Response of Guanosine 5′-Triphosphate Concentration to Nutritional Changes and Its Significance for Bacillus subtilis Sporulation

We have investigated the changes in the guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) and P-ribosyl-PP pools in stringent and relaxed strains of Bacillus subtilis under conditions frequently used to initiate sporulation. After a shift-down from a Casamino Acids-glutamate to a glutamate medium (Sterlini-Mandelstam shift-down), the pools of adenosine 5'-triphosphate and P-ribosyl-PP increased in both strains; in the stringent strain, ppGpp and pppGpp increased and GTP decreased rapidly, whereas in the relaxed strain, ppGpp and pppGpp increased only slightly and GTP decreased only slowly and less extensively. The stringent strain sporulated well, whereas the relaxed strain sporulated late and poorly. Addition of decoyinine, an inhibitor of guanosine 5'-monophosphate synthetase, caused a further decrease of GTP and initiated good sporulation of the relaxed strain. After a shift-down from a glucose-lactate to a lactate medium (Ramaley-Burden shift-down) the pool of P-ribosyl-PP (and GTP) decreased in both strains, indicating a shortage of purine precursors. This shift-down also caused a stringent response which prevented the consumption of nucleotides, as shown by the maintenance of adenosine 5'-triphosphate at a high concentration in the stringent strain but not in the relaxed strain. After a delay, the relaxed strain, in which GTP decreased as fast as in the stringent strain, sporulated also as efficiently. In nutrient sporulation medium the stringent strain and, less effectively, the relaxed strain accumulated ppGpp and pppGpp transiently towards the end of exponential growth. Eventually, the P-ribosyl-PP pool decreased drastically in both strains. In all cases the initiation of sporulation was correlated with a significant decrease of GTP. Granaticin, an antibiotic which prevents the charging of leucyl-transfer ribonucleic acid, was used to show that the stringent response inhibited the formation of xanthosine monophosphate from inosine monophosphate. It prevented the accumulation of xanthosine monophosphate in decoyinine-treated cultures of the stringent strain but not in those of the relaxed strain.     

The relationship between translational initiation and messenger RNA inactivation in down-shifted Escherichia coli

The parameters of protein synthesis and functional inactivation of global messenger RNA (mRNA) were examined in a Tic+ strain of Escherichia coli during the 30-min period following a shift-down from glucose-minimal to succinate-minimal medium. The rate of mRNA inactivation and the relative translational initiation frequency were both most severely depressed immediately after the shift-down and increased slowly thereafter. If glucose was restored to the medium at any time after shift-down, mRNA inactivation immediately resumed its normal (preshift) rate and the protein-forming capacity was increased. These changes in mRNA inactivation rate do not reflect an altered mRNA composition in the down-shifted cells. The relative rate of mRNA inactivation was linearly proportional to the relative translational initiation frequency over a 10-fold range of initiation frequencies. Low initiation frequencies represent increased "dwell" of the ribosomes at the initiation site before the commencement of polypeptide chain initiation. We propose that initiating ribosomes protect mRNA from an inactivating endonucleolytic cleavage at or near the ribosome binding site.     

Control of protein synthesis in Escherichia coli: Lack of correlation with changes in intracellular pools of ATP,GTP, and ppGpp

Intracellular pools of ATP, GTP, and ppGpp have been measured in Escherichia coli after an energy source shift-down from glucose minimal to succinate-minimal medium. In a Tic⁺ strain (ATCC 10798), which reduces translational initiation after the down-shift, the rate of protein labeling falls to about 30% of its preshift rate within the first minute after shift and reaches a minimum of 17% by 6 min after shift. The ATP pool in this strain remains constant for about 10 min after shift, then declines gradually to about 60% of its initial level. The temporal discrepancy between protein synthesis and the decline in the ATP pool indicates that a decrease in intracellular ATP is not necessary for the control of protein synthesis. In a Tic^? strain (W1), which cannot control translational initiation under these conditions, the decline in the ATP pool is somewhat more rapid and more pronounced (to 40%) than in the Tic⁺ strain, indicating that the decline in the ATP pool is not sufficient to trigger control of translational initiation. The intracellular GTP pool in the Tic⁺ strain remains constant for 2 min after shift, then declines gradually to reach a minimum of 45% of its initial level at 20 min after shift. The pattern is in general similar in the the Tic^? strain, although the ultimate decline in GTP is more pronounced (to 29%). These data indicate that the decline in GTP is not sufficient and probably unnecessary to elicit control of translational initiation. Intracellular levels of ppGpp increase with very similar kinetics in relA⁺Tic⁺ (ATCC 10798) and relA⁺Tic^? (W1) strains, indicating that elevated ppGpp levels are not sufficient to elicit control of translation. In a relA^?Tic⁺ strain (NF162), or in a relA⁺Tic⁺ strain treated with rifampin, the ppGpp pool does not increase significantly after shift-down although translational initiation is reduced. Thus, an increase in the ppGpp pool is not necessary to control of translational initiation.     

Polysome stability in relaxed and stringent strain of Escherichia coli during amino acid starvation

The influence of amino acid starvation on polysome content was examined in relaxed and stringent strains of Escherichia coli which were isogenic for the RC locus. No difference was observed between the polysome profiles obtained from two different sets of stringent and relaxed strains starved for the same amino acid. In both relaxed and stringent strains, starvation for amino acids other than methionine resulted in only a slight breakdown of polysomes with a concomitant increase of 70S ribosomes. However, starvation for methionine in both RC stringent and relaxed strains of E. coli resulted in a more extensive degradation of polysomes and accumulation of 70S ribosomes. The 70S ribosomes obtained as a result of methionine starvation were more sensitive to degradation to 50 and 30S subunits in 10(-3)m Mg(2+) than 70S monomers obtained either by degradation of polysomes with ribonuclease or by starvation of cells for amino acids other than methionine. The 70S ribosomes from methionine starvation were similar (sensitivity to 10(-3)m Mg(2+)) to 70S ribosomes obtained from cells in which initiation of protein synthesis had been prevented by trimethoprim, an inhibitor of formylation. Since N-formyl-methionyl-transfer ribonucleic acid is required for initiation, the 70S ribosomes obtained in both methionine-starved and trimethoprim-treated cells must result from association of 50 and 30S subunits for reasons other than reinitiation. These results suggest that the level of ribonucleic acid synthesis does not influence the distribution of ribosomes in the polysome profile and vice versa.     

Ribonucleic Acid Regulation in Amino Acid-Limited Cultures of Escherichia coli Grown in a Chemostat

The regulation of ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis was examined in cultures of bacteria whose growth was limited in the chemostat by the supply of a required amino acid. Strains possessing the relaxed (relA) mutation accumulated excess RNA (relative to protein) at low growth rates when growth was limited by arginine, histidine, or cysteine but not when limited by methionine. In contrast, stringent (relA(+)) strains maintained a constant RNA/protein ratio with decreasing growth rate regardless of the amino acid used to limit growth. The presence of excess RNA in relaxed strains was accompanied by an absence of increase in RNA production upon addition of chloramphenicol, a lag upon shift-up in growth by addition of excess of the limiting amino acid, and a decreased rate of production of beta-galactosidase upon induction. Analysis of the RNA accumulated in relaxed strains indicated it was present as transfer RNA as well as 50S and 30S ribosomal subunits. Microscope examination of the relaxed strains during histidine-, arginine-, or cysteine-limited growth in the chemostat showed them to be 10 to 20 times longer in size than the stringent strains. Also, cell density was reduced to one-tenth when the increased size was observed. An analysis of the amount of ppGpp present in all slow-growing amino acid-limited cultures (relaxed and stringent) demonstrated that only basal levels of ppGpp were made. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that when growth is limited in the chemostat by an initiation event in protein synthesis, i.e., limited methionine, RNA regulation occurs in relaxed as well as stringent strains. Also, when other amino acids are limiting in concentration during translation, errors occur in relaxed strains, resulting in misread proteins.     

Studies on the turnover of endogenous choline-containing phospholipids of cultured neuroblastoma cells

The effects of two polypeptide antibiotics, polymixin B and gramicidin S, on the intracellular pool size and turnover of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) were analyzed in stringent (relA+) and relaxed (relA) strains of Escherichia coli. When either one of these two drugs was added to stringent bacteria cultures at a final concentration that blocked protein and RNA synthesis, ppGpp was found to accumulate. Under similar conditions of inhibition of macromolecular synthesis, ppGpp also appeared to accumulate in relaxed bacteria. Moreover, in either type of strain, no significant accumulation of guanosine pentaphosphate (pppGpp) could be detected upon drug treatment. It was, therefore, concluded that polymixin and gramicidin elicit ppGpp accumulation through a mechanism independent of the relA gene product and, consequently, quite distinct from the stringent control system triggered by amino acid starvation. Further experiments performed by using tetracycline as an inhibitor of ppGpp synthesis, showed that the increase in the level of this nucleotide induced by drug action was due, in fact, to a strong restriction of its degradation rate.     

Identification of a Precursor Pool of Ribosome Protein in Escherichia coli

Antibodies prepared against proteins from 50S ribosomes of Escherichia coli also reacted with the supernatant proteins of a cell-free extract of E. coli which was ribosome-free. A reaction of immunological identity (Ouchterlony tests) was demonstrated for one of these supernatant proteins and one protein found in 50S ribosomes. Isotope experiments involving a shift from (14)C-leucine medium to (12)C-leucine medium showed that these proteins are not formed by breakdown of ribosomes during the preparation of cell-free extracts, but instead represent a pool of ribosome protein which is utilized during growth. In shift experiments from (14)C-leucine to (12)C-leucine medium, the kinetics of disappearance of labeled supernatant ribosome proteins (as measured by reaction with antibody) indicated that half the pool is depleted in 0.1 generation time at 37 C in glucose-salts medium. The pool was also depleted under conditions of amino acid starvation of a "relaxed" strain which accumulated "relaxed" particles. Most, if not all, of the protein present in "relaxed" particles was derived from the pool. The pool represented about 3 to 4% of the total soluble proteins in the ribosome-free supernatant fluid of an E. coli extract.     

Control of protein synthesis in Escherichia coli: control of bacteriophage Q beta coat protein synthesis after energy source shift-down.

Escherichia coli Q13 was infected with bacteriophage Q beta and subjected to energy source shift-down (from glucose-minimal to succinate-minimal medium) 20 min after infection. Production of progeny phage was about fourfold slower in down-shifted cultures than in the cultures in glucose medium. Shift-down did not affect the rate of phage RNA replication, as measured by the rate of incorporation of [14C]uracil in the presence of rifampin, with appropriate correction for the reduced entry of exogenous uracil into the UTP pool. Phage coat protein synthesis was three- to sixfold slower in down-shifted cells than in exponentially growing cells, as determined by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. The polypeptide chain propagation rate in infected cells was unaffected by the down-shift. Thus, the reduced production of progeny phage in down-shifted cells appears to result from control of phage protein synthesis at the level of initiation of translation. The reduction in the rate of Q beta coat protein synthesis is comparable to the previously described reduction in the rate of synthesis of total E. coli protein and of beta-galactosidase, implying that the mechanism which inhibits translation in down-shifted cells is neither messenger specific nor specific for 5' proximal cistrons. The intracellular ATP pool size was nearly constant after shift-down; general energy depletion is thus not a predominant factor. The GTP pool, by contrast, declined by about 40%. Also, ppGpp did not accumulate in down-shifted, infected cells in the presence of rifampin, indicating that ppGpp is not the primary effector of this translational inhibition.     

Inhibition of lacZ Gene Translation Initiation in trp-lac Fusion Strains

Different levels of beta-galactosidase are found in various trp-lac fusion strains. These levels of beta-galactosidase fall within a 60-fold range. The amount of thiogalactoside transacetylase activity detected in these same strains only varies 10-fold and is found in amounts greater than those predicted from the beta-galactosidase levels. The observation that the beta-galactosidase and thiogalactoside transacetylase levels are not directly proportional, that the lacZ messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) levels are not proportional to the beta-galactosidase activity, that, at least for the one fusion strain tested, the SuA polarity suppressor does not affect the beta-galactosidase level, and that, in all but one strain, the beta-galactosidase activity appears to reside in normal beta-galactosidase molecules suggests that the disproportionately low production of beta-galactosidase is due to a decrease in the frequency of translation initiation of lacZ mRNA in these strains. Several mechanisms are proposed to explain this decrease. Some possible bases for the disproportional production of beta-galactosidase and thiogalactoside transacetylase are also described. The preferred explanation for these disproportional enzyme levels is that only a fraction of the full complement of ribosomes need initiate translation at lacZ for the functional synthesis of lac mRNA to occur and that once the lac ribonucleic acid is made a full complement of ribosomes can bind at internal translation initiation sites at Y and A.     

Turnover as a control of ribonucleic acid accumulation in bacteria undergoing stepdown.

The synthesis of ribosomes was compared in rel+ and rel- strains of Escherichia coli undergoing "stepdown" in growth from glucose medium to one with lactate as principal carbon source. Two strains (CP78 and CP79), isogenic except for rel, showed similar behaviour with respect to (1) the kinetics of labelling total RNA and ribosomes with exogenous uracil, (2) the proportion of newly formed protein that could be bound with nascent rRNA in mature ribosomes, and (3) the rate of induction of enzymically active beta-galactosidase (relative to the rate of ribosome synthesis). It was concluded that, as there was no net accumulation of RNA during stepdown in either strain, rRNA turnover must be occurring at a high rate. The general features of ribosome maturation in rel+ and rel- cells were almost identical with those found in auxotrophic rel+ organisms starved of required amino acids. In both cases, there was a considerable delay in the maturation of new ribosomal particles, owing to a relative shortfall in the rate of synthesis of ribosome-associated proteins. Only about 4-5% of the total protein labelled during stepdown was capable of binding with newly formed rRNA. This compared with 3.5% for rel+ and 0.5% for rel- auxotrophs during amino acid starvation. The turnover rate for newly formed mRNA and rRNA was virtually the same in "stepped-down" rel+ and rel- strains and was similar to that of the same fraction in amino acid-starved rel+ cells. The functional lifetime of mRNA was also identical. It seems that in the rel- strain many of the characteristics typical of the isogenic rel+ strain are displayed under these conditions, at least as regards the speed of ribosome maturation and the induction of beta-galactosidase. Studies on the thermolability of the latter enzyme induced during stepdown indicate that inaccurate translation, which occurs in rel- strains starved for only a few amino acids, is less evident in this situation than in straightforward amino acid deprivation.     

Stable Ribonucleic Acid Synthesis in Stringent (rel+) and Relaxed (rel−) Polyamine Auxotrophs of Escherichia coli K-12

The relationship of polyamines to stable ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis under conditions of amino acid withdrawal or chloramphenicol treatment was examined with the use of a closely related rel(+), rel(-) pair conditionally incapable of synthesizing putrescine. Under conditions of polyamine starvation, the cellular sperimidine level fell to one-third to one-half of the value observed in putrescine-supplemented cultures and putrescine became undetectable; cadaverine was synthesized by both strains, but the relaxed strain, MA 252, accumulated less cadaverine per cell than its stringent twin, MA 254. Upon amino acid withdrawal, the stringent strain remained stringent whether starved of or supplemented with polyamines. Similarly, the relaxed strain was capable of making RNA either with or without polyamine starvation. On the addition of chloramphenicol or upon amino acid withdrawal in the relaxed strain, supplementation with spermidine had no effect on the initial rate of RNA synthesis, although RNA accumulation was greater in the presence of added spermidine. Spermidine added at the conclusion of RNA synthesis prompted additional synthesis, although preincubation with spermidine again had no effect on the initial rate. All forms of stable RNA species were made with polyamine supplementation. The present data appear to rule out the possibility that polyamines are primary causative agents in stimulating RNA synthesis, but rather suggest an indirect or secondary role for spermidine in which the polyamines "stimulate" stable RNA synthesis probably by relieving RNA product inhibition of RNA synthesis.     

Control of protein synthesis in Escherichia coli: strain differences in control of translational initiation after energy source shift-down.

We have studied the parameters of protein synthesis in a number of Escherichia coli strains after a shift-down from glucose-minimal to succinate-minimal medium. One group of strains, including K-12(lambda) (ATCC 10798) and NF162, showed a postshift translational yield of 50 to 65% and a 2- to 2.5-fold increase in the functional lifetime of general messenger ribonucleic acid. There was no change in the lag time for beta-galactosidase induction in these strains after the shift-down. A second group, including W1 and W2, showed no reduction in translational yield, no change in the functional lifetime of messenger ribonucleic acid, and a 50% increase in the lag time for beta-galactosidase induction. Evidence is presented which indicates that this increased lag time is not the result of a decreased rate of polypeptide chain propagation. A third group of strains, including NF161, CP78, and NF859, showed an intermediate pattern: translational yield was reduced to about 75% of normal, and the messenger ribonucleic acid functional lifetime was increased by about 50%. Calculation of the relative postshift rates of translational initiation gave about 0.2, 1.0, and 0.5, respectively, for the three groups. There was no apparent correlation between the ability to control translation and the genotypes of these strains at the relA, relX, or spoT loci. Measurements of the induction lag for beta-galactosidase during short-term glucose starvation or after a down-shift induced by alpha-methylglucoside indicated that these regimens elicit responses that are physiologically distinct from those elicited by a glucose-to-succinate shift-down.     

Accumulation of guanosine tetraphosphate induced by polymixin and gramicidin in Escherichia coli

The effects of two polypeptide antibiotics, polymixin B and gramicidin S, on the intracellular pool size and turnover of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp) were analyzed in stringent (relA⁺) and relaxed (relA) strains of Escherichia coli. When either one of these two drugs was added to stringent bacteria cultures at a final concentration that blocked protein and RNA synthesis, ppGpp was found to accumulate. Under similar conditions of inhibition of macromolecular synthesis, ppGpp also appeared to accumulate in relaxed bacteria. Moreover, in either type of strain, no significant accumulation of guanosine pentaphosphate (pppGpp) could be detected upon drug treatment. It was, therefore, concluded that polymixin and gramicidin elicit ppGpp accumulation through a mechanism independent of the relA gene product and, consequently, quite distinct from the stringent control system triggered by amino acid starvation. Further experiments performed by using tetracycline as an inhibitor of ppGpp synthesis, showed that the increase in the level of this nucleotide induced by drug action was due, in fact, to a strong restriction of its degradation rate.     

Regulation of Ribonucleic Acid Synthesis in Escherichia coli During Diauxie Lag: Accumulation of Heterogeneous Ribonucleic Acid

The synthesis of ribonucleic acid (RNA) and of protein in Escherichia coli during glucose-lactose diauxie lag have been examined. The rate of RNA synthesis is about 7%, of the corresponding rate during exponential growth and the rate of protein synthesis 10 to 15%. Inhibition of RNA synthesis occurs to the same extent in both rel and rel(+) strains. The RNA which accumulates during 20 min in diauxie lag is composed of about 50% ribosomal and transfer RNA species and about 50% of a fraction which resembles messenger RNA (mRNA) in its heterogeneous sedimentation properties. Decay of the heterogeneous fraction occurs in the presence of glucose and actinomycin D with a half-life of 3 min, the same as that of pulse-labeled mRNA; however, during the diauxie lag, the half-life of this RNA is about 25 min. Accumulation of the heterogeneous RNA is further increased when protein synthesis is blocked by chloramphenicol. The data suggest that the disproportionate accumulation of mRNA during diauxie lag and energy source shift-down may be attributed at least in part to increased stability of mRNA, but do not rule out a preferential synthesis of mRNA.     

Functional aspects of bacterial polysomes during limited protein synthesis

The effects of amino acid starvation on the metabolic behavior of polysomes and the size distribution of proteins have been studied in an otherwise isogenic pair of stringent (relA+) and relaxed (relA) strains of Escherichia coli. The stability of polysomes has been analyzed by using two different approaches. First, the process of their degradation has been followed after treating the cells with rifampicin, an inhibitor of the synthesis of all classes of RNA including messenger RNA. Secondly, the process of their assembly has been studied after their previous conversion to monosomes, as induced by glucose deprivation of cells. It is shown that, in either type of bacterial strain, polysomes are continually broken down and re-synthesized during amino acid starvation. However, such polysome turnover is then less rapid than in normally growing bacteria and, moreover, it seems amino acid specific since it occurs at a lower rate during arginine starvation than during histidine starvation, namely, in the relaxed strain. The molecular weight distribution of proteins has been determined after labeling of cells with radioactive methionine and separation of polypeptides by one-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The average size of polypeptides synthesized in the stringent strain during starvation is quite similar to that measured during normal growth. By contrast, a significant shift towards smaller molecules is observed in the relaxed strain deprived of an essential amino acid. Here again, this reduction of the size of polypeptides seems amino acid specific since it is especially marked during arginine starvation. These results are discussed in terms of ribosomes translocation and premature peptide chain termination in connection with the accuracy of the translational process.     

Characterization of Mutants of Escherichia coli Temperature-Sensitive for Ribonucleic Acid Regulation: an Unusual Phenotype Associated with a Phenylalanyl Transfer Ribonucleic Acid Synthetase Mutant

A mutant strain AA-522, temperature-sensitive for protein synthesis, was isolated from a stringent strain (CP-78) of Escherichia coli K-12. The mutant strain has a relaxed phenotype at the nonpermissive growth temperature. Protein synthesis stops completely at 42 C, whereas the rate of ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis is maintained at 20% of the 30 C rate. Sucrose-gradient centrifugation analysis of RNA-containing particles formed at 42 C indicated the presence of “relaxed particles.” These particles possess 16S and 23S RNA and are precursors to normal 50S and 30S ribosomal subunits. A search for the temperature-sensitive protein responsible for the halt in protein synthesis implicated phenylalanyl transfer RNA (tRNA) synthetase. Essentially no enzyme activity is detected in vitro at 30 or 40 C. Analysis of phenylalanyl tRNA synthetase activity in revertants of strain AA-522 indicated the presence of intragenic suppressor mutations. Revertants of strain AA-522 analyzed for the relaxed response at 42 C were all stringent; strain AA-522 was stringent at 30 C. These data indicate that a single mutation in phenylalanyl tRNA synthetase is responsible for both a block in protein synthesis and the relaxed phenotype at 42 C.     

Stringent control during carbon starvation of marine Vibrio sp. strain S14: molecular cloning, nucleotide sequence, and deletion of the relA gene.

In order to evaluate the role of the stringent response in starvation adaptations of the marine Vibrio sp. strain S14, we have cloned the relA gene and generated relaxed mutants of this organism. The Vibrio relA gene was selected from a chromosomal DNA library by complementation of an Escherichia coli delta relA strain. The nucleotide sequence contains a 743-codon open reading frame that encodes a polypeptide that is identical in length and highly homologous to the E. coli RelA protein. The amino acid sequences are 64% identical, and they share some completely conserved regions. A delta relA::kan allele was generated by replacing 53% of the open reading frame with a kanamycin resistance gene. The Vibrio relA mutants displayed a relaxed control of RNA synthesis and failed to accumulate ppGpp during amino acid limitation. During carbon and energy starvation, a relA-dependent burst of ppGpp synthesis concomitant with carbon source depletion and growth arrest was observed. Also, in the absence of the relA gene, there was an accumulation of ppGpp during carbon starvation, but this was slower and smaller than that which occurred in the stringent strains, and it was preceded by a marked decrease in the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio. In both the wild-type and the relaxed strains, carbon source depletion caused an immediate decrease in the size of the GTP pool and a block of net RNA accumulation. The relA mutation did not affect long-term survival or the development of resistance against heat, ethanol, and oxidative stress during carbon starvation of Vibrio sp. strain S14.