Stochastic variation in telomere shortening rate causes heterogeneity of human fibroblast replicative life span

The replicative life span of human fibroblasts is heterogeneous, with a fraction of cells senescing at every population doubling. To find out whether this heterogeneity is due to premature senescence, i.e. driven by a nontelomeric mechanism, fibroblasts with a senescent phenotype were isolated from growing cultures and clones by flow cytometry. These senescent cells had shorter telomeres than their cycling counterparts at all population doubling levels and both in mass cultures and in individual subclones, indicating heterogeneity in the rate of telomere shortening. Ectopic expression of telomerase stabilized telomere length in the majority of cells and rescued them from early senescence, suggesting a causal role of telomere shortening. Under standard cell culture conditions, there was a minor fraction of cells that showed a senescent phenotype and short telomeres despite active telomerase. This fraction increased under chronic mild oxidative stress, which is known to accelerate telomere shortening. It is possible that even high telomerase activity cannot fully compensate for telomere shortening in all cells. The data show that heterogeneity of the human fibroblast replicative life span can be caused by significant stochastic cell-to-cell variation in telomere shortening.     

Reversible manipulation of telomerase expression and telomere length. Implications for the ionizing radiation response and replicative senescence of human cells

Most human cells do not express telomerase and irreversibly arrest proliferation after a finite number of divisions (replicative senescence). Several lines of evidence suggest that replicative senescence is caused by short dysfunctional telomeres, which arise when DNA is replicated in the absence of adequate telomerase activity. We describe a method to reversibly bypass replicative senescence and generate mass cultures that have different average telomere lengths. A retrovirus carrying hTERT flanked by excision sites for Cre recombinase rendered normal human fibroblasts telomerase-positive and replicatively immortal. Superinfection with retroviruses carrying wild-type or mutant forms of TIN2, a negative regulator of telomere length, created telomerase-positive, immortal populations with varying average telomere lengths. Subsequent infection with a Cre-expressing retrovirus abolished telomerase activity, creating mortal cells with varying telomere lengths. Using these cell populations, we show that, after hTERT excision, cells senesce with shorter telomeres than parental cells. Moreover, long telomeres, but not telomerase, protected cells from the loss of division potential caused by ionizing radiation. Finally, although telomerase-negative cells with short telomeres senesced after fewer doublings than those with long telomeres, telomere length per se did not correlate with senescence. Our results support a role for telomere structure, rather than length, in replicative senescence.     

Telomerase activation in human fibroblasts during escape from crisis

The immortalization of human diploid fibroblasts requires the circumvention of both the senescence (M1) and crisis (M2) mechanisms of growth control. Cells expressing the SV40 T antigen virtually always bypass senescence, but only rarely escape crisis. The low frequency of this latter event indicates that cellular mutations are necessary to escape crisis. Thirteen subpopulations of T antigen-expressing human fibroblasts were cultured into crisis. Colonies that appeared to resume growth were assayed for telomerase activity, telomere maintenance, and the immortal phenotype. Our results show that 33 of 35 colonies were telomerase negative and were not immortal. Two colonies were telomerase positive when assayed in the first approximately 15 population doublings after crisis. The first was strongly positive, maintained telomeres at a stable short length, and was later determined to be immortal. The second initially had a weak telomerase signal, grew extremely slowly, and when examined had greatly elongated telomeres consistent with the ALT (alternative lengthening of telomeres) mechanism of telomere maintenance. These cells eventually grew faster and were later determined to be immortal. Additionally, two subpopulations had initially weak and later strong telomerase activity and the cells never entered a defined crisis period. We observed a perfect correlation between telomere maintenance and escape from crisis, supporting the hypothesis that the lack of stable telomeres causes crisis and that the ability to maintain telomeres abrogates crisis. J. Cell. Physiol. 180:46–52, 1999. © 1999 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Telomere Length Dynamics in Telomerase-Positive Immortal Human Cell Populations

It has been proposed that the progressive shortening of telomeres in somatic cells eventually results in senescence. Previous experiments have demonstrated that many immortal cell lines have acquired telomerase activity leading to stabilization of telomere length. Telomere dynamics and telomerase activity were examined in the telomerase-positive immortal cell lines HeLa and 293 and subclones derived from them. A mass culture of HeLa cells had a stable mean telomere length over 60 population doublings (PD)in vitro.Subclones of this culture, however, had a range of mean telomere lengths indicating that telomeric heterogeneity exists within a population with a stable mean telomere length. Some of the subclones lacked detectable telomerase activity soon after isolation but regained it by PD 18, suggesting that at least some of the variation in telomere length can be attributed to variations in telomerase activity levels. 293 subclones also varied in telomere length and telomerase activity. Some telomerase-positive 293 subclones contained long telomeres that gradually shortened, demonstrating that factors other than telomerase also act to modulate telomere length. Fluctuations in telomere length in telomerase-positive immortalized cells may contribute to chromosomal instability and clonal evolution.     

Dynamics of telomere erosion in transformed and non-transformed avian cells in vitro

Although vertebrate telomeres are highly conserved, telomere dynamics and telomerase profiles vary among species. The objective of the present study was to examine telomerase activity and telomere length profiles of transformed and non-transformed avian cells in vitro. Non-transformed chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEFs) showed little or no telomerase activity from the earliest passages through senescence. Unexpectedly, a single culture of particularly long-lived senescent CEFs showed telomerase activity after over 250 days in culture. Transformed avian lines (six chicken, two quail and one turkey) and tumor samples (two chicken) exhibited telomerase activity. Telomere length profiles of non-transformed CEF cultures derived from individual embryos of an inbred line (UCD 003) exhibited cycles of shortening and lengthening with a substantial net loss of telomeric DNA by senescence. The telomere length profiles of several transformed cell lines resembled telomere length profiles of senescent CEFs in that they exhibited little of the typical smear of terminal restriction fragments (TRFs) suggesting that these transformed cells may possess a reduced amount of telomeric DNA. These results show that avian telomerase activity profiles are consistent with the telomerase activity profiles of human primary and transformed cells. Further, monitoring of telomere lengths of primary cells provides evidence for a dynamic series of changes over the lifespan of any specific cell culture ultimately resulting in net telomeric DNA loss by senescence.     

Telomere loss: mitotic clock or genetic time bomb?

The Holy Grail of gerontologists investigating cellular senescence is the mechanism responsible for the finite proliferative capacity of somatic cells. In 1973, Olovnikov proposed that cells lose a small amount of DNA following each round of replication due to the inability of DNA polymerase to fully replicate chromosome ends (telomeres) and that eventually a critical deletion causes cell death. Recent observations showing that telomeres of human somatic cells act as a mitotic clock, shortening with age both in vitro and in vivo in a replication dependent manner, support this theory's premise. In addition, since telomeres stabilize chromosome ends against recombination, their loss could explain the increased frequency of dicentric chromosomes observed in late passage (senescent) fibroblasts and provide a checkpoint for regulated cell cycle exit. Sperm telomeres are longer than somatic telomeres and are maintained with age, suggesting that germ line cells may express telomerase, the ribonucleoprotein enzyme known to maintain telomere length in immortal unicellular eukaryotes. As predicted, telomerase activity has been found in immortal, transformed human cells and tumour cell lines, but not in normal somatic cells. Telomerase activation may be a late, obligate event in immortalization since many transformed cells and tumour tissues have critically short telomeres. Thus, telomere length and telomerase activity appear to be markers of the replicative history and proliferative potential of cells; the intriguing possibility remains that telomere loss is a genetic time bomb and hence causally involved in cell senescence and immortalization.     

Maintenance of telomeres in SV40-transformed pre-immortal and immortal human fibroblasts

Shortening of telomeres has been hypothesized to contribute to cellular senescence and may play a role in carcinogenesis of human cells. Furthermore, activation of telomerase has frequently been demonstrated in tumor-derived and in vitro immortalized cells. In this study, we have assessed these phenomena during the life span of simian virus 40 (SV40)-transformed preimmortal and immortal human fibroblasts. We observed progressive reduction in telomere length in preimmortal transformed cells with extended proliferative capacity, with the most dramatic shortening at late passage. Telomere lengths became stabilized (or increased) in immortal fibroblasts accompanied, in one case, by the activation of telomerase. However, an independent immortal cell line that displayed stable telomeres did not have detectable telomerase activity. Furthermore, we found significant telomerase activity in two preimmortal derivatives. Our results provide further evidence for maintenance of telomeres in immortalized human fibroblasts, but they suggest a lack of causal relationship between telomerase activation and immortalization. © 1996 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Transient expression of human telomerase extends the life span of normal human fibroblasts

We utilized the Cre/lox recombination system to transiently express the catalytic subunit of telomerase (hTERT) in normal diploid foreskin fibroblasts (BJ cells). A retroviral construct containing an hTERT cDNA, flanked by loxP-sites was introduced into near senescent BJ cells (population doubling 85). At population doubling (PD) 92, which exceeds the typical life span of these cells, we excised the gene via Cre-mediated recombination. All clones lost telomerase activity and showed telomere shortening over an additional 50 PDs. Interestingly, the average telomere length in these cells became shorter than in untreated BJ cells at senescence. This may be due to hTERT preferentially elongating the shortest telomeres, leading to greater length uniformity. In summary, transient telomerase expression and only a very small average telomere elongation by hTERT resulted in a 50% increase in life span of human fibroblasts. This suggests a potentially safe use of hTERT in tissue engineering.     

Stabilization of telomere length and karyotypic stability are directly correlated with the level of hTERT gene expression in primary fibroblasts

Telomere shortening and lack of telomerase activity have been implicated in cellular senescence in human fibroblasts. Expression of the human telomerase (hTERT) gene in sheep fibroblasts reconstitutes telomerase activity and extends their lifespan. However, telomere length is not maintained in all cell lines, even though in vitro telomerase activity is restored in all of them. Cell lines expressing higher levels of hTERT mRNA do not exhibit telomere erosion or genomic instability. By contrast, fibroblasts expressing lower levels of hTERT do exhibit telomere shortening, although the telomeres eventually stabilize at a shorter length. The shorter telomere lengths and the extent of karyotypic abnormalities are both functions of hTERT expression level. We conclude that telomerase activity is required to bypass senescence but is not sufficient to prevent telomere erosion and genomic instability at lower levels of expression.     

Spontaneous senescence in the MDA-MB-231 cell line

Normal human somatic cells have a limited division potential when they grow in vitro. It is believed that shortening of telomeres, specialized structures at the ends of chromosomes, controls cell growth. When one telomere achieves a critical minimal length, the cell cycle control mechanism recognizes it as DNA damage and causes the cell's exit from the cycle in G1-phase. Because it is not possible to extend telomeres in normal cells, this non-dividing state is prolonged indefinitely, and is known as cellular senescence. The immortal cell line MDA-MB-231 has active telomerase, which prevents telomere shortening and allows cells' permanent divisions. However, there is a fraction of cells that do not divide over several days in culture as documented for some other tumour cell lines. Combination of methods has made it possible to isolate these non-growing cells and compare them with the fraction of fast-growing cells from the same culture. Although the non-growing fraction contains a significant percentage of typical senescent cells, both fractions have equal telomerase activity and telomere length. In this paper we discuss possible mechanisms that cause the appearance of this non-growing fraction of cells in cultures of MDA-MB-231, which indicate stress and genome instability rather than variation in telomerase activity or telomere shortening to affect individual cells.     

An analysis of replicative senescence in dermal fibroblasts derived from chronic leg wounds predicts that telomerase therapy would fail to reverse their disease-specific cellular and proteolytic phenotype

The accumulation of senescent fibroblasts within tissues has been suggested to play an important role in mediating impaired dermal wound healing, which is a major clinical problem in the aged population. The concept that replicative senescence in wound fibroblasts results in reduced proliferation and the failure of refractory wounds to respond to treatment has therefore been proposed. However, in the chronic wounds of aged patients the precise relationship between the observed alteration in cellular responses with aging and replicative senescence remains to be determined. Using assays to assess cellular proliferation, senescence-associated staining beta-galactosidase, telomere length, and extracellular matrix reorganizational ability, chronic wound fibroblasts demonstrated no evidence of senescence. Furthermore, analysis of in vitro senesced fibroblasts demonstrated cellular responses that were distinct and, in many cases, diametrically opposed from those exhibited by chronic wound fibroblasts. Forced expression of telomerase within senescent fibroblasts reversed the senescent cellular phenotype, inhibiting extracellular matrix reorganizational ability, attachment, and matrix metalloproteinase production and thus produced cells with impaired key wound healing properties. It would appear therefore that the distinct phenotype of chronic wound fibroblasts is not simply due to the aging process, mediated through replicative senescence, but instead reflects disease-specific cellular alterations of the fibroblasts themselves.     

Overexpression of the p21 sdi1 gene induces senescence-like state in human cancer cells: implication for senescence-directed molecular therapy for cancer.

Normal cells in a culture enter a nondividing state after a finite number of population doubling, which is termed replicative senescence, whereas cancer cells have unlimited proliferative potential and are thought to exhibit an immmortal phenotype by escaping from senescence. The p21 gene (also known as sdi1), which encodes the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor, is expressed at high levels in senescent cells and contributes to the growth arrest. To examine if the p21sdi1 gene transfer could induce senescence in human cancer cells, we utilized an adenoviral vector-based expression system and four human cancer cell lines differing in their p53 status. Transient overexpression of p21sdi1 on cancer cells induced quiescence by arresting the cell cycle at the G1 phase and exhibited morphological changes, such as enlarged nuclei as well as a flattened cellular shape, specific to the senescence phenotype. We also showed that p21sdi1-transduced cancer cells expressed beta-galactosidase activity at pH 6.0, which is known to be a marker of senescence. Moreover, the polymerase chain reaction-based assay demonstrated that levels of telomerase activity were significantly lower in p21sdi1-expressing cells compared to parental cancer cells. These observations provide the evidence that p21sdi1 overexpression could induce a senescence-like state and reduce telomerase activity in human cancer cells, suggesting that these novel p21sdi1 functions may have important implications for anticancer therapy.     

Human keratinocytes that express hTERT and also bypass a p16(INK4a)-enforced mechanism that limits life span become immortal yet retain normal growth and differentiation characteristics

Normal human cells exhibit a limited replicative life span in culture, eventually arresting growth by a process termed senescence. Progressive telomere shortening appears to trigger senescence in normal human fibroblasts and retinal pigment epithelial cells, as ectopic expression of the telomerase catalytic subunit, hTERT, immortalizes these cell types directly. Telomerase expression alone is insufficient to enable certain other cell types to evade senescence, however. Such cells, including keratinocytes and mammary epithelial cells, appear to require loss of the pRB/p16(INK4a) cell cycle control mechanism in addition to hTERT expression to achieve immortality. To investigate the relationships among telomerase activity, cell cycle control, senescence, and differentiation, we expressed hTERT in two epithelial cell types, keratinocytes and mesothelial cells, and determined the effect on proliferation potential and on the function of cell-type-specific growth control and differentiation systems. Ectopic hTERT expression immortalized normal mesothelial cells and a premalignant, p16(INK4a)-negative keratinocyte line. In contrast, when four keratinocyte strains cultured from normal tissue were transduced to express hTERT, they were incompletely rescued from senescence. After reaching the population doubling limit of their parent cell strains, hTERT(+) keratinocytes entered a slow growth phase of indefinite length, from which rare, rapidly dividing immortal cells emerged. These immortal cell lines frequently had sustained deletions of the CDK2NA/INK4A locus or otherwise were deficient in p16(INK4a) expression. They nevertheless typically retained other keratinocyte growth controls and differentiated normally in culture and in xenografts. Thus, keratinocyte replicative potential is limited by a p16(INK4a)-dependent mechanism, the activation of which can occur independent of telomere length. Abrogation of this mechanism together with telomerase expression immortalizes keratinocytes without affecting other major growth control or differentiation systems.     

Subsenescent telomere lengths in fibroblasts immortalized by limiting amounts of telomerase

Human fibroblasts expressing the catalytic component of human telomerase (hTERT) have been followed for 250-400 population doublings. As expected, telomerase activity declined in long term culture of stable transfectants. Surprisingly, however, clones with average telomere lengths several kilobases shorter than those of senescent parental cells continued to proliferate. Although the longest telomeres shortened, the size of the shortest telomeres was maintained. Cells with subsenescent telomere lengths proliferated for an additional 20 doublings after inhibiting telomerase activity with a dominant-negative hTERT mutant. These results indicate that, under conditions of limiting telomerase activity, cis-acting signals may recruit telomerase to act on the shortest telomeres, argue against the hypothesis that the mortality stage 1 mechanism of cellular senescence is regulated by telomere positional effects (in which subtelomeric loci silenced by long telomeres are expressed when telomeres become short), and suggest that catalytically active telomerase is not required to provide a protein-capping role at the end of very short telomeres.     

Hybrids from fusion of normal human T lymphocytes with immortal human cells exhibit limited life span

A number of normal human cell types have been shown to exhibit cellular senescence in vitro. We and others had found that fusion of normal human fibroblasts with immortal human cells yielded hybrids having limited lifespan. This indicated that the phenotype of cellular senescence is dominant and that immortality results from recessive changes in genes involved in growth control. They also supported the hypothesis that senescence results from genetic mechanisms rather than random damage. Since T lymphocytes are a highly differentiated cell type, in contrast to fibroblasts, it was of interest to determine whether similar mechanisms caused senescence in the T cells. We therefore fused normal human T lymphocytes with an immortal human cell line to determine whether they could restore the senescent, nondividing phenotype in hybrids, as do normal human fibroblasts. Eleven of fifteen hybrid clones studied exhibited limited proliferative potential after achieving a range of population doubling similar to that observed in the cell fusion studies involving normal fibroblasts. These results provide evidence that cellular senescence in T lymphocytes occurs via genetic mechanisms.     

Telomerase abrogates aneuploidy‐induced telomere replication stress,senescence and cell depletion

The causal role of aneuploidy in cancer initiation remains under debate since mutations of euploidy‐controlling genes reduce cell fitness but aneuploidy strongly associates with human cancers. Telomerase activation allows immortal growth by stabilizing telomere length, but its role in aneuploidy survival has not been characterized. Here, we analyze the response of primary human cells and murine hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) to aneuploidy induction and the role of telomeres and the telomerase in this process. The study shows that aneuploidy induces replication stress at telomeres leading to telomeric DNA damage and p53 activation. This results in p53/Rb‐dependent, premature senescence of human fibroblast, and in the depletion of hematopoietic cells in telomerase‐deficient mice. Endogenous telomerase expression in HSCs and enforced expression of telomerase in human fibroblasts are sufficient to abrogate aneuploidy‐induced replication stress at telomeres and the consequent induction of premature senescence and hematopoietic cell depletion. Together, these results identify telomerase as an aneuploidy survival factor in mammalian cells based on its capacity to alleviate telomere replication stress in response to aneuploidy induction.