The turnover of carbon pools contributing to soil CO2 and soil respiration in a temperate forest exposed to elevated CO2 concentration

Soil carbon is returned to the atmosphere through the process of soil respiration, which represents one of the largest fluxes in the terrestrial C cycle. The effects of climate change on the components of soil respiration can affect the sink or source capacity of ecosystems for atmospheric carbon, but no current techniques can unambiguously separate soil respiration into its components. Long‐term free air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiments provide a unique opportunity to study soil C dynamics because the CO₂ used for fumigation has a distinct isotopic signature and serves as a continuous label at the ecosystem level. We used the ¹³C tracer at the Duke Forest FACE site to follow the disappearance of C fixed before fumigation began in 1996 (pretreatment C) from soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂, as an index of belowground C dynamics during the first 8 years of the experiment. The decay of pretreatment C as detected in the isotopic composition of soil‐respired CO₂ and soil CO₂ at 15, 30, 70, and 200 cm soil depth was best described by a model having one to three exponential pools within the soil system. The majority of soil‐respired CO₂ (71%) originated in soil C pools with a turnover time of about 35 days. About 55%, 50%, and 68% of soil CO₂ at 15, 30, and 70 cm, respectively, originated in soil pools with turnover times of less than 1 year. The rest of soil CO₂ and soil‐respired CO₂ originated in soil pools that turn over at decadal time scales. Our results suggest that a large fraction of the C returned to the atmosphere through soil respiration results from dynamic soil C pools that cannot be easily detected in traditionally defined soil organic matter standing stocks. Fast oxidation of labile C substrates may prevent increases in soil C accumulation in forests exposed to elevated [CO₂] and may consequently result in shorter ecosystem C residence times.     

Hierarchical saturation of soil carbon pools near a natural CO2 spring

Soil has been identified as a possible carbon (C) sink to mitigate increasing atmospheric CO₂ concentration. However, several recent studies have suggested that the potential of soil to sequester C is limited and that soil may become saturated with C under increasing CO₂ levels. To test this concept of soil C saturation, we studied a gley and organic soil at a grassland site near a natural CO₂ spring. Total and aggregate‐associated soil organic C (SOC) concentration showed a significant increase with atmospheric CO₂ concentration. An asymptotic function showed a better fit of SOC and aggregation with CO₂ level than a linear model. There was a shift in allocation of total C from smaller size fractions to the largest aggregate fraction with increasing CO₂ concentration. Litter inputs appeared to be positively related to CO₂ concentration. Based on modeled function parameters and the observed shift in the allocation of the soil C from small to large aggregate‐size classes, we postulate that there is a hierarchy in C saturation across different SOC pools. We conclude that the asymptotic response of SOC concentration at higher CO₂ levels indicates saturation of soil C pools, likely because of a limit to physical protection of SOC.     

Leaf litter production and decomposition in a poplar short-rotation coppice exposed to free air CO2 enrichment (POPFACE)

The capacity of forest ecosystems to sequester C in the soil relies on the net balance between litter production above, as well as, below ground, and decomposition processes. Nitrogen mineralization and its availability for plant growth and microbial activity often control the speed of both processes. Litter production, decomposition and N mineralization are strongly interdependent. Thus, their responses to global environmental changes (i.e. elevated CO₂, climate, N deposition, etc.) cannot be fully understood if they are studied in isolation. In the present experiment, we investigated litter fall, litter decomposition and N dynamics in decomposing litter of three Populus spp., in the second and third growing season of a short rotation coppice under FACE. Elevated CO₂ did not affect annual litter production but slightly retarded litter fall in the third growing season. In all species, elevated CO₂ lowered N concentration, resulting in a reduction of N input to the soil via litter fall, but did not affect lignin concentrations. Litter decomposition was studied in bags incubated in situ both in control and FACE plots. Litter lost between 15% and 18% of the original mass during the eight months of field incubation. On average, litter produced under elevated CO₂ attained higher residual mass than control litter. On the other end, when litter was incubated in FACE plots it exhibited higher decay rates. These responses were strongly species‐specific. All litter increased their N content during decomposition, indicating immobilization of N from external sources. Independent of the initial quality, litter incubated on FACE soils immobilized less N, possibly as a result of lower N availability in the soil. Indeed, our results refer to a short‐term decomposition experiment. However, according to a longer‐term model extrapolation of our results, we anticipate that in Mediterranean climate, under elevated atmospheric CO₂, soil organic C pool of forest ecosystems may initially display faster turnover, but soil N availability will eventually limit the process.     

Scaling up evolutionary responses to elevated CO2: lessons from Arabidopsis

Results from norm of reaction studies and selection experiments indicate that elevated CO₂ will act as a selective agent on natural plant populations, especially for C₃ species that are most sensitive to changes in atmospheric CO₂ concentration. Evolutionary responses to CO₂ may alter plant physiology, development rate, growth, and reproduction in ways that cannot be predicted from single generation studies. Moreover, ecological and evolutionary changes in plant communities will have a range of consequences at higher spatial scales and may cause substantial deviations from ecosystem level predictions based on short‐term responses to elevated CO₂. Therefore, steps need to be taken to identify the plant traits that are most likely to evolve at elevated CO₂, and to understand how these changes may affect net primary productivity within ecosystems. These processes may range in scale from molecular and physiological changes that occur among genotypes at the individual and population levels, to changes in community‐ and ecosystem‐level productivity that result from the integrative effects of different plant species evolving simultaneously. In this review, we (1) synthesize recent studies investigating the role of atmospheric CO₂ as a selective agent on plants, (2) discuss possible control points during plant development that may change in response to selection at elevated CO₂ with an emphasis at the primary molecular level, and (3) provide a quantitative framework for scaling the evolutionary effects of CO₂ on plants in order to determine changes in community and ecosystem productivity. Furthermore, this review points out that studies integrating the effects of plant evolution in response to elevated CO₂ are lacking, and therefore more attention needs be devoted to this issue among the global change research community.     

Atmospheric CO2 concentration does not directly affect leaf respiration in bean or poplar

It is a matter of debate if there is a direct (short‐term) effect of elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentration (C_a) on plant respiration in the dark. When C_a doubles, some authors found no (or only minor) changes in dark respiration, whereas most studies suggest a respiratory inhibition of 15–20%. The present study shows that the measurement artefacts – particularly leaks between leaf chamber gaskets and leaf surface, CO₂ memory and leakage effects of gas exchange systems as well as the water vapour (‘water dilution’) effect on DCO₂ measurement caused by transpiration – may result in larger errors than generally discussed. A gas exchange system that was used in three different ways – as a closed system in which C_a increased continuously from 200 to 4200 mmol (CO₂) mol^‐1 (air) due to respiration of the enclosed leaf; as an intermittently closed system that was repeatedly closed and opened during C_a periods of either 350 or 2000 mmol mol^‐1, and as an open system in which C_a varied between 350 and 2000 mmol mol^‐1– is described. In control experiments (with an empty leaf chamber), the respective system characteristics were evaluated carefully. When all relevant system parameters were taken into account, no effects of short‐term changes in CO₂ on dark CO₂ efflux of bean and poplar leaves were found, even when C_a increased to 4200 mmol mol^‐1. It is concluded that the leaf respiration of bean and poplar is not directly inhibited by elevated atmospheric CO₂.     

Soil CO2 efflux of two silver birch clones exposed to elevated CO2 and O3 levels during three growing seasons

In the present open‐top chamber experiment, two silver birch clones (Betula pendula Roth, clone 4 and clone 80) were exposed to elevated levels of carbon dioxide (CO₂) and ozone (O₃), singly and in combination, and soil CO₂ efflux was measured 14 times during three consecutive growing seasons (1999–2001). In the beginning of the experiment, all experimental trees were 7 years old and during the experiment the trees were growing in sandy field soil and fertilized regularly. In general, elevated O₃ caused soil CO₂ efflux stimulation during most measurement days and this stimulation enhanced towards the end of the experiment. The overall soil respiration response to CO₂ was dependent on the genotype, as the soil CO₂ efflux below clone 80 trees was enhanced and below clone 4 trees was decreased under elevated CO₂ treatments. Like the O₃ impact, this clonal difference in soil respiration response to CO₂ increased as the experiment progressed. Although the O₃ impact did not differ significantly between clones, a significant time × clone × CO₂× O₃ interaction revealed that the O₃‐induced stimulation of soil respiration was counteracted by elevated CO₂ in clone 4 on most measurement days, whereas in clone 80, the effect of elevated CO₂ and O₃ in combination was almost constantly additive during the 3‐year experiment. Altogether, the root or above‐ground biomass results were only partly parallel with the observed soil CO₂ efflux responses. In conclusion, our data show that O₃ impacts may appear first in the below‐ground processes and that relatively long‐term O₃ exposure had a cumulative effect on soil CO₂ efflux. Although the soil respiration response to elevated CO₂ depended on the tree genotype as a result of which the O₃ stress response might vary considerably within a single tree species under elevated CO₂, the present experiment nonetheless indicates that O₃ stress is a significant factor affecting the carbon cycling in northern forest ecosystems.     

Carbon and nitrogen pools and mineralization in a grassland gley soil under elevated carbon dioxide at a natural CO2 spring

The growth and chemical composition of most plants are influenced by elevated CO₂, but accompanying effects on soil organic matter pools and mineralization are less clearly defined, partly because of the short‐term nature of most studies. Herein we describe soil properties from a naturally occurring cold CO₂ spring (Hakanoa) in Northland, New Zealand, at which the surrounding vegetation has been exposed to elevated CO₂ for at least several decades. The mean annual temperature at this site is ≈ 15.5 °C and rainfall ≈ 1550 mm. The site was unfertilized and ungrazed, with a vegetation of mainly C3 and C4 grasses, and had moderate levels of ‘available’ P. Two soils were present ? a gley soil and an organic soil – but only the gley soil is examined here. Average atmospheric CO₂ concentrations at 17 sampling locations in the gley soil area ranged from 372 to 670 ppmv. In samples at 0–5 cm depth, pH averaged 5.4; average values for organic C were 150 g, total N 11 g, microbial C 3.50 g, and microbial N 0.65 g kg^?1, respectively. Under standardized moisture conditions at 25 °C, average rates of CO₂‐C production (7–14 days) were 5.4 mg kg^?1 h^?1 and of net mineral‐N production (14 ?42 days) 0.40 mg kg^?1 h^?1. These properties were all correlated positively and significantly (P < 0.10) with atmospheric CO₂ concentrations, but not with soil moisture (except for CO₂‐C production) or with clay content; they were, however, correlated negatively and mainly significantly with soil pH. In spite of uncertainties associated with the uncontrolled environment of naturally occurring springs, we conclude that storage of C and N can increase under prolonged exposure to elevated CO₂, and may include an appreciable labile fraction in mineral soil with an adequate nutrient supply.     

Soil CO2 efflux in a boreal pine forest under atmospheric CO2 enrichment and air warming

The response of forest soil CO₂ efflux to the elevation of two climatic factors, the atmospheric concentration of CO₂ (↑CO₂ of 700 μmol mol⁻¹) and air temperature (↑ T with average annual increase of 5°C), and their combination (↑CO₂+↑ T ) was investigated in a 4-year, full-factorial field experiment consisting of closed chambers built around 20-year-old Scots pines ( Pinus sylvestris L.) in the boreal zone of Finland. Mean soil CO₂ efflux in May–October increased with elevated CO₂ by 23–37%, with elevated temperature by 27–43%, and with the combined treatment by 35–59%. Temperature elevation was a significant factor in the combined 4-year efflux data, whereas the effect of elevated CO₂ was not as evident. Elevated temperature had the most pronounced impact early and late in the season, while the influence of elevated CO₂ alone was especially notable late in the season. Needle area was found to be a significant predictor of soil CO₂ efflux, particularly in August, a month of high root growth, thus supporting the assumption of a close link between whole-tree physiology and soil CO₂ emissions. The decrease in the temperature sensitivity of soil CO₂ efflux observed in the elevated temperature treatments in the second year nevertheless suggests the existence of soil response mechanisms that may be independent of the assimilating component of the forest ecosystem. In conclusion, elevated atmospheric CO₂ and air temperature consistently increased forest soil CO₂ efflux over the 4-year period, their combined effect being additive, with no apparent interaction.     

Future atmospheric CO2 leads to delayed autumnal senescence

Growing seasons are getting longer, a phenomenon partially explained by increasing global temperatures. Recent reports suggest that a strong correlation exists between warming and advances in spring phenology but that a weaker correlation is evident between warming and autumnal events implying that other factors may be influencing the timing of autumnal phenology. Using freely rooted, field‐grown Populus in two Free Air CO₂ Enrichment Experiments (AspenFACE and PopFACE), we present evidence from two continents and over 2 years that increasing atmospheric CO₂ acts directly to delay autumnal leaf coloration and leaf fall. In an atmosphere enriched in CO₂ (by ～45% of the current atmospheric concentration to 550 ppm) the end of season decline in canopy normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) – a commonly used global index for vegetation greenness – was significantly delayed, indicating a greener autumnal canopy, relative to that in ambient CO₂. This was supported by a significant delay in the decline of autumnal canopy leaf area index in elevated as compared with ambient CO₂, and a significantly smaller decline in end of season leaf chlorophyll content. Leaf level photosynthetic activity and carbon uptake in elevated CO₂ during the senescence period was also enhanced compared with ambient CO₂. The findings reveal a direct effect of rising atmospheric CO₂, independent of temperature in delaying autumnal senescence for Populus, an important deciduous forest tree with implications for forest productivity and adaptation to a future high CO₂ world.     

Elevated CO2 stimulates associative N2 fixation in a C3 plant of the Chesapeake Bay wetland

In this study, the response of N₂ fixation to elevated CO₂ was measured in Scirpus olneyi, a C₃ sedge, and Spartina patens, a C₄ grass, using acetylene reduction assay and ¹⁵N₂ gas feeding. Field plants grown in PVC tubes (25 cm long, 10 cm internal diameter) were used. Exposure to elevated CO₂ significantly (P < 0·05) caused a 35% increase in nitrogenase activity and 73% increase in ¹⁵N incorporated by Scirpus olneyi. In Spartina patens, elevated CO₂ (660 ± 1 μ mol mol ^{− 1}) increased nitrogenase activity and ¹⁵N incorporation by 13 and 23%, respectively. Estimates showed that the rate of N₂ fixation in Scirpus olneyi under elevated CO₂ was 611 ± 75 ng ¹⁵N fixed plant ^{− 1} h ^{− 1} compared with 367 ± 46 ng ¹⁵N fixed plant ^{− 1} h ^{− 1} in ambient CO₂ plants. In Spartina patens, however, the rate of N₂ fixation was 12·5 ± 1·1 versus 9·8 ± 1·3 ng ¹⁵N fixed plant ^{− 1} h ^{− 1} for elevated and ambient CO₂, respectively. Heterotrophic non-symbiotic N₂ fixation in plant-free marsh sediment also increased significantly (P < 0·05) with elevated CO₂. The proportional increase in ¹⁵N₂ fixation correlated with the relative stimulation of photosynthesis, in that N₂ fixation was high in the C₃ plant in which photosynthesis was also high, and lower in the C₄ plant in which photosynthesis was relatively less stimulated by growth in elevated CO₂. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that carbon fixation in C₃ species, stimulated by rising CO₂, is likely to provide additional carbon to endophytic and below-ground microbial processes.     

Canopy photosynthesis of crops and native plant communities exposed to long-term elevated CO2

Abstract. There have been seven studies of canopy photosynthesis of plants grown in elevated atmospheric CO₂: three of seed crops, two of forage crops and two of native plant ecosystems. Growth in elevated CO₂ increased canopy photosynthesis in all cases. The relative effect of CO₂ was correlated with increasing temperature: the least stimulation occurred in tundra vegetation grown at an average temperature near 10°C and the greatest in rice grown at 43°C. In soybean, effects of CO₂ were greater during leaf expansion and pod fill than at other stages of crop maturation. In the longest running experiment with elevated CO₂ treatment to date, monospecific stands of a C₃ sedge, Scirpus olneyi (Grey), and a C₄ grass, Spartina patens (Ait.) Muhl., have been exposed to twice normal ambient CO₂ concentrations for four growing seasons, in open top chambers on a Chesapeake Bay salt marsh. Net ecosystem CO₂ exchange per unit green biomass (NCE_b) increased by an average of 48% throughout the growing season of 1988, the second year of treatment. Elevated CO₂ increased net ecosystem carbon assimilation by 88% in the Scirpus olneyi community and 40% in the Spartina patens community.     

The growth response of C4 plants to rising atmospheric CO2 partial pressure: a reassessment

Despite mounting evidence showing that C₄ plants can accumulate more biomass at elevated CO₂ partial pressure (p(CO₂)), the underlying mechanisms of this response are still largely unclear. In this paper, we review the current state of knowledge regarding the response of C₄ plants to elevated p(CO₂) and discuss the likely mechanisms. We identify two main routes through which elevated p(CO₂) can stimulate the growth of both well-watered and water-stressed C₄ plants. First, through enhanced leaf CO₂ assimilation rates due to increased intercellular p(CO₂). Second, through reduced stomatal conductance and subsequently leaf transpiration rates. Reduced transpiration rates can stimulate leaf CO₂ assimilation and growth rates by conserving soil water, improving shoot water relations and increasing leaf temperature. We argue that bundle sheath leakiness, direct CO₂ fixation in the bundle sheath or the presence of C₃-like photosynthesis in young C₄ leaves are unlikely explanations for the high CO₂-responsiveness of C₄ photosynthesis. The interactions between elevated p(CO₂), leaf temperature and shoot water relations on the growth and photosynthesis of C₄ plants are identified as key areas needing urgent research.