Influence of the spacer region between the Shine–Dalgarno box and the start codon for fine-tuning of the translation efficiency in Escherichia coli

Translation efficiency contributes several orders of magnitude difference in the overall yield of exogenous gene expression in bacteria. In diverse bacteria, the translation initiation site, whose sequence is the primary determinant of the translation performance, is comprised of the start codon and the Shine–Dalgarno box located upstream. Here, we have examined how the sequence of a spacer between these main components of the translation initiation site contributes to the yield of synthesized protein. We have created a library of reporter constructs with the randomized spacer region, performed fluorescently activated cell sorting and applied next-generation sequencing analysis (the FlowSeq protocol). As a result, we have identified sequence motifs for the spacer region between the Shine–Dalgarno box and AUG start codon that may modulate the translation efficiency in a 100-fold range.     

Translation initiation factor 3 antagonizes authentic start codon selection on leaderless mRNAs

In this study, we have examined the influence of initiation factors on translation initiation of leaderless mRNAs whose 5'-terminal residues are the A of the AUG initiating codon. A 1:1 ratio of initiation factors to ribosomes abolished ternary complex formation at the authentic start codon of different leaderless mRNAs. Supporting this observation, in vitro translation assays using limiting ribosome concentrations with competing leaderless λ c I and Escherichia coli ompA mRNAs, the latter containing a canonical ribosome binding site, revealed reduced cI synthesis relative to OmpA in the presence of added initiation factors. Using in vitro toeprinting and in vitro translation assays, we show that this effect can be attributed to IF3. Moreover, in vivo studies revealed that the translational efficiency of a leaderless reporter gene is decreased with increased IF3 levels. These studies are corroborated by the observed increased translational efficiency of a leaderless reporter construct in an infC mutant strain unable to discriminate against non-standard start codons. These results suggest that, in the absence of a leader or a Shine–Dalgarno sequence, the function(s) of IF3 limits stable 30S ternary complex formation.     

Mutations affecting translation of the bacteriophage T4 rIIB gene cloned in Escherichia coli

Summary Mutant ribosome binding sites of the bacteriophage T4 rIIB gene, resident on an 873 bp DNA fragment, were cloned into a plasmid vector as in-frame fusions to a reporter gene, beta-galactosidase. The collection of mutations included changes in the region 5 to the Shine/Dalgarno sequence, a mutation of the Shine/Dalgarno sequence, the alternate initiation codons GUG, AUA and ACG, and mutants in which several closely spaced initiation codons compete with each other on the same mRNA. The results show that the secondary structure variations we have installed 5 to the Shine/Dalgarno sequence have little effect on translation. GUG is essentially as good an initiator of translation as AUG when they are assayed on separate messages, but is outcompeted at least 50-fold in the sequence AUGUG. AUA and ACG are poor start codons, and are temperature sensitive. The initiation codon pair AUGAUA, in which the AUG is only two nucleotides from the Shine/Dalgarno sequence, displays a novel cold-sensitive phenotype.     

Characterization of translational initiation sites in E. coli.

We characterize the Shine and Dalgarno sequence of 124 known gene beginnings. This information is used to make "rules" which help distinguish gene beginning from other sites in a library of over 78,000 bases of mRNA. Gene beginnings are found to have information besides the initiation codon and Shine and Dalgarno sequence which can be used to make better "rules".     

mRNA containing an extended Shine-Dalgarno sequence is translated independently of ribosomal protein S1.

The role of ribosomal protein S1 in the translation of mRNA containing an extended Shine-Dalgarno sequence was investigated. Using the toeprinting technique, formation of the ternary initiation complex between 30S subunits, both S1-depleted or treated with anti-S1 antibodies, and mini-mRNA containing the 9 nucleotide-long Shine-Dalgarno sequence was studied. It was concluded that the initiation of translation on mRNA with an extended Shine-Dalgarno sequence is S1-independent. It was demonstrated that S1-depleted ribosomes effectively translate the cro-mini-mRNA in a cell-free system. In contrast to cro-mini-mRNA, 30S subunits without protein S1 are inactive in ternary initiation complex formation with, and cell-free translation of, MS2 or fr phage RNAs and RNA protein III of phage fd.     

Diverse molecular mechanisms for translation initiation in prokaryotes

Classical model of prokaryotic translation initiation based on the central role of interactions between mRNA and 16S rRNA was proposed more than 30 years ago by Shine and Dalgarno. Since then, due to the rapid progress in genome sequencing and to novel technical approaches, basic researches have substantially enriched our knowledge on the problem. The present review focuses on the bioinformatic data as well as on experimental results obtained in vivo and in vitro, which show the diversity of molecular mechanisms for ribosome recruitment in prokaryotes.     

Diverse molecular mechanisms of translation initiation in prokaryotes

More than 30 years ago Shine and Dalgarno proposed a classic model of prokaryotic translation initiation, based on the central role of the mRNA-16S rRNA interactions. Since then basic research has greatly extended the view of this process, owing to rapid progress in experimental techniques and genome sequencing. This review focuses on bioinformatic data and experimental results obtained in vitro and in vivo, demonstrating the diversity of molecular mechanisms for ribosome recruitment in prokaryotes.     

Escherichia coli mRNAs with strong Shine/Dalgarno sequences also contain 5' end sequences complementary to domain # 17 on the 16S ribosomal RNA

A well-established feature of the translation initiation region, which attracts the ribosomes to the prokaryotic mRNAs, is a purine rich area called Shine/Dalgarno sequence (SD). There are examples of various other sequences, which despite having no similarity to an SD sequence are capable of enhancing and/or initiating translation. The mechanisms by which these sequences affect translation remain unclear, but a base pairing between mRNA and 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is proposed to be the likely mechanism. In this study, using a computational approach, we identified a non-SD signal found specifically in the translation initiation regions of Escherichia coli mRNAs, which contain super strong SD sequences. Nine of the 11 E. coli translation initiation regions, which were previously identified for having super strong SD sequences, also contained six or more nucleotides complementary to box-17 on the 16S rRNA (nucleotides 418-554). Mutational analyses of those initiation sequences indicated that when complementarity to box-17 was eliminated, the efficiency of the examined sequences to mediate the translation of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) mRNA was reduced. The results suggest that mRNA sequences with complementarity to box-17 of 16S rRNA may function as enhancers for translation in E. coli.     

The Human IGF1R IRES likely operates through a Shine–Dalgarno‐like interaction with the G961 loop (E‐site) of the 18S rRNA and is kinetically modulated by a naturally polymorphic polyU loop

IGF1R is a proto‐oncogene with potent mitogenic and antiapoptotic activities, and its expression must be tightly regulated to maintain normal cellular and tissue homeostasis. We previously demonstrated that translation of the human IGF1R mRNA is controlled by an internal ribosome entry site (IRES), and delimited the core functional IRES to a 90‐nucleotide segment of the 5′‐untranslated region positioned immediately upstream of the initiation codon. Here we have analyzed the sequence elements that contribute to the function of the core IRES. The Stem2/Loop2 sequence of the IRES exhibits near‐perfect Watson–Crick complementarity to the G961 loop (helix 23b) of the 18S rRNA, which is positioned within the E‐site on the platform of the 40S ribosomal subunit. Mutations that disrupt this complementarity have a negative impact on regulatory protein binding and dramatically decrease IRES activity, suggesting that the IGF1R IRES may recruit the 40S ribosome by a eukaryotic equivalent of the Shine–Dalgarno (mRNA–rRNA base‐pairing) interaction. The homopolymeric Loop3 sequence of the IRES modulates accessibility and limits the rate of translation initiation mediated through the IRES. Two functionally distinct allelic forms of the Loop3 poly(U)‐tract are prevalent in the human population, and it is conceivable that germ‐line or somatic variations in this sequence could predispose individuals to development of malignancy, or provide a selectable growth advantage for tumor cells. J. Cell. Biochem. 110: 531–544, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Comparison of mRNA features affecting translation initiation and reinitiation

Regulation of gene expression at the level of translation accounts for up to three orders of magnitude in its efficiency. We systematically compared the impact of several mRNA features on translation initiation at the first gene in an operon with those for the second gene. Experiments were done in a system with internal control based on dual cerulean and red (CER/RFP) fluorescent proteins. We demonstrated significant differences in the efficiency of Shine Dalgarno sequences acting at the leading gene and at the following genes in an operon. The majority of frequent intercistronic arrangements possess medium SD dependence, medium dependence on the preceding cistron translation and efficient stimulation by A/U-rich sequences. The second cistron starting immediately after preceding cistron stop codon displays unusually high dependence on the SD sequence.     

Kinetic checkpoint at a late step in translation initiation

The translation initiation efficiency of a given mRNA is determined by its translation initiation region (TIR). mRNAs are selected into 30S initiation complexes according to the strengths of the secondary structure of the TIR, the pairing of the Shine-Dalgarno sequence with 16S rRNA, and the interaction between initiator tRNA and the start codon. Here, we show that the conversion of the 30S initiation complex into the translating 70S ribosome constitutes another important mRNA control checkpoint. Kinetic analysis reveals that 50S subunit joining and dissociation of IF3 are strongly influenced by the nature of the codon used for initiation and the structural elements of the TIR. Coupling between the TIR and the rate of 70S initiation complex formation involves IF3- and IF1-induced rearrangements of the 30S subunit, providing a mechanism by which the ribosome senses the TIR and determines the efficiency of translational initiation of a particular mRNA.     

Analysis of base-pairing potentials between 16S rRNA and 5' UTR for translation initiation in various prokaryotes.

MOTIVATION: It is well accepted that the 3' end of 16S rRNA is directly involved in prokaryotic translation initiation by pairing with the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence, which is located in the ribosome-binding site of mRNA. According to Shine and Dalgarno, Escherichia coli 's 5' UTR has the pattern of 'AGGAGG' (SD sequence), which is complementary to the 3' end sequence of 16S rRNA. In this work, we systematically calculated free-energy values of the base pairing between the 3' end of 16S rRNA and the 5' UTR of mRNA, in order to analyze the base-pairing potentials in various prokaryotes. The free-energy values were then plotted over distances from the start codon to visualize the free-energy pattern of 5'UTRs. RESULTS: The average free-energy values fell sharply before the start codon in E. coli, which is consistent with the model that the 3' end of 16S rRNA base pairs with the SD sequence. Haemophilus influenzae, Bacillus subtilis and Helicobacter pylori show a similar pattern, suggesting that the organisms have basically the same mechanism of translation initiation as E. coli. Other eubacteria, such as Synechocystis PCC6803, Mycoplasma genitalium, Mycoplasma pneumoniae and Borrelia burgdorferi also show decreases in their free-energy values, although they are less evident. We also did the same analysis with a eukaryote genome as a control; no fall in free-energy values was observed between the 3' end of 18S rRNA and 5' UTRs of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, suggesting that this organism does not base pair in translation initiation. The three archaebacteria A. fulgidus, M. jannaschii and M. thermoautotrophicum show patterns similar to eubacteria, but not to S. cerevisiae, indicating that archaebacteria are closer to eubacteria than to eukaryotes with respect to the mechanism of translation initiation. From these observations, it appears that the shape of the curve produced by the algorithm can be used to predict the mechanism of translation initiation. AVAILABILITY: The C programs used in our analysis are available upon request.     

RNA secondary structure and in vitro translation efficiency

Cell-free protein synthesis is a promising technology featuring many advantages compared to in vivo expression techniques. However, most proteins are still synthesized in vivo due to relatively low protein yields commonly achieved in vitro, especially in the batch mode of reaction. In Escherichia coli S30 extract-based cell-free systems protein yields are supposed to be partially limited by a secondary structure formation of the mRNA. In this study we checked promising members of various classes of RNA chaperones and several different RNA helicases on their ability to enhance in vitro translation. The data clearly show that the addition of none of these factors provides a general solution to the problem. However, protein yields can be increased in presence of a microRNA hybridizing with the 5′ untranslated region of mRNAs, possibly by inducing structural changes improving accessibility of the Shine Dalgarno sequence for the ribosomes.     

The construction of a synthetic Escherichia coli trp promoter and its use in the expression of a synthetic interferon gene.

An 82 base pair DNA fragment has been synthesised which contains the E. coli trp promoter and operator sequences and also encodes the first Shine Dalgarno sequence of the trp operon. This DNA fragment is flanked by EcoRI and ClaI/TaqI cohesive ends and is thus easy to clone, transfer between vector systems and couple to genes to drive their expression. It has been cloned into plasmid pAT153, producing a convenient trp promoter vector. We have also joined the fragment to a synthetic IFN-alpha 1 gene, using synthetic oligonucleotides to generate a completely natural, highly efficient bacterial translation initiation signal on the promoter proximal side of the IFN gene. Plasmids carrying this construction enable E. coli cells to express IFN-alpha 1 almost constitutively and with significantly higher efficiency than from a lacUV5 promoter based system.     

Quantitative analysis of ribosome binding sites in E.coli.

185 clones with randomized ribosome binding sites, from position -11 to 0 preceding the coding region of beta-galactosidase, were selected and sequenced. The translational yield of each clone was determined; they varied by more than 3000-fold. Multiple linear regression analysis was used to determine the contribution to translation initiation activity of each base at each position. Features known to be important for translation initiation, such as the initiation codon, the Shine/Dalgarno sequence, the identity of the base at position -3 and the occurrence of alternative ATGs, are all found to be important quantitatively for activity. No other features are found to be of general significance, although the effects of secondary structure can be seen as outliers. A comparison to a large number of natural E.coli translation initiation sites shows the information profile to be qualitatively similar although differing quantitatively. This is probably due to the selection for good translation initiation sites in the natural set compared to the low average activity of the randomized set.     

A three-way junction and constituent stem-loops as the stimulator for programmed -1 frameshifting in bacterial insertion sequence IS911

Several signals are required for the programmed frameshifting in translation of IS911 mRNA. These include a Shine Dalgarno (SD)-like sequence, a slippery sequence of six adenine residues and a guanine residue (A6G) and a 3' secondary structure. The structure of the mRNA containing these elements was investigated using chemical and enzymatic probing. The probing data show that the 3' structure is a three-way junction of stems. The function of the three-way junction was investigated by mutagenesis. Disrupting the stability of the structure greatly affects frameshifting and transposition levels as tested by separate in vivo assays. Structural probing and thermal melting profiles indicate that the disrupted three-way junctions have altered structures.