Importance of NKG2D-NKG2D ligands interaction for cytolytic activity of natural killer cell

In this study, we investigate the relationship between natural killer (NK) cell susceptibility and the surface markers of cancer cells. Through phenotypic analysis, we found evidence that more susceptible cancer cell lines (K562 and Jurkat) express more NKG2D ligands. Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I chain-related A/B (MIC-A/B) and UL16 binding protein (ULBP) 1-5 molecules are typical ligands of NKG2D. The high killing activity of NK cells against K562 was abolished through the addition of a NKG2D blocking antibody. Upon in vitro stimulation with quercetin, low susceptible cancer cells increased NKG2D ligand expression, leading to enhancement of NK cell cytolytic activity. These results suggested that the anti-cancer activity of NK cells is not dependent on the origin and growth style of the target cells, but is dependent on the surface markers of the target cells.     

Analysis of mechanisms by which NK cells acquire increased cytotoxicity against class I MHC-eliminated targets

Acid treatment, where cells are exposed to 0.2 M citric acid buffer at pH 3 for 2 min, was described in a previous paper to be a method which specifically eliminates class I MHC antigens from the membrane of viable cells. We applied this method to characterize functional roles of class I MHC antigens on the target cells in NK cell cytotoxicity. When NK target cells, U937, Molt-4, and Raji, were subjected to acid treatment, the treated cells lost their surface class I MHC antigens and became more sensitive to NK cell killing. On the other hand, the susceptibility of K562 cells which initially lacked class I MHC antigens did not significantly change after such treatment. We then examined the mechanism which enables NK cells to become more cytotoxic against class I MHC antigen-eliminated target cells. Single cell binding assay and cold target inhibition assay demonstrated that class I MHC antigen-eliminated target cells did not acquire high binding affinity to NK cells. However, the interaction between NK cells and class I MHC antigen-eliminated targets resulted in a greater increase in production of NKCF-like factor than did the interaction between NK cells and untreated targets. Class I MHC antigen-eliminated targets did not acquire high killer susceptibility to NKCF-like factor. The present study utilizing the acid treatment method confirmed that surface class I MHC antigens on the targets are important immunoregulatory molecules not only for cytotoxic T lymphocytes but also for NK cells and elucidated some of the underlying mechanisms.     

Adriamycin induced resistance of sensitive K 562 cells to natural killer lymphocyte attack

Summary The effect of Adriamycin (ADM) on eryhtroleukaemia K 562 cell susceptibility to human natural killer (NK) cell activity has been studied. When cultivated for 3 days in the presence of 10 to 40 nM ADM, K 562 cells decreased their susceptibility to NK-mediated lysis in a dose-dependent fashion. At a concentration of 40 nM, previously found to induce optimal differentiation-associated properties in K 562 cells, the induced resistance to NK-mediated lysis increased progressively from day 1 to day 3 of culture. ADM treatment did not induce K 562 cells to release factors which interfered with NK activity since supernatants from ADM-treated K 562 cell cultures caused no significant modification in the NK lytic process. Binding to NK of ADM-treated K 562 cells was unaffected since treated and untreated cells had identical capacities in a conjugate-forming cell assay or adsorption of NK cells on target cell monolayers. In cold target competition assays ADM-treated K 562 cells acted as more effective competitors than untreated K 562 cells. These observations imply that the reduced killing of the ADM-treated K 562 cells was independent of target-NK cell recognition, and suggest that ADM treatment could allow malignant cells to escape NK surveillance.     

Modulation of natural cytotoxicity by alloantibodies. V. The mechanism of a selective augmenting effect of anti-H-2 antisera on the natural killer activity of mouse spleen cells

Treatment of mouse spleen cells with specific anti-H-2 antisera augments their natural killer (NK) activity against K562 cells but not against YAC target tumor cells. The same population of natural killer cells was found to lyse K562 as well as YAC target cells, since (a) depletion of YAC reactive NK cells by absorption on YAC monolayers resulted in a concomitant depletion of anti-K562 NK activity of mouse spleen cells, and (b) both K562 and YAC cells could inhibit their own as well as each others lysis in a cross-competition assay. Anti-H-2 antiserum could not induce anti-K562 NK activity in spleen cells previously depleted of NK cells by absorption on YAC monolayers, indicating that alloantiserum does not act by recruiting otherwise nonreactive cells to become cytotoxic toward K562 target cells. In a target-binding assay, K562 binding of NK cells (T-cell-, B-cell-, and macrophage-depleted spleen cells) increased five- to eightfold in the presence of anti-H-2 antiserum whereas YAC cells binding of NK cells was not increased. H-2 antigens per se did not appear to be involved in the alloantisera effect since anti-NK antiserum directed against a non-H-2 antigen selectively expressed on NK cells, showed a similar selective NK enhancing effect. Protein A, a reagent which binds to the Fc region of immunoglobulin molecules, completely blocked the alloantiserum induced augmentation of anti-K562 NK activity, but did not alter basal NK activity. Moreover, the F(ab)₂ fraction of alloantibodies failed to enhance anti-K562 cytotoxic activity of mouse spleen cells, indicating a crucial role for the Fc portion of the alloantibodies attached to the NK cells, in NK augmentation. Utilization of several target cell lines with or without membrane Fc receptors (FcR) revealed that alloantiserum enhanced the lysis of only FcR⁺ target cells. It is proposed that alloantibody-coated NK cells, as a result of a secondary interaction between attached alloantibody and Fc receptors on target cells, interact more readily with the target cells and thereby cause a higher level of lytic activity.     

Human natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes require cell surface carbohydrate determinants for lytic function

Cloned and uncloned populations of natural killer (NK) cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) were treated with tunicamycin, an antibiotic that inhibits N-linked glycosylation, in order to study the potential role of cell surface carbohydrate determinants in lytic function. It is shown that tunicamycin-treated NK and CTL effector cells lose killer function in a dose-dependent manner. This effect is reversible; cells washed free of tunicamycin begin to recover their killer activity within 2 to 3 days after initial treatment. Conjugate experiments indicate that killer-target cell binding is not affected by tunicamycin treatment of the NK cells. It is also shown that tunicamycin treatment of target cells does not significantly affect their ability to be lysed by NK or CTL effector cells. These studies provide evidence that carbohydrate determinants are important in the lytic mechanism of both CTL and NK cells, rather than in specific effector-target cell binding.     

Phospholipase C treatment of certain human target cells reduces their susceptibility to NK lysis without affecting binding or sensitivity to lytic granules.

Phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) is an enzyme that has the capacity to release glycosyl-phosphatidyl inositol (G-PI)-anchored proteins from the cells surface. Pretreatment of the human T-cell leukemia cell line Molt-4 with PI-PLC resulted in a decrease in the susceptibility to lysis by natural killer (NK) cells. Treatment of the erythroleukemia cell line K562 with PI-PLC had no effect on its NK susceptibility. PI-PLC-treated and untreated Molt-4 bound equally well to lymphocytes in target-binding studies with effector cell preparations enriched for NK cells. Susceptibility to cytolytic granules isolated from rat LGL tumor cells remained the same after treatment of Molt-4 or K562 with PI-PLC. Combined treatment of Molt-4 with PI-PLC and rlFN-alpha or rlFN-gamma resulted in additive reductions of the NK susceptibility, suggesting that PI-PLC and interferons act on different mechanisms to protect cells from NK lysis. When expression of a number of antigens on Molt-4 and K562 was analyzed in flow cytometry, only the expression of CD58 was reduced after PI-PLC treatment. The susceptibility of Con A blasts to MLR derived cytotoxic T-cells was not altered by treatment with phospholipase. These data suggest that PI-PLC treatment reduces the capacity of some target cells to activate NK cells upon contract. The mechanism behind this phenomenon is presently unclear.     

Interferon-gamma-treated K562 target cells distinguish functional NK cells from lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells

In vitro incubation of the erythroleukemic cell line K562 with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) renders these cells relatively resistant to natural killer (NK) cell lysis. However, such treatment does not alter their sensitivity to LAK cell lysis. Thus, the lytic susceptibility of interferon-gamma-treated K562 (I-K562) cells to LAK cells as opposed to its relative resistance to NK cell lysis provides a functional assay to help distinguish these two types of effector cells. The relative resistance of I-K562 for NK cell-mediated lysis was not secondary to the release of soluble factors or the frequency of Leu-19+, CD3+ T cells, residual IFN-gamma, or expression of MHC Class I molecules. Coincubation of I-K562 cells with NK or LAK cells overnight did not appreciably change the pattern of lytic responses against K562 and I-K562 target cells. However, incubation of PBMC in vitro with I-K562 but not native K562 in the presence of r-IL-2 leads to a marked decrease in the generation of LAK cells. The inhibition of LAK cell generation was not secondary to differences in the consumption of bioactive levels of IL-2. Differences in the lytic capability of NK and LAK effector cells suggest heterogeneity among cells that mediate such non-MHC-restricted lysis. Use was made of cells from a patient with a large granular lymphocyte lymphoproliferative disease (greater than 85% Leu-19+) to determine if such cells could be used to distinguish clonal population of cells which would represent NK or LAK cell function. Of interest was the finding that such cells, even after incubation in vitro with IL-2, showed lytic function representative of NK cells but not LAK cells. Data concerning the inhibition of LAK cell generation by I-K562 cells have important implications for future therapeutic trials of IFN-gamma and IL-2 in the treatment of human malignancies.     

Synergistic effects of phorbol ester and interferon-alpha: target cell class I HLA antigen expression and resistance to natural killer and lymphokine-activated killer cell-mediated cytolysis

This study was undertaken to investigate whether target cell class I HLA antigen expression induced by phorbol ester and interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha) was associated with resistance to natural killer (NK) cells and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Class I antigen expression on the surface of the K562 erythroleukemia cell line was enhanced by either IFN-alpha or phorbol ester (PDBu). Addition of PDBu together with IFN-alpha had a synergistic effect on class I antigen expression on the cells. Furthermore, synergism between IFN-alpha and PDBu was also found in class I antigen expression by MOLT-3 cells. This synergistic effect on class I antigen expression was blocked by the protein synthesis inhibitor (cycloheximide). Pretreatment of K562 cells with PDBu and IFN-alpha made them more resistant to lysis by NK and LAK cells than did either PDBu or IFN-alpha. In contrast to PDBu, 4 alpha PDD, a biologically inactive phorbol analogue, alone or combination with IFN-alpha, had no effect on class I antigen expression and susceptibility to lysis by NK and LAK cells. Kinetic experiments showed an inverse relationship between the expression of class I antigens and susceptibility to NK cell-mediated cytolysis. Using cold target competition analysis, target cells pretreated with PDBu and IFN-alpha clearly competed less effectively than did untreated cells for lysis of untreated target cells. These results demonstrate that target cells pretreated with PDBu and IFN-alpha decrease their sensitivity to natural killer and lymphokine-activated killer cells inversely with target cell class I HLA antigen expression.     

Analysis of the mechanisms involved in NK resistance induced by a new tumor factor NK-RIF

The mechanisms involved in susceptibility or resistance of neoplasic cells to lysis by NK cells are not well known. We have recently described a 12-kDa factor (NK-RIF), produced and released by different tumor cell lines, making K562 resistant to NK lysis without affecting the cytotoxic function of NK effector cells. In this paper we further study the mechanism involved in NK resistance of K562 mediated by NK-RIF and its biological implications. The results show that NK-RIF does not affect the binding capacity of target and effector cells nor the levels of HLA class I antigen expression on the target cells, as a proof that resistance to NK-mediated lysis is not always associated with a defect in target effector binding or with an increased MHC class I antigen expression. However NK-RIF-treated K562 loses its capacity to induce NK cell activation and the subsequent capacity to release NKCF and makes K562 resistant to lysis by NKCF. Therefore our results show that induction of resistance to NK cytotoxicity can be the result of the modulation of target structures responsible for inducing effector cell activation without affecting target/effector binding molecules. This indicates that the structures involved in adherence and activation of NK cells have a different nature and that molecules other than HLA participate in NK resistance.     

Identification of a human natural killer cell target cell antigen with monoclonal antibodies

mAb have been derived against NK cell-sensitive target cells in an effort to identify the target cell structure involved in Ag recognition by NK cells. Several mAb were selected for further study based on their preliminary target cell binding characteristics. Flow cytometry demonstrated that each of these mAb bound to a series of NK-sensitive target cells of various origins (e.g., K562 and Molt-4) while having little or no reactivity with several NK-resistant target cell lines (e.g., SB and Daudi). Functional studies revealed that two of the mAb were able to inhibit the lysis of NK-sensitive K562 target cells by freshly isolated, endogenous NK cells in a dose-dependent fashion. Further, these mAb also could inhibit the killing of K562 target cells by both activated NK cells and cultured lymphokine-activated killer cells, as well as the cytolysis of other NK-sensitive target cells by each of these effector cell populations. Control experiments with another mAb which bound to the target cells but did not inhibit lysis implied that the effects of these mAb on NK cell function was not the result of steric hindrance. Single cell conjugate assays demonstrated that the mAb inhibited NK cell lysis via the inhibition of binding (recognition). Biochemical analysis of this target cell structure revealed that it was a molecule of approximately 42 kDa which may exist as a homodimer in its native state. Thus, it appears that the mAbs identify an unique Ag on the surface of NK cell-sensitive target cells which is involved in NK cell Ag recognition.     

Anti-idiotype antibodies to the 9.1C3 blocking antibody used to probe the lethal hit stage of NK cell-mediated cytolysis

We previously described a monoclonal antibody, 9.1C3, which blocked natural killer (NK) cell-mediated cytolysis by acting on effector cells during a late step in the lethal hit stage. The present work describes the production in rabbits of anti-idiotypic (anti-id) antibodies to the 9.1C3 antibody. In addition to reacting specifically with the 9.1C3 antibody, the anti-id antibodies bound strongly to the K562 target cell. The anti-id antibodies blocked killing of K562 targets by NK, antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, and NK-like cells but did not inhibit killing by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Pretreatment of cells and washing before assay indicated that blocking occurred at the target cell level. Of particular interest, single cell assays with Percoll-enriched large granular lymphocytes demonstrated that the antibodies caused no reduction in binding. These data are consistent with a model for NK cell-mediated lysis that involves a secondary target cell receptor independent of the primary NK-target cell interaction. The anti-id antibodies immunoprecipitated cell surface proteins of relative m.w. 79K and 62K unreduced, and 94K and 79K reduced from K562 target cells. The development of anti-id antibodies may be a useful procedure to explore the structure and function of cellular receptors involved in NK cell-mediated cytolysis.     

Long-term killing of natural killer-resistant target cells by interferon-alpha-, interferon-gamma-, and interleukin-2-activated natural killer cells

The sensitivity of target cells to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated cytotoxicity was investigated. Five target cell lines were examined for susceptibility to killing by activated NK cells in a 4-hour cytotoxicity assay: one of them (K562) was highly sensitive, while the other four were resistant. However, the four NK-resistant target cell lines were fully susceptible to lysis when the assay was extended to 24 h. The cytotoxic cells that killed the NK-resistant target cells in a 24-hour assay were plastic- and nylon wool-nonadherent human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) and their cytotoxicity was increased by interferon-alpha, interferon-gamma, and interleukin-2. Further, the cytotoxic activity of PBMC in the long-term assay was associated with large granular lymphocytes purified on a Percoll gradient, that killed the NK-sensitive cell line K562 in a 4-hour assay. All of the above are general criteria to qualify the cytotoxic cells as NK cells. Thus, the NK-resistant phenotype may not reflect absolute immunity to NK-mediated lysis, but it may reflect the different rates at which various target cell lines can be killed.     

Preparation of target antigens specifically recognized by human natural killer cells

In an attempt to identify target cell membrane molecules recognized by natural killer (NK) cells, artificial membranes were prepared from detergent-solubilized plasma membranes of NK target cells and synthetic lipids. Such reconstituted membranes from human and rat NK target cells were shown to inhibit both human and rat NK-target cell conjugates in a species-specific fashion; these reconstituted membranes failed to inhibit NK cytotoxicity. The detergent-solubilized material from the human NK target K562 was subjected to various procedures prior to reconstitution and the conjugate inhibition assay. Conjugate inhibitory activity was lost upon trypsin digestion and incubation at 65 degrees C. This inhibition activity was absorbed to concanavalin A agarose and could subsequently be eluted with alpha-methylmannoside, resulting in approximately 20-fold purification. Gel filtration of this material on an AcA-34 column in detergent gave a broad activity peak with maximal activity in the molecular weight range of 30,000-165,000. Gel electrophoresis of purified membranes demonstrated multiple molecular weight bands in lipid membranes. The K562 membrane material, purified by concanavalin A agarose and gel filtration, inhibited conjugates between human NK cells and any of four human target cells, but not of conjugates with (1) human large granular lymphocytes and antibody-coated mouse tumor cells nor (2) rat NK cells and their target cells. Thus the purified glycoproteins from K562 retain the property of specific inhibition of human NK-target conjugates.     

Distinct effects of interferon-gamma and MHC class I surface antigen levels on resistance of the K562 tumor cell line to natural killer-mediated lysis

Various investigators have examined the relationship between tumor cell susceptibility to natural killer (NK) cell lysis and the expression of HLA class I antigens on the tumor cell. There is controversy as to whether or not an inverse relationship exists, and if so, the basis of the relationship between these two phenomena remains undefined. To address these questions, the genomic clones for two HLA antigens were transfected into the erythroleukemia cell line K562, a cell line that is used as the standard to assess human NK and major histocompatibility complex (MHC) nonrestricted cytolysis. Susceptibility to NK lysis was not affected by the de novo expression of HLA antigens on the K562 after DNA mediated gene transfer. Interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) treatment of K562 induced levels of MHC class I antigen surface expression comparable to those found on the transfected cells; however, the IFN-gamma-treated cells were resistant to NK lysis. When very high levels of surface HLA antigens were induced on the transfectants, a potential effect of class I MHC expression on K562 lysis could be discerned that was distinct from the resistance to NK lysis induced by IFN-gamma-treatment.     

The role of asparagine-linked carbohydrate in natural killer cell-mediated cytolysis

Chinese hamster ovary cell lines with specific lesions in the formation of glycoconjugates were tested for their sensitivity to lysis by interferon-boosted human natural killer cells. We report here that the type of asparagine-linked carbohydrate present on target cell glycoproteins determines their susceptibility to natural killer lysis. The targets tested were Chinese hamster ovary parent cells and Lec1, Lec2, and Lec8 mutants. Lec8 and Lec2 cells show an overall reduction of galactose and/or sialic acid in their glycoconjugates due to defects in the translocation of UDP-galactose and CMP-sialic acid, respectively. Due to a specific block in N-linked carbohydrate processing, Lec1 cells produce only high mannose-type oligosaccharides, but their glycolipids are identical to those of the parent. Both Lec2 and Lec8 mutants are more sensitive to natural killer lysis than the parent cells. This is consistent with their extensive reduction in cell surface sialic acid. Furthermore, Lec1 mutants are more susceptible to natural killer lysis than the parent cells. To confirm that the increased natural killer sensitivity of Lec1 cells was due to the modification of N-linked carbohydrate, parent cells were treated with swainsonine, a specific inhibitor of N-linked oligosaccharide processing. Swainsonine-treated parent cells are nearly as sensitive to natural killer lysis as the Lec1 mutants.     

Scanning electron microscopic study of natural killer cell-mediated cytotoxicity

The interaction between human natural killer (NK) cells and NK-susceptible target cells, as well as the mechanism involved in target cell lysis, were studied with scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Low density human peripheral blood lymphocytes, highly enriched with large granular lymphocytes (LGL), were used as effector cells, and K562-cells were used as NK-susceptible target cells. The surface features of LGL/NK cells were examined under SEM. In the area of interaction, NK/target-cell conjugates showed microvilli and/or filipodia, and extensive areas of intercellular contact. In addition, the effector cells in some NK/target-cell conjugates were polarized toward the target cell. Changes in target cell surface features included loss of microvilli, large surface blebs and the appearance of small pore-like lesions on the cell membrane. Our findings show that target cell lysis occurred by apoptosis and plasma membrane lesions analogous to those seen during complement-mediated cytotoxicity.     

Tumor cell differentiation modulates susceptibility to natural killer cells

Induced differentiation in three human cell lines altered their sensitivity specifically to human natural killer (NK) cells by affecting their expression of NK target antigens. Differentiation of HL-60, a promyelocytic leukemia cell line, and the erythroleukemic cell line K562 was accompanied by a concomitant decrease in susceptibility to NK-mediated lysis whereas induction of MeWo melanoma cells resulted in an enhanced sensitivity to lysis. Our findings suggest that target cell susceptibility to NK-mediated lysis may in part be dependent on the stage of differentiation of the tumor cell target.     

Natural killer cell-target interactions: the role of 4F2 antigen in the human system

The manner by which natural killer cells discriminate between target and nontarget cells is a subject of intense investigation. Recently, the antigen recognized by the 4F2 monoclonal antibody has been implicated as the target recognition molecule of cloned human natural killer cells. Here we report the results of our studies on the possible role of 4F2 antigen in target recognition by natural killer cells present in the peripheral blood. In our hands, the 4F2 antibody only weakly blocked the killing of K562 leukemia cells by human natural killer cells. Furthermore, no correlation was observed between the level of cell surface 4F2 antigen and the natural killer susceptibility of several tumor cell lines, the ability of these cells to bind to natural killer cells, or the ability of these cell lines to compete with K562 cells in a natural killer assay. Therefore, the 4F2 antigen does not appear to be the target recognition molecule of most peripheral blood natural killer cells.     

IFN-gamma treatment of K562 cells inhibits natural killer cell triggering and decreases the susceptibility to lysis by cytoplasmic granules from large granular lymphocytes

Pretreatment of human K562 leukemia cells with rIFN-alpha and rIFN-gamma resulted in decreased susceptibility to lysis by human peripheral blood NK cells. The reduction of NK-susceptibility after IFN treatment was not due to a general effect of IFN on the stability of the cell membrane because the susceptibility of K562 cells to lysis by antibodies plus C, distilled water, or lysolecithin was unaffected. Binding studies with effector cell preparations enriched for NK cells with large granular lymphocyte morphology revealed no difference in binding to control and IFN-gamma-treated target cells. The sensitivity to soluble NK cytotoxic factors was not affected significantly by the IFN treatment. In contrast, the susceptibility of IFN-treated target cells to the cytotoxic activity of purified cytoplasmic granules from a rat large granular lymphocyte tumor was significantly reduced, indicating that the IFN-induced resistance acted at the level of susceptibility to the lytic mechanism of NK cells. However, IFN-alpha was more effective than IFN-gamma in inducing resistance to the cytoplasmic granules although resulting in only a weak resistance in the cell-mediated cytotoxic assay. IFN-gamma but not IFN-alpha caused a reduction in the frequency of effector cells that had reoriented their Golgi apparatus toward their bound target cell. In addition, IFN-gamma treated K562 cells failed to elicit an influx of Ca2+ into effector cells. Taken together, the results suggest that IFN-gamma in addition to an increased resistance to the lytic molecules released by NK cells can also induce changes in the target cells which prevent the triggering and activation of the effector cell.