Common Molecular Mechanisms in Field- and Agrin-Induced Acetylcholine Receptor Clustering

1. The aggregation of acetylcholine receptors at the developing neuromuscular junction is critical to the development and function of this synapse. In vitro studies have shown that receptor aggregation can be induced by the finding of agrin to the muscle cell surface and by the electric field-induced concentration of a (nonreceptor) molecule at the cathodal cell pole.2. We report here on the interaction between agrin binding and electric fields with respect to the distribution of receptors and agrin binding sites.3. (a) Pretreatment of cells with agrin completely blocks the development of field-induced receptor clusters. (b) Field-induced aggregation of receptors precedes the field-induced aggregation of agrin binding sites by approximately 30min. (c) Electric fields prevent agrin-induced receptor clustering despite the presence of agrin binding sites and freely diffusing receptors.4. These results indicate that another membrane component—but not the agrin binding site and not the receptor—is required for agrin-induced receptor clustering. They also suggest that electric fields and agrin cause receptor clustering via common molecular mechanisms.     

Electrophoresis and diffusion in the plane of the cell membrane.

Electrophoretic and diffusional movements of concanavalin A (Con A) receptors and acetylcholine (ACh) receptors in the plane of the plasma membrane of mononucleate, spherical Xenopus myoblasts were studied by microfluorimetry and iontophoresis. We found that (a) a uniform electric field of 10 V/cm applied along the cell surface produces a partial accumulation of both types of receptors toward the cathodal pole of the cell within 30 min: (b) post-field relaxation of the culture results in the complete recovery of the uniform distribution of the Con A receptors within 10 min; and (c) in contrast to the Con A receptor in general, accumulation of ACh receptors by the electric field results in the formation of stable, localized receptor aggregates. Theoretical analyses were carried out for the distribution of charged membrane receptors at equilibrium between electrophoresis and diffusion, and for the rate of back diffusion after the removal of the field. These analyses indicated that, at 22 degrees C, the average electrophoretic mobility of the electrophoretically mobile population of the Con A receptors is about 1.9 X 10(-3) micron/s per V/cm, while their average diffusion coefficient is 5.1 X 10(-9) cm2/s.     

Acetylcholine receptor clustering is triggered by a change in the density of a nonreceptor molecule

Acetylcholine receptors become clustered at the neuromuscular junction during synaptogenesis, at least in part via lateral migration of diffusely expressed receptors. We have shown previously that electric fields initiate a specific receptor clustering event which is dependent on lateral migration in aneural muscle cell cultures (Stollberg, J., and S. E. Fraser. 1988. J. Cell Biol. 107:1397-1408). Subsequent work with this model system ruled out the possibility that the clustering event was triggered by increasing the receptor density beyond a critical threshold (Stollberg, J., and S. E. Fraser. 1990. J. Neurosci. 10:247-255). This leaves two possibilities: the clustering event could be triggered by the field-induced change in the density of some other molecule, or by a membrane voltage-sensitive mechanism (e.g., a voltage- gated calcium signal). Electromigration is a slow, linear process, while voltage-sensitive mechanisms respond in a rapid, nonlinear fashion. Because of this the two possibilities make different predictions about receptor clustering behavior in response to pulsed or alternating electric fields. In the present work we have studied subcellular calcium distributions, as well as receptor clustering, in response to such fields. Subcellular calcium distributions were quantified and found to be consistent with the predicted nonlinear response. Receptor clustering, however, behaves in accordance with the predictions of a linear response, consistent with the electromigration hypothesis. The experiments demonstrate that a local increase in calcium, or, more generally, a voltage-sensitive mechanism, is not sufficient and probably not necessary to trigger receptor clustering. Experiments with slowly alternating electric fields confirm the view that the clustering of acetylcholine receptors is initiated by a local change in the density of some non-receptor molecule.     

Interrelationship of concanavalin-A-binding and antigenic sites on the acetylcholine receptor from Torpedo marmorata

A preparation of purified 125I-labelled acetylcholine receptor was shown to bind to concanavalin A and to be totally bound by rabbit antiserum to Torpedo acetylcholine receptor. Pre-incubation of the receptor with F(ab')2 and Fab fragments from antibodies against Torpedo acetylcholine receptor, or with corresponding fragments from control immunoglobulin G showed that subsequent binding of the receptor to concanavalin A was specifically inhibited to a maximum of approximately 25% by the immune fragments. Treatment of acetylcholine receptor with periodate or with glycosidases apparently destroyed or removed carbohydrate residues without affecting the antigenicity of the receptor as assessed by radioimmunoassay. These results suggest that although there is a steric interrelatonship between the antigenic and concanavalin-A-binding sites of the receptor the latter sites do not contain its major antigenic determinants.     

Isologous Oxygen,Sulfur, and Selenium Compounds as Probes of Acetylcholine Receptors

Evidence is presented that while the conformations of acetylcholine and acetylthiolcholine are different, acetylthiolcholine and acetylselenolcholine are structurally and conformationally very similar. Experiments with sulfur and selenium isologs of acetylcholine, choline, and local anesthetics suggest that the active sites of receptors of the electroplax and of electric eel acetylcholinesterase are different, but are compatible with the postulate that acetylcholine receptors of axonal and synaptic excitable membranes are similar.     

CHOLINERGIC SITES IN SKELETAL MUSCLE: INTERACTION WITH CONCANAVALIN A

Abstract– The interaction of normal and denervated skeletal muscle cholinergic sites with the lectin concanavalin A and concanavalin A-Sepharose are detailed. Concanavalin A blocks the binding of ¹²⁵I-α-bungarotoxin to both the high and low affinity sets of cholinergic sites described previously. The characteristics of the block of ¹²⁵I-α-bungarotoxin binding to the high affinity set (acetylcholine receptor) is not competitive. The data suggest that the concanavalin binds multivalently to the macro-molecular complex containing the ACh receptor site and sterically prevents the α-bungarotoxin binding. The interaction of both sets of cholinergic sites with concanavalin A-Sepharose was also studied. The macromolecule(s) containing both the high and low affinity sets of sites bind to the concanavalin A-Sepharose. The data indicate a multivalent association with the affinity resin. Following the affinity procedure, a partial purification in both sets of sites is effected. The equilibrium binding of ¹²⁵I-diiodo-α-bungarotoxin to the preparations from the affinity procedure (both normal and denervated muscle) was examined. The K_D of the α-bungarotoxin binding to the high affinity sets of sites (acetylcholine receptor) in both normal and denervated preparations changes from ∼10⁻⁹mol/l to ∼ 10⁻¹⁰ mol/l following purification. No change in the K_D of the α-bungarotoxin binding to the low affinity set of sites was observed following purification. The ¹²⁵l-α-bungarotoxin binding to the partially purified acetylcholine receptor was blocked by unlabelled α-bungarotoxin, concanavalin A, d-tubocurarine and carbamylcholine.     

Cell shape-dependent rectification of surface receptor transport in a sinusoidal electric field.

In the presence of an extracellular electric field, transport dynamics of cell surface receptors represent a balance between electromigration and mutual diffusion. Because mutual diffusion is highly dependent on surface geometry, certain asymmetrical cell shapes effectively create an anisotropic resistance to receptor electromigration. If the resistance to receptor transport along a single axis is anisotropic, then an applied sinusoidal electric field will drive a net time-average receptor displacement, effectively rectifying receptor transport. To quantify the importance of this effect, a finite difference mathematical model was formulated and used to describe charged receptor transport in the plane of a plasma membrane. Representative values for receptor electromigration mobility and diffusivity were used. Model responses were examined for low frequency (10(-4)-10 Hz) 10-V/cm fields and compared with experimental measurements of receptor back-diffusion in human fibroblasts. It was found that receptor transport rectification behaved as a low-pass filter; at the tapered ends of cells, sinusoidal electric fields in the 10(-3) Hz frequency range caused a time-averaged accumulation of receptors as great as 2.5 times the initial uniform concentration. The extent of effective rectification of receptor transport was dependent on the rate of geometrical taper. Model studies also demonstrated that receptor crowding could alter transmembrane potential by an order of magnitude more than the transmembrane potential directly induced by the field. These studies suggest that cell shape is important in governing interactions between alternating current (ac) electric fields and cell surface receptors.     

Subunit structure and peptide mapping of junctional and extrajunctional acetylcholine receptors from rat muscle.

We have purified the junctional acetylcholine receptor from normal rat skeletal muscle and compared its structure with that of the extrajunctional receptor from denervated muscle. The two receptors from leg muscle were distinguished by isoelectric focusing and by reaction with sera from patients with myasthenia gravis. The junctional form of the acetylcholine receptor was purified from normal leg muscle by affinity chromatography on concanavalin A/Sepharose and cobrotoxin/Sepharose followed by sucrose gradient centrifugation. Analysis of radioiodinated receptor by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in sodium dodecyl sulfate indicated that the subunit structure of the junctional receptor was similar to that previously determined for the extra-junctional form (Froehner, S. C., et al. (1977) J. Biol. Chem. 252, 8589-8596), with major polypeptides, whose apparent molecular weights in 9% polyacrylamide gels were 45 000 and 51 000. In addition, several minor polypeptides were found. When the two receptors were labeled with different isotopes of iodine and run together on a sodium dodecyl sulfate gel, the subunits of one receptor could not be resolved from those of the other. As seen earlier with the extrajunctional form, the affinity alkylating reagent [3H]MBTA labeled the 45 000- and 49 000-dalton polypeptides of the junctional receptor. Peptide mapping showed that the two MBTA binding subunits are structurally related, although they are unrelated to the other polypeptides, and that the 45 000- and 51 000-dalton polypeptides of the junctional receptor were indistinguishable from those of the extrajunctional receptor. In addition, peptide mapping of the four subunits of acetylcholine receptor isolated from Torpedo californica electric organ showed that these four polypeptides appear to be structurally unrelated.     

Diverse pre- and post-synaptic expression of m1-m4 muscarinic receptor proteins in neurons and afferents in the rat neostriatum

We have utilized subtype specific antibodies to determine the cellular and subcellular distributions of the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor subtypes that are highly expressed in the rat striatum (m1-m4). Each receptor is expressed in distinct populations of striatal neurons in the relative proportions predicted by their mRNAs. They concentrate at post-synaptic sites and each of the four subtypes are also transported to pre-synaptic sites. m2 appears to be the only presynaptic autoreceptor in the striatum, but it is also localized in non-cholinergic terminals. These distinct pre- and post-synaptic localizations suggest that muscarinic receptor subtype diversity evolved to enable increasingly complex responses to acetylcholine release.     

The mechanism of agrin-induced acetylcholine receptor aggregation.

Agrin, a protein isolated from the synapse-rich electric organ of Torpedo californica, induces the formation of specializations on myotubes in culture which resemble the post-synaptic apparatus at the vertebrate skeletal neuromuscular junction. For example, the specializations contain aggregates of acetylcholine receptors and acetylcholinesterase. This report summarizes the evidence that the formation of the post-synaptic apparatus at developing and regenerating neuromuscular junctions is triggered by the release of agrin from motor axon terminals and describes results of recent experiments which suggest that agrin-induced tyrosine phosphorylation of the beta subunit of the acetylcholine receptor may play a role in receptor aggregation.     

Immunochemical similarities between subunits of acetylcholine receptors from Torpedo, Electrophorus, and mammalian muscle.

Polypeptide chains composing acetylcholine receptors from the electric organs of Torpedo californica and Electrophorus electricus were purified and labeled with 125I. Immunochemical studies with these labeled chains showed that receptor from Electrophorus is composed of three chains corresponding to the alpha, beta, and gamma chains of receptor from Torpedo but lacks a chain corresponding to the delta chain of Torpedo. Experiments suggest that receptor from mammalian muscle contains four groups of antigenic determinants corresponding to all four of the Torpedo chains. Binding of 125I-labeled chains was measured by quantitative immune precipitation and electrophoresis. Antisera to the following immunogens were used: denatured alpha, beta, gamma, and delta chains of Torpedo receptor, native receptor from Torpedo and Electrophorus electric organs and from rat and fetal calf muscle, and human muscle receptor (from autoantisera of patients with myasthenia gravis). The four chains of Torpedo receptor were immunologically distinct from one another and from higher molecular weight chains found in electric organ membranes. Antibodies to these chains reacted very efficiently with native Torpedo receptor, but the reverse was not true. Antibodies to native receptor from Torpedo and Electrophorus reacted slightly with each of the chains of the corresponding receptor. However, cross-reaction between chains and antibodies to any native receptor was most obviuos with the alpha chain of Torpedo or the corresponding alpha' chain of Electrophorus. Antiserum to alpha chains exhibited higher titer aginst receptor from denervated rat muscle. Antibodies from myasthenia gravis patients did not cross-react detectably with 125I-labeled chains from electric organ receptors. Most interspecies cross-reaction occurred at conformationally dependent determinants whose subunit localization could not be determined by reaction with the denatured chains.     

The putative agrin receptor binds ligand in a calcium-dependent manner and aggregates during agrin-induced acetylcholine receptor clustering.

Agrin derived from Torpedo electric organ induces the clustering of acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) on cultured myotubes. As a first step toward characterizing the plasma membrane receptor for agrin, we have examined agrin binding to cultured myotubes. Agrin binding is saturable as measured by radioimmunoassay and, like agrin-induced AChR clustering, requires extracellular calcium. Immunofluorescence shows that on myotubes incubated with agrin at 4 degrees C, agrin binds in a uniform, finely punctate pattern that correlates poorly with the distribution of AChRs. Myotubes stimulated with agrin at 37 degrees C for greater than or equal to 2 hr show a coclustering of agrin binding sites and AChRs. By contrast, if anti-AChR antibodies are used either to cluster or to internalize AChRs, the distribution and number of agrin binding sites remain unchanged. The aggregation and calcium dependence of the putative agrin receptor may represent important control points in postsynaptic differentiation.     

Localization of azidophencyclidine-binding site on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor alpha-subunit

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors in receptor-rich membranes from Torpedo californica and from T. marmorata electric tissue were photolabeled with the non-competitive inhibitor [3H]azidophencyclidine. The receptor subunits were separated on SDS-polyacrylamide gels and the alpha-subunits recovered from the gel, were subjected to Staphylococcus aureus V8 protease cleavage. The proteolytic fragments were resolved by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and were identified on protein blots by 125I-labeled alpha-bungarotoxin binding and by staining with concanavalin A. The site of specific azidophencyclidine labeling has been localized to the V8-18 kDa fragment which binds toxin. Labeling of the V8-18 kDa fragment was observed in the absence and in the presence of carbamylcholine. This was found for both the species of Torpedo used here.     

Control of acetylcholine receptor mobility and distribution in cultured muscle membranes. A fluorescence study

The molecular control of the distribution and motion of acetylcholine receptors in the plasma membrane of developing rat myotubes in primary cell culture was investigated by fluorescence techniques. Acetylcholine receptors were marked with tetramethylrhodamine-labeled α-bungarotoxin and lateral molecular motion in the membrane was measured by the fluorescence photobleaching recovery technique. Three types of experiments are discussed: (I) The effect of enzymatic cleavages, drugs, cross-linkers, and physiological alterations on the lateral motion of acetylcholine receptors and on the characteristic distribution of acetylcholine receptors into patch and diffuse areas. (II) Observation of the distribution and/or motion of fluorescence-labeled concanavalin A receptors, lipid probes, cell surface protein, and stained cholinesterase in acetylcholine receptor patch and diffuse areas. (III) The effect of a protein synthesis inhibitor and electrical stimulation on membrane incorporation of new acetylcholine receptors.Some of the main conclusions are: (a) acetylcholine receptor lateral motion is inhibited by concanavalin A plant lectin and by anti-α-bungarotoxin antibody, but marginally enhanced by treatment with a local anesthetic; (b) patches are stabilized by an immobile cellular structure consisting of molecules other than the acetylcholine receptors themselves; (c) this structure is highly selective for acetylcholine receptors and not for other cell membrane components; (d) acetylcholine receptor patch integrity and diffuse area motion are independent of direct metabolic energy requirements and are sensitive to electrical excitation of myotube; (e) lipid molecules can move laterally in both acetylcholine receptor patches and diffuse areas; and (f) acetylcholine receptor lateral motion in diffuse areas and immobility in patch areas are not altered by specific agents which are known to affect extrinsic cell surface proteins, or cytoplasmic microfilaments and microtubules.     

Purification and characterization of a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from chick brain

Immunohistochemical studies have previously shown that both the chick brain and chick ciliary ganglion neurons contain a component which shares antigenic determinants with the main immunogenic region of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from electric organ and skeletal muscle. Here we describe the purification and initial characterization of this putative neuronal acetylcholine receptor. The component was purified by monoclonal antibody affinity chromatography. The solubilized component sediments on sucrose gradients as a species slightly larger than Torpedo acetylcholine receptor monomers. It was affinity labeled with bromo[3H]acetylcholine. Labeling was prevented by carbachol, but not by alpha-bungarotoxin. Two subunits could be detected in the affinity-purified component, apparent molecular weights 48 000 and 59 000. The 48 000 molecular weight subunit was bound both by a monoclonal antibody directed against the main immunogenic region of electric organ and skeletal muscle acetylcholine receptor and by antisera raised against the alpha subunit of Torpedo receptor. Evidence suggests that there are two alpha subunits in the brain component. Antisera from rats immunized with the purified brain component exhibited little or no cross-reactivity with Torpedo electric organ or chick muscle acetylcholine receptor. One antiserum did, however, specifically bind to all four subunits of Torpedo receptor. Experiments to be described elsewhere (J. Stollberg et al., unpublished results) show that antisera to the purified brain component specifically inhibit the electrophysiological function of acetylcholine receptors in chick ciliary ganglion neurons without inhibiting the function of acetylcholine receptors in chick muscle cells. All of these properties suggest that this component is a neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptor with limited structural homology to muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor.     

Lectins implicate specific carbohydrate domains in electric field stimulated nerve growth and guidance

Both endogenous lectins and DC electric fields may control aspects of early nerve growth and nerve guidance. To test whether such endogenous cues interact, lectins of varying sugar affinity and valency were studied for effects on electric field induced growth and reorientation of cultured Xenopus neurites. Concanavalin A (Con A), succinylated concanavalin A (S-Con A), and wheat germ agglutinin all completely inhibited field-induced cathodal reorientation. Lentil and pea lectins, which share the same sugar affinity as Con A/S-Con A, were only partially effective in inhibiting reorientation. Because S-Con A does not alter lateral mobility of membrane receptors, the previously accepted notion that Con A inhibited field-induced reorientation by preventing receptors from translocating and becoming redistributed asymmetrically in the membrane may be oversimplified. There are likely to be additional steric interactions that Con A and S-Con A share that inactive asymmetrically redistributed receptors and prevent reorientation. Additionally, nerves growing in an applied field branch more commonly toward the cathode. Con A and S-Con A alone prevented this development of asymmetric branching. All the lectins tested prevented the normal field-induced increase in nerve growth rate, while all, except peanut agglutinin, prevented the usual faster growth cathodally than anodally. We suggest that lectin interactions with electric field effects in vitro may involve modulation of neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, neurotrophin receptors, or voltage-dependent calcium channels. Similar interactions between endogenous lectins and endogenous electric fields are to be expected. © 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Phosphorylation of ligand-gated ion channels: a possible mode of synaptic plasticity.

Most neurotransmitter receptors examined to date have been shown either to be regulated by protein phosphorylation or to contain consensus sequences for phosphorylation by protein kinases. Neurotransmitter receptors that mediate rapid synaptic transmission in the nervous system are the ligand-gated ion channels and include the nicotinic acetylcholine receptors of muscle and nerve and the excitatory and inhibitory amino acid receptors: the glutamate, GABAA, and glycine receptors. These receptors are multimeric proteins composed of homologous subunits which each span the membrane several times and contain a large intracellular loop that is a mosaic of consensus sites for protein phosphorylation. Recent evidence has suggested that extracellular signals released from the presynaptic neuron, such as neurotransmitters and neuropeptides as well as an extracellular matrix protein, regulate the phosphorylation of ligand-gated ion channels. The functional effects of phosphorylation are varied and include the regulation of receptor desensitization rate, subunit assembly, and receptor aggregation at the synapse. These results suggest that phosphorylation of neurotransmitter receptors represents a major mechanism in the regulation of their function and may play an important role in synaptic plasticity.     

Development of the electromotor system of Torpedo marmorata: Distribution of extracellular matrix and cytoskeletal components during acetylcholine receptor focalization

Summary A combination of direct fluorescence and indirect immunofluorescence microscopy has been used to compare the distribution of the acetylcholine receptor with the distribution of major cytoskeletal and extracellular matrix components during electrocyte differentiation in the electric organs of Torpedo marmorata. Laminin, fibronectin and extracellular matrix proteoglycan are always more extensively distributed around the differentiating cell than the acetylcholine receptor-rich patch that forms on the ventral surface of the cell. The distribution of acetylcholinesterase within the ventral surface of the differentiating electrocyte closely resembles the distribution of the acetylcholine receptor. Areas of apparently high acetylcholine receptor density within the ventrally forming acetylcholine receptor-rich patch are always areas of apparently high extracellular matrix proteoglycan density but are not always areas of high laminin or fibronectin density. Desmin levels appear to increase at the onset of differentiation and desmin initially accumulates in the ventral pole of each myotube as it begins to form an electrocyte. During differentiation F-actin-positive filament bundles are observed that extend from the nuclei down to the ventrally forming acetylcholine receptorrich patch. Most filament bundles terminate in the acetylcholine receptor-rich region of the cell membrane. Electronmicroscopic autoradiography suggests that the filament bundles attach to the membrane at sites where small acetylcholine receptor clusters are found. The results of this study suggest that, out of the four extracellular matrix components studied, only the distribution of acetylcholinesterase (which may be both matrix- and membrane-bound at this stage) closely parallels that of the acetylcholine receptor, and that F-actin filament bundles terminate in a region of the cell that is becoming an area of high acetylcholine receptor density.Abbreviations ACHR nicotinic acetylcholine receptor - ACHE acetylcholinesterase - BSA bovine serum albumin - EMPG extracellular matrix proteoglycan fraction - FITC fluorescein isothiocyanate - FN fibronectin - LN laminin - TBS Tris-HCl-buffered saline - SDS PAGE sodium dodecyl sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis     

Mechanism of agrin-induced acetylcholine receptor aggregation.

Agrin induces the formation of specializations on chick myotubes in culture at which several components of the postsynaptic apparatus accumulate, including acetylcholine receptors (AChRs). Agrin also induces AChR phosphorylation. Several lines of evidence suggest that agrin-induced phosphorylation of tyrosine residues in the beta subunit of the AChR is an early step in receptor aggregation: agrin-induced phosphorylation and aggregation have the same dose dependence; treatments that prevent aggregation block phosphorylation; phosphorylation begins before any detectable change in receptor distribution, reaches a maximum hours before aggregation is complete, and declines slowly together with the disappearance of aggregates after agrin is withdrawn; agrin slows the rate at which receptors are solubilized from intact myotubes by detergent extraction; and the change in receptor extractability parallels the change in phosphorylation. A model for agrin-induced AChR aggregation is presented in which phosphorylation of AChRs by an agrin-activated protein tyrosine kinase causes receptors to become attached to the cytoskeleton, which reduces their mobility and detergent extractability, and leads to the accumulation of receptors in the vicinity of the activated kinase, forming an aggregate.     

Cloning and Expression of a G Protein-Linked Acetylcholine Receptor from Caenorhabditis elegans

Abstract : We have isolated a cDNA clone from the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans that encodes a protein of greatest sequence similarity to muscarinic acetylcholine receptors. This gene codes for a polypeptide of 682 amino acids containing seven putative transmembrane domains. The amino acid identities, excluding a highly variable middle portion of the third intracellular loop, to the human m1-m5 receptors are 28-34%. When this cloned receptor was coexpressed with a G protein-gated inwardly rectifying K⁺ channel (GIRK1) in Xenopus oocyte, acetylcholine was able to elicit the GIRK current. This acetylcholine-induced current was substantially inhibited by the muscarinic antagonist atropine in a reversible manner. However, another muscarinic agonist oxotremorine and antagonists scopolamine and pirenzepine had little or negligible effects on this receptor. Taken together, these results suggest that the cloned gene encodes a G protein-linked acetylcholine receptor that is most similar to but pharmacologically distinct from muscarinic acetylcholine receptors.