T cell conditioning explains early disappearance of the memory CD8 T cell response to infection

Memory CD8 T cells respond more rapidly to acute intracellular infections than naive CD8 T cells. An understanding of the biological processes involved in memory CD8 T cell recognition of Ag and up-regulation of effector mechanism necessitates analyzing memory CD8 T cells at early time points after infection. In the current study, we show that memory CD8 T cells ostensibly disappear from the spleens, blood, and peripheral organs of mice early after infection with Listeria monocytogenes. This disappearance is critically dependent on Ag, and cell-associated Ag alone can mediate this phenomenon. Further investigations, however, suggest that this disappearance is secondary to T cell-APC interactions, also known as T cell conditioning, and disruption of these putative interactions during splenic processing improves recovery of Ag-specific memory CD8 T cell populations after immunization. Conventional analyses of memory CD8 T cell populations early after infection and possibly in the presence of low levels of Ag (as during chronic infections) may exclude significant numbers of the responding CD8 T cell population.     

Discriminating between different pathways of memory CD8+ T cell differentiation

Despite the rapid accumulation of quantitative data on the dynamics of CD8(+) T cell responses following acute viral or bacterial infections of mice, the pathways of differentiation of naive CD8(+) T cells into memory during an immune response remain controversial. Currently, three models have been proposed. In the "stem cell-associated differentiation" model, following activation, naive T cells differentiate into stem cell-like memory cells, which then convert into terminally differentiated short-lived effector cells. In the "linear differentiation" model, following activation, naive T cells first differentiate into effectors, and after Ag clearance, effectors convert into memory cells. Finally, in the "progressive differentiation" model, naive T cells differentiate into memory or effector cells depending on the amount of specific stimulation received, with weaker stimulation resulting in formation of memory cells. This study investigates whether the mathematical models formulated from these hypotheses are consistent with the data on the dynamics of the CD8(+) T cell response to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus during acute infection of mice. Findings indicate that two models, the stem cell-associated differentiation model and the progressive differentiation model, in which differentiation of cells is strongly linked to the number of cell divisions, fail to describe the data at biologically reasonable parameter values. This work suggests additional experimental tests that may allow for further discrimination between different models of CD8(+) T cell differentiation in acute infections.     

Differential microenvironment localization of effector and memory CD8 T cells

CD8 T cells are critical for the clearance of intracellular pathogens. Upon infection, naive CD8 T cells differentiate into effector cells that target and eliminate infected cells. Following clearance of the pathogen, most effector cells die, although a small fraction survives to establish a memory population. Subsequent exposure to the same pathogen induces a rapid response of memory T cells and efficient elimination of the pathogen. Although much is known about the CD8 T cell response, the precise microenvironment location of effector and memory CD8 T cells in secondary lymphoid organs is not well characterized. In this study, we present an in situ analysis of the localization of effector and memory CD8 T cells during the murine immune response to lymphocytic choriomenginits virus. We identified the location of these cells using a transgenic mouse model system in which CD8 T cells are irreversibly tagged with yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) after activation. After infection, YFP+ CD8 T cells were initially observed within T cell zones. Later, these cells were found in the red pulp and a disruption of all CD8 T cell zones was observed. After resolution of the immune response, YFP+ memory CD8 T cells were observed primarily in T cells zones. Thus, in the spleens of mice, effector CD8 T cells localize to the red pulp and memory CD8 T cells localize to the T cell zones. Upon rechallenge, memory CD8 T cells rapidly proliferate and the secondary effector CD8 T cells are found in the red pulp.     

Cognate memory CD4+ T cells generated with dendritic cell priming influence the expansion, trafficking, and differentiation of secondary CD8+ T cells and enhance tumor control

CD4(+) T cells are known to provide support for the activation and expansion of primary CD8(+) T cells, their subsequent differentiation, and ultimately their survival as memory cells. However, the importance of cognate memory CD4(+) T cells in the expansion of memory CD8(+) T cells after re-exposure to Ag has been not been examined in detail. Using bone marrow-derived dendritic cells pulsed with cognate or noncognate MHC class I- and class II-restricted peptides, we examined whether the presence of memory CD4(+) T cells with the same Ag specificity as memory CD8(+) T cells influenced the quantity and quality of the secondary CD8(+) T cell response. After recombinant vaccinia virus-mediated challenge, we demonstrate that, although cognate memory CD4(+) T cells are not required for activation of secondary CD8(+) T cells, their presence enhances the expansion of cognate memory CD8(+) T cells. Cognate CD4(+) T cell help results in an approximate 2-fold increase in the frequency of secondary CD8(+) T cells in secondary lymphoid tissues, and can be accounted for by enhanced proliferation in the secondary CD8(+) T cell population. In addition, cognate memory CD4(+) T cells further selectively enhance secondary CD8(+) T cell infiltration of tumor-associated peripheral tissue, and this is accompanied by increased differentiation into effector phenotype within the secondary CD8(+) T cell population. The consequence of these improvements to the magnitude and phenotype of the secondary CD8(+) T cell response is substantial increase in control of tumor outgrowth.     

CD4 T cells are required for CD8 T cell survival during both primary and memory recall responses

The role of CD4 T cell help in primary and secondary CD8 T cell responses to infectious pathogens remains incompletely defined. The primary CD8 T response to infections was initially thought to be largely independent of CD4 T cells, but it is not clear why some primary, pathogen-specific CD8 T cell responses are CD4 T cell dependent. Furthermore, although the generation of functional memory CD8 T cells is CD4 T cell help dependent, it remains controversial when the "help" is needed. In this study, we demonstrated that CD4 T cell help was not needed for the activation and effector differentiation of CD8 T cells during the primary response to vaccinia virus infection. However, the activated CD8 T cells showed poor survival without CD4 T cell help, leading to a reduction in clonal expansion and a diminished, but stable CD8 memory pool. In addition, we observed that CD4 T cell help provided during both the primary and secondary responses was required for the survival of memory CD8 T cells during recall expansion. Our study indicates that CD4 T cells play a crucial role in multiple stages of CD8 T cell response to vaccinia virus infection and may help to design effective vaccine strategies.     

Differential sensitivity of naive and memory CD8+ T cells to apoptosis in vivo

Apoptosis is a critical regulator of homeostasis in the immune system. In this study we demonstrate that memory CD8(+) T cells are more resistant to apoptosis than naive cells. After whole body irradiation of mice, both naive and memory CD8(+) T cells decreased in number, but the reduction in the number of naive cells was 8-fold greater than that in memory CD8(+) T cells. In addition to examining radiation-induced apoptosis, we analyzed the expansion and contraction of naive and memory CD8(+) T cells in vivo following exposure to Ag. We found that memory CD8(+) T cells not only responded more quickly than naive cells after viral infection, but that secondary effector cells generated from memory cells underwent much less contraction compared with primary effectors generated from naive cells (3- to 5-fold vs 10- to 20-fold decrease). Increased numbers of secondary memory cells were observed in both lymphoid and non-lymphoid tissues. When naive and memory cells were transferred into the same animal, secondary effectors underwent less contraction than primary effector cells. These experiments analyzing apoptosis of primary and secondary effectors in the same animal show unequivocally that decreased downsizing of the secondary response reflects an intrinsic property of the memory T cells and is not simply due to environmental effects. These findings have implications for designing prime/boost vaccine strategies and also for optimizing immunotherapeutic regimens for treatment of chronic infections.     

TGF-beta 1 attenuates the acquisition and expression of effector function by tumor antigen-specific human memory CD8 T cells

TGF-beta1 is a potent immunoregulatory cytokine. However, its impact on the generation and effector function of Ag-specific human effector memory CD8 T cells had not been evaluated. Using Ag-specific CD8 T cells derived from melanoma patients immunized with the gp100 melanoma Ag, we demonstrate that the addition of TGF-beta1 to the initial Ag activation cultures attenuated the gain of effector function by Ag-specific memory CD8 T cells while the phenotypic changes associated with activation and differentiation into effector memory were comparable to control cultures. These activated memory CD8 T cells consistently expressed lower mRNA levels for T-bet, suggesting a mechanism for TGF-beta1-mediated suppression of gain of effector function in memory T cells. Moreover, TGF-beta1 induced a modest expression of CCR7 on Ag-activated memory CD8 T cells. TGF-beta1 also suppressed cytokine secretion by Ag-specific effector memory CD8 T cells, as well as melanoma-reactive tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes and CD8 T cell clones. These results demonstrate that TGF-beta1 suppresses not only the acquisition but also expression of effector function on human memory CD8 T cells and tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes reactive against melanoma, suggesting that TGF-beta1-mediated suppression can hinder the therapeutic benefits of vaccination, as well as immunotherapy in cancer patients.     

Pathogen-induced inflammatory environment controls effector and memory CD8+ T cell differentiation

In response to infection, CD8(+) T cells integrate multiple signals and undergo an exponential increase in cell numbers. Simultaneously, a dynamic differentiation process occurs, resulting in the formation of short-lived effector cells (SLECs; CD127(low)KLRG1(high)) and memory precursor effector cells (CD127(high)KLRG1(low)) from an early effector cell that is CD127(low)KLRG1(low) in phenotype. CD8(+) T cell differentiation during vesicular stomatitis virus infection differed significantly than during Listeria monocytogenes infection with a substantial reduction in early effector cell differentiation into SLECs. SLEC generation was dependent on Ebi3 expression. Furthermore, SLEC differentiation during vesicular stomatitis virus infection was enhanced by administration of CpG-DNA, through an IL-12-dependent mechanism. Moreover, CpG-DNA treatment enhanced effector CD8(+) T cell functionality and memory subset distribution, but in an IL-12-independent manner. Population dynamics were dramatically different during secondary CD8(+) T cell responses, with a much greater accumulation of SLECs and the appearance of a significant number of CD127(high)KLRG1(high) memory cells, both of which were intrinsic to the memory CD8(+) T cell. These subsets persisted for several months but were less effective in recall than memory precursor effector cells. Thus, our data shed light on how varying the context of T cell priming alters downstream effector and memory CD8(+) T cell differentiation.     

Induction of telomerase activity and maintenance of telomere length in virus-specific effector and memory CD8+ T cells

Acute viral infections induce extensive proliferation and differentiation of virus-specific CD8+ T cells. One mechanism reported to regulate the proliferative capacity of activated lymphocytes is mediated by the effect of telomerase in maintaining the length of telomeres in proliferating cells. We examined the regulation of telomerase activity and telomere length in naive CD8+ T cells and in virus-specific CD8+ T cells isolated from mice infected with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. These studies reveal that, compared with naive CD8+ T cells, which express little or no telomerase activity, Ag-specific effector and long-lived memory CD8+ T cells express high levels of telomerase activity. Despite the extensive clonal expansion that occurs during acute lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus infection, telomere length is maintained in both effector and memory CD8+ T cells. These results suggest that induction of telomerase activity in Ag-specific effector and memory CD8+ T cells is important for the extensive clonal expansion of both primary and secondary effector cells and for the maintenance and longevity of the memory CD8+ T cell population.     

Fully functional memory CD8 T cells in the absence of CD4 T cells

The role of CD4 T cells in providing help to CD8 T cells in primary and secondary responses to infection remains controversial. Using recombinant strains of virus and bacteria expressing the same Ag, we determined the requirement for CD4 T cells in endogenous CD8 T cell responses to infection with vesicular stomatitis virus and Listeria monocytogenes (LM). Depletion of CD4 T cells had no effect on the frequency of primary or secondary vesicular stomatitis virus-specific CD8 T cells in either lymphoid or nonlymphoid tissues. In contrast, the primary LM-specific CD8 T cell response was CD4 T cell dependent. Surprisingly, the LM-specific CD8 T cell recall response was also CD4 T cell dependent, which correlated with a requirement for CD40/CD40L interactions. However, concomitant inhibition of CD40L and CD4 T cell removal revealed that these pathways may be operating independently. Importantly, despite the absence of CD4 T cells during the recall response or throughout the entire response, CD8 memory T cells were functional effectors and proliferated equivalently to their "helped" counterparts. These data call into question the contention that CD4 T cells condition memory CD8 T cells during the primary response and indicate that the principal role of CD4 T cells in generating CD8 memory cells after infection is augmentation of proliferation or survival through costimulatory signals.     

Shortening the infectious period does not alter expansion of CD8 T cells but diminishes their capacity to differentiate into memory cells

Following a primary immune response, a portion of effector T cells gives rise to long-lived memory cells. Although primary expansion and differentiation of effector CD8 T cells is dictated by a brief exposure to Ag, it is unclear whether full memory differentiation is also programmed within the same short window. By carefully modulating the kinetics of Listeria monocytogenes infection, we analyzed the requirements for the programming of effector and memory T cell development in vivo. We find that although limiting the infectious period to the first 24-48 h does not impact the size of the primary CD8 response, the ensuing memory population is significantly diminished. This effect is particularly pronounced in the development of tissue-homing memory cells and is inversely proportional to the initial infectious dose. In contrast to CD8 responses, the differentiation of primary CD4 responses was highly dependent on the continued presence of the infection. Shortening the duration of the infection greatly reduced the development of CD4 effector responses in the spleen and prevented their trafficking to peripheral sites of infection. We propose that the stimulus received by CD8 T cells during the early stages of infection largely contribute to the differentiation of CD8 effector cells, whereas continued or distinct signals received at later stages influence their ability to differentiate into memory cells.     

Epigenetic remodeling of the IL-2 and IFN-gamma loci in memory CD8 T cells is influenced by CD4 T cells

Memory T cells (T(M)) are able to rapidly exert effector functions, including immediate effector cytokine production upon re-encounter with Ag, which is critical for protective immunity. Furthermore, this poised state is maintained as T(M) undergo homeostatic proliferation over time. We examined the molecular basis underlying this enhanced functional capacity in CD8 T(M) by comparing them to defective CD8 T(M) generated in the absence of CD4 T cells. Unhelped CD8 T(M) are defective in many functions, including the immediate expression of cytokines, such as IL-2 and IFN-gamma. Our data show that this defect in IL-2 and IFN-gamma production is independent of clonal selection, functional avidity maturation, and the integrity of proximal TCR signaling, but rather involves epigenetic modification of these cytokine genes. Activated Ag-specific CD8 T cells exhibit rapid DNA demethylation at the IL-2 and IFN-gamma loci and substantial histone acetylation at the IFN-gamma promoter and enhancer regions. These epigenetic modifications occur early after infection at the effector stage and are maintained through memory development. However, activated unhelped CD8 T cells, which fail to develop into functional memory and are incapable of rapid cytokine production, exhibit increased DNA methylation at the IL-2 promoter and fail to acetylate histones at the IFN-gamma locus. Thus, CD4 T cell help influences epigenetic modification during CD8 T(M) differentiation and these epigenetic changes provide a molecular basis for the enhanced responsiveness and the maintenance of a "ready-to-respond" state in CD8 T(M).     

Renewal of peripheral CD8+ memory T cells during secondary viral infection of antibody-sufficient mice

Kinetic studies and short pulses of injected 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine have been used to analyze the development and renewal of peripheral CD8(+) memory T cells in the lungs during primary and secondary respiratory virus infections. We show that developing peripheral CD8(+) memory T cells proliferate during acute viral infection with kinetics that are indistinguishable from those of lymphoid CD8(+) memory T cells. Secondary exposure to the same virus induces a new round of T cell proliferation and extensive renewal of the peripheral and lymphoid CD8(+) memory T cell pools in both B cell-deficient mice and mice with immune Abs. In mice with virus-specific Abs, CD8(+) T cell proliferation takes place with minimal inflammation or effector cell recruitment to the lungs. The delayed arrival of CD8(+) memory T cells to the lungs of these animals suggests that developing memory cells do not require the same inflammatory signals as effector cells to reach the lung airways. These studies provide important new insight into mechanisms that control the maintenance and renewal of peripheral memory T cell populations during natural infections.     

Strength of stimulus and clonal competition impact the rate of memory CD8 T cell differentiation

The developmental pathways of long-lived memory CD8 T cells and the lineage relationship between memory T cell subsets remain controversial. Although some studies indicate the two major memory T cell subsets, central memory T (T(CM)) and effector memory T (T(EM)), are related lineages, others suggest that these subsets arise and are maintained independently of one another. In this study, we have investigated this issue and examined the differentiation of memory CD8 T cell subsets by tracking the lineage relationships of both endogenous and TCR transgenic CD8 T cell responses after acute infection. Our data indicate that TCR transgenic as well as nontransgenic T(EM) differentiate into T(CM) in the absence of Ag. Moreover, the rate of memory CD8 T cell differentiation from T(EM) into the self-renewing and long-lived pool of T(CM) is influenced by signals received during priming, including Ag levels, clonal competition, and/or the duration of infection. Although some T(EM) appear to not progress to T(CM), the vast majority of T(CM) are derived from T(EM). Thus, long-lasting, Ag-independent CD8 T cell memory results from progressive differentiation of memory CD8 T cells, and the rate of memory T cell differentiation is governed by events occurring early during T cell priming.     

Serum antibodies critically affect virus-specific CD4+/CD8+ T cell balance during respiratory syncytial virus infections

Following infection with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), reinfection in healthy individuals is common and presumably due to ineffective memory T cell responses. In peripheral blood of healthy adults, a higher CD4(+)/CD8(+) memory T cell ratio was observed compared with the ratio of virus-specific effector CD4(+)/CD8(+) T cells that we had found in earlier work during primary RSV infections. In mice, we show that an enhanced ratio of RSV-specific neutralizing to nonneutralizing Abs profoundly enhanced the CD4(+) T cell response during RSV infection. Moreover, FcγRs and complement factor C1q contributed to this Ab-mediated enhancement. Therefore, the increase in CD4(+) memory T cell response likely occurs through enhanced endosomal Ag processing dependent on FcγRs. The resulting shift in memory T cell response was likely amplified by suppressed T cell proliferation caused by RSV infection of APCs, a route important for Ag presentation via MHC class I molecules leading to CD8(+) T cell activation. Decreasing memory CD8(+) T cell numbers could explain the inadequate immunity during repeated RSV infections. Understanding this interplay of Ab-mediated CD4(+) memory T cell response enhancement and infection mediated CD8(+) memory T cell suppression is likely critical for development of effective RSV vaccines.     

The impact of pre-existing memory on differentiation of newly recruited naive CD8 T cells

One goal of immunization is to generate memory CD8 T cells of sufficient quality and quantity to confer protection against infection. It has been shown that memory CD8 T cell differentiation in vivo is controlled, at least in part, by the amount and duration of infection, Ag, and inflammatory cytokines present early after the initiation of the response. In this study, we used models of anti-vectorial immunity to investigate the impact of pre-existing immunity on the development and differentiation of vector-induced primary CD8 T cell responses. We showed that existing CD8 T cell memory influences the magnitude of naive CD8 T cell responses. However, the differentiation of newly recruited (either TCR-transgenic or endogenous) primary CD8 T cells into populations with the phenotype (CD62L(hi), CD27(hi), KLRG-1(low)) and function (tissue distribution, Ag-driven proliferation, cytokine production) of long-term memory was facilitated when they were primed in the presence of vector-specific memory CD8 T cells of the same or unrelated specificity. Therefore, these data suggested that the presence of anti-vectorial immunity impacts the rate of differentiation of vector-induced naive CD8 T cells, a notion with important implications for the design of future vaccination strategies.