Limiting TCR expression leads to quantitative but not qualitative changes in thymic selection

Thymic selection is controlled in part by the avidity of the interaction between thymocytes and APCs. In agreement, the selective outcome can be modulated by altering the expression levels of selecting ligands on APCs. Here we test the converse proposition, i. e., whether changing TCR levels on thymocytes can alter the selective outcome. To this end, we have generated mice in which all thymocytes express two transgenic TCRs simultaneously (dual TCR-expressing (DTE) mice), the class I-restricted HY TCR and the class II-restricted AND TCR. Due to mutual dilution, surface expression levels of the two individual transgenic TCRs are diminished in DTE relative to single TCR-expressing mice. We find that thymic selection is highly sensitive to these reductions in TCR surface expression. Positive selection mediated by the AND and HY TCRs is severely impaired or abolished, respectively. Negative selection of the HY TCR in male DTE mice is also partly blocked, leading to the appearance of significant numbers of double positive thymocytes. Also, in the periphery of male, but not female, DTE mice, substantial numbers of single positive CD8bright cells accumulate, which are positively selected in the thymus but by a highly inefficient hemopoietic cell-dependent process. Overall our results favor the interpretation that the outcome of thymic selection is not determined solely by avidity and the resulting signal intensity, but is also constrained by other factors such as the nature of the ligand and/or its presentation by different subsets of APCs.     

Characterization of two TCR transgenic mouse lines specific for herpes simplex virus

To better understand the T cell-mediated processes involved in the immune response to herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1)infection, two HSV-specific T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mouse lines were produced. These mice (gBT-I.1 and gBT-I.3) are MHC class I-restricted and specific for the immunodominant peptide from HSV glycoprotein B (gB), gB498-505. Although derived from the same clone, the mice differ in the chromosomal location of the TCR transgenes and show marked differences in TCR alpha/beta expression on both CD4+ and CD8+ cells in the thymus. Despite this, peripheral CD8+ Tcells from both mice express equally high levels of the transgenic TCR and bind the KbgB498-505 tetramer to the same degree. In concordance with this, both were shown to respond equally well in vitro upon stimulation with the gB498-505 peptide or HSV-infected cells. These data show that selection of broadly equivalent peripheral T-cell subsets can occur in the presence of distinctly different thymic T-cell subsets.     

MHC class I allele dosage alters CD8 expression by intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes

The development of TCR alphabeta(+), CD8alphabeta(+) intestinal intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL) is dependent on MHC class I molecules expressed in the thymus, while some CD8alphaalpha(+) IEL may arise independently of MHC class I. We examined the influence of MHC I allele dosage on the development CD8(+) T cells in RAG 2(-/-) mice expressing the H-2D(b)-restricted transgenic TCR specific for the male, Smcy-derived H-Y Ag (H-Y TCR). IEL in male mice heterozygous for the restricting (H-2D(b)) and nonrestricting (H-2D(d)) MHC class I alleles (MHC F(1)) were composed of a mixture of CD8alphabeta(+) and CD8alphaalpha(+) T cells, while T cells in the spleen were mostly CD8alphabeta(+). This was unlike IEL in male mice homozygous for H-2D(b), which had predominantly CD8alphaalpha(+) IEL and few mostly CD8(-) T cells in the spleen. Our results demonstrate that deletion of CD8alphabeta(+) cells in H-Y TCR male mice is dependent on two copies of H-2D(b), whereas the generation of CD8alphaalpha(+) IEL requires only one copy. The existence of CD8alphabeta(+) and CD8alphaalpha(+) IEL in MHC F(1) mice suggests that their generation is not mutually exclusive in cells with identical TCR. Furthermore, our data imply that the level of the restricting MHC class I allele determines a threshold for conventional CD8alphabeta(+) T cell selection in the thymus of H-Y TCR-transgenic mice, whereas the development of CD8alphaalpha(+) IEL is dependent on, but less sensitive to, this MHC class I allele.     

Thymic alterations in EphA4-deficient mice

In the present work, we have demonstrated in vivo an altered maturation of the thymic epithelium that results in defective T cell development which increases with age, in the thymus of Eph A4-deficient mice. The deficient thymi are hypocellular and show decreased proportions of double-positive (CD4+CD8+) cells which reach minimal numbers in 4-wk-old thymi. The EphA4 (-/-) phenotype correlates with an early block of T cell precursor differentiation that results in accumulation of CD44-CD25+ triple-negative cells and, sometimes, of CD44+CD25- triple-negative thymocytes as well as with increased numbers of apoptotic cells and an important reduction in the numbers of cycling thymocytes. Various approaches support a key role of the thymic epithelial cells in the observed phenotype. Thymic cytoarchitecture undergoes profound changes earlier than those found in the thymocyte maturation. Thymic cortex is extremely reduced and consists of densely packed thymic epithelial cells. Presumably the lack of forward Eph A4 signaling in the Eph A4 -/- epithelial cells affects their development and finally results in altered T cell development.     

Atypical memory phenotype T cells with low homeostatic potential and impaired TCR signaling and regulatory T cell function in Foxn1Delta/Delta mutant mice

Foxn1Delta/Delta mutants have a block in thymic epithelial cell differentiation at an intermediate progenitor stage, resulting in reduced thymocyte cellularity and blocks at the double-negative and double-positive stages. Whereas naive single-positive thymocytes were reduced >500-fold in the adult Foxn1Delta/Delta thymus, peripheral T cell numbers were reduced only 10-fold. The current data shows that Foxn1Delta/Delta peripheral T cells had increased expression of activation markers and the ability to produce IL-2 and IFN-gamma. These cells acquired this profile immediately after leaving the thymus as early as the newborn stage and maintained high steady-state proliferation in vivo but decreased proliferation in response to TCR stimulation in vitro. Single-positive thymocytes and naive T cells also had constitutively low alphabetaTCR and IL7R expression. These cells also displayed reduced ability to undergo homeostatic proliferation and increased rates of apoptosis. Although the frequency of Foxp3+CD4+CD25+ T cells was normal in Foxn1Delta/Delta mutant mice, these cells failed to have suppressor function, resulting in reduced regulatory T cell activity. Recent data from our laboratory suggest that T cells in the Foxn1Delta/Delta thymus develop from atypical progenitor cells via a noncanonical pathway. Our results suggest that the phenotype of peripheral T cells in Foxn1Delta/Delta mutant mice is the result of atypical progenitor cells developing in an abnormal thymic microenvironment with a deficient TCR and IL7 signaling system.     

Selective Depletion of Eosinophils or Neutrophils in Mice Impacts the Efficiency of Apoptotic Cell Clearance in the Thymus

Developing thymocytes undergo a rigorous selection process to ensure that the mature T cell population expresses a T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire that can functionally interact with major histocompatibility complexes (MHC). Over 90% of thymocytes fail this selection process and die. A small number of macrophages within the thymus are responsible for clearing the large number of dying thymocytes that must be continuously cleared. We studied the capacity of thymic macrophages to clear apoptotic cells under acute circumstances. This was done by synchronously inducing cell death in the thymus and then monitoring the clearance of apoptotic thymocytes. Interestingly, acute cell death was shown to recruit large numbers of CD11b⁺ cells into the thymus. In the absence of a minor CSF-1 dependent population of macrophages, the recruitment of these CD11b⁺ cells into the thymus was greatly reduced and the clearance of apoptotic cells was disrupted. To assess a possible role for the CD11b⁺ cells in the clearance of apoptotic cells, we analyzed mice deficient for eosinophils and mice with defective trafficking of neutrophils. Failure to attract either eosinophils or neutrophils to the thymus resulted in the impaired clearance of apoptotic cells. These results suggested that there is crosstalk between cells of the innate immune system that is necessary for maximizing the efficiency of apoptotic cell removal.     

Competition for specific intrathymic ligands limits positive selection in a TCR transgenic model of CD4+ T cell development

Efficient positive selection of a broad repertoire of T cells is dependent on the presentation of a diverse array of endogenous peptides on MHC molecules in the thymus. It is unclear, however, whether the development of individual TCR specificities is influenced by the abundance of their selecting ligands. To examine this, we analyzed positive selection in a transgenic mouse carrying a TCR specific for the human CLIP:I-Ab class II complex. We found that these mice exhibit significantly reduced CD4+ T cell development compared with two other transgenic mice carrying TCRs selected on I-Ab. Moreover, many of the selected cells in these mice express endogenous and transgenic receptors as a consequence of dual TCRalpha expression. Dramatic enhancement of the selection efficiency is observed, however, when fewer transgenic cells populate the thymus in mixed bone marrow chimeras. These results suggest that positive selection is limited by the availability of selecting peptides in the thymus. This becomes apparent when large numbers of thymocytes compete for such peptides in TCR transgenic animals. Under such conditions, thymocytes appear to undergo further TCRalpha gene rearrangement to produce a receptor that may be selected more efficiently by other thymic self-peptides.     

Self-reactive T cells selected on thymic cortical epithelium are polyclonal and are pathogenic in vivo

Positive selection of CD4+ T cells requires that the TCR of a developing thymocyte interact with self MHC class II molecules on thymic cortical epithelium. In contrast, clonal deletion is mediated by dendritic cells and medullary epithelium. We previously generated K14 mice expressing MHC class II only on thymic cortical epithelium. K14 CD4+ T cells were positively, but not negatively, selected and had significant in vitro autoreactivity. Here, we examine the function of these autoreactive CD4+ T cells in more detail. Analysis of a series of K14-derived T hybrids demonstrated that the autoreactive population of CD4+ T cells is phenotypically and functionally diverse. Purified K14 CD4+ T cells transferred into lethally irradiated wild-type B6 mice cause acute graft vs host disease with bone marrow failure. Further, these autoreactive CD4+ T cells cause hypergammaglobulinemia and the production of autoantibodies when transferred into unirradiated wild-type hosts. Thus, positive selection by normal thymic cortical epithelial cells, unopposed by negative selection, produces polyclonal CD4+ T cells that are pathologic.     

Induction of high level IL-2 production in CD4+8- T helper lymphocytes requires post-thymic development.

Triggering of the CD3:TCR complex by optimal concentrations of anti-CD3, anti-TCR beta-chain, and allogeneic stimulator cells induced dramatically higher levels (fivefold for anti-CD3, greater than 10-fold for anti-TCR beta-chain, 84-fold for alloantigen) of IL-2 production in spleen CD4+8- T cells than their thymic counterparts, despite comparable levels of CD3 and TCR beta-chain expression. The nature of the reduced IL-2 production was examined by analysis of anti-CD3-induced IL-2 production at the single cell level. The frequency of IL-2-producing cells in spleen CD4+8- T cells (40.0%) was approximately threefold that of thymus CD4+8- T cells (14.5%). Furthermore, the average IL-2 levels among positive IL-2 producers was also approximately threefold higher in spleen CD4+8- T cells than their thymic counterparts. Adoptive transfer of purified Thy-1.2+ CD4+8- T cells into Thy-1.1-congenic hosts provided a physiologic and histocompatible system that enabled identification of transferred donor (Thy-1.2+) among a sea of host (Thy-1.2-) CD4+ T cells, whose immune function with respect to IL-2 inducibility was examined after isolation by electronic cell sorting. Donor CD4+ T cells thus isolated from host spleen shortly (1 day) after i.v. transfer of thymus CD4+8- T cells were similar to freshly isolated thymus CD4+8- T cells in that they both produced little IL-2 in response to anti-CD3. However, by day 3 post-transfer, IL-2 production by donor CD4+8- T cells had more than doubled and by day 8, they produced IL-2 levels comparable to those of host spleen CD4+8- T cells. A similar acquisition of high level IL-2 inducibility in thymus CD4+8- T cells upon i.v. transfer into Thy-1.1-congenic hosts was also observed using allogeneic cells as the stimulus of IL-2 production. When thymus CD4+8- T cells were intra-thymically transferred into Thy-1.1-congenic hosts, those donor cells that emigrated to the periphery became high IL-2 producers in a time-dependent manner, whereas those that remained inside the thymus showed no signs of up-regulation in IL-2 inducibility. Intrathymic transfer of CD4-8- thymocytes revealed that the most recent thymic emigrant CD4+8- T cells contained few IL-2-producing cells and were not functionally mature with respect to high level IL-2 inducibility.     

Characterization of the ovalbumin-specific TCR transgenic line OT-I: MHC elements for positive and negative selection

The present report provides the first extensive characterization of the OT-I TCR transgenic line, which produces MHC class I-restricted, ovalbumin-specific, CD8+ T cells (OT-I cells). These cells are shown to be positively selected in vivo in H-2b C57BL/6 mice and in bm5 mice, which express the Kbm5 mutant molecule. In contrast, OT-I cells were not selected by mutant Kb molecules in bm1, bm3, bm8, bm10, bm11 or bm23 mice. Interestingly, however, when positive selection was examined in vitro in foetal thymic organ culture (FTOC), bm1 and bm8 were still poorly selective, but the bm3 haplotype now selected as efficiently as B6. The ability to select in vitro correlated with the capacity to present the ovalbumin (OVA) peptide to OT-I cells, as measured by induction of an OVA-specific proliferative response. These results suggest that a lower affinity TCR:MHC interaction may be necessary for positive selection in FTOC compared with selection in situ.     

Up-regulation of IL-7, stromal-derived factor-1 alpha, thymus-expressed chemokine, and secondary lymphoid tissue chemokine gene expression in the stromal cells in response to thymocyte depletion: implication for thymus reconstitution

Three in vivo adult mouse models were established to study which signals are required to restore the postnatal thymus. Single administration of dexamethasone, estradiol, or exposure to sublethal dose of gamma irradiation served as prototype thymus-ablating therapies. In all models, transient thymic atrophy was manifested due to the loss of the predominant portion of CD4- CD8- double negative and CD4+ CD8+ double positive thymocytes and was followed by a complete regeneration of the thymuses. Acute atrophy/regeneration was observed in the dexamethasone and irradiation models; in the estradiol-treated animals, slow kinetics of atrophy and regeneration was observed. Importantly, in both acute and chronic models, high levels of IL-7 mRNA were detected in the thymuses isolated from mice during maximum atrophy. In addition, chemokine gene array analysis of involuted thymuses revealed high levels of mRNA expression of stromal-derived factor-1alpha (SDF-1alpha), thymus-expressed chemokine (TECK), and secondary lymphoid tissue chemokine (SLC) but not of other chemokines. The levels of IL-7, SDF-1alpha, TECK, and SLC mRNA inversely correlated with the kinetics of regeneration. RT-PCR analysis of stromal cells purified from involuted thymuses confirmed increased IL-7, SDF-1alpha, and SLC gene expression in MHC class II+ CD45- epithelial cells and increased IL-7 and TECK gene expression in class II+ CD45+ CD11c+ dendritic cells. Thus, our data showed for the first time that expression of IL-7, SDF-1alpha, TECK, and SLC mRNA is induced in the thymic stroma during T cell depletion and may play an important role in the reconstitution of the adult thymus.     

Maturation and function of mouse T-cells with a transgenic TCR positively selected by highly disparate xenogeneic porcine MHC.

Remarkably normal cellular immune function, along with specific T-cell tolerance to highly disparate xenogeneic donors, can be achieved by grafting fetal pig thymus (FP THY) tissue to T and NK cell-depleted, thymectomized (ATX) mice. Porcine MHC can mediate positive selection of mouse CD4+ T-cells with a mouse MHC-restricted TCR in FP THY-grafted, T- and NK cell-depleted, ATX TCR-transgenic "AND" mice. However, functional studies were not performed on transgenic mouse T-cells selected in a FP THY graft. We have now performed further studies to confirm the ability of porcine MHC to mediate the positive selection of mouse T-cells with a mouse MHC-restricted TCR, and to exclude the possibility that the maturation of mouse T-cells with a mouse MHC-restricted TCR in FP THY grafts in ATX "AND" mice is a special case. For this purpose, TCR-transgenic mice with an unrelated transgenic TCR ["3A9", specific for hen egg lysozyme (HEL) peptide 46-61 presented by I-Ak] were employed. Similar to FP THY-grafted ATX "AND" mice, large numbers of mouse CD4 single positive thymocytes expressing the transgenic TCR (Vbeta8.2) and expressing a mature phenotype (Qa-2high and heat stable antigen, HSAlow) were detected in FP THY grafts. Porcine thymus grafting led to a high level of peripheral repopulation with mouse naive-type (CD44low CD45RBhigh CD62Lhigh) CD4+ cells expressing the transgenic TCR in T and NK cell-depleted ATX "3A9" mice, regardless of whether the recipients had a positive selecting or a non-selecting, class II deficient MHC background. The mouse CD4+ T-cells expressing the "3A9" TCR showed efficient primary proliferative responses to the protein antigen (HEL) when it was presented by mouse class II+ antigen presenting cells (APC) in vitro. These results, collectively, support the general conclusion that discordant xenogeneic porcine MHC can mediate positive selection of mouse T-cells with mouse MHC-restricted TCR. This study has implications for the potential clinical use of xenogeneic thymus transplantation to reconstitute cellular immunity in the setting of thymic insufficiency or thymectomy, and hence for its applicability to the induction of xenograft tolerance and in the treatment of immunodeficiency diseases.     

A defect in deletion of nucleosome-specific autoimmune T cells in lupus-prone thymus: role of thymic dendritic cells

To study central tolerance to the major product of ongoing apoptosis in the thymus, we made new lines of transgenic (Tg) mice expressing TCR of a pathogenic autoantibody-inducing Th cell that was specific for nucleosomes and its histone peptide H4(71-94). In the lupus-prone (SWR x NZB)F1 (SNF1) thymus, introduction of the lupus TCR transgene caused no deletion, but marked down-regulation of the Tg TCR and up-regulation of endogenous TCRs. Paradoxically, autoimmune disease was suppressed in the alphabetaTCR Tg SNF1 mice with induction of highly potent regulatory T cells in the periphery. By contrast, in the MHC-matched, normal (SWR x B10. D2)F1 (SBF1), or in the normal SWR backgrounds, marked deletion of transgenic thymocytes occurred. Thymic lymphoid cells of the normal or lupus-prone mice were equally susceptible to deletion by anti-CD3 Ab or irradiation. However, in the steady state, spontaneous presentation of naturally processed peptides related to the nucleosomal autoepitope was markedly greater by thymic dendritic cells (DC) from normal mice than that from lupus mice. Unmanipulated thymic DC of SNF1 mice expressed lesser amounts of MHC class II and costimulatory molecules than their normal counterparts. These results indicate that apoptotic nucleosomal autoepitopes are naturally processed and presented to developing thymocytes, and a relative deficiency in the natural display of nucleosomal autoepitopes by thymic DC occurs in lupus-prone SNF1 mice.     

Thymus-dependent and thymus-independent developmental pathways for peripheral T cell receptor-gamma delta-bearing lymphocytes

To elucidate the developmental pathways of T cells that bear TCR gamma delta, we have analyzed the kinetics of expression and biochemical characteristics of gamma delta receptors in the thymus and spleen of normal and athymic (nude) mice, as well as nude mice engrafted with neonatal thymuses. TCR gamma delta-bearing thymocytes and splenocytes have a CD4-8- phenotype, and both populations express products of the C gamma 1 locus. TCR gamma delta-bearing cells develop in the thymus before their appearance in the spleen. Young nude mice have no detectable TCR gamma delta-bearing cells in their spleens. When young nude mice are given thymus grafts, TCR gamma delta-bearing cells of host origin first develop in the engrafted thymus, followed by their appearance in the spleen. In the absence of a thymus graft, the spleens of old nude mice eventually develop small numbers of TCR gamma delta + cells, as well as TCR alpha beta + cells. These results demonstrate that there is a major thymic-dependent pathway for TCR gamma delta expression, as well as a minor thymic-independent pathway seen in older nude mice. The development of TCR gamma delta + cells in the thymus before their appearance in the spleen, both in normal ontogeny as well as in the thymus-engrafted nude mouse model, suggests that thymic TCR gamma delta + cells are precursors of the thymus-dependent population of peripheral TCR gamma delta + cells.     

Exclusion and inclusion of alpha and beta T cell receptor alleles.

Exclusion and inclusion of T cell receptor (TCR) genes were analyzed in alpha beta TCR transgenic mice. Both transgenes are expressed unusually early on the surface of CD4-8-, HSA+, IL-2R- thymocytes. These progenitor cells give rise to progeny, which at the single-cell level contains endogenous alpha but not beta TCR-RNA as well as protein, in addition to products encoded by the transgenes. Thus, the surface expression of an alpha beta TCR does not prevent further alpha TCR rearrangement in immature thymocytes that still transcribe RAG-1 and RAG-2 genes. Reduced levels of RAG-1 and RAG-2 RNA are detectable only in CD4+8+ TCR high cells, which result from positive selection in the thymus. The results suggest that a developing T cell may try different alpha beta TCRs for binding to thymic MHC ligands, and that recombination at the alpha locus ceases only after positive selection.     

Age-associated rapid and Stat6-independent IL-4 production by NK1-CD4+8- thymus T lymphocytes.

The source of IL-4 required for priming naive T cells into IL-4-secreting effectors has not been clearly identified. Here we show that upon TCR stimulation, thymus NK1-CD4+8- T cells produced IL-4, the magnitude of which was inversely correlated with age. This IL-4 production response by Th2-prone BALB/c mice was approximately 9-fold that of Th1-prone C57BL/10 mice. More than 90% of activated NK1-CD4+8- thymocytes did not use the invariant V alpha 14-J alpha 281 chain characteristic of typical CD1-restricted NK1+CD4+ T cells. Stat6-null NK1-CD4+8- thymocytes produced bioactive IL-4, with induction of IL-4 mRNA expression within 1 h of stimulation. Our results support the possibility that TCR repertoire-diverse conventional NK1-CD4+ T cells are a potential IL-4 source for directing naive T cells toward Th2/type 2 CD8+ T cell (Tc2) effector development.     

Thymus and autoimmunity: production of CD25+CD4+ naturally anergic and suppressive T cells as a key function of the thymus in maintaining immunologic self-tolerance

This study shows that the normal thymus produces immunoregulatory CD25+4+8- thymocytes capable of controlling self-reactive T cells. Transfer of thymocyte suspensions depleted of CD25+4+8- thymocytes, which constitute approximately 5% of steroid-resistant mature CD4+8- thymocytes in normal naive mice, produces various autoimmune diseases in syngeneic athymic nude mice. These CD25+4+8- thymocytes are nonproliferative (anergic) to TCR stimulation in vitro, but potently suppress the proliferation of other CD4+8- or CD4-8+ thymocytes; breakage of their anergic state in vitro by high doses of IL-2 or anti-CD28 Ab simultaneously abrogates their suppressive activity; and transfer of such suppression-abrogated thymocyte suspensions produces autoimmune disease in nude mice. These immunoregulatory CD25+4+8- thymocytes/T cells are functionally distinct from activated CD25+4+ T cells derived from CD25-4+ thymocytes/T cells in that the latter scarcely exhibits suppressive activity in vitro, although both CD25+4+ populations express a similar profile of cell surface markers. Furthermore, the CD25+4+8- thymocytes appear to acquire their anergic and suppressive property through the thymic selection process, since TCR transgenic mice develop similar anergic/suppressive CD25+4+8- thymocytes and CD25+4+ T cells that predominantly express TCRs utilizing endogenous alpha-chains, but RAG-2-deficient TCR transgenic mice do not. These results taken together indicate that anergic/suppressive CD25+4+8- thymocytes and peripheral T cells in normal naive mice may constitute a common T cell lineage functionally and developmentally distinct from other T cells, and that production of this unique immunoregulatory T cell population can be another key function of the thymus in maintaining immunologic self-tolerance.     

The TNF receptor family member CD30 is not essential for negative selection

CD30 is a member of the TNF receptor superfamily that has been implicated in negative selection and some forms of peripheral tolerance. A previous study of CD30(-/-) mice in a class I-restricted H-Y TCR-transgenic mouse model showed that CD30 is essential for removal of autoreactive thymocytes. During the course of the studies of CD30 in the class II-restricted TCR-transgenic mice, we found that the absence of CD30 has no effect on negative selection. Surprisingly, we also found that the CD30 mutation does not perturb apoptosis of the autoreactive thymocytes in the class I-restricted H-Y TCR-transgenic model. The minimal role of CD30 in negative selection and other recent data are discussed.