Site-site interaction on mitochondrial F1-ATPase. Functional symmetry of the high-affinity nucleotide binding sites

Interactions between the high affinity binding sites on mitochondrial F1 were analysed by combined use of the nucleotide analogues 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)-ADP (N-ADP) and 2'-3'-O-(2,4,6-trinitrophenyl)-ADP (TNP-ADP). The binding behaviour of F1 with respect to these ligands was studied by measuring the fluorescence of F1 and of TNP-ADP and the fluorescence anisotropy of N-ADP. A total of 3 high affinity binding sites can be occupied by TNP-ADP. By exchange experiments, it could be shown that binding of TNP-ADP to such a site considerably accelerates the dissociation of a ligand bound to a neighbouring site. These results support the notion that the functional behaviour of F1 is symmetric: during the catalytic cycle any individual site can successively assume different affinity states as has been predicted by hypotheses such as the binding change model.     

The characteristics and effect on catalysis of nucleotide binding to noncatalytic sites of chloroplast F1-ATPase.

The recent finding that the presence of ATP at non-catalytic sites of chloroplast F1-ATPase (CF1) is necessary for ATPase activity (Milgrom, Y. M., Ehler, L. L., and Boyer, P. D. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265,18725-18728) prompted more detailed studies of the effect of noncatalytic site nucleotides on catalysis. CF1 containing at noncatalytic sites less than one ADP or about two ATP was prepared by heat activation in the absence of Mg2+ and in the presence of ADP or ATP, respectively. After removal of medium nucleotides, the CF1 preparations were used for measurement of the time course of nucleotide binding from 10 to 100 microM concentrations of 3H-labeled ADP, ATP, or GTP. The presence of Mg2+ strongly promotes the tight binding of ADP and ATP at noncatalytic sites. For example, the ADP-heat-activated enzyme in presence of 1 mM Mg2+ binds ADP with a rate constant of 0.5 x 10(6) M-1 min-1 to give an enzyme with two ADP at noncatalytic sites with a Kd of about 0.1 microM. Upon exposure to Mg2+ and ATP the vacant noncatalytic site binds an ATP rapidly and, as an ADP slowly dissociates, a second ATP binds. The binding correlates with an increase in the ATPase activity. In contrast the tight binding of [3H]GTP to noncatalytic sites gives an enzyme with no ATPase activity. The three noncatalytic sites differ in their binding properties. The noncatalytic site that remains vacant after the ADP-heat-activated CF1 is exposed to Mg2+ and ADP and that can bind ATP rapidly is designated as site A; the site that fills with ATP as ADP dissociates when this enzyme is exposed to Mg2+ and ATP is called site B, and the site to which ADP remains bound is called site C. Procedures are given for attaining CF1 with ADP at sites B and C, with GTP at sites A and/or B, and with ATP at sites A, B, and/or C, and catalytic activities of such preparations are measured. For example, little or no ATPase activity is found unless ATP is at site A, but ADP can remain at site C with no effect on ATPase. Maximal GTPase activity requires ATP at site A but about one-fifth of maximal GTPase is attained when GTP is at sites A and B and ATP at site C. Noncatalytic site occupancy can thus have profound effects on the ATPase and GTPase activities of CF1.     

The nucleotide binding site of F1-ATPase which carries out uni-site catalysis is one of the alternating active sites of the enzyme

Nucleotide-depleted mitochondrial F1-ATPase binds 3'-(2')-O-(2-nitro-4-azidobenzoyl)-derivatives of ATP (NAB-ATP) and GTP (NAB-GTP) when these nucleotide analogues are added to the enzyme in equimolar quantities in the presence of Mg2+ (uni-site catalysis conditions). The binding of NAB-ATP is accompanied by its hydrolysis and inorganic phosphate dissociation from the enzyme; NAB-ADP remains bound to F1-ATPase. The F1-ATPase X NAB-ADP complex has no ATPase activity and its reactivation in the presence of an excess of ATP is accompanied by NAB-ADP release. The illumination of the F1-ATPase complexes with NAB-ADP or NAB-GDP leads to the covalent binding of one nucleotide analogue molecule to the enzyme and to the irreversible inactivation of F1-ATPase. It follows from the results obtained that the modification of just one of the F1-ATPase catalytic sites is sufficient to complete the inhibition of ATPase activity.     

Classification of nucleotide binding sites on mitochondrial F1-ATPase from yeast

Methods are described to classify nucleotide binding sites of the mitochondrial coupling factor F1 from yeast on the basis of their affinities and stability properties. High affinity sites or states for ATP and related adenine analogs and low affinity sites or states which bind a broad range of different nucleotide triphosphates are found. The results are discussed in terms of a two site, two cycle scheme, where binding of nucleotide at one site facilitates the release of nucleotide at a second site.     

Interaction between aurovertin and adenine nucleotide binding sites on mitochondrial F1-ATPase and the isolated beta subunit

The effect of aurovertin on the binding parameters of ADP and ATP to native F1 from beef heart mitochondria in the presence of EDTA has been explored. Three exchangeable sites per F1 were titrated by ADP and ATP in the absence or presence of aurovertin. Curvilinear Scatchard plots for the binding of both ADP and ATP were obtained in the absence of aurovertin, indicating one high affinity site (Kd for ADP = 0.6-0.8 microM; Kd for ATP = 0.3-0.5 microM) and two lower affinity sites (Kd for ADP = 8-10 microM; Kd for ATP = 7-10 microM). With a saturating concentration of aurovertin capable of filling the three beta subunits of F1, the curvilinearity of the Scatchard plots was decreased for ATP binding and abolished for ADP binding, indicating homogeneity of ADP binding sites in the F1-aurovertin complex (Kd for ADP = 2 microM). When only the high affinity aurovertin site was occupied, maximal enhancement of the fluorescence of the F1-aurovertin complex was attained with 1 mol of ADP bound per mol of F1 and maximal quenching for 1 mol of ATP bound per mol of F1. When the F1-aurovertin complex was incubated with [3H]ADP followed by [14C]ATP, full fluorescence quenching was attained when ATP had displaced the previously bound ADP. In the case of the isolated beta subunit, both ADP and ATP enhanced the fluorescence of the beta subunit-aurovertin complex. The Kd values for ADP and ATP in the presence of EDTA were 0.6 mM and 3.7 mM, respectively; MgCl2 decreased the Kd values to 0.1 mM for both ADP and ATP. It is postulated that native F1 possesses three equivalent interacting nucleotide binding sites and exists in two conformations which are in equilibrium and recognize either ATP (T conformation) or ADP (D conformation). The negative interactions between the nucleotide binding sites of F1 are strongest in the D conformation. Upon addition of aurovertin, the site-site cooperativity between the beta subunits of F1 is decreased or even abolished.     

Characterization of the nucleotide tight-binding sites of the isolated mitochondrial F1-ATPase

The properties of the nucleotides tightly bound with mitochondrial F1-ATPase were examined. One of three bound nucleotide molecules is localized at the site with Kd approximately 10(-7) M and released with koff approximately 0.1 s-1. The second nucleotide molecule is bound with the enzyme with Kd approximately 10(-8) M and koff for its dissociation is 3 X 10(-4) s-1. The third is never released even in the presence of 1 mM ATP or ADP. The last two nucleotides are believed to be bound at the noncatalytic sites of F1-ATPase. Pyrophosphate promotes liberation of two releasable nucleotide molecules, decreasing the affinity of the enzyme to AD(T)P. From the results obtained it follows that the only suitable criterion for localization of the nucleotide at the F1-ATPase catalytic site is the high rate (koff greater than or equal to 0.1 s-1) of its spontaneous release.     

Evidence for a nucleotide binding site on the isolated beta subunit from Escherichia coli F1-ATPase. Interaction between nucleotide and aurovertin D binding sites

The nucleotide binding capacity and affinity of the isolated beta subunit from Escherichia coli F1-ATPase have been studied with radiolabeled ADP and ATP by an equilibrium dialysis technique. Each mole of beta subunit in the presence of EDTA bound 1 mol of ADP or ATP with Kd values of 25 microM and 50-100 microM, respectively. At a saturating concentration, aurovertin enhanced the affinity of ADP or ATP for the isolated beta subunit by 3-6-fold. The Kd values for the binding of ADP or ATP were also assessed through the enhancing effect of ADP on [14C]aurovertin binding (Issartel, J.-P., Klein, G., Satre, M., & Vignais, P.V. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 3485-3492); the Kd values determined by this approach were several times lower than in the absence of aurovertin, in agreement with results obtained by direct titration with radiolabeled ADP or ATP.     

Adenine nucleotide binding sites on beef heart F1-ATPase. Asymmetry and subunit location

Previously we have shown that beef heart mitochondrial F1 contains a total of six adenine nucleotide binding sites. Three "catalytic" sites exchange bound ligand rapidly during hydrolysis of MgATP, whereas three "noncatalytic" sites do not. The noncatalytic sites behave asymmetrically in that a single site releases bound ligand upon precipitation of F1 with ammonium sulfate. In the present study, we find this same site to be the only noncatalytic site that undergoes rapid exchange of bound ligand when F1 is incubated in the presence of EDTA at pH 8.0. Following 1000 catalytic turnovers/F1, the site retains the unique capacity for EDTA-induced exchange, indicating that the asymmetric determinants are permanent and that the three noncatalytic sites on soluble F1 do not pass through equivalent states during catalysis. Measurements of the rate of ligand binding at the unique noncatalytic site show that uncomplexed nucleotide binds preferentially. At pH 7.5, in the presence of Mg2+, the rate constant for ADP binding is 9 X 10(3) M-1 s-1 and for dissociation is 4 X 10(-4) s-1 to give a Kd = 50 nM. The rate of dissociation is 10 times faster in the presence of EDTA or during MgATP hydrolysis, and it increases rapidly at pH below 7. EDTA-induced exchange is inhibited by Mg2+, Mn2+, Co2+, and Zn2+ but not by Ca2+ and is unaffected by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide modification. The unique noncatalytic site binds 2-azido-ADP. Photolysis results in the labeling of the beta subunit. Photolabeling of a single high-affinity catalytic site under conditions for uni-site catalysis also results in the labeling of beta, but a different pattern of labeled peptides is obtained in proteolytic digests. The results demonstrate the presence of two different nucleotide binding domains on the beta subunit of mitochondrial F1.     

1H-NMR studies on nucleotide binding to the catalytic sites of bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase

The conformation of adenine nucleotides bound to bovine mitochondrial F1-ATPase was investigated using transfer nuclear Overhauser enhancement measurements. It is shown that all nucleotides investigated adopt a predominantly anti conformation when bound to the catalytic sites. Furthermore, the experiment suggests that 8-azido-ADP and 8-azido-ATP, which are predominantly in the syn conformation in solution, are in the anti conformation when bound to F1 catalytic sites.     

Adenine nucleotide binding sites on beef heart F1-ATPase. Specificity of cooperative interactions between catalytic sites

Cooperative interactions between nucleotide binding sites on beef heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase have been studied by measuring substrate-promoted release of 5'adenylyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate (AMP-PNP) from a single high affinity site. The site is initially loaded by incubating F1 with an equimolar amount of the nonhydrolyzable ATP analog. When unbound [3H]AMP-PNP is removed and the complex diluted to a concentration below the Kd, release of ligand shows an apparent absolute requirement for medium ADP. Release is biphasic with the extent of release during the initial rapid phase dependent on the concentration of medium ADP. Although phosphate alone has no effect, it enhances the rapid phase of ADP-promoted release over 2-fold with a half-maximal effect at 60 micrometers P1. The binding of efrapeptin (A23871) to the F1.AMP-PNP complex completely prevents ADP-promoted dissociation. Although AMP-PNP release also occurs in the presence of medium ATP, the F1.AMP-PNP complex does not dissociate if an ATP-regenerating system of sufficient capacity to prevent accumulation of medium ADP is added. Consistent with an inability of nucleoside triphosphate to promote release is the failure of medium, nonradioactive AMP-PNP to affect retention of the 3H-labeled ligand. The stability of F1.AMP-PNP complex in the absence of medium nucleotide and the highly specific ability of ADP plus P1 to promote rapid release of the ATP analog are interpreted as support for an ATP synthesis mechanism that requires substrate binding at one catalytic site for product release from an adjacent interacting site.     

Characterization of nucleotide binding sites of the isolated H(+)-ATPase from spinach chloroplasts, CF(0)F(1)

Soluble purified CF(0)F(1) from chloroplasts was either oxidized or reduced and then incubated with [alpha-(32)P]ATP in the presence or in the absence of Mg(2+). Depending on the conditions of incubation, the enzyme showed different tight-nucleotide binding sites. In the presence of EDTA, two sites bind [alpha-(32)P]ATP from the reaction medium at different rates. Both sites promote ATP hydrolysis, since equimolar amounts of [alpha-(32)P]ATP and [alpha-(32)P]ADP are bound to the enzyme. In the presence of Mg(2+), only one site appears during the first hour of incubation, with characteristics similar to those described in the absence of Mg(2+). However, after this time a third site appears also permitting binding of ATP from the reaction medium, but in this case the bound ATP is not hydrolyzed. Covalent derivatization by 2-azido-[alpha-(32)P]ATP was used to distinguish between catalytic and noncatalytic sites. In the presence of Mg(2+), there are at least three distinct nucleotide binding sites that bind nucleotide tightly from the reaction medium: two of them are catalytic and one is noncatalytic.     

Differentiation of two states of F1-ATPase by nucleotide analogs

The hydroperoxide-induced net release of Ca²⁺ from rat liver mitochondria is stimulated by the Ca²⁺ uptake inhibitor ruthenium red. At moderate Ca²⁺ loads the release takes place with preservation of a high mitochondrial membrane potential. During and after Ca²⁺ release mitochondria remain intact. The hydroperoxide-induced release of Ca²⁺ might therefore be a physiological relevance.     

Effect of the epsilon-subunit on nucleotide binding to Escherichia coli F1-ATPase catalytic sites.

The influence of the epsilon-subunit on the nucleotide binding affinities of the three catalytic sites of Escherichia coli F1-ATPase was investigated, using a genetically engineered Trp probe in the adenine-binding subdomain (beta-Trp-331). The interaction between epsilon and F1 was not affected by the mutation. Kd for binding of epsilon to betaY331W mutant F1 was approximately 1 nM, and epsilon inhibited ATPase activity by 90%. The only nucleotide binding affinities that showed significant differences in the epsilon-depleted and epsilon-replete forms of the enzyme were those for MgATP and MgADP at the high-affinity catalytic site 1. Kd1(MgATP) and Kd1(MgADP) were an order of magnitude higher in the absence of epsilon than in its presence. In contrast, the binding affinities for MgATP and MgADP at sites 2 and 3 were similar in the epsilon-depleted and epsilon-replete enzymes, as were the affinities at all three sites for free ATP and ADP. Comparison of MgATP binding and hydrolysis parameters showed that in the presence as well as the absence of epsilon, Km equals Kd3. Thus, in both cases, all three catalytic binding sites have to be occupied to obtain rapid (Vmax) MgATP hydrolysis rates.     

Synthesis and properties of azidonitrophenyl pyrophosphate, a photoaffinity probe of the nucleotide binding sites of mitochondrial F1-ATPase

4-Azido-2-nitrophenyl pyrophosphate (azido-PPi) labeled with 32P in the alpha position was prepared and used to photolabel beef heart mitochondrial F1. Azido-PPi was hydrolyzed by yeast inorganic pyrophosphatase, but not by mitochondrial F1-ATPase. Incubation of F1 with [alpha-32P]azido-PPi in the dark under conditions of saturation resulted in the binding of the photoprobe to three sites, two of which exhibited a high affinity (Kd = 2 microM), the third one having a lower affinity (Kd = 300 microM). Mg2+ was required for binding. As with PPi [Issartel et al. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 13538-13544], the binding of 3 mol of azido-PPi/mol of F1 resulted in the release of one tightly bound nucleotide. ADP, AMP-PNP, and PPi competed with azido-PPi for binding to F1, but Pi and the phosphate analogue azidonitrophenyl phosphate did not. The binding of [32P]Pi to F1 was enhanced at low concentrations of azido-PPi, as it was in the presence of low concentrations of PPi. Sulfite, which is thought to bind to an anion-binding site on F1, inhibited competitively the binding of both ADP and azido-PPi, suggesting that the postulated anion-binding site of F1 is related to the exchangeable nucleotide-binding sites. Upon photoirradiation of F1 in the presence of [alpha-32P]azido-PPi, the photoprobe became covalently bound with concomitant inactivation of F1. The plots relating the inactivation of F1 to the covalent binding of the probe were rectilinear up to 50% inactivation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Structural comparison of F1-ATPase: interplay among enzyme structures, catalysis, and rotations

F(1)-ATPase, a rotary motor powered by adenosine triphosphate hydrolysis, has been extensively studied by various methods. Here, we performed a systematic comparison of 29 X-ray crystal structures of F(1)-complexes, finding fine interplay among enzyme structures, catalysis, and rotations. First, analyzing the 87 structures of enzymatic αβ-subunits, we confirmed that the two modes, the hinge motion of β-subunit and the loose/tight motion of the αβ-interface, dominate the variations. The structural ensemble was nearly contiguous bridging three clusters, αβ(TP), αβ(DP), and αβ(E). Second, the catalytic site analysis suggested the correlation between the phosphate binding and the tightening of the αβ-interface. Third, addressing correlations of enzymatic structures with the orientations of the central stalk γ, we found that the γ rotation highly correlates with loosening of αβ(E)-interface and β(DP) hinge motions. Finally, calculating the helix 6 angle of β, we identified the recently observed partially closed conformation being consistent with β(HC).     

Azidonaphthoyl-ADP: a specific photolabel for the high-affinity nucleotide-binding sites of F1-ATPase

3'-O-[5-azidonaphthoyl]-ADP has been synthesized as a photoreactive analog to 3'-O-naphthoyl(1)-ADP which is known to bind to the high-affinity nucleotide sites of mitochondrial F1-ATPase, considered to be the catalytic sites. The photolabel in the dark acts as a ligand to F1-ATPase and as a competitive inhibitor with Ki = 11 microM. Binding to the enzyme is accompanied by a quench of endogenous protein fluorescence leveling off at an occupancy of 1 mol/mol F1, whereas the total number of reversible sites accessible to the analog is 3 mol/mol F1 as measured by isotope studies. Covalent insertion by near ultraviolet activation of the probe yields labeling of both alpha and beta polypeptides of F1; it is accompanied by corresponding removal of reversible high-affinity sites for ADP or naphthoyl-ADP and by an inhibition of the enzyme; total inactivation occurs at a covalent occupancy of 2 mol/mol F1. This is the maximum number of sites accessible to covalent modification by the label; one reversible site is still available in the totally inactivated enzyme. This observation is discussed in terms of a stochastic model requiring a minimum of two interacting catalytic domains out of three in order to commence catalysis.     

Novel approaches towards characterization of the high-affinity nucleotide binding sites on mitochondrial F1-ATPase by the fluorescence probes 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)adenosine di- and triphosphate

The fluorescence properties of 3'-O-(1-naphthoyl)adenosine di- and triphosphates (termed N-ADP and N-ATP, respectively) were investigated in detail. Of special importance for the use of these analogues as environmental probes is their high quantum yield (0.58 in water) and the polarity dependence of shape and wavelength position of the emission spectrum. Upon binding of N-ADP and N-ATP to mitochondrial F1-ATPase, the fluorescence intensity is markedly decreased, due to polarity changes and 'ground-state' quenching. Using this signal for equilibrium binding studies, three (at least a priori) equivalent nucleotide-binding sites were detected on the enzyme. The perspective intrinsic dissociation constants are as follows: N-ADP/Mg2+ 120 nM; N-ATP/Mg2+ 160 nM; N-ADP/EDTA 560 nM; N-ATP/EDTA 3500 nM. For bound ligand the environment was found to be rather unipolar; the rotational mobility of the fluorophore is restricted, its accessibility for iodide anions (as a quencher) is hindered. These facts show a location of the binding sites quite deeply embedded in the protein. The conformation of the binding domains is strongly dependent on the absence or presence of Mg2+, as can be seen from the relative efficiencies of the singlet-singlet energy transfer from tyrosine residues in the protein to bound naphthoyl moieties. Investigation of the binding kinetics revealed this process as biphasic (in presence of Mg2+). After the first fast step (kon greater than 1 X 10(6) M-1 X s-1), in which the analogue is bound to the enzyme, a slow local conformational rearrangement occurs.     

Tightly bound nucleotides affect phosphate binding to mitochondrial F1-ATPase

The interaction of inorganic phosphate with native and nucleotide-depleted F1-ATPase was studied. F1-ATPase depleted of tightly bound nucleotides loses the ability to bind inorganic phosphate. The addition of ATP, ADP, GTP and GDP but not AMP, restores the phosphate binding. The nucleotides affecting the phosphate binding to F1-ATPase are located at the catalytic (exchangeable) site of the enzyme. The phosphate is thought to bind to the same catalytic site where the nucleotide is already bound. It is thought that ADP is the first substrate to bind to F1-ATPase in the ATP synthesis reaction.     

Total number and differentiation of nucleotide binding sites on mitochondrial F1-ATPase. An approach by photolabeling and equilibrium binding studies

In this study 3'-O-[3-(4-azido-2-nitrophenyl)propionyl]-ADP was used as a photoaffinity analog for nucleotide binding sites on nucleotide-depleted F1-ATPase. Catalytic and binding properties of the labeled enzyme were investigated. The analog behaves as a competitive inhibitor in the dark (Ki = 50 microM). Photoirradiation of F1 in the presence of the analog leads to inactivation depending linearly on the incorporation of label. Complete inactivation is achieved at a stoichiometry of 3 mol/mol F1. The label is distributed between alpha and beta subunits in a ratio of 30%:70%. Although three sites were blocked covalently by photolabeling, three reversible sites of much higher affinity than the labeled sites were preserved. Mild alkaline treatment of photoinactivated enzyme leads to almost complete reactivation which is due to hydrolysis of the 3'-ester bond and release of the ADP moiety from the covalently bound analog. The conclusions drawn are as follows. The total number of sites which can be simultaneously occupied by nucleotides on F1 is six. Adopting the finding [Grubmeyer, C. & Penefsky, H. S. (1981) J. Biol. Chem. 256, 3718-3727] that the high-affinity sites are the catalytic ones which can be covalently labeled by 3'-O-[5-azidonaphthoyl(1)]-ADP [Lübben, M., Lücken, U., Weber, J. & Sch?fer, G. (1984) Eur. J. Biochem. 143, 483-490], it appears likely that azidonitrophenylpropionyl-ADP is a specific photolabel for the lower-affinity sites on nucleotide-depleted F1. This means that both types of sites can be differentiated by specific photoaffinity analogs. The labeled low-affinity sites interact with the catalytic sites, abolishing enzyme turnover, when steadily occupied by ADP kept in place by the covalently linking residue, which by itself has no inhibitory effect on the enzyme.