Assessing the role of the T cell receptor beta gene enhancer in regulating coding joint formation during V(D)J recombination

To assess the role of the T cell receptor (TCR) beta gene enhancer (Ebeta) in regulating the processing of VDJ recombinase-generated coding ends, we assayed TCRbeta rearrangement of Ebeta-deleted (DeltaEbeta) thymocytes in which cell death is inhibited via expression of a Bcl-2 transgene. Compared with DeltaEbeta, DeltaEbeta Bcl-2 thymocytes show a small accumulation of TCRbeta standard recombination products, including coding ends, that involves the proximal Dbeta-Jbeta and Vbeta14 loci but not the distal 5' Vbeta genes. These effects are detectable in double negative pro-T cells, predominate in double positive pre-T cells, and correlate with regional changes in chromosomal structure during double negative-to-double positive differentiation. We propose that Ebeta, by driving long range nucleoprotein interactions and the control of locus expression and chromatin structure, indirectly contributes to the stabilization of coding ends within the recombination processing complexes. The results also illustrate Ebeta-dependent and -independent changes in chromosomal structure, suggesting distinct modes of regulation of TCRbeta allelic exclusion depending on the position within the locus.     

A change in the structure of Vbeta chromatin associated with TCR beta allelic exclusion

To investigate chromatin control of TCR beta rearrangement and allelic exclusion, we analyzed TCR beta chromatin structure in double negative (DN) thymocytes, which are permissive for TCR beta recombination, and in double positive (DP) thymocytes, which are postallelic exclusion and nonpermissive for Vbeta to DbetaJbeta recombination. Histone acetylation mapping and DNase I sensitivity studies indicate Vbeta and DbetaJbeta segments to be hyperacetylated and accessible in DN thymocytes. However, they are separated from each other by hypoacetylated and inaccessible trypsinogen chromatin. The transition from DN to DP is accompanied by selective down-regulation of Vbeta acetylation and accessibility. The level of DP acetylation and accessibility is minimal for five of six Vbeta segments studied but remains substantial for one. Hence, the observed changes in Vbeta chromatin structure appear sufficient to account for allelic exclusion of many Vbeta segments. They may contribute to, but not by themselves fully account for, allelic exclusion of others.     

Productive coupling of accessible Vbeta14 segments and DJbeta complexes determines the frequency of Vbeta14 rearrangement

To elucidate mechanisms that regulate Vbeta rearrangement, we generated and analyzed mice with a V(D)J recombination reporter cassette of germline Dbeta-Jbeta segments inserted into the endogenous Vbeta14 locus (Vbeta14(Rep)). As a control, we first generated and analyzed mice with the same Dbeta-Jbeta cassette targeted into the generally expressed c-myc locus (c-myc(Rep)). Substantial c-myc(Rep) recombination occurred in both T and B cells and initiated concurrently with endogenous Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangements in thymocytes. In contrast, Vbeta14(Rep) recombination was restricted to T cells and initiated after endogenous Dbeta to Jbeta rearrangements, but concurrently with endogenous Vbeta14 rearrangements. Thus, the local chromatin environment imparts lineage and developmental stage-specific accessibility upon the inserted reporter. Although Vbeta14 rearrangements occur on only 5% of endogenous TCRbeta alleles, the Vbeta14(Rep) cassette underwent rearrangement on 80-90% of alleles, supporting the suggestion that productive coupling of accessible Vbeta14 segments and DJbeta complexes influence the frequency of Vbeta14 rearrangements. Strikingly, Vbeta14(Rep) recombination also occurs on TCRbeta alleles lacking endogenous Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangements, indicating that Vbeta14 accessibility per se is not subject to allelic exclusion.     

Inhibition of T-cell receptor beta-chain gene rearrangement by overexpression of the non-receptor protein tyrosine kinase p56lck.

The variable region genes of the T cell receptor (TCR) alpha and beta chains are assembled by somatic recombination of separate germline elements. During thymocyte development, gene rearrangements display both an ordered progression, with beta chain formation preceding alpha chain, and allelic exclusion, with each cell containing a single functional beta chain rearrangement. Although considerable evidence supports the view that the individual loci are regulated independently, signaling molecules that may participate in controlling TCR gene recombination remain unidentified. Here we report that the lymphocyte-specific protein tyrosine kinase p56lck, when overexpressed in developing thymocytes, provokes a reduction in V beta--D beta rearrangement while permitting normal juxtaposition of other TCR gene segments. Our data support a model in which p56lck activity impinges upon a signaling process that ordinarily permits allelic exclusion at the beta-chain locus.     

Allelic exclusion of a T cell receptor-beta minilocus.

A TCR-beta minilocus in germline configuration (beta M) has previously been shown to undergo rearrangement and expression in transgenic mice. To study allelic exclusion of TCR miniloci, several beta M transgenic mouse lines were generated and crossed with mice transgenic for a functionally rearranged TCR V beta 2 gene (beta R). PCR analysis of beta M beta R double transgenic mice revealed almost complete suppression of endogenous TCR V beta gene rearrangements, but blockage of minilocus V beta rearrangements was achieved with only one of five minilocus transgenic lines. This result cannot be explained by copy number or arrangement of the multiple miniloci integrated. It appears that the minilocus is not autonomously regulated which suggests that sequences flanking the integration sites influence accessibility of the minilocus for rearrangement and allelic exclusion. However, although productively rearranged genes were formed in double transgenic mice, surface expression of minilocus-encoded beta chains was not detected. This indicates that allelic exclusion may operate at a level after gene rearrangement.     

Receptor revision in peripheral T cells creates a diverse V beta repertoire

In Vbeta5 transgenic mice, the age-dependent accumulation of Vbeta5(-)CD4(+) T cells expressing endogenous Vss elements represents an exception to the rule of strict allelic exclusion at the TCRbeta locus. The appearance of these cells is limited to the lymphoid periphery and is driven by a peripherally expressed tolerogen. Expression of the lymphoid-specific components of the recombinase machinery and the presence of recombination intermediates strongly suggest that TCR revision rescues tolerogen-reactive peripheral T cells from deletion. Here, we report that the appearance of Vbeta5(-)CD4(+) T cells is CD28-dependent. In addition, we find that the TCR repertoire of this unusual population of T cells in individual Vbeta5 transgenic mice is surprisingly diverse, both at the level of surface protein and at the nucleotide level within a given family of V(D)Jbeta rearrangements. This faithful recreation of the nontransgenic repertoire suggests that endogenous Vbeta-expressing populations do not arise from expansion of an initially rare subset. Furthermore, the undersized N regions in revised TCR genes distinguish these sequences from those generated in the adult thymus. The diversity of the revised TCRs, the minimal mouse-to-mouse variation in the expressed endogenous Vbeta repertoire, the atypical length of junctional sequences, and the CD28 dependence of the accumulation of Vbeta5(-)CD4(+) T cells all point to their extrathymic origin. Thus, tolerogen-driven receptor revision in peripheral T cells can expand the TCR repertoire extrathymically, thereby contributing to the flexibility of the immune repertoire.     

A role for MAPK in feedback inhibition of Tcrb recombination

The Tcrb locus is subject to a host of regulatory mechanisms that impart a strict cell and developmental stage-specific order to variable (V), diversity (D), and joining (J) gene segment recombination. The Tcrb locus is also regulated by allelic exclusion mechanisms, which restrict functional rearrangements to a single allele. The production of a functional rearrangement in CD4-CD8- double-negative (DN) thymocytes leads to the assembly of a pre-TCR and initiates signaling cascades that allow for DN to CD4+CD8+ double-positive (DP) differentiation, proliferation, and feedback inhibition of further Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangement. Feedback inhibition is believed to be controlled, in part, by the loss of Vbeta gene segment accessibility during the DN to DP transition. However, the pre-TCR signaling pathways that lead to the inactivation of Vbeta chromatin have not been determined. Because activation of the MAPK pathway is documented to promote DP differentiation in the absence of allelic exclusion, we characterized the properties of Vbeta chromatin within DP thymocytes generated by a constitutively active Raf1 (Raf-CAAX) transgene. Consistent with previous reports, we show that the Raf-CAAX transgene does not inhibit Tcrb recombination in DN thymocytes. Nevertheless, DP thymocytes generated by Raf-CAAX signals display normal down-regulation of Vbeta segment accessibility and normal feedback inhibition of the Vbeta to DJbeta rearrangement. Therefore, our results emphasize the distinct requirements for feedback inhibition in the DN and DP compartments. Although MAPK activation cannot impose feedback in DN thymocytes, it contributes to feedback inhibition through developmental changes that are tightly linked to DN to DP differentiation.     

Characterization of TCR gene rearrangements during adult murine T cell development

Development of the alphabeta and gammadelta T cell lineages is dependent upon the rearrangement and expression of the TCRalpha and beta or gamma and delta genes, respectively. Although the timing and sequence of rearrangements of the TCRalpha and TCRbeta loci in adult murine thymic precursors has been characterized, no similar information is available for the TCRgamma and TCRdelta loci. In this report, we show that approximately half of the total TCRdelta alleles initiate rearrangements at the CD44highCD25+ stage, whereas the TCRbeta locus is mainly in germline configuration. In the subsequent CD44lowCD25+ stage, most TCRdelta alleles are fully recombined, whereas TCRbeta rearrangements are only complete on 10-30% of alleles. These results indicate that rearrangement at the TCRdelta locus can precede that of TCRbeta locus recombination by one developmental stage. In addition, we find a bias toward productive rearrangements of both TCRdelta and TCRgamma genes among CD44highCD25+ thymocytes, suggesting that functional gammadelta TCR complexes can be formed before the rearrangement of TCRbeta. These data support a model of lineage commitment in which sequential TCR gene rearrangements may influence alphabeta/gammadelta lineage decisions. Further, because TCR gene rearrangements are generally limited to T lineage cells, these analyses provide molecular evidence that irreversible commitment to the T lineage can occur as early as the CD44highCD25+ stage of development.     

Regulation of TCRβ allelic exclusion by gene segment proximity and accessibility

Ag receptor loci are regulated to promote allelic exclusion, but the mechanisms are not well understood. Assembly of a functional TCR β-chain gene triggers feedback inhibition of V(β)-to-DJ(β) recombination in double-positive (DP) thymocytes, which correlates with reduced V(β) chromatin accessibility and a locus conformational change that separates V(β) from DJ(β) gene segments. We previously generated a Tcrb allele that maintained V(β) accessibility but was still subject to feedback inhibition in DP thymocytes. We have now further analyzed the contributions of chromatin accessibility and locus conformation to feedback inhibition using two novel TCR alleles. We show that reduced V(β) accessibility and increased distance between V(β) and DJ(β) gene segments both enforce feedback inhibition in DP thymocytes.     

Human alpha beta and gamma delta thymocyte development: TCR gene rearrangements, intracellular TCR beta expression, and gamma delta developmental potential--differences between men and mice

To evaluate the role of the TCR in the alphabeta/gammadelta lineage choice during human thymocyte development, molecular analyses of the TCRbeta locus in gammadelta cells and the TCRgamma and delta loci in alphabeta cells were undertaken. TCRbeta variable gene segments remained largely in germline configuration in gammadelta cells, indicating that commitment to the gammadelta lineage occurred before complete TCRbeta rearrangements in most cases. The few TCRbeta rearrangements detected were primarily out-of-frame, suggesting that productive TCRbeta rearrangements diverted cells away from the gammadelta lineage. In contrast, in alphabeta cells, the TCRgamma locus was almost completely rearranged with a random productivity profile; the TCRdelta locus contained primarily nonproductive rearrangements. Productive gamma rearrangements were, however, depleted compared with preselected cells. Productive TCRgamma and delta rearrangements rarely occurred in the same cell, suggesting that alphabeta cells developed from cells unable to produce a functional gammadelta TCR. Intracellular TCRbeta expression correlated with the up-regulation of CD4 and concomitant down-regulation of CD34, and plateaued at the early double positive stage. Surprisingly, however, some early double positive thymocytes retained gammadelta potential in culture. We present a model for human thymopoiesis which includes gammadelta development as a default pathway, an instructional role for the TCR in the alphabeta/gammadelta lineage choice, and a prolonged developmental window for beta selection and gammadelta lineage commitment. Aspects that differ from the mouse are the status of TCR gene rearrangements at the nonexpressed loci, the timing of beta selection, and maintenance of gammadelta potential through the early double positive stage of development.