Targeted Genome Editing by Recombinant Adeno-Associated Virus （rAAV） Vectors for Generating Genetically Modified Pigs

Recombinant adeno-associated virus(rAAV) vectors have been extensively used for experimental gene therapy of inherited human diseases.Several advantages,such as simple vector construction,high targeting frequency by homologous recombination,and applicability to many cell types,make rAAV an attractive approach for targeted genome editing.Combined with cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer(SCNT),this technology has recently been successfully adapted to generate gene-targeted pigs as models for cystic fibrosis, hereditary tyrosinemia type 1,and breast cancer.This review summarizes the development of rAAV for targeted genome editing in mammalian cells and provides strategies for enhancing the rAAV-mediated targeting frequency by homologous recombination.We discuss current development and application of the rAAV vectors for targeted genome editing in porcine primary fibroblasts,which are subsequently used as donor cells for SCNT to generate cloned genetically designed pigs and provide positive perspectives for the generation of gene-targeted pigs with rAAV in the future.     

Gene targeting from laboratory to livestock: Current status and emerging concepts

The development of methods for cell-mediated transgenesis, based on somatic cell nuclear transfer, provides a tremendous opportunity to shape the genetic make-up of livestock animals in a much more directed approach than traditional animal breeding and selection schemes. Progress in the site-directed modulation of livestock genomes is currently limited by the low efficiencies of gene targeting imposed by the low frequency of homologous recombination and limited proliferative capacity of primary somatic cells that are used to produce transgenic animals. Here we review the current state of the art in the field, discuss the crucial aspects of the methodology and provide an overview of emerging approaches to increase the efficiency of gene targeting in somatic cells.     

Pig gene knockout by rAAV-mediated homologous recombination: comparison of BRCA1 gene knockout efficiency in Yucatan and G?ttingen fibroblasts with slightly different target sequences

In this study, we compared the gene targeting efficiencies of two rAAV-BRCA1 KO targeting constructs in Yucatan and G?ttingen minipig fibroblasts. The homology arms of the constructs consisted exclusively of exonic sequences amplified by PCR from Yucatan genomic DNA. The sequences were identical to those of the reference porcine genome of a Duroc sow (Ensembl Susscrofa 9) and the BRCA1 gene of the Landrace breed (NCBI acc. no. AB271921). Surprisingly, we found that the very efficient gene targeting observed for Yucatan fibroblasts (35% targeting efficiency) was completely absent using either of the two constructs in G?ttingen fibroblasts. Sequencing of the relevant BRCA1 exon 11 region (~2 kb) in the G?ttingen minipig revealed three single nucleotide differences in the sequence targeted by the left homology arm of the construct (0.3% of the bases) and three or seven in the two right homology regions (0.3 or 0.7% of the bases, respectively). Construction of a novel rAAV-BRCA1 targeting vector based on the G?ttingen genomic DNA sequence re-established gene targeting although the efficiency was somewhat lower than that observed for Yucatan fibroblasts. These BRCA1 KO G?ttingen fibroblast clones have been used as nuclear donor cells for somatic cell nuclear transfer to generate a G?ttingen BRCA1 KO pig model as previously done with the Yucatan breed. The present study illustrates that even a few mismatches present in the homology arms of an efficient rAAV-targeting construct can completely abolish gene targeting by homologous recombination emphasizing the importance of using isogenic DNA even for creating targeting constructs consisting of exon sequences only.     

DNA oligonucleotide-assisted genetic manipulation increases transformation and homologous recombination efficiencies: Evidence from gene targeting of Dictyostelium discoideum

Artificial gene alteration by homologous recombination in living cells, termed gene targeting, presents fundamental and considerable knowledge of in vivo gene function. In principle, this method can possibly be applied to any type of genes and transformable cells. However, its success is limited due to a low frequency of homologous recombination between endogenous targeted gene and exogenous transgene. Here, we describe a general gene-targeting method in which co-transformation of DNA oligonucleotides (oligomers) could significantly increase the homologous recombination frequency and transformation efficiency. The oligomers were simply designed such that they were identical to both the ends of the homologous flanking regions of the targeting construct. Using this strategy, both targeted alleles of diploid cells were simultaneously replaced in a single transformation procedure. Thus, the simplicity and versatility of this method applicable to any type of cell may increase the application of gene targeting.     

ht-Pam基因在山羊β-酪蛋白基因座定位整合的研究

利用体细胞基因打靶与核移植技术制备动物乳腺生物反应器是当今转基因定位整合表达的一种新技术。分别克隆山羊的β-酪蛋白基因5′调控区的6.3kb片段,外显子7、外显子8和9三个基因片段,并与克隆的人tPA突变体cDNA一起构建了含有neo和tk正负筛选标记基因的β-酪蛋白基因打靶载体P^GBC4tPA,并验证了neo基因、tk基因以及Cre-LoxP系统的有效性。将线性化的P^GBC4tPA通过电转染整合到山羊胎儿成纤维细胞基因组中,利用G418和GANC进行抗性细胞克隆的药物筛选,初步获得抗性细胞克隆244个,PCR检测后获得阳性细胞克隆31个,其中初步验证2个细胞克隆转植基因整合位点重组后的基因序列正确,并且该细胞克隆能够有效扩增。这为下一步基因打靶体细胞核移植制备山羊乳腺生物反应器奠定了基础。     

Establishment of a rapid and scalable gene expression system in livestock by site-specific integration

Somatic cell-mediated transgenesis is routinely used to transfer exogenous genes to livestock genomes. However, transgene insertion events are essentially random which may lead to transgene silencing or alter animal phenotype because of insertional mutagenesis. To overcome these problems, we established a gene manipulation system in goat somatic cells based on homologous recombination and flp recombinase-mediated site-specific integration. First, we performed gene targeting to introduce an frt-docking site into the α1 (I) procollagen (ColA1) locus in goat somatic cells. Second, the targeted cell clones were rejuvenated by embryo cloning, and the vigorous cells with targeted frt were reestablished. Third, a gene-replacement system was used to introduce an EGFP reporter gene into the targeted ColA1 locus via flp mediated recombination. As a result, the transgenic somatic cell exhibited faithful expression of EGFP gene under control of the CMV promoter. Similarly, other expression vectors can be introduced into the defined site to evaluate gene functions or express valuable proteins. The gene manipulation system described here will be applicable in other livestock somatic cells, and would allow for the rapid generation of livestock with transgene targeted to the defined site.     

1,5-isoquinolinediol increases the frequency of gene targeting by homologous recombination in mouse fibroblasts.

Gene targeting is a technique that allows the introduction of predefined alterations into chromosomal DNA. It involves a homologous recombination reaction between the targeted genomic sequence and an exogenous targeting vector. In theory, gene targeting constitutes the ideal method of gene therapy for single gene disorders. In practice, gene targeting remains extremely inefficient for at least two reasons: very low frequency of homologous recombination in mammalian cells and high proficiency of the mammalian cells to randomly integrate the targeting vector by illegitimate recombination. One known method to improve the efficiency of gene targeting is inhibition of poly(ADP-ribose)polymerase (PARP). It has been shown that PARP inhibitors, such as 3-methoxybenzamide, could lower illegitimate recombination, thus increasing the ratio of gene targeting to random integration. However, the above inhibitors were reported to decrease the absolute frequency of gene targeting. Here we show that treatment of mouse Ltk cells with 1,5-isoquinolinediol, a recent generation PARP inhibitor, leads to an increase up to 8-fold in the absolute frequency of gene targeting in the correction of the mutation at the stable integrated HSV tk gene.     

Simple Monitoring of Gene Targeting Efficiency in Human Somatic Cell Lines Using the PIGA Gene

Gene targeting in most of human somatic cell lines has been labor-intensive because of low homologous recombination efficiency. The development of an experimental system that permits a facile evaluation of gene targeting efficiency in human somatic cell lines is the first step towards the improvement of this technology and its application to a broad range of cell lines. In this study, we utilized phosphatidylinositol glycan anchor biosynthesis class A (PIGA), a gene essential for the synthesis of glycosylphosphatidyl inositol (GPI) anchors, as a reporter of gene targeting events in human somatic cell lines. Targeted disruption of PIGA was quantitatively detected with FLAER, a reagent that specifically binds to GPI anchors. Using this PIGA-based reporter system, we successfully detected adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated gene targeting events both with and without promoter-trap enrichment of gene-targeted cell population. The PIGA-based reporter system was also capable of reproducing previous findings that an AAV-mediated gene targeting achieves a remarkably higher ratio of homologous versus random integration (H/R ratio) of targeting vectors than a plasmid-mediated gene targeting. The PIGA-based system also detected an approximately 2-fold increase in the H/R ratio achieved by a small negative selection cassette introduced at the end of the AAV-based targeting vector with a promoter-trap system. Thus, our PIGA-based system is useful for monitoring AAV-mediated gene targeting and will assist in improving gene targeting technology in human somatic cell lines.     

Enhancement of Extra Chromosomal Recombination in Somatic Cells by Affecting the Ratio of Homologous Recombination (HR) to Non-Homologous End Joining (NHEJ)

Advancements in somatic cell gene targeting have been slow due to the finite lifespan of somatic cells and the overall inefficiency of homologous recombination. The rate of homologous recombination is determined by mechanisms of DNA repair, and by the balance between homologous recombination (HR) and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ). A plasmid-to-plasmid, extra chromosomal recombination system was used to study the effects of the manipulation of molecules involved in NHEJ (Mre11, Ku70/80, and p53) on HR/NHEJ ratios. In addition, the effect of telomerase expression, cell synchrony, and DNA nuclear delivery was examined. While a mutant Mre11 and an anti-Ku aptamer did not significantly affect the rate of NHEJ or HR, transient expression of a p53 mutant increased overall HR/NHEJ by 2.5 fold. However, expression of the mutant p53 resulted in increased aneuploidy of the cultured cells. Additionally, we found no relationship between telomerase expression and changes in HR/NHEJ. In contrast, cell synchrony by thymidine incorporation did not induce chromosomal abnormalities, and increased the ratio of HR/NHEJ 5-fold by reducing the overall rate of NHEJ. Overall our results show that attempts at reducing NHEJ by use of Mre11 or anti-Ku aptamers were unsuccessful. Cell synchrony via thymidine incorporation, however, does increase the ratio of HR/NHEJ and this indicates that this approach may be of use to facilitate targeting in somatic cells by reducing the numbers of colonies that need to be analyzed before a HR is identified.     

Enhancement of extra chromosomal recombination in somatic cells by affecting the ratio of homologous recombination (HR) to non-homologous end joining (NHEJ)

Advancements in somatic cell gene targeting have been slow due to the finite lifespan of somatic cells and the overall inefficiency of homologous recombination. The rate of homologous recombination is determined by mechanisms of DNA repair, and by the balance between homologous recombination (HR) and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ). A plasmid-to-plasmid, extra chromosomal recombination system was used to study the effects of the manipulation of molecules involved in NHEJ (Mre11, Ku70/80, and p53) on HR/NHEJ ratios. In addition, the effect of telomerase expression, cell synchrony, and DNA nuclear delivery was examined. While a mutant Mre11 and an anti-Ku aptamer did not significantly affect the rate of NHEJ or HR, transient expression of a p53 mutant increased overall HR/NHEJ by 2.5 fold. However, expression of the mutant p53 resulted in increased aneuploidy of the cultured cells. Additionally, we found no relationship between telomerase expression and changes in HR/NHEJ. In contrast, cell synchrony by thymidine incorporation did not induce chromosomal abnormalities, and increased the ratio of HR/NHEJ 5-fold by reducing the overall rate of NHEJ. Overall our results show that attempts at reducing NHEJ by use of Mre11 or anti-Ku aptamers were unsuccessful. Cell synchrony via thymidine incorporation, however, does increase the ratio of HR/NHEJ and this indicates that this approach may be of use to facilitate targeting in somatic cells by reducing the numbers of colonies that need to be analyzed before a HR is identified.     

Site-specific modification of the bovine genome using Cre recombinase-mediated gene targeting.

Cre recombinase (Cre)-mediated targeted insertion of a transgene is a powerful technique that can be used to tailor genomes. When combined with somatic cell nuclear transfer it could offer an efficient way to generate transgenic livestock with site-specific genetic modifications that are free of antibiotic selection markers. We have engineered primary bovine fibroblasts to contain a chromosomal acceptor site with incompatible loxP/lox2272 sites for Cre-mediated cassette exchange and show for the first time that Cre-mediated targeting can be applied in these acceptor cells. Molecular characterization of the resulting cell clones revealed Cre-mediated transgene insertion efficiencies of up to 98% when antibiotic selection was used to identify transgene containing cell clones. Most clonal lines also contained random insertions of the targeting and Cre expression plasmids with only about 10% of the clones being exclusively modified by the intended targeted insertion. This targeting efficiency was sufficient to enable the isolation of correctly targeted clones without the help of antibiotic selection. Therefore, this recombinase-mediated insertion strategy has the potential to produce transgenic cattle from antibiotic selection marker-free somatic cells with transgenes inserted into proven genomic loci ensuring reliable expression levels.     

Efficient recruitment of transfected DNA to a homologous chromosomal target in mammalian cells.

A Chinese hamster ovary cell line hemizygous for a defective adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (aprt) gene was transfected with a plasmid, pAG100, capable of correcting the endogenous aprt mutation by targeted homologous recombination. In some experiments, pAG100 was transfected in combination with one of two 'competitor' plasmids. Competitor pCOMP-A was identical to pAG100 except that the aprt sequence on pCOMP-A had the same mutation as the endogenous aprt gene. Competitor pCOMP-B was identical to pAG100 except for a 763 bp deletion in the aprt sequence encompassing the site of mutation in the endogenous gene. Neither pCOMP-A nor pCOMP-B was capable of correcting the defect in the endogenous aprt gene via gene targeting. We asked whether cotransfection of a 4-fold excess of either competitor DNA molecule with pAG100 would reduce the efficiency of targeted correction of the endogenous aprt gene. We report that while plasmid pCOMP-B did not influence the efficiency of gene targeting by pAG100, plasmid pCOMP-A reduced the number of gene targeting events about 5-fold. These observations indicate that the initial homologous interaction between transfected DNA and a genomic target sequence occurs rapidly and that targeting efficiency is limited by a step subsequent to homologous pairing.     

Efficient somatic gene targeting in the lymphoid human cell line DG75

Among the different approaches used to define the function of a protein of interest, alteration and/or deletion of its encoding gene is the most direct strategy. Homologous recombination between the chromosomal gene locus and an appropriately designed targeting vector results in an alteration or knockout of the gene of interest. Homologous recombination is easily performed in yeast or in murine embryonic stem cells, but is cumbersome in more differentiated and diploid somatic cell lines. Here we describe an efficient method for targeting both alleles of a complex human gene locus in DG75 cells, a cell line of lymphoid origin. The experimental approach included a conditional knockout strategy with three genotypic markers, which greatly facilitated the generation and phenotypic identification of targeted recombinant cells. The vector was designed such that it could be reused for two consecutive rounds of recombination to target both alleles. The human DG75 cell line appears similar to the chicken DT40 pre B-cell line, which supports efficient homologous recombination. Therefore, the DG75 cell line is a favorable addition to the limited number of cell lines amenable to gene targeting and should prove useful for studying gene function through targeted gene alteration or deletion in human somatic cells.     

Efficient gene targeting mediated by adeno-associated virus and DNA double-strand breaks

Gene targeting is the in situ manipulation of the sequence of an endogenous gene by the introduction of homologous exogenous DNA. Presently, the rate of gene targeting is too low for it to be broadly used in mammalian somatic cell genetics or to cure genetic diseases. Recently, it has been demonstrated that infection with recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors can mediate gene targeting in somatic cells, but the mechanism is unclear. This paper explores the balance between random integration and gene targeting with rAAV. Both random integration and spontaneous gene targeting are dependent on the multiplicity of infection (MOI) of rAAV. It has previously been shown that the introduction of a DNA double-stranded break (DSB) in a target gene can stimulate gene targeting by several-thousand-fold in somatic cells. Creation of a DSB stimulates the frequency of rAAV-mediated gene targeting by over 100-fold, suggesting that the mechanism of rAAV-mediated gene targeting involves, at least in part, the repair of DSBs by homologous recombination. Absolute gene targeting frequencies reach 0.8% with a dual vector system in which one rAAV vector provides a gene targeting substrate and a second vector expresses the nuclease that creates a DSB in the target gene. The frequencies of gene targeting that we achieved with relatively low MOIs suggest that combining rAAV vectors with DSBs is a promising strategy to broaden the application of gene targeting.     

锌指核酸内切酶:基因操作的有力工具

针对动植物进行基因靶向操作的技术,是解析基因功能、研究疾病,以及农业经济生产中一个有用的工具。至今,基因靶向操作主要是通过在胚胎干细胞(embryonic stem cell,ES cell)中进行同源重组或者是体细胞核转移的方法进行,但同源重组方法由于需要ES细胞而被限制在个别物种,而核转移方法存在核去分化、效率低、成本高的缺陷。近几年,一种基于锌指核酸内切酶(zinc-finger nuclease,ZFN)基因靶向修饰的新技术被应用于包括植物、果蝇、爪蟾、斑马鱼和大鼠等不同物种的基因操作。通过胚胎注射ZFN的质粒或是mRNA可以有效地定靶并迅速地在内源基因上引起可遗传的突变。ZFN介导基因靶向敲除的可行性,使得那些无法获得ES细胞和克隆技术支持的物种的基因靶向修饰成为可能。     

Evaluation of gene targeting by homologous recombination in ovine somatic cells

Mouse models for some human genetic diseases are limited in their applications since they do not accurately reproduce the phenotype of the human disease. It has been suggested that larger animals, for example sheep, might produce more useful models, as some aspects of sheep physiology and anatomy are more similar to those of humans. The development of methods to clone animals from somatic cells provides a potential novel route to generate such large animal models following gene targeting. Here, we assess targeting of the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) gene in ovine somatic cells using homologous recombination (HR) of targeting constructs with extensive (>11 kb) homology. Electroporation of these constructs into ovine fetal and post-natal fibroblasts generated G418-resistant clones, but none analyzed had undergone HR, suggesting that at least for this locus, it is an extremely inefficient process. Karyotyping of targeted ovine fetal fibroblasts showed them to be less chromosomally stable than post-natal fibroblasts, and, moreover, extended culture periods caused them to senesce, adversely affecting their viability for use as nuclear transfer donor cells. These data stress the importance of donor cell choice in somatic cell cloning and suggest that culture time be kept to a minimum prior to nuclear transfer in order to maximize cell viability.     

Impact of non-homologous end-joining deficiency on random and targeted DNA integration: implications for gene targeting

In higher animal cells, the principal limitation of gene-targeting technology is the extremely low efficiency of targeted integration, which occurs three to four orders of magnitude less frequently than random integration. Assuming that random integration mechanistically involves non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ), inactivation of this pathway should reduce random integration and may enhance gene targeting. To test this possibility, we examined the frequencies of random and targeted integration in NHEJ-deficient chicken DT40 and human Nalm-6 cell lines. As expected, loss of NHEJ resulted in drastically reduced random integration in DT40 cells. Unexpectedly, however, this was not the case for Nalm-6 cells, indicating that NHEJ is not the sole mechanism of random integration. Nevertheless, we present evidence that NHEJ inactivation can lead to enhanced gene targeting through a reduction of random integration and/or an increase in targeted integration by homologous recombination. Most intriguingly, our results show that, in the absence of functional NHEJ, random integration of targeting vectors occurs more frequently than non-targeting vectors (harboring no or little homology to the host genome), implying that suppression of NHEJ-independent random integration events is needed to greatly enhance gene targeting in animal cells.     

Use of two gRNAs for CRISPR/Cas9 improves bi‐allelic homologous recombination efficiency in mouse embryonic stem cells

Targeted genome editing in mouse embryonic stem cells (ESCs) is a powerful resource to functionally characterize genes and regulatory elements. The use of the CRISPR/Cas9 genome editing approach has remarkably improved the time and efficiency of targeted recombination. However, the efficiency of this protocol is still far from ideal when aiming for bi‐allelic homologous recombination, requiring at least two independent targeting recombination events. Here we describe an improved protocol that uses two gRNAs flanking the selected targeted region, leading to highly efficient homologous recombination in mouse ESCs. The bi‐allelic recombination targeting efficiency is over 90% when using two gRNAs together with the inhibition of non‐homologous end‐joint repair. Moreover, this technique is compatible with the generation of knocked‐in mice and the use of ESC‐derived differentiation protocols, therefore facilitating and accelerating the gene targeting in mice and ESCs.     

Reverse genetic studies of homologous DNA recombination using the chicken B-lymphocyte line, DT40

DT40 is an avian leucosis virus-transformed chicken B-lymphocyte line which exhibits high ratios of targeted to random integration of transfected DNA constructs. This efficient targeted integration may be related to the ongoing diversification of the variable segment of the immunoglobulin gene through homologous DNA recombination-controlled gene conversion. DT40s are a convenient model system for making gene-targeted mutants. Another advantage is the relative tractability of these cells, which makes it possible to disrupt multiple genes in a single cell and to generate conditionally gene-targeted mutants including temperature-sensitive mutants. There are strong phenotypic similarities between murine and DT40 mutants of various genes involved in DNA recombination. These similarities confirm that the DT40 cell line is a reasonable model for the analysis of vertebrate DNA recombination, despite obvious concerns associated with the use of a transformed cell line, which may have certain cell-line-specific characteristics. Here we describe our studies of homologous DNA recombination in vertebrate somatic cells using reverse genetics in DT40 cells.     

Pooling and PCR as a method to combat low frequency gene targeting in mouse embryonic stem cells

The introduction of germ line modifications by gene targeting in mouse embryonic stem (ES) cells has proven a fundamental technology to relate genes to mammalian biology. Critical aspects required for successful gene targeting have traditionally been experimental enhancements that increase the frequency or detection of homologous recombination within ES cells; however, the utilization of such methods may still result in the failed isolation of a positively targeted ES cell clone. In this study, we discuss the current enhancement methods and describe an ES cell pooling strategy that maximizes the ability to detect properly targeted ES cells regardless of an inherent low targeting efficiency. The sensitivity required to detect correctly targeted events out of a pool of ES cell clones is provided by polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and only those pools containing positives need to be expanded and screened to find individually targeted clones. This method made it possible to identify targeted clones from a screen of approximately 2,300 ES cell colonies by performing only 123 PCR reactions. This technically streamlined approach bypasses the need to troubleshoot and re-engineer an existing targeting construct that is functionally suitable despite its low targeting frequency.