How normal is abnormal? Discrimination between deformations and natural variation in gonad morphology of European whitefish Coregonus lavaretus

The gonad morphology of whitefish Coregonus lavaretus collected in Lake Thun, Switzerland, and two neighbouring lakes was assessed in order to differentiate between 'normal' and 'abnormal' character states of gonad morphology, which had been previously described in C. lavaretus from Lake Thun (constrictions, asymmetries, aplasia, compartmentations, fusions and hermaphroditism). In total, 4668 fish were collected and analysed using two complementary sampling schemes: (1) monthly samples of catches by the commercial fishermen and (2) samples of ripe spawners of all known 33 spawning sites of the three lakes. Considerable variation in gonad morphology in C. lavaretus populations of all lakes was found. Notably, all deviation types were observed in fish of all three lakes. Asymmetries and constrictions were frequent in all three lakes and showed systematic differences in frequency between the two sampling strategies. This indicates that asymmetries and constrictions represent to a large extent natural variation in gonad morphology of C. lavaretus and are also prone to considerable measurement error. In contrast, aplasia, fusions, compartmentations and hermaphroditism occurred predominantly in one C. lavaretus form of Lake Thun and in particular in populations spawning at great depths. This suggests that these deviation types are probably reliable indicators for gonad deformations and supports the interpretation that Lake Thun harbours a unique case of deformed gonads in C. lavaretus of yet unknown origin.     

Gonadal alterations in male whitefish Coregonus fatioi: no evidence for genetic damage reducing viability in early life stages

In recent years, numerous cases of morphological gonadal alterations in fish have been recorded throughout the world and across a wide range of species. In the whitefish Coregonus fatioi from the pre-alpine Lake Thun (Switzerland), the frequency of gonadal alterations is particularly high and the variety of alteration types large. Little is known about the proximal causes and the direct consequences of these morphological features on population persistence. In particular, the potential for the observed alterations to be the phenotypic expression of reduced genetic quality has not yet been addressed. In this study, we used offspring survival during embryogenesis as a proximate indicator of male genetic quality and tested whether the presence of gonadal alterations in males is an indicator of reduced quality. Embryos resulted from in vitro fertilizations of gametes from 126 males and females. We found no significant correlation between embryo survival and gonadal alteration in adults. Our findings suggest that in C. fatioi of Lake Thun, alterations in gonad morphology are not a phenotypic expression of variation in genetic quality.     

Sperm velocity in an Alpine whitefish: effects of age, size, condition, fluctuating asymmetry and gonad abnormalities

The relationship between sperm velocity and individual age, size, body condition and fluctuating asymmetry was investigated in Alpine whitefish Coregonus fatioi . The fish analysed belonged to one among several sympatric whitefish populations of Lake Thun, Switzerland, which are characterized by a high prevalence of gonad alterations. Therefore, sperm velocity data were also tested for a link between gonad deformation and sperm swimming speed. Sperm velocity was significantly lower in larger-grown individuals and in individuals of higher body condition. As expected, sperm velocity was higher in males with higher levels of fluctuating asymmetry, but it did not significantly vary with male age. Moreover, variation in sperm velocity was found to be significantly higher in individuals showing some types of gonad alterations but it did not significantly correlate with the presence of other types of alterations.     

The gonadal anatomy and sexual pattern of the protandrous sex-reversing fish, Rhabdosargus sarba (Teleostei: Sparidae)

The gonadal anatomy and sexual pattern of Rhabdosargus sarba (Teleostei: Sparidae) was studied to provide some basic structural information for the subsequent investigations on the endocrinology of protandrous hermaphroditism in this fish. Evidence derived from relating sex to differences in body size, from gonadal histology and from biopsy, revealed the occurrence of natural sex reversal from male to female in this species. The gonad of R. sarba possessed topographically distinct male and female zones that were well separated by connective tissue. Based on gross-anatomical and histological observations, four types of gonad were distinguished and were designated as Types I-IV in the present study. Active spermatogenetic tissue was present in the Type I, II and IV gonads. Dormant oogonia and perinucleolar oocytes were found in the Type I (male) and II (intersex) gonads, respectively. In the Type III (female) gonad, a functional ovarian zone was observed and the testicular tissue was vestigial. The existence of ovarian tissue as an oogonial band in the Type IV (male) gonad, which was found more commonly in large specimens, suggested that these functional males might not undergo sex reversal in their life cycle. The interrelationship of the different types of gonad is discussed with reference to protandrous hermaphroditism.     

Gonad development and size‐at‐maturity of silver therapon Leiopotherapon plumbeus (Kner 1864; Teleostei:Terapontidae) in tropical volcanic lakes in south Luzon,Philippines

Gonad development of the silver therapon Leiopotherapon plumbeus in two volcanic crater  lake  habitats (Sampaloc Lake, Taal Lake) in south Luzon, Philippines was examined during the annual reproductive cycle. The minimum body size‐at‐maturity of fish in these two lake habitats was also compared. Four gonad development stages were characterized as basis for the classification of ovarian (immature, maturing, mature, spawned) and testicular maturation (immature, maturing, mature) phases. The occurrence of all development stages in individual gonads suggest an asynchronous development whereby advanced stages are recruited continuously from a pool of younger stage germ cells to result in elevated female and male GSI throughout the annual cycle due to active gonadogenesis. Together with the increasing occurrence of advanced stage oocytes and spermatozoa from March until October, the elevated GSI of fish may indicate peak gonadal growth during the onset of the dry season (December–January) for eventual spawning from the beginning (May–June) until the end of the wet season (October–November). In both lake habitats, male fish were smaller than females but, regardless of sex, the minimum size‐at‐maturity of fish in Sampaloc Lake was significantly smaller than fish in Taal Lake. Overall, asynchronous development during oogenesis and spermatogenesis allows for year‐round reproduction of silver therapon, with elevated gonad growth in the dry season in preparation for spawning during the wet season. Compared with fish in Taal Lake, a smaller size‐at‐maturity of fish in Sampaloc Lake may be a response of the wild fishery stock to long‐term high fishing mortality and degradation of the lake habitat.     

Gonadal regeneration in masculinized female or steroid-treated rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

In salmonids, the development of an indifferent gonad into a testis or an ovary is normally determined chromosomally but can be reversed or changed by the administration of exogenous steroids during specific times in embryonic development. Because the gonads of sexually mature rainbow trout (RBT) are capable of regeneration following surgical removal and since regeneration of some tissue involves dedifferentiation, the objective of this experiment was to determine if the phenotypic sex of RBT gonads could be reversed during the regenerative process. In experiment 1, male RBT were surgically gonadectomized (Gx) or left intact and subsequently treated with estradiol-17beta, a steroid that feminizes male RBT embryos. All Gx males regenerated testicular tissue regardless of treatment. Likewise, the gonads of sham-operated, intact fish treated with exogenous estrogen showed no evidence of sex-reversal. In experiment 2, testes from masculinized females (XX genotype; male phenotype) were surgically removed. In all cases, only testicular tissue was regenerated in the masculinized females. Taken together, these results are consistent with the conclusion that gonads of salmonid fishes are not susceptible to sex-reversing stimuli during the regenerative process and that gonadal regeneration in salmonids is a result of cellular proliferation of the remaining gonadal remnant.     

Morphological development of the gonads in zebrafish

Gonadogenesis of zebrafish Danio rerio was investigated by means of light microscopy to test the suitability of gonad histology as an endpoint in hazard assessment of endocrine‐active compounds. At age 2 weeks post‐fertilization (pf), primordial germ cells were found in a dorsocaudal position in the body cavity. At 4 weeks pf, the majority of the fish (86%) possessed paired gonads with meiotic germ cells; these gonads represented presumptive ovaries. At week 5 pf, 87% of the fish examined had ovaries with perinucleolar oocytes. Further development of the gonads in female zebrafish up to week 11 pf was characterized by an increase in gonad size as well as in the number and size of perinucleolar oocytes. Starting with week 5, some fish showed alterations of gonad morphology, including a decrease in the number and size of the oocytes, an enhanced basophilia and irregular shape of the oocytes, and finally their degeneration into residual bodies. With the decline in oocyte number, stromal cells became more numerous and they infiltrated the gonadal matrix. In several 7 week‐old zebrafish with altered gonadal morphology, enhanced numbers of gonial cells arranged in cyst‐like groups appeared. These gonads were interpreted as presumptive testes. In one fish out of 32 individuals examined, spermatocytes were detected, in addition to the gonial cells. During the subsequent weeks, the percentage of fish showing early testes with spermatogonia, spermatocytes and spermatids increased and reached 40% at 11 weeks pf. The sequence of gonadal alterations taking place in some of the individuals from week 5 pf onwards was interpreted to reflect the transition of protogynic ovaries into testes. The developmental pattern described identifies zebrafish to be a juvenile hermaphrodite. The results of this study are of relevance for the use of gonadal histopathology as endpoint in endocrine disruption testing, particularly in order to avoid false diagnoses of ‘intersex gonads’ in zebrafish.     

Where does gonadal sex differentiation begin? Gradient of histological sex differentiation in the gonads of pejerrey,Odontesthes bonariensis (Pisces,Atherinidae)

This study investigated the possibility that the histological process of gonadal sex differentiation in pejerrey (Odontesthes bonariensis), a fish with marked temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), occurs through a predictable gradient of differentiation as opposed to simultaneous or random differentiation throughout the gonad. For this purpose, fish reared at 17 degrees, 24 degrees, and 29 degrees C from hatching were sampled weekly for 11 weeks, fixed, and prepared for histological observation of serial cross-sections of the gonads. The thermal manipulation and sampling procedure ensured the availability of males and females at various degrees of gonadal sex differentiation. The location of the differentiated area(s) was estimated in the right and left gonads of 17 females and 14 males selected among the available specimens so as to represent increasing degrees of differentiation. The analysis revealed that sex differentiation followed a gradient from the anterior to posterior areas of the gonads regardless of sex. Furthermore, plotting of the degree of sex differentiation in the right gonad as a function of the degree of differentiation of the left gonad clearly showed that sex differentiation only begins in the right gonad when 10-30% of the length of the left gonad has already differentiated. The mean rostral edge of the differentiated areas in females was 9% and 10.8% for the left and right gonads, respectively, while for males these values were 7.3% and 7.0%, respectively. Thus, it was established that ovarian and testicular differentiation in pejerrey follow both a cephalocaudal and a left-to-right gradient. Possible explanations for this gradient and its relevance for TSD in pejerrey, that is, as a mechanism to prevent discrepant differentiation of male and female features within the same gonad, are discussed.     

Juvenile bisexuality in the red sea bream,Pagrus major

The histology of the gonad of the red sea bream,Pagrus major, was examined in order to study the early gonadal development, sexual maturation and sex ratio in a natural population. A total of 1,117 fish between the ages of 4 months and 8 years were examined. Gonads of 4-month-old fish were either sexually undifferentiated with a central cavity, or ovarian in form. Gonads of 12- and 18-month-old fish were ovaries or bisexual gonads, while those of 2-year-old fish were ovaries, bisexual gonads or testes. Fish aged between 3 and 8 years had ovaries or testes, except for a few bisexual gonads found in 3- and 4-year-old fish. The chronological appearance of females, hermaphrodites and males in that order, and histological evidence, suggested that the testis originates from the ovary via a bisexual gonad in the juvenile stage. The sex ratio of females to males at the age of 2 years and over was about 1:1, suggesting that hermaphroditic red sea bream appear in about 50% of the juvenile population. The sexual pattern in this species, therefore, is concluded to be gonochorism with a bisexual juvenile stage.     

Sex reversal and aromatase in chicken.

Aromatase inhibitors administered before sexual differentiation of the gonads can induce sex reversal in female chickens. To analyze the process of sex reversal, we have followed for several months the changes induced by Fadrozole, a nonsteroidal aromatase inhibitor, in gonadal aromatase activity and in morphology and structure of the female genital system. Fadrozole was injected into eggs on day four of incubation, and its effects were examined during the embryonic development and for eight months after hatching. In control females, aromatase activity in the right and the left gonad was high in the middle third of embryonic development, and then decreased up to hatching. After hatching, aromatase activity increased in the left ovary, in particular during folliculogenesis, whereas in the right regressing gonad, it continued to decrease to reach testicular levels at one month. In treated females, masculinization of the genital system was characterized by the maintenance of the right gonad and its differentiation into a testis, and by the differentiation of the left gonad into an ovotestis or a testis; however, in all individuals, the left Müllerian duct and the posterior part of the right Müllerian duct were maintained. In testes and ovotestes, aromatase activity was lower than in gonads of control females (except in the right gonad as of one month after hatching) but remained higher than in testes of control and treated males. Moreover, in ovotestes, aromatase activity was higher in parts displaying follicles than in parts devoid of follicles. The main structural changes in the gonads during sex reversal were partial (in ovotestes) or complete (in testes) degeneration of the cortex in the left gonad, and formation of an albuginea and differentiation of testicular cords/tubes in the two gonads. Testicular cords/tubes transdifferentiated from ovarian medullary cords and lacunae whose epithelium thickened and became Sertolian. Transdifferentiation occurred all along embryonic and postnatal development; thus, new testicular cords/tubes were continuously formed while others degenerated. The sex reversed gonads were also characterized by an abundant fibrous interstitial tissue and abnormal medullary condensations of lymphoid-like cells; in the persisting testicular cords/tubes, spermatogenesis was delayed and impaired. Related to aromatase activity, persistence of too high levels of estrogens can explain the presence of oviducts, gonadal abnormalities and infertility in sex reversed females.     

Differentiation of ambisexual gonads and immunohistochemical localization of P450 cholesterol side-chain cleavage enzyme during gonadal sex differentiation in the protandrous anemonefish, Amphiprion clarkii

To clarify the relationship between steroid hormones and sex differentiation of the protandrous anemonefish Amphiprion clarkii, we histologically examined its gonadal differentiation. From hatching to 30 days post hatching (dph), all of the gonads surveyed were sexually undifferentiated. The gonads of all fish first differentiated into ovaries at 60 dph, and the oocytes gradually developed and increased in number as the ovaries grew up until 183 dph. Some cysts of differentiated spermatogenic germ cells appeared in the ovaries at 214 dph, and ambisexual gonads with both ovarian and testicular tissues formed by 273 dph. Using immunohistochemistry, we then investigated the expression of cytochrome P450 cholesterol side-chain cleavage enzyme (P450scc), during gonadal sex differentiation. P450scc-immunopositive reactions first appeared in sexually undifferentiated gonads at 30 dph. Beginning at 60 dph, the number of strongly positive cells increased throughout the differentiation of the ovaries and continued to increase during the testicular differentiation until 210 dph. Immunopositive cells were observed more frequently in ovarian tissue than in testicular tissue in the ambisexual gonads at 270 dph. These results suggest that endogenous steroid hormones are important for the sex differentiation, including the primary sex differentiation and subsequent testicular differentiation, of the anemonefish.     

Sex differentiation in mammals and tempo of growth: probabilities vs. switches

In the conventional model of sex differentiation in placental mammals, a switch is envisaged to steer the indifferent gonad into the path of either testicular or ovarian development. The immediate cause of the switch is thought to be the presence or absence of Sertoli cells, which in turn is controlled by the presence or absence of the testis-determining factor on the Y chromosome (TDF in humans, Tdy in mice). Quantitative investigations indicate, however, that the rate of growth of XY gonads is faster than that of XX gonads before the formation of Sertoli cells, and furthermore, that XY embryos develop faster than XX embryos long before the formation of gonadal ridges. Since the genetic constitution of the sex chromosomes appears to manifest itself from the earliest embryonic stages onwards, the concept of indifferent gonads being switched into alternate pathways becomes inappropriate. A model is proposed in which gonadal differentiation depends on developmental thresholds: the formation of Sertoli cells needs to occur by a particular stage in time in a sufficiently developed gonad, failing which the gonad will enter the ovarian pathway. While TDF is the principal factor enhancing the rate of gonadal growth, other factors which influence development rates can modulate the probability of a gonad becoming either a testis or an ovary.     

Bi-directional sex change and gonad structure in the gobiid fish <Emphasis Type="Italic">Trimma yanagitai</Emphasis>

Bi-directional sex change in the deep-water gobiid fish Trimma yanagitai was examined. The gonads of all individuals consisted of ovarian and testicular elements, and an accessory gonadal structure. In no gonads were both testicular and ovarian parts simultaneously active. Bi-directional sex changes occurred during the rearing experiments in aquaria under conditions of which there was co-existence of two males or plural females. The sex of individuals could be determined by their relative body size or social dominance: the largest individuals acting as male and the remainder as female.     

Hermaphroditism and sexual function inCirrhitichthys aureus and the other Japanese hawkfishes (Cirrhitidae: Teleostei)

The present paper deals with gonadal formation, sex succession and sexual function in the Japanese hawkfishes,Cirrhitichthys aureus (Temminck et Schlegel),C. aprinus (Cuvier),C. falco Randall,Cirrhitops hubbardi (Schultz) andCyprinocirrhites polyactis (Bleeker). Detailed studies were made forC. aureus collected from Suruga Bay, central Japan. In this species the gonad of a young fish of 21.8 mm SL had begun to initially differentiate into an ovary forming an early ovarian cavity of the parovarian type. The gonadal structures of 63 further specimens ofC. aureus, ranging from 23.9 to 114.3 mm SL, could be separated into three categories: viz., ovaries (7), ambisexual gonads (54) and secondary testes (2). Reproduction ofC. aureus in Suruga Bay took place from June to November. Although ovaries which appeared throughout the year presented only in the immature stage and occurred only in small fish ranging from 25.1 to 46.6 mm SL, functional gonads occurred in 32 ambisexual fish ranging from 61.5 to 113.5 mm SL and in one secondary male of 101.5 mm SL, collected during the reproductive season. The smaller ambisexual fish, ranging from 61.5 to 92.0 mm SL, showed active oogenetic processes in the major ovarian zones with many ripened eggs ovulating into the ovarian cavity. These gynogenic gonads undoubtedly functioned as female; however, distinct meiosis proceeded partially in the minor testicular zones with a few spermatozoa occurring in the vas deferens. The larger ambisexual specimens, ranging from 71.5 to 113.5mm SL, had slender androgenic gonads, which showed active spermatogenesis in various testicular zones and which might function as males with reduced ovigerous lamellae. The secondary males had testes occupied by seminal lobules, but which retained the ovarian cavity within. According to aquarium rearing experiments, in a pair ofC. aureus twice crossed mutually after spawning, functional sex changes occurred in twice, opposite directions, in a single gonad, i.e., from female to male and from male to female. These gonadal aspects in captiveC. aureus seemed to show an intermediate phenomenon between consecutive and simultaneous hermaphroditism. This finding also suggested thatC. aureus had similar sex succession characteristics to those of the serranid,Serranus fasciatus, studied by Hasting and Petersen (1986) and the gobiid,Trimma okinawae, studied by Sunobe (1990). We also established that normal functional hermaphroditism occurred in the four other cirrhitid species, which showed almost identical gonadal characteristics toC. aureus.     

Induction of gonadal intersex in genotypic male rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) embryos following immersion in estradiol-17beta

This investigation was conducted to determine the initial period of gonadal sensitivity to estrogen in genetically male rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Fish were immersed in approximately 250 microg estradiol-17beta, (E2)/l for two 2 hr periods during different stages of embryonic development beginning 30 days postfertilization (DPF) and continuing until 68 DPF. Histological analysis of gonad samples indicated a significant proportion of E2-treated fish had intersex gonads; these gonads were primarily comprised of testicular tissue with one or more oocytes scattered throughout. The most sensitive period for altering normal testicular development was found to occur between 44 and 51 DPF (63% intersex), while the labile period in general was determined to span 24 days (from 30 to 54 DPF). Additionally, quantitative RT-PCR was used to measure estrogen receptor (ER) mRNA expression in whole individual untreated embryos at six weekly time points throughout the period of E2-exposure. Although the intersex condition was not observed throughout the entire E2-exposure period, ER mRNA was detected at each time point assayed.     

Gonadal development and diandric protogyny in two populations of Dascyllus reticulatus from Madang, Papua New Guinea

Two Dascyllus reticulatus populations from Madang, Papua New Guinea exhibited diandric protogyny. In both populations, gonads began as undifferentiated, and then developed oocytes in the primary growth stage and an ovarian lumen. From this ovarian state or from more developed ovaries containing oocytes beyond the primary‐growth stage, some gonads developed into testes. The first sign of testicular development was degeneration of oocytes, degeneration of oocytes in the primary growth stage in ovarian gonads and degeneration of oocytes of all growth stages present including the primary growth stage in ovaries, which was then followed by development of spermatogenic tissue. In both populations, most of the fish that had gonads with degenerating oocytes were smaller than the smallest mature females, indicating that development towards testes was mostly initiated in immature gonads containing only pre‐vitellogenic oocytes. On some occasions, however, females as large as other mature females also had gonads with degenerating oocytes, suggesting that development towards testes may have occurred in mature ovaries as well. This latter notion is further strengthened by the discovery of a fish having a gonad that contained both degenerating vitellogenic oocytes and developing spermatogenic tissue. Taken together, these results suggest that D. reticulatus can exhibit diandric protogyny, because testes in D. reticulatus developed from juvenile gonads as well as from mature ovaries.     

Gonadal sex reversal in triploid rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss).

Sex determination in salmonids is primarily governed by sex chromosomes; however, phenotypic expression and successful development of the gonads may be influenced by additional factors. Exposure to exogenous steroids during the critical period of gonadal differentiation will reverse the expected phenotypic sex of both female and male trout. Triploidy, a viable condition in rainbow trout (RBT), alters the degree of gonadal development in a gender-specific manner. Males produce testes with similar morphology and function as diploid fish, but females produce underdeveloped ovaries devoid of growing oocytes. One possible explanation for this observed gender difference is that the timing of meiotic initiation may influence ovarian/testicular development in triploid RBT. To determine whether the early entrance of germ cells into meiosis results in the lack of ovarian development in triploid females, the objective of this study was to sex-reverse genotypic triploid female RBT (XXX) into phenotypic males and genotypic triploid male RBT (XXY) into phenotypic females. Male fish were exposed to estradiol-17beta (E(2)) and females were exposed to the non-aromatizable androgen 17alpha-methyldihydrotestosterone (MDHT). Over 90% of the male fish treated with exogenous E(2) developed gonadal structures indistinguishable from the gonads of triploid females. Triploid female RBT treated with MDHT developed testes; however, not all fish treated with this androgen were completely sex reversed. The results of this investigation are consistent with the hypothesis that the failure of ovarian development in triploid RBT is due to the early onset of meiosis and does not appear to be due to genotypic sex. J. Exp. Zool. 284:466-472, 1999.     

Influence of prenatal stress on steroidogenesis in gonads of blue foxes

Handling is a source of stress for farm bred blue foxes. The influence of handling during the late gestational period was investigated in 10-day-old male and female blue foxes. Testosterone and estradiol were measured by RIA in the plasma, gonadal homogenates andin vitro incubates, from blue foxes of both sexes. The gonads were incubatedin vitro without or with human chorionic gonadotropin. In cubs of both sexes, the gonad weights and ovarian estradiol production were decreased by stress. The testicular testosterone and ovarian estradiol contents were increased in prenatally stressed cubs as compared to the controls. The testicular content and baselinein vitro production of testosterone were not affected by prenatal stress, but the testicular response to human chorionic gonadotropin was higher in the stressed group. This study suggests that prenatal stress induced by handling pregnant vixens may influence gonadal steroidogenesis and that this effect was more pronounced in female cubs.