Assembly-dependent conformational changes in a viral capsid protein. Calorimetric comparison of successive conformational states of the gp23 surface lattice of bacteriophage T4

Inter- and intra-subunit bonding within the surface lattice of the capsid of bacteriophage T4 has been investigated by differential scanning calorimetry of polyheads, in conjunction with electron microscopy, limited proteolysis and sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The bonding changes corresponding to successive stages of assembly of the major capsid protein gp23, including its maturation cleavage, were similarly characterized. The uncleaved/unexpanded surface lattice exhibits two endothermic transitions. The minor event, at 46 degrees C, does not visibly affect the surface lattice morphology and probably represents denaturation of the N-terminal domain of gp23. The major endotherm, at 65 degrees C, represents denaturation of the gp23 polymers. Soluble gp23 from dissociated polyheads is extremely unstable and exhibits no endotherm. Cleavage of gp23 to gp23* and the ensuing expansion transformation effects a major stabilization of the surface lattice of polyheads, with single endotherms whose melting temperatures (t*m) range from 73 to 81 degrees C, depending upon the mutant used and the fraction of gp23 that is cleaved to gp23* prior to expansion. Binding of the accessory proteins soc and hoc further modulates the thermograms of cleaved/expanded polyheads, and their effects are additive. hoc binding confers a new minor endotherm at 68 degrees C corresponding to at least partial denaturation of hoc. Denatured hoc nevertheless remains associated with the surface lattice, although in an altered, protease-sensitive state which correlates with delocalization of hoc subunits visualized in filtered images. While hoc binding has little effect on the thermal stability of the gp23* matrix, soc binding further stabilizes the surface lattice (delta Hd approximately +50%; delta t*m = +5.5 degrees C). It is remarkable that in all states of the surface lattice, the inter- and intra-subunit bonding configurations of gp23 appear to be co-ordinated to be of similar thermal stability. Thermodynamically, the expansion transformation is characterized by delta H much less than 0; delta Cp approximately 0, suggesting enhancement of van der Waals' and/or H-bonding interactions, together with an increased exposure to solvent of hydrophobic residues of gp23* in the expanded state. These findings illuminate hypotheses of capsid assembly based on conformational properties of gp23: inter alia, they indicate a role for the N-terminal portion of gp23 in regulating polymerization, and force a reappraisal of models of capsid swelling based on the swivelling of conserved domains.     

The maturation-dependent conformational change of the major capsid protein of bacteriophage T4 involves a substantial change in secondary structure

We have investigated the conformational basis of the expansion transformation that occurs upon maturation of the bacteriophage T4 prohead, by using laser Raman spectroscopy to determine the secondary structure of the major capsid protein in both the precursor and the mature states of the surface lattice. This transformation involves major changes in the physical, chemical, and immunological properties of the capsid and is preceded in vivo by processing of its major protein, gp23 (56 kDa), to gp23* (49 kDa), by proteolysis of its N-terminal gp23-delta domain. The respective secondary structures of gp23 in the unexpanded state, and of gp23* in the expanded state, were determined from the laser Raman spectra of polyheads, tubular polymorphic variants of the capsid. Similar measurements were also made on uncleaved polyheads that had been expanded in vitro and, for reference, on thermally denatured polyheads. We find that, with or without cleavage of gp23, expansion is accompanied by substantial changes in secondary structure, involving a major reduction in alpha-helix content and an increase in beta-sheet. The beta-sheet contents of gp23* or gp23 in the expanded state of the surface lattice, and even of gp23 in the unexpanded state, are sufficient for a domain with the "jellyroll" fold of antiparallel beta-sheets, previously detected in the capsid proteins of other icosahedral viruses.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Proteolysis of the major capsid protein T4 bacteriophage polyheads limited by quaternary structure.

Bacteriophage T4 carrying an amber mutation in gene 22 plus an amber mutation in gene 21 form aberrant, tubular structures termed rough polyheads, instead of complete phage when they infect Escherichia coli B. These rough polyheads consist almost entirely of the major capsid protein in its uncleaved form (gp23). When rough polyheads are treated under mild conditions with any of the five proteases, trypsin, chymotrypsin, thermolysin, pronase, or the protease from Staphylococcus aureus V8, the gp23 is rapidly hydrolyzed at a limited number of peptide bonds. In contrast, cleaved capsid protein (gp23) in mature phage capsids is completely resistant to proteolysis under the same conditions. A major project in this laboratory requires determining the primary structure of gp23, a large protein (Mr = 58,000) quite rich in those amino acids at which cleavages are achieved by conventional means. Recovery of peptides from the complex mixtures resulting from such cleavages proved to be extremely difficult. The limited proteolysis of gp23 in rough polyheads had yielded a set of large, easily purified fragments which are greatly simplifying the task of determining the primary structure of this protein.     

The maturation-dependent conformational change of phage T4 capsid involves the translocation of specific epitopes between the inner and the outer capsid surfaces

After polymerization of the phage T4 prohead is complete, its capsid expands by approximately 16%, is greatly stabilized, and acquires the capacity to bind accessory proteins. These effects are manifestations of a large-scale, irreversible, conformational change undergone by the major capsid protein, gp23 (521 residues) which is cleaved to gp23* (residues 66-521) during this maturation process. In order to explore its structural basis, we have performed immunoelectron microscopy with antibodies raised against synthetic peptides that correspond to precisely defined segments of the amino acid sequence of gp23. These antibodies were used to label purified polyheads (tubular polymorphic variants of the normal icosahedral capsid), in experiments designed to impose constraints on the possible foldings of the gp23/gp23* polypeptide chains in their successive conformational states. Peptide 1 (residues 48-57), part of the gp23-delta domain that is excised when gp23 is converted to gp23*, resides on the inner surface of the precursor surface lattice, but--if not proteolyzed--is found on the outer surface of the mature surface lattice. Peptide 2 (residues 65-73), immediately distal to the cleavage site, is located on the inside of the precursor surface lattice, and remains there subsequent to expansion. Peptide 3 (residues 139-146) is translocated in the opposite direction from peptide 1, i.e., from the outer to the inner surface upon expansion; moreover, expansion greatly increases the polyheads' affinity for these antibodies. Peptide 5 (residues 301-308) is located on the inside in both the precursor and the mature states. Taking into account data from other sources, these observations imply that the conformational change that underlies capsid expansion involves a radical reorganization of the proteins' structure, in which at least three distinct epitopes, situated in widely differing parts of the polypeptide chain, are translocated from one side to the other. Moreover, the amino-terminal portion of gp23/gp23*, around the cleavage site, is particularly affected.     

Head maturation pathway of bacteriophages T4 and T2. IV. In vitro transformation of T4 head-related particles produced by mutants in gene 17 to capsid-like structures

T4 mutants in gene 17 accumulate particles which contain the main head protein in the cleaved form (gp23*) arranged in an unexpanded lattice (empty small particles), together with other expanded capsids (empty large particles). The isolated empty small particles can be transformed in vitro, by lowering the ionic strength, to capsid-like structures. This structural transformaton is not coupled to chemical modification of the structural proteins of the empty small particles. In contrast to unexpanded particles that are easily dissociated, the transformed structures are as resistant to dissociation as other T-even head-related particles with expanded lattice. Furthermore, the transformed particles are able to bind in vitro hoc and soc proteins, rendering capsids indistinguishable from the normal T4 capsids both morphologically and by their stability against denaturing agents. Our results indicate that the in vitro transformation of the empty small particles might mimic important and characteristic aspects of the in vivo maturation of T4 heads, thus suggesting a possible role of the "cleaved but unexpanded" particle in the maturation pathway of the T4 shell.     

Proteolytic cleavage and structural transformation: Their relationship in bacteriophage T4 capsid maturation

Giant T4 phage capsoids formed in canavanine-treated cultures infected by phage mutants in genes 21 and 17, respectively, differ with regard to cleavage of the major capsid protein, gp 23, and in the fine structure of their hexagonal surface lattices. Quantitative computer processing of electron micrographs shows that the significant differences in capsomer morphology amount to six symmetrically placed features present in the uncleaved hexamer but absent after cleavage. These features may be related with the N-terminal portions of gp 23 monomers excised by phage-specific proteolysis. Cleaved 17^? giants can be induced to undergo a further structural transformation (expansion). Structural characteristics of partially transformed giant particles give clues about the dynamics of the cleavage and expansion transformations. Both processes appear to be polar, initiating in one cap and propagating along the particle. The transition zone of partial cleavage is diffuse, whereas the transition between unexpanded and expanded areas is confined to a narrow band of some 20 nm width.     

Structure of T4 polyheads: II. A pathway of polyhead transformations as a model for T4 capsid maturation

We have studied the aberrant tubular polyheads of bacteriophages T4D and T2L as a model system for capsid maturation. Six different types of polyhead surface lattice morphology, and the corresponding protein compositions are reported and discussed. Using in vitro systems to induce transformations between particular polyhead types, we have deduced that the structural classes represent successive points in a transitional pathway. In the first step, coarse polyheads (analogous to the prohead τ-particle) are proteolytically cleaved by a phagecoded protease, a fragment of the gene 21 product. This cleavage of P23 to P23¹ induces a co-operative lattice transformation in the protein of the surface shell, to a conformation equivalent to that of T2L giant phage capsids. These polyheads (derived either from T4 or T2L lysates) can accept further T4-coded proteins. In doing so, they pass through intermediate structural states, eventually reaching an end point whose unit cell morphology is indistinguishable from that of the giant T4 capsids. At least one protein (called soc (Ishii & Yanagida, 1975)) is bound stoichiometrically to P23¹ in the end-state conformation. The simulation of several aspects of capsid maturation (cleavage of P23 to P23¹, stabilization, and lattice expansion) in the polyhead pathway suggest that it parallels the major events of phage T-even capsid maturation, decoupled from any involvement of DNA packaging.     

Chaperonin-mediated folding of bacteriophage T4 major capsid protein. II. Production of gene product 23 deletion mutants

Folding of bacteriophage T4 major capsid protein, gene product 23 (534 a.a.), is aided by two proteins: E. coli GroEL chaperonin and viral gp31 co-chaperonin. In the present work a set of mutants with extensive deletions inside gene 23 using controlled digestion with Bal31 nuclease has been constructed. Proteins with deletions were co-expressed from plasmid vectors with phage gp31 co-chaperonin. Deletions from 8 to 33 a.a. in the N-terminal region of the gp23 molecule covering the protein proteolytic cleavage site during capsid maturation have no influence on the mutants' ability to produce in E. coli cells proteins which form regular structures—polyheads. Deletions in other regions of the polypeptide chain (187-203 and 367-476 a.a.) disturb the correct folding and subsequent assembly of gp23 into polyheads.     

Phage display of intact domains at high copy number: a system based on SOC, the small outer capsid protein of bacteriophage T4.

Peptides fused to the coat proteins of filamentous phages have found widespread applications in antigen display, the construction of antibody libraries, and biopanning. However, such systems are limited in terms of the size and number of the peptides that may be incorporated without compromising the fusion proteins' capacity to self-assemble. We describe here a system in which the molecules to be displayed are bound to pre-assembled polymers. The polymers are T4 capsids and polyheads (tubular capsid variants) and the display molecules are derivatives of the dispensable capsid protein SOC. In one implementation, SOC and its fusion derivatives are expressed at high levels in Escherichia coli, purified in high yield, and then bound in vitro to separately isolated polyheads. In the other, a positive selection vector forces integration of the modified soc gene into a soc-deleted T4 genome, leading to in vivo binding of the display protein to progeny virions. The system is demonstrated as applied to C-terminal fusions to SOC of (1) a tetrapeptide; (2) the 43-residue V3 loop domain of gp120, the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein; and (3) poliovirus VP1 capsid protein (312 residues). SOC-V3 displaying phage were highly antigenic in mice and produced antibodies reactive with native gp120. That the fusion protein binds correctly to the surface lattice was attested in averaged electron micrographs of polyheads. The SOC display system is capable of presenting up to approximately 10(3) copies per capsid and > 10(4) copies per polyhead of V3-sized domains. Phage displaying SOC-VP1 were isolated from a 1:10(6) mixture by two cycles of a simple biopanning procedure, indicating that proteins of at least 35 kDa may be accommodated.     

Head maturation pathway of bacteriophages T4 and T2. III. Isolation and characterization of particles produced by mutants in gene 17

We have isolated and characterized two types of particles produced in comparable amounts by mutants in gene 17: the empty large particle and the empty small particle. Dimensions, morphology, stability, and protein composition of the empty large particle are very similar to those of the capsids or empty heads of mature phage. The other type of particle (empty small particle) is very similar in dimensions and stability to the prehead, but differs in that it is composed of processed proteins (gp23, gp24, IpIII). Structural analysis has shown that the protein subunits of the empty small particles are arranged in an unexpanded type of lattice (11.2 to 11.3 nm), whereas the empty large particles have an expanded lattice (13 nm). The characterization of the empty small particle as being composed of cleaved proteins, but still unexpanded, shows that the expansion of the T4 head shell is not necessarily linked to the cleavage of the structural proteins.     

Specific labeling of protein domains with antibody fragments

Monovalent antibody Fab fragments, prepared from antisera raised against two different types of crystalline arrays made of either intact, or a proteolytic fragment of bacteriophage T4 major capsid protein, gp23*, were employed to stoichiometrically label different gp23* protein domains on the outer surface of a tubular variant (i.e., "polyheads") of bacteriophage T4 capsids. Computer filtrations of both negatively stained and freeze-dried/metal-shadowed specimens permitted approximate mapping of the Fab binding sites within the capsomere of the polyheads.     

Correlation between structural transformation and cleavage of the major head protein of T4 bacteriophage

We have studied the maturation of T4 polyheads, the aberrant tubular structures related to the capsid of T4 bacteriophage. Conditions have been found under which more than 95% of the major head protein (P23) undergoes the same cleavage that occurs during development of the normal capsid. The concomitant structural changes in the polyheads have been followed using electron microscope image filtering techniques. As a result of the cleavage, a radical transformation of the hexagonal lattice occurs, Involving a 10–15% expansion in the lattice dimensions. However, a metastable intermediate state similar to the uncleaved structure has been observed immediately after cleavage of the protein subunits. Some kind of additional physical stimulus seems to be required to trigger the major structural change, which appears to be highly cooperative.     

Letter: Capsid structure of bacteriophage lambda

The arrangement of capsomers in the capsid of phage λ has been investigated by electron micrography of negatively stained fragments of empty capsids, polyheads, and intact virions. The proposed structure is a composite T = 7 levo lattice, with hexamer and pentamer clustering of the D protein and trimer clustering of the E protein. Such a lattice requires that the λ capsid contain 420 copies of the D and E proteins, a number compatible with recent chemical determinations.     

Use of Ar+ plasma etching to localize structural proteins in the capsid of herpes simplex virus type 1.

Partially cored herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) capsids (B capsids) were eroded in a low-energy (0.5-keV) Ar+ ion plasma under conditions in which the outermost structural proteins were expected to be degraded before more internal ones. After various periods of etching, the proteins remaining intact were separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and determined quantitatively by densitometric scanning of the stained gels. The results showed that the major capsid polypeptide (VP5) and two other capsid proteins, VP19 and VP23, were degraded rapidly beginning as soon as capsids were exposed to the ion plasma. In contrast, significant lags were observed for erosion of VP21, VP22a, and VP24, suggesting that these proteins were available to accelerated ions only after other, more external structures had been damaged or eroded away. The results suggest that VP5, VP19, and VP23 are exposed on the surface of the capsid, while VP21, VP22a, and VP24 are found inside the capsid cavity. The experiments are consistent with the view that VP5 constitutes the major structural component of the hexavalent capsomers. It is proposed that VP19 and VP23 may form other surface structures such as the pentavalent capsomers, the capsid floor, or the intercapsomeric fibers.     

Cell-free assembly of the herpes simplex virus capsid.

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) capsids were found to assemble spontaneously in a cell-free system consisting of extracts prepared from insect cells that had been infected with recombinant baculoviruses coding for HSV-1 capsid proteins. The capsids formed in this system resembled native HSV-1 capsids in morphology as judged by electron microscopy, in sedimentation rate on sucrose density gradients, in protein composition, and in their ability to react with antibodies specific for the HSV-1 major capsid protein, VP5. Optimal capsid assembly required the presence of extracts containing capsid proteins VP5, VP19, VP23, VP22a, and the maturational protease (product of the UL26 gene). Assembly was more efficient at 27 degrees C than at 4 degrees C. The availability of a cell-free assay for HSV-1 capsid formation will be of help in identifying the morphogenetic steps that occur during capsid assembly in vivo and in evaluating candidate antiherpes therapeutics directed at capsid assembly.     

Molecular interactions of Epstein-Barr virus capsid proteins

The capsids of herpesviruses, which comprise major and minor capsid proteins, have a common icosahedral structure with 162 capsomers. An electron microscopic study shows that Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) capsids in the nucleus are immunolabeled by anti-BDLF1 and anti-BORF1 antibodies, indicating that BDLF1 and BORF1 are the minor capsid proteins of EBV. Cross-linking and electrophoresis studies of purified BDLF1 and BORF1 revealed that these two proteins form a triplex that is similar to that formed by the minor capsid proteins, VP19C and VP23, of herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1). Although the interaction between VP23, a homolog of BDLF1, and the major capsid protein VP5 could not be verified biochemically in earlier studies, the interaction between BDLF1 and the EBV major capsid protein, viral capsid antigen (VCA), can be confirmed by glutathione S-transferase (GST) pulldown assay and coimmunoprecipitation. Additionally, in HSV-1, VP5 interacts with only the middle region of VP19C; in EBV, VCA interacts with both the N-terminal and middle regions of BORF1, a homolog of VP19C, revealing that the proteins in the EBV triplex interact with the major capsid protein differently from those in HSV-1. A GST pulldown study also identifies the oligomerization domains in VCA and the dimerization domain in BDLF1. The results presented herein reveal how the EBV capsid proteins interact and thereby improve our understanding of the capsid structure of the virus.     

Effect of Formamide on the Capsid Morphology of Adenovirus Types 4 and 7

Treatment of adenovirus types 4 and 7 with formamide disrupted the virions, degrading the capsids into predominantly single capsomers. As shown by electron microscopic observation, disruption proceeded in the following sequence: (i) reduction of the electron density of the virions, suggesting release of an internal component; (ii) progressive cleavage of the capsid into two or more segments and the formation (type 7 only) of capsomer “sheets”; (iii) final cleavage of the capsid into single or groups of a few capsomers. The sequence appeared similar for both adenoviruses; for both types, the rate and extent of disruption were dependent on the formamide concentration, but type 7 was more easily disrupted than type 4 by short-term (5 to 10 sec) treatment at the low (10%) concentration. At 30% formamide, the intercapsomer bonds of either type were fully cleaved, and the capsids were completely degraded into predominantly single capsomers. Pretreatment with formaldehyde did not prevent this degradation. Under suitable conditions, virus-derived remnants can be observed among the breakdown products. These remnants have been shorn of capsomers and presumably represent intact internal nucleoprotein.     

Detecting small changes and additional peptides in the canine parvovirus capsid structure

Parvovirus capsids are assembled from multiple forms of a single protein and are quite stable structurally. However, in order to infect cells, conformational plasticity of the capsid is required and this likely involves the exposure of structures that are buried within the structural models. The presence of functional asymmetry in the otherwise icosahedral capsid has also been proposed. Here we examined the protein composition of canine parvovirus capsids and evaluated their structural variation and permeability by protease sensitivity, spectrofluorometry, and negative staining electron microscopy. Additional protein forms identified included an apparent smaller variant of the virus protein 1 (VP1) and a small proportion of a cleaved form of VP2. Only a small percentage of the proteins in intact capsids were cleaved by any of the proteases tested. The capsid susceptibility to proteolysis varied with temperature but new cleavages were not revealed. No global change in the capsid structure was observed by analysis of Trp fluorescence when capsids were heated between 40 degrees C and 60 degrees C. However, increased polarity of empty capsids was indicated by bis-ANS binding, something not seen for DNA-containing capsids. Removal of calcium with EGTA or exposure to pHs as low as 5.0 had little effect on the structure, but at pH 4.0 changes were revealed by proteinase K digestion. Exposure of viral DNA to the external environment started above 50 degrees C. Some negative stains showed increased permeability of empty capsids at higher temperatures, but no effects were seen after EGTA treatment.     

Role of the major capsid protein of phage T4 in DNA packaging from structure-function and site-directed mutagenesis studies

Heat cleavage of asp-pro peptide bonds was used to probe the primary structures of the Phage T4 major capsid protein precursor, gp23, its mature capsid form gp23*, and a DNA-dependent ATPase, called capsizyme. This analysis suggests that capsizyme is a gp23** resulting from the N-terminal processing found in gp23* as well as shortening at the C-terminus. Photoaffinity labeling with Azido-ATP and BrU-DNA, followed by heat cleavage, suggests binding sites for these compounds toward the C-terminus of gp23**, suggesting localization of functions within the gp23 primary sequence. Site-directed mutagenesis experiments were targeted therefore to the C-terminal end of g23 as well as to its processing sites. N-terminal processing site modification supports the consensus gp21 proteinase cleavage rule, whereas mutagenesis at the C-terminus suggests that the C-terminal alteration is unlikely to result from a gp21-morphogenesis proteinase cleavage. Amino acid replacements in gp23 at newly introduced amber sites reveal a new g23 mutant phenotype, defective partially DNA-filled heads, in support of the hypothesis that gp23 and its products function directly in the DNA packaging mechanism.     

DNA packaging of bacteriophage T4 proheads in vitro. Evidence that prohead expansion is not coupled to DNA packaging

We developed a system for DNA packaging of isolated bacteriophage T4 proheads in vitro and studied the role of prohead expansion in DNA packaging. Biologically active proheads have been purified from a number of packaging-deficient mutant extracts. The cleaved mature prohead is the active structural precursor for the DNA packaging reaction. Packaging of proheads requires ATP, Mg2+ and spermidine, and is stimulated by polyethylene glycol and dextran. Predominantly expanded proheads (ELPs) are produced at 37 degrees C and predominantly unexpanded proheads (ESPs) are produced at 20 degrees C. Both the expanded and unexpanded proheads are active in DNA packaging in vitro. This is based on the observations that (1) both ESPs and ELPs purified by chromatography on DEAE-Sephacel showed DNA packaging activity; (2) apparently homogeneous ELPs prepared by treatment with sodium dodecyl sulfate (which dissociates ESPs) retained significant biological activity; (3) specific precipitation of ELPs with anti-hoc immunoglobulin G resulted in loss of DNA packaging activity; and (4) ESPs upon expansion in vitro to ELPs retained packaging activity. Therefore, contrary to the models that couple DNA packaging to head expansion, in T4 the expansion and packaging appear to be independent, since the already expanded DNA-free proheads can be packaged in vitro. We therefore propose that the unexpanded to expanded prohead transition has evolved to stabilize the capsid and to reorganize the prohead shell functionally from a core-interacting to a DNA-interacting inner surface.