Activation of mRNA translation by phage protein and low temperature: the case of Lactococcus lactis abortive infection system AbiD1

Background  

Abortive infection (Abi) mechanisms comprise numerous strategies developed by bacteria to avoid being killed by bacteriophage (phage). Escherichia coli Abis are considered as mediators of programmed cell death, which is induced by infecting phage. Abis were also proposed to be stress response elements, but no environmental activation signals have yet been identified. Abis are widespread in Lactococcus lactis, but regulation of their expression remains an open question. We previously showed that development of AbiD1 abortive infection against phage bIL66 depends on orf1, which is expressed in mid-infection. However, molecular basis for this activation remains unclear.     

细菌毒素-抗毒素系统在噬菌体流产感染中的作用北大核心CSCD

细菌常受到数量众多的噬菌体感染,宿主细菌在和噬菌体竞赛中进化出多样化的分子策略,流产感染(abortive infection,Abi)是其中之一。毒素-抗毒素系统(toxin-antitoxin system,TA)会在细菌受到压力胁迫时表达并介导细菌的低代谢甚至休眠,还能直接减少子代噬菌体形成。此外,部分毒素序列和结构与Cas蛋白高度同源,噬菌体甚至会编码抗毒素类似物来阻遏对应毒素的活性。这表明流产感染中细菌死亡过程导致的噬菌体感染失败与TA功能高度重合,TA可能是噬菌体侵染宿主的主要阻力和防御力量之一。文中基于TA系统的分类和功能,对参与噬菌体流产感染的TA系统进行了综述,并预测具有流产功能的TA系统和其在抗生素开发和疾病治疗中的应用前景。这有助于认识细菌-噬菌体相互作用,并指导噬菌体治疗和合成生物学。     

A Starter Culture Rotation Strategy Incorporating Paired Restriction/ Modification and Abortive Infection Bacteriophage Defenses in a Single Lactococcus lactis Strain

Three derivatives of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis NCK203, each with a different pair of restriction/ modification (R/M) and abortive infection (Abi) phage defense systems, were constructed and then rotated in repeated cycles of a milk starter culture activity test (SAT). The rotation proceeded successfully through nine successive SATs in the presence of phage and whey containing phage from previous cycles. Lactococcus cultures were challenged with 2 small isometric-headed phages, (phi)31 and ul36, in one rotation series and with a composite of 10 industrial phages in another series. Two native lactococcal R(sup+)/M(sup+) plasmids, pTRK68 and pTRK11, and one recombinant plasmid, pTRK308, harboring a third distinct R/M system were incorporated into three NCK203 derivatives constructed separately for the rotation. The R(sup+)/M(sup+) NCK203 derivatives were transformed with high-copy-number plasmids encoding four Abi genes, abiA, abiC, per31, and per50. Various Abi and R/M combinations constructed in NCK203 were evaluated for their effects on cell growth, level of phage resistance, and retardation of phage development during repeated cycles of the SAT. The three NCK203 derivatives chosen for use in the SAT exhibited additive effects of the R/M and Abi phenotypes against sensitive phages. In such combinations, phage escaping restriction are prevented from completing their infective cycle by an abortive response that kills the host cell. The rotation series successfully controlled modified, recombinant, and mutant phages which were resistant to any one of the individual defense systems by presenting a different set of R/M and Abi defenses in the next test of the rotation.     

Involvement of the Major Capsid Protein and Two Early-Expressed Phage Genes in the Activity of the Lactococcal Abortive Infection Mechanism AbiT

The dairy industry uses the mesophilic, Gram-positive, lactic acid bacterium (LAB) Lactococcus lactis to produce an array of fermented milk products. Milk fermentation processes are susceptible to contamination by virulent phages, but a plethora of phage control strategies are available. One of the most efficient is to use LAB strains carrying phage resistance systems such as abortive infection (Abi) mechanisms. Yet, the mode of action of most Abi systems remains poorly documented. Here, we shed further light on the antiviral activity of the lactococcal AbiT system. Twenty-eight AbiT-resistant phage mutants derived from the wild-type AbiT-sensitive lactococcal phages p2, bIL170, and P008 were isolated and characterized. Comparative genomic analyses identified three different genes that were mutated in these virulent AbiT-insensitive phage derivatives: e14 (bIL170 [e14(bIL170)]), orf41 (P008 [orf41(P008)]), and orf6 (p2 [orf6(p2)] and P008 [orf6(P008)]). The genes e14(bIL170) and orf41(P008) are part of the early-expressed genomic region, but bioinformatic analyses did not identify their putative function. orf6 is found in the phage morphogenesis module. Antibodies were raised against purified recombinant ORF6, and immunoelectron microscopy revealed that it is the major capsid protein (MCP). Coexpression in L. lactis of ORF6(p2) and ORF5(p2), a protease, led to the formation of procapsids. To our knowledge, AbiT is the first Abi system involving distinct phage genes.     

Characterization of AbiR, a novel multicomponent abortive infection mechanism encoded by plasmid pKR223 of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR2

The native lactococcal plasmid pKR223 encodes two distinct phage resistance mechanisms, a restriction and modification (R/M) system designated LlaKR2I and an abortive infection mechanism (Abi) which affects prolate-headed-phage proliferation. The nucleotide sequence of a 16,174-bp segment of pKR223 encompassing both the R/M and Abi determinants has been determined, and sequence analysis has validated the novelty of the Abi system, which has now been designated AbiR. Analysis of deletion and insertion clones demonstrated that AbiR was encoded by two genetic loci, separated by the LlaKR2I R/M genes. Mechanistic studies on the AbiR phenotype indicated that it was heat sensitive and that it impeded phage DNA replication. These data indicated that AbiR is a novel multicomponent, heat-sensitive, "early"-functioning Abi system and is the first lactococcal Abi system described which is encoded by two separated genetic loci.     

Mutagenesis and Functional Characterization of the RNA and Protein Components of the toxIN Abortive Infection and Toxin-Antitoxin Locus of Erwinia

Bacteria are constantly challenged by bacteriophage (phage) infection and have developed multiple adaptive resistance mechanisms. These mechanisms include the abortive infection systems, which promote “altruistic suicide” of an infected cell, protecting the clonal population. A cryptic plasmid of Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica, pECA1039, has been shown to encode an abortive infection system. This highly effective system is active across multiple genera of gram-negative bacteria and against a spectrum of phages. Designated ToxIN, this two-component abortive infection system acts as a toxin-antitoxin module. ToxIN is the first member of a new type III class of protein-RNA toxin-antitoxin modules, of which there are multiple homologues cross-genera. We characterized in more detail the abortive infection phenotype of ToxIN using a suite of Erwinia phages and performed mutagenesis of the ToxI and ToxN components. We determined the minimal ToxI RNA sequence in the native operon that is both necessary and sufficient for abortive infection and to counteract the toxicity of ToxN. Furthermore, site-directed mutagenesis of ToxN revealed key conserved amino acids in this defining member of the new group of toxic proteins. The mechanism of phage activation of the ToxIN system was investigated and was shown to have no effect on the levels of the ToxN protein. Finally, evidence of negative autoregulation of the toxIN operon, a common feature of toxin-antitoxin systems, is presented. This work on the components of the ToxIN system suggests that there is very tight toxin regulation prior to suicide activation by incoming phage.Interactions between bacteria and their natural parasites, bacteriophages (phage), have global-scale effects (42). Although the vast majority of the phage infections, which occur at a rate of 10²⁵ infections per s (26), are overlooked by humans, en masse they affect environmental nutrient cycling (18) and have long been known to be vital to the spread and continued diversity of microbial genes (11). A tiny proportion of this activity can directly affect our everyday activities; the lysis of bacteria following phage infection has potential medical benefits, such as use in phage therapy (30), or can be economically damaging, as it is in cases of bacterial fermentation failure (for instance, in the dairy industry [31]).Gram-positive lactococcal strains used in dairy fermentation have been shown to naturally harbor multiple phage resistance mechanisms (16). These mechanisms can be broadly classed as systems which (i) prevent phage adsorption, (ii) interfere with phage DNA injection, (iii) restrict unmodified DNA, and (iv) induce abortive infection. There is also an increasing amount of research that focuses on new systems that use clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats to mediate phage resistance (3). Clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats and associated proteins, although widespread in archaea and bacteria (39), have not been identified yet in lactococcal strains (23).The abortive infection (Abi) systems induce cell death upon phage infection and often rely on a toxic protein to cause “altruistic cell suicide” in the infected host (16). Although Abi systems have been studied predominantly using lactococcal systems, because of their potential economic importance (8) they have been identified in some gram-negative species, such as Escherichia coli, Vibrio cholerae, Shigella dysenteriae, and Erwinia carotovora (9, 14, 36, 38). The prr and lit systems of E. coli have been studied at the molecular level, and their mode of action and mode of activation by incoming phage have been identified (2, 37, 38). In contrast, lactococcal Abi systems have been characterized mainly by the range of phages actively aborted and the scale of these effects, and the Abi systems have been grouped based on general modes of action (8, 12). More recently, research has begun to identify more specific lactococcal Abi activities at the molecular level (12, 17) and has revealed phage activation of two such Abi systems (6, 21).An Abi system was identified on plasmid pECA1039, which was isolated from a strain of the phytopathogen E. carotovora subsp. atroseptica (14). Designated ToxIN, this two-component Abi system operates as a novel protein-RNA toxin-antitoxin (TA) system to abort phage infection in multiple gram-negative bacteria. The toxic activity of the ToxN protein was inhibited by ToxI RNA, which consists of 5.5 direct repeats of 36 nucleotides. It is now recognized that TA loci, which were originally characterized as “plasmid addiction” modules (43), are widely distributed in the chromosomes of archaea and bacteria (19) and in phage genomes, such as that of the extrachromosomal prophage P1 (27). As a result, the precise biological role of TA systems is under debate (29). It is clear, however, that they can be effective phage resistance systems, as is the case for toxIN in E. carotovora subsp. atroseptica (14) and hok/sok and mazEF in E. coli (22, 33). Previously characterized TA systems operate with both components interacting as either RNAs (e.g., hok/sok) (type I) or proteins (e.g., MazE and MazF) (type II). In this study, a mutagenesis approach was used to further characterize the ToxI and ToxN components of the new (type III) protein-RNA TA Abi system. The regulation of the operon and the mode of phage activation were also examined.     

Characterization of AbiR, a Novel Multicomponent Abortive Infection Mechanism Encoded by Plasmid pKR223 of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR2

The native lactococcal plasmid pKR223 encodes two distinct phage resistance mechanisms, a restriction and modification (R/M) system designated LlaKR2I and an abortive infection mechanism (Abi) which affects prolate-headed-phage proliferation. The nucleotide sequence of a 16,174-bp segment of pKR223 encompassing both the R/M and Abi determinants has been determined, and sequence analysis has validated the novelty of the Abi system, which has now been designated AbiR. Analysis of deletion and insertion clones demonstrated that AbiR was encoded by two genetic loci, separated by the LlaKR2I R/M genes. Mechanistic studies on the AbiR phenotype indicated that it was heat sensitive and that it impeded phage DNA replication. These data indicated that AbiR is a novel multicomponent, heat-sensitive, “early”-functioning Abi system and is the first lactococcal Abi system described which is encoded by two separated genetic loci.     

Bacteriophage exclusion,a new defense system

The ability to withstand viral predation is critical for survival of most microbes. Accordingly, a plethora of phage resistance systems has been identified in bacterial genomes (Labrie et al, 2010 ), including restriction‐modification systems (R‐M) (Tock & Dryden, 2005 ), abortive infection (Abi) (Chopin et al, 2005 ), Argonaute‐based interference (Swarts et al, 2014 ), as well as clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) and associated protein (Cas) adaptive immune system (CRISPR‐Cas) (Barrangou & Marraffini, 2014 ; Van der Oost et al, 2014 ). Predictably, the dark matter of bacterial genomes contains a wealth of genetic gold. A study published in this issue of The EMBO Journal by Goldfarb et al ( 2015 ) unveils bacteriophage exclusion (BREX) as a novel, widespread bacteriophage resistance system that provides innate immunity against virulent and temperate phage in bacteria.     

Genetic analysis of chromosomal regions of Lactococcus lactis acquired by recombinant lytic phages

Recombinant phages are generated when Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis harboring plasmids encoding the abortive type (Abi) of phage resistance mechanisms is infected with small isometric phages belonging to the P335 species. These phage variants are likely to be an important source of virulent new phages that appear in dairy fermentations. They are distinguished from their progenitors by resistance to Abi defenses and by altered genome organization, including regions of L. lactis chromosomal DNA. The objective of this study was to characterize four recombinant variants that arose from infection of L. lactis NCK203 (Abi(+)) with phage phi31. HindIII restriction maps of the variants (phi31.1, phi31.2, phi31.7, and phi31.8) were generated, and these maps revealed the regions containing recombinant DNA. The recombinant region of phage phi31.1, the variant that occurred most frequently, was sequenced and revealed 7.8 kb of new DNA compared with the parent phage, phi31. This region contained numerous instances of homology with various lactococcal temperate phages, as well as homologues of the lambda recombination protein BET and Escherichia coli Holliday junction resolvase Rus, factors which may contribute to efficient recombination processes. A sequence analysis and phenotypic tests revealed a new origin of replication in the phi31.1 DNA, which replaced the phi31 origin. Three separate HindIII fragments, accounting for most of the recombinant region of phi31.1, were separately cloned into gram-positive suicide vector pTRK333 and transformed into NCK203. Chromosomal insertions of each plasmid prevented the appearance of different combinations of recombinant phages. The chromosomal insertions did not affect an inducible prophage present in NCK203. Our results demonstrated that recombinant phages can acquire DNA cassettes from different regions of the chromosome in order to overcome Abi defenses. Disruption of these regions by insertion can alter the types and diversity of new phages that appear during phage-host interactions.     

Cloning and characterization of the abortive infection genetic determinant abiD isolated from pBF61 of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR5.

A 6.3-kb fragment from pBF61 in Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR5 was cloned and found to confer an abortive phage infection (Abi+) phenotype exhibiting a reduction in efficiency of plating and plaque size for small isometric- and prolate-headed bacteriophages sk1 and c2, respectively, and to produce a 10-fold decrease in c2 phage burst size. Phage adsorption was not significantly reduced. An open reading frame of 1,098 bp was sequenced and designated abiD. Tn5 mutagenesis confirmed that abiD was required for the Abi+ phenotype.     

Localization of Separate Genetic Loci for Reduced Sensitivity towards Small Isometric-Headed Bacteriophage sk1 and Prolate-Headed Bacteriophage c2 on pGBK17 from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR2

The mechanism of reduced sensitivity to the small isometric-headed bacteriophage sk1 encoded on a 19-kilobase (kb) HpaII fragment subcloned from pKR223 of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis KR2 was examined. The reduced sensitivity to phage sk1 was due to a modest restriction/modification (R/M) system that was not active against prolate-headed phage c2. The genetic loci for the R/M system against sk1 and the abortive phage infection (Abi) mechanism effective against phage c2 were then localized by restriction mapping, subcloning, and deletion analysis. The restriction gene was localized to a region of a 2.7-kb EcoRV fragment and included an EcoRI site within that fragment. The modification gene was found to be physically separable from the restriction gene and was present on a 1.75-kb BstEII-XbaI fragment. The genetic locus for the Abi phenotype against phage c2 was localized to a region containing a 1.3-kb EcoRI fragment. Attempts to clone the c2 Abi mechanism independent of the sk1 R/M system were unsuccessful, suggesting that expression of the abi genes required sequences upstream of the modification gene. Some pGBK17 (vector pGB301 plus a 19-kb HpaII insert fragment) transformants exhibited the R/M system against phage sk1 but lost the Abi mechanism against phage c2. These transformants contained a 1.2- to 1.3-kb insertion in the Abi region. The data identified genetic loci on a cloned 19-kb HpaII fragment responsible for restriction activity and for modification activity against a small isometric-headed phage and for Abi activity against prolate-headed phage c2. A putative insertion element was also found to inactivate the abi gene(s).     

Abortive infection mechanisms and prophage sequences significantly influence the genetic makeup of emerging lytic lactococcal phages

In this study, we demonstrated the remarkable genome plasticity of lytic lactococcal phages that allows them to rapidly adapt to the dynamic dairy environment. The lytic double-stranded DNA phage ul36 was used to sequentially infect a wild-type strain of Lactococcus lactis and two isogenic derivatives with genes encoding two phage resistance mechanisms, AbiK and AbiT. Four phage mutants resistant to one or both Abi mechanisms were isolated. Comparative analysis of their complete genomes, as well as morphological observations, revealed that phage ul36 extensively evolved by large-scale homologous and nonhomologous recombination events with the inducible prophage present in the host strain. One phage mutant exchanged as much as 79% of its genome compared to the core genome of ul36. Thus, natural phage defense mechanisms and prophage elements found in bacterial chromosomes contribute significantly to the evolution of the lytic phage population.     

Phage abortive infection mechanism from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis, expression of which is mediated by an Iso-ISS1 element.

A 5-kb DNA fragment conferring a phage abortive infection phenotype (Abi+) has been cloned from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis IL416. The Abi+ determinant was subcloned on a 2-kb fragment which carried an Iso-ISS1 element and an open reading frame of 753 bp designated ORFX. Deletion within ORFX entailed the loss of the Abi+ phenotype, establishing that ORFX is the structural abi-416 gene. The expression of abi-416 was shown to be mediated by the Iso-ISS1 element, which contains a sequence fitting the consensus sequence for gram-positive promoters.     

Phage abortive infection mechanism from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis, expression of which is mediated by an Iso-ISS1 element.

A 5-kb DNA fragment conferring a phage abortive infection phenotype (Abi+) has been cloned from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis IL416. The Abi+ determinant was subcloned on a 2-kb fragment which carried an Iso-ISS1 element and an open reading frame of 753 bp designated ORFX. Deletion within ORFX entailed the loss of the Abi+ phenotype, establishing that ORFX is the structural abi-416 gene. The expression of abi-416 was shown to be mediated by the Iso-ISS1 element, which contains a sequence fitting the consensus sequence for gram-positive promoters.     

Phenotypic and genetic characterization of the bacteriophage abortive infection mechanism AbiK from Lactococcus lactis.

The natural plasmid pSRQ800 isolated from Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis W1 conferred strong phage resistance against small isometric phages of the 936 and P335 species when introduced into phage-sensitive L. lactis strains. It had very limited effect on prolate phages of the c2 species. The phage resistance mechanism encoded on pSRQ800 is a temperature-sensitive abortive infection system (Abi). Plasmid pSRQ800 was mapped, and the Abi genetic determinant was localized on a 4.5-kb EcoRI fragment. Cloning and sequencing of the 4.5-kb fragment allowed the identification of two large open reading frames. Deletion mutants showed that only orf1 was needed to produce the Abi phenotype. orf1 (renamed abiK) coded for a predicted protein of 599 amino acids (AbiK) with an estimated molecular size of 71.4 kDa and a pI of 7.98. DNA and protein sequence alignment programs found no significant homology with databases. However, a database query based on amino acid composition suggested that AbiK might be in the same protein family as AbiA. No phage DNA replication nor phage structural protein production was detected in infected AbiK+ L. lactis cells. This system is believed to act at or prior to phage DNA replication. WHen cloned into a high-copy vector, AbiK efficiency increased 100-fold. AbiK provides another powerful tool that can be useful in controlling phages during lactococcal fermentations.     

The abortive infection functions of CRISPR-Cas and Argonaute

CRISPR-Cas and prokaryotic Argonaute (pAgo) are nucleic acid (NA)-guided defense systems that protect prokaryotes against the invasion of mobile genetic elements. Previous studies established that they are directed by NA fragments (guides) to recognize invading complementary NA (targets), and that they cleave the targets to silence the invaders. Nevertheless, growing evidence indicates that many CRISPR-Cas and pAgo systems exploit the abortive infection (Abi) strategy to confer immunity. The CRISPR-Cas and pAgo Abi systems typically sense invaders using the NA recognition ability and activate various toxic effectors to kill the infected cells to prevent the invaders from spreading. This review summarizes the diverse mechanisms of these CRISPR-Cas and pAgo systems, and highlights their critical roles in the arms race between microbes and invaders.