Radiosensitization by hypoxic pretreatment with misonidazole: an interaction of damage at the DNA level

Prolonged exposures to misonidazole (MISO) in vitro under hypoxic conditions result in radiosensitization which is characterized by a decrease in the size of the radiation survival curve shoulder for cells irradiated under hypoxic or aerobic conditions after drug removal. Although intracellular glutathione (GSH) was depleted during hypoxic exposures to MISO, this could not account for the dose-additive radiosensitization (decrease in shoulder size) since GSH depletion by diethylmaleate had no effect on the sensitivity of cells irradiated in air. The alkaline elution assay was used to measure DNA strand breaks and their repair after exposure to MISO, graded doses of X rays, and the combination of MISO pretreatment with X rays. The elution rate of DNA from irradiated cells increased linearly with X-ray dose, with and without MISO pretreatment. However, the DNA elution rates measured after MISO pretreatment were greater by a constant amount at all X-ray doses greater than 1 Gy. In terms of both cell survival and DNA elution rate, MISO-pretreated cells behaved as though they had received an extra 1.5 Gy. Although the initial damage after X rays was greater in MISO-pretreated cells, there was no effect of MISO pretreatment on the rate of repair of radiation-induced DNA strand breaks. The agreement between the differences in survival levels and DNA elution rates for irradiated control and MISO-pretreated cells and absence of an effect on DNA repair rates suggest that the pretreatment sensitization is due to an additive interaction of damage at the DNA level.     

Mechanism of radiosensitization by halogenated pyrimidines: effect of BrdU on radiation induction of DNA and chromosome damage and its correlation with cell killing

The effect of BrdU incorporation on cell radiosensitivity as well as on the induction of DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) and chromosome damage by radiation was studied in CHO cells. Induction of DNA DSB was measured by the nonunwinding filter elution technique and damage at the chromosome level was visualized and scored in G1 cells using the technique of premature chromosome condensation. The results indicated an increase in the radiosensitivity of cells grown in the presence of BrdU. Although sensitization was observed both in cells irradiated in the exponential phase and in cells irradiated in the plateau phase of growth, the degree of sensitization was greater in exponentially growing cells for the same degree of thymidine replacement by BrdU in the DNA. It is hypothesized that this indicates the possible importance of chromatin structure at the time of irradiation and/or the importance of chromatin conformation changes after irradiation in the expression of radiation-induced potentially lethal damage in cells containing BrdU. Incorporation of BrdU affected both the slope and the width of the shoulder of the survival curve and increased the induction of DNA and chromosome damage per unit absorbed dose. The increase observed in the slope of the survival curve was quantitatively similar to the increase observed in damage induction at the DNA and the chromosome level, suggesting a cause-effect relationship between these phenomena. Reduction in the width of the shoulder did not correlate with the increase in the induction of DNA and chromosome damage, suggesting that different phenomena, probably related to enhanced fixation of radiation-induced potentially lethal damage in cells containing BrdU, underlie its modulation.     

Filter elution assays for DNA damage: practical and mechanistic significance of the DNA in the filter support wash.

The alkaline and neutral (or nondenaturing) filter elution assays are popular methods for the measurement of DNA strand breakage and its repair in eukaryotic cells. In both alkaline and neutral elution, it is recommended practice to wash the filter support after removal of the filter and to analyze the DNA recovered by this procedure together with that remaining on the filter as uneluted DNA, although it is not obvious why the DNA in the filter support wash should be so interpreted. We have observed that the sum of the DNA on the filter and that recovered in the filter support wash is approximately constant when the pH of the alkaline filter elution assay for total strand breaks is increased from 12.1 to 12.6, whereas the fraction on the filter itself is markedly smaller at the higher pH. This behavior characterized DNA elution from undamaged cells, as well as from cells treated with various DNA-damaging agents. These findings are consistent with the "tug-of-war" mechanism that has been proposed for alkaline elution, but are inconsistent with the simplest mechanism of the "sieve" class. In the neutral filter elution assay for double-strand breaks, by contrast, the distribution of DNA between the filter and the filter support wash is pH-independent. This suggests that single- and double-stranded DNA segments traverse a filter by different physical mechanisms. Our observations underscore the importance of carrying out the filter support wash and the analysis of the DNA it contains as uneluted DNA in alkaline elution, while indicating that a different analysis of this DNA might be appropriate for neutral elution.     

Alkaline step elution analysis of gamma-ray induced DNA strand breaks and repair in diploid yeast

Gamma-ray induction of DNA strand breaks and their repair was analysed in the diploid yeast strain D7 (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) by means of the alkaline step elution technique. A dose-dependent increase of DNA strand breakage was observed in the dose range 25-2000 Gy corresponding to 100 and 0.01 per cent survival. When, after exposure to gamma-irradiation, the cells were incubated for 2 h in liquid growth medium, the elution profiles reached the pattern of unirradiated controls, thus indicating the restoration of cellular DNA due to repair. The alkaline step elution analysis is found to be a useful and reproducible technique for studying the induction of DNA strand breaks and repair in yeast. In comparison with other current methods, such as alkaline sucrose gradients and DNA unwinding, this method appears to be more rapid, versatile and easier to handle.     

Radiation-induced damage to DNA in drug- and radiation-resistant sublines of a human breast cancer cell line.

An Adriamycin-resistant subline of a human breast cancer cell line, MCF-7 ADRR, has been shown to exhibit radioresistance associated with an increase in the size of the shoulder on the radiation survival curve. In the present study, damage to DNA of MCF-7 sublines WT and ADRR by 60Co gamma radiation was measured by filter elution techniques. The initial amount of DNA damage, measured by both alkaline and neutral filter elution, was lower in ADRR cells, suggesting that these cells are resistant to radiation-induced single- and double-strand DNA breaks. In the case of double-strand breaks the difference between WT and ADRR cells was significant only at the lower radiation doses studied (up to 100 Gy). In cells depleted of glutathione (GSH) by L-buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) treatment, ADRR cells were sensitized to radiation-induced DNA damage, while WT cells were unaffected. The rate of repair of single- and double-strand DNA breaks following radiation was the same for both sublines, and repair of radiation damage was not affected by BSO treatment in either cell line. The relative resistance of ADRR cells to initial DNA damage by radiation is the only difference so far detected at the molecular level which reflects radiation survival, and it is possible that other factors are involved in the resistance of ADRR cells to killing by radiation. Sensitization of ADRR cells to radiation-induced DNA damage by GSH depletion, although not likely to involve inhibition of GSH-dependent detoxification enzymes per se (irradiation was done at 4 degrees C), suggests that at the molecular level radioresponse in this subline is related to maintenance of GSH/GSSG redox equilibrium.     

Sister chromatid differentiation after in situ detection of ultraviolet-induced DNA breaks under electron microscopy

Summary— Chinese hamster DON cells with 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU)-substituted chromosomes were ultraviolet (UV)-exposed and processed for in situ detection of induced DNA breaks under electron microscopy. For this purpose, UV-induced breaks were amplified by an exonuclease III digestion to obtain single stranded DNA motifs which could hybridize with oligonucleotides of random sequences. These reannealed motifs could be used as primers which were extended by the Klenow polymerase, incorporating biotinylated-dUTP that was detected by a gold-tagged streptavidin. After processing, the chromatid whose DNA was BrdU-substituted in one strand showed a higher electron density than the chromatid substituted in both strands. In contrast, the unifilarly substituted chromatid showed about twice the labelling of DNA breaks as the bifilarly substituted one. This result could be the consequence of a greater loss of chromatin tracts in the bifilarly substituted chromatid, as implied by an X-ray microanalysis which showed that the amount of phosphorous lost by the bifilarly substituted chromatid was higher than that of the unifilarly substituted chromatid.     

125I-induced DNA double strand breaks: use in calibration of the neutral filter elution technique and comparison with X-ray induced breaks

The neutral filter elution assay, for measurement of DNA double strand breakage, has been calibrated using mouse L cells and Chinese hamster V79 cells labelled with [125I]dUrd and then held at liquid nitrogen temperature to accumulate decays. The basis of the calibration is the observation that each 125I decay, occurring in DNA, produces a DNA double strand break. Linear relationships between 125I decays per cell and lethal lesions per cell (minus natural logarithm survival) and the level of elution, were found. Using the calibration data, it was calculated that the yield of DNA double strand breaks after X-irradiation of both cell types was from 6 to 9 X 10(-12) DNA double strand breaks per Gy per dalton of DNA, for doses greater than 6 Gy. Neutral filter elution and survival data for X-irradiated and 125I-labelled cells suggested that the relationships between lethal lesions and DNA double strand breakage were significantly different for both cell types. An attempt was made to study the repair kinetics for 125I-induced DNA double strand breaks, but was frustrated by the rapid DNA degradation which occurs in cells that have been killed by the freezing-thawing process.     

Radiation-induced DNA base damage detected in individual aerobic and hypoxic cells with endonuclease III and formamidopyrimidine-glycosylase.

X-ray-induced DNA base damage can be detected using endonuclease III and formamidopyrimidine-glycosylase, which create DNA strand breaks at enzyme-sensitive sites. Strand breaks can then be measured with excellent sensitivity using the alkaline comet assay, a single-cell gel electrophoresis method that detects DNA damage in individual cells. In using this approach to measure the oxygen enhancement ratio (OER) for radiation-induced base damage, we observed that the number of enzyme-sensitive sites increased with dose up to 4 Gy in air and 12 Gy in hypoxic WIL2NS cells. After rejoining of radiation-induced strand breaks, base damage was detected more easily after higher doses. The number of radiation-induced enzyme-sensitive sites was similar under both air and nitrogen. Base damage produced by hydrogen peroxide and 4-nitroquinoline-N-oxide (4NQO) was also measured. Results with hydrogen peroxide (20 min at 4 degrees C) were similar to those observed for X rays, indicating that enzyme-sensitive sites could be detected most efficiently when few direct strand breaks were present. Removing DNA-associated proteins before irradiation did not affect the ability to detect base damage. Base damage produced by 4NQO (30 min at 37 degrees C) was readily apparent after treatment with low concentrations of the drug when few 4NQO-induced strand breaks were present, but the detection sensitivity decreased rapidly as direct strand breaks increased after treatment with higher concentrations. We conclude that: (1) the OER for base damage is approximately 1.0, and (2) the presence of direct DNA strand breaks (>2000-4000 per cell) prevents accurate detection of base damage measured as enzyme-sensitive sites with the alkaline comet method.     

X-ray induced DNA double strand break production and repair in mammalian cells as measured by neutral filter elution.

This work presents a neutral filter elution method for detecting DNA double strand breaks in mouse L1210 cells after X-ray. The assay will detect the number of double strand breaks induced by as little as 1000 rad of X-ray. The rate of DNA elution through the filters under neutral conditions increases with X-ray dose. Certain conditions for deproteinization, pH, and filter type are shown to increase the assay's sensitivity. Hydrogen peroxide and Bleomycin also induce apparent DNA double strand breaks, although the ratios of double to single strand breaks vary from those produced by X-ray. The introduction of double strand cuts by HpA I restriction endonuclease in DNA lysed on filters results in a rapid rate of elution under neutral conditions, implying that the method can detect double strand breaks if they exist in the DNA. The eluted DNA bands with a double stranded DNA marker in cesium chloride. This evidence suggests that the assay detects DNA double strand breaks. L1210 cells are shown to rejoin most of the DNA double strand breaks induced by 5-10 krad of X-ray with a half-time of about 40 minutes.     

Cell inactivation and DNA single- and double-strand breaks in cultured mammalian cells irradiated by a thermal neutron beam

The effects on the cellular viability and induction and repair kinetics of DNA strand breaks in HeLa cells were examined after exposure to a thermal neutron beam and compared with those after gamma-irradiation. The thermal neutron survival curve had no initial shoulder. The relative biological effectiveness (r.b.e.) value of the neutron beam was determined to be 2.2 for cell killing (ratio of D0 values), 1.8 and 0.89 for single strand breakage (ssb) by alkaline sedimentation and alkaline elution respectively, and for double strand breakage (dsb) 2.6 by neutral elution. No difference was observed between thermal neutrons and gamma-rays in the repair kinetics of ssb and dsb. It is suggested that the effect induced by the intracellular nuclear reaction, 14N(n,p)14C is mainly responsible for the high r.b.e. values observed.     

The effect of mitotic inhibitors on DNA strand size and radiation-associated break repair in Down syndrome fibroblasts

The effect of mitotic inhibitors on formation and repair of DNA breaks was studied in cultured fibroblasts from patients with Down syndrome in order to investigate the hypothesis that the karyotyping procedure itself may play a role in the increased chromosome breakage seen in these cells after gamma radiation exposure. Using the nondenaturing elution and alkaline elution techniques to examine fibroblasts from Down syndrome patients and from controls, no specific abnormalities in Down syndrome cells could be detected after exposure to mitotic inhibitors, including rate and extent of elution of DNA from filters as well as repair of radiation-induced DNA breaks. In both normal and Down syndrome cell strains, however, exposure to mitotic inhibitors was associated with a decrease in cellular DNA strand size, suggesting the presence of drug-induced DNA strand breaks. The mechanism of increased chromosome sensitivity of Down syndrome cells to gamma radiation remains unknown.     

DNA-bound proteins contribute much more than soluble intracellular compounds to the intrinsic protection against radiation-induced DNA strand breaks in human cells

To assess the role of soluble intracellular compounds and DNA-bound proteins in the intrinsic protection against radiation-induced DNA strand breaks, the alkaline unwinding technique was applied to cellular, nuclear, and nucleoid monolayers. It was found that, when the soluble intracellular compounds were removed from human fibroblasts by permeabilization (nuclear monolayers) and irradiated in a phosphate buffer containing 150 mM monovalent cations (Na+ and K+) and 0.8 mM MgCl2, the frequency of radiation-induced DNA strand breaks increased twofold. Removal of both soluble intracellular compounds and DNA-bound proteins from the cells by a pretreatment with 2 M NaCl (nucleoid monolayers) resulted in a 100-fold increase in the frequency of strand-break induction by gamma radiation. Expressed as percentage of total intrinsic protection against radiation-induced DNA strand breaks, DNA-bound protein contributed 99% compared to 1% by soluble intracellular compounds. Using a different experimental approach it was found that the radioprotective capacity of soluble intracellular compounds was equivalent to about 5 mM dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and DNA-bound proteins to about 70 mM DMSO. It is concluded that DNA-bound proteins play a much greater role than soluble intracellular compounds in the intrinsic protection against radiation-induced DNA strand breaks in cultured human cells.     

Reduction in DNA repair capacity following differentiation of murine proadipocytes

It has been suggested that terminally differentiated mammalian cells have a decreased DNA repair capacity, compared with proliferating stem cells. To investigate this hypothesis, we have examined gamma-ray-induced DNA strand breaks and their repair in the murine proadipocyte stem cell line 3T3-T. By exposure to human plasma, 3T3-T cells can be induced to undergo nonterminal and then terminal differentiation. DNA strand breaks were evaluated using the technique of alkaline elution. No difference was detected among stem, nonterminally differentiated, and terminally differentiated cells in the initial levels of radiation-induced DNA strand breaks. Each of the strand break dose response increased as a linear function of gamma-ray dose. The strand breaks induced by 4 Gy rejoined following biphasic kinetics for each cell type. At each time point examined after irradiation, however, the percentage of strand breaks that had not rejoined in terminally differentiated cells was three to six times greater than in stem cells. The rate of strand break rejoining in nonterminally differentiated cells was of an intermediate value between that of the stem and of the terminally differentiated cells. These results indicate that, at least for 3T3-T cells, differentiated cells have a reduced capacity for DNA repair.     

Gamma radiation-induced single strand breaks in DNA and their repair in spheroplasts and nuclei of light-grown and dark-grown Euglena cells

Exposure of light-grown and dark-grown Euglena cells to gamma radiation causes single strand breaks in nuclear DNA as assessed by sedimentation analysis in alkaline sucrose density gradients. The number of radiation-induced single strand breaks in nuclear DNA of light-grown cells is found to be less than that in dark-grown cells. Post-irradiation incubation of both types of cells in 0 . 1 M phosphate buffer, pH 7 . 0 at 25 degrees C for 1 hour results in restitution of the strand breaks in DNA. Light-grown cells (cells with chloroplasts) are able to rejoin all the single strand breaks in DNA produced by gamma irradiation at D50 and D5 doses. On the other hand, dark-grown cells (cells devoid of chloroplasts) are unable to rejoin all the strand breaks caused by irradiation at either of the doses. The rate of DNA repair in dark-grown cells is also much slower than that in light-grown cells. Radiation-induced single strand breaks in DNA and their repair in nuclei from both types of cells is found to be similar to that observed in the spheroplasts. It is suggested that some factor(s) elaborated by chloroplasts may contribute towards the efficiency of nuclear DNA repair in Euglena cells.     

Accumulation of DNA strand breaks during thymineless death in thymidylate synthase-negative mutants of mouse FM3A cells

Thymidylate synthase-negative mutants of cultured mouse cells were immediately committed to cell death upon thymidine deprivation, especially when the cells were synchronized in the S phase. Thymidylate deprivation induced single strand breaks in chromosome-size DNA strands, as measured by alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation, giving rise to two peaks, one with large and the other with small fragments, the latter about the size of T4 DNA. An increase in the small DNA fragments paralleled that of thymineless death. Thymidine deprivation also produced double strand DNA fragments as determined by a method of neutral filter elution, and their extent paralleled that of cell death. Double-stranded DNA eluted through the filter sedimented as a single peak both in a neutral and in an alkaline sucrose gradient that coincided with that of the above small DNA fragments. Therefore, the strand breaks seemed to occur in some defined portions of the genome and in a specific manner compared to breaks induced by x-rays, which occurred rather randomly. Cycloheximide blocked both thymineless death and the production of the small DNA fragments. The strand breaks induced by thymidine starvation were not repaired but instead advanced on subsequent incubation of the cells in growth medium containing thymidine.     

The effect of bromodeoxyuridine and ultraviolet light on 9L rat brain tumor cells

Incorporation of the thymidine analog bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) into DNA increases the sensitivity of a cell to uv light. We have examined the effect of uv light on cell killing and alkaline elution profiles in 9L rat brain tumor cells pretreated with BrdUrd. Combination treatment with BrdUrd and uv irradiation produced a dose enhancement ratio of 3.8 at the 10% survival level compared with uv-radiated control cells; cell killing depended on both the time of treatment and the concentration of BrdUrd used for incubation. Sequential treatment caused single-strand breaks and DNA-protein crosslinks in the portion of DNA containing BrdUrd; uv irradiation alone caused very few strand breaks and no DNA-protein crosslinks. Because of the presence of both lesions in cells treated with BrdUrd and uv light, it was possible to calculate crosslinking factors without using a charging X-ray dose to induce strand breaks, the method commonly used with crosslinking drugs. Results of repair studies suggested that single-strand breaks are repaired more rapidly than are DNA-protein crosslinks.     

Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate imbalance. 5-Fluorodeoxyuridine-induced DNA double strand breaks in mouse FM3A cells and the mechanism of cell death

The mechanism of cytotoxic action of 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FdUrd) in mouse FM3A cells was investigated. We observed the FdUrd-induced imbalance of intracellular deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate (dNTP) pools and subsequent double strand breaks in mature DNA, accompanied by cell death. The imbalance of dNTP pools was maximal at 8 h after 1 microM FdUrd treatment; a depletion of dTTP and dGTP pools and an increase in the dATP pool were observed. The addition of FdUrd in culture medium induced strand breaks in DNA, giving rise to a 90 S peak by alkaline sucrose gradient sedimentation. The loss of cell viability and colony-forming ability occurred at about 10 h. DNA double strand breaks as measured by the neutral elution method were also observed in FdUrd-treated cells about 10 h after the addition. These results lead us to propose that DNA double strand breaks play an important role in the mechanism of FdUrd-mediated cell death. A comparison of the ratio of single and double strand breaks induced by FdUrd to that observed following radiation suggested that FdUrd produced double strand breaks exclusively. Cycloheximide inhibited both the production of DNA double strand breaks and the FdUrd-induced cell death. An activity that can induce DNA double strand breaks was detected in the lysate of FdUrd-treated FM3A cells but not in the untreated cells. This suggests that FdUrd induces the cellular DNA double strand breaking activity. The FdUrd-induced DNA strand breaks and cell death appear to occur in the S phase. Our results indicate that imbalance of the dNTP pools is a trigger for double strand DNA break and cell death.     

The repair of double-strand DNA breaks correlates with radiosensitivity of L5178Y-S and L5178Y-R cells

To better understand the basis for the difference in radiosensitivity between the variant murine leukemic lymphoblast cell lines L5178Y-R (resistant) and L5178Y-S (sensitive), the production and repair of DNA damage after X irradiation were measured by the DNA alkaline and neutral elution techniques. The initial yield of single-strand DNA breaks and the rates of their repair were found to be the same in both cell lines by the DNA alkaline elution technique. Using the technique of neutral DNA elution, L5178Y-S cells exhibited slightly increased double-strand breakage immediately after irradiation, most significantly at lower doses (i.e., less than 10 Gy). Nevertheless, even at doses that yielded equal initial double-strand breakage of both cell lines, the survival of L5178Y-S cells was significantly less than that of L5178Y-R cells. When the technique of neutral DNA elution was employed to measure the kinetics of DNA double-strand break repair, both cell lines exhibited biphasic fast and slow components of repair. However, the double-strand repair rate was much lower in the radiosensitive L5178Y-S cells than in the L5178Y-R cells (T1/2 of 60 vs 16 min). This difference was more pronounced in the fast-repair component. These results suggest that the repair of double-strand DNA breaks is an important factor determining the radiosensitivity of L5178Y cells.     

Rejoining of DNA strand breaks by T4 DNA ligase in mammalian cells

We have tested the ability of T4 DNA ligase to rejoin radiation-induced DNA strand breaks in living hamster cells (CHO-K1, EM9, xrs-5). T4 DNA ligase was introduced into cells by electroporation prior to x-irradiation. Single- and double-strand breaks were measured by the alkaline comet assay technique, and double-strand breaks (DSBs) were evaluated by the pulsed-field gel electrophoresis method. In the comet assay, the three cell lines showed reduced tail moments following pretreatment with T4 DNA ligase, both directly after irradiation and after repair incubation for 4 h. Similarly, the results obtained from pulsed-field gel electrophoresis showed reduced DSB frequencies after pretreatment with T4 DNA ligase. We conclude that exogeneous T4 ligase contributes to rejoining of radiation-induced strand breaks.