AP-1 and AP-3 mediate sorting of melanosomal and lysosomal membrane proteins into distinct post-Golgi trafficking pathways

The adaptor complexes AP-1 and AP-3 are localized to endosomes and/or the trans Golgi network (TGN). Because of limitations in analysing intracellular adaptor function directly, their site of function is a matter of ongoing uncertainty. To overcome this problem and to analyse adaptor sorting at the TGN, we reconstituted vesicle formation from Golgi/TGN-enriched membranes in a novel in vitro budding assay. Melanocytes were metabolically labelled followed by a 19°C temperature block to accumulate newly synthesized proteins in Golgi membranes, which were then enriched by subcellular fractionation and used as donor membranes for vesicle formation in vitro . The incorporation of the melanosomal proteins tyrosinase and tyrosinase-related protein 1 (TRP-1) as well as Lamp-1 and 46 kDa mannose-6-phosphate receptor (MPR46) into Golgi/TGN-derived vesicles was temperature, nucleotide, cytosol, ADP ribosylation factor 1 and adaptor dependent. We show that sorting of TRP-1 and MPR46 was AP-1 dependent, while budding of tyrosinase and Lamp-1 required AP-3. Depletion of clathrin inhibited sorting of all four cargo proteins, suggesting that AP-1 and AP-3 are involved in the formation of distinct types of clathrin-coated vesicles, each of which is characterized by the incorporation of specific cargo membrane proteins.     

Cetaben-induced changes on the morphology and peroxisomal enzymes in MH1C1 rat hepatoma cells and HepG2 human hepatoblastoma cells

Human HepG2 and rat MH1C1 hepatoma cell lines were examined for their response to cetaben, an exceptional type of peroxisome proliferator. Shape change and proliferation of peroxisomes as well as induction of selected peroxisomal enzymes catalase, acyl-CoA oxidase, and peroxisomal bifunctional enzyme, were assessed in response to cetaben. In MH1C1 cells, peroxisomes were seen in clusters displaying typical features of microperoxisomes. Cetaben caused little but reversible proliferation and morphological heterogeneity with the occurrence of dumbbell-shaped and cup-shaped peroxisomal profiles. Peroxisomes in HepG2 cells showed marked variation in size and shape. Cetaben treatment of HepG2 cells caused disintegration of Golgi regions and augmented mitochondrial matrix. Interestingly, MH1C1 cells showed different subunit composition of acyl-CoA oxidase in immunoblot analysis: only subunit A at 72 kDa was detected but not the cleavage products. In situ hybridization underlined the marked morphological heterogeneity observed, and both cell lines revealed different stages of gene expression. Our results indicate that cetaben represents an extraordinary type of peroxisomal proliferator with pleiotropic effects on human and rat hepatoma cells, and, at least in the human hepatoma cell line HepG2, these effects are not restricted to peroxisome proliferation.     

Cholesterol supports the retinoic acid-induced synaptic vesicle formation in differentiating human SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells

Synaptic vesicle formation, vesicle activation and exo/endocytosis in the pre-synaptic area are central steps in neuronal communication. The formation and localization of synaptic vesicles in human SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cells, differentiated with 12-o-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate, dibutyryl cyclic AMP, all-trans-retinoic acid (RA) and cholesterol, was studied by fluorescence microscopy and immunocytochemical methods. RA alone or together with cholesterol, produced significant neurite extension and formation of cell-to-cell contacts. Synaptic vesicle formation was followed by anti-synaptophysin (SypI) and AM1-43 staining. SypI was only weakly detected, mainly in cell somata, before 7 days in vitro, after which it was found in neurites. Depolarization of the differentiated cells with high potassium solution increased the number of fluorescent puncta, as well as SypI and AM1-43 co-localization. In addition to increase in the number of synaptic vesicles, RA and cholesterol also increased the number and distribution of lysosome-associated membrane protein 2 labeled lysosomes. RA-induced Golgi apparatus fragmentation was partly avoided by co-treatment with cholesterol. The SH-SY5Y neuroblastoma cell line, differentiated by RA and cholesterol and with good viability in culture, is a valuable tool for basic studies of neuronal metabolism, specifically as a model for dopaminergic neurons.     

Transport of the membrane glycoprotein of vesicular stomatitis virus to the cell surface in two stages by clathrin-coated vesicles

The G protein of vesicular stomatitis virus is a transmembrane glycoprotein that is transported from its site of synthesis in the rough endoplasmic reticulum to the plasma membrane via the Golgi apparatus. Pulse-chase experiments suggest that G is transported to the cell surface in two successive waves of clathrin-coated vesicles. The oligosaccharides of G protein carried in the early wave are of the "high-mannose" (G1) form, whereas the oligosaccharides in the second, later wave are of the mature "complex" (G2) form. the early wave is therefore proposed to correspond to transport of G in coated vesicles from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi apparatus, and the succeeding wave to transport from the Golgi apparatus to the plasma membrane. The G1- and G2-containing coated vesicles appear to be structurally distinct, as judged by their differential precipitation by anticoated vesicle serum.     

ATP-dependent fusion of liposomes with the Golgi apparatus of perforated cells

We examined the interactions of lipid vesicles (liposomes) labeled with various fluorescent markers with the intracellular membranes of semi-intact ("perforated") fibroblasts. When incubations were performed in the presence of an ATP-regenerating system, both vesicle lipids and entrapped water soluble markers were transferred to the Golgi apparatus of treated cells, indicative of membrane fusion. Fusion occurred using unilamellar vesicles 30-80 nm in diameter and composed of phosphatidylcholine alone, but was inhibited when equimolar amounts of either phosphatidylserine or sphingomyelin were present in the vesicles. Lipid vesicle-Golgi membrane fusion was also inhibited by pretreatment of the perforated cells with N-ethylmaleimide. These findings suggest that lipid vesicles may be useful for delivery of labeled lipids, macromolecules, and dyes to the Golgi apparatus, and for modeling the interactions of transport vesicles with the Golgi apparatus.     

A role for clathrin in reassembly of the Golgi apparatus

The Golgi apparatus is a highly dynamic organelle whose organization is maintained by a proteinaceous matrix, cytoskeletal components, and inositol phospholipids. In mammalian cells, disassembly of the organelle occurs reversibly at the onset of mitosis and irreversibly during apoptosis. Several pharmacological agents including nocodazole, brefeldin A (BFA), and primary alcohols (1-butanol) induce reversible fragmentation of the Golgi apparatus. To dissect the mechanism of Golgi reassembly, rat NRK and GH3 cells were treated with 1-butanol, BFA, or nocodazole. During washout of 1-butanol, clathrin, a ubiquitous coat protein implicated in vesicle traffic at the trans-Golgi network and plasma membrane, and abundant clathrin coated vesicles were recruited to the region of nascent Golgi cisternae. Knockdown of endogenous clathrin heavy chain showed that the Golgi apparatus failed to reform efficiently after BFA or 1-butanol removal. Instead, upon 1-butanol washout, it maintained a compact, tight morphology. Our results suggest that clathrin is required to reassemble fragmented Golgi elements. In addition, we show that after butanol treatment the Golgi apparatus reforms via an initial compact intermediate structure that is subsequently remodeled into the characteristic interphase lace-like morphology and that reassembly requires clathrin.     

Cholesterol and vesicular stomatitis virus G protein take separate routes from the endoplasmic reticulum to the plasma membrane

Transport of newly synthesized cholesterol and vesicular stomatitis virus G protein from the endoplasmic reticulum to the plasma membrane is interrupted by incubation at 15 degrees C. Under this condition the newly synthesized molecules accumulate in both the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and a subcellular vesicle fraction of low density called the lipid-rich vesicle fraction. The material in the lipid-rich vesicle fraction appears to be a post-ER intermediate in the transport process to the plasma membrane (PM). Although both newly synthesized cholesterol and G protein accumulate in this intermediate compartment at 15 degrees C, suggesting cotransport, treatment with Brefeldin A does not affect cholesterol transport to the PM, whereas it strongly inhibits G protein transport. We conclude that cholesterol and G protein leave the ER in separate vesicles, the cholesterol containing vesicles bypass the Golgi apparatus and proceed to the PM, whereas G protein containing vesicles follow the well documented Golgi route to the cell surface.     

Intracellular localization of phospholipase D1 in mammalian cells

Phospholipase D (PLD) hydrolyzes phosphatidylcholine to generate phosphatidic acid. In mammalian cells this reaction has been implicated in the recruitment of coatomer to Golgi membranes and release of nascent secretory vesicles from the trans-Golgi network. These observations suggest that PLD is associated with the Golgi complex; however, to date, because of its low abundance, the intracellular localization of PLD has been characterized only indirectly through overexpression of chimeric proteins. We have used highly sensitive antibodies to PLD1 together with immunofluorescence and immunogold electron microscopy as well as cell fractionation to identify the intracellular localization of endogenous PLD1 in several cell types. Although PLD1 had a diffuse staining pattern, it was enriched significantly in the Golgi apparatus and was also present in cell nuclei. On fragmentation of the Golgi apparatus by treatment with nocodazole, PLD1 closely associated with membrane fragments, whereas after inhibition of PA synthesis, PLD1 dissociated from the membranes. Overexpression of an hemagglutinin-tagged form of PLD1 resulted in displacement of the endogenous enzyme from its perinuclear localization to large vesicular structures. Surprisingly, when the Golgi apparatus collapsed in response to brefeldin A, the nuclear localization of PLD1 was enhanced significantly. Our data show that the intracellular localization of PLD1 is consistent with a role in vesicle trafficking from the Golgi apparatus and suggest that it also functions in the cell nucleus.     

Isolation of a vesicular intermediate in the cell-free transfer of membrane from transitional elements of the endoplasmic reticulum to Golgi apparatus cisternae of rat liver

Preparations enriched in part-smooth (lacking ribosomes), part-rough (with ribosomes) transitional elements of the endoplasmic reticulum when incubated with ATP plus a cytosol fraction responded by the formation of blebbing profiles and approximately 60-nm vesicles. The 60-nm vesicles formed resembled closely transition vesicles in situ considered to function in the transfer of membrane materials between the endoplasmic reticulum and the Golgi apparatus. The transition elements following incubation with ATP and cytosol were resolved by preparative free-flow electrophoresis into fractions of differing electronegativity. The main fraction contained the larger vesicles of the transitional membrane elements, while a less electronegative minor shoulder fraction was enriched in the 60-nm vesicles. If the vesicles concentrated by preparative free-flow electrophoresis were from material previously radiolabeled with [3H]leucine and then added to Golgi apparatus immobilized to nitrocellulose, radioactivity was transferred to the Golgi apparatus membranes. The transfer was rapid (T1/2 of about 5 min), efficient (10-30% of the total radioactivity of the transition vesicle preparations was transferred to Golgi apparatus), and independent of added ATP but facilitated by cytosol. Transfer was specific and apparently unidirectional in that Golgi apparatus membranes were ineffective as donor membranes and endoplasmic reticulum vesicles were ineffective as recipient membranes. Using a heterologous system with transition vesicles from rat liver and Golgi apparatus isolated from guinea pig liver, coalescence of the small endoplasmic reticulum-derived vesicles with Golgi apparatus membranes was demonstrated using immunocytochemistry. Employed were polyclonal antibodies directed against the isolated rat transition vesicle preparations. When localized by immunogold procedures at the electron microscope level, regions of rat-derived vesicles were found fused with cisternae of guinea pig Golgi apparatus immobilized to nitrocellulose strips. Membrane transfer was demonstrated from experiments where transition vesicle membrane proteins were radioiodinated by the Bolton-Hunter procedure. Additionally, radiolabeled peptide bands not present initially in endoplasmic reticulum appeared following coalescence of the derived vesicles with Golgi apparatus. These bands, indicative of processing, required that both Golgi apparatus and transition vesicles be present and did not occur in incubated endoplasmic reticulum preparations or on nitrocellulose strips to which no Golgi apparatus were added.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Lipoprotein secretion by rat liver Golgi apparatus. Lipoprotein particles and lipase activity.

Lipoprotein particles of the size range of very low density lipoproteins in smooth endoplasmic reticulum, peripheral elements of the Golgi apparatus, and secretory vesicles of the immature Golgi apparatus face are 55 to 80 nm in diameter. Particles in mature secretory vesicles are smaller (45 nm). Concomitant with the change in particle size, the lumina of mature vesicles increase in electron density. A technique to fractionate immature and mature secretory vesicles was based on precipitation of a cupric-ferrocyanide complex (Hatchett's brown) through the action of a NADH-ferricyanide oxido-reductase resistant to glutaraldehyde which is characteristic of the membranes of mature secretory vesicles and of the plasma membrane of liver. Mature secretory vesicle fractions so isolated were enriched in cholesterol and depleted in triglycerides relative to immature vesicles on a phospholipid basis. Lipase activity was present in secretory vesicle fractions of the Golgi apparatus as shown by biochemical analysis and by cytochemistry. Cytochemical studies showed lipase to be present in both mature and immature vesicles but most evident in immature vesicles. The findings suggest that some very low density lipoprotein particles are converted to particles of smaller diameter during transit through Golgi apparatus. A lipase-mediated hydrolysis of triglycerides may relate to the transformation.     

Is cytochrome P-450 transported from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi apparatus in rat hepatocytes?

The Golgi apparatus mediates intracellular transport of not only secretory and lysosomal proteins but also membrane proteins. As a typical marker membrane protein for endoplasmic reticulum (ER) of rat hepatocytes, we have selected phenobarbital (PB)-inducible cytochrome P- 450 (P-450[PB]) and investigated whether P-450(PB) is transported to the Golgi apparatus or not by combining biochemical and quantitative ferritin immunoelectron microscopic techniques. We found that P-450(PB) was not detectable on the membrane of Golgi cisternae either when P-450 was maximally induced by phenobarbital treatment or when P-450 content in the microsomes rapidly decreased after cessation of the treatment. The P-450 detected biochemically in the Golgi subcellular fraction can be explained by the contamination of the microsomal vesicles derived from fragmented ER membranes to the Golgi fraction. We conclude that when the transfer vesicles are formed by budding on the transitional elements of ER, P-450 is completely excluded from such regions and is not transported to the Golgi apparatus, and only the membrane proteins destined for the Golgi apparatus, plasma membranes, or lysosomes are selectively collected and transported.     

Assembly of spermatid acrosome depends on microtubule organization during mammalian spermiogenesis

The acrosome is a secretory vesicle attached to the nucleus of the sperm. Our hypothesis is that microtubules participate in the membrane traffic between the Golgi apparatus and acrosome during the first steps of spermatid differentiation. In this work, we show that nocodazole-induced microtubule depolarization triggers the formation of vesicles of the acrosomal membrane, without detaching the acrosome from the nuclear envelope. Nocodazole also induced fragmentation of the Golgi apparatus as determined by antibodies against giantin, golgin-97 and GM130, and electron microscopy. Conversely, neither the acrosome nor the Golgi apparatus underwent fragmentation in elongating spermatids (acrosome- and maturation-phase). The microtubule network of round spermatids of azh/azh mice also became disorganized. Disorganization correlated with fragmentation of the acrosome and the Golgi apparatus, as evaluated by domain-specific markers. Elongating spermatids (acrosome and maturation-phase) of azh/azh mice also had alterations in microtubule organization, acrosome, and Golgi apparatus. Finally, the spermatozoa of azh/azh mice displayed aberrant localization of the acrosomal protein sp56 in both the post-acrosomal and flagellum domains. Our results suggest that microtubules participate in the formation and/or maintenance of the structure of the acrosome and the Golgi apparatus and that the organization of the microtubules in round spermatids is key to sorting acrosomal proteins to the proper organelle.     

Membranes of mammary gland : XV. 5-Thio- -glucose decreases lactose content and inhibits secretory vesicle maturation in lactating rat mammary gland

Short-term administration of the glucose analog 5-thio- -glucose to primiparous lactating rats reduced mammary tissue lactose concentrations to half of control levels. Treatment with colchicine alone caused slight reductions in mammary tissue lactose content. These treatments did not alter the morphology or degree of development of rough endoplasmic reticulum or Golgi apparatus, but did cause alterations in secretory vesicles. In mammary tissue from untreated lactating animals, large, swollen secretory vesicles were abundant in apical regions of epithelial cells. After thioglucose administration secretory vesicles in the apical cytoplasm were smaller and were more densely packed with contents. While administration of colchicine alone caused accumulation of large numbers of nearly fully swollen vesicles, treatment with both colchicine and thioglucose induced accumulation of smaller, less fully developed secretory vesicles which contained morphologically recognizable casein micelles. Mammary tissue from late gestation rats was low in lactose; vesicles in this tissue resembled secretory vesicles in tissue from rats treated with thioglucose in that they were small and densely packed. These observations suggest that lactose, an osmoregulator in mammary gland, is transferred from Golgi apparatus to the apical cell surface within secretory vesicles. Lactose appears to be important for secretory vesicle maturation in mammary epithelial cells.     

Active ADP-ribosylation factor-1 (ARF1) is required for mitotic Golgi fragmentation

In mammalian cells the Golgi apparatus undergoes an extensive disassembly process at the onset of mitosis that is believed to facilitate equal partitioning of this organelle into the two daughter cells. However, the underlying mechanisms for this fragmentation process are so far unclear. Here we have investigated the role of the ADP-ribosylation factor-1 (ARF1) in this process to determine whether Golgi fragmentation in mitosis is mediated by vesicle budding. ARF1 is a small GTPase that is required for COPI vesicle formation from the Golgi membranes. Treatment of Golgi membranes with mitotic cytosol or with purified coatomer together with wild type ARF1 or its constitutive active form, but not the inactive mutant, converted the Golgi membranes into COPI vesicles. ARF1-depleted mitotic cytosol failed to fragment Golgi membranes. ARF1 is associated with Golgi vesicles generated in vitro and with vesicles in mitotic cells. In addition, microinjection of constitutive active ARF1 did not affect mitotic Golgi fragmentation or cell progression through mitosis. Our results show that ARF1 is active during mitosis and that this activity is required for mitotic Golgi fragmentation.     

Improved preservation of the form and contents of wall vesicles and the golgi apparatus in freeze substituted hyphae ofSaprolegnia

Summary Secretory vesicles involved in cell wall synthesis (wall vesicles) and the Golgi apparatus have been compared in conventionally fixed and freeze substituted hyphae of the oomycete fungusSaprolegnia ferax. Wall vesicles freeze substituted in various fluids range from spherical to tubular and contain an intensely staining, phosphorous rich matrix. In contrast diverse conventional fixations cause artefactual constrictions in most tubular vesicles and loss of their intensely staining contents. These data are interpreted to show the existence of an intravesicular skeletal system, with cellular regulation, to determine vesicle morphology and intravesicular synthesis of a hypothetical phosphorylated glycolipid cell wall precursor. Whilst freeze substitution gives superior preservation of wall vesicle morphology, it does not demonstrate any preferential association between wall vesicles and microtubules thus suggesting that microtubules are only indirectly involved in wall vesicle transport. Freeze substitution is superior to conventional fixation for analysis of the Golgi apparatus because it uniquely reveals both differentiation of a specific single cisterna in each Golgi body and greater differences in membrane thicknesses throughout the endomembrane system.     

Caveolin moves from caveolae to the Golgi apparatus in response to cholesterol oxidation

Caveolae are a membrane specialization used to internalize molecules by potocytosis. Caveolin, an integral membrane protein, is associated with the striated coat present on the cytoplasmic surface of the caveolae membrane. We now report that oxidation of caveolar cholesterol with cholesterol oxidase rapidly displaces the caveolin from the plasma membrane to intracellular vesicles that colocalize with Golgi apparatus markers. After the enzyme is removed from the medium, caveolin returns to caveolae. When untreated cells are gently homogenized, caveolin on the plasma membrane is accessible to both anti-caveolin IgG and trypsin. After cholesterol oxidase treatment, however, Golgi-associated caveolin is inaccessible to both of these molecules. Brefeldin A, which inhibits ER to Golgi trafficking, blocks the appearance of caveolin in the Golgi apparatus but does not prevent caveolin from leaving the plasma membrane. Indirect immunogold localization experiments show that in the presence of cholesterol oxidase caveolin leaves the plasma membrane and becomes associated with endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi compartments. Surprisingly, the loss of caveolin from the plasma membrane does not affect the number or morphology of the caveolae.     

Differentiation and continuity of the Golgi apparatus during carposporogenesis inPolysiphonia (Rhodophyta)

Summary Changes in the morphology of the Golgi apparatus during carposporogenesis occur gradually and are observed first in proximal cisternae. As successive cisternae mature, the appearance of the Golgi apparatus is gradually altered. Morphological changes are observed in the contents of differentiating cisternae and detached vesicles, and in the mode of vesicle detachment. The reprogramming of the Golgi apparatus between consecutive developmental stages does not appear to occur abruptly. Cisternae transitional between successive stages are observed to have features characteristic of both. Several unusual morphological features of the Golgi apparatus and detached vesicles are discussed.     

Characterization of a secretory vesicle-rich fraction from lactating bovine mammary gland.

Fractions enriched in secretory vesicles were obtained from lactating bovine mammary tissue by a straightforward procedure involving gentle homogenization and centrifugation in isotonic milk salt solution containing Ficoll. Secretory vesicle-rich fractions could also be obtained from lactating rat mammary gland by this procedure. With rats, yields of vesicles were substantially increased by administration of colchicine or thioglucose to animals several hours before sacrifice. Isolated fractions were enriched in lactose and consisted predominantly of 0.2–1.2 μm diameter vesicles, many of which contained casein micelles. Enzymatic, compositional and morphological examination revealed vesicle preparations to be largely free of contamination by rough endoplasmic reticulum, mitochondria, nuclei, peroxisomes and lysosomes. Specific activity of several marker enzymes of the secretory vesicle fraction were similar to, or intermediate between, Golgi apparatus and milk lipid globule membranes. Amounts of cholesterol and gangliosides in vesicle fractions approached levels found in plasma membranes. In distribution of major phospholipids, secretory vesicles were intermediate between Golgi apparatus and milk lipid globule membranes. The pattern of polypeptides of secretory vesicle membrane was qualitatively similar to that of Golgi apparatus membranes. While there were similarities between these polypeptide patterns and that of lipid globule membranes, the latter contained relatively more of certain polypeptides, particularly the internal coat-associated polypeptides of the globule membrane. These observations are discussed in relation to the endomembrane hypothesis and the origin of the membrane of milk lipid globules.     

Trafficking of lipids from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi apparatus in a cell-free system from rat liver

Trafficking and sorting of lipids during transport from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi apparatus was studied using a cell-free system from rat liver. Transitional elements of the endoplasmic reticulum were prepared from liver slices prelabeled with [14C]- or [3H]acetate as the donor fraction. Non-radioactive Golgi apparatus were immobilized on nitrocellulose as the acceptor. When reconstituted, the radiolabeled donor retained a capacity to transfer labeled lipids to the non-radioactive Golgi apparatus acceptor. Transfer exhibited two kinetically different components. One was stimulated by ATP, facilitated by cytosol and inhibited by guanosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) and N-ethylmaleimide. In parallel with protein transport, the ATP-dependent lipid transfer occurred with a temperature transition at about 20 degrees C. The other was not stimulated by ATP, did not require cytosol, was acceptor unspecific, was unaffected by inhibitors and, while temperature dependent, did not exhibit a sharp temperature transition. The ATP-independent transfer was non-vesicular. In contrast, the ATP-dependent transfer was vesicular. Transition vesicles isolated by preparative free-flow electrophoresis, when used as the donor fraction, transferred lipids to Golgi apparatus acceptor with a 5-6-fold greater efficiency than that exhibited by the unfractionated transitional endoplasmic reticulum. Formation of transition vesicles was ATP-dependent. Transferred lipids were chiefly phosphatidylcholine and cholesterol. Membrane triglycerides, major constituents of the transitional endoplasmic reticulum membranes, were both depleted in the transition vesicle-enriched fractions and not transferred to Golgi apparatus suggestive of lipid sorting prior to or during transition vesicle formation. The characteristics of the ATP plus cytosol-dependent transfer were similar to those for protein transfer mediated by transition vesicles. Thus, the 50-70-nm vesicles derived from transitional endoplasmic reticulum appear to function in the trafficking of both newly synthesized proteins and lipids from the endoplasmic reticulum to the Golgi apparatus.     

The Golgi apparatus: going round in circles?

Recent studies have questioned the idea that the Golgi complex is a stable organelle with a unique identity through which secretory cargo is transported by vesicles. Instead, it is proposed that Golgi apparatus proteins continuously recycle via the endoplasmic reticulum by vesicle transport, whereas cargo molecules remain in maturing cisternal structures. Rather than forming a rigid matrix, structural Golgi proteins might be highly dynamic and recycle via the cytoplasm. I will discuss the evidence for these claims and consider whether or not they really disprove older ideas on how the Golgi apparatus is structured and performs its function.