Autophagy is not universally required for phosphatidyl-serine exposure and apoptotic cell engulfment during neural development

Apoptosis and autophagy are physiological processes implicated in the maintenance of cell and tissue homeostasis. We took advantage of the existence of multiple phases of

developmental cell death in the embryonic chick retina and of the availability of shortterm organotypic retinal cultures to approach the possible relationship between

apoptosis and autophagy during neural development. We examined retinas at embryonic day 5, an early stage at which cell death is related to eye morphogenesis and to retinal

ganglion cell generation, as well as at embryonic day 9, when cell death is associated with neurotrophic support of the retinal ganglion cells. Exposure to 3-methyl-adenine, a

classical inhibitor of autophagy, elicited a selective accumulation of apoptotic bodies in the dorsotemporal area of embryonic day 5 retinas where neurogenesis is taking place.

This accumulation was correlated with a blockage of phosphatidyl-serine presentation and, consequently, with a lack of engulfment of the dying cells by their neighbors. In

striking contrast, none of these phenomena were observed in association with cell death in the optic nerve and optic fissure at embryonic day 5, or in embryonic day 9 retinas.

Our data suggest that autophagy is essential for phosphatidyl-serine presentation by apoptotic cells during the phase of cell death associated to neurogenesis, but this is not a

universal requirement for all phases of cell death occurring during retinal development.     

Immunocytochemical localisation of neuronal nitric oxide synthase in developing and transplanted rabbit retinas

 Nitric oxide (NO) acts as a modulator of neuronal transmission in mature neuronal systems, including the retina. Recently, NO has also been suggested to have a trophic function during development. We examined immunocytochemically the distribution of NO-producing cells in developing and transplanted rabbit retinas. An antibody detecting the neuronal isoform of its biosynthetic enzyme, nitric oxide synthase (NOS), was used on normal developing retinas [starting at embryonic day (E) 15] and on rabbit retinal transplants after various survival times (1–139 days after surgery). Weakly stained cell bodies were first observed in the proximal margin of the neuroblastic layer at E 29. Stained processes projecting towards a developing inner plexiform layer were also visible at this time point. Immunoreactive cells were located at later stages in the innermost part of the inner nuclear layer and in the ganglion cell layer, and are likely to correspond mainly to amacrine cells. NOS-labelled cells were also found in retinal transplants. The first NOS-labelled cells appeared, as in normal developing retinas, in ages corresponding to E 29 and were still detected in transplants corresponding to postnatal day 123. NOS-labelled cells were seen in areas between rosettes, where amacrine cells are located. NOS-labelled processes were at times seen to project for long distances, forming very distinct plexuses. NOS-containing amacrine cells thus appear both in the transplants and in developing retinas in the embryonic stages, long before synaptic function involving these cells can be expected, suggesting a role for NO not only in neuromodulation but also in retinal development. Accepted: 22 January 1997     

A comprehensive characterization of membrane vesicles released by autophagic human endothelial cells

The stress status of the apoptotic cell can promote phenotypic changes that have important consequences on the immunogenicity of the dying cell. Autophagy is one of the biological processes activated in response to a stressful condition. It is an important mediator of intercellular communications, both by regulating the unconventional secretion of molecules, including interleukin 1β, and by regulating the extracellular release of ATP from early stage apoptotic cells. Additionally, autophagic components can be released in a caspase‐dependent manner by serum‐starved human endothelial cells that have engaged apoptotic and autophagic processes. The nature and the components of the extracellular vesicles released by dying autophagic cells are not known. In this study, we have identified extracellular membrane vesicles that are released by human endothelial cells undergoing apoptosis and autophagy, and characterized their biochemical, ultrastructural, morphological properties as well as their proteome. These extracellular vesicles differ from classical apoptotic bodies because they do not contain nucleus components and are released independently of Rho‐associated, coiled‐coil containing protein kinase 1 activation. Instead, they are enriched with autophagosomes and mitochondria and convey various danger signals, including ATP, suggesting that they could be involved in the modulation of innate immunity.     

An imbalance in autophagy contributes to retinal damage in a rat model of oxygen-induced retinopathy

In retinopathy of prematurity (ROP), the abnormal retinal neovascularization is often accompanied by retinal neuronal dysfunction. Here, a rat model of oxygen-induced retinopathy (OIR), which mimics the ROP disease, was used to investigate changes in the expression of key mediators of autophagy and markers of cell death in the rat retina. In addition, rats were treated from birth to postnatal day 14 and 18 with 3-methyladenine (3-MA), an inhibitor of autophagy. Immunoblot and immunofluorescence analysis demonstrated that autophagic mechanisms are dysregulated in the retina of OIR rats and indicated a possible correlation between autophagy and necroptosis, but not apoptosis. We found that 3-MA acts predominantly by reducing autophagic and necroptotic markers in the OIR retinas, having no effects on apoptotic markers. However, 3-MA does not ameliorate retinal function, which results compromised in this model. Taken together, these results revealed the crucial role of autophagy in retinal cells of OIR rats. Thus, inhibiting autophagy may be viewed as a putative strategy to counteract ROP.     

Novel estradiol analogue induces apoptosis and autophagy in esophageal carcinoma cells

Cancer is the second leading cause of death in South Africa. The critical role that microtubules play in cell division makes them an ideal target for the development of chemotherapeutic drugs that prevent the hyperproliferation of cancer cells. The new in silico-designed estradiol analogue 2-ethyl-3-O-sulfamoylestra-1,3,5(10)16-tetraene (ESE-16) was investigated in terms of its in vitro antiproliferative effects on the esophageal carcinoma SNO cell line at a concentration of 0.18 μM and an exposure time of 24 h. Polarization-optical differential interference contrast and triple fluorescent staining (propidium iodide, Hoechst 33342 and acridine orange) revealed a decrease in cell density, metaphase arrest, and the occurrence of apoptotic bodies in the ESE-16-treated cells when compared to relevant controls. Treated cells also showed an increase in the presence of acidic vacuoles and lysosomes, suggesting the occurrence of autophagic processes. Cell death via autophagy was confirmed using the Cyto-ID autophagy detection kit and the aggresome detection assay. Results showed an increase in autophagic vacuole and aggresome formation in ESE-16 treated cells, confirming the induction of cell death via autophagy. Cell cycle progression demonstrated an increase in the sub-G1 fraction (indicative of the presence of apoptosis). In addition, a reduction in mitochondrial membrane potential was also observed, which suggests the involvement of apoptotic cell death induced by ESE-16 via the intrinsic apoptotic pathway. In this study, it was demonstrated that ESE-16 induces cell death via both autophagy and apoptosis in esophageal carcinoma cells. This study paves the way for future investigation into the role of ESE-16 in ex vivo and in vivo studies as a possible anticancer agent.     

Hydra, a versatile model to study the homeostatic and developmental functions of cell death

In the freshwater cnidarian polyp Hydra, cell death takes place in multiple contexts. Indeed apoptosis occurs during oogenesis and spermatogenesis, during starvation, and in early head regenerating tips, promoting local compensatory proliferation at the boundary between heterografts. Apoptosis can also be induced upon exposure to pro-apoptotic agents (colchicine, wortmannin), upon heat-shock in the thermosensitive sf-1 mutant, and upon wounding. In all these contexts, the cells that undergo cell death belong predominantly to the interstitial cell lineage, whereas the epithelial cells, which are rather resistant to pro-apoptotic signals, engulf the apoptotic bodies. Beside this clear difference between the interstitial and the epithelial cell lineages, the different interstitial cell derivatives also show noticeable variations in their respective apoptotic sensitivity, with the precursor cells appearing as the most sensitive to pro-apoptotic signals. The apoptotic machinery has been well conserved across evolution. However, its specific role and regulation in each context are not known yet. Tools that help characterize apoptotic activity in Hydra have recently been developed. Among them, the aposensor Apoliner initially designed in Drosophila reliably measures wortmannin-induced apoptotic activity in a biochemical assay. Also, flow cytometry and TUNEL analyses help identify distinctive features between wortmannin-induced and heat-shock induced apoptosis in the sf-1 strain. Thanks to the live imaging tools already available, Hydra now offers a model system with which the functions of the apoptotic machinery to maintain long-term homeostasis, stem cell renewal, germ cell production, active developmental processes and non-self response can be deciphered.     

Vacuolar H+ -ATPase c protects glial cell death induced by sodium nitroprusside under glutathione-depleted condition

We examined the role of the c subunit (ATP6L) of vacuolar H(+) -ATPase and its molecular mechanisms in glial cell death induced by sodium nitroprusside (SNP). ATP6L siRNA-transfected cells treated with SNP showed a significant increase in cytotoxicity under glutathione (GSH)-depleted conditions after pretreatment with buthionine sulfoximine, but reduction of ATP6L did not affect the regulation of lysosomal pH in analyses with lysosomal pH-dependent fluorescence probes. Photodegraded SNP and ferrous sulfate induced cytotoxicity with the same pattern as that of SNP, but SNAP and potassium cyanide did not show activity. Pretreatment of the transfected cells with deferoxamine (DFO) reduced ROS production and significantly inhibited the cytotoxicity, which indicates that primarily iron rather than nitric oxide or cyanide from SNP contributes to cell death. Involvement of apoptotic processes in the cells was not shown. Pretreatment with JNK or p38 chemical inhibitor significantly inhibited the cytotoxicity, and we also confirmed that the MAPKs were activated in the cells by immunoblot analysis. Significant increase of LC3-II conversion was observed in the cells, and the conversions were inhibited by cotransfection of the MAPK siRNAs and pretreatment with DFO. Introduction of Atg5 siRNA inhibited the cytotoxicity and inhibited the activation of MAPKs and the conversion of LC3. We finally confirmed autophagic cell death and involvement of MAPKs by observation of autophagic vacuoles via electron microscopy. These data suggest that ATP6L has a protective role against SNP-induced autophagic cell death via inhibition of JNK and p38 in GSH-depleted glial cells.     

Caspase activation regulates the extracellular export of autophagic vacuoles

The endothelium plays a central role in the regulation of vascular wall cellularity and tone by secreting an array of mediators of importance in intercellular communication. Nutrient deprivation of human endothelial cells (EC) evokes unconventional forms of secretion leading to the release of nanovesicles distinct from apoptotic bodies and bearing markers of multivesicular bodies (MVB). Nutrient deficiency is also a potent inducer of autophagy and vesicular transport pathways can be assisted by autophagy. Nutrient deficiency induced a significant and rapid increase in autophagic features, as imaged by electron microscopy and immunoblotting analysis of LC3-II/LC3-I ratios. Increased autophagic flux was confirmed by exposing serum-starved cells to bafilomycin A 1. Induction of autophagy was followed by indices of an apoptotic response, as assessed by microscopy and poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase cleavage in absence of cell membrane permeabilization indicative of necrosis. Pan-caspase inhibition with ZVAD-FMK did not prevent the development of autophagy but negatively impacted autophagic vacuole (AV) maturation. Adopting a multidimensional proteomics approach with validation by immunoblotting, we determined that nutrient-deprived EC released AV components (LC3I, LC3-II, ATG16L1 and LAMP2) whereas pan-caspase inhibition with ZVAD-FMK blocked AV release. Similarly, nutrient deprivation in aortic murine EC isolated from CASP3/caspase 3-deficient mice induced an autophagic response in absence of apoptosis and failed to prompt LC3 release. Collectively, the present results demonstrate the release of autophagic components by nutrient-deprived apoptotic human cells in absence of cell membrane permeabilization. These results also identify caspase-3 as a novel regulator of AV release.     

Creatine transporter localization in developing and adult retina: importance of creatine to retinal function

Creatine and phosphocreatine are required to maintain ATP needed for normal retinal function and development. The aim of the present study was to determine the distribution of the creatine transporter (CRT) to gain insight to how creatine is transported into the retina. An affinity-purified antibody raised against the CRT was applied to adult vertebrate retinas and to mouse retina during development. Confocal microscopy was used to identify the localization pattern as well as co-localization patterns with a range of retinal neurochemical markers. Strong labeling of the CRT was seen in the photoreceptor inner segments in all species studied and labeling of a variety of inner neuronal cells (amacrine, bipolar, and ganglion cells), the retinal nerve fibers and sites of creatine transport into the retina (retinal pigment epithelium, inner retinal blood vessels, and perivascular astrocytes). The CRT was not expressed in Müller cells of any of the species studied. The lack of labeling of Müller cells suggests that neurons are independent of this glial cell in accumulating creatine. During mouse retinal development, expression of the CRT progressively increased throughout the retina until approximately postnatal day 10, with a subsequent decrease. Comparison of the distribution patterns of the CRT in vascular and avascular vertebrate retinas and studies of the mouse retina during development indicate that creatine and phosphocreatine are important for ATP homeostasis. photoreceptor; development; glutamine synthetase; neurochemistry     

Caspase activation regulates the extracellular export of autophagic vacuoles

The endothelium plays a central role in the regulation of vascular wall cellularity and tone by secreting an array of mediators of importance in intercellular communication. Nutrient deprivation of human endothelial cells (EC) evokes unconventional forms of secretion leading to the release of nanovesicles distinct from apoptotic bodies and bearing markers of multivesicular bodies (MVB). Nutrient deficiency is also a potent inducer of autophagy and vesicular transport pathways can be assisted by autophagy. Nutrient deficiency induced a significant and rapid increase in autophagic features, as imaged by electron microscopy and immunoblotting analysis of LC3-II/LC3-I ratios. Increased autophagic flux was confirmed by exposing serum-starved cells to bafilomycin A₁. Induction of autophagy was followed by indices of an apoptotic response, as assessed by microscopy and poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase cleavage in absence of cell membrane permeabilization indicative of necrosis. Pan-caspase inhibition with ZVAD-FMK did not prevent the development of autophagy but negatively impacted autophagic vacuole (AV) maturation. Adopting a multidimensional proteomics approach with validation by immunoblotting, we determined that nutrient-deprived EC released AV components (LC3I, LC3-II, ATG16L1 and LAMP2) whereas pan-caspase inhibition with ZVAD-FMK blocked AV release. Similarly, nutrient deprivation in aortic murine EC isolated from CASP3/caspase 3-deficient mice induced an autophagic response in absence of apoptosis and failed to prompt LC3 release. Collectively, the present results demonstrate the release of autophagic components by nutrient-deprived apoptotic human cells in absence of cell membrane permeabilization. These results also identify caspase-3 as a novel regulator of AV release.     

Rose Bengal Acetate PhotoDynamic Therapy (RBAc-PDT) Induces Exposure and Release of Damage-Associated Molecular Patterns (DAMPs) in Human HeLa Cells

The new concept of Immunogenic Cell Death (ICD), associated with Damage Associated Molecular Patterns (DAMPs) exposure and/or release, is recently becoming very appealing in cancer treatment. In this context, PhotoDynamic Therapy (PDT) can give rise to ICD and to immune response upon dead cells removal. The list of PhotoSensitizers (PSs) able to induce ICD is still short and includes Photofrin, Hypericin, Foscan and 5-ALA. The goal of the present work was to investigate if Rose Bengal Acetate (RBAc), a powerful PS able to trigger apoptosis and autophagy, enables photosensitized HeLa cells to expose and/or release pivotal DAMPs, i.e. ATP, HSP70, HSP90, HMGB1, and calreticulin (CRT), that characterize ICD. We found that apoptotic HeLa cells after RBAc-PDT exposed and released, early after the treatment, high amount of ATP, HSP70, HSP90 and CRT; the latter was distributed on the cell surface as uneven patches and co-exposed with ERp57. Conversely, autophagic HeLa cells after RBAc-PDT exposed and released HSP70, HSP90 but not CRT and ATP. Exposure and release of HSP70 and HSP90 were always higher on apoptotic than on autophagic cells. HMGB1 was released concomitantly to secondary necrosis (24 h after RBAc-PDT). Phagocytosis assay suggests that CRT is involved in removal of RBAc-PDT generated apoptotic HeLa cells. Altogether, our data suggest that RBAc has all the prerequisites (i.e. exposure and/or release of ATP, CRT, HSP70 and HSP90), that must be verified in future vaccination experiments, to be considered a good PS candidate to ignite ICD. We also showed tha CRT is involved in the clearance of RBAc photokilled HeLa cells. Interestingly, RBAc-PDT is the first cancer PDT protocol able to induce the translocation of HSP90 and plasma membrane co-exposure of CRT with ERp57.     

Autophagy and apoptosis are redundantly required for C. elegans embryogenesis

Apoptosis, the main form of regulated (or programmed) cell death, allows the organism to tightly control cell numbers and tissue size, and to protect itself from potentially damaging cells. This type of cellular self-killing has long been assumed to be essential for early development. In the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, however, the core apoptotic cell death pathway appears to be dispensable for embryogenesis when most developmental cell deaths take place: mutant nematodes defective for apoptosis develop into adulthood, with superficially normal morphology and behavior. Accumulating evidence indicates a similar situation in mammalian systems as well. For example, apoptosis-deficient mice can grow as healthy, fertile adults. These observations raise the possibility that alternative cell death mechanisms may compensate for the lack of apoptotic machinery in developing embryos. Interestingly, C. elegans embryogenesis can also occur without autophagy, an alternative form of cellular self-destruction (also called autophagic cell death). In an upcoming paper we report that simultaneous inactivation of the autophagic and apoptotic gene cascades in C. elegans arrests development at early stages, and the affected embryos exhibit severe morphological defects. Double-mutant nematode embryos deficient in both autophagy and apoptosis are unable to undergo body elongation or to arrange several tissues correctly. This novel function of autophagy genes in morphogenesis indicates a more fundamental role for cellular self-digestion in tissue patterning than previously thought.     

Localization of calcineurin in the mature and developing retina.

We studied the localization of calcineurin by immunoblotting analysis and immunohistochemistry as a first step in clarifying the role of calcineurin in the retina. Rat, bovine, and human retinal tissues were examined with subtype-nonspecific and subtype-specific antibodies for the A alpha and A beta isoforms of its catalytic subunit. In mature retinas of the three species, calcineurin was localized mainly in the cell bodies of ganglion cells and the cells in the inner nuclear layer, in which amacrine cells were distinctively positive. The calcineurin A alpha and A beta isoforms were differentially localized in the nucleus and the cytoplasm of the ganglion cell, respectively. Calcineurin was also present in developing rat retinas, in which the ganglion cells were consistently positive for it. The presence of calcineurin across mammalian species and regardless of age shown in the present study may reflect its importance in visual function and retinal development, although its function in the retina has not yet been clarified. (J Histochem Cytochem 49:187-195, 2001)     

Epidermal growth factor-like domain repeat of stabilin-2 recognizes phosphatidylserine during cell corpse clearance

Exposure of phosphatidylserine (PS) on the cell surface occurs early during apoptosis and serves as a recognition signal for phagocytes. Clearance of apoptotic cells by a membrane PS receptor is one of the critical anti-inflammatory functions of macrophages. However, the PS binding receptors and their recognition mechanisms have not been fully investigated. Recently, we reported that stabilin-2 is a PS receptor that mediates the clearance of apoptotic cells, thus releasing the anti-inflammatory cytokine, transforming growth factor β. In this study, we showed that epidermal growth factor (EGF)-like domain repeats (EGFrp) in stabilin-2 can directly and specifically recognize PS. The EGFrps also competitively impaired apoptotic cell uptake by macrophages in in vivo models. We also showed that calcium ions are required for stabilin-2 to mediate phagocytosis via EGFrp. Interestingly, at least four tandem repeats of EGF-like domains were required to recognize PS, and the second atypical EGF-like domain in EGFrp was critical for calcium-dependent PS recognition. Considering that PS itself is an important target molecule for both apoptotic cells and nonapoptotic cells during various cellular processes, our results should help elucidate the molecular mechanism by which apoptotic cell clearance in the human body occurs and also have implications for targeting PS externalization of nonapoptotic cells.     

Autophagy-induced regression of hyaloid vessels in early ocular development

The hyaloid vessel is a transient intraocular circulatory system that undergoes a complete regression as the retina becomes matured with retinal vascularization. If the complete involution of the hyaloid vessels failes, the pathological persistence of these vessels results in persistent hyperplastic primary vitreous (PHPV) associated with severe ocular pathologies. Unfortunately despite its clinical significance, cellular and molecular processes involved in hyaloid regression remain to be elucidated. Herein, we for the first time demonstrated that autophagy could contribute to the regression of hyaloid vessels in early developing retina. In developing retina, hyaloid vessel regression coincided with retinal vascular development; this occurred simultaneous with apoptotic and autophagic processes. Moreover, in vascular endothelial cells under hypoxic conditions, LC3-II conversion was detected along with caspase-3 activation. The autophagy inducer rapamycin induced autophagy-mediated cell death of vascular endothelial cells in a dose-dependent manner. Moreover, rapamycin significantly enhanced the involution of hyaloid vessels in the early developing eye. Therefore, our results suggest that the autophagy pathway would be involved in hyaloid regression that occurs during early ocular development. Furthermore, activation of the autophagy pathway could be considered for a therapeutic approach to PHPV.     

Autophagy: for better or for worse

Autophagy is a lysosomal degradation pathway that degrades damaged or superfluous cell components into basic biomolecules, which are then recycled back into the cytosol. In this respect, autophagy drives a flow of biomolecules in a continuous degradation-regeneration cycle. Autophagy is generally considered a pro-survival mechanism protecting cells under stress or poor nutrient conditions. Current research clearly shows that autophagy fulfills numerous functions in vital biological processes. It is implicated in development, differentiation, innate and adaptive immunity, ageing and cell death. In addition, accumulating evidence demonstrates interesting links between autophagy and several human diseases and tumor development. Therefore, autophagy seems to be an important player in the life and death of cells and organisms. Despite the mounting knowledge about autophagy, the mechanisms through which the autophagic machinery regulates these diverse processes are not entirely understood. In this review, we give a comprehensive overview of the autophagic signaling pathway, its role in general cellular processes and its connection to cell death. In addition, we present a brief overview of the possible contribution of defective autophagic signaling to disease.     

Insulin and IGFs induce apoptosis in chick embryo retinas deprived of L-glutamine

In chick embryo retinas, cultured in serum-free medium lacking L-glutamine, IGF-I, IGF-II and insulin induced apoptotic DNA fragmentation and cell death, IGF-I being the most efficacious compound. The apoptotic effect, which was particularly evident in retinas removed from 7-day-old chick embryos, declined with the age of the embryos and disappeared after day 11. Apoptosis appeared after a time lag of 8 h and then increased with time up to 16 h. Cycloheximide, an inhibitor of protein synthesis, was capable of entirely abolishing apoptotic cell death. The effect induced by IGFs or insulin was suppressed by the addition of glutamine. Cytokine-mediated apoptosis was also observed after withdrawal of phosphate. We suggest that IGFs or insulin may produce, in retinas cultured in medium lacking L-glutamine or phosphate, a conflict of signals that could be lethal for retinal cells.     

Proteolysis of Ambra1 during apoptosis has a role in the inhibition of the autophagic pro-survival response

Under stress conditions, pro-survival and pro-death processes are concomitantly activated and the final outcome depends on the complex crosstalk between these pathways. In most cases, autophagy functions as an early-induced cytoprotective response, favoring stress adaptation by removing damaged subcellular constituents. Moreover, several lines of evidence suggest that autophagy inactivation by the apoptotic machinery is a crucial event for cell death execution. Here we show that apoptotic stimuli induce a rapid decrease in the level of the autophagic factor Activating Molecule in Beclin1-Regulated Autophagy (Ambra1). Ambra1 degradation is prevented by concomitant inhibition of caspases and calpains. By both in vitro and in vivo approaches, we demonstrate that caspases are responsible for Ambra1 cleavage at the D482 site, whereas calpains are involved in complete Ambra1 degradation. Finally, we show that Ambra1 levels are critical for the rate of apoptosis induction. RNA interference-mediated Ambra1 downregulation further sensitizes cells to apoptotic stimuli, while Ambra1 overexpression and, more efficiently, a caspase non-cleavable mutant counteract cell death by prolonging autophagy induction. We conclude that Ambra1 is an important target of apoptotic proteases resulting in the dismantling of the autophagic machinery and the accomplishment of the cell death program.