Global gene expression profiles of Bacillus subtilis grown under anaerobic conditions

Bacillus subtilis can grow under anaerobic conditions, either with nitrate or nitrite as the electron acceptor or by fermentation. A DNA microarray containing 4,020 genes from this organism was constructed to explore anaerobic gene expression patterns on a genomic scale. When mRNA levels of aerobic and anaerobic cultures during exponential growth were compared, several hundred genes were observed to be induced or repressed under anaerobic conditions. These genes are involved in a variety of cell functions, including carbon metabolism, electron transport, iron uptake, antibiotic production, and stress response. Among the highly induced genes are not only those responsible for nitrate respiration and fermentation but also those of unknown function. Certain groups of genes were specifically regulated during anaerobic growth on nitrite, while others were primarily affected during fermentative growth, indicating a complex regulatory circuitry of anaerobic metabolism.     

The anaerobic life of Bacillus subtilis: Cloning of the genes encoding the respiratory nitrate reductase system

Abstract The Gram-positive soil bacterium Bacillus subtilis , generally regarded as an aerobe, grows under strict anaerobic conditions using nitrate as an electron acceptor and should be designated as a facultative anaerobe. Growth experiments demonstrated a lag phase of 24 to 36 hours after the shift from aerobic, to the onset of anaerobic respiratory growth. Anaerobically adapted cells grew without further lag phase after their transfer to fresh anaerobic growth medium. The cells change their morphology from rods to longer filament-like structures when moved from aerobic to anaerobic respiratory growth conditions. Surprisingly, anaerobically grown B. subtilis lost the capacity for sporulation. An investigation of the molecular basis of the switch between aerobic and anaerobic growth was initiated by the cloning of the genes encoding the respiratory nitrate reductase from B. subtilis . Oligonucleotides deduced from conserved amino acid sequence regions of eubacterial respiratory nitrate reductases and related enzymes were used for the isolation of the genes. Four open reading frames with significant homology to the E. coli respiratory nitrate reductase opérons ( narGHIJ, narZYWV ) were isolated and termed narGHJI . A chromosomal knock-out mutation of the B. subtilis nar operon totally abolished nitrate respiration.     

Characterization of anaerobic fermentative growth of Bacillus subtilis: identification of fermentation end products and genes required for growth.

Bacillus subtilis can grow anaerobically by respiration with nitrate as a terminal electron acceptor. In the absence of external electron acceptors, it grows by fermentation. Identification of fermentation products by using in vivo nuclear magnetic resonance scans of whole cultures indicated that B. subtilis grows by mixed acid-butanediol fermentation but that no formate is produced. An ace mutant that lacks pyruvate dehydrogenase (PDH) activity was unable to grow anaerobically and produced hardly any fermentation product. These results suggest that PDH is involved in most or all acetyl coenzyme A production in B. subtilis under anaerobic conditions, unlike Escherichia coli, which uses pyruvate formate lyase. Nitrate respiration was previously shown to require the ResDE two-component signal transduction system and an anaerobic gene regulator, FNR. Also required are respiratory nitrate reductase, encoded by the narGHJI operon, and moaA, involved in biosynthesis of a molybdopterin cofactor of nitrate reductase. The resD and resDE mutations were shown to moderately affect fermentation, but nitrate reductase activity and fnr are dispensable for fermentative growth. A search for genes involved in fermentation indicated that ftsH is required, and is also needed to a lesser extent for nitrate respiration. These results show that nitrate respiration and fermentation of B. subtilis are governed by divergent regulatory pathways.     

Comparative growth analysis of the facultative anaerobes Bacillus subtilis,Bacillus licheniformis,and Escherichia coli

Bacillus subtilis anaerobic respiration and fermentative growth capabilities were compared to two other facultative anaerobes, Bacillus licheniformis and Escherichia coli. In glycerol defined medium, B. subtilis grew with nitrate, but not nitrite or fumarate, while B. licheniformis grew with nitrate or fumarate, but not nitrite. Growth of E. coli occurred in glycerol defined medium with either nitrate, nitrite, or fumarate. In order to grow by fermentation, B. subtilis required both glucose and pyruvate, while B. licheniformis and E. coli were capable of using either glucose or pyruvate.     

Expression and characterization of the Escherichia coli fdo locus and a possible physiological role for aerobic formate dehydrogenase.

In the presence of nitrate, the major anaerobic respiratory pathway includes formate dehydrogenase (FDH-N) and nitrate reductase (NAR-A), which catalyze formate oxidation coupled to nitrate reduction. Two aerobically expressed isoenzymes, FDH-Z and NAR-Z, have been recently characterized. Enzymatic analysis of plasmid subclones carrying min 88 of the Escherichia coli chromosome was consistent with the location of the fdo locus encoding FDH-Z between the fdhD and fdhE genes which are necessary for the formation of both formate dehydrogenases. The fdo locus produced three proteins (107, 34, and 22 kDa) with sizes similar to those of the subunits of the purified FDH-N. In support to their structural role, these polypeptides were recognized by antibodies specific to FDH-N. Expression of a chromosomal fdo-uidA operon fusion was induced threefold by aerobic growth and about twofold by anaerobic growth in the presence of nitrate. However, it was independent of the two global regulatory proteins FNR and ArcA, which control genes for anaerobic and aerobic functions, respectively, and of the nitrate response regulator protein NARL. In contrast, a mutation affecting either the nucleoid-associated H-NS protein or the CRP protein abolished the aerobic expression. A possible role for FDH-Z during the transition from aerobic to anaerobic conditions was examined. Synthesis of FDH-Z was maximal at the end of the aerobic growth and remained stable after a shift to anaerobiosis, whereas FDH-N production developed only under anaerobiosis. Furthermore, in an fnr strain deprived of both FDH-N and NAR-A activities, aerobically expressed FDH-Z and NAR-Z enzymes were shown to reduce nitrate at the expense of formate under anaerobic conditions, suggesting that this pathway would allow the cell to respond quickly to anaerobiosis.     

Genome-wide expression analysis indicates that FNR of Escherichia coli K-12 regulates a large number of genes of unknown function

The major regulator controlling the physiological switch between aerobic and anaerobic growth conditions in Escherichia coli is the DNA binding protein FNR. To identify genes controlled by FNR, we used Affymetrix Antisense GeneChips to compare global gene expression profiles from isogenic MG1655 wild-type and Deltafnr strains grown in glucose minimal media under aerobic or anaerobic conditions. We found that 297 genes contained within 184 operons were regulated by FNR and/or by O2 levels. The expression of many genes known to be involved in anaerobic respiration and fermentation was increased under anaerobic growth conditions, while that of genes involved in aerobic respiration and the tricarboxylic acid cycle were repressed as expected. The expression of nine operons associated with acid resistance was also increased under anaerobic growth conditions, which may reflect the production of acidic fermentation products. Ninety-one genes with no presently defined function were also altered in expression, including seven of the most highly anaerobically induced genes, six of which we found to be directly regulated by FNR. Classification of the 297 genes into eight groups by k-means clustering analysis indicated that genes with common gene expression patterns also had a strong functional relationship, providing clues for studying the function of unknown genes in each group. Six of the eight groups showed regulation by FNR; while some expression groups represent genes that are simply activated or repressed by FNR, others, such as those encoding functions for chemotaxis and motility, showed a more complex pattern of regulation. A computer search for FNR DNA binding sites within predicted promoter regions identified 63 new sites for 54 genes. We suggest that E. coli MG1655 has a larger metabolic potential under anaerobic conditions than has been previously recognized.     

Acid- and base-induced proteins during aerobic and anaerobic growth of Escherichia coli revealed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Proteins induced by acid or base, during long-term aerobic or anaerobic growth in complex medium, were identified in Escherichia coli. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis revealed pH-dependent induction of 18 proteins, nine of which were identified by N-terminal sequencing. At pH 9, tryptophan deaminase (TnaA) was induced to a high level, becoming one of the most abundant proteins observed. TnaA may reverse alkalinization by metabolizing amino acids to produce acidic products. Also induced at high pH, but only in anaerobiosis, was glutamate decarboxylase (GadA). The gad system (GadA/GadBC) neutralizes acidity and enhances survival in extreme acid; its induction during anaerobic growth may help protect alkaline-grown cells from the acidification resulting from anaerobic fermentation. To investigate possible responses to internal acidification, cultures were grown in propionate, a membrane-permeant weak acid which acidifies the cytoplasm. YfiD, a homologue of pyruvate formate lyase, was induced to high levels at pH 4.4 and induced twofold more by propionate at pH 6; both of these conditions cause internal acidification. At neutral or alkaline pH, YfiD was virtually absent. YfiD is therefore a strong candidate for response to internal acidification. Acid or propionate also increased the expression of alkyl hydroperoxide reductase (AhpC) but only during aerobic growth. At neutral or high pH, AhpC showed no significant difference between aerobic and anaerobic growth. The increase of AhpC in acid may help protect the cell from the greater concentrations of oxidizing intermediates at low pH. Isocitrate lyase (AceA) was induced by oxygen across the pH range but showed substantially greater induction in acid or in base than at pH 7. Additional responses observed included the induction of MalE at high pH and induction of several enzymes of sugar metabolism at low pH: the phosphotransferase system components ManX and PtsH and the galactitol fermentation enzyme GatY. Overall, our results indicate complex relationships between pH and oxygen and a novel permeant acid-inducible gene, YfiD.     

Multiple regulatory elements for the glpA operon encoding anaerobic glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and the glpD operon encoding aerobic glycerol-3-phosphate dehydrogenase in Escherichia coli: further characterization of respiratory control.

In Escherichia coli, sn-glycerol-3-phosphate can be oxidized by two different flavo-dehydrogenases, an anaerobic enzyme encoded by the glpACB operon and an aerobic enzyme encoded by the glpD operon. These two operons belong to the glp regulon specifying the utilization of glycerol, sn-glycerol-3-phosphate, and glycerophosphodiesters. In glpR mutant cells grown under conditions of low catabolite repression, the glpA operon is best expressed anaerobically with fumarate as the exogenous electron acceptor, whereas the glpD operon is best expressed aerobically. Increased anaerobic expression of glpA is dependent on the fnr product, a pleiotropic activator of genes involved in anaerobic respiration. In this study we found that the expression of a glpA1(Oxr) (oxygen-resistant) mutant operon, selected for increased aerobic expression, became less dependent on the FNR protein but more dependent on the cyclic AMP-catabolite gene activator protein complex mediating catabolite repression. Despite the increased aerobic expression of glpA1(Oxr), a twofold aerobic repressibility persisted. Moreover, anaerobic repression by nitrate respiration remained normal. Thus, there seems to exist a redox control apart from the FNR-mediated one. We also showed that the anaerobic repression of the glpD operon was fully relieved by mutations in either arcA (encoding a presumptive DNA recognition protein) or arcB (encoding a presumptive redox sensor protein). The arc system is known to mediate pleiotropic control of genes of aerobic function.     

Metabolic profiles and aprE expression in anaerobic cultures of Bacillus subtilis using nitrate as terminal electron acceptor

Cultures using nitrate as the terminal electron acceptor were conducted in Schaeffer's medium to evaluate the growth performance and metabolic profiles of Bacillus subtilis, and its potential to express the aprE (subtilisin) gene under anoxic conditions. Nitrate was converted to ammonia through nitrite reduction; and different product profiles were observed during the growth phase when nitrate was added at various concentrations (4-24 mM) to Schaeffer's medium containing glucose (4 g l(-1)). If nitrate was not limiting, then acetic acid and acetoin were accumulated, suggesting a limitation of reduced cofactors but, if nitrate became limiting, then lactic acid and butanediol were accumulated, suggesting an excess of reduced cofactors. Due to a strong lysis at the onset of the end of the growth phase, sporulation frequency and aprE expression were negligible in anaerobic batch cultures. Fed-batch fermentation allowed the development of a stationary phase through a continuous supply of glucose and nitrate. In this case, sporulation frequency was almost null, but interestingly aprE expression was similar to that found in aerobic cultures.     

Impact of aeration and heme-activated respiration on Lactococcus lactis gene expression: identification of a heme-responsive operon

Lactococcus lactis is a widely used food bacterium mainly characterized for its fermentation metabolism. However, this species undergoes a metabolic shift to respiration when heme is added to an aerobic medium. Respiration results in markedly improved biomass and survival compared to fermentation. Whole-genome microarrays were used to assess changes in L. lactis expression under aerobic and respiratory conditions compared to static growth, i.e., nonaerated. We observed the following. (i) Stress response genes were affected mainly by aerobic fermentation. This result underscores the differences between aerobic fermentation and respiration environments and confirms that respiration growth alleviates oxidative stress. (ii) Functions essential for respiratory metabolism, e.g., genes encoding cytochrome bd oxidase, menaquinone biosynthesis, and heme uptake, are similarly expressed under the three conditions. This indicates that cells are prepared for respiration once O(2) and heme become available. (iii) Expression of only 11 genes distinguishes respiration from both aerobic and static fermentation cultures. Among them, the genes comprising the putative ygfCBA operon are strongly induced by heme regardless of respiration, thus identifying the first heme-responsive operon in lactococci. We give experimental evidence that the ygfCBA genes are involved in heme homeostasis.     

Regulators of aerobic and anaerobic respiration in Bacillus subtilis.

Two Bacillus subtilis genes, designated resD and resE, encode proteins that are similar to those of two-component signal transduction systems and play a regulatory role in respiration. The overlapping resD-resE genes are transcribed during vegetative growth from a very weak promoter directly upstream of resD. They are also part of a larger operon that includes three upstream genes, resABC (formerly orfX14, -15, and -16), the expression of which is strongly induced postexponentially. ResD is required for the expression of the following genes: resA, ctaA (required for heme A synthesis), and the petCBD operon (encoding subunits of the cytochrome bf complex). The resABC genes are essential genes which encode products with similarity to cytochrome c biogenesis proteins. resD null mutations are more deleterious to the cell than those of resE. resD mutant phenotypes, directly related to respiratory function, include streptomycin resistance, lack of production of aa3 or caa3 terminal oxidases, acid accumulation when grown with glucose as a carbon source, and loss of ability to grow anaerobically on a medium containing nitrate. A resD mutation also affected sporulation, carbon source utilization, and Pho regulon regulation. The data presented here support an activation role for ResD, and to a lesser extent ResE, in global regulation of aerobic and anaerobic respiration i B.subtilis.     

Characterization of a novel tetracycline resistance that functions only in aerobically grown Escherichia coli.

A tetracycline resistance (Tcr) gene that was found originally on two Bacteroides plasmids (pBF4 and pCP1) confers tetracycline resistance on Escherichia coli, but only when it is grown aerobically. Using maxicells, we have identified a 44-kilodalton protein which is encoded by the region that carries the Tcr gene and which may be the Tcr gene product. Localization experiments indicate that this 44-kilodalton protein is cytoplasmic. To determine whether the tetracycline resistance gene is expressed under anaerobic conditions, we have constructed a protein fusion between the Tcr gene and lacZ. In strains of E. coli carrying the fusion, beta-galactosidase activity was the same when the cells were grown under anaerobic conditions as when the cells were grown under aerobic conditions. This indicates that the tetracycline resistance gene product is made under anaerobic conditions but does not work. The failure of the Tcr protein to function under anaerobic conditions was not due to a requirement for function of the anaerobic electron transport system, because neither nitrate nor fumarate added to anaerobic media restored tetracycline resistance. Inhibition of the aerobic electron transport system with potassium cyanide did not prevent growth on tetracycline of cells containing the Tcr gene. A heme-deficient mutant, E. coli SHSP19, which carries the Tcr gene, was still resistant to tetracycline even when grown in heme-free medium. These results indicate that functioning of the Tcr gene product is not dependent on the aerobic electron transport system. Thus the requirement for aerobic conditions appears to reflect a requirement for oxygen. Spent medium from an E. coli strain carrying the Tcr gene, which was grown in medium containing tetracycline (50 micrograms/ml), did not inhibit growth of a tetracycline-susceptible strain of E. coli. Thus, the Tcr gene product may be detoxifying tetracycline.