complex modulus under small amplitude steady oscillatory conditions (1 less than or equal to omega less than or equal to 100 rad/s) - and (2) nonlinear shear-rate dependent apparent viscosities and primary normal stress difference under steady shearing conditions (0.25 less than or equal to gamma less than or equal to 250 s-1). Our transient flow data show that all proteoglycan aggregate solutions exhibited transient stress overshoot effects in shear stress and normal stress. From these steady and transient flow data, we conclude that link protein stabilized aggregates have significant effects on their dynamic and steady-shear properties as well as transient flow properties. The transient stress overshoot data provide a measure of the energy per unit volume of fluid required to overcome the proteoglycan networks in solution from a resting state. Thus we found that link-stable aggregates form much stronger networks than link-free aggregates. This is corroborated by the fact that link-stable aggregates form more elastic (lower than delta) and stiffer (higher [G*]) networks than link-free aggregates. The complete spectrum of viscometric flow data is entirely compatible with the proposed role of link protein in adding structural stability to the proteoglycan-hyaluronate bond. In cartilage, the enhanced strength of the networks formed by link-stable aggregates may play an important role in determining the material properties of the tissue and thereby contribute to the functional capacity of cartilage in diarthrodial joints.     

Viscoelastic properties of solutions of ovine submaxillary mucin

The linear viscoelastic and rheological properties of high molecular weight ovine submaxillary mucin (OSM) solution have been investigated in terms of the Newtonian steady-flow viscosity [eta(gamma)], the complex oscillatory viscosity [eta*(omega)], and the storage and loss shear moduli [G'(omega) and G"(omega)]. It was observed that tau(gamma), eta*(omega), and G'(omega) are always higher when OSM is dissolved in 0.1M NaCl than when at the same concentration in 6M GdnHCl. This is consistent with previous observations that submaxillary mucins self-associate in 0.1M NaCl to form large aggregates, which are disrupted in 6M GdnHCl. As the OSM concentration increases, the appearance of a plateau shear modulus indicates the formation of a gel network in both solvents. The results suggest gelation involves specific intermolecular interactions, perhaps due to hydrophobic forces between interdigitated oligosaccharide side chains. The viscoelastic behavior of OSM solution at high concentration is thus similar to that reported in the literature for porcine gastric mucin (PGM). However, the OSM gels are mechanically weaker, having moduli that are an order of magnitude lower than those for PGM gels of comparable concentration. The oligosaccharide side chains of OSM consist of only 1-2 sugar units compared to 10-15 for PGM, but it appears that this is sufficient to allow for intermolecular interaction and the formation of weak gels.     

The role of link protein in mediating the interaction between hyaluronic acid and newly secreted proteoglycan subunits from adult human articular cartilage

Normal adult human articular cartilage in organ culture secretes proteoglycan subunits that cannot initially interact in a normal manner with hyaluronic acid unless the latter is present at high concentrations and a neutral pH is employed. However, if the newly secreted subunit is allowed to mature in the cartilage matrix for up to 12 h, then its ability to interact is indistinguishable from that of its more mature counterparts. This conversion does not take place if the proteoglycan subunits are incubated in dilute solutions in the absence of the cartilage, and it is prevented by culturing at low temperature. The newly secreted proteoglycan subunits can, however, be induced to interact with hyaluronic acid by the presence of link proteins. The complex formed by these three components cannot be dissociated in the presence of hyaluronic acid oligosaccharides, suggesting a normal aggregate configuration. It is thus possible that proteoglycan aggregate formation within the cartilage is initially mediated by the presence of link proteins, which induce a conformational change with the hyaluronic acid-binding region of the proteoglycan subunits, although additional modification may be necessary to render any such change irreversible.     

Elasto-thixotropic properties of bronchial mucus and polymer analogs. I. Experimental results

The non-newtonian viscous and elasto-thixotropic properties of native and lyophilized pathological bronchial mucus and of polymer solutions (3% and 6% PIB in decalin) used as mucus analogs were analyzed using a cone-plate Carri-Med rheometer and a Couette viscoelastometer that we have specifically developed for measuring the rheological properties of bronchial mucus in clinical practice. The master curves obtained for apparent viscosity under steady conditions as a function of shear rates (gamma: 2.6 X 10(-3) to 6.9 X 10(1) sec-1) were fairly similar, whatever the apparatus used. Under transient conditions, at low shear rate (gamma less than 1.4 sec-1), PIB and mucus exhibited a typical viscoelastic behavior: the shear stress increased slightly up to a steady-state value. At higher gamma, a transitory overshoot of sigma characteristic of the elastothixotropic systems appeared. Such a behavior can be interpreted as resulting from structural changes such as formation and rupture of the three-dimensional network present in bronchial mucus as in polymer solutions.     

Local measurements of viscoelastic moduli of entangled actin networks using an oscillating magnetic bead micro-rheometer.

A magnetically driven bead micro-rheometer for local quantitative measurements of the viscoelastic moduli in soft macromolecular networks such as an entangled F-actin solution is described. The viscoelastic response of paramagnetic latex beads to external magnetic forces is analyzed by optical particle tracking and fast image processing. Several modes of operation are possible, including analysis of bead motion after pulse-like or oscillatory excitations, or after application of a constant force. The frequency dependencies of the storage modulus, G'(omega), and the loss modulus, G'(omega), were measured for frequencies from 10(-1) Hz to 5 Hz. For low actin concentrations (mesh sizes epsilon > 0.1 micron) we found that both G'(omega) and G'(omega) scale with omega 1/2. This scaling law and the absolute values of G' and G' agree with conventional rheological measurements, demonstrating that the magnetic bead micro-rheometer allows quantitative measurements of the viscoelastic moduli. Local variations of the viscoelastic moduli (and thus of the network density and mesh size) can be probed in several ways: 1) by measurement of G' and G' at different sites within the network; 2) by the simultaneous analysis of several embedded beads; and 3) by evaluation of the bead trajectories over macroscopic distances. The latter mode yields absolute values and local fluctuations of the apparent viscosity eta(x) of the network.     

Immunochemistry of cartilage proteoglycan. Immunodiffusion and gel-electrophoretic studies

Cartilage proteoglycan is thought to be composed of subunits, core proteins with covalently attached sulphated polysaccharide side chains, which form aggregates by non-covalent association with a link protein. The new technique of non-disruptive extraction followed by fractionation in caesium chloride gradients provides a useful means of preparing relatively pure proteoglycan aggregate, subunit and link fractions. Immunological studies of these fractions led to the identification of an antigen associated with the proteoglycan subunit which was common to several species and to the demonstration of additional species-specific antigens in aggregate and link fractions derived from bovine nasal cartilage. Polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis with sodium dodecyl sulphate of bovine proteoglycan aggregate and link fractions gave two protein bands in the gels and a protein-polysaccharide band at the origin; subunit fractions gave only the band at the origin. These results are consistent with the current concept of cartilage proteoglycan structure.     

Effects of blood storage on rheology and damage in low-stress shear flow

Data are presented on the rheological and hemolytic behavior of whole human blood as it ages while stored at 4 degrees C (as in blood banking practice) up to 26 days. The viscometric properties of steady shear viscosity eta and oscillatory (complex) viscosity eta * = eta' - i eta" reported over ranges of shear rate gamma and radian frequency omega of 33 less than gamma less than 4130 s-1 and 1.5 less than omega less than 48 s -1; data on autologous plasma are given for reference. The Cox-Merz relation, eta (gamma) = [eta *(omega)] omega = gamma, is found to be a good approximation, with eta greater than or equal to [eta *], over the range studied. Release of hemoglobin (Hgb) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) into the plasma during shearing is tracked as a function of time for 30 min, and its sensitivity to gamma magnitude is measured. Bloods from four different donors are studied, with primary attention given to one (SSR). For all bloods, the release of both Hgb and LDH increases with storage age, but differences in such aging characteristics between different bloods can be substantial (even when rheological properties are identical). A post-shear incubation at 4 degrees C for one day shows no enhancement of plasma Hgb and LDH levels beyond those expected from normal aging after the shearing experience, demonstrating the absence of significant delayed-action effects as a consequence of shearing trauma.     

Hydrodynamics of concentrated proteoglycan solutions

The dynamics of water transport in proteoglycan compartments has been studied in relation to osmotic flow (proteoglycan diffusion) and hydraulic permeability (proteoglycan sedimentation) in concentrated solutions of proteoglycan subunit and native proteoglycan aggregate isolated from Swarm rat chondrosarcoma. A central parameter that describes the kinetics of both types of water movement is the hydrodynamic frictional coefficient of water with proteoglycan. The frictional coefficient is markedly concentration dependent, increasing with increasing concentration, and highlights important structural features and types of organization of the proteoglycans in concentrated solutions. These include the requirements that proteoglycans in the extracellular matrix not to be immobilized but to have translational diffusive mobility and concentration gradients to be osmotically active, that chondroitin sulfate segmental mobility describing translational motion largely determines osmotic flow and hydraulic permeability of the proteoglycans, and that the proteoglycans exhibit an enhanced ability to resist flow as compared to other macromolecules. Additional dynamic studies suggest the formation of transient super-aggregate structures may occur at high concentrations which endows the proteoglycan subunit hydrodynamic properties similar to proteoglycan aggregate.     

A possible role for polyamines in cartilage in the mechanism of calcification

The role of polyamines in cartilage is not known: they may be somehow related to the mechanism of calcification. In epiphyseal cartilage from calf scapulas, they are more concentrated in the ossifying area, where calcification takes place, than in the resting region. Spermidine is present in greater amounts than spermine and putrescine. Since ornithine decarboxylase (EC 4.1.1.17) is measurable only in the resting region of the tissue, it is in this area that polyamine biosynthesis occurs, while they accumulate in the ossifying area. Immunohistochemical evidence is obtained that only in the ossifying zone is spermidine extracellular. It is at this level that the matrix is rearranged to become calcified, and proteoglycans are dissociated and partially removed. The effect of polyamines on solutions of proteoglycan subunits has been studied in vitro by following variations of turbidity and viscosity. While in the presence of putrescine the specific viscosity decreases to asymptotic values, in the presence of either 30 mM spermidine or 2.5-10 mM spermine, the decrement is more marked. At the same concentrations, increase of the turbidity of proteoglycan subunit solutions was observed. Only spermidine showed the capacity of displacing proteoglycan subunits from a column of Sepharose 4B-type II collagen: at 15 mM concentration, about 90% of proteoglycans were removed from the column. Alkaline phosphatase activity, which plays an important role in calcification, is enhanced by spermidine and spermine. These results obtained in vitro support the hypothesis that polyamines may be related to calcification of preosseous cartilage.     

Rheological properties of mammalian cell culture suspensions: Hybridoma and HeLa cell lines

Data on viscous (eta') and elastic (eta') components of the complex viscosity versus oscillatory angular frequency (0.01 to 4.0 rad/s) with increasing strains were obtained for hybridoma cell (62'D3) and HeLa cell (S3) suspensions in PBS at 0.9 (mL/mL) cell volume fraction using a Weissenberg rheogoniometer equipped with two parallel plate geometry at ambient temperature. Both cell suspensions exhibited shear thinning behavior. From the measured viscoelastic properties, the yield stress was calculated. Hybridoma cell suspension (15 mum as the mean diameter of cells) showed the yield stress at 550 dyne/cm(2) that was 1.8 times higher than the value of HeLa cell suspension (22 mum mean diameter) as measured at the oscillatory angular frequency, 4.0 rad/s. The apparent viscosities of HeLa cell suspension at four concentrations and varying steady shear rate were also determined using the Brookfield rotational viscometer. The yield stress to steady shear test was about 130 dyne/cm(2) for HeLa cell suspension at 0.9 (mL/mL) cell volume fraction. The apparent viscosity was in the range about 1 approximately 1000 Poise depending on the cell concentration and shear rate applied. A modified semiempirical Mooney equation, \documentclass{article}\pagestyle{empty}\begin{document}$ \eta = \eta _0 \exp [K\dot \gamma ;{ - \beta } \phi /(1 - K'\sigma \phi _c /D)] $\end{document} was derived based on the cell concentration, the cell morphology, and the steady shear rate. The beta, shear rate index, was estimated as 0.159 in the range of shear rate, 0.16 to 22.1 s(-1), for the cell volume fractions from 0.6 to 0.9 (mL/mL). In this study, the methods of determining the shear sensitivity and the viscous and the elastic components of mammalian cell suspensions are described under the steady shear field. (c) 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Rheology and dynamic light scattering of silk fibroin solution extracted from the middle division of Bombyx mori silkworm

Dynamic light scattering (DLS) and rheological measurements were performed on aqueous silk fibroin solutions extracted from the middle division of Bombyx mori silkworm over a wide range of polymer concentration C from 0.08 to 27.5 wt %. DLS results obtained in the dilute region of C less than 1 wt % are consistent with a model that an elementary unit is a large protein complex consisting of silk fibroin and P25 with a 6:1 molar ratio. Rheological measurements in the dilute C region reveal that those units (or clusters) with the hydrodynamic radius of about 100 nm form a network extending over the whole sample volume with small pseudoplateau modulus mainly by ionic bonding between COO(-) ions of the fibroin molecules and divalent metallic ions such as Ca(2+) or Mg(2+) ions present in the sample and also that, after a yield stress is reached, steady plastic flow is induced with viscosity much lower than the zero-shear viscosity estimated from creep and creep recovery measurements by 4-6 orders of magnitude. Angular frequency omega dependencies of the storage and the loss shear moduli, G'(omega) and G' '(omega), measured in the linear viscoelastic region, indicate that all solutions possess the pseudoplateau modulus in the low omega region and samples become highly viscoleastic for C greater, similar 4.2 wt %. Above C = 11.2 wt % another plateau appears at the high omega end accompanied by a distinct maximum of G' ' in the intermediate omega region. The relaxation motion with tau = 0.5 s corresponding to the maximum of G' ' is one of characteristic properties of the fibroin solutions in the high C region. Thermorheological behaviors of the solution with C = 27.5 wt % show that the network structure formed in the MM part of the silk gland is susceptible to temperature and a more stable homogeneous network is realized by raising the temperature up to T = 65 degrees C.     

The isolation of collagen-associated proteoglycan from bovine nasal cartilage and its preferential interaction with alpha2 chains of type I collagen.

A collagen complex from bovine nasal cartilage was prepared by extraction of the tissue with 3M-MgCl2 solutions, by using two different procedures. When it was compared with calf skin acid-soluble tropocollagen by polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis, the 3M-MgCl2-soluble cartilage collagen in the complex appeared to be predominantly type I in nature, consisting of both alpha1 and alpha2 chains. The soluble cartilage collagens were digested with purified bacterial collagenase, and the soluble digests were fractionated on Sepharose 4B. Hydroxyproline-free proteoglycan was isolated in the excluded volume of the column eluate, and this was found to be an aggregate which could be dissociated to link proteins and proteoglycan subunit by equilibrium-density-gradient centrifugation in a CsCl-4M-guanidinium chloride gradient. Interaction with calf skin-soluble tropocollagen was studied by CM-cellulose chromatography. The link-protein system did not interact, but proteoglycan from the bottom of the gradient did interact. In addition, when proteoglycan subunit was allowed to interact with collagen, there was a preferential binding to the alpha2 and beta12 components, and this effect was also observed with the proteoglycan material obtained from the collagenase digests of 3M-MgCl2-soluble cartilage collagen complexes. However, specificity for alpha2 and beta12 chains was not exhibited by chondroitin sulphate glycosaminoglycan, and it is therefore concluded that preference for alpha2 and beta12 chains is a function of the intact proteoglycan structure.     

Shear and extensional rheology of cellulose/ionic liquid solutions

In this study, we characterize the shear and extensional rheology of dilute to semidilute solutions of cellulose in the ionic liquid 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium acetate (EMIAc). In steady shear flow, the semidilute solutions exhibit shear thinning, and the high-frequency complex modulus measured in small amplitude oscillatory shear flow exhibits the characteristic scaling expected for solutions of semiflexible chains. Flow curves of the steady shear viscosity plotted against shear rate closely follow the frequency dependence of the complex viscosity acquired using oscillatory shear, thus satisfying the empirical Cox-Merz rule. We use capillary thinning rheometry (CaBER) to characterize the relaxation times and apparent extensional viscosities of the semidilute cellulose solutions in a uniaxial extensional flow that mimics the dynamics encountered in the spin-line during fiber spinning processes. The apparent extensional viscosity and characteristic relaxation times of the semidilute cellulose/EMIAc solutions increase dramatically as the solutions enter the entangled concentration regime at which fiber spinning becomes viable.     

Lateral nanomechanics of cartilage aggrecan macromolecules

To explore the role of the brush-like proteoglycan, aggrecan, in the shear behavior of cartilage tissue, we measured the lateral resistance to deformation of a monolayer of chemically end-attached cartilage aggrecan on a microcontact printed surface in aqueous NaCl solutions via lateral force microscopy. The effects of bath ionic strength (IS, 0.001-1.0 M) and lateral displacement rate (approximately 1-100 microm/s) were studied using probe tips functionalized with neutral hydroxyl-terminated self-assembled alkanethiol monolayers. Probe tips having two different end-radii (R approximately 50 nm and 2.5 microm) enabled access to different length-scales of interactions (nano and micro). The measured lateral force was observed to depend linearly on the applied normal force, and the lateral force to normal force proportionality constant, mu, was calculated. The value mu increased (from 0.03 +/- 0.01 to 0.11 +/- 0.01) with increasing bath IS (0.001-1.0 M) for experiments using the microsized tip due to the larger compressive strain of aggrecan that resulted from increased IS at constant compressive force. With the nanosized tip, mu also increased with IS but by a smaller amount due to the fewer number of aggrecan involved in shear deformation. The variations in lateral force as a function of applied compressive strain epsilon(n) and changes in bath IS suggested that both electrostatic and nonelectrostatic interactions contributed significantly to the shear deformational behavior of the aggrecan layers. While lateral force did not vary with lateral displacement rate at low IS, where elastic-like electrostatic interactions between aggrecan dominated, lateral force increased significantly with displacement rate at physiological and higher IS, suggestive of additional viscoelastic and/or poroelastic interactions within the aggrecan layer. These data provide insights into molecular-level deformation of aggrecan macromolecules that are important to the understanding of cartilage behavior.     

The presence of a cartilage-like proteoglycan in the adult human meniscus.

Proteoglycans were extracted from the adult human meniscus under dissociative conditions and purified by CsCl-density-gradient centrifugation. The preparations of highest density contained proteoglycan that possessed the ability to interact with hyaluronic acid, was of large subunit size and was composed of chondroitin sulphate, keratan sulphate and sialic acid-containing oligosaccharides. This 'cartilage-like' proteoglycan also exhibited subunit and aggregate structures analogous to those of hyaline-cartilage proteoglycans when examined by electron microscopy. However, the composition of this proteoglycan was more comparable with proteoglycans from immature cartilage than from age-matched cartilage. The preparations from lower density, which were enriched in dermatan sulphate, contained smaller proteoglycan that was not able to interact with hyaluronic acid. This non-aggregating proteoglycan may be structurally distinct from the 'cartilage-like' proteoglycan, which does not contain dermatan sulphate.     

Flow properties of N-(carboxymethyl) chitosan aqueous systems in the sol and gel domains

The flow behaviour and the viscoelastic properties of N-(carboxymethyl) chitosan aqueous systems in the sol and gel domains have been investigated by means of dynamic, steady and transient shear techniques. For polymer concentrations Cp up to 1%, a typical response of moderately concentrated polymer solutions was observed under continuous and oscillatory shear conditions. No time-dependent properties were detected during transient shear experiments. On the other hand, for all the samples with Cp greater than 1%, the rheological properties were more similar to those of a weak gel system. The continuous shear flow behaviour was of the plastic type and the viscoelastic quantities G' and G" were parallel to each other and slightly dependent on the frequency of oscillation omega. Stress overshoots were observed during transient shear experiments, and the kinetics of the structural breakdown and build-up processes were found to be dependent both on the polymer concentration and the applied shear rate.     

Inhibition of proteoglycan synthesis by hydrogen peroxide in cultured bovine articular cartilage

Oxygen-derived reactive species, generated enzymatically by the action of xanthine oxidase upon hypoxanthine, significantly inhibit proteoglycan synthesis by cultured bovine articular cartilage (Bates, E.J., Lowther, D.A. and Handley, C.J. (1984) Ann. Rheum. Dis. 43, 462-469). Here we extend these investigations and show, through the use of catalase and the specific iron chelator diethylenetriaminepentaacetic acid, that the active species involved is H2O2 and not the hydroxyl radical. Incubations of cartilage with H2O2 at concentrations of 1 X 10(-4) M and above are also inhibitory to proteoglycan synthesis. Subsequent recovery of the tissue is dependent upon the initial dose of xanthine oxidase or H2O2. Xanthine oxidase at 84 mU per incubation results in a prolonged inhibition of proteoglycan synthesis which is still apparent after 14 days in culture. Lower concentrations of xanthine oxidase (21-66 mU) are inhibitory to proteoglycan synthesis, but the tissue is able to synthesise proteoglycans at near normal rates after 3 days in culture. The inhibition of proteoglycan synthesis by 1 X 10(-4) M H2O2 is completely reversed after 5 days in culture, whereas 1 X 10(-3) M H2O2 results in a more prolonged inhibition. The synthesis of the proteoglycan core protein is inhibited, but the ability of the newly formed proteoglycans to aggregate with hyaluronic acid is unimpaired.     

Cell-free translation of messenger RNA for chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan core protein in rat cartilage.

Total RNA was extracted from the cartilage tissues rat Swarm chondrosarcoma, neonatal-rat breastplate and embryonic-chicken sterna and translated in wheat-germ cell-free reactions. The core protein of the chondroitin sulphate proteoglycan subunit was identified among translation products of rat mRNA by its apparent Mr of 330 000 and by its immunoprecipitation with specific antisera prepared against rat or chicken proteoglycan antigens. The apparent Mr of the rat proteoglycan core protein is 8000-10000 less than that of the equivalent chicken cartilage core-protein product.     

Interaction between proteoglycan subunit and type II collagen from bovine nasal cartilage, and the preferential binding of proteoglycan subunit to type I collagen.

We studied the interaction of proteoglycan subunit with both types I and II collagen. All three molecular species were isolated from the ox. Type II collagen, prepared from papain-digested bovine nasal cartilage, was characterized by gel electrophoresis, amino acid analysis and CM-cellulose chromatography. By comparison of type I collagen, prepared from papain-digested calf skin, with native calf skin acid-soluble tropocollagen, we concluded that the papain treatment left the collagen molecules intact. Interactions were carried out at 4 degrees C in 0.06 M-sodium acetate, pH 4.8, and the results were studied by two slightly different methods involving CM-cellulose chromatography and polyacrylamide-gel electrophoresis. It was demonstrated that proteoglycan subunit, from bovine nasal cartilage, bound to cartilage collagen. Competitive-interaction experiments showed that, in the presence of equal amounts of calf skin acid-soluble tropocollagen (type I) and bovine nasal cartilage collagen (type II), proteoglycan subunit bound preferentially to the type I collagen. We suggest from these results that, although not measured under physiological conditions, it is unlikely that the binding in vivo between type II collagen and proteoglycan is appreciably stronger than that between type I collagen and proteoglycan.