Comparative study on the chromophore binding sites of rod and red-sensitive cone visual pigments by use of synthetic retinal isomers and analogues

A comparative study on the chromophore (retinal) binding sites of the opsin (R-photopsin) from chicken red-sensitive cone visual pigment (iodopsin) and that scotopsin) from bovine rod pigment (rhodopsin) was made by the aid of geometric isomers of retinal (all-trans, 13-cis, 11-cis, 9-cis, and 7-cis) and retinal analogues including fluorinated (14-F, 12-F, 10-F, and 8-F) and methylated (12-methyl) 11-cis-retinals. The stereoselectivity of R-photopsin for the retinal isomers and analogues was almost identical with that of scotopsin, indicating that the shapes of the chromophore binding sites of both opsins are similar, although the former appears to be somewhat more restricted than the latter. The rates of pigment formation from R-photopsin were considerably greater than those from scotopsin. In addition, all the iodopsin isomers and analogues were more susceptible to hydroxylamine than were the rhodopsin ones. These observations suggest that the retinal binding site of iodopsin is located near the protein surface. On the basis of the spectral properties of fluorinated analogues, a polar group in the chromophore binding site of iodopsin as well as rhodopsin was estimated to be located near the hydrogen atom at the C10 position of the retinylidene chromophore. A large difference in wavelength between the absorption maxima of iodopsin and rhodopsin was significantly reduced in the 9-cis and 7-cis pigments. On the assumption that the retinylidene chromophore is anchored rigidly at the alpha-carbon of the lysine residue and loosely at the cyclohexenyl ring, each of the two isomers would have the Schiff-base nitrogen at a position altered from that of the 11-cis pigments.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Accessibility of the iodopsin chromophore.

Iodopsin can replace its chromophore (11-cis retinal) by added 9-cis retinal, resulting in the formation of isoiodopsin. NaBH4 bleaches iodopsin in the dark. In a relatively low concentration of digitonin, the scotopsin (the protein moiety of chicken rhodopsin) removes 11-cis retinal from iodopsin in the dark. These facts suggest that the linkage of the chromophore to opsin in the iodopsin molecule (presumably a Schiff-base linkage) is accessible to these reagents, which is different from the situation in rhodopsin.     

Spectral tuning in salamander visual pigments studied with dihydroretinal chromophores.

In visual pigments, opsin proteins regulate the spectral absorption of a retinal chromophore by mechanisms that change the energy level of the excited electronic state relative to the ground state. We have studied these mechanisms by using photocurrent recording to measure the spectral sensitivities of individual red rods and red (long-wavelength-sensitive) and blue (short-wavelength-sensitive) cones of salamander before and after replacing the native 3-dehydro 11-cis retinal chromophore with retinal analogs: 11-cis retinal, 3-dehydro 9-cis retinal, 9-cis retinal, and 5,6-dihydro 9-cis retinal. The protonated Schiff's bases of analogs with unsaturated bonds in the ring had broader spectra than the same chromophores bound to opsins. Saturation of the bonds in the ring reduced the spectral bandwidths of the protonated Schiff's bases and the opsin-bound chromophores and made them similar to each other. This indicates that torsion of the ring produces spectral broadening and that torsion is limited by opsin. Saturating the 5,6 double bond in retinal reduced the perturbation of the chromophore by opsin in red and in blue cones but not in red rods. Thus an interaction between opsin and the chromophoric ring shifts the spectral maxima of the red and blue cone pigments, but not that of the red rod pigment.     

Breaking the covalent bond--a pigment property that contributes to desensitization in cones

Retinal rod and cone pigments consist of an apoprotein, opsin, covalently linked to a chromophore, 11-cis retinal. Here we demonstrate that the formation of the covalent bond between opsin and 11-cis retinal is reversible in darkness in amphibian red cones, but essentially irreversible in red rods. This dissociation, apparently a general property of cone pigments, results in a surprisingly large amount of free opsin--about 10% of total opsin--in dark-adapted red cones. We attribute this significant level of free opsin to the low concentration of intracellular free 11-cis retinal, estimated to be only a tiny fraction (approximately 0.1 %) of the pigment content in red cones. With its constitutive transducin-stimulating activity, the free cone opsin produces an approximately 2-fold desensitization in red cones, equivalent to that produced by a steady light causing 500 photoisomerizations s-1. Cone pigment dissociation therefore contributes to the sensitivity difference between rods and cones.     

Effect of anion binding on the thermal reverse reaction of bathoiodopsin: anion stabilizes two forms of iodopsin

The thermal reactions of the bathoproduct of the long wavelength sensitive visual pigment iodopsin were investigated under various anionic and environmental conditions, to get an insight into the mechanism leading to the unusual thermal isomerization of the retinal chromophore from the trans to the 11-cis form at very low temperatures (-160 degrees C). The all-trans chromophore of the bathoiodopsin produced from iodopsin in the presence of chloride thermally reverted to the 11-cis form, while in the presence of nitrate it kept its all-trans configuration upon warming. Different protein environments, either in a detergent or in phosphatidylcholine (PC) liposomes, did not change the reaction characteristics of the bathoiodopsins under the two anionic conditions. However, reaction characteristics of bathoiodopsins produced in the absence of small anions were dependent on the environment. The trans-to-cis isomerization occurred upon warming of bathoiodopsin in the presence of detergent but not in liposomes. Spectral measurements revealed that iodopsin in the absence of small anions is a mixture of two spectrally distinct forms that exhibit absorption maxima and reaction characteristics similar to those of chloride-bound and nitrate-bound iodopsins, respectively. Thus, iodopsin exhibits two conformational states, each of which is stabilized by the binding of chloride and nitrate, respectively.     

Regeneration of bovine and octopus opsins in situ with natural and artificial retinals

We consider the problem of color regulation in visual pigments for both bovine rhodopsin (lambda max = 500 nm) and octopus rhodopsin (lambda max = 475 nm). Both pigments have 11-cis-retinal (lambda max = 379 nm, in ethanol) as their chromophore. These rhodopsins were bleached in their native membranes, and the opsins were regenerated with natural and artificial chromophores. Both bovine and octopus opsins were regenerated with the 9-cis- and 11-cis-retinal isomers, but the octopus opsin was additionally regenerated with the 13-cis and all-trans isomers. Titration of the octopus opsin with 11-cis-retinal gave an extinction coefficient for octopus rhodopsin of 27,000 +/- 3000 M-1 cm-1 at 475 nm. The absorption maxima of bovine artificial pigments formed by regenerating opsin with the 11-cis dihydro series of chromophores support a color regulation model for bovine rhodopsin in which the chromophore-binding site of the protein has two negative charges: one directly hydrogen bonded to the Schiff base nitrogen and another near carbon-13. Formation of octopus artificial pigments with both all-trans and 11-cis dihydro chromophores leads to a similar model for octopus rhodopsin and metarhodopsin: there are two negative charges in the chromophore-binding site, one directly hydrogen bonded to the Schiff base nitrogen and a second near carbon-13. The interaction of this second charge with the chromophore in octopus rhodopsin is weaker than in bovine, while in metarhodopsin it is as strong as in bovine.     

Multiple visual pigments in a photoreceptor of the salamander retina

Although a given retina typically contains several visual pigments, each formed from a retinal chromophore bound to a specific opsin protein, single photoreceptor cells have been thought to express only one type of opsin. This design maximizes a cell''s sensitivity to a particular wavelength band and facilitates wavelength discrimination in retinas that process color. We report electrophysiological evidence that the ultraviolet-sensitive cone of salamander violates this rule. This cell contains three different functional opsins. The three opsins could combine with the two different chromophores present in salamander retina to form six visual pigments. Whereas rods and other cones of salamander use both chromophores, they appear to express only one type of opsin per cell. In visual pigment absorption spectra, the bandwidth at half-maximal sensitivity increases as the pigment''s wavelength maximum decreases. However, the bandwidth of the UV-absorbing pigment deviates from this trend; it is narrow like that of a red-absorbing pigment. In addition, the UV-absorbing pigment has a high apparent photosensitivity when compared with that of red- and blue-absorbing pigments and rhodopsin. These properties suggest that the mechanisms responsible for spectrally tuning visual pigments separate two absorption bands as the wavelength of maximal sensitivity shifts from UV to long wavelengths.     

Synthetic pigment analogues of the purple membrane protein.

Nonphysiological analogues of retinal have been shown to form pigments in reactions with the apoprotein of the purple membrane of Halobacterium halobium. Both the all-trans and 13-cis isomers of a retinal analogue, having an elongated chain with an extra double bond, formed pigments. Unlike the native all-trans and 13-cis retinal1-based pigments, the new pigments were not interconvertible with each other and were unstable against hydroxylamine. When incorporated into phospholipid vesicles, they showed no proton pumping activity upon illumination. The ability of the extended-length retinal to form pigments contrasts with its nonreactivity with opsin (apoprotein of rhodopsin), suggesting a less stringent binding site for the purple membrane chromophore. All-trans retinal2 also combined with bleached purple membrane to form a blue pigment absorbing at ca. 590 nm. Like the native purple membrane, the blu membrane showed proton pumping activity upon illumination in phospholipid vesicles.     

Amphioxus homologs of Go-coupled rhodopsin and peropsin having 11-cis- and all-trans-retinals as their chromophores

Because of low contents in the native organs and failure of the expression in cultured cells, the chromophore configurations of the pigments in Go-coupled opsin and peropsin groups in the opsin family are unknown. Here we have succeeded in expression of the amphioxus homologs of these groups in HEK293s cells and found that they can be regenerated with 11-cis- and all-trans-retinals, respectively. Light isomerized the chromophores of these opsins into the all-trans and 11-cis forms, respectively. The results strongly suggest that the physiological function of peropsin would be a retinal photoisomerase, while 11-cis configuration is necessary for the Go-coupled opsin groups.     

Occupancy of the chromophore binding site of opsin activates visual transduction in rod photoreceptors

The retinal analogue beta-ionone was used to investigate possible physiological effects of the noncovalent interaction between rod opsin and its chromophore 11-cis retinal. Isolated salamander rod photoreceptors were exposed to bright light that bleached a significant fraction of their pigment, were allowed to recover to a steady state, and then were exposed to beta-ionone. Our experiments show that in bleach-adapted rods beta-ionone causes a decrease in light sensitivity and dark current and an acceleration of the dim flash photoresponse and the rate constants of guanylyl cyclase and cGMP phosphodiesterase. Together, these observations indicate that in bleach-adapted rods beta-ionone activates phototransduction in the dark. Control experiments showed no effect of beta-ionone in either fully dark-adapted or background light-adapted cells, indicating direct interaction of beta-ionone with the free opsin produced by bleaching. We speculate that beta-ionone binds specifically in the chromophore pocket of opsin to produce a complex that is more catalytically potent than free opsin alone. We hypothesize that a similar reaction may occur in the intact retina during pigment regeneration. We propose a model of rod pigment regeneration in which binding of 11-cis retinal to opsin leads to activation of the complex accompanied by a decrease in light sensitivity. The subsequent covalent attachment of retinal to opsin completely inactivates opsin and leads to the recovery of sensitivity. Our findings resolve the conflict between biochemical and physiological data concerning the effect of the occupancy of the chromophore binding site on the catalytic potency of opsin. We show that binding of beta-ionone to rod opsin produces effects opposite to its previously described effects on cone opsin. We propose that this distinction is due to a fundamental difference in the interaction of rod and cone opsins with retinal, which may have implications for the different physiology of the two types of photoreceptors.     

Photosensitivity of 10-substituted visual pigment analogues: detection of a specific secondary opsin-retinal interaction

The photosensitivities of the bovine rhodopsin and gecko pigment 521 analogues regenerated from C-10-substituted analogues of 11-cis- and 9-cis-retinals were determined by two different methods. A similar reactivity trend was noted for both pigment systems as revealed in the photosensitivity of the gecko pigments and relative quantum yields of the bovine analogues. The 10-fluoro-11-cis photopigments had a photosensitivity less than, but approaching, that of the native (11-cis) visual pigment while the 10-fluoro-9-cis photopigments had a much lower photosensitivity than the parent 9-cis regenerated pigment. The results are interpreted in terms of recently described models of rhodopsin architecture and of the primary molecular reaction of visual pigments to light. The unusually low photoreactivity of the 10-fluoro-9-cis pigment molecule is viewed as the result of a regiospecific hydrogen-bonding interaction of the electronegative fluorine atom to the opsin.     

Isomerization and oxidation of vitamin a in cone-dominant retinas: a novel pathway for visual-pigment regeneration in daylight

The first step toward light perception is 11-cis to all-trans photoisomerization of the retinaldehyde chromophore in a rod or cone opsin-pigment molecule. Light sensitivity of the opsin pigment is restored through a multistep pathway called the visual cycle, which effects all-trans to 11-cis re-isomerization of the retinoid chromophore. The maximum throughput of the known visual cycle, however, is too slow to explain sustained photosensitivity in bright light. Here, we demonstrate three novel enzymatic activities in cone-dominant ground-squirrel and chicken retinas: an all-trans-retinol isomerase, an 11-cis-retinyl-ester synthase, and an 11-cis-retinol dehydrogenase. Together these activities comprise a novel pathway that regenerates opsin photopigments at a rate 20-fold faster than the known visual cycle. We suggest that this pathway is responsible for sustained daylight vision in vertebrates.     

Thermal activation and photoactivation of visual pigments

A visual pigment molecule in a retinal photoreceptor cell can be activated not only by absorption of a photon but also "spontaneously" by thermal energy. Current estimates of the activation energies for these two processes in vertebrate rod and cone pigments are on the order of 40-50 kcal/mol for activation by light and 20-25 kcal/mol for activation by heat, which has forced the conclusion that the two follow quite different molecular routes. It is shown here that the latter estimates, derived from the temperature dependence of the rate of pigment-initiated "dark events" in rods, depend on the unrealistic assumption that thermal activation of a complex molecule like rhodopsin (or even its 11-cis retinaldehyde chromophore) happens through a simple process, somewhat like the collision of gas molecules. When the internal energy present in the many vibrational modes of the molecule is taken into account, the thermal energy distribution of the molecules cannot be described by Boltzmann statistics, and conventional Arrhenius analysis gives incorrect estimates for the energy barrier. When the Boltzmann distribution is replaced by one derived by Hinshelwood for complex molecules with many vibrational modes, the same experimental data become consistent with thermal activation energies that are close to or even equal to the photoactivation energies. Thus activation by light and by heat may in fact follow the same molecular route, starting with 11-cis to all-trans isomerization of the chromophore in the native (resting) configuration of the opsin. Most importantly, the same model correctly predicts the empirical correlation between the wavelength of maximum absorbance and the rate of thermal activation in the whole set of visual pigments studied.     

Halorhodopsin and sensory rhodopsin contain a C6-C7 s-trans retinal chromophore.

Halorhodopsin (HR) and sensory rhodopsin (SR) have been regenerated with retinal analogues that are covalently locked in the 6-s-cis or 6-s-trans conformations. Both pigments regenerate more completely with the locked 6-s-trans retinal and produce analogue pigments with absorption maxima (577 nm for HR and 592 nm for SR) nearly identical to those of the native pigments (577 and 587 nm). This indicates that HR and SR bind retinal in the 6-s-trans conformation. The opsin shift for the locked 6-s-trans analogue in HR is 1,200 cm-1 less than that for the native chromophore (5,400 cm-1). The opsin shift for the 6-s-trans analogue in SR is 1,100 cm-1 less than that for the native retinal (5,700 cm-1). This demonstrates that approximately 20% of the opsin shift in these pigments arises from a protein-induced change in the chromophore conformation from twisted 6-s-cis in solution to planar 6-s-trans in the protein. The reduced opsin shift observed for the locked 6-s-cis analogue pigments compared with the locked 6-s-trans pigments may be due to a positive electrostatic perturbation near C7.     

Raman microscope and quantum yield studies on the primary photochemistry of A2-visual pigments.

The 77-K resonance Raman vibrational spectrum of intact goldfish rod photoreceptors containing 3,4-dehydro (A2) retinal is dominated by scattering from the 9-cis component of the steady state at all excitation wavelengths. Intact goldfish photoreceptors were regenerated with an A1-retinal chromophore to determine whether this behavior is caused by the protein or the chromophore. The resulting Raman spectrum was typical of an A1-pigment exhibiting significant scattering from all three components of the steady state: rhodopsin, bathorhodopsin, and isorhodopsin. Furthermore, regeneration of bovine opsin with A2-retinal produces a characteristic "A2-Raman spectrum" that is dominated by scattering from the 9-cis pigment. We conclude that the differences between the Raman spectra of the A1-and A2-pigments are caused by some intrinsic difference in the photochemical properties of the retinal chromophores. To quantitate these observations, the 77-K adsorption spectra and the photochemical quantum yields (phi) of the native A2-goldfish and the regenerated A2-bovine pigments were measured. In the goldfish A2-pigment, the value of phi 4 (9-cis----trans) is 0.05; phi 3 (trans----9-cis) is 0.10; and phi 2 (trans----11-cis) is 0.35. By contrast, in the bovine A1-pigment, these quantum yields are 0.10, 0.053, and 0.50, respectively. The reduced value of phi 4 and the increased value of phi 3 in the goldfish pigment confirms that the 9-cis isomer is photochemically more stable in A2-pigments.     

The 3, 4-didehydroretinal chromophore of goldfish porphyropsin

The isomeric configuration of the 3,4-didehydroretinal chromophore of goldfish porphyropsin was determined by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and by the regeneration of this visual pigment with authentic isomers of 3,4-didehydroretinal. A nonisomerizing, quantitative method using hydroxylamine and methylene chloride was employed to extract the 3,4-didehyroretinal chromophore from the rod outer segment membrane (containing the porphyropsin). When this extracted chromophore was injected into the HPLC, only a single major peak was observed and this peak coeluted with the authentic 11-cis 3,4-didehydroretinyl oxime. This suggests that the chromophore of goldfish porphyropsin is 11-cis 3,4-didehydroretinal. When the bleached rod outer segments (containing the opsin) were incubated with different 3,4-didehydroretinal isomers (13-cis, 11-cis, 9-cis, and all-trans), only the 11-cis isomer resulted in the degeneration of porphyropsin. This also suggests that the porphyropsin chromophore exists in the 11-cis configuration.     

Photoisomerization efficiency in UV-absorbing visual pigments: protein-directed isomerization of an unprotonated retinal Schiff base

A visual pigment consists of an opsin protein and a chromophore, 11-cis-retinal, which binds to a specific lysine residue of opsin via a Schiff base linkage. The Schiff base chromophore is protonated in pigments that absorb visible light, whereas it is unprotonated in ultraviolet-absorbing visual pigments (UV pigments). To investigate whether an unprotonated Schiff base can undergo photoisomerization as efficiently as a protonated Schiff base in the opsin environment, we measured the quantum yields of the bovine rhodopsin E113Q mutant, in which the Schiff base is unprotonated at alkaline pH, and the mouse UV pigment (mouse UV). Photosensitivities of UV pigments were measured by irradiation of the pigments followed by chromophore extraction and HPLC analysis. Extinction coefficients were estimated by comparing the maximum absorbances of the original pigments and their acid-denatured states. The quantum yield of the bovine rhodopsin E113Q mutant at pH 8.2, where the Schiff base is unprotonated, was significantly lower than that of wild-type rhodopsin, whereas the mutant gave a quantum yield almost identical to that of the wild type at pH 5.5, where the Schiff base is protonated. These results suggest that Schiff base protonation plays a role in increasing quantum yield. The quantum yield of mouse UV, which has an unprotonated Schiff base chromophore, was significantly higher than that of the unprotonated form of the rhodopsin E113Q mutant, although it was still lower than the visible-absorbing pigments. These results suggest that the mouse UV pigment has a specific mechanism for the efficient photoisomerization of its unprotonated Schiff base chromophore.     

Vertebrate ancient-long opsin has molecular properties intermediate between those of vertebrate and invertebrate visual pigments

VA/VAL opsin is one of the four kinds of nonvisual opsins that are closely related to vertebrate visual pigments in the phylogenetic tree of opsins. Previous studies indicated that among these opsins, parapinopsin and pinopsin exhibit molecular properties similar to those of invertebrate bistable visual pigments and vertebrate visual pigments, respectively. Here we show that VA/VAL opsin exhibits molecular properties intermediate between those of parapinopsin and pinopsin. VAL opsin from Xenopus tropicalis was expressed in cultured cells, and the pigment with an absorption maximum at 501 nm was reconstituted by incubation with 11-cis-retinal. Light irradiation of this pigment caused cis-to-trans isomerization of the chromophore to form a state having an absorption maximum in the visible region. This state has the ability to activate Gi and Gt types of G proteins. Therefore, the active state of VAL opsin is a visible light-absorbing intermediate, which probably has a protonated retinylidene Schiff base as its chromophore, like the active state of parapinopsin. However, this state was apparently photoinsensitive and did not show reverse reaction to the original pigment, unlike the active state of parapinopsin, and instead similar to that of pinopsin. Furthermore, the Gi activation efficiency of VAL opsin was between those of pinopsin and parapinopsin. Thus, the molecular properties of VA/VAL opsin give insights into the mechanism of conversion of the molecular properties from invertebrate to vertebrate visual pigments.     

Photochemistry of the primary event in short-wavelength visual opsins at low temperature.

Two short-wavelength cone opsins, frog (Xenopus laevis) violet and mouse UV, were expressed in mammalian COS1 cells, purified in delipidated form, and studied using cryogenic UV-vis spectrophotometry. At room temperature, the X. laevis violet opsin has an absorption maximum at 426 nm when generated with 11-cis-retinal and an absorption maximum of 415 nm when generated with 9-cis-retinal. The frog short-wavelength opsin has two different batho intermediates, one stable at 30 K (lambda(max) approximately 446 nm) and the other at 70 K (lambda(max) approximately 475 nm). Chloride ions do not affect the absorption maximum of the violet opsin. At room temperature, mouse UV opsin has an absorption maximum of 357 nm, while at 70 K, the pigment exhibits a bathochromic shift to 403 nm with distinct vibronic structure and a strong secondary vibronic band at 380 nm. We have observed linear relationships when analyzing the energy difference between the initial and bathochromic intermediates and the normalized difference spectra of the batho-shifted intermediates of rod and cone opsins. We conclude that the binding sites of these pigments change from red to green to violet via systematic shifts in the position of the primary counterion relative to the protonated Schiff base. The mouse UV cone opsin does not fit this trend, and we conclude that wavelength selection in this pigment must operate via a different molecular mechanism. We discuss the possibility that the mouse UV chromophore is initially unprotonated.     

Synthesis of the all-trans-retinal chromophore of retinal G protein-coupled receptor opsin in cultured pigment epithelial cells.

Light-dependent production of 11-cis-retinal by the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and normal regeneration of rhodopsin under photic conditions involve the RPE retinal G protein-coupled receptor (RGR) opsin. This microsomal opsin is bound to all-trans-retinal which, upon illumination, isomerizes stereospecifically to the 11-cis isomer. In this paper, we investigate the synthesis of the all-trans-retinal chromophore of RGR in cultured ARPE-hRGR and freshly isolated bovine RPE cells. Exogenous all-trans-[(3)H]retinol is incorporated into intact RPE cells and converted mainly into retinyl esters and all-trans-retinal. The intracellular processing of all-trans-[(3)H]retinol results in physiological binding to RGR of a radiolabeled retinoid, identified as all-trans-[(3)H]retinal. The ARPE-hRGR cells contain a membrane-bound NADPH-dependent retinol dehydrogenase that reacts efficiently with all-trans-retinol but not the 11-cis isomer. The NADPH-dependent all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase activity in isolated RPE microsomal membranes can be linked in vitro to specific binding of the chromophore to RGR. These findings provide confirmation that RGR opsin binds the chromophore, all-trans-retinal, in the dark. A novel all-trans-retinol dehydrogenase exists in the RPE and performs a critical function in chromophore biosynthesis.