Malondialdehyde and thiobarbituric acid-reactivity as diagnostic indices of lipid peroxidation and peroxidative tissue injury

Increasing appreciation of the causative role of oxidative injury in many disease states places great importance on the reliable assessment of lipid peroxidation. Malondialdehyde (MDA) is one of several low-molecular-weight end products formed via the decomposition of certain primary and secondary lipid peroxidation products. At low pH and elavated temperature, MDA readily participates in nucleophilic addition reaction with 2-thiobarbituric acid (TBA), generating a red, fluorescent 1:2 MDA:TBA adduct. These facts, along with the availability of facile and sensitive methods to quantify MDA (as the free aldehyde or its TBA derivative), have led to the routine use of MDA determination and, particularly, the “TBA test” to detect and quantify lipid peroxidation in a wide array of sample types. However, MDA itself participates in reactions with molecules other than TBA and is a catabolic substrate. Only certain lipid peroxidation products generate MDA (invariably with low yields), and MDA is neither the sole end product of fatty peroxide formation and decomposition nor a substance generated exclusively through lipid peroxidation. Many factors (e.g., stimulus for and conditions of peroxidation) modulate MDA formation from lipid. Additional factors (e.g., TBA-test reagents and constituents) have profound effects on test response to fatty peroxide-derived MDA. The TBA test is intrinsically nonspecific for MDA: nonlipid-related materials as well as fatty peroxide-derived decomposition products other than MDA are TBA positive. These and other considerations from the extensive literature on MDA, TBA reactivity, and oxidative lipid degradation support the conclusion that MDA determination and the TBA test can offer, at best, a narrow and somewhat empirical window on the complex process of lipid peroxidation. The MDA content and/or TBA reactivity of a system provides no information on the precise structures of the “MDA precursor(s),” their molecular origins, or the amount of each formed. Consequently, neither MDA determination nor TBA-test response can generally be regarded as a diagnostic index of the occurrence/extent of lipid peroxidation, fatty hydroperoxide formation, or oxidative injury to tissue lipid without independent chemical evidence of the analyte being measured and its source. In some cases, MDA/TBA reactivity is an indicator of lipid peroxidation; in other situations, no qualitative or quantitative relationship exists among sample MDA content, TBA reactivity, and fatty peroxide tone. Utilization of MDA analysis and/or the TBA test and interpretation of sample MDA content and TBA test response in studies of lipid peroxidation require caution, discretion, and (especially in biological systems) correlative data from other indices of fatty peroxide formation and decomposition.     

Detection of in vivo lipid peroxidation using the thiobarbituric acid assay for lipid hydroperoxides

Thiobarbituric acid (TBA) assays which have been modified for detection of lipid hydroperoxides appear to be useful for demonstration of in vivo lipid peroxidation. Since these methods require heating tissue membranes with the buffered TBA, there is a possibility of interference from the detection of autoxidation that occurs during heating. These studies were undertaken to investigate conditions which favor TBA color production from hydroperoxide while limiting autoxidation during the assay. An acetic acid-sodium acetate buffered (pH 3.6) TBA assay was used. Heating linoleic acid hydroperoxide with 50 microM ferric iron or under nitrogen nearly doubled color production compared to heating it with no added iron or under air. The lipid antioxidant butylated hydroxytoluene inhibited color production from fatty acid hydroperoxides. When tissue fractions, including liver and lung microsomes and lung whole membranes, were heated in the assay, color production was greater under air than under nitrogen and was much greater under oxygen. When liver microsomes from carbon tetrachloride-exposed rats were used, color was increased only when oxygen was present in the heating atmosphere. The results with tissue fractions appear to demonstrate autoxidation during color development rather than the presence of preformed hydroperoxides. Finally, it was found that color production from membrane fractions was dependent on the vitamin E content of the membranes. It appears that autoxidation during heating should be limited by heating under nitrogen and not by adding antioxidants, which inhibit color production from hydroperoxides. As the vitamin E effect demonstrates, antioxidant status must be considered, since a change in color production could result from a change in antioxidant content without the accumulation of lipid hydroperoxides.     

The reaction of 2-thiobarbituric acid with biologically active alpha,beta-unsaturated aldehydes

The standard assay for lipid peroxidation is the measurement of the pink, 532 n, absorbing chromogen which is formed upon reaction of 2-thiobarbituric acid (TBA) with the lipid peroxidation product malonaldehyde (MDA). The present studies indicate that the toxic lipid peroxidation product trans-4-hydroxynonenal and its dehydration product trans, trans-nonadienal react with TBA to form chromogens which absorb maximally at 530 and 532 nm, respectively. Other biologically active alpha, beta-unsaturated aldehydes, such as acrolein and crotonaldehyde, short-chain homologs of alkenals formed during lipid peroxidation, and trans,trans-muconaldehyde, a novel diene dialdehyde, react with TBA to form products which absorb maximally at 495 nm. The molar extinction coefficients of the aldehyde: TBA chromogens formed were found to vary widely, suggesting that only small contributions to the 532 nm absorption by TBA adducts of reactive aldehydes other than MDA may be encountered during the use of the TBA assay.     

Analysis of lipid peroxidation mechanisms in human spermatozoa

The mechanisms by which ferrous ion promoters induce malondialdehyde generation by human spermatozoa have been investigated in order to provide a rational basis for the quantification and interpretation of lipid peroxidation assays. Incubation of human spermatozoa with a ferrous ion promoter in the presence of thiobarbituric acid (TBA) led to the generation of the bone fide malondialdehyde-TBA adduct. The importance of iron in the stimulation of lipid peroxidation was emphasized by the ability of Desferal* and EDTA to suppress malondialdehyde generation. Paradoxically, when the concentration of EDTA relative to iron was equimolar or greater, the suppression of malondialdehyde formation was accompanied by the generation of hydroxyl radicals. These results suggested that the addition of promoter did not effect the first-chain initiation of lipid peroxidation but favored an alternative mechanism involving the catalytic decomposition of pre-existing lipid peroxides. This conclusion was reinforced by the inability of reagents that would limit the formation (superoxide dismutase and/or catalase) or availability (mannitol, formate) of hydroxyl radicals, to influence malondialdehyde generation. While hydroxyl radicals were not directly involved in Fe²⁺-promoted malondialdehyde generation, the existence of significant correlations between reactive oxygen species production and the outcome of the TBA assay, suggested that Fenton chemistry might be important in the initiation of peroxidative damage. It is proposed that the impeded propagation of peroxidation initiated by Fenton or Haber Weiss reactions would lead to the accumulation of lipid peroxides in the spermatozoa and it is these peroxides that are induced to decompose during the Fe²⁺-promoted TBA assay, stimulating a lipoperoxidative chain reaction and malondialdehyde formation. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Comparison of two methods used to analyse lipid peroxidation from Vaccinium myrtillus (L.) during snow removal, reacclimation and cold acclimation.

Malondialdehyde (MDA) concentration is a widely used method to analyse lipid peroxidation in biological material. In plant tissues, however, certain compounds (anthocyanins, carbohydrates) may interfere with measurements which may lead to an overestimation of the MDA levels. Two methods were compared for analysing lipid peroxidation, either uncorrected or corrected for interfering compounds. The comparison was performed in three separate experiments with respect to cold treatments (snow removal in winter, reacclimation in summer and cold acclimation in autumn) in bilberry (Vaccinium myrtillus L.). During winter and autumn the methods seem to measure different compounds, but during active growth in the summer the difference between the methods was less. This is obviously due to carbohydrates which act as cryoprotectants and increase in concentration during cold acclimation as well as due to the anthocyanins. It is thus suggested that the validity of the uncorrected method to measure MDA and thereby lipid peroxidation is best in plant tissue which is in an active growth state.     

The measurement and mechanism of lipid peroxidation in biological systems

The basic chemistry of the propagation of lipid peroxidation reactions has been known for years, but the mechanism of initiation of this process in biological membrane systems is still uncertain. Currently available assays for measuring peroxidation are reviewed--the more specific the assay used, the less peroxide is found in healthy human tissues and body fluids. Lipid peroxidation can arise as a consequence of tissue injury in many disease states and may sometimes contribute significantly to worsening the tissue injury.     

Carnosine,homocarnosine and anserine: could they act as antioxidants in vivo?

Carnosine, homocarnosine and anserine have been proposed to act as antioxidants in vivo. Our studies show that all three compounds are good scavengers of the hydroxyl radical (.OH) but that none of them can react with superoxide radical, hydrogen peroxide or hypochlorous acid at biologically significant rates. None of them can bind iron ions in ways that interfere with 'site-specific' iron-dependent radical damage to the sugar deoxyribose, nor can they restrict the availability of Cu2+ to phenanthroline. Homocarnosine has no effect on iron ion-dependent lipid peroxidation; carnosine and anserine have weak inhibitory effects when used at high concentrations in some (but not all) assay systems. However, the ability of these compounds to interfere with a commonly used version of the thiobarbituric acid (TBA) test may have led to an overestimate of their ability to inhibit lipid peroxidation in some previous studies. By contrast, histidine stimulated iron ion-dependent lipid peroxidation. It is concluded that, because of the high concentrations present in vivo, carnosine and anserine could conceivably act as physiological antioxidants by scavenging .OH, but that they do not have a broad spectrum of antioxidant activity, and their ability to inhibit lipid peroxidation is not well established. It may be that they have a function other than antioxidant protection (e.g. buffering), but that they are safer to accumulate than histidine, which has a marked pro-oxidant action upon iron ion-dependent lipid peroxidation. The inability of homocarnosine to react with HOCl, interfere with the TBA test or affect lipid peroxidation systems in the same way as carnosine is surprising in view of the apparent structural similarity between these two molecules.     

Elevation of thiobarbituric acid values in the rat liver intoxicated by T-2 toxin

In the present study we first demonstrated that T-2 toxin markedly stimulated lipid peroxidation specifically in the liver of rats. The amount of lipid peroxides in the liver, estimated by the thiobarbituric acid (TBA) method, increased dose dependently, being proportional to the extent of its acute toxicity measured by various parameters in rats fed a commercial diet. Further, to elucidate the mechanism of lipid peroxidation and its role in hepatic injury caused by T-2 toxin, time-course studies on the correlation between lipid peroxide content and some biological and histopathological data were undertaken in rats given 4 mg of the toxin/kg perorally. The TBA reactive substances in the liver began to increase after 6 hr. However, much earlier than this there were some other alterations, which included decreases in the amount of cytochrome P-450 in the liver, of GPT (thereafter an increase) and phospholipids in the plasma, and of basophilic masses in the hepatocytes (arrayed as a rough endoplasmic reticulum in the electron micrograph). The vitamin E-deficient study showed that vitamin E markedly inhibited the stimulative effect of T-2 toxin on lipid peroxidation, but not diminish any other measured parameters of the injury. The toxin-induced stimulation of lipid peroxidation does not appear to be caused by activation of microsomal NADPH-cytochrome c reductase nor by a decrease in the level of cytosolic glutathione peroxidase. These results suggest that T-2 toxin might induce some alteration of the membrane structure and consequently might stimulate lipid peroxidation in situ.     

The Action of Hydrogen Peroxide on the Formation of Thiobarbituric Acid-Reactive Material From Microsomes, Liposomes Or From Dna Damaged By Bleomycin Or Phenanthroline. Artefacts in the Thiobarbituric Acid Test

Incubation of rat-liver microsomes, previously azide-treated to inhibit catalase, with H₂O₂ caused a loss of cytochrome P-450 but not of cytochrome b₅. This loss of P-450 was not prevented by scavengers of hydroxyl radical, chain-breaking antioxidants or metal ion-chelating agents. Application of the thiobarbituric acid (TBA) assay to the reaction mixture suggested that H₂O₂ induces lipid peroxidation, but this was found to be due largely or completely to an effect of H²O₂ on the TBA assay. By contrast, addition of ascorbic acid and Fe(III) to the microsomes led to lipid peroxidation and P-450 degradation: both processes were inhibited by chelating agents and chain-breaking antioxidants, but not by hydroxyl radical scavengers. H₂O₂ inhibited ascorbate/Fe (III)-induced microsomal lipid peroxidation, but part of this effect was due to an action of H₂O₂ in the TBA test itself. H₂O₂ also decreased the colour measured after carrying out the TBA test upon authentic malondialdehyde, tetraethoxypropane, a DNA-Cu²⁺/o-phenanthroline system in the presence of a reducing agent, ox-brain phospholipid liposomes in the presence of Fe(III) and ascorbate, or a bleomycin-iron ion/DNA/ascorbate system. Caution must be used in interpreting the results of TBA tests upon systems containing H₂O₂.     

Comparison of the effects of laser and light-emitting diodes on lipid peroxidation in rat wound exudate

The effect of laser and light-emitting diode radiation on lipid peroxidation in rat wound exudate was studied with the aim to compare the efficiency of coherent laser and incoherent light-emitting diode radiations. A model of aseptic wound in rat suggested by L.I. Slutskii was used. A He-Ne laser (632 nm) and a U-332B light-emitting diode were used in this study. The intensity of lipid peroxidation was estimated by the TBA assay. The antioxidative capacity of rat wound fluid was evaluated by means of chemiluminescent assays in two model systems: a) aqueous system with ABAP and luminol and b) in phospholipid liposome suspension with Fe2+ and cumarin. It was shown that exposure of rat wounds to both laser and light-emitting diode radiation decreased the concentration of TBA products and increased the antioxidative capacity of wound exudates, compared with the control group (without irradiation). The results obtained show that exposure of wounds to both laser and light-emitting diode irradiation causes a decrease in the oxidative stress in the rat wound fluid. No significant quantitative difference between the effects of laser and light-emitting diode irradiation was found.     

Antibacterial and antioxidant cassane diterpenoids from Caesalpinia benthamiana

Bioactivity-guided fractionation of the light petroleum extract of Caesalpinia benthamiana (=Mezoneuron benthamianum) root bark has led to the isolation of two cassane diterpenoids, designated as benthaminin 1 and 2. A third compound, a deoxy form of caesaldekarin C (also referred to as methyl vouacapenate) which has previously been isolated from Caesalpinia major, C. bonducella, Vouacapoua americana and V. macropetala, was also isolated, together with beta-sitosterol and stigmastenone. The antibacterial and antioxidant activities of these cassane diterpenoids have been assessed using the microdilution assay method and DPPH spectrophotometric and TBA lipid peroxidation assays. Benthaminin 1 was the more active antibacterial compound with MIC values of 47.8 microM for both Staphylococcus aureus and Micrococcus flavus. Benthaminin 2 was the more active antioxidant compound and showed IC50 values of 42.7 microM and 74.2 microM for the DPPH and TBA assays, respectively. Deoxycaesaldekarin C possessed both antibacterial and antioxidant activities. The presence of methyl ester and methyl functional groups as well as an unsaturated furan ring appears to confer antibacterial activity. On the other hand, the relatively stronger antioxidant activity of benthaminin 2 may be associated with the presence of an exocyclic methylene function.     

The effect of calcium on phospholipid peroxidation

The effect of calcium ions on the peroxidation of ox-brain phospholipid liposomes in different free-radical catalysing systems has been assessed. Using thiobarbituric acid-reactivity (TBA) as a measure of lipid peroxidation, calcium ions both inhibited and enhanced peroxidation in the different systems.Changing the composition of the ox-brain phospholipid liposome with synthetic non TBA-reactive phosphatidylcholine, significantly altered its susceptibility to peroxidation both in the presence and absence of calcium ions.The results are discussed with reference to the possibility that calcium ions induce conformational changes in membrane phospholipids. Susceptibility to peroxidation is then influenced by a complex interrelationship between the qualitative lipid composition of the membrane, the pro-oxidant catalyst and the presence of calcium or other active ions.     

Evaluation of antioxidants: Scope, limitations and relevance of assays

Peroxidation of lipids, particularly polyunsaturated fatty acid residues (PUFA) of phospholipids and cholesterol esters, is a process of marked implications: it shortens the shelf-life of food and drugs, it causes fragmentation of DNA, it damages cellular membranes and it promotes the genesis of many human diseases. Much effort is therefore devoted to a search for "potent antioxidants", both synthetic and from natural sources, mostly plants. This, in turn, requires a reliable, simple, preferably high throughput assay of the activity of alleged antioxidants. The most commonly used assays are based on measurements of the total antioxidant capacity (TAC) of a solution, as evaluated either by determining the rate of oxidation of the antioxidant or by measuring the protection of an easily determined indicator against oxidation by the antioxidants. The commonly used assays utilized for ranking antioxidants share three common problems: (i) They usually evaluate the effects of those antioxidants that quench free radicals, which constitute only a part of the body's antioxidative network, in which enzymes play the central role. (ii) Both the capacity and potency of antioxidants, as obtained by various methods, do not necessarily correlate with each other. (iii) Most estimates are based on methods conducted in solution and are therefore not necessarily relevant to processes that occur at the lipid-water interfaces in both membranes and micro emulsions (e.g. lipoproteins). Given this "state of art", many researchers, including us, try to develop a method based on the formation of hydroperoxides (LOOH) upon peroxidation of PUFA in lipoproteins or in model membranes, such as liposomes. In these systems, as well as in lipoproteins, the most apparent effect of antioxidants is prolongation of the lag time preceding the propagation of a free radical chain reaction. In fact, under certain conditions both water soluble antioxidants (e.g. vitamin C and urate) and the lipid soluble antioxidant tocopherol (vitamin E), promote or even induce peroxidation. Based on the published data, including our results, we conclude that terms such as 'antioxidative capacity' or 'antioxidative potency' are context-dependent. Furthermore, criteria of the efficacy of antioxidants based on oxidation in solution are not necessarily relevant to the effects of antioxidants on peroxidation in biological systems or model lipid assemblies, because the latter processes occur at water/lipid interfaces. We think that evaluation of antioxidants requires kinetic studies of the biomarker used and that the most relevant characteristic of 'oxidative stress' in the biological context is the kinetics of ex vivo peroxidation of lipids. We therefore propose studying the kinetics of lipid-peroxidation in the absence of the studied antioxidant and in its presence at different antioxidant concentrations. These protocols mean that antioxidants are assayed by methods commonly used to evaluate oxidative stress. The advantage of such evaluation is that it enables quantization of the antioxidants' efficacy in a model of relevance to biological systems. In view of the sensitivity of the lag time preceding peroxidation, we propose studying how much antioxidant is required to double the lag observed prior to rapid peroxidation. The latter quantity (C(2lag)) can be used to express the strength of antioxidants in the relevant system (e.g. LDL, serum or liposomes).     

Reaction conditions affecting the relationship between thiobarbituric acid reactivity and lipid peroxides in human plasma.

The thiobarbituric acid (TBA) reactivity of human plasma was studied to evaluate its adequacy in quantifying lipid peroxidation as an index of systemic oxidative stress. Two spectrophotometric TBA tests based on the use of either phosphoric acid (pH 2.0, method A) or trichloroacetic plus hydrochloric acid (pH 0.9, method B) were employed with and without sodium sulfate (SS) to inhibit sialic acid (SA) reactivity with TBA. To correct for background absorption, the absorbance values at 572 nm were subtracted from those at 532 nm, which represent the absorption maximum of the TBA:MDA adduct. Method B gave values of TBA-reactive substances (TBARS) 2-fold higher than those detected with method A. SS lowered TBARS by about 50% with both methods, indicating a significant involvement of SA in plasma TBA reactivity. Standard SA, at a physiologically relevant concentration of 1.5 mM, reacted with TBA, creating interference problems, which were substantially eliminated by SS plus correction for background absorbance. When method B was carried out in the lipid and protein fraction of plasma, SS inhibited by 65% TBARS formation only in the latter. Protein TBARS may be largely ascribed to SA-containing glycoproteins and, to a minor extent, protein-bound MDA. Indeed, EDTA did not affect protein TBARS assessed in the presence of SS. TBA reactivity of whole plasma and of its lipid fraction was instead inhibited by EDTA, suggesting that lipoperoxides (and possibly monofunctional lipoperoxidation aldehydes) are involved as MDA precursors in the TBA test. Pretreatment of plasma with KI, a specific reductant of hydroperoxides, decreased TBARS by about 27%. Moreover, aspirin administration to humans to inhibit prostaglandin endoperoxide generation reduced plasma TBARS by 40%. In conclusion, reaction conditions affect the relationship between TBA reactivity and lipid peroxidation in human plasma. After correction for the interfering effects of SA in the TBA test, 40% of plasma TBARS appears related to in vivo generated prostaglandin endoperoxides and only about 60% to lipoperoxidation products. Thus, the TBA test is not totally specific to oxidant-driven lipid peroxidation in human plasma.     

Lipid peroxidation cannot be used as a universal criterion of oxidative stress

Oxidative stress is a term used to denote the imbalance between the concentrations of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species and the defense mechanisms of the body. Although it is generally accepted that such an imbalance plays a pivotal role in many pathologies, the term "oxidative stress" remains ill defined. In an attempt to evaluate the relationship between various assays of oxidative stress, we have analyzed the correlations between the results reported in those publications in which "oxidative stress" has been assayed by at least two methods. We found good correlations between the concentrations of several peroxidation products, including malondialdehyde, F2-Isoprostanes, lipid hydroperoxides, conjugated dienes, glutathione and protein carbonyls, but not with other criteria of "individual oxidative status" such as the concentration of antioxidants and products of DNA fragmentation (the "comet" assay). In light of these findings, we divide the assays used for evaluation of "oxidative stress" into the following three categories: (i) assays based on measuring the concentrations of oxidation products of lipids, proteins and DNA, as well as the concentrations of antioxidants, (ii) assays used to evaluate the oxidative and reductive capacity of biological fluids and (iii) assays used to evaluate the ex vivo susceptibility of lipids to oxidation upon their exposure to a source of free radicals. Our analyses demonstrate that oxidative stress cannot be defined in universal terms. Two results are of special interest:1.the commonly used criteria based on lipid peroxidation can not be regarded as a general estimate of the individual "oxidative status".2.the levels of antioxidants exhibit a non-monotonic relation with other criteria for oxidative stress. Further research is required to evaluate the significance of the latter finding.     

Advances in methods for the determination of biologically relevant lipid peroxidation products

Abstract

Lipid peroxidation is recognized to be an important contributor to many chronic diseases, especially those of an inflammatory pathology. In addition to their value as markers of oxidative damage, lipid peroxidation products have also been shown to have a wide variety of biological and cell signalling effects. In view of this, accurate and sensitive methods for the measurement of lipid peroxidation products are essential. Although some assays have been described for many years, improvements in protocols are continually being reported and, with recent advances in instrumentation and technology, highly specialized and informative techniques are increasingly used. This article gives an overview of the most currently used methods and then addresses the recent advances in some specific approaches. The focus is on analysis of oxysterols, F₂-isoprostanes and oxidized phospholipids by gas chromatography or liquid chromatography mass spectrometry techniques and immunoassays for the detection of 4-hydroxynonenal.     

在96孔板中进行抗脂质过氧化的微量测定

以Fe²⁺/半胱氨酸诱导大鼠肝微粒体为基本模型,根据硫代巴比妥酸(TBA)反应原理,优化不同反应条件,建立了一种在96孔板上进行抗脂质过氧化测定的一步反应方法,该方法的灵敏度不低于传统的试管法,而且还具有微量、快速、简便等优点,特别适用于大规模筛选和研究抗氧化剂.此外,也可用于其它系统诱导的抗脂质过氧化的测定.     

Methods for determination of lipid peroxidation in biological samples

Interest in the pathological consequences of lipid peroxidation has led to the development of a number of analytical approaches to the quantitation of products. However, the various analytical methodologies employed often do not measure the same chemical classes of products, and apparent discrepencies have been observed, particularly in studies of lipid peroxidation in biological systems. This review provides a brief discussion of some of the strengths and weakness of methods currently used for the determination of lipid peroxidation in biological tissues.     

Measurement of Lipid Peroxidation

Lipid peroxidation results in the formation of conjugated dienes, lipid hydroperoxides and degradation products such as alkanes, aldehydes and isoprostanes. The approach to the quantitative assessment of lipid peroxidation depends on whether the samples involve complex biological material obtained in vivo, or whether the samples involve relatively simple mixtures obtained in vituo. Samples obtained in vivo contain a large number of products which themselves may undergo metabolism. The measurement of conjugated diene formation is generally applied as a dynamic quantitation e.g. during the oxidation of LDL, and is not generally applied to samples obtained in vivo. Lipid hydroperoxides readily decompose, but can be measured directly and indirectly by a variety of techniques. The measurement of MDA by the TBAR assay is non-specific, and is generally poor when applied to biological samples. More recent assays based on the measurement of MDA or HNE-lysine adducts are likely to be more applicable to biological samples, since adducts of these reactive aldehydes are relatively stable. The discovery of the isoprostanes as lipid peroxidation products which can be measured by gas chromatography mass spectrometry or immunoassay has opened a new avenue by which to quantify lipid peroxidation in vivo, and will be discussed in detail.     

A comparison of trihydroxyindole and HPLC/electrochemical methods for catecholamine measurement in adrenal chromaffin cells

Three commonly used methods for the determination of epinephrine and norepinephrine levels in adrenal medullary tissue were compared. Two variations of the trihydroxyindole procedure, which utilized oxidation at room temperature or 0°C, underestimated levels of total catecholamines in certain standard solutions and were unable to determine correctly their norepinephrine:epinephrine ratios. However, both the variability and the underestimation of the trihydroxyindole procedure carried out at room temperature were more pronounced than that of the trihydroxyindole assay at 0°C. In addition, we tested an isocratic HPLC method utilizing electrochemical detection which separates epinephrine from norepinephrine. The ability of this method to measure correctly total and individual catecholamine levels was superior to either trihydroxyindole procedure, as was its variability. When the three assay methods were used to measure total and individual catecholamine levels in cultured adrenal bovine chromaffin cells, both the trihydroxyindole (0°C) method and the HPLC method yielded values in agreement with those in the literature. However, the HPLC method produced data with lower error estimates. The trihydroxyindole (room temperature) assay was unable to reliably measure levels of epinephrine and norepinephrine in chromaffin cells.These comparisons of catecholamine assays demonstrated that there are circumstances under which the use of each is appropriate. In experiments where the epinephrine:norephinephrine ratio may be changing, the more accurate and precise HPLC assay may be essential, since the trihydroxyindole assays underestimate total catecholamines to varying degrees depending on this ratio. However, the HPLC method suffers from a requirement for technical sophistication for routine use. Therefore, in some laboratories and for repetitive measurement of many samples, the trihydroxyindole assay has a distinct advantage due to its easy utilization and ubiquitous materials. However, the superior results obtained with the trihydroxyindole (0°C) assay over the trihydroxyindole (room temperature) assay emphasizes the need to evaluate the trihydroxyindole procedure for the required purpose, especially if differential oxidation is used for estimation of individual catecholamine levels.